Classification of the spoilage flora of fish, with special reference to Shewanella putrefaciens

One hundred and fifty-nine Gram-negative strains isolated from refrigerated fish, taken from the Baltic Sea or Swedish inland waters, together with 32 reference strains of Shewanella, Pseudomonas, Aeromonas and Alcaligenes, were phenotypically classified using 124 unit characters. Data were processed by the Simple Matching (SSM) and Jaccard (SJ) coefficients, and unweighted pair group algorithm with arithmetic averages. Fourteen clusters were defined at the 75% SJ similarity level which correspond to the SSM level of 86%. SJ-based clusters containing field strains were designated Pseudomonas fragi (cluster 1; 31% of the field strains), Ps. lundensis (cluster 2; 2% of the field strains), Ps. fluorescens biovar III (cluster 4; 4% of the field strains), Ps. putida biovar A (cluster 5; 3% of the field strains), Ps. fluorescens/putida (clusters 3 and 6; 6% of the field strains), Psychrobacter (clusters 8 and 9; 3% of the field strains), Shewanella putrefaciens (clusters 10, 11, 12 and 13; 44% of the field strains) and Aer. sobria (cluster 14; 6% of the field strains, all isolated from fresh water fish). Each field strain represented the spoilage flora of refrigerated fish at a total aerobic count of about 10(8) cfu/g. Phenotypic characteristics of major clusters are given. The four S. putrefaciens clusters may be separated by key characteristics. Shewanella putrefaciens ATCC 8071T and reference strains from sources other than fish, did not group in any of the clusters. The mol % guanine + cytosine content was on average 47.6 for cluster 10, and 45.3 for cluster 13.     

Species of Pseudomonas obtained at 7°C and 30°C during aerobic storage of lamb carcasses

A total of 268 strains of Pseudomonas isolated during storage life of lamb carcasses was identified to species level. One-hundred and thirteen strains obtained at 30°C were Ps.fragi (51), Ps. lundensis (17), Ps. fluorescens biovars I (10), III (9) and VI (1), Ps. putida biovar A (8 strains) and unidentified (17 strains). Species and biovars isolated at 7°C (155) were Ps. fragi (101), Ps. lundensis (32), Ps. fluorescens biovar I (6), Ps. putida biovar A (8) and unidentified (8). Numerical analysis (82% S _SM, UPGMA) of 'psychrotrophic' and 'mesophilic' strains resulted in the formation of nine and eight clusters respectively. The dendrograms obtained exhibited similar structures. Most of the strains of Ps. lundensis and Ps. fragi clustered together. Strains of this latter species also joined the type strain of Ps. testosteroni and appeared included with phenons containing the Ps. putida strains. There were clusters made up exclusively of strains assigned to one biovar or group ( Ps. fluorescens biovars I and II and unidentified). A high level of similarity was observed between clusters of Ps. fluorescens biovar I and those containing the Ps. fragi-Ps. lundensis complex (>74% S _SM) and Ps. lundensis (>80%). The recovery of pseudomonads seemed to be affected by the sampling day.     

Species of Pseudomonas obtained at 7 degrees C and 30 degrees C during aerobic storage of lamb carcasses.

A total of 268 strains of Pseudomonas isolated during storage life of lamb carcasses was identified to species level. One-hundred and thirteen strains obtained at 30 degrees C were Ps. fragi (51), Ps. lundensis (17), Ps. fluorescens biovars I (10), III (9) and VI (1), Ps. putida biovar A (8 strains) and unidentified (17 strains). Species and biovars isolated at 7 degrees C (155) were Ps. fragi (101), Ps. lundensis (32), Ps. fluorescens biovar I (6), Ps. putida biovar A (8) and unidentified (8). Numerical analysis (82% SSM, UPGMA) of 'psychrotrophic' and 'mesophilic' strains resulted in the formation of nine and eight clusters respectively. The dendrograms obtained exhibited similar structures. Most of the strains of Ps. lundensis and Ps. fragi clustered together. Strains of this latter species also joined the type strain of Ps. testosteroni and appeared included with phenons containing the Ps. putida strains. There were clusters made up exclusively of strains assigned to one biovar or group (Ps. fluorescens biovars I and II and unidentified). A high level of similarity was observed between clusters of Ps. fluorescens biovar I and those containing the Ps. fragi-Ps. lundensis complex (> 74% SSM) and Ps. lundensis (> 80%). The recovery of pseudomonads seemed to be affected by the sampling day.     

