Enhanced litter input rather than changes in litter chemistry drive soil carbon and nitrogen cycles under elevated CO2: a microcosm study

Elevated CO₂ has been shown to stimulate plant productivity and change litter chemistry. These changes in substrate availability may then alter soil microbial processes and possibly lead to feedback effects on N availability. However, the strength of this feedback, and even its direction, remains unknown. Further, uncertainty remains whether sustained increases in net primary productivity will lead to increased long‐term C storage in soil. To examine how changes in litter chemistry and productivity under elevated CO₂ influence microbial activity and soil C formation, we conducted a 230‐day microcosm incubation with five levels of litter addition rate that represented 0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.4 and 1.8 × litterfall rates observed in the field for aspen stand growing under control treatments at the Aspen FACE experiment in Rhinelander, WI, USA. Litter and soil samples were collected from the corresponding field control and elevated CO₂ treatment after trees were exposed to elevated CO₂ (560 ppm) for 7 years. We found that small decreases in litter [N] under elevated CO₂ had minor effects on microbial biomass carbon, microbial biomass nitrogen and dissolved inorganic nitrogen. Increasing litter addition rates resulted in linear increase in total C and new C (C from added litter) that accumulated in whole soil as well as in the high density soil fraction (HDF), despite higher cumulative C loss by respiration. Total N retained in whole soil and in HDF also increased with litter addition rate as did accumulation of new C per unit of accumulated N. Based on our microcosm comparisons and regression models, we expected that enhanced C inputs rather than changes in litter chemistry would be the dominant factor controlling soil C levels and turnover at the current level of litter production rate (230 g C m⁻² yr⁻¹ under ambient CO₂). However, our analysis also suggests that the effects of changes in biochemistry caused by elevated CO₂ could become significant at a higher level of litter production rate, with a trend of decreasing total C in HDF, new C in whole soil, as well as total N in whole soil and HDF.     

The Effect of Elevated [CO2] on Uptake and Allocation of 13C and 15N in Beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) during Leafing

Abstract: A continuous dual ¹³CO₂ and ¹⁵NH₄¹⁵NO₃ labelling experiment was undertaken to determine the effects of ambient (350μmol mol^-1) or elevated (700μmol mol^-1) atmospheric CO₂ concentrations on C and N uptake and allocation within 3-year-old beech ( Fagus sylvatica L.) during leafing. After six weeks of growth, total carbon uptake was increased by 63 % (calculated on total C content) under elevated CO₂ but the carbon partitioning was not altered. 56 % of the new carbon was found in the leaves. On a dry weight basis was the content of structural biomass in leaves 10 % lower and the lignin content remained unaffected under elevated as compared to ambient [CO₂]. Under ambient [CO₂] 37 %, and under elevated [CO₂] 51 %, of the lignin C of the leaves derived from new assimilates. For both treatments, internal N pools provided more than 90 % of the nitrogen used for leaf-growth and the partitioning of nitrogen was not altered under elevated [CO₂]. The C/N ratio was unaffected by elevated [CO₂] at the whole plant level, but the C/N ratio of the new C and N uptake was increased by 32 % under elevated [CO₂].     

Large seasonal changes in Q10 of soil respiration in a beech forest

We analyzed one year of continuous soil respiration measurements to assess variations in the temperature sensitivity of soil respiration at a Danish beech forest. A single temperature function derived from all measurements across the year (Q₁₀ = 4.2) was adequate for estimating the total annual soil respiration and its seasonal evolution. However, Q₁₀'s derived from weekly datasets ranged between three in summer (at a mean soil temperature of 14 °C) and 23 in winter (at 2 °C), indicating that the annual temperature function underestimated the synoptic variations in soil respiration during winter. These results highlight that empirical models should be parameterized at a time resolution similar to that required by the output of the model. If the objective of the model is to simulate the total annual soil respiration rate, annual parameterization suffices. If however, soil respiration needs to be simulated over time periods from days to weeks, as is the case when soil respiration is compared to total ecosystem respiration during synoptic weather patterns, more short‐term parameterization is required. Despite the higher wintertime Q₁₀'s, the absolute response of soil respiration to temperature was smaller in winter than in summer. This is mainly because in absolute numbers, the temperature sensitivity of soil respiration depends not only on Q₁₀, but also on the rate of soil respiration, which is highly reduced in winter. Nonetheless, the Q₁₀ of soil respiration in winter was larger than can be explained by the decreasing respiration rate only. Because the seasonal changes in Q₁₀ were negatively correlated with temperature and positively correlated with soil moisture, they could also be related to changing temperature and/or soil moisture conditions.     

