Multiple calcium binding sites make calmodulin multifunctional

Protein-protein or protein-ion interactions with multisite proteins are essential to the regulation of intracellular and extracellular events. There is, however, limited understanding of how ligand-multisite protein interactions selectively regulate the activities of multiple protein targets. In this paper, we focus on the important calcium (Ca(2+)) binding protein calmodulin (CaM), which has four Ca(2+) ion binding sites and regulates the activity of over 30 other proteins. Recent progress in structural studies has led to significant improvements in the understanding of Ca(2+)-CaM-dependent regulation mechanisms. However, no quantitative model is currently available that can fully explain how the structural diversity of protein interaction surfaces leads to selective activation of protein targets. In this paper, we analyze the multisite protein-ligand binding mechanism using mathematical modelling and experimental data for Ca(2+)-CaM-dependent protein targets. Our study suggests a potential mechanism for selective and differential activation of Ca(2+)-CaM targets by the same CaM molecules, which are involved in a variety of intracellular functions. The close agreement between model predictions and experimental dose-response curves for CaM targets available in the literature suggests that such activation is due to the selective activity of CaM conformations in complexes with variable numbers of Ca(2+) ions. Although the paper focuses on the Ca(2+)-CaM pair as a particularly data rich example, the proposed model predictions are quite general and can easily be extended to other multisite proteins. The results of the study may therefore be proposed as a general explanation for multifunctional target regulation by multisite proteins.     

Drug-protein interactions: binding of chlorpromazine to calmodulin, calmodulin fragments, and related calcium binding proteins

The quantitative binding of a phenothiazine drug to calmodulin, calmodulin fragments, and structurally related calcium binding proteins was measured under conditions of thermodynamic equilibrium by using a gel filtration method. Plant and animal calmodulins, troponin C, S100 alpha, and S100 beta bind chlorpromazine in a calcium-dependent manner with different stoichiometries and affinities for the drug. The interaction between calmodulin and chlorpromazine appears to be a complex, calcium-dependent phenomenon. Bovine brain calmodulin bound approximately 5 mol of drug per mol of protein with apparent half-maximal binding at 17 microM drug. Large fragments of calmodulin had limited ability to bind chlorpromazine. The largest fragment, containing residues 1-90, retained only 5% of the drug binding activity of the intact protein. A reinvestigation of the chlorpromazine inhibition of calmodulin stimulation of cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase further indicated a complex, multiple equilibrium among the reaction components and demonstrated that the order of addition of components to the reaction altered the drug concentration required for half-maximal inhibition of the activity over a 10-fold range. These results confirm previous observations using immobilized phenothiazines [Marshak, D.R., Watterson, D.M., & Van Eldik, L.J. (1981) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 78, 6793-6797] that indicated a subclass of calcium-modulated proteins bound phenothiazines in a calcium-dependent manner, demonstrate that the interaction between phenothiazines and calmodulin is more complex than previously assumed, and suggest that extended regions of the calmodulin molecule capable of forming the appropriate conformation are required for specific, high-affinity, calcium-dependent drug binding activity.     

Sequential events in calmodulin on binding with calcium and interaction with target enzymes

khe conformational and functional events in calmodulin (CaM) are disproportionate to the mean saturation by Ca2+. The enhancement of intrinsic tyrosine fluorescence closely follows the appearance of species CaM X Can greater than or equal to 1; the exposure of the hydrophobic patch at the surface of CaM coincides with the appearance of CaM X Can greater than or equal to 2. For the activation of four different target enzymes, i.e., brain phosphodiesterase and adenylate cyclase, red blood cell Ca,Mg-ATPase, and skeletal muscle phosphorylase b kinase, CaM X Can greater than or equal to 3 is required. The different enzymes have the same affinity for the active species. The direct interaction of CaM with Ca2+ and phosphorylase b kinase has been analyzed according to the theory of energy coupling: whereas the first two stoichiometric calcium-binding constants in the complex are not significantly different from those of free CaM, the third Ca2+ binds with an affinity at least 10(6)-fold higher to enzyme-bound CaM than to free CaM, which corresponds to a free energy coupling of -7 kcal/mol CaM. The similarities in the activation mechanism of different enzymes suggest the existence of one unique CaM-binding domain. The characteristics of the interaction between CaM and melittin, a small amphiphatic cytotoxin, led us to propose melittin as a model for such a CaM-binding domain.     

Binding of calcium by calmodulin: influence of the calmodulin binding domain of the plasma membrane calcium pump.

The interaction between calmodulin and synthetic peptides corresponding to the calmodulin binding domain of the plasma membrane Ca2+ pump has been studied by measuring Ca2+ binding to calmodulin. The largest peptide (C28W) corresponding to the complete 28 amino acid calmodulin binding domain enhanced the Ca2+ affinity of calmodulin by more than 100 times, implying that the binding of Ca2+ increased the affinity of calmodulin for the peptide by more than 10(8) times. Deletion of the 8 C-terminal residues from peptide C28W did not decrease the affinity of Ca2+ for the high-affinity sites of calmodulin, but it decreased that for the low-affinity sites. A larger deletion (13 residues) decreased the affinity of Ca2+ for the high-affinity sites as well. The data suggest that the middle portion of peptide C28W interacts with the C-terminal half of calmodulin. Addition of the peptides to a mixture of tryptic fragments corresponding to the N- and C-terminal halves of calmodulin produced a biphasic Ca2+ binding curve, and the effect of peptides was different from that on calmodulin. The result shows that one molecule of peptide C28W binds both calmodulin fragments. Interaction of the two domains of calmodulin through the central helix is necessary for the high-affinity binding of four Ca2+ molecules.     

Fluorescence characterization of VU-9 calmodulin, an engineered calmodulin with one tryptophan in calcium binding domain III

Absorption and fluorescence properties of VU-9 calmodulin, an engineered calmodulin in which a tryptophan residue has been introduced in position 99, have been investigated. Tryptophan 99 fluoresces with a maximum around 348 nm and is easily quenched by fluorescence quenchers such as acrylamide, indicating that the chromophore is in a polar environment and well exposed to the solvent, a location which has been reported previously for tyrosine 99 in mammalian calmodulin [Kilhoffer, M. C., Demaille, J. G., & Gérard, D. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 4407-4414]. The quantum yields of tryptophan 99 were found to be 0.19 in the absence of calcium and 0.15 in its presence. These values indicate that the chromophore is in a particular microenvironment where it is protected from the quenching mechanisms normally occurring in proteins. Steady-state fluorescence polarization measurements indicate that the protein exhibits segmental mobility both in the absence and in the presence of calcium. Binding of calcium decreases the mobility of the chromophore, a good indication for a rigidification of the protein structure. A quite rigid structure of at least the carboxy-terminal part of VU-9 calmodulin in the presence of Ca2+ is also suggested by F?rster energy-transfer measurements.     

Study of calcium binding to calmodulin using laser raman spectroscopy

Laser Raman spectroscopy has been used to study calcium binding to calmodulin, Ca2+-dependent regulator protein. Cation binding accompanied by spectral changes of tyrosine residues in the regions of Fermi-resonance doublet and 1600-1620 cm-1, of some carboxylate-containing residues, amide I, III and C-C(N) skeletal vibrations. Amide III contour analysis and calculations of Amide I contours show that complexation causes peptide backbone conformational changes characterized mainly by increased alpha-helical content.     

The TRPV5/6 calcium channels contain multiple calmodulin binding sites with differential binding properties

The epithelial Ca(2+) channels TRPV5/6 (transient receptor potential vanilloid 5/6) are thoroughly regulated in order to fine-tune the amount of Ca(2+) reabsorption. Calmodulin has been shown to be involved into calcium-dependent inactivation of TRPV5/6 channels by binding directly to the distal C-terminal fragment of the channels (de Groot et al. in Mol Cell Biol 31:2845-2853, 12). Here, we investigate this binding in detail and find significant differences between TRPV5 and TRPV6. We also identify and characterize in vitro four other CaM binding fragments of TRPV5/6, which likely are also involved in TRPV5/6 channel regulation. The five CaM binding sites display diversity in binding modes, binding stoichiometries and binding affinities, which may fine-tune the response of the channels to varying Ca(2+)-concentrations.     

Quantitative aspects of the development of a hydrophobic binding site on calmodulin by calcium binding

The interactive binding by calmodulin of Ca²⁺ and 1-anilinonaphthalene-8-sulfonate (1,8-ANS) has been examined. In the presence of saturating levels of Ca²⁺, calmodulin develops one moderately strong binding site for 1,8-ANS, plus one or more weaker sites. The binding of 1,8-ANS by unliganded, or singly liganded, calmodulin is slight; the development of a strong binding site, as well as the characteristic fluorescence enhancement and CD spectrum, requires the binding of two Ca²⁺ ions. Little further change occurs on binding additional Ca²⁺ ions.     

Increased covalent binding of acetaldehyde to calmodulin in the presence of calcium

The regulatory protein, calmodulin, undergoes major conformational changes in response to changes in intracellular calcium concentration. Furthermore, calmodulin has been reported to have lysine residues which markedly increase their reactivity toward electrophilic substances in the calcium-loaded state. We found that calmodulin formed two to three times more stable adducts with acetaldehyde in the calcium-loaded state as compared to the calcium-free state. Competition-binding studies showed that calmodulin could preferentially compete with albumin for acetaldehyde in the presence, but not in the absence, of calcium. When calmodulin was in the calcium-loaded state, trifluoperazine, an inhibitor of calmodulin activity, significantly decreased the stable binding of acetaldehyde to the protein, whereas in the calcium-free state, minimal effects on binding were observed. Since calmodulin is involved in regulation of multiple important processes in the cell, it is possible that acetaldehyde-calmodulin adducts could contribute to liver injury by perturbation of calcium-dependent homeostatic mechanisms within the hepatocyte.     

Calcium binding to complexes of calmodulin and calmodulin binding proteins

The free energy of coupling for binding of Ca2+ and the calmodulin-sensitive phosphodiesterase to calmodulin was determined and compared to coupling energies for two other calmodulin binding proteins, troponin I and myosin light chain kinase. Free energies of coupling were determined by quantitating binding of Ca2+ to calmodulin complexed to calmodulin binding proteins with Quin 2 to monitor free Ca2+ concentrations. The geometric means of the dissociation constants (-Kd) for Ca2+ binding to calmodulin in the presence of equimolar rabbit skeletal muscle troponin I, rabbit skeletal muscle myosin light chain kinase, and bovine heart calmodulin sensitive phosphodiesterase were 2.1, 1.1, and 0.55 microM. The free-energy couplings for the binding of four Ca2+ and these proteins to calmodulin were -4.48, -6.00, and -7.64 kcal, respectively. The Ca2+-independent Kd for binding of the phosphodiesterase to calmodulin was estimated at 80 mM, indicating that complexes between calmodulin and this enzyme would not exist within the cell under low Ca2+ conditions. The large free-energy coupling values reflect the increase in Ca2+ affinity of calmodulin when it is complexed to calmodulin binding proteins and define the apparent positive cooperativity for Ca2+ binding expected for each system. These data suggest that in vitro differences in free-energy coupling for various calmodulin-regulated enzymes may lead to differing Ca2+ sensitivities of the enzymes.     

Effects of trifluoperazine on calcium binding by calmodulin. A microcalorimetric study

Microcalorimetric titrations of calmodulin with Ca2+ and trifluoperazine (TFP) at various molar ratios have been carried out at 25 degrees C and at pH 7.0. Ca2+ binding to calmodulin produces heat (-delta H) in the presence of TFP, while heat is absorbed in the absence of TFP. The total heat produced by Ca2+ binding to all four sites is increased at increasing TFP-to-calmodulin ratios, attaining a plateau at about 7. These results indicate that at the higher ratios, the enthalpy changes (delta H) associated with Ca2+ binding are affected by TFP molecules bound at both high- and low-affinity sites. In addition, the Ca2+ binding reaction of the calmodulin-TFP complex is driven solely by a favorable enthalpy change of -27 kJ/mol of site; the entropy change (delta S) is -35 J/mol/K. These thermodynamic changes are opposite to those for TFP-free calmodulin and distinctly different from other Ca2+ binding proteins such as skeletal and cardiac troponin C and parvalbumin, where the reaction is driven by favorable changes of entropy as well as enthalpy.     

Coupling of RYR1 and L-type calcium channels via calmodulin binding domains

In skeletal muscle the L-type Ca2+ channel directly controls the opening of the sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+ release channel (RYR1), and RYR1, in turn, prevents L-type Ca2+ channel inactivation. We demonstrate that the two proteins interact using calmodulin binding regions of both proteins. A recombinant protein representing amino acids 1393-1527 (D1393-1527) of the carboxyl-terminal tail of the skeletal muscle L-type voltage-dependent calcium channel binds Ca2+, Ca2+ calmodulin, and apocalmodulin. In the absence of calmodulin, D1393-1527 binds to both RYR1 and a peptide representing the calmodulin binding site of RYR1 (amino acids 3609-3643). In addition, biotinylated R3609-3643 peptide can be used with streptavidin beads to pull down [3H]PN200-110-labeled L-type channels from detergent-solubilized transverse tubule membranes. The binding of the L-type channel carboxyl-terminal tail to the calmodulin binding site on RYR1 may stabilize the contact between the two proteins, provide a mechanism for Ca2+ and/or calmodulin regulation of their interaction, or participate directly in functional signaling between these two proteins. A unique aspect of this study is the finding that calmodulin binding sequences can serve as specific binding motifs for proteins other than calmodulin.     