A study of the incidence of different fluorescent Pseudomonas species and biovars in the microflora of fresh and spoiled meat and fish, raw milk, cheese, soil and water.

Of 182 various foodstuffs and environmental samples examined, 86% had microflora containing fluorescent Pseudomonas in differing proportions. A computer-aided technique was used to identify most of the 445 fluorescent strains. Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar V-1 was most frequently isolated (24%); it either predominated or was present in all types of samples. Other strains, belonging to the other subgroups of biovar V (V-2, V-4, V-5, V-6 and V-7), together represented 14.3%. We also identified Ps. fluorescens biovars I-1 and I-2 (13.9%), II-1 and II-3 (3.6%), III-1 and III-2 (8.7%), IV-2 (0.7%); Ps. putida A and B (11%); Ps. lundensis (10.3%); group B3 (2%) and Ps. aeruginosa (0.7%). Unidentified strains accounted for 10.6% of the flora, many resembling Ps. fluorescens biovar V. Although the presence of Ps. fluorescens V-1 was often marked, other taxa predominated or were present in large quantities in some particular samples, such as Ps. fluorescens I-1 in raw milk and cheese, Ps. lundensis in spoiled meat and Ps. fluorescens III-1 in spoiled fish. Pseudomonas putida A and B were evident in environmental rather than in food samples.     

A study of the incidence of different fluorescent Pseudomonas species and biovars in the microflora of fresh and spoiled meat and fish, raw milk, cheese, soil and water

M. GENNARI AND F. DRAGOTTO. 1992. Of 182 various foodstuffs and environmental samples examined, 86% had microflora containing fluorescent Pseudomonas in differing proportions. A computer-aided technique was used to identify most of the 445 fluorescent strains. Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar V-1 was most frequently isolated (24%); it either predominated or was present in all types of samples. Other strains, belonging to the other subgroups of biovar V (V-2, V-4, V-5, V-6 and V-7), together represented 14.3%. We also identified Ps. fluorescens biovars I-1 and I-2 (13.9%), II-1 and II-3 (3.6%), III-1 and III-2 (8.7%), IV-2 (0.7%); Ps. putida A and B (11%); Ps. lundensis (10.3%); group B3 (2%) and Ps. aeruginosa (0.7%). Unidentified strains accounted for 10.6% of the flora, many resembling Ps. fluorescens biovar V. Although the presence of Ps. fluorescens V-1 was often marked, other taxa predominated or were present in large quantities in some particular samples, such as Ps. fluorescens I-1 in raw milk and cheese, Ps. lundensis in spoiled meat and Ps. fluorescens III-1 in spoiled fish. Pseudomonas putida A and B were evident in environmental rather than in food samples.     

Numerical systematics of bacteria of the genus Pseudomonas

In 290 strains of bacteria belonging to the genus Pseudomonas, 120 morphological and physiologo-biochemical characters were studied and the results obtained thereby were analyzed by the methods of numerical taxonomy using computers. The majority of strains were subdivided into 11 clusters: Ps. aeruginosa (1), Ps. putida (2), Ps. rathonis (5), Ps. syringae (8), Ps. pseudoalcaligenes (9), Ps. maltophilia (10), Ps. acidovorans (11), Ps. testosteroni (12), Ps. mendocina (13), Ps. cepacia (14), Ps. fluorescens (3). The latter cluster included also the strains identified earlier as Ps. aurantiaca, Ps. lemonnieri, Ps. fluoro-violaceus, and Ps. aureofaciens. Three clusters contained strains which could not be identified and probably should be regarded as distinct species. The characteristics have been selected useful for diagnostics of the above Pseudomonas bacteria and the subgroups of Ps. fluorescens.     

