Recombinogenic flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I

Aberration of eukaryotic topoisomerase I catalysis leads to potentially recombinogenic pathways by allowing the joining of heterologous DNA strands. Recently, a new ligation pathway (flap ligation) was presented for vaccinia virus topoisomerase I, in which blunt end cleavage complexes ligate the recessed end of duplex acceptors having a single-stranded 3'-tail. This reaction was suggested to play an important role in the repair of topoisomerase I-induced DNA double-strand breaks. Here, we characterize flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I. We demonstrate that cleavage complexes containing the enzyme at a blunt end allow invasion of a 3'-acceptor tail matching the scissile strand of the donor, which facilitates ligation of the recessed 5'-hydroxyl end. However, the reaction was strictly dependent on the length of double-stranded DNA of the donor complexes, and longer stretches of base-pairing inhibited strand invasion. The stabilization of the DNA helix was most probably provided by the covalently bound enzyme itself, since deleting the N-terminal domain of human topoisomerase I stimulated flap ligation. We suggest that stabilization of the DNA duplex upon enzyme binding may play an important role during normal topoisomerase I catalysis by preventing undesired strand transfer reactions. For flap ligation to function in a repair pathway, factors other than topoisomerase I, such as helicases, would be necessary to unwind the DNA duplex and allow strand invasion.     

DNA strand transfer catalyzed by vaccinia topoisomerase: ligation of DNAs containing a 3' mononucleotide overhang

The specificity of vaccinia topoisomerase for transesterification to DNA at the sequence 5′-CCCTT and its versatility in strand transfer have illuminated the recombinogenic properties of type IB topoisomerases and spawned topoisomerase-based strategies for DNA cloning. Here we characterize a pathway of topoisomerase-mediated DNA ligation in which enzyme bound covalently to a CCCTT end with an unpaired +1T nucleotide rapidly and efficiently joins the CCCTT strand to a duplex DNA containing a 3′ A overhang. The joining reaction occurs with high efficiency, albeit slowly, to duplex DNAs containing 3′ G, T or C overhangs. Strand transfer can be restricted to the correctly paired 3′ A overhang by including 0.5 M NaCl in the ligation reaction mixture. The effects of base mismatches and increased ionic strength on the rates of 3′ overhang ligation provide a quantitative picture of the relative contributions of +1 T:A base pairing and electrostatic interactions downstream of the scissile phosphate to the productive binding of an unlinked acceptor DNA to the active site. The results clarify the biochemistry underlying topoisomerase-cloning of PCR products with non-templated 3′ overhangs.     

DNA strand breakage by wheat germ type 1 topoisomerase

Properties of strand breakage in duplex and single-stranded DNA by the wheat germ type 1 DNA topoisomerase were investigated. Strand breakage in duplex DNA is dependent upon the use of denaturing conditions to inactivate the enzyme and terminate the reaction, whereas breakage of single-stranded DNA occurs under the normal reaction conditions and is not dependent upon denaturation. Breakage generates a free 5' hydroxyl group and enzyme bound to the 3' side of the break, presumably via the 3' phosphate group. The location of sites of breakage with both duplex and single-stranded DNA is not random. In all these respects the wheat germ enzyme closely resembles the rat liver type 1 topoisomerase. A comparison of the locations of the sites of breakage in duplex DNA generated by the topoisomerases from wheat germ and rat liver indicates a number of common sites, although the patterns of breakage are not identical.     

Minimal DNA duplex requirements for topoisomerase I-mediated cleavage in vitro

The minimal DNA duplex requirements for topoisomerase I-mediated cleavage at a specific binding sequence were determined by analyzing the interaction of the enzyme with sets of DNA substrates varying successively by single nucleotides at the 5'- or 3' end of either strand. Topoisomerase I cleavage experiments showed a minimal region of nine nucleotides on the scissile strand and five nucleotides on the noncleaved strand. On the scissile strand, seven of the nine nucleotides were situated upstream to the cleavage site, while all five nucleotides required on the non-cleaved strand were located to this side. The results suggested that topoisomerase I bound tightly to this region, stabilizing the DNA duplex extensively. On minimal substrates which were partially single-stranded downstream to the cleavage site, cleavage was suicidal, that is, the enzyme was able to cleave the substrates, but unable to perform the final religation.     

