The cytolytic T lymphocyte response to trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic cells. II. Evidence for antigen-specific suppressor T cells.

The subcutaneous administration of trinitrophenyl (TNP)-coupled syngeneic cells 7 days before co-culture with TNP-coupled syngeneic stimulator cells results in increased cytolytic activity. This augmented cytotoxic response has been shown to be dependent, at least partially, on radioresistant "helper" T cells. In this paper we have demonstrated that TNBS-generated suppressor T cells that are capable of suppressing contact sensitivity can specifically suppress the augmented response seen after subcutaneous priming. The i.v. administration of TNP-coupled cells results in priming of the recipient; however, if cells from these animals are transferred to a second recipient, there is evidence of suppressor activity. Thus, the cytotoxic T lymphocyte response is controlled by the same type of complex interactions previously demonstrated for humoral and delayed-type hypersensitivity responses.     

The effects of sodium metaperiodate on T and B lymphocytes.

The differential mitogenic response of T and B lymphocytes to sodium metaperiodate has been investigated. It was found that periodate treatment leads to lymphocyte stimulation in spleen cells from Balb/c mice but not in spleen cells from the congenitally athymic nu/nu mice. In addition, treatment of Balb/c spleen cells with anti-θ serum plus complement lowers the mitogenic response to periodate and to concanavalin A without affecting the response to lipopolysaccharide. These results suggest a requirement for the presence of T lymphocytes in the initiation of a response to periodate. Spleen cells from nude mice also react with periodate, and their ability to respond to B cell mitogens is impaired after treatment with the chemical reagent.     

Adherent cell function in murine T lymphocyte antigen recognition. I. A. macrophage-dependent T cell proliferation assay in the mouse.

The data in this report describe a T cell proliferation assay with nylon wool column-purified murine lymph node lymphocyte from animals immunized by footpad injection of antigen in CFA. It was found that the in vitro immune response of sensitized T cells to soluble protein antigens was functionally dependent on the presence of adherent cells, more specifically macrophages, at all concentrations of in vitro antigen challenge. The response was due to T cells in that cytotoxic treatment of the immune lymphocyte cells with anti-Thy 1.2 serum and complement effectively eliminated the antigen-specific DNA synthetic responses. The antigen-specific proliferation of murine lymphocytes depleted of adhereent cells could not be reconstituted with either guinea pig macrophages nor murine fibroblasts, indicating the existence of species and cell type specificity. In contrast to previous observations in the guinea pig, soluble products of cultured adherent cells could at least partially replace the function of intact macrophages in the response to antigen.     

Cell-cell interactions in the T cell proliferative response. I. Analysis of the cell types involved and evidence for nonspecific T cell recruitment

In the antigen-induced T cell proliferative response, it has been firmly established that antigen-specific T cell activation signals are provided by a specialized antigen-presenting cell (APC). However, the number of responding T cell populations involved has not been clearly delineated. This problem can be analyzed by plotting the logarithm of the number of cultured cells against the logarithm of the response. This yields a straight line, the slope of which indicates the minimum number of interacting cell populations that are required to give the response. In the antigen-induced T cell proliferative response, this number is 3. Based on their ability to shift the slopes of the log cell number-log response line, two of the populations were identified to be T cells. The third cell, which was present in irradiated spleens, possessed certain properties of the APC. Of the two T cells, one was antigen-specific and the other could come from normal unprimed animals. The frequency of antigen-specific proliferating T cells in primed animals was estimated to be only 1 in 1.3 x 10(3), and a large proportion of the proliferation was shown to be due to unprimed cells. Furthermore, without the need to use antigen-pulsed macrophages, this slope analysis demonstrated convincingly that the successful interaction between APCs and proliferating T lymphocytes is determined by products of the I-region immune response genes.     

Regulatory function of T lymphocytes in the immune response to polyvinyl pyrrolidone. I. Two categories of suppressor T cells.

The regulation of antibody response of mice to polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP) was investigated using three preparations of PVP (K90, K30, and K15) differing from each other in molecular weight. The immunogenicity of PVP was higher as the molecular weight increased. The depletion of thymus-derived cells resulted in the augmentation of anti-PVP response. On the other hand, the response of intact mice to the most immunogenic PVP (K90) was suppressed more or less by the injection of any preparation of PVP 4 days prior to K90. This was most pronounced when the smallest PVP (K15) was preinjected. The suppression, however, was not observed in thymectomized-irradiated-bone marrow reconstituted mice.These results indicated that anti-PVP response was regulated by two different categories of thymus-derived cells, that is, “intrinsic” and “induced” suppressor cells. The activity of the latter was transferrable, PVP-specific, and eliminated by anti-Thy 1 serum and complement. In addition, the mean affinity of anti-PVP plaque-forming antibodies was found to be reduced by the action of “induced” suppressor cells.     