Classification of the spoilage flora of raw and pasteurized bovine milk, with special reference to Pseudomonas and Bacillus

Eighty-one bacterial strains isolated from refrigerated raw milk, 124 from pasteurized milk and cream stored at 5°C and 7°C, and 19 type and reference strains of Pseudomonas spp. and Bacillus spp. were characterized by numerical phenotypic analysis. Data were processed with simple matching ( S _SM) and Jaccard ( S _J) coefficients, and UPGMA clustering. Fourteen clusters of Gram-negative bacteria were formed at S _J= 79% ( S _SM= 90%). Raw milk was exclusively spoilt by Gram-negative bacteria, the majority of which were Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar I, Ps. fragi, Ps. lundensis and Ps. fluorescens biovar III. Minor groups in raw milk included Enterobacteriaceae spp. and Acinetobacter spp. Pasteurized milk was spoilt by essentially the same Gram-negative organisms in 65% (5°C) and 50% (7°C) of the cases. The phenotypic characteristics of Gram-negative bacteria are given. Bacillus polymyxa (both temperatures) and B. cereus (only at 7°C) were responsible for 77% of samples spoiled by the Gram-positive organisms. Minor milk spoilage groups included other Bacillus spp. and lactic acid bacteria. All Bacillus spp. grew fermentatively in milk, and most strains denitrified. It is suggested that: (i) industrial recontamination tests of pasteurized milk are directed against Pseudomonas; (ii) milk is stored at 5°C or lower to avoid growth of B. cereus ; and (iii) the significance of gas-producing and nitrate/nitrite-reducing Bacillus strains is recognized in cheese production.     

Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar V: its resolution into distinct component groups and the relationship of these groups to other P. fluorescens biovars, to P. putida, and to psychrotrophic pseudomonads associated with food spoilage

A numerical taxonomic analysis was performed to evaluate the appropriateness of a single biovar designation (biovar V) for all Pseudomonas fluorescens isolates negative for denitrification, levan production and phenazine pigmentation and to determine the relationship of biovar V strains to other taxa within the same Pseudomonas RNA homology group. Seventy-two strains assigned to P. fluorescens biovar V and four strains of P. fragi were characterized and the data subjected to a numerical taxonomic analysis along with comparable data for 17 previously characterized strains of this biovar and 89 P. putida strains. Seven distinct biovar V clusters containing three or more strains were revealed, and the carbon sources useful for their differentiation were identified. Cluster 1 (38 strains) closely resembled two atypical P. fluorescens I strains. It was also related to P. fluorescens biovar IV and to P. fragi. Cluster 2 (5 strains) was related to cluster 1. Cluster 3 (7 strains) was identical to a major group of meat spoilage psychrotrophic pseudomonads (P. lundensis). Cluster 4 (3 strains) was not related to any other group examined. Cluster 5 consisted of six isolates initially designated P. putida A along with four P. fluorescens biovar V strains all of which resembled P. putida more than they resembled the other P. fluorescens groups. Cluster 6 (16 strains) was distinct from the other biovar V clusters, but was closely related to P. fluorescens biovars I and II. Cluster 7 (3 strains) shared many characteristics with cluster 5. Separate P. fluorescens biovar designations are proposed for cluster 6 and for the combined clusters 1 and 2. A new P. putida biovar is proposed for the combined clusters 5 and 7.     

Numerical taxonomy of Bacillus isolated from orally administered drugs

Numerical taxonomy procedures were used to study 118 strains of Bacillus isolated from non-sterile drugs prepared for oral administration. Similarities between pairs of strains were calculated by the simple matching coefficient of Sokal and Michener (S_SM). Each strain was tested for 60 unit characters and three clusters were defined. The strains in each cluster presented a similarity level of at least 60%. Cluster A comprised the strains identified as Bacillus cereus (S_SM= 93·13%), cluster B contained three subgroups corresponding to the species B. pumilus, B. subtilis and B. licheniformis (S_SM= 84·35%) and cluster C also included three subgroups that belonged to the species B. firmus, B. lentus and B. badius (S_SM= 80·14%). The most discriminating tests were selected to differentiate the clusters from the subgroups. The feature with the highest discriminating power between clusters A and B was the lack of acid production from arabinose and mannitol. The Voges-Proskauer, methyl red tests and sensitivity to polymyxin B clearly distinguished cluster A from C. The Voges-Proskauer test and acid production from arabinose were the best to differentiate between B and C. Bacillus pumilus and B. subtilis differed in starch hydrolysis and B. licheniformis in growing anaerobically. To discriminate B. firmus from B. lentus the most important tests were the acid production from glucose and sucrose; intermediate strains were found. Bacillus badius was differentiated from B. firmus by 10 tests, and from B. lentus by the production of urease.     

