The elongation factor Tu from Escherichia coli, aminoacyl-tRNA, and guanosine tetraphosphate form a ternary complex which is bound by programmed ribosomes

The interaction of the Escherichia coli elongation factor Tu guanosine tetraphosphate complex (EF-Tu ppGpp) with aminoacyl-tRNAs(aa-tRNA) was reinvestigated by gel filtration and hydrolysis protection experiments. These experiments show that EF-Tu X ppGpp like EF-Tu X GDP (Pingoud, A., Block, W., Wittinghofer, A., Wolf, H. & Fischer, E. (1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 11261-11267) forms a fairly stable complex with Phe-tRNAPhe, KAss being 0.6 X 10(5) M-1 at 25 degrees C. The binding of the EF-Tu X ppGpp X aa-tRNA complex to programmed ribosomes was investigated by a centrifugation technique. It is shown that this complex is bound codon-specific with KAss = 3 X 10(7) M-1 at 0 degrees C and that it stimulates peptidyl transfer. A numerical estimation of the intracellular concentration of EF-Tu X GTP X aa-tRNA and EF-Tu X ppGpp X aa-tRNA during normal growth and under the stringent response indicates that ppGpp accumulation does affect the EF-Tu X GTP X aa-tRNA concentration but does not lead to major depletion of this pool. Furthermore, due to the higher affinity of EF-Tu X GTP to aa-tRNA and of the ternary complex EF-Tu X GTP X aa-tRNA to the ribosome, EF-Tu X ppGpp X aa-tRNA binding to the ribosome is not significant. According to our measurements and calculations, therefore, a direct participation of EF-Tu in slowing down the rate of protein biosynthesis and improving its accuracy during amino acid starvation is not obvious.     

The reaction of ribosomes with elongation factor Tu.GTP complexes. Aminoacyl-tRNA-independent reactions in the elongation cycle determine the accuracy of protein synthesis

The fidelity of protein synthesis depends on the rate constants for the reaction of ribosomes with ternary complexes of elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), GTP, and aminoacyl (aa)-tRNA. By measuring the rate constants for the reaction of poly(U)-programmed ribosomes with a binary complex of elongation factor (EF-Tu) and GTP we have shown that two of the key rate constants in the former reaction are determined exclusively by ribosome-EF-Tu interactions and are not affected by the aa-tRNA. These are the rate constant for GTP hydrolysis, which plays an important role in the fidelity of ternary complex selection by the ribosome, and the rate constant for EF-Tu.GDP dissociation from the ribosome, which plays an equally important role in subsequent proofreading of the aa-tRNA. We conclude that the fidelities of ternary complex selection and proofreading are fundamentally dependent on ribosome-EF-Tu interactions. These interactions determine the absolute value of the rate constants for GTP hydrolysis and EF-Tu.GDP dissociation. The ribosome then uses these rate constants as internal standards to measure, respectively, the rate constants for ternary complex and aa-tRNA dissociation from the ribosome. These rates, in turn, are highly dependent on whether the ternary complex and aa-tRNA are cognate or near-cognate to the codon being translated.     

The influence of the concentrations of elongation factors and tRNAs on the dynamics and accuracy of protein biosynthesis

Computer simulations of the elongation cycle of bacterial protein biosynthesis demonstrate that the accuracy of protein biosynthesis cannot be explained by a mechanism which involves only an initial selection and a proofreading reaction. It is suggested that only a combination of initial selection, proofreading and a retardation of non-cognate flows at the level of the EF-Tu-catalyzed GTPase reaction and the peptidyl transfer can guarantee sufficient accuracy at reasonable costs. According to this view the ribosome functions as an allosteric enzyme which, in both its affinity and enzymatic activity, responds optimally only to the cognate substrate. Detailed calculations show, furthermore, that increasing the concentration of EF-G and EF-Ts above the level prevailing in vivo only slightly increases the rate of elongation. In contrast, increasing the concentration of EF-Tu over aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) leads to a sharp decline in the rate of elongation. While varying the concentration of EF-G has no effect on the accuracy of protein synthesis, excess of EF-Tu over aminoacyl-tRNA leads to a large increase in accuracy. These results suggest a mechanism by which the accuracy of protein biosynthesis is preserved during amino acid starvation.     

Guanosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) as an analog of GTP in protein biosynthesis. The effects of temperature and polycations on the accuracy of initial recognition of aminoacyl-tRNA ternary complexes by ribosomes

Guanosine 5'-O-(3-thio)triphosphate (GTP gamma S) is a good analog of GTP in the reactions leading to the formation of a peptide bond in protein biosynthesis. It forms binary and ternary complexes with elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), and with EF-Tu and aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA). In addition, it stimulates aa-tRNA binding to ribosomes. Although GTP gamma S hydrolysis is more than three orders of magnitude slower than GTP hydrolysis, both reactions are dependent on the formation of a noncovalent complex (RS X TC) between mRNA-programmed ribosomes and ternary complex, and the complexes resulting from that hydrolysis are intermediates in peptide formation. The rate of dissociation of the ribosome X EF-Tu X GTP gamma S X aa-tRNA complex was determined from the rate of labeled peptide formation in the presence of an unlabeled ternary complex chase. This rate (2.2 X 10(-3) s-1) is similar to that determined previously (Thompson, R.C., and Karim, A.M. (1982) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 79, 4922-4926) from the progress of GTP gamma S hydrolysis. The effects of temperature and polycation concentration on this rate constant and that for GTP gamma S hydrolysis are reported. The rate constants measured are consistent with a kinetic rather than thermodynamic limit on the accuracy of the aa-tRNA selection in vivo.     

Recognition of aminoacyl-tRNA: a common molecular mechanism revealed by cryo-EM

The accuracy of ribosomal translation is achieved by an initial selection and a proofreading step, mediated by EF-Tu, which forms a ternary complex with aminoacyl(aa)-tRNA. To study the binding modes of different aa-tRNAs, we compared cryo-EM maps of the kirromycin-stalled ribosome bound with ternary complexes containing Phe-tRNA^Phe, Trp-tRNA^Trp, or Leu-tRNA^LeuI. The three maps suggest a common binding manner of cognate aa-tRNAs in their specific binding with both the ribosome and EF-Tu. All three aa-tRNAs have the same ‘loaded spring' conformation with a kink and twist between the D-stem and anticodon stem. The three complexes are similarly integrated in an interaction network, extending from the anticodon loop through h44 and protein S12 to the EF-Tu-binding CCA end of aa-tRNA, proposed to signal cognate codon–anticodon interaction to the GTPase centre and tune the accuracy of aa-tRNA selection.     

Recognition and selection of tRNA in translation

Aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) is delivered to the ribosome in a ternary complex with elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) and GTP. The stepwise movement of aa-tRNA from EF-Tu into the ribosomal A site entails a number of intermediates. The ribosome recognizes aa-tRNA through shape discrimination of the codon-anticodon duplex and regulates the rates of GTP hydrolysis by EF-Tu and aa-tRNA accommodation in the A site by an induced fit mechanism. Recent results of kinetic measurements, ribosome crystallography, single molecule FRET measurements, and cryo-electron microscopy suggest the mechanism of tRNA recognition and selection.     

Possible evolution of factors involved in protein biosynthesis.

The elongation factors of protein biosynthesis are well preserved through out evolution. They catalyze the elongation phase of protein biosynthesis, where on the ribosome amino acids are added one at a time to a growing peptide according to the genetic information transcribed into mRNA. Elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) provides the binding of aminoacylated tRNA to the ribosome and protects the aminoester bond against hydrolysis until a correct match between the codon on mRNA and the anticodon on tRNA can be achieved. Elongation factor G (EF-G) supports the translocation of tRNAs and of mRNA on the ribosome so that a new codon can be exposed for decoding. Both these factors are GTP binding proteins, and as such exist in an active form with GTP and an inactive form with GDP bound to the nucleotide binding domain. Elongation factor Ts (EF-Ts) will catalyze the exchange of nucleotide on EF-Tu. This review describes structural work on EF-Tu performed in our laboratory over the last eight years. The structural results provide a rather complete picture of the major structural forms of EF-Tu, including the so called ternary complex of aa-tRNA:EF-Tu:GTP. The structural comparison of this ternary complex with the structure of EF-G:GDP displays an unexpected macromolecular mimicry, where three domains of EF-G mimick the shape of the tRNA in the ternary complex. This observation has initiated much speculation on the evolution of all factors involved in protein synthesis, as well as on the details of the ribosomal function in one part of elongation.     