T lymphocyte heterogeneity in the rat. III. Autoreactive T cells are activated by B cells

Evidence has been presented to show that CD4+ autoreactive T cell lines (ATs)2 in the rat require periodic stimulation with syngeneic spleen cells for in vitro proliferation. This proliferation can be blocked by treatment of the stimulator (spleen) cells with mAb to Ia antigens. Although ATs are Ia+ and can activate the allogeneic MLR, they fail to be autostimulatory. Fractionation of the spleen cells revealed that ATs can be stimulated with B cells and not by macrophages, although the latter were efficient in several accessory cell functions, including antigen presentation, lectin-dependent T cell activation and allogenic MLR response. Moreover, B cells proliferated and differentiated in response to AT cells. These data are compatible with a model in which ATs respond to hitherto undetermined B cell membrane antigen(s) in association with MHC class II antigens. These results may have important implications in understanding autoimmune responses.     

Independent analysis of T helper and T killer cell function in young and old NZB mice.

With age, NZB mice lose their ability to develop a cytotoxic response after alloimmunization in vitro. This decline is shown to coincide with a diminution of T-helper cell activity as assessed by proliferation in mixed lymphocyte culture or in response to PHA. When cytotoxic T cell precursors are activated with the polyclonal activator Con A, there is no reduction in the number of cytotoxic effector T cells that develop. No autoreactive cytotoxic cells are seen in Con A-activated cultures. These findings are related to previous work on cell-mediated immunity in NZB and B/W mice.     

Functional heterogeneity among the T-derived lymphocytes of the mouse. VII. Conversion of T1 cells to T2 cells by antigen.

The T1 subpopulation of peripheral T cells was defined in mice by its short half life, insensitivity to anti-thymocyte sera (ATS) in vivo, and slow kinetics of response to antigen. The T2 subpopulation was defined by its long life time, elimination by ATS in vivo, and rapid response to antigen. Mice containing only T1-type T cells were constructed by adult thymectomy (ATx) followed immediately by the elimination of T2 cells by ATS treatment. Immunization of these mice with SRBC led to the production of memory helper cells in the T2 subpopulation. This process depended on the presence of T1 cells and for the most part required SRBC immunization, although a few SRBC-specific T2 cells reappeared in the mice in the absence of antigen. We conclude that T1 cells can give rise to T2 cells in an antigen-driven step and that the two populations correspond to virgin and memory T cells, respectively.     

Functional heterongeneity among the T-derived lymphocytes of the mouse. VI. Memory T cells stored in the T2 subpopulation.

Memory T cells were demonstrated in mice which were the precursors for cells causing sheep red blood cell-(SRBC) specific helper activity in the in vitro response of spleen cells to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-SRBC. These memory cells were distinguished from the effectors of helper activity generated during the primary response and were shown to belong to the T2 subpopulation of peripheral T cells on the basis of 1) their rapid response to a challenge with SRBC, 2) their long lifetime, and 3) their sensitivity to small in vivo doses of anti-thymocyte serum.     

Cellular basis of tolerance to serum albumin in adult mice. I. characterization of T suppressor and T helper cells.

The surface markers and size of suppressor cells were determined in adult (BALB/c x C57BL/Ka)F1 mice which were tolerized with a single injection of deaggregated bovine serum albumin (BSA). Suppressor cells from the spleens of tolerazided donors were assayed in a cell transfer system in which graded numbers of cells were injected into irradiated syngeneic mice along with limiting numbers of T cells primed to BSA and an excess of B cells primed to DNP-BSA. Adoptive hosts were challenged with DNP-BSA in saline, and the anti-DNP response was measured. Suppressor cells were antigen specific as shown by the inhibitory activity of BSA-tolerant spleen cells on the response to DNP-BSA, but not to DNP-BGG. Suppressor cells were eliminated by in vitro treatment with anti-Thy 1.2, anti-Ly-2.2, anti-I-J subregion antisera and C, but not with anti-Ly-1 or anti-I-A subregion antisera. Neither unprimed nor primed helper T cells were detected in the spleen of tolerized donors after in vitro treatment with anti-Ly-2.2 antisera. Both helper and suppressor T cells from the spleens of primed or tolerized donors, respectively, showed a rapid sedimentation velocity (S greater than 3.7 mm/hr).     

HgCl2-induced perturbation of the T cell network in experimental allergic encephalomyelitis. I. In vitro characterization of T cells involved.

Mercuric chloride (HgCl2) induces in Lewis (LEW) rats a non-antigen-specific immunosuppression and is able to down-modulate experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in about 70% of the rats. The aim of the present study was to determine the frequencies of lymph node cells involved in the proliferative response to myelin basic protein in rats injected with HgCl2 and immunized with myelin by using limiting dilution analysis (LDA). Highly frequent CD8+ T suppressor cells and at least 10-fold less frequent protein basic-specific T helper cells were detected in these rats. A third cell type allowing the proliferative response of Th cells in spite of Ts cells was also demonstrated. These cells, which could act as contrasuppressor cells, were CD4+ and adhered to Vicia villosa lectin; their frequency was in the same range as that of T helper cells. These data illustrate the potential role of different levels of T cell immunoregulatory activity in autoimmunity and the major interest of LDA in their analysis.     

Hierarchy of T cell dependency in antibody response among different antigens.

T cell dependency of antibody response to polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), sheep red blood cells (SRBC), bovine gamma globulin (BGG), and bovine serum albumin (BSA) was examined. PVP and the other three are known as a T cell-independent antigen and T cell-dependent antigens respectively. Adult mice were thymectomized, X-irradiated, reconstituted with syngeneic bone marrow cells (TxXB mice), with bone marrow cells plus thymus cells (TxXBT mice), or with bone marrow cells treated with anti-Thy-1.2 serum and complement (TxXB-theta mice) and used as experimental animals. The anti-PVP response of TxXBT mice was significantly lower than that of TxXB mice, suggesting that T cells exerted a suppressive effect on the response to PVP. Both IgM and IgG responses to SRBC and BGG occurred even in TxXB-theta mice with the aid of bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS). However, a significant response to BSA was not observed in TxXB mice even in the presence of LPS or several other adjuvants. These results indicate that the T cell dependency of antigens is different among so called thymus-dependent antigens, that antibody response less dependent on the helper action of T cells can be supported by LPS in the absence of T cells, and that anti-BSA response seems to be extremely T cell dependent.     

In vitro studies of the rabbit immune system. IV. Differential mitogen responses of isolated T and B cells.

The mitogenic responses of separated rabbit lymphocyte populations functionally analogous to mouse T and B cells have been tested in vitro. Purified T cells were prepared by passage over nylon wool (NW) and purified B cells prepared by treatment with antithymocyte serum and complement (ATS + C). ATS + C kills 70% of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL's) and 50% of the spleen cells while passage over NW yields 40% of the applied PBL's and 5–23% of the applied spleen cells. NW-purified T cells from the spleen or PBL's respond fully to concanavalin A (Con A) but have a reduced response to phytohemaglutinin (PHA) and little or no response to goat anti-rabbit immunoglobulin (anti-Ig). PBL's that survive ATS + C (B cells) are stimulated by anti-Ig but not by Con A or PHA. B cells purified from spleen do not respond to Con A or PHA but will respond to anti-Ig under appropriate conditions. A full spleen B-cell response to anti-Ig required removal of Ig produced by the cultures that blocked anti-Ig stimulation. It is concluded that, for rabbit lymphocytes, Con A and PHA are primarily T-cell mitogens and that anti-Ig is primarily a B-cell mitogen. However, the mitogen response of unfractionated PBL or spleen cell populations indicates an overlap in reactivity. This could be due to cells sharing T and B properties, alteration of cell populations by the fractionation procedures used, or recruitment of one population in the presence of a mitogenic response of the other population.     

Nature of the antigenic complex recognized by T lymphocytes. VI. The effect of anti-TNP antibody on T cell responses to TNP-conjugated macrophages.

