Antibody performance in western blot applications is context‐dependent

An important concern for the use of antibodies in various applications, such as western blot (WB) or immunohistochemistry (IHC), is specificity. This calls for systematic validations using well‐designed conditions. Here, we have analyzed 13 000 antibodies using western blot with lysates from human cell lines, tissues, and plasma. Standardized stratification showed that 45% of the antibodies yielded supportive staining, and the rest either no staining (12%) or protein bands of wrong size (43%). A comparative study of WB and IHC showed that the performance of antibodies is application‐specific, although a correlation between no WB staining and weak IHC staining could be seen. To investigate the influence of protein abundance on the apparent specificity of the antibody, new WB analyses were performed for 1369 genes that gave unsupportive WBs in the initial screening using cell lysates with overexpressed full‐length proteins. Then, more than 82% of the antibodies yielded a specific band corresponding to the full‐length protein. Hence, the vast majority of the antibodies (90%) used in this study specifically recognize the target protein when present at sufficiently high levels. This demonstrates the context‐ and application‐dependence of antibody validation and emphasizes that caution is needed when annotating binding reagents as specific or cross‐reactive. WB is one of the most commonly used methods for validation of antibodies. Our data implicate that solely using one platform for antibody validation might give misleading information and therefore at least one additional method should be used to verify the achieved data.     

Transfer of silver-stained proteins from polyacrylamide gels to polyvinylidene difluoride membranes.

We have developed a method to transfer proteins from a silver-stained polyacrylamide gel to a polyvinylidene difluoride (Immobilon-P) transfer membrane (Millipore, Bedford, MA). If the silver stained gels are rinsed in 2 x SDS Laemmli sample buffer prior to transfer, almost all proteins can be transferred comparably to non-stained controls. Some proteins stained with silver can be directly transfer, almost all proteins can be transferred comparably to non-stained controls. Some proteins stained with silver can be directly transferred to a single sheet of Immobilon-P without a prior rinse in sample buffer. Most important in the Western blot the antigenicity of the transferred protein is retained in either way. The method described is simple, inexpensive and versatile. A slight modification of the technique permits one to extract minor proteins, or detect their antigenic activities, without contamination of contiguous proteins.     

Immunoblotting procedure for the analysis of electrophoretically-fractionated bacterial lipopolysaccharide

A procedure is described for the efficient transfer of fractionated bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from SDS-polyacrylamide gels to nitrocellulose filters, and its subsequent display by a peroxidase-linked antibody. The method is sensitive, and reveals and resolves high molecular weight LPS molecules having side chain lengths of up to and greater than 30 repeat units. It is also useful for the rapid analysis of LPS in bacterial outer membrane preparations.     

Luminescent immunodetection of western-blotted proteins from coomassie-stained polyacrylamide gel

Immunodetection with horseradish peroxidase-linked antibodies on Coomassie-stained nitrocellulose blots can be performed efficiently and rapidly with the peroxidase substrate luminol. The luminescence produced is detected with radioautographic film. This procedure allows a direct identification of immunodetected bands of stained nitrocellulose sheets without using radiolabeled secondary antibodies. Because of its convenience and sensitivity, this method could be particularly suitable for purification of immunodetected proteins.     

Determination of membrane antigens by a covalent crosslinking method with monoclonal antibodies

Monoclonal antibodies that recognize cell surface proteins may serve as very useful tools for the study of the biological functions of membrane proteins. However, solubilization of the antigens with detergents may lead to major conformational changes of the protein, making their determination with monoclonal antibodies by immune blot or ordinary immunoprecipitation methods difficult. This is especially evident when the monoclonal antibodies recognize tertiary structures of the proteins in the membrane. We have generated two monoclonal antibodies which are specific for the cell surface antigens of multidrug-resistant human cell lines. However, the antigens of both monoclonal antibodies were difficult to detect by either immune blot or ordinary immunoprecipitation methods. We used a cleavable crosslinking reagent dithiobis(succinimidyl propionate) to covalently link the monoclonal antibody with its antigenic determinant in the membrane of intact cells. By this method, we were able to detect the antigens for these two monoclonal antibodies following solubilization, immunoprecipitation, and analysis by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. This method should have wide applicability in determination of membrane antigens recognized by monoclonal antibodies when immune blot or ordinary immunoprecipitation methods are not successful.     