Effect of Mg2+ concentration, polyamines, streptomycin, and mutations in ribosomal proteins on the accuracy of the two-step selection of aminoacyl-tRNAs in protein biosynthesis

Discrimination against the binding of noncognate aminoacyl (aa)-tRNAs by mRNA-programmed ribosomes is the outcome of two selection steps, one involving an aa-tRNA.EFTu.GTP complex, which occurs prior to and includes GTP hydrolysis, the other involving the aa-tRNA alone, which follows GTP hydrolysis. Conditions which lead to errors in protein synthesis have been found to influence the accuracy of one or both selection steps in a system measuring poly(U)-directed binding of Leu-tRNA2Leu. Streptomycin has a large effect only on the discrimination process following GTP hydrolysis, but the other pertubations of recognition studied, high [Mg2+], polyamines, the strA1 and ram1 mutations, affect both discrimination processes. The general result is consistent with the view that proofreading of aa-tRNA by ribosomes for the most part uses the same specificity determinants used in the initial selection of a ternary complex.     

Evolutionary optimization of speed and accuracy of decoding on the ribosome

Speed and accuracy of protein synthesis are fundamental parameters for the fitness of living cells, the quality control of translation, and the evolution of ribosomes. The ribosome developed complex mechanisms that allow for a uniform recognition and selection of any cognate aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) and discrimination against any near-cognate aa-tRNA, regardless of the nature or position of the mismatch. This review describes the principles of the selection-kinetic partitioning and induced fit-and discusses the relationship between speed and accuracy of decoding, with a focus on bacterial translation. The translational machinery apparently has evolved towards high speed of translation at the cost of fidelity.     

New antibiotic that acts specifically on the GTP-bound form of elongation factor Tu.

The new thiazolyl peptide antibiotic GE2270 A, isolated from Planobispora rosea strain ATCC 53773, is shown to inhibit bacterial protein biosynthesis in vitro by affecting specifically the GTP-bound form of elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu). The 'off' rate of EF-Tu.GTP is slowed down 400-fold, locking GTP on EF-Tu, whereas EF-Tu.GDP is unaffected. Therefore, on the EF-Tu.guanine nucleotide interaction, GE2270 A mimicks the effect of aa-tRNA. In line with this, the binding of aa-tRNA to EF-Tu.GTP is hindered by the antibiotic, as shown by the absence of a stable ternary complex and the inhibition of the enzymatic binding of aa-tRNA to the ribosome. This blocks the elongation cycle. GE2270 A does not essentially modify the intrinsic GTPase activity of EF-Tu, but impairs the stimulation by ribosomes of this reaction. The negative effect of GE2270 A on the EF-Tu.GTP interaction with aa-tRNA bears similarities with that of the structurally unrelated pulvomycin, whereas marked differences were found by comparing the effects of these two antibiotics on EF-Tu.GDP. This work emphasizes the varieties of the transitional conformations which tune the EF-Tu interaction with GTP and GDP.     

Structural insights into cognate versus near-cognate discrimination during decoding

The structural basis of the tRNA selection process is investigated by cryo-electron microscopy of ribosomes programmed with UGA codons and incubated with ternary complex (TC) containing the near-cognate Trp-tRNA(Trp) in the presence of kirromycin. Going through more than 350 000 images and employing image classification procedures, we find ～8% in which the TC is bound to the ribosome. The reconstructed 3D map provides a means to characterize the arrangement of the near-cognate aa-tRNA with respect to elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) and the ribosome, as well as the domain movements of the ribosome. One of the interesting findings is that near-cognate tRNA's acceptor stem region is flexible and CCA end becomes disordered. The data bring direct structural insights into the induced-fit mechanism of decoding by the ribosome, as the analysis of the interactions between small and large ribosomal subunit, aa-tRNA and EF-Tu and comparison with the cognate case (UGG codon) offers clues on how the conformational signals conveyed to the GTPase differ in the two cases.     

Correlation between RNA synthesis and basal level guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate in relaxed mutants of Escherichia coli

Through the use of a new nucleotide extraction procedure, we had previously shown that relaxed mutants of Escherichia coli exhibit a unique response to amino acid starvation (Lagosky, P. A., and Chang, F. N. (1980) J. Bacteriol. 144, 499-508). The basal level amounts of guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp) in both relA and phenotypically relaxed relA+ rplK (relC) strains were shown to decrease at the onset of amino acid limitation and to remain severely depressed throughout the course of the starvation. Upon resupplementation of amino acid-starved relaxed mutants, the production of ppGpp resumes and results in the temporary overaccumulation of this nucleotide beyond its original basal level amount. We now show that the basal level ppGpp content of relaxed bacteria, as well as its subsequent fluctuations in response to amino acid starvation, is inversely correlated with the initial rates of RNA synthesis in these strains. The ability of ppGpp to control the rate of protein synthesis in relA mutants was also examined. It was observed that ppGpp had no apparent direct effect on the initial rates of protein synthesis in relA mutants. The constant inverse correlation which exists between ppGpp content in relA mutants, and their rates of RNa synthesis provide evidence which indicates that basal level ppGpp synthesis has definite physiological significance. It also suggests that the synthesis of basal level ppGpp might be an absolute requirement needed for normal bacterial growth.     