Linking microbial activity and soil organic matter transformations in forest soils under elevated CO2

Soil organic matter (SOM) dynamics ultimately govern the ability of soil to provide long‐term C sequestration and the nutrients required for ecosystem productivity. Predicting belowground responses to elevated CO₂ requires an integrated understanding of SOM transformations and the microbial activity that governs them. It remains unclear how the microorganisms upon which these transformations depend will function in an elevated CO₂ world. This study examines SOM transformations and microbial metabolism in soils from the Duke Free Air Carbon Enrichment site in North Carolina, USA. We assessed microbial respiration and net nitrogen (N) mineralization in soils with and without elevated CO₂ exposure during a 100‐day incubation. We also traced the depleted C isotopic signature of the supplemental CO₂ into SOM and the soils' phospholipid fatty acids (PLFA), which serve as biomarkers for living cells. Cumulative net N mineralization in elevated CO₂ soils was 50% that in control soils after a 100‐day incubation. Respiration was not altered with elevated CO₂. C : N ratios of bulk SOM did not change with elevated CO₂, but incubation data suggest that the C : N ratios of mineralized organic matter increased with elevated CO₂. Values of SOM δ¹³C were depleted with elevated CO₂ (?26.7±0.2 vs. ?30.2±0.3‰), reflecting the depleted signature of the supplemental CO₂. We compared δ¹³C of individual PLFA with the δ¹³C of SOM to discern incorporation of the depleted C isotopic signature into soil microbial groups in elevated CO₂ plots. PLFA i15:0, a15:0, and 10Met18:0 reflected significant incorporation of recently produced photosynthate, suggesting that the bacterial groups defined by these biomarkers are active metabolizers in elevated CO₂ soils. At least one of these groups (actinomycetes, 10Met18:0) specializes in metabolizing less labile substrates. Because control plots did not receive an equivalent ¹³C tracer, we cannot determine from these data whether this group of organisms was stimulated by elevated CO₂ compared with these organisms in control soils. Stimulation of this group, if it occurred in the elevated CO₂ plot, would be consistent with a decline in the availability of mineralizable organic matter with elevated CO₂, which incubation data suggest may be the case in these soils.     

A new method to measure carbon isotope composition of CO2 respired by trees: stem CO2 equilibration

1.  Applying Keeling plot techniques to derive δ¹³C of respiratory input in a closed non-equilibrated chamber can lead to large errors because steady-state diffusion rules are violated in a non-steady-state environment. To avoid these errors, respiratory δ¹³C can be derived using equilibrated closed chambers.
2.  We introduce a new method to obtain stem respired CO₂δ¹³C (δ_{st - r}) with closed equilibrated stem chambers (E-SC). We present a theoretical model describing the equilibration process, test the model against field data and find excellent agreement. The method is further tested by comparing it with closed non-equilibrated stem chambers (NE-SC); we found no difference between these methods.
3.  Our theoretical model to describe CO₂ diffusion from the respiratory pool into the chamber and the equation to derive the δ¹³C of the efflux are general. They could be applied to other ecosystem components (e.g. soils).
4.  Our method is easy to implement, cost effective, minimizes sources of error and allows for rigorous leak detection. One major limitation is its inability to detect rapid change; the equilibration process requires 15 ± 2 h. A second limitation is that it cannot be used for species that produce abundant pitch at sites of stem wounding (e.g. Pseudotsuga menziesii ).
5.  Investigating δ¹³C of CO₂ respired by different ecosystem components is necessary to interpret δ¹³C of ecosystem respiration. This parameter has major implications with respect to global carbon cycle science.     