Two classes of DNA end-joining reactions catalyzed by vaccinia topoisomerase I.

The ability of a eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I to catalyze DNA rearrangements was examined in vitro using defined substrates and purified enzyme. Site-specific DNA strand cleavage by vaccinia topoisomerase I across from a nick generated double-strand breaks that could be religated to a heterologous blunt-ended duplex DNA regardless of the sequence of the acceptor molecule. Topoisomerase bound covalently at internal positions could religate the bound strand to an incoming acceptor provided that DNA molecule had sequence homology to the region 3' of the scissile bond. These end-joining reactions suggest two potential modes of topoisomerase-mediated recombination that differ in their requirements for DNA homology.     

DNA strand transfer reactions catalyzed by vaccinia topoisomerase I.

Vaccinia virus DNA topoisomerase I forms a 3'-phosphoryl intermediate with duplex DNAs containing the conserved binding/cleavage motif 5'CCCTT decreases. Covalently bound enzyme is capable of transferring the incised DNA strand to a heterologous DNA acceptor containing a 5'OH terminus. Both intramolecular and intermolecular religation reactions are catalyzed. Intramolecular strand transfer occurs to the noncleaved strand of the DNA duplex and results in formation of a hairpin loop. Intermolecular religation to an exogenous DNA strand is favored over hairpin formation and requires the potential for base pairing between the acceptor and the noncleaved strand of the donor complex. As few as 4 potential base pairs are sufficient to support intermolecular transfer. These results in vitro are consistent with the proposal that vaccinia topoisomerase can catalyze sequence-specific strand transfer during genetic recombination in vivo (Shuman, S. (1991) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 88, 10104-10108.).     

Biochemical characterization of the DNA substrate specificity of Werner syndrome helicase

Werner syndrome is a hereditary premature aging disorder characterized by genome instability. The product of the gene defective in WS, WRN, is a helicase/exonuclease that presumably functions in DNA metabolism. To understand the DNA structures WRN acts upon in vivo, we examined its substrate preferences for unwinding. WRN unwound a 3'-single-stranded (ss)DNA-tailed duplex substrate with streptavidin bound to the end of the 3'-ssDNA tail, suggesting that WRN does not require a free DNA end to unwind the duplex; however, WRN was completely blocked by streptavidin bound to the 3'-ssDNA tail 6 nucleotides upstream of the single-stranded/double-stranded DNA junction. WRN efficiently unwound the forked duplex with streptavidin bound just upstream of the junction, suggesting that WRN recognizes elements of the fork structure to initiate unwinding. WRN unwound two important intermediates of replication/repair, a 5'-ssDNA flap substrate and a synthetic replication fork. WRN was able to translocate on the lagging strand of the synthetic replication fork to unwind duplex ahead of the fork. For the 5'-flap structure, WRN specifically displaced the 5'-flap oligonucleotide, suggesting a role of WRN in Okazaki fragment processing. The ability of WRN to target DNA replication/repair intermediates may be relevant to its role in genome stability maintenance.     

The anchor site of telomerase from Euplotes aediculatus revealed by photo-cross-linking to single- and double-stranded DNA primers.

Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein enzyme that adds telomeric sequence repeats to the ends of linear chromosomes. In vitro, telomerase has been observed to add repeats to a DNA oligonucleotide primer in a processive manner, leading to the postulation of a DNA anchor site separate from the catalytic site of the enzyme. We have substituted photoreactive 5-iododeoxypyrimidines into the DNA oligonucleotide primer d(T4G4T4G4T4G2) and, upon irradiation, obtained cross-links with the anchor site of telomerase from Euplotes aediculatus nuclear extract. No cross-linking occurred with a primer having the same 5' end and a nontelomeric 3' end. These cross-links were shown to be between the DNA primer and (i) a protein moiety of approximately 130 kDa and (ii) U51-U52 of the telomerase RNA. The cross-linked primer could be extended by telomerase in the presence of [alpha-32P]dGTP, thus indicating that the 3' end was bound in the enzyme active site. The locations of the cross-links within the single-stranded primers were 20 to 22 nucleotides upstream of the 3' end, providing a measure of the length of DNA required to span the telomerase active and anchor sites. When the single-stranded primers are aligned with the G-rich strand of a Euplotes telomere, the cross-linked nucleotides correspond to the duplex region. Consistent with this finding, a cross-link to telomerase was obtained by substitution of 5-iododeoxycytidine into the CA strand of the duplex region of telomere analogs. We conclude that the anchor site in the approximately 130-kDa protein can bind duplex as well as single-stranded DNA, which may be critical for its function at chromosome ends. Quantitation of the processivity with single-stranded DNA primers and double-stranded primers with 3' tails showed that only 60% of the primer remains bound after each repeat addition.     

Intrinsic intermolecular DNA ligation activity of eukaryotic topoisomerase II. Potential roles in recombination.

Drosophila melanogaster topoisomerase II is capable of joining phi X174 (+) strand DNA that it has cleaved to duplex oligonucleotide acceptor molecules by an intermolecular ligation reaction (Gale, K. C. and Osheroff, N. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 9538-9545). In order to investigate potential mechanisms for topoisomerase II-mediated DNA recombination, this intrinsic enzyme activity was further characterized. Intermolecular DNA ligation proceeded in a time-dependent fashion and was concentration-dependent with respect to oligonucleotide. The covalent linkage between phi X174 (+) strand DNA and acceptor molecules was confirmed by Southern analysis and alkaline gel electrophoresis. Topoisomerase II-mediated intermolecular DNA ligation required the oligonucleotide to contain a 3'-OH terminus. Moreover, the reaction was dependent on the presence of a divalent cation, was inhibited by salt, and was not affected by the presence of ATP. The enzyme was capable of ligating phi X174 (+) strand DNA to double-stranded oligonucleotides that contained 5'-overhang, 3'-overhand, or blunt ends. Single-stranded, nicked, or gapped oligonucleotides also could be used as acceptor molecules. These results demonstrate that the type II enzyme has an intrinsic ability to mediate illegitimate DNA recombination in vitro and suggests possible roles for topoisomerase II in nucleic acid recombination in vivo.     

Direction of the DNA-unwinding reaction catalysed by Escherichia coli DNA helicase II

The direction of the DNA-unwinding reaction catalysed by Escherichia coli DNA helicase II was studied using gapped linear DNA molecules with short duplex ends as substrate. The results suggest that DNA helicase II unwinds with 3'-5' polarity relative to the single strand of the DNA partial duplex. At high enzyme DNA ratio the enzyme also unwinds the duplex connected to the 3' end of the single strand and, as further studies show, fully duplex linear DNA. The fraction of DNA unwound decreases as the length of the duplex substrate increases. The preference of DNA helicase II for a short duplex can obscure the fact that the typical substrate is duplex connected to the 5' end of a single strand.     

Mapping of eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I catalyzed cleavage without concomitant religation in the vicinity of DNA structural anomalies

Sensitive sites for covalent trapping of eukaryotic topoisomerase I at DNA structural anomalies were mapped by a new method using purified enzyme and defined DNA substrates. To insure that the obtained topoisomerase I trapping patterns were not influenced by DNA sequence variations, a single DNA imperfection was placed centrally within a homonucleotide track. Mapping of topoisomerase I-mediated irreversible cleavage sites on homopolymeric DNA substrates containing mismatches showed trapping of the enzyme in several positions in close vicinity of the DNA imperfection, with a strong preference for the 5' junction between the duplex DNA and the base-pairing anomaly. On homopolymeric DNA substrates containing a nick, sites of topoisomerase I-mediated cleavage on the intact strand were located just opposite to the nick and from one to ten nucleotides 5' to the nick. Sites of enzyme-mediated cleavage next to a nick and an immobile single-stranded branch were located 5' to the strand interruption in distances of two to six nucleotides and two to ten nucleotides, respectively. Taken together these findings suggest that covalent trapping of topoisomerase I proceeds at positions adjacent to mismatches, nicks and single-stranded branches, where the cleavage reaction is allowed and the ensuing ligation reaction prevented. In principle, the developed interference method might be of general utility to define topoisomerase-DNA interactions relative to different types of structural anomalies.     