Numerical taxonomy of proteolytic psychrotrophs from Queensland raw milks

Eighty-seven proteolytic psychrotrophic micro-organisms were isolated from 11 bulk milk supplies of two Queensland factories from different climatic regions, before and after storage at 4°C for 7 d. These isolates together with 15 reference strains formed the basis of a numerical taxonomic study involving 81 attributes. All but six isolates were pseudomonads. The strains clustered into nine groups, of which one group consisted of four yeasts. One group, containing 39 isolates, was designated as Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar 1; three groups, containing 27 isolates, as Ps. fluorescens biovar 5; and one group, containing 10 isolates, as Ps. putida biovar A. This study showed that the proteolytic psychrotrophic microflora of the 11 milks supplying the two factories was substantially different and that the proteolytic flora of 7 d refrigerated milk could not be estimated by examining the flora before storage.     

Numerical taxonomy of proteolytic psychrotrophs from Queensland raw milks

Eighty-seven proteolytic psychrotrophic micro-organisms were isolated from 11 bulk milk supplies of two Queensland factories from different climatic regions, before and after storage at 4 degrees C for 7 d. These isolates together with 15 reference strains formed the basis of a numerical taxonomic study involving 81 attributes. All but six isolates were pseudomonads. The strains clustered into nine groups, of which one group consisted of four yeasts. One group, containing 39 isolates, was designated as Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar 1; three groups, containing 27 isolates, as Ps. fluorescens biovar 5; and one group, containing 10 isolates, as Ps. putida biovar A. This study showed that the proteolytic psychrotrophic microflora of the 11 milks supplying the two factories was substantially different and that the proteolytic flora of 7 d refrigerated milk could not be estimated by examining the flora before storage.     

A study of the relative incidence of different Pseudomonas groups on meat using a computer-assisted identification technique employing only carbon source tests

A computer-assisted probabilistic identification technique employing 18 carbon source utilization tests has been developed and applied to 787 Pseudomonas strains isolated from beef, pork and lamb stored under aerobic conditions. Seven hundred and twelve (89.7%) were identified using these tests alone and a further six (0.8%) with extra tests. Taxa detected were Ps. fragi cluster 2, 390 strains (49.6% of all isolates); Ps. fragi cluster 1, 191 strains (24.9%); meat cluster 3, 87 strains (11.1%); Ps. fluorescens biotype I, 31 strains (3.9%); Ps. fluorescens biotype III, 7 strains (0.9%); and Ps. putida , 1 strain (0.1%). The relative incidence of members of the various taxa was similar on beef, pork and lamb, and was unaffected by storage temperature in the range 0°–10°C. Each taxon was also detected at similar rates before and after spoilage. Meat origin (abattoir) affected the frequency of detection of meat cluster 3 and Ps. fluorescens biotype I strains but did not affect the incidence of detection of either cluster of Ps. fragi.     

A numerical taxonomic study of the Pseudomonas flora isolated from poultry meat

Pseudomonas strains were isolated from both fresh and cold-stored broiler skin. Phenotypically-based numerical taxonomic techniques were used to characterize the isolates and 36 reference strains. For this purpose, Biolog GN Microplates, API 20NE and a number of other biochemical tests were used. Jaccard clustering revealed the predominance of four major Pseudomonas groups: Ps. fragi, Ps. lundensis, strains belonging to Ps. fluorescens biovars and an unidentified group of strains displaying a high degree of similarity to Ps. fluorescens biovars. Within Ps. fluorescens, biovar A was best represented. The marked proteolytic character of members of Ps. fluorescens biovars A, B and C, as well as of members of the unidentified cluster, supports their possible role in the origin of organoleptic defects. In the Ps. lundensis cluster, a distinct group of Ps. lundensis-like species was found. Further genotypic studies should be carried out to clarify the taxonomic status of the Ps. lundensis-like strains and that of the unidentified group resembling Ps. fluorescens biovars A and B.     