Seasonal patterns of soil CO2 efflux and soil air CO2 concentration in a Scots pine forest: comparison of two chamber techniques

A non‐vented non‐steady state flow‐through chamber and a non‐vented non‐steady state non‐flow‐through chamber technique were used to measure CO₂ efflux of a young Scots pine forest on a fertile till soil in southern Finland. Soil temperature, soil moisture and soil CO₂ concentration were measured concurrently with CO₂ efflux for two and a half successive years. The CO₂ efflux showed a seasonal pattern, effluxes ranging from low 0.0–0.1 g CO₂ m ^{? 2} h ^{? 1} in winter to peak values of 2.3 g CO₂ m ^{? 2} h ^{? 1} occurring in late June and in July. The daily average effluxes in July measured by flow through chambers were 1.23 and 0.98 g CO₂ m ^{? 2} h ^{? 1} in 1998 and 1999, respectively. The annual accumulated CO₂ efflux was 3117 and 3326 g CO₂ m ^{? 2} in 1998 and 1999, respectively. The spatial variation in CO₂ efflux was high (CV 0.18–0.45) and increased with increasing efflux. Soil air CO₂ concentration showed similar seasonal pattern the peak concentrations occurring in July–August. The CO₂ concentrations ranged from 580 to 780 µ mol mol ^{? 1} in the humus layer to 13 620–14 470 µ mol mol ^{? 1} in the C‐horizon. In winter the soil air CO₂ concentrations were lower, especially in deeper soil layers. Drought decreased CO₂ efflux and soil air CO₂ concentration. The in situ comparison on forest soil between the chamber methods showed the non‐flow‐through chamber to give ～～50% lower efflux values than that of the flow‐through chamber. When calibrated against known CO₂ efflux ranging from 0.4 to 0.8 g CO₂ m ^{? 2} h ^{? 1} generated with a diffusion box method developed by Widén and Lindroth [Acta Universitatis Agriculturae Suecia Silvestria, 2001], the flow‐through chamber gave equal effluxes at the lower end of the calibration range, but overestimated high effluxes by 20%. Non‐flow‐through chamber underestimated the CO₂ efflux by 30%.     

Partitioning sources of soil-respired CO2 and their seasonal variation using a unique radiocarbon tracer

Soil respiration is derived from heterotrophic (decomposition of soil organic matter) and autotrophic (root/rhizosphere respiration) sources, but there is considerable uncertainty about what factors control variations in their relative contributions in space and time. We took advantage of a unique whole‐ecosystem radiocarbon label in a temperate forest to partition soil respiration into three sources: (1) recently photosynthesized carbon (C), which dominates root and rhizosphere respiration; (2) leaf litter decomposition and (3) decomposition of root litter and soil organic matter >1–2 years old. Heterotrophic sources and specifically leaf litter decomposition were large contributors to total soil respiration during the growing season. Relative contributions from leaf litter decomposition ranged from a low of ～1±3% of total soil respiration (6± 3 mg C m^?2 h^?1) when leaf litter was extremely dry, to a high of 42±16% (96± 38 mg C m^?2 h^?1). Total soil respiration fluxes varied with the strength of the leaf litter decomposition source, indicating that moisture‐dependent changes in litter decomposition drive variability in total soil respiration fluxes. In the surface mineral soil layer, decomposition of C fixed in the original labeling event (3–5 years earlier) dominated the isotopic signature of heterotrophic respiration. Root/rhizosphere respiration accounted for 16±10% to 64±22% of total soil respiration, with highest relative contributions coinciding with low overall soil respiration fluxes. In contrast to leaf litter decomposition, root respiration fluxes did not exhibit marked temporal variation ranging from 34±14 to 40±16 mg C m^?2 h^?1 at different times in the growing season with a single exception (88±35 mg C m^?2 h^?1). Radiocarbon signatures of root respired CO₂ changed markedly between early and late spring (March vs. May), suggesting a switch from stored nonstructural carbohydrate sources to more recent photosynthetic products.     