Crystal structure of bacteriophage T4 5' nuclease in complex with a branched DNA reveals how flap endonuclease-1 family nucleases bind their substrates

Bacteriophage T4 RNase H, a flap endonuclease-1 family nuclease, removes RNA primers from lagging strand fragments. It has both 5' nuclease and flap endonuclease activities. Our previous structure of native T4 RNase H (PDB code 1TFR) revealed an active site composed of highly conserved Asp residues and two bound hydrated magnesium ions. Here, we report the crystal structure of T4 RNase H in complex with a fork DNA substrate bound in its active site. This is the first structure of a flap endonuclease-1 family protein with its complete branched substrate. The fork duplex interacts with an extended loop of the helix-hairpin-helix motif class 2. The 5' arm crosses over the active site, extending below the bridge (helical arch) region. Cleavage assays of this DNA substrate identify a primary cut site 7-bases in from the 5' arm. The scissile phosphate, the first bond in the duplex DNA adjacent to the 5' arm, lies above a magnesium binding site. The less ordered 3' arm reaches toward the C and N termini of the enzyme, which are binding sites for T4 32 protein and T4 45 clamp, respectively. In the crystal structure, the scissile bond is located within the double-stranded DNA, between the first two duplex nucleotides next to the 5' arm, and lies above a magnesium binding site. This complex provides important insight into substrate recognition and specificity of the flap endonuclease-1 enzymes.     

Author index

Properties of strand breakage in duplex and single-stranded DNA by the wheat germ type 1 DNA topoisomerase were investigated. Strand breakage in duplex DNA is dependent upon the use of denaturing conditions to inactivate the enzyme and terminate the reaction, whereas breakage of single-stranded DNA occurs under the normal reaction conditions and is not dependent upon denaturation. Breakage generates a free 5′ hydroxyl group and enzyme bound to the 3′ side of the break, presumably via the 3′ phosphate group. The location of sites of breakage with both duplex and single-stranded DNA is not random. In all these respects the wheat germ enzyme closely resembles the rat liver type 1 topoisomerase. A comparison of the locations of the sites of breakage in duplex DNA generated by the topoisomerases from wheat germ and rat liver indicates a number of common sites, although the patterns of breakage are not identical.     

The role of gene A protein and E. coli rep protein in the replication of phi X 174 replicative form DNA

The gene A protein of bacteriophage phi X 174 initiates replication of super-twisted RFI DNA by cleaving the viral (+) strand at the origin of replication and binding to the 5' end. Upon addition of E. coli rep protein (single-stranded DNA dependent ATPase), E. coli single-stranded DNA binding protein and ATP, complete unwinding of the two strands occurs. Electron microscopic analyses of intermediates in the reaction reveal that the unwinding occurs by movement of the 5' end into the duplex, displacing the viral strand in the form of a single-stranded loop. Since unwinding will not occur in the absence of either gene A protein or rep protein, it is presumed that the rep protein interacts to form a complex with the bound gene A protein. Single-stranded DNA binding protein facilitates the unwinding by binding to the exposed single-stranded DNA. Further addition of the four deoxyribotriphosphates and DNA polymerase III holoenzyme to the reaction results in synthesis of viral (+) single-stranded circles in amounts exceeding that of the input template. A model describing the role of gene A protein and rep protein in duplex DNA replication is presented and other properties of gene A protein discussed.     