A Numerical Taxonomic Study of Pseudomonas-like Bacteria Isolated from Fish in Southeastern Queensland and their Association with Spoilage

Pseudomonas -like bacteria isolated from fresh and spoiling fish in southeastern Queensland were subjected to a wide range of physiological and nutritional tests. The results of these tests, together with those of 20 named strains, were analysed numerically, resulting in the formation of 11 groups. Most of the isolates clustered into group 1 and group 2 which also contained the bulk of the strains able to produce spoilage odours when grown in a tryptic digest of fish muscle at 2°C. Almost all of the group 1 organisms produced sulphydryl type odours, had only 50 mol % G + C and were identified as strains of Alteromonas putrefaciens which were deficient in the ability to produce H₂S detectable in Peptone Iron Agar. Certain of the group 2 strains produced fruity and sulphydryl type odours, but these organisms were not distinguishable from other strains in this group not producing odours. Group 2 strains were highly related to Pseudomonas fragi and were intermediate in properties between Ps. fluorescens and Ps. putida. The remaining nine minor groups contained few organisms able to produce spoilage odours.     

Isolation of fluorescent pseudomonads from the rhizosphere of banana plants antagonistic towards root necrosing fungi

Total aerobic bacteria and fluorescent pseudomonads were counted in bulk and rhizospheric soils of banana plants of 14 plantations in Martinique (French West Indies). Fluorescent Pseudomonas isolates were then identified and investigated for in vitro antagonism towards Cylindrocladium sp., a fungal pathogen of banana roots. Total aerobic bacteria and fluorescent pseudomonads were significantly more abundant in rhizospheric soils than in bulk soils. Among 58 fluorescent Pseudomonas isolates, 41 were identified as Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar V and 17 as Ps. putida biovar A. Six strains exhibited an antagonism towards Cylindrocladium isolates. Among them, Ps. putida strain 93.1 totally blocked fungal growth. No relationship was established between the antifungal effect and enzyme or hydrogen cyanide production by bacteria, suggesting that siderophores and other compounds were involved in fungal inhibition. Antagonistic fluorescent pseudomonads represent a potential for the biological control of banana root infections by Cylindrocladium sp.     

Differentiation of Shewanella putrefaciens and Shewanella alga on the basis of whole-cell protein profiles, ribotyping, phenotypic characterization, and 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis.

Seventy-six presumed Shewanella putrefaciens isolates from fish, oil drillings, and clinical specimens, the type strain of Shewanella putrefaciens (ATCC 8071), the type strain of Shewanella alga (IAM 14159), and the type strain of Shewanella hanedai (ATCC 33224) were compared by several typing methods. Numerical analysis of sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of whole-cell protein and ribotyping patterns showed that the strains were separated into two distinct clusters with 56% +/- 10% and 40% +/- 14% similarity for whole-cell protein profiling and ribotyping, respectively. One cluster consisted of 26 isolates with 52 to 55 mol% G + C and included 15 human isolates, mostly clinical specimens, 8 isolates from marine waters, and the type strain of S. alga. This homogeneous cluster of mesophilic, halotolerant strains was by all analyses identical to the recently defined species S. alga (U. Simidu et al., Int. J. Syst. Bacteriol, 40:331-336, 1990). Fifty-two typically psychrotolerant strains formed the other, more heterogeneous major cluster, with 43 to 47 mol% G + C. The type strain of S. putrefaciens was included in this group. The two groups were confirmed by 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis. It is concluded that the isolates must be considered two different species, S. alga and S. putrefaciens, and that most mesophilic isolates formerly identified as S. putrefaciens belong to S. alga. The ecological role and potential pathogenicity of S. alga can be evaluated only if the organism is correctly identified.     

A study of the relative incidence of different Pseudomonas groups on meat using a computer-assisted identification technique employing only carbon source tests

A computer-assisted probabilistic identification technique employing 18 carbon source utilization tests has been developed and applied to 787 Pseudomonas strains isolated from beef, pork and lamb stored under aerobic conditions. Seven hundred and twelve (89.7%) were identified using these tests alone and a further six (0.8%) with extra tests. Taxa detected were Ps. fragi cluster 2, 390 strains (49.6% of all isolates); Ps. fragi cluster 1, 191 strains (24.9%); meat cluster 3, 87 strains (11.1%); Ps. fluorescens biotype I, 31 strains (3.9%); Ps. fluorescens biotype III, 7 strains (0.9%); and Ps. putida, 1 strain (0.1%). The relative incidence of members of the various taxa was similar on beef, pork and lamb, and was unaffected by storage temperature in the range 0 degrees-10 degrees C. Each taxon was also detected at similar rates before and after spoilage. Meat origin (abattoir) affected the frequency of detection of meat cluster 3 and Ps. fluorescens biotype I strains but did not affect the incidence of detection of either cluster of Ps. fragi.     