Species control variation in litter decomposition in a pine forest exposed to elevated CO2

Net primary production and the flux of dry matter and nutrients from vegetation to soils has increased following four years of exposure to elevated CO₂ in a southern pine forest in NC, USA. This has increased the demand for nutrients to support enhanced rates of NPP and altered the conditions for litter decomposition on the forest floor. We quantified the chemistry and decomposition dynamics of leaf litter produced by five of the most abundant tree species in this ecosystem during the third and fourth growing seasons under elevated CO₂. The objectives of this study were to determine (i) if there were systemic or species‐specific changes in leaf litter chemistry associated with a sustained enhancement of plant growth under elevated CO₂; and (ii) whether the process of litter decomposition was altered by increased inputs of energy and nutrients to the forest floor in the plots under elevated CO₂. Leaf litter chemistry, including various C fractions and N concentration, was virtually unchanged by elevated CO₂. With few exceptions, plant litter produced under elevated CO₂ lost mass or N at the same relative rate as that produced under ambient CO₂. The relationship between initial litter chemistry and decomposition was not altered by elevated CO₂. The greater forest floor mass and nutrient content in the plots under elevated CO₂ had no consistent or long‐term effect on litter decomposition. Thus, we found no evidence that plant and microbial processes under elevated CO₂ resulted in systemic changes in mass loss or N dynamics during decomposition. In contrast to the limited effects of elevated CO₂ on litter chemistry and decomposition, there were large differences among species in initial litter chemistry, mass loss and N dynamics during decomposition. If the species composition of this forest community is altered by elevated CO₂, the indirect effect of a change in species composition will exert greater control over the long‐term rate of nutrient cycling than the direct effect of elevated CO₂ on litter chemistry and decomposition dynamics alone.     

Altered patterns of soil carbon substrate usage and heterotrophic respiration in a pine forest with elevated CO2 and N fertilization

To assess how heterotrophic microorganisms may alter their activities and thus their CO₂‐C return to the atmosphere with elevated CO₂ and changing N availability, we examined soil organic matter (SOM) dynamics at the Duke Free Air Carbon Enrichment (FACE) site, after N fertilizer was applied. We measured heterotrophic respiration during early and late stages of SOM mineralization in soil incubations to capture activity on relatively labile and refractory SOM pools. We also measured δ¹³C of respired CO₂‐C and phospholipid fatty acids (PLFAs) during early mineralization stages to track the microbial groups involved in substrate use. We calculated , a measure of δ¹³C_PLFA normalized by respired δ¹³CO₂, to assess microbial function with C substrates formed with elevated CO₂ and altered N availability, via the distinct δ¹³C of the supplemental CO₂. We also quantified extracellular enzyme activity (EEA) during labile and recalcitrant SOM mineralization. Early in the incubations, increased N availability reduced heterotrophic CO₂‐C release. By the later stages of SOM mineralization, elevated CO₂ soils with fertilization had respired 72% of the CO₂‐C respired by all other soils. values suggest that fungi in elevated CO₂ plots took up C substrates possessing the δ¹³C signature of recently formed SOM, and added N promoted the activity of Gram‐negative bacteria and reduced that of Gram‐positive bacteria, particularly actinomycetes. Consistent with this, the enzyme responsible for the degradation of peptidoglycan and chitin, compounds produced by Gram‐positive bacteria and fungi, respectively, experienced a decline in activity with N fertilization. If patterns observed in this study with N additions are reversed with progressive N limitation at this site, actinomycetes and other Gram‐positive bacteria responsible for mineralizing relatively recalcitrant substrates may experience increases in their activity. Such shifts in microbial functioning may result in increased turnover of, and C release from, relatively decay‐resistant material.     

