Biochemical and immunological studies on clathrin light chains and their binding sites on clathrin triskelions

Clathrin light chains from bovine brain tissue (LC alpha and LC beta) are monomeric proteins with an average mol. wt. of approximately 33,000, as determined by sedimentation equilibrium. Solution studies on purified light chains indicate a large Stokes radius (Re = 3.3 nm) and little defined secondary structure. Both light chains bind specifically and with high affinity (KA approximately 5 x 10(7)/M) to overlapping sites on clathrin heavy chains. These binding sites are contained within a 125,000 dalton heavy chain fragment that forms truncated triskelions with legs, 15 nm shorter than those of intact triskelions. As judged by immuno-electron microscopy, light chain-specific IgG molecules bind mostly to the center of triskelions, but there are also sites that are scattered some 16 nm along the proximal part of triskelion legs. From heterologous binding experiments using human placenta light chains and heavy chain fragments from bovine brain clathrin, it is concluded that the domains of light and heavy chains that are involved in the interaction are conserved across tissue and species boundaries.     

Human erythrocyte clathrin and clathrin-uncoating protein

Clathrin, a Mr = 72,000 clathrin-associated protein, and myosin were purified in milligram quantities from the same erythrocyte hemolysate fraction. Erythrocyte clathrin closely resembled brain clathrin in several respects: (a) both are triskelions as visualized by electron microscopy with arms 40 nm in length with globular ends and a flexible hinge region in the middle of each arm, and these triskelions assemble into polyhedral "cages" at appropriate pH and ionic strength; (b) both molecules contain heavy chains of Mr = 170,000 that are indistinguishable by two-dimensional maps of 125I-labeled peptides; and (c) both molecules contain light chains of Mr approximately 40,000 in a 1:1 molar ratio with the heavy chain. Erythrocyte clathrin is not identical to brain clathrin since antibody raised against the erythrocyte protein reacts better with erythrocyte clathrin than with brain clathrin and since brain clathrin contains two light chains resolved on sodium dodecyl sulfate gels while the light chain of erythrocyte clathrin migrates as a single band. The erythrocyte Mr = 72,000 clathrin-associated protein is closely related to a protein in brain that mediates ATP-dependent disassembly of clathrin from coated vesicles and binds tightly to clathrin triskelions (Schlossman, D. M., Schmid, S. L., Braell, W. A., and Rothman, J. E. (1984) J. Cell Biol. 99, 723-733). The erythrocyte and brain proteins have identical Mr on sodium dodecyl sulfate gels and identical maps of 125I-labeled peptides, share antigenic sites, and bind tightly to ATP immobilized on agarose. Clathrin and the uncoating protein are not restricted to reticulocytes since equivalent amounts of these proteins are present in whole erythrocyte populations and reticulocyte-depleted erythrocytes. Clathrin is present at 6,000 triskelions/cells, while the uncoating protein is in substantial excess at 250,000 copies/cell.     

Compromise of clathrin function and membrane association by clathrin light chain deletion

While clathrin heavy chains from different species are highly conserved in amino acid sequence, clathrin light chains are much more divergent. Thus clathrin light chain may have different functions in different organisms. To investigate clathrin light chain function, we cloned the clathrin light chain, clcA, from Dictyostelium and examined clathrin function in clcA– mutants. Phenotypic deficiencies in development, cytokinesis, and osmoregulation showed that light chain was critical for clathrin function in Dictyostelium . In contrast with budding yeast, we found the light chain did not influence steady-state levels of clathrin, triskelion formation, or contribute to clathrin over-assembly on intracellular membranes. Imaging GFP-CHC in clcA– mutants showed that the heavy chain formed dynamic punctate structures that were remarkably similar to those found in wild-type cells. However, clathrin light chain knockouts showed a decreased association of clathrin with intracellular membranes. Unlike wild-type cells, half of the clathrin in clcA– mutants was cytosolic, suggesting that the absence of light chain compromised the assembly of triskelions onto intracellular membranes. Taken together, these results suggest a role for the Dictyostelium clathrin light chain in regulating the self-assembly of triskelions onto intracellular membranes, and demonstrate a crucial contribution of the light chain to clathrin function in vivo .     