Thiostrepton inhibition of tRNA delivery to the ribosome

Ribosome-stimulated hydrolysis of guanosine-5'-triphosphate (GTP) by guanosine triphosphatase (GTPase) translation factors drives protein synthesis by the ribosome. Allosteric coupling of GTP hydrolysis by elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) at the ribosomal GTPase center to messenger RNA (mRNA) codon:aminoacyl-transfer RNA (aa-tRNA) anticodon recognition at the ribosomal decoding site is essential for accurate and rapid aa-tRNA selection. Here we use single-molecule methods to investigate the mechanism of action of the antibiotic thiostrepton and show that the GTPase center of the ribosome has at least two discrete functions during aa-tRNA selection: binding of EF-Tu(GTP) and stimulation of GTP hydrolysis by the factor. We separate these two functions of the GTPase center and assign each to distinct, conserved structural regions of the ribosome. The data provide a specific model for the coupling between the decoding site and the GTPase center during aa-tRNA selection as well as a general mechanistic model for ribosome-stimulated GTP hydrolysis by GTPase translation factors.     

Induced fit in initial selection and proofreading of aminoacyl-tRNA on the ribosome.

The fidelity of aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) selection by the bacterial ribosome is determined by initial selection before and proofreading after GTP hydrolysis by elongation factor Tu. Here we report the rate constants of A-site binding of a near-cognate aa-tRNA. The comparison with the data for cognate aa-tRNA reveals an additional, important contribution to aa-tRNA discrimination of conformational coupling by induced fit. It is found that two rearrangement steps that limit the chemical reactions of A-site binding, i.e. GTPase activation (preceding GTP hydrolysis) and A-site accommodation (preceding peptide bond formation), are substantially faster for cognate than for near-cognate aa-tRNA. This suggests an induced-fit mechanism of aa-tRNA discrimination on the ribosome that operates in both initial selection and proofreading. It is proposed that the cognate codon-anticodon interaction, more efficiently than the near-cognate one, induces a particular conformation of the decoding center of 16S rRNA, which in turn promotes GTPase activation and A-site accommodation of aa-tRNA, thereby accelerating the chemical steps. As kinetically favored incorporation of the correct substrate has also been suggested for DNA and RNA polymerases, the present findings indicate that induced fit may contribute to the fidelity of template-programed systems in general.     

The relA/spoT-Homologous Gene in Streptomyces coelicolor Encodes Both Ribosome-Dependent (p)ppGppSynthesizing and -Degrading Activities

Streptomyces coelicolor (p)ppGpp synthetase (Rel protein) belongs to the RelA and SpoT (RelA/SpoT) family, which is involved in (p)ppGpp metabolism and the stringent response. The potential functions of the rel gene have been examined. S. coelicolor Rel has been shown to be ribosome associated, and its activity in vitro is ribosome dependent. Analysis in vivo of the active recombinant protein in well-defined Escherichia coli relA and relA/spoT mutants provides evidence that S. coelicolor Rel, like native E. coli RelA, is functionally ribosome associated, resulting in ribosome-dependent (p)ppGpp accumulation upon amino acid deprivation. Expression of an S. coelicolor C-terminally deleted Rel, comprised of only the first 489 amino acids, catalyzes a ribosome-independent (p)ppGpp formation, in the same manner as the E. coli truncated RelA protein (1 to 455 amino acids). An E. coli relA spoT double deletion mutant transformed with S. coelicolor rel gene suppresses the phenotype associated with (p)ppGpp deficiency. However, in such a strain, a rel-mediated (p)ppGpp response apparently occurs after glucose depletion, but only in the absence of amino acids. Analysis of ppGpp decay in E. coli expressing the S. coelicolor rel gene suggests that it also encodes a (p)ppGpp-degrading activity. By deletion analysis, the catalytic domains of S. coelicolor Rel for (p)ppGpp synthesis and degradation have been located within its N terminus (amino acids 267 to 453 and 93 to 397, respectively). In addition, E. coli relA in an S. coelicolor rel deletion mutant restores actinorhodine production and shows a nearly normal morphological differentiation, as does the wild-type rel gene, which is in agreement with the proposed role of (p)ppGpp nucleotides in antibiotic biosynthesis.     