Canopy-scale δ13C of photosynthetic and respiratory CO2 fluxes: observations in forest biomes across the United States

The δ¹³C values of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO₂) can be used to partition global patterns of CO₂ source/sink relationships among terrestrial and oceanic ecosystems using the inversion technique. This approach is very sensitive to estimates of photosynthetic ¹³C discrimination by terrestrial vegetation (Δ_A), and depends on δ¹³C values of respired CO₂ fluxes (δ¹³C_R). Here we show that by combining two independent data streams – the stable isotope ratios of atmospheric CO₂ and eddy‐covariance CO₂ flux measurements – canopy scale estimates of Δ_A can be successfully derived in terrestrial ecosystems. We also present the first weekly dataset of seasonal variations in δ¹³C_R from dominant forest ecosystems in the United States between 2001 and 2003. Our observations indicate considerable summer‐time variation in the weekly value of δ¹³C_R within coniferous forests (4.0‰ and 5.4‰ at Wind River Canopy Crane Research Facility and Howland Forest, respectively, between May and September). The monthly mean values of δ¹³C_R showed a smaller range (2–3‰), which appeared to significantly correlate with soil water availability. Values of δ¹³C_R were less variable during the growing season at the deciduous forest (Harvard Forest). We suggest that the negative correlation between δ¹³C_R and soil moisture content observed in the two coniferous forests should represent a general ecosystem response to the changes in the distribution of water resources because of climate change. Shifts in δ¹³C_R and Δ_A could be of sufficient magnitude globally to impact partitioning calculations of CO₂ sinks between oceanic and terrestrial compartments.     

Wood CO2 efflux in a primary tropical rain forest

The balance between photosynthesis and plant respiration in tropical forests may substantially affect the global carbon cycle. Woody tissue CO₂ efflux is a major component of total plant respiration, but estimates of ecosystem‐scale rates are uncertain because of poor sampling in the upper canopy and across landscapes. To overcome these problems, we used a portable scaffolding tower to measure woody tissue CO₂ efflux from ground level to the canopy top across a range of sites of varying slope and soil phosphorus content in a primary tropical rain forest in Costa Rica. The objectives of this study were to: (1) determine whether to use surface area, volume, or biomass for modeling and extrapolating wood CO₂ efflux, (2) determine if wood CO₂ efflux varied seasonally, (3) identify if wood CO₂ efflux varied by functional group, height in canopy, soil fertility, or slope, and (4) extrapolate wood CO₂ efflux to the forest. CO₂ efflux from small diameter woody tissue (<10 cm) was related to surface area, while CO₂ efflux from stems >10 cm was related to both surface area and volume. Wood CO₂ efflux showed no evidence of seasonality over 2 years. CO₂ efflux per unit wood surface area at 25° (F_A) was highest for the N‐fixing dominant tree species Pentaclethra macroloba, followed by other tree species, lianas, then palms. Small diameter F_A increased steeply with increasing height, and large diameter F_A increased with diameter. Soil phosphorus and slope had slight, but complex effects on F_A. Wood CO₂ efflux per unit ground area was 1.34±0.36 μmol m^?2 s^?1, or 508±135 g C m^?2 yr^?1. Small diameter wood, only 15% of total woody biomass, accounted for 70% of total woody tissue CO₂ efflux from the forest; while lianas, only 3% of total woody biomass, contributed one‐fourth of the total wood CO₂ efflux.     