Predominance of clathrin light chain LCb correlates with the presence of a regulated secretory pathway

Two forms of clathrin light chains, LCa and LCb, are expressed in all mammalian and avian tissues that have been examined, whereas only one type is found in yeast. Regions of structural dissimilarity between LCa and LCb indicate possible functional diversity. To determine how LCa and LCb might differentially influence clathrin function, light chain expression patterns and turnover were investigated. Relative expression levels of the two light chains were determined in cells and tissues with and without a regulated secretory pathway. LCa/LCb ratios ranged from 5:1 to 0.33:1. A higher proportion of LCb was observed in cells and tissues that maintain a regulated pathway of secretion, suggesting a specialized role for the LCb light chain in this process. The ratio of light chains in assembled clathrin was found to reflect the levels of total light chains expressed in the cell, indicating no preferential incorporation into triskelions or coated vesicles. The half-lives of LCa, LCb, and clathrin heavy chain were determined to be 24, 45, and 50 h, respectively. Thus, LCa is turned over independently of the other subunits. However, the half-lives of all three subunits are sufficiently long to allow triskelions to undergo many rounds of endocytosis, minimizing the possibility that turnover contributes to regulation of clathrin function. Rather, differential levels of LCa and LCb expression may influence tissue specific clathrin regulation, as suggested by the predominance of LCb in cells maintaining a regulated secretory pathway.     

The association of clathrin fragments with coated vesicle membranes

The association between clathrin triskelions and the clathrin-stripped membranes of coated vesicles has been investigated using a filter assay to separate bound from unbound clathrin. The filter assay is more sensitive and less cumbersome than a sedimentation assay used previously (1). While confirming the high affinity interaction between clathrin and the vesicle membrane, our results yield Scatchard plots that are curvilinear and consistent with a positively cooperative interaction between clathrin and the vesicle membranes. Controlled digestion with trypsin removes the distal portions of the triskelion legs leaving the proximal 31 nm portions that form the hub of the triskelions. These hubs are trimers of large 112,000- and 124,000-dalton fragments of clathrin heavy chains. They competitively inhibit the binding of 125I-labeled intact triskelions to stripped vesicles with a KI identical to the KD for the association of 125I-labeled intact triskelions to stripped vesicles. Furthermore, these large fragment trimers bind to stripped vesicles with approximately the same high affinity as do intact triskelions and also show evidence of a positively cooperative interaction. It is concluded that clathrin binds to coated vesicles by an interaction that is mediated by the proximal 112,000-dalton fragment of the clathrin heavy chains.     

Two classes of binding sites for uncoating protein in clathrin triskelions

Clathrin released from coated vesicles or empty cages by the ATP-dependent action of uncoating protein exists as a complex with the uncoating protein. Despite its apparent consumption during a round of uncoating, we have found that uncoating protein functions as an enzyme in that it rapidly and spontaneously recycles from its product (triskelions) to its substrate (cages). The binding of uncoating protein to clathrin triskelions is a complex equilibrium that involves the interaction of uncoating protein with at least two distinct sites on the clathrin molecule. Limited proteolysis dissected clathrin into two domains, each of which contained distinct binding sites. Binding to one of these sites, located on the proximal leg of a triskelion, was dependent upon the presence of light chains and was unstable to gel filtration. Binding to the second kind of site, located on the distal portion of a triskelion leg, was stable to gel filtration and was independent of the presence of light chains.     

Clathrin light chains: arrays of protein motifs that regulate coated-vesicle dynamics

Polymerization of clathrin triskelions into clathrin coats and subsequent disassembly by the heat shock protein hsc70 control receptor-mediated pathways of intracellular transport. The clathrin light chains are major regulatory elements in these processes. These polypeptides consist of linear arrays of functional domains with distinctive sequence motifs. Comparison of unicellular and multicellular eukaryotes reveals differences in the numbers of clathrin light chains and in the functional domains they contain.     