A synthetic 33-residue analogue of bovine brain calmodulin calcium binding site III: synthesis, purification, and calcium binding

The sequential solid-phase synthesis of a peptide analogue of bovine brain calmodulin calcium binding site III covering residues 81-113 of the natural sequence is described. Methionine-109 is replaced by a leucine residue to avoid complications in the synthesis and purification. In an attempt to relate the structure of the calcium binding sites in the naturally occurring calcium binding protein to the calcium affinity of these sites, the synthetic analogue is examined for calcium binding by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The calcium binding characteristics are compared to those of a synthetic analogue of the homologous calcium binding site III in rabbit skeletal troponin C. The Kd of the calmodulin site III fragment for Ca2+ is determined as 878 microM whereas the Kd of the troponin C fragment is 30 times smaller at 28 microM. Structural changes induced in the peptides by Ca2+ and trifluoroethanol are similar. This study supports our contention that the single synthetic calcium binding site is a reasonable model for the study of the structure-activity relationships of the calcium binding sites in calcium-regulated proteins such as calmodulin and troponin C.     

Helix A stabilization precedes amino-terminal lobe activation upon calcium binding to calmodulin

The structural coupling between opposing domains of CaM was investigated using the conformationally sensitive biarsenical probe 4,5-bis(1,3,2-dithioarsolan-2-yl)resorufin (ReAsH), which upon binding to an engineered tetracysteine motif near the end of helix A (Thr-5 to Phe-19) becomes highly fluorescent. Changes in conformation and dynamics are reflective of the native CaM structure, as there is no change in the (1)H- (15)N HSQC NMR spectrum in comparison to wild-type CaM. We find evidence of a conformational intermediate associated with CaM activation, where calcium occupancy of sites in the amino-terminal and carboxyl-terminal lobes of CaM differentially affect the fluorescence intensity of bound ReAsH. Insight into the structure of the conformational intermediate is possible from a consideration of calcium-dependent changes in rates of ReAsH binding and helix A mobility, which respectively distinguish secondary structural changes associated with helix A stabilization from the tertiary structural reorganization of the amino-terminal lobe of CaM necessary for high-affinity binding to target proteins. Helix A stabilization is associated with calcium occupancy of sites in the carboxyl-terminal lobe ( K d = 0.36 +/- 0.04 microM), which results in a reduction in the rate of ReAsH binding from 4900 M (-1) s (-1) to 370 M (-1) s (-1). In comparison, tertiary structural changes involving helix A and other structural elements in the amino-terminal lobe require calcium occupancy of amino-terminal sites (K d = 18 +/- 3 microM). Observed secondary and tertiary structural changes involving helix A in response to the sequential calcium occupancy of carboxyl- and amino-terminal lobe calcium binding sites suggest an important involvement of helix A in mediating the structural coupling between the opposing domains of CaM. These results are discussed in terms of a model in which carboxyl-terminal lobe calcium activation induces secondary structural changes within the interdomain linker that release helix A, thereby facilitating the formation of calcium binding sites in the amino-terminal lobe and linked tertiary structural rearrangements to form a high-affinity binding cleft that can associate with target proteins.     

FRET detection of calmodulin binding to the cardiac RyR2 calcium release channel

Calmodulin (CaM) binding to the type 2 ryanodine receptor (RyR2) regulates Ca release from the cardiac sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR). However, the structural basis of CaM regulation of the RyR2 is poorly defined, and the presence of other potential CaM binding partners in cardiac myocytes complicates resolution of CaM's regulatory interactions with RyR2. Here, we show that a fluorescence-resonance-energy-transfer (FRET)-based approach can effectively resolve RyR2 CaM binding, both in isolated SR membrane vesicles and in permeabilized ventricular myocytes. A small FRET donor was targeted to the RyR2 cytoplasmic assembly via fluorescent labeling of the FKBP12.6 subunit. Acceptor fluorophore was attached at discrete positions within either the N- or the C-lobe of CaM. FRET between FKBP12.6 and CaM bound to SR vesicles indicated CaM binding at a single high-affinity site within 60 Å of FKBP12.6. Micromolar Ca increased the apparent affinity of CaM binding and slowed CaM dissociation, but did not significantly affect maximal FRET efficiency at saturating CaM. FRET was strongest when the acceptor was attached at either of two positions within CaM's N-lobe versus sites in CaM's C-lobe, providing CaM orientation information. In permeabilized ventricular myocytes, FKBP12.6 and CaM colocalized to Z-lines, and the efficiency of energy transfer to both the N- and C-lobes of CaM was comparable to that observed in SR vesicle experiments. Results also indicate that both the location and orientation of CaM binding on the RyR2 are very similar to the skeletal muscle RyR1 isoform. Specific binding of CaM to functional RyR2 channels in the cardiac myocyte environment can be monitored using FKBP biosensors and FRET.     