In this paper we examined the effect of anti-TNP antibody on guinea pig T cell proliferation in response to TNP-modified macrophages in vitro. The addition of anti-TNP to TNP-modified macrophages immediately after conjugation inhibited their ability to stimulate TNP-specific T cell proliferation. This inhibition appeared to be specific for the TNP response since anti-TNP had no effect on the ability of TNP-modified macrophages pulsed with either PPD or TNP-Ova to stimulate efficient PPD or Ova T cell responses. On the other hand, anti-TNP had no effect on the TNP-specific response to TNP-modified macrophages that had been cultured overnight before addition to primed T cells or to macrophages which had been pulsed with TNP-Ova. We also demonstrated that the same TNP-specific T cell subpopulation responds to both freshly TNP-modified macrophages and overnight cultured TNP-modified macrophages. These results suggest that the relevant TNP-determinants recognized by T cells are not exposed on the macrophage surface and raise the possibility that macrophages must process membrane-conjugated TNP to create the immunogen recognized by T cells.     

Epidermal growth factor and the control of proliferation of Balb 3T3 and benzo[a]pyrene-transformed Balb 3T3 cells.

Benzo[a]pyrene-transformed Balb 3T3 cells (BP3T3) exhibit "normal" growth controls at low concentrations of serum. Epidermal growth factor (EGF) stimulates DNA synthesis and cell division in both Balb 3T3 and BP3T3 cells at physiological concentrations. The growth response of BP3T3 cells to EGF is qualitatively the same as that of 3T3 cells, however, the transformed cells have a lower quantitative requirement. Both 3T3 and BP3T3 cells show a density-dependent response to EGF, but the shift in the dose response curve for BP3T3 cells at high cell density is smaller than that seen for 3T3 cells. One cause of the restricted growth of 3T3 cells at high cell density compared with BP3T3 cells is the increased concentration of growth factor needed for stimulation of 3T3 cells at higher cell densities. A lower rate of depletion of other growth factory by BP3T3 cells may also explain the smaller effect of cell density on the EGF response of these cells.     

Role of antigen-specific T cell help in the generation of in vivo antibody responses. II. Sustained antigen-specific T cell help is required to induce a specific antibody response.

The injection of mice with a goat or rabbit antibody to mouse IgD stimulates a large polyclonal IgG response, approximately 10% of which is specific for antigenic determinants on the anti-IgD antibody molecule. The large goat IgG (GIgG)-specific antibody response in mice injected with goat antibody to mouse IgD requires that GIgG-specific B cells undergo much greater clonal expansion than B cells specific for other Ag. One possible explanation for the greater clonal expansion of GIgG-specific B cells is that B cells that lack GIgG specificity can only be stimulated with GIgG-specific T help during the relatively short time that anti-IgD binds to, and is processed and presented by, these B cells before they cease to express membrane mIgD. In contrast, GIgG-specific B cells can continue to bind, process, and present GIgG through mIgM after they lose mIgD. To test the hypothesis that extended stimulation with Ag-specific T help is required to generate a specific antibody response, we determined time requirements for Ag-specific T cell help for the development of such a response. Mice were injected with rabbit antibody to mouse IgD plus one or more daily injections of FITC conjugated to a F(ab')2 fragment of rabbit IgG (FITC-(Fab')2), which has a short in vivo half-life, and IgG1 anti-FITC antibody production was analyzed. In this system, each additional injection of FITC-F(ab')2 extends the period during which FITC-specific B cells can process this Ag and present it to rabbit IgG-specific T cells. Each additional injection of FITC-F(ab')2 stimulated a several-fold increase in IgG1 anti-FITC antibody levels, and injections on 5 consecutive days were required to induce a maximal anti-FITC response. These observations provide evidence that sustained Ag-specific T cell help is required to stimulate the degree of B cell clonal expansion that characterizes a specific antibody response.     

Reaginic antibody formation in the mouse. VII. Induction of suppressor T cells for IgE and IgG antibody responses.

Intravenous injections of urea-denatured ovalbumin (UD-OA) into OA-primed high responder mice suppressed the antibody response not only to the priming antigen but also to subsequent immunization with dinitrophenyl derivatives of OA (DNP-OA). The transfer of normal spleen cells or OA-primed spleen cells into UD-OA-treated animals did not restore the capacity of responding to DNP-OA to form anti-DNP IgE and IgG antibodies. The transfer of splenic T cell fraction from the UD-OA-treated animals into normal syngeneic mice diminished both IgE and IgG antibody responses of the recipients to DNP-OA. The B cell-rich fraction from the same donors failed to affect the anti-hapten antibody response and enhanced anti-cancer (OA) IgG antibody response of the recipients. It was also found that the transfer of T cell-rich fraction of OA-primed spleen cells failed to suppress antibody response of the recipients to DNP-OA. The results indicated that spleen cells of UD-OA-treated mice contained suppressor T cells which are distinct from helper cells. Suppressive activity of T cells in the UD-OA treated animals was specific for OA. The transfer of the T cell-rich fraction failed to suppress anti-DNP antibody response of the recipients to DNP-KLH.     