A Comparison of GFP‐Tagged Clathrin Light Chains with Fluorochromated Light Chains In Vivo and In Vitro

Clathrin triskelia consist of three heavy chains and three light chains (LCs). Green fluorescent protein (GFP)‐tagged LCs are widely utilized to follow the dynamics of clathrin in living cells, but whether they reflect faithfully the behavior of clathrin triskelia in cells has not been investigated yet thoroughly. As an alternative approach, we labeled purified LCs either with Alexa 488 or Cy3 dye and compared them with GFP‐tagged LC variants. Cy3‐labeled light chains (Cy3‐LCs) were microinjected into HeLa cells either directly or in association with heavy chains. Within 1–2 min the Cy3‐LC heavy chain complexes entered clathrin‐coated structures, whereas uncomplexed Cy3‐LC did not within 2 h. These findings show that no significant exchange of LCs occurs over the time–course of an endocytic cycle. To explore whether GFP‐tagged LCs behave functionally like endogenous LCs, we characterized them biochemically. Unlike wild‐type LCs, recombinant LCs with a GFP attached to either end did not efficiently inhibit clathrin assembly in vitro, whereas Cy3‐ and Alexa 488‐labeled LC behaved similar to wild‐type LCs in vitro and in vivo. Thus, fluorochromated LCs are a valuable tool for investigating the complex behavior of clathrin in living cells.     

Deep-etch visualization of 27S clathrin: a tetrahedral tetramer

It has recently been reported that 8S clathrin trimers or "triskelions" form larger 27S oligomers upon dialysis into low ionic strength buffers (Prasad, K., R. E. Lippoldt, H. Edelhoch, and M. S. Lewis, 1986, Biochemistry, 25:5214-5219). Here, deep-etch electron microscopy of the 27S species reveals that they are closed tetrahedra composed of four clathrin triskelions. This was determined by two approaches. First, standard quick-freezing and freeze-etching of unfixed 27S species suspended in 2 mM 2-(N-morpholino)ethane sulfonic acid (MES) buffer, pH 5.9, yielded unambiguous images of tetrahedra that measured 33 nm on each edge. Second, the technique of freeze-drying molecules on mica (Heuser, J. E., 1983, J. Mol. Biol., 169:155-195) was modified to overcome the low affinity of mica in 2 mM MES, by pretreating the mica with polylysine. Thereafter, 27S species adsorbed avidly to it and collapsed into characteristic configurations containing four globular domains, each linked to the others by three approximately 33-nm struts. The globular domains look like vertices of deep-etched clathrin triskelions and the links, numbering 12 in all, look like four sets of triskelion legs. New light scattering and equilibrium centrifugation data confirm that 27S polymer is four times as massive as one clathrin triskelion. We conclude that in conditions that do not favor the formation of standard clathrin cages, low affinity interactions lead to closed, symmetrical assemblies of four triskelions, each of which assumes a unique puckered, straight-legged configuration to create the edges of a tetrahedron. Tetrahedra are similar in construction to the cubic octomers of clathrin recently found in ammonium sulfate solutions (Sorger, P. K., R. A. Crowther, J. T. Finch, and B. M. F. Pearse, 1986, J. Cell Biol., 103:1213-1219) but are still smaller, involving only half as many clathrin triskelions.     

Isolation and partial characterization of clathrin-coated vesicles from pea (Pisum sativum L.) cotyledons

Summary Clathrin-coated vesicles have been isolated from cotyledons of both developing and germinating pea seeds using differential centrifugation, ribonuclease treatment, discontinuous sucrose gradients, and isopycnic centrifugation on a linear D₂O-Ficoll gradient. The yield of coated vesicles from developing pea cotyledons was exceptional, being 1.6 × higher than the yield from hog and bovine brain, 5.3 × higher than the yield from carrot suspension cultures, and 13 × the yield from cotyledons of germinating pea seeds. The pea coated vesicles are similar to other plant coated vesicles in size (approximately 80 nm in diameter) and in having a clathrin heavy chain of 190,000 M_r. The lipid phosphorus to protein ratio, 190–250 nmol P per mg protein, of the coated vesicles from plants is comparable to that reported for highly purified coated vesicles from animals. The nondenatured pea clathrin reacted weakly with an antiserum to bovine brain clathrin, but pea clathrin denatured by sodium dodecyl sulfate did not.Abbreviations CLC Clathrin light chain - CHC clathrin heavy chain - CV coated vesicle - DTