Comparison of bioMérieux API 20NE and Remel RapID NF Plus, identification systems of type strains of Ralstonia pickettii

A : Comparison of two commercial miniaturized rapid systems for the identification of Ralstonia pickettii strains. METHODS AND RESULTS: Varying identification results were encountered using the bioMérieux API NE system and the Remel IDS RapID NF Plus commercial systems for R. pickettii. To compare these two systems, eight strains of R. pickettii were purchased from different commercial culture collections. Additionally, 32 industrial and eight clinical isolates, initially identified using the Vitek Junior (bioMérieux) were tested. Total number of isolates tested was 48. The API 20NE identified 29 isolates, as R. pickettii but was unsuccessful with 19 isolates. The Remel IDS RapID NF Plus identified 46 isolates as R. pickettii. One clinical and one industrial isolates was identified as non-R. pickettii with both systems. CONCLUSIONS: The above results indicate that the use of API 20NE system for examining the identification of R. pickettii strains is inconsistent. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This study demonstrated that the RapID NF Plus is more accurate as an inexpensive identification system for the identification of R. pickettii, a potential emerging organism of medically and industrial importance.     

Comparison of biochemical and molecular methods for the identification of bacterial isolates associated with failed loggerhead sea turtle eggs

Aims: Comparison of biochemical vs molecular methods for identification of microbial populations associated with failed loggerhead turtle eggs. Methods and Results: Two biochemical (API and Microgen) and one molecular methods (16s rRNA analysis) were compared in the areas of cost, identification, corroboration of data with other methods, ease of use, resources and software. The molecular method was costly and identified only 66% of the isolates tested compared with 74% for API. A 74% discrepancy in identifications occurred between API and 16s rRNA analysis. The two biochemical methods were comparable in cost, but Microgen was easier to use and yielded the lowest discrepancy among identifications (29%) when compared with both API 20 enteric (API 20E) and API 20 nonenteric (API 20NE) combined. A comparison of API 20E and API 20NE indicated an 83% discrepancy between the two methods. Conclusions: The Microgen identification system appears to be better suited than API or 16s rRNA analysis for identification of environmental isolates associated with failed loggerhead eggs. Significance and Impact of the Study: Most identification methods are not intended for use with environmental isolates. A comparison of identification systems would provide better options for identifying environmental bacteria for ecological studies.     

Evaluation of different approaches for identification of xenobiotic- degrading pseudomonads.

Different approaches were evaluated to identify aerobic, gram-negative, biodegradative isolates assumed to be pseudomonads. Quinone and polyamine analysis allowed rapid identification to the genus level, i.e., allocation of those isolates belonging to the Pseudomonas fluorescens complex which represents the phylogenetically defined core of the heterogeneous genus Pseudomonas. Subsequent studies concentrated only on these true pseudomonads. The multiple-test system API 20NE, determination of the moles percent G+C content, and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of soluble proteins aided in identification on the species level. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of both soluble proteins and whole-cell lipopolysaccharides allowed recognition of identical strains and double isolates, which were confirmed by DNA-DNA hybridization.     

Evaluation of different approaches for identification of xenobiotic- degrading pseudomonads

Different approaches were evaluated to identify aerobic, gram-negative, biodegradative isolates assumed to be pseudomonads. Quinone and polyamine analysis allowed rapid identification to the genus level, i.e., allocation of those isolates belonging to the Pseudomonas fluorescens complex which represents the phylogenetically defined core of the heterogeneous genus Pseudomonas. Subsequent studies concentrated only on these true pseudomonads. The multiple-test system API 20NE, determination of the moles percent G+C content, and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of soluble proteins aided in identification on the species level. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of both soluble proteins and whole-cell lipopolysaccharides allowed recognition of identical strains and double isolates, which were confirmed by DNA-DNA hybridization.     