Long-range effects on calcium binding and conformational change in the N-domain of calmodulin

Proteins within the EF-hand protein family exhibit different conformational responses to Ca(2+) binding. Calmodulin and other members of the EF-hand protein family undergo major changes in conformation upon binding Ca(2+). However, some EF-hand proteins, such as calbindin D9k (Clb), bind Ca(2+) without a significant change in conformation. Here, we investigate the effects of replacement of a leucine at position 39 of the N-terminal domain of calmodulin (N-Cam) with a phenylalanine derived from Clb. This variant is studied alone and in the context of other mutations that affect the conformational properties of N-Cam. Strikingly, the introduction of Phe39, which is distant from the calcium binding sites, leads to a significant enhancement of Ca(2+) binding affinity, even in the context of other mutations which trap the protein in the closed form. The results yield novel insights into the evolution of EF-hand proteins as calcium sensors versus calcium buffers.     

Conformation and ion binding properties of peptides related to calcium binding domain III of bovine brain calmodulin

The conformational and ion binding properties of the sequences 93-104, 96-104, and 93-98 of domain III of bovine brain calmodulin (CaM) have been studied by CD and Tb3+-mediated fluorescence. In aqueous solution the interaction of all fragments with Ca2+ and Mg2+ ions is very weak and without any effect on the peptide conformation, which remains always random. In trifluoroethanol the interaction is very strong and the different fragments exhibit very distinct binding properties. In particular, the dodecapeptide fragment 93-104, and its N-terminal hexapeptide 98-104, bind calcium and magnesium with a very high binding constant (Kb greater than 10(5) M-1), undergoing a substantial conformational change. The structural rearrangement is particularly evident in the hexapeptide fragment, which tend to form a beta-bend. The C-terminal nonapeptide fragment 96-104 interacts with calcium and magnesium more weakly, and the binding process causes a decrease of ordered structure. These results suggest that, even in the entire dodecapeptide sequence corresponding to the loop of domain III of CaM, the calcium binding site is shifted toward the N-terminal hexapeptide segment. This interpretation is consistent with the results of crystallographic studies of CaM, which show that the calcium ions are located toward the amino terminal portion of the loop.     

Conformational changes upon calcium binding and phosphorylation in a synthetic fragment of calmodulin

We have recently investigated by far-UV circular dichroism (CD) the effects of Ca(2+) binding and the phosphorylation of Ser 81 for the synthetic peptide CaM [54-106] encompassing the Ca(2+)-binding loops II and III and the central alpha helix of calmodulin (CaM) (Arrigoni et al., Biochemistry 2004, 43, 12788-12798). Using computational methods, we studied the changes in the secondary structure implied by these spectra with the aim to investigate the effect of Ca(2+) binding and the functional role of the phosphorylation of Ser 81 in the action of the full-length CaM. Ca(2+) binding induces the nucleation of helical structure by inducing side chain stacking of hydrophobic residues. We further investigated the effect of Ca(2+) binding by using near-UV CD spectroscopy. Molecular dynamics simulations of different fragments containing the central alpha-helix of CaM using various experimentally determined structures of CaM with bound Ca(2+) disclose the structural effects provided by the phosphorylation of Ser 81. This post-translational modification is predicted to alter the secondary structure in its surrounding and also to hinder the physiological bending of the central helix of CaM through an alteration of the hydrogen bond network established by the side chain of residue 81. Using quantum mechanical methods to predict the CD spectra for the frames obtained during the MD simulations, we are able to reproduce the relative experimental intensities in the far-UV CD spectra for our peptides. Similar conformational changes that take place in CaM [54-106] upon Ca(2+) binding and phosphorylation may occur in the full-length CaM.