Incorporation of aminoacyl-tRNA into the ribosome as seen by cryo-electron microscopy

Aminoacyl-tRNAs (aa-tRNAs) are delivered to the ribosome as part of the ternary complex of aa-tRNA, elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) and GTP. Here, we present a cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) study, at a resolution of approximately 9 A, showing that during the incorporation of the aa-tRNA into the 70S ribosome of Escherichia coli, the flexibility of aa-tRNA allows the initial codon recognition and its accommodation into the ribosomal A site. In addition, a conformational change observed in the GTPase-associated center (GAC) of the ribosomal 50S subunit may provide the mechanism by which the ribosome promotes a relative movement of the aa-tRNA with respect to EF-Tu. This relative rearrangement seems to facilitate codon recognition by the incoming aa-tRNA, and to provide the codon-anticodon recognition-dependent signal for the GTPase activity of EF-Tu. From these new findings we propose a mechanism that can explain the sequence of events during the decoding of mRNA on the ribosome.     

Replication of lambda plasmid in amino acid-starved strains of Escherichia coli.

We found that lambda plasmid replication, as measured by the increase in plasmid content per bacterial mass, proceeds for hours in an amino acid-starved, relaxed mutant of Escherichia coli K-12, whereas is inhibited in its wild-type stringent partner. Replication of lambda plasmid in amino acid-starved, relaxed cells reveals absolute lambda O dependence and is not inhibited by chloramphenicol at 200 micrograms/ml. The replication also occurs in wild-type cells treated with chloramphenicol. We conclude that lambda plasmid replication is under stringent control, probably as a result of the action of ppGpp, the signal for the stringent response, on RNA polymerase.     

Conformational Sampling of Aminoacyl-tRNA during Selection on the Bacterial Ribosome

Aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA), in a ternary complex with elongation factor-Tu and GTP, enters the aminoacyl (A) site of the ribosome via a multi-step, mRNA codon-dependent mechanism. This process gives rise to the preferential selection of cognate aa-tRNAs for each mRNA codon and, consequently, the fidelity of gene expression. The ribosome actively facilitates this process by recognizing structural features of the correct substrate, initiated in its decoding site, to accelerate the rates of elongation factor-Tu-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis and ribosome-catalyzed peptide bond formation. Here, the order and timing of conformational events underpinning the aa-tRNA selection process were investigated from multiple structural perspectives using single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The time resolution of these measurements was extended to 2.5 and 10 ms, a 10- to 50-fold improvement over previous studies. The data obtained reveal that aa-tRNA undergoes fast conformational sampling within the A site, both before and after GTP hydrolysis. This suggests that the alignment of aa-tRNA with respect to structural elements required for irreversible GTP hydrolysis and peptide bond formation plays a key role in the fidelity mechanism. These observations provide direct evidence that the selection process is governed by motions of aa-tRNA within the A site, adding new insights into the physical framework that helps explain how the rates of GTP hydrolysis and peptide bond formation are controlled by the mRNA codon and other fidelity determinants within the system.     

Interaction of mitochondrial elongation factor Tu with aminoacyl-tRNA and elongation factor Ts

Elongation factor (EF) Tu promotes the binding of aminoacyl-tRNA (aa-tRNA) to the acceptor site of the ribosome. This process requires the formation of a ternary complex (EF-Tu.GTP.aa-tRNA). EF-Tu is released from the ribosome as an EF-Tu.GDP complex. Exchange of GDP for GTP is carried out through the formation of a complex with EF-Ts (EF-Tu.Ts). Mammalian mitochondrial EF-Tu (EF-Tu(mt)) differs from the corresponding prokaryotic factors in having a much lower affinity for guanine nucleotides. To further understand the EF-Tu(mt) subcycle, the dissociation constants for the release of aa-tRNA from the ternary complex (K(tRNA)) and for the dissociation of the EF-Tu.Ts(mt) complex (K(Ts)) were investigated. The equilibrium dissociation constant for the ternary complex was 18 +/- 4 nm, which is close to that observed in the prokaryotic system. The kinetic dissociation rate constant for the ternary complex was 7.3 x 10(-)(4) s(-)(1), which is essentially equivalent to that observed for the ternary complex in Escherichia coli. The binding of EF-Tu(mt) to EF-Ts(mt) is mutually exclusive with the formation of the ternary complex. K(Ts) was determined by quantifying the effects of increasing concentrations of EF-Ts(mt) on the amount of ternary complex formed with EF-Tu(mt). The value obtained for K(Ts) (5.5 +/- 1.3 nm) is comparable to the value of K(tRNA).