Nicks 3'' or 5'' to AP sites or to mispaired bases, and one-nucleotide gaps can be sealed by T4 DNA ligase.

Using synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides with 3'-OH ends and 32P-labelled 5'-phosphate ends and the technique of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, it is shown that, in the presence of the complementary polynucleotide, an AP (apurinic or apyrimidinic) site at the 3' or the 5' end of the labelled oligodeoxynucleotides does not prevent their ligation by T4 DNA ligase, although the reaction rate is decreased. This decrease is more severe when the AP site is at the 3' end; the activated intermediates accumulate showing that it is the efficiency of the adenyl-5'-phosphate attack by the 3'-OH of the base-free deoxyribose which is mostly perturbed. Using the same technique, it is shown that a mispaired base at the 3' or 5' end of oligodeoxynucleotides does not prevent their ligation. A one-nucleotide gap, limited by 3'-OH and 5'-phosphate, can also be closed by T4 DNA ligase although with difficulty; here again the activation of the 5'-phosphate end does not seem to be slowed down, but rather the 3'-OH attack of the adenyl-5'-phosphate. All these anomalous ligations take place with the nick or the gap in front of a continuous complementary strand. Blunt ends ligation of correct duplexes occurs readily; however an AP site or a mispaired base at the 3' or 5' end of one strand of the duplexes prevents ligation between these strands. But a missing nucleotide (responsible for one unpaired nucleotide protruding at the 3' or 5' end of the complementary strand) does not stop ligation of the shorter oligodeoxynucleotides between independent duplexes.     

Extent of single-stranded DNA required for efficient TraI helicase activity in vitro

The IncF plasmid protein TraI functions during bacterial conjugation as a site- and strand-specific DNA transesterase and a highly processive 5' to 3' DNA helicase. The N-terminal DNA transesterase domain of TraI localizes the protein to nic and cleaves this site within the plasmid transfer origin. In the cell the C-terminal DNA helicase domain of TraI is essential for driving the 5' to 3' unwinding of plasmid DNA from nic to provide the strand destined for transfer. In vitro, however, purified TraI protein cannot enter and unwind nicked plasmid DNA and instead requires a 5' tail of single-stranded DNA at the duplex junction. In this study we evaluate the extent of single-stranded DNA adjacent to the duplex that is required for efficient TraI-catalyzed DNA unwinding in vitro. A series of linear partial duplex DNA substrates containing a central stretch of single-stranded DNA of defined length was created and its structure verified. We found that substrates containing >or=27 nucleotides of single-stranded DNA 5' to the duplex were unwound efficiently by TraI, whereas substrates containing 20 or fewer nucleotides were not. These results imply that during conjugation localized unwinding of >20 nucleotides at nic is necessary to initiate unwinding of plasmid DNA strands.     

The Bacillus subtilis AddAB helicase/nuclease is regulated by its cognate Chi sequence in vitro

The AddAB enzyme is important to homologous DNA recombination in Bacillus subtilis, where it is thought to be the functional counterpart of the RecBCD enzyme of Escherichia coli. In vivo, AddAB responds to a specific five-nucleotide sequence (5'-AGCGG-3' or its complement) in a manner analogous to the response of the RecBCD enzyme to interaction with chi sequences. Here, we show that purified AddAB enzyme is able to load at a double-stranded DNA end and is both a DNA helicase and nuclease, whose combined action results in the degradation of both strands of the DNA duplex. During translocation, recognition of the properly oriented sequence 5'-AGCGG-3' causes attenuation of the AddAB enzyme nuclease activity that is responsible for degradation of the strand 3'-terminal at the entry site. Therefore, we conclude that 5'-AGCGG-3' is the B. subtilis Chi site and it is hereafter referred to as chi(Bs). After encountering chi(Bs), both the degradation of the 5'-terminal strand and the helicase activity persist. Thus, processing of a double-stranded DNA end by the AddAB enzyme produces a duplex DNA molecule with a protruding 3'-terminated single-stranded tail, a universal intermediate of the recombination process.