The diversity of lipases from psychrotrophic strains of Pseudomonas : a novel lipase from a highly lipolytic strain of Pseudomonas fluorescens

Strains of Pseudomonas fluorescens and Ps. fragi are the predominant psychrotrophs found in raw milk and may cause spoilage due to the secretion of hydrolytic enzymes such as lipase and protease. The diversity of lipases has been examined in Pseudomonas isolates from raw milk which represent different taxonomic groups (phenons). Significant diversity was found using both DNA hybridization and immunoblotting techniques, which has implications for the development of a diagnostic test. The lipase-encoding gene ( lipA ) was cloned from one strain, C9, of Ps. fluorescens biovar V. In contrast to previously reported lipase sequences from Ps. fluorescens , the gene encodes a lipase of M_r 33 kDa. Alignment of all known Pseudomonas and Burkholderia lipase amino acid sequences indicates the existence of two major groups, one of M_r approximately 30 kDa comprising sequences from Ps. fragi , Ps. aeruginosa , Ps. fluorescens C9 and Burkholderia , and one of approximately 50 kDa comprising Ps. fluorescens lipases. The lipase from C9 does not contain a signal peptide and is presumed to be secreted via a signal peptide-independent pathway. The lipA gene of strain C9 was disrupted by insertional mutagenesis. The mutant retained its lipolytic phenotype, strongly suggesting the presence of a second lipase in this strain.     

Production and specificity of poly- and monoclonal antibodies raised against Shewanella putrefaciens

B. FONNESBECH, H. FRØKIAER, L. GRAM AND C. MOSBY JESPERSEN. 1993. Polyclonal antibodies were raised in rabbits and mice against Shewanella putrefaciens. Murine monoclonal antibodies were produced against the type strain (ATCC 8071) as well as wild type strains isolated from fish products. The specificities of four polyclonal and 12 monoclonal antibodies were tested by dot-blotting, an indirect and a competitive ELISA against 16 Gram-negative strains; including six strains of S. putrefaciens and one strain of Pseudomonas rubescens (NC 10695). All polyclonal antibodies reacted strongly with S. putrefaciens and with Ps. rubescens and cross-reacted with the nine other bacteria ( Pseudomonas spp., Aeromonas spp. and Vibrio anguillarum ). The monoclonal antibodies could be divided into three groups with different patterns of specificity. The largest group (8 monoclonal antibodies) reacted strongly with S. putrefaciens and with Ps. rubescens and showed only weak reactions with the other strains. The results confirm that Ps. rubescens should be classified as S. putrefaciens.     

Interaction between fish spoilage bacteria Pseudomonas sp. and Shewanella putrefaciens in fish extracts and on fish tissue

The interaction between fish spoilage bacteria, Pseudomonas sp. and Shewanella putrefaciens , was investigated using fish extract and fish tissue as model systems. Isolates of Pseudomonas that produced iron chelators, siderophores, inhibited growth of S. putrefaciens in a fish-extract-agar diffusion assay but no, or only weak, antagonistic activity was seen when the medium was supplemented with iron. Sterile-filtered supernatant fluid from a siderophore-producing Pseudomonas grown in fish extract was inhibitory to S. putrefaciens if the number of Pseudomonas was above 10⁸ cfu ml⁻¹. In contrast, supernatant fluids from siderophore-negative Pseudomonas isolates did not inhibit growth of S. putrefaciens. The inhibitory effect was, except for one strain of Pseudomonas , not seen in supernatant fluids from iron-enriched cultures of Pseudomonas sp. Finally, siderophore-producing Pseudomonas sp. lowered the maximum cell level of S. putrefaciens 1–2 log units from 10⁹ to 10¹⁰ cfu g⁻¹ when the strains were grown on fish muscle blocks at 0°C but the growth rate of S. putrefaciens was not affected.