A trichloroacetic acid-acetone method greatly reduces infrared autofluorescence of protein extracts from plant tissue

Immunoblotting is used to determine many important characteristics of proteins. After electrophoretic separation, proteins are transferred to a membrane and reacted with a specific antibody. The antibody-protein complex is then visualized by radiographic, chromogenic, chemiluminescent, or more recently described fluorescence detection methods. Fluorescence-based detection offers some advantages over other approaches, including increased sensitivity, improved quantifiable range, and the ability to detect multiple antigens on the same blot. However, this technique is unavailable for analysis of green plant tissues by standard extraction methods because of contaminating autofluorescent pigments. We have compared 3 methods for extracting protein from plant tissue for use with infrared fluorescence-based immunoblot analysis. We report a trichloroacetic acid-acetone method that effectively eliminates autofluorescence while retaining the immunogenicity of a target protein.     

Preparation of polyclonal antibody specific for AtPLC4, an Arabidopsis phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C in rabbits

Phosphoinositide-specific phospholipase Cs (PI-PLCs) are important enzymes in eukaryotes, which catalyze the hydrolysis of phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate into the two second messengers inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate and diacylglycerol. The Arabidopsis genome contains nine putative PI-PLC genes. AtPLC4, an abiotic stress induced gene, has been reported to encode an active PI-PLC isoform. However, the exact roles of putative AtPLC4 in plant remain to be elicited. The first 108 amino acid residues of the N-terminal of AtPLC4, referred to as AtPLC4 N, was expressed as a recombinant protein in Escherichia coli and used as antigen in generating antibody. Purified recombinant proteins including AtPLC1 to AtPLC5, AtPLC8, AtPLC9 and AtPLC4 N were transferred onto the same blot to test specificity of the prepared antibody. Western blot result shows that only AtPLC4 and AtPLC4 N can be recognized by the antibody. The antibody recognized a protein of approximately 68kDa in the plasma membrane fraction and cytosolic fractions prepared from Arabidopsis thaliana plants. This corresponds very well with the calculated molecular weight of AtPLC4. The results suggest that AtPLC4 may encode a plasma membrane-associated protein.     

抗欧亚活血丹凝集素特异性多克隆抗体的制备

欧亚活血丹外源凝集素(Gleheda)是分离自欧亚活血丹 (Glechoma hederacea) 叶片中的一种糖基化植物新蛋白. 如同其他糖基化蛋白,通过免疫学方法探测 Gleheda 的过程中通常受到一些不相干糖蛋白的妨碍,为此制定了抗 Gleheda 特异性多克隆抗体的纯化方案. 免疫血清蛋白经硫酸铵选择性沉淀后,分别以 Gleheda 和刺槐外源凝集蛋白 (RPA) 结合在 Sepharose 4B作为亲和配体,采用亲和层析法连续纯化 2 次,然后进一步采用离子交换层析 Q Fast Flow 提纯. 经每一步骤提纯得到的抗体组分对 Gleheda 的特异性,均同时采用双向免疫扩散检验和 Western blot 分析. 结果表明,以 Gleheda 为配体,亲和纯化制备得到的抗体组分对叶片粗提物中的许多植物 (糖) 蛋白仍然表现交叉反应. 为除去由植物糖蛋白中的聚糖所引起这些非特异性交叉反应抗体,接着以 RPA 为配体再次进行亲和纯化,Western blot 分析显示,抗体的特异性得到提高但并非除去了所有非特异性交叉反应的抗体. 最后进一步采用离子交换层析制备得到仅抗 Gleheda 蛋白的特异性抗体组分,此抗体组分适用于免疫探测研究. 该抗体纯化制备程序简易而高效,而且不需要昂贵的设备.     

Variability in the immunodetection of His-tagged recombinant proteins

Labeling of recombinant proteins with polypeptide fusion partners, or affinity tagging, is a useful method to facilitate subsequent protein purification and detection. Poly-histidine tags (His-tags) are among the most commonly used affinity tags. We report strikingly variable immunodetection of two His-tagged recombinant human erythropoietins (Epo): wild type Epo (Epo(wt)) and Epo containing an R103A mutation (Epo(R103A)). Both were engineered to contain a C-terminal six residue His-tag. The cDNA constructs were stably transfected into Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and COS-7 cells. Clones from the CHO cell transfections were selected for further characterization and larger-scale protein expression. Three chromatographic steps were utilized to achieve pharmacologically pure Epo. Conditioned media from the Epo-expressing cell lines and protein-containing samples from each step of purification were analyzed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and dot blot, using both monoclonal anti-human Epo antibody (AE7A5) and anti-His antibodies. While the successful incorporation of the His-tag into our constructs was confirmed by Epo binding to Ni(2+)- nitrilotriacetic acid resin and by microcapillary reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography nano-electrospray tandem mass spectrometery amino acid sequencing, the levels of immunodetection of His-tagged protein varied markedly depending on the particular anti-His-tag antibody used. Such variability in His-tag immunorecognition can lead to critical adverse effects on several analytical methods.     

Design, preparation and use of ligated phosphoproteins: a novel approach to study protein phosphatases by dot blot array, ELISA and Western blot assays

The study of substrate specificity of protein phosphatases (PPs) is very challenging since it is difficult to prepare a suitable phosphorylated substrate. Phosphoproteins, phosphorylated by a protein kinase, or chemically synthesized phosphopeptides are commonly used substrates for PPs. Both types of these substrates have their advantages and limitations. Phosphoproteins mimic more closely the physiologically relevant PP substrates, but their preparation is technically demanding. Synthetic phosphopeptides present advantages over proteins because they can be easily produced in large quantity and their amino acid sequence can be designed to contain potential determinants of substrate specificity. However, short peptides are less optimal compared to in vivo PP substrates and often display poor and variable binding to different matrices, resulting in low sensitivity in analysis of PP activity on solid support. In this work we utilize the intein-mediated protein ligation (IPL) technique to generate substrates for PPs, combining the advantages of proteins and synthetic peptides in one molecule. The ligation of a synthetic phosphopeptide to an intein-generated carrier protein (CP) with a one-to-one stoichiometry results in the formation of a ligated phosphoprotein (LPP). Three widely used assays, dot blot array, Western blot and ELISA were employed to study the PP activity on LPP substrates. Dephosphorylation was measured by detection of the remaining phosphorylation, or lack of it, with a phospho-specific antibody. The data show the advantage of LPPs over free peptides in assays on solid supports. LPPs exhibited enhanced binding to the matrices used in the study, which significantly improved sensitivity and consistency of the assays. In addition, saturation of the signal was circumvented by serial dilution of the assay samples. This report describes detailed experimental procedures for preparation of LPP substrates and their use in PP assays based on immobilization on solid supports.     

Immunoaffinity chromatography

The basic procedure of immunoaffinity chromatography (IAC) is described. The insoluble support matrices available for IAC and their activation chemistries, including some of the most recently introduced, are reviewed. Means of selecting the most appropriate monoclonal antibody (MAb) are described, although an empirical approach is still required for the final choice of antibody. Precise methods of runing IAC columns are surveyed including the binding, washing, and elution stages, although no precise recommendations can be made particularly for the elution step since this is unique to a particular MAb and antigen. All IAC sorbents lose activity with time through a combination of MAb inactivation and ligand leakage. The relative importance of the two phenomena is discussed, and suggestions are made to minimize the problem along with an indication of the relative stabilities of a range of coupling chemistries. A sample of the proteins purified by IAC is given together with pointers to the future of the technique.     

FerriDye: colloidal iron binding followed by Perls' reaction for the staining of proteins transferred from sodium dodecyl sulfate gels to nitrocellulose and positively charged nylon membranes

A staining method for proteins on (positively charged) nylon and nitrocellulose membranes is described. The two-step method uses cationic cacodylate iron colloid which is substituted with Tween 20 at an OD460 nm = 0.5, followed by Perls' reaction with acid potassium ferrocyanide. It stains transferred proteins deep blue with low background. The sensitivity is intermediate between that of conventional stains and AuroDye, the colloidal gold stain. This is the first sensitive staining method for proteins transferred on (positively charged) nylon membranes. These membranes have documented advantages in immunoblotting. It will therefore be a useful tool for correlating the position of bands or spots of proteins detected with overlay assays with the complete electropherogram in a duplicate protein blot.     

The erasable Western blot

A method for successfully removing primary and secondary antibodies from nitrocellulose blots while preserving the originally immobilized polypeptides was developed. Polypeptides were separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate and electrophoretically transferred to nitrocellulose. Nonspecific binding sites were blocked with 5% (w/v) nonfat dried milk. After blots were reacted sequentially with antibodies directed against the antigen of interest and with radiolabeled secondary antibody, a 10-min wash in 5% (w/v) milk was required prior to drying and autoradiography. A 30-min incubation at 70 degrees C in 2% (w/v) sodium dodecyl sulfate containing 100 mM beta-mercaptoethanol quantitatively removed the antibodies and allowed reuse of the blot. A modification of this method similarly allowed reuse of Western blots when proteins were immobilized on nylon. Potential applications and limitations of this method are discussed.     

Colony filtration blotting for screening soluble expression in Escherichia coli

We have developed a screen for detecting E. coli colonies that produce soluble recombinant target proteins at the colony level: the colony filtration (CoFi) blot. Colonies are transferred, induced and lysed on a filter membrane that can separate soluble proteins from inclusion bodies. Upon lysis, the soluble proteins diffuse through the filter membrane and are captured on a nitrocellulose membrane. The nitrocellulose membrane is incubated with antibodies or probes specific for the target protein and are then developed. In the resulting image, colonies expressing soluble protein can easily be identified. This protocol can be used to screen thousands of constructs in a matter of days, making it very suitable for expression libraries. The protocol is robust and flexible with regard to lysis conditions, induction temperatures and strains. The method requires only standard laboratory equipment and is based on immunochemicals used for western blotting. The following protocol describes the screening of a DNA library with detection done using chemiluminescence. Depending on induction temperature, the whole procedure can be performed in <2 d.     

Immunodetection of nitrocellulose-adhesive proteins at the nanogram level after trinitrophenyl modification

A method for protein detection on nitrocellulose membranes based on modification with 2,4,6-trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid and reaction with anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) serum as first antibody followed by peroxidase-conjugated second antibody is described. Protein quantities between 1 and 3 ng can be detected in the dot test. This method was used in a double immunodetection procedure after electrophoretic transfer of proteins localizing first a distinct antigen with its specific antiserum followed by visualization of the complete protein pattern on the same blot by the TNP/anti-TNP method as described above. As only water-soluble reagents are employed no shrinkage of the membrane occurs. Furthermore, the method can be used in a simultaneous immunodetection procedure visualizing the specific antigen together with TNP marker proteins using a mixture of the specific antiserum and the anti-TNP serum as first antibody.     

Avidin- or streptavidin-biotin as a highly sensitive method to stain total protein on membranes

A sensitive method for staining proteins after transfer from polyacrylamide gels to nitrocellulose paper is described. Transferred proteins are first derivatized by reaction of the nitrocellulose replica with sulfosuccinimidobiotin and are then reacted sequentially with streptavidin, rabbit anti-streptavidin, and horseradish peroxidase-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG antibody. Incubation with the enzyme substrate α-chloronaphthol, produces dark protein bands against a white background. The binding of streptavidin to the proteins is dependent on biotin derivatization as demonstrated by competition with biotinylated bovine serum albumin or 10 nM biotin. The procedure detects less than 5ng of transferred protein in a single band and is thus 5–10 times more sensitive than horseradish peroxidase-conjugated avidin alone. For bovine serum albumin, the method is comparable in sensitivity to silver staining of protein in polyacrylamide gels.     

Antibodies to phase related proteins in juvenile and mature Prunus avium

In the search for biochemical and molecular markers of juvenility in trees proteins have been identified which are preferentially or differentially expressed in either the juvenile or the mature phases of Prunus avium cv. Stella. These fall into two classes: those which are phase-related and those which may be affected by root-shoot distance. N-terminal amino acid sequence data from some of these proteins were used to produce polyclonal antibodies to corresponding synthetic peptides in order to determine if they could be used as markers of phase state in woody plants. Western blot analysis was performed on proteins extracted from three sources; juvenile trees, mature trees and rooted cuttings from mature trees. The results showed that the antibodies recognised differentially-expressed proteins. In particular, one antibody to a juvenile specific protein cross-reacted with a polypeptide of approx. 28 kDa which was present in greater amounts in shoot tips of juvenile P. avium cv. Stella seedlings compared with rooted cuttings of mature plants placed in the same growth environment.     

Mapping of linear epitopes recognized by monoclonal antibodies with gene-fragment phage display libraries

Epitope mapping with mono- or polyclonal antibodies has so far been done either by dissecting the antigens into overlapping polypeptides in the form of recombinantly expressed fusion proteins, or by synthesizing overlapping short peptides, or by a combination of both methods. Here, we report an alternative method which involves the generation of random gene fragments of approximately 50–200 by in length and cloning these into the 5 terminus of the protein III gene of fd phages. Selection for phages that bind a given monoclonal antibody and sequencing the DNA inserts of immunopositive phages yields derived amino acid sequences containing the desired epitope. A monoclonal antibody (mAb 215) directed against the largest subunit of Drosophila RNA polymerase II (RPB215) was used to map the corresponding epitope in a fUSE5 phage display library made of random DNA fragments from plasmid DNA containing the entire gene. After a single round of panning with this phage library, bacterial colonies were obtained which produced fd phages displaying the mAb 215 epitope. Sequencing of single-stranded phage DNA from a number of positive colonies (recognized by the antibody on colony immunoblots) resulted in overlapping sequences all containing the 15mer epitope determined by mapping with synthetic peptides. Similarly, we have localized the epitopes recognized by a mouse monoclonal antibody directed against the human p53 protein, and by a mouse monoclonal antibody directed against the human cytokeratin 19 protein. Identification of positive colonies after the panning procedure depends on the detection system used (colony immunoblot or ELISA) and there appear to be some restrictions to the use of linker-encoded amino acids for optimal presentation of epitopes. A comparison with epitope mapping by synthetic peptides shows that the phage display method allows one to map linear epitopes down to a size only slightly larger than the true epitope. In general, our phage display method is faster, easier, and cheaper than the construction of overlapping fusion proteins or the use of synthetic peptides, especially in cases where the antigen is a large polypeptide such as the 215 kDa subunit of eukaryotic RNA polymerase II.     

Immunochemical measurement of histone H3 in non-nucleosomal compartments of cultured mammalian cells

We measured histone H3 in the non-nucleosomal compartment of cultured mammalian cells by enzyme-linked immunoelectrotransfer blot assay of cytosolic proteins using affinity-purified rabbit anti-H3 IgG, and peroxidase-linked second antibodies. The cytosolic H3 level was estimated to be 0.5-1.0% of the nucleosomal H3 content in MH-134SC cells (mean generation time 11 h) and 3-4% in HeLa cells (mean generation time 22 h). It showed characteristic changes under the inhibitions of DNA and/or protein synthesis and during the cell cycle of HeLa cells. These indicate an inverse relationship between the cytosolic H3 level and the replicating activity of nuclear DNA. The possible implication of the non-nucleosomal histones in the regulation of histone gene expression is discussed.