Polyphosphate accumulation among denitrifying bacteria in activated sludge

Bacterial polyphosphate accumulation and denitrification are important processes in biological removal of nutrients from wastewater. It has been suggested that phosphorus accumulators are able to denitrify. However, the bacteria known as the most important phosphorus accumulators, belonging to the genus Acinetobacter are generally not known to denitrify. To clarify how commonly both physiological traits are present in the same organism, we screened 165 isolates from activated sludge and wastewater for their ability to denitrify, and the ability of the denitrifying isolates to accumulate polyphosphate. Of the 165 isolates, 149 were from acetate mineral medium (87 of these identified as Acinetobacter by the API 20 NE identification system) and 16 were from nutrient broth and nitrate medium. Only 15 of 165 isolates tested showed true respiratory denitrification activity. In the presence of acetylene they converted more than 80% of 5mM NO3- to N2O in 6 days. None of the Acinetobacter isolates were among the 15 respiratory denitrifiers. The denitrifying isolates were identified as species of Pseudomonas, Agrobacterium, Pasteurella, Sphingomonas or could not be identified by the API 20 NE identification system. According to the BIOLOG identification system the denitrifiers were species of Pseudomonas, Hydrogenophaga, Citrobacter, Xanthomonas or they could not be identified. The ability of confirmed denitrifiers to accumulate phosphate was measured in experiments where cells pregrown under phosphorus limitation were exposed to phosphate (8 mg P/L) under aerobic conditions. The rates of excess phosphate uptake varied from 0.3 to more than 23 mg P/g dry matter/h. Rates for four isolates were higher than those reported for Acinetobacter strains. These results show that polyphosphate accumulation and denitrification in activated sludge can be carried out by the same organisms.     

Molecular and phenotypic characterization of Pseudomonas spp. isolated from milk

Putative Pseudomonas spp. isolated predominantly from raw and processed milk were characterized by automated ribotyping and by biochemical reactions. Isolates were biochemically profiled using the Biolog system and API 20 NE and by determining the production of proteases, lipases, and lecithinases for each isolate. Isolates grouped into five coherent clusters, predominated by the species P. putida (cluster A), P. fluorescens (cluster B), P. fragi (as identified by Biolog) or P. fluorescens (as identified by API 20 NE) (cluster C), P. fragi (as identified by Biolog) or P. putida (as identified by API 20 NE) (cluster D), and P. fluorescens (cluster E). Isolates within each cluster also displayed similar enzyme activities. Isolates in clusters A, C, and D were generally negative for all three enzyme activities; isolates in cluster B were predominantly positive for all three enzyme activities; and isolates in cluster E were negative for lecithinase but predominantly positive for protease and lipase activities. Thus, only isolates from clusters B and E produced enzyme activities associated with dairy product flavor defects. Thirty-eight ribogroups were differentiated among the 70 isolates. Ribotyping was highly discriminatory for dairy Pseudomonas isolates, with a Simpson's index of discrimination of 0.955. Isolates of the same ribotype were never classified into different clusters, and ribotypes within a given cluster generally showed similar ribotype patterns; thus, specific ribotype fragments may be useful markers for tracking the sources of pseudomonads in dairy production systems. Our results suggest that ribogroups are generally homogeneous with respect to nomenspecies and biovars, confirming the identification potential of ribotyping for Pseudomonas spp.     

Genetic diversity and spoilage potentials among Pseudomonas spp. isolated from fluid milk products and dairy processing plants

Degradation of milk components through various enzymatic activities associated with the contamination of dairy products by Pseudomonas spp. can reduce the shelf life of processed milk. Reliable methods for differentiating among Pseudomonas spp. strains are necessary to identify and eliminate specific sources of bacterial contamination from dairy processing systems. To that end, we assessed the genetic diversity and dairy product spoilage potentials among a total of 338 Pseudomonas spp. isolates from raw and pasteurized milk and from environmental samples collected from four dairy processing plants. The majority of isolates were identified as P. fluorescens and P. putida by API 20 NE. A total of 42 different ribotype patterns were identified among a subset of 81 isolates. The presence of many different ribotypes within this collection indicates high genetic diversity among the isolates and suggests multiple origins of contamination within the processing plant and in dairy products. The extracellular enzyme activity patterns among Pseudomonas isolates appeared to be associated with ribotypes. Isolates with the same ribotype frequently had the same extracellular protease, lecithinase, and lipase activities. For example, isolates grouped in ribotype 55-S-6 had the highest extracellular protease activity, while those in ribotypes 50-S-8 and 72-S-3 had the highest extracellular lipase activities. We conclude that ribotyping provides a reliable method for differentiating Pseudomonas strains with dairy food spoilage potential.     

Investigation of persistent colonization by Pseudomonas aeruginosa-like strains in a spring water bottling plant.

Ninety-seven strains, producing a fluorescent pigment under UV light and/or a green diffusive pigment on cetrimide-naladixic acid agar, were isolated from a spring water bottling plant. These strains were presumptively identified as Pseudomonas aeruginosa, but they could not be confirmed as strains of this species nor identified by the API 20NE identification system. The isolates and reference strains were clustered by computer-assisted whole-cell protein sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The numerical analysis of the protein electrophoregrams resulted in the formation of four clusters at a similarity level of 80% and two unclustered type strains. One cluster included strains isolated during a 4-month period and reference strains of several biotypes of P. fluorescens. The remaining isolates formed another cluster with a very high similarity of level, which included two groups of strains based on biochemical characterization by the API 20NE Test System. Strains were typed by random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD)-PCR and two different RAPD patterns were obtained, corresponding to each biochemical profile. This persistent colonization seems to be caused by a single species present in the bottling system, with two clonal origins, not related to P. aeruginosa or to any of the other type strains tested. Partial 16S rDNA sequence of a representative strain of one cluster of isolates had a level of similarity of 99.3% with P. alcaligenes. This study shows that characteristics similar to P. aeruginosa on cetrimide-naladixic acid agar can be exhibited by several groups of fluorescent pseudomonads that do not belong to this species, clearly showing that confirmation tests must be performed before a decision regarding the water quality is made.     

Comparison of different biochemical and molecular methods for the identification of Vibrio parahaemolyticus

AIMS: Multicentre evaluation of biochemical and molecular methods for the identification of Vibrio parahaemolyticus. METHODS AND RESULTS: For the biochemical identification methods, API 20E and API 20NE and Alsina's scheme were evaluated in intra- and interlaboratory tests in order to determine the accuracy and concordance of each method. Both in intra- and interlaboratory tests, the Alsina's scheme showed the highest sensitivity (86% of correct identifications in the interlaboratory test). False-positive results were obtained by all methods (specificity was 95% for API 20E, 73% for API 20NE and 84% for Alsina's scheme) and concordance varied from 65% of API 20NE to 84% of API 20E. For the molecular identifications, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for the detection of toxR gene, tl gene and pR72H fragment were tested on 30 strains by two laboratories. The PCR for toxR showed the highest inclusivity (96%), exclusivity (100%) and concordance (97%). CONCLUSIONS: Among the biochemical identification methods tested, the Alsina's scheme gave more reliable results; however, in order to avoid false-positive results, all the biochemical identifications should be confirmed by means of molecular methods. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Availability of an efficient identification method of Vibrio parahaemolyticus to use in official control of fisheries products.     

Screening of lactic acid bacteria from fermented vegetables by carbohydrate profiling and PCR-ELISA

AIMS: The aim of this study was to identify potential souring agents, isolated from fermented plant material, by API 50 CHL assay and a molecular method based on polymerase chain reaction and colorimetric hybridization (PCR-ELISA). METHODS AND RESULTS: Forty-two strains of lactic acid bacteria derived from plant material were screened by taking advantage of API 50 CHL and PCR-ELISA. Oligonucleotide probes used for hybridization in PCR-ELISA were specific for lactobacilli, the Leuconostoc family, Lactobacillus pentosus/plantarum and Lactobacillus brevis. The hybrides were detected by a colour-developing reaction. Bacteria isolated from fermented cucumbers were identified as Lact. plantarum-related (Lact. plantarum and Lact. pentosus) and Leuconostoc species. Most of the strains isolated from sauerkraut were identified as Lact. pentosus/plantarum. CONCLUSIONS: Complementary results were obtained in the identification of bacterial strains, isolated from fermented cucumbers and sauerkraut, by API 50 CHL and PCR-ELISA. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: PCR-ELISA proved to be suitable for the screening of large numbers of bacterial isolates from fermented vegetables. This will be useful for the identification of strains suitable for the design of starter cultures for the fermentation of plant material.     