Abnormal thymocyte development and production of autoreactive T cells in T cell receptor transgenic autoimmune mice.

Development of a C57BL/6-+/+ TCR transgenic mouse containing the rearranged TCR alpha- and beta-chain specific for the Db + HY male Ag results in production of a nearly monoclonal population of early thymocytes expressing the Db + HY reactive TCR. These thymocytes are autoreactive in H-2Db male mice and undergo clonal deletion and down-regulation of CD8. To study the effect of the lpr gene on development of autoreactive T cells, these transgenic mice were backcrossed with C57BL/6-lpr/lpr mice. T cell populations in the thymus and spleen were analyzed by three-color flow cytometry for expression of CD4, CD8, and TCR. The thymus of TCR transgenic H-2b/b lpr/lpr male mice had an increase in percent and absolute number of CD8dull thymocytes compared to TCR transgenic H-2b/b +/+ male mice. However, there was not a complete defect in clonal deletion, because clonal deletion and down-regulation of CD8 was apparent in both +/+ and lpr/lpr H-2Db HY+ male mice compared to H-2Db HY- female mice. The phenotype of splenic T cells was almost identical in TCR transgenic +/+ and lpr/lpr males with about 50% CD4-CD8- T cells and 50% CD8+ T cells. However, there was a dramatic increase in the SMLR proliferative response of splenic T cells from TCR transgenic lpr/lpr males compared to TCR transgenic +/+ males. To determine the specificity of this response, spleen cells from TCR transgenic lpr/lpr and +/+ mice were cultured with irradiated H-2b/b and H-2k/k male and female spleen cells. T cells from TCR transgenic C57BL/6-lpr/lpr male mice had an increased proliferative response to H-2b/b male spleen cells compared to T cells from TCR transgenic C57BL/6(-)+/+ male mice, but both lpr/lpr and +/+ mice had a minimal response to irradiated H-2b/b female or H-2k/k male or female stimulator cells. The splenic T cells from TCR transgenic lpr/lpr mice also had an increased specific cytotoxic activity against H-2b/b male target cells compared to TCR transgenic +/+ mice. These results demonstrate that there is a defect in negative selection of self-reactive T cells in the thymus of lpr/lpr mice and a defect in induction or maintenance of clonal anergy of self-reactive T cells in the periphery of lpr/lpr mice.     

Activation of distinct helper and suppressor T cells in experimental trypanosomiasis.

Spleen cells taken from mice soon after infection with Trypanosoma brucei S 42 enhance the primary in vitro antibody response of normal spleen cells to sheep red blood cells (SRBC), but do not affect their response to DNP-Ficoll. Spleen cells harvested later in the infection (day 6 onwards) suppress the antibody response of normal spleen cells to both SRBC and DNP-Ficoll. The enhancing and suppressive effects of "infected" spleen cells are sensitive to treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 anti-serum and complement, and can be mediated by nylon wool-purified populations of T cells. The enhancing T cell is sensitive to ALS, not lost within 4 weeks of adult thymectomy, and bears the Ly-1+, 23- phenotype. The suppressor T cell is insensitive to ALS, lost within 20 weeks of adult thymectomy, and bears the Ly-1+, 23+ phenotype. The significance of the activation of distinct helper and suppressor T cells is discussed in relation to the pathogenesis of trypanosomiasis.     

Complement-dependent and -independent pathways of T cell-B cell cooperation.

BDF1 mice treated with CoV had markedly reduced levels (less than 20%) of native serum C3 32 hr later, whereas the frequency of splenic CR+ cells was normal. CoV treatment before immunization reduced the IgM PFC response to a T-dependent antigen (TNP-SRBC) by more than 60%. Inclusion of highly specific anti-C3 antibody had no effect on the T-dependent IgM response of CR- B cells. The residual PFC responses in cultures of unfractionated spleen cells treated with anti-C3 could be largely or completely accounted for by CR- B cells in the cultures. The effect of anti-C3 antibody was not due to cytotoxicity. These data collectively indicate that the effect of CoV on T-dependent antibody responses is due to decreased C3 in serum rather than to interaction of C receptors directly with CoV or with C3 cleavage products. They suggest the existence of at least two distinct pathways of T-B cooperation, one in which C3 is an obligatory participant and another in which it may be uninvolved.