The turnover of carbon pools contributing to soil CO2 and soil respiration in a temperate forest exposed to elevated CO2 concentration

Soil carbon is returned to the atmosphere through the process of soil respiration, which represents one of the largest fluxes in the terrestrial C cycle. The effects of climate change on the components of soil respiration can affect the sink or source capacity of ecosystems for atmospheric carbon, but no current techniques can unambiguously separate soil respiration into its components. Long‐term free air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiments provide a unique opportunity to study soil C dynamics because the CO₂ used for fumigation has a distinct isotopic signature and serves as a continuous label at the ecosystem level. We used the ¹³C tracer at the Duke Forest FACE site to follow the disappearance of C fixed before fumigation began in 1996 (pretreatment C) from soil CO₂ and soil‐respired CO₂, as an index of belowground C dynamics during the first 8 years of the experiment. The decay of pretreatment C as detected in the isotopic composition of soil‐respired CO₂ and soil CO₂ at 15, 30, 70, and 200 cm soil depth was best described by a model having one to three exponential pools within the soil system. The majority of soil‐respired CO₂ (71%) originated in soil C pools with a turnover time of about 35 days. About 55%, 50%, and 68% of soil CO₂ at 15, 30, and 70 cm, respectively, originated in soil pools with turnover times of less than 1 year. The rest of soil CO₂ and soil‐respired CO₂ originated in soil pools that turn over at decadal time scales. Our results suggest that a large fraction of the C returned to the atmosphere through soil respiration results from dynamic soil C pools that cannot be easily detected in traditionally defined soil organic matter standing stocks. Fast oxidation of labile C substrates may prevent increases in soil C accumulation in forests exposed to elevated [CO₂] and may consequently result in shorter ecosystem C residence times.     

Soil CO2 efflux in a boreal pine forest under atmospheric CO2 enrichment and air warming

The response of forest soil CO₂ efflux to the elevation of two climatic factors, the atmospheric concentration of CO₂ (↑CO₂ of 700 μmol mol⁻¹) and air temperature (↑ T with average annual increase of 5°C), and their combination (↑CO₂+↑ T ) was investigated in a 4-year, full-factorial field experiment consisting of closed chambers built around 20-year-old Scots pines ( Pinus sylvestris L.) in the boreal zone of Finland. Mean soil CO₂ efflux in May–October increased with elevated CO₂ by 23–37%, with elevated temperature by 27–43%, and with the combined treatment by 35–59%. Temperature elevation was a significant factor in the combined 4-year efflux data, whereas the effect of elevated CO₂ was not as evident. Elevated temperature had the most pronounced impact early and late in the season, while the influence of elevated CO₂ alone was especially notable late in the season. Needle area was found to be a significant predictor of soil CO₂ efflux, particularly in August, a month of high root growth, thus supporting the assumption of a close link between whole-tree physiology and soil CO₂ emissions. The decrease in the temperature sensitivity of soil CO₂ efflux observed in the elevated temperature treatments in the second year nevertheless suggests the existence of soil response mechanisms that may be independent of the assimilating component of the forest ecosystem. In conclusion, elevated atmospheric CO₂ and air temperature consistently increased forest soil CO₂ efflux over the 4-year period, their combined effect being additive, with no apparent interaction.     

Correlating δ13C and δ18O in cellulose of trees

We measured the carbon and oxygen isotopic composition of stem cellulose of Pinus sylvestris, Picea abies, Fagus sylvatica and Fraxinus excelsior. Several sites along a transect of a small valley in Switzerland were selected which differ in soil moisture conditions. At every site, six trees per species were sampled, and a sample representing a mean value for the period from 1940 to 1990 was analysed. For all species, the mean site δ¹³C and δ¹⁸O of stem cellulose are related to the soil moisture availability, whereby higher isotope ratios are found at drier sites. This result is consistent with isotope fractionation models when assuming enhanced stomatal resistance (thus higher δ¹³C of incorporated carbon) and increased oxygen isotope enrichment in the leaf water (thus higher δ¹⁸O) at the dry sites. δ¹⁸ O-δ¹³C plots reveal a linear relationship between the carbon and oxygen isotopes in cellulose. To interpret this relationship we developed an equation which combines the above-mentioned fractionation models. An important new parameter is the degree to which the leaf water enrichment is reflected in the stem cellulose. In the combined model the slope of the δ¹⁸O-δ¹³C plot is related to the sensitivity of the p_i/p_a of a plant to changing relative humidity.