Development of a DNA microarray for enterococcal species, virulence, and antibiotic resistance gene determinations among isolates from poultry

A DNA microarray (Enteroarray) was designed with probes targeting four species-specific taxonomic identifiers to discriminate among 18 different enterococcal species, while other probes were designed to identify 18 virulence factors and 174 antibiotic resistance genes. In total, 262 genes were utilized for rapid species identification of enterococcal isolates, while characterizing their virulence potential through the simultaneous identification of endogenous antibiotic resistance and virulence genes. Enterococcal isolates from broiler chicken farms were initially identified by using the API 20 Strep system, and the results were compared to those obtained with the taxonomic genes atpA, recA, pheS, and ddl represented on our microarray. Among the 171 isolates studied, five different enterococcal species were identified by using the API 20 Strep system: Enterococcus faecium, E. faecalis, E. durans, E. gallinarum, and E. avium. The Enteroarray detected the same species as API 20 Strep, as well as two more: E. casseliflavus and E. hirae. Species comparisons resulted in 15% (27 isolates) disagreement between the two methods among the five API 20 Strep identifiable species and 24% (42 isolates) disagreement when considering the seven Enteroarray identified species. The species specificity of key antibiotic and virulence genes identified by the Enteroarray were consistent with the literature adding further robustness to the redundant taxonomic probe data. Sequencing of the cpn60 gene further confirmed the complete accuracy of the microarray results. The new Enteroarray should prove to be a useful tool to accurately genotype strains of enterococci and assess their virulence potential.     

以分子生物学鉴定结果为“金标准”评估Rapid ID Yeast Plus及API20C AUX对酵母样真菌的鉴定效能

目的 以分子生物学方法为“金标准”对两种商品化酵母样真菌鉴定产品Rapid ID Yeast Plus（简称RapIDYST）及API20C AUX（简称API20C）的鉴定效能进行评估.方法 从2010年中国医院侵袭性真菌感染监测网菌株库中筛选酵母样真菌25种,共计194株.其中,包含临床最常见的5种酵母样真菌（白念珠菌、热带念珠菌、光滑念珠菌、近平滑念珠菌、新生隐球菌）共130株,占研究总菌株数的67.0％.所有菌株已经过分子生物学方法准确鉴定至种水平.菌株复苏分纯后,严格按照产品操作指南,平行进行RapID YST和API20C鉴定.结果 所研究菌株中,有181株（18种）在RapID YST鉴定菌种数据库中,所有在库菌株种及复合体鉴定正确率为87.8％（159/181）.相比,API鉴定菌种库包含菌株174株（18种）,在库菌株种及复合体鉴定正确率为92.0％ （160/174）.RapID YST与API20C对于5种临床常见的酵母样真菌的种鉴定正确率分别为93.1％和97.1％.对于库外菌株,RapID YST的鉴定错误率分别为23.1％（3/13）,相比API20C的鉴定错误率为60.0％ （12/20）.综合此次评估结果,二者对酵母样真菌的鉴定效能无显著差异（McNemar检验,P＞0.05）.结论 两种商品化产品对酵母样真菌的鉴定效能基本一致;相较而言,RapID YST在操作便捷性、检测时间方面具有较大优势.     

Differences in the API 20E biochemical patterns of clinical and environmental Vibrio parahaemolyticus isolates

Genetic differences in clinical and environmental strains of Vibrio parahaemolyticus have been widely used as criteria in identifying pathogenic isolates. However, few studies have been carried out to assess the differences in biochemical characteristics of V. parahaemolyticus isolates from human and environmental sources. We compared the biochemical profiles obtained by the characterization of V. parahaemolyticus isolates from human infections and the marine environment using the API 20E system. Environmental and clinical isolates showed significant differences in the gelatin and arabinose tests. Additionally, clinical isolates were correctly identified according to the API 20E profile using 0.85% NaCl diluent, but they presented nonspecific profiles with 2% NaCl diluent. In contrast, use of 2% NaCl diluent facilitated correct identification of the environmental isolates. Clinical isolates showed significant differences in up to five biochemical tests with respect to the API 20E database. The API 20E system is widely used in routine identification of bacteria in clinical laboratories, and this discrepancy in an important number of biochemical tests may lead to misidentification of V. parahaemolyticus infection.     

Comparison of API 20NE and Biolog GN identification systems assessed by techniques of multivariate analyses.

The increasing use of commercial multitest systems for identification of environmental bacteria creates the problem of how to compare the identification results obtained from different systems. The limited use of species designations in such comparisons is caused by low usage of environmental bacteria in the development of commercial identification schemes. Two multivariate statistical methods, the Mantel's test and the co-inertia analysis, were applied to analyze data derived from the Biolog GN and the API 20NE systems of identification for 50 environmental bacterial strains. We found these two methods to be useful for revealing the relationship between the two sets of numerical taxonomic traits. Both of these methods showed that the distances according to the Biolog GN results between the studied strains were related to those derived from the API 20NE results, despite the differences in the test sets of the two systems. In addition, the co-inertia analysis allowed us to visualise the relationships between classifications of strains derived from the two identification systems and, simultaneously, to estimate the contribution of particular tests to the differentiation of bacterial strains.     

Occurrence of virulence factors among human intestinal enterococcal isolates

AIMS: The aim of this study was to investigate the frequency of enterococcal virulence factors among human intestinal Enterococcus faecalis strains and to find out whether the pattern differs from that seen in published reports on food and clinical isolates. METHODS AND RESULTS: The E. faecalis isolates were cultured from human faecal samples obtained from five ulcerative colitis patients in remission phase. The species identification was based on API120 strips and species-specific PCR primers. The isolates were further characterized using the pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. The presence of seven different known enterococcal virulence factors among the confirmed E. faecalis isolates were screened using PCR techniques and published primers. CONCLUSIONS: Among the 35 isolates representing nine different pulsotypes the most frequent virulence factors were cpd (33 isolates), agg (25 isolates), gelE (22 isolates) and esp (15 isolates). No complete sets of genes associated for the production of functional cytolysin were encountered indicating that intestinal enterococci may differ in this respect from clinical strains. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: According to the results, the commensal enterococcal strains appear to differ from clinical isolates in their complement of presumed virulence factors.     

Misidentification of Aeromonas veronii biovar sobria as Vibrio alginolyticus by the Vitek system

AIMS: To find the cause of misidentification of aeromonads when using the Vitek system. METHODS AND RESULTS: Two Aeromonas veronii biovar sobria isolates were misidentified as Vibrio alginolyticus by the Vitek system. Both strains' identification was confirmed by biochemical testing, API 20E/20NE kits and/or 16S RFLP analysis. Thirty-one known Aeromonas species were tested by the Vitek system using 0.45 and 0.85% saline in the suspension medium. It was not clear whether low salinity causes misidentification of Aeromonas species more frequently. CONCLUSIONS: The specified reaction time may be inappropriately short for some critical biochemical tests of some strains. An ingenious reading strategy regarding incubation time is necessary to improve identification of Aeromonas species by the Vitek system. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: To our knowledge, this is the first report of misidentification of A. veronii biovar sobria as V. alginolyticus in the Vitek system.     

Identification of dimethyl disulfide-forming bacteria isolated from activated sludge

Twenty-four strains with high dimethyl disulfide (DMDS)-forming ability were isolated from activated sludge and identified to the genus level. These bacteria were classified into four groups (A, B, C, and D) by the API ZYM System (API System S.A., Montalieu, France). Group A (three strains) was identified as genus Lactobacillus by the API 20B System, by the method of Cowan and Steel, and by production of lactic acid as confirmed by gas-liquid chromatography. Group B (eight strains) was identified as genus Corynebacterium by API 20B and the Cowan and Steel method. Group C (one strain) was suggested to belong to genus Corynebacterium by the API 20B System. Group D (12 strains) was identified as genus Pseudomonas or Alcaligenes by the API 20B System, as genus Alcaligenes by the Cowan and Steel method, and as Achromobacter group Vd by the API 20NE System. However, on the basis of guanine-plus-cytosine contents in DNA and form of flagella, these strains were identified as genus Pseudomonas. Formation of DMDS from DL-methionine and S-methyl-L-cysteine was tested. DMDS-forming bacteria isolated from activated sludge formed DMDS from both precursors. In genus Pseudomonas, P. aeruginosa could not form DMDS from either precursor, but P. acidovorans, P. alcaligenes, P. pseudoalcaligenes, and P. testosteroni formed DMDS. In genus Alcaligenes, A. denitrificans subsp. xylosoxydans, A. denitrificans subsp. denitrificans, A. faecalis, and A. odorans formed DMDS from both precursors. Achromobacter group Vd formed DMDS from S-methyl-L-cysteine, but could not from DL-methionine.     

Phenotypic characterization of raw milk-associated psychrotrophic bacteria

Among the 68 isolates, selected from 13 raw-milk samples in Finland (that originate from farm, truck or silo tanks), 60 (88%) were psychrotrophs. All the isolates were characterized by the determination of their spoilage and phenotypic features: proteolytic and lipolytic activities, the production of lecithinases and hemolytic factors were considered. Phenotypic characterization of the isolates was mainly performed with API 20NE and BIOLOG GN2 identification systems; the results were system-dependent, although the presence of representatives of the Pseudomonas genus (for the majority of the isolates) was suggested by both systems. The results of the numerical profile analyses by API 20NE proposed that some strains might be members of Stenotrophomonas, Burkholderia and Acinetobacter genera; however, the identity of many isolates remained doubtful or controversial.     

Identification of respiratory isolates of Stenotrophomonas maltophilia by commercial biochemical systems and species-specific PCR

One hundred strains of Stenotrophomonas maltophilia isolates from respiratory specimens were biochemically identified using the API 20NE strip and the VITEK2 ID-GNB card. The identification was confirmed by a species-specific PCR using two primers specific for the 23S rRNA gene. The API 20NE showed only 1 strain with "low discrimination" whereas the VITEK2 gave 12. In any case, the two biochemical systems showed good reliability compared to SS-PCR.     

Identification of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in water-bottling plants on the basis of procedures included in ISO 16266:2006

ISO 16266:2006 provides a standardized procedure for the isolation and identification of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in waters. In some cases the method described in this ISO is not conclusive enough to confirm or discard the presence of this opportunistic human pathogen. In this study the capacity of the procedure described in ISO 16266:2006 to identify presumptive P. aeruginosa isolates was evaluated.Forty-one presumptive P. aeruginosa strains, previously isolated from water-bottling plants following ISO 16266:2006, were submitted to all the tests recommended by ISO 16266:2006 (Cetrimide agar with nalidixic acid, King B agar, Acetamide broth and Oxidase test). Additional tests that have been widely used for the identification of P. aeruginosa were also performed (Asparagine broth and King A agar). Furthermore, we also conducted the non-compulsory ISO 16266:2006 assay to study the capacity of the strains to grow at 4 °C and 42 °C. Finally, all the strains were biochemically phenotyped with PhP-48 plates (Bactus AB, Sweden) and API 20NE galleries (Biomérieux, France), and their 16 rRNA gene was sequenced.ISO 16266:2006 correctly identified 27 out of 29 genotypically confirmed P. aeruginosa isolates, although two false negative identifications were obtained.Growth in Asparagine broth should be discarded as a confirmative test as it showed false negatives and false positives. In contrast, API 20NE galleries correctly identified all the confirmed isolates.King A medium and growth tests at 4 °C and 42 °C correctly discriminated all the studied strains, even the two that were not identified with the basic ISO 16266:2006 tests.Given that King A medium and growth tests at 4 °C and 42 °C are straightforward, rapid, and inexpensive, it is strongly recommended that they be used for routine confirmation of P. aeruginosa when applying ISO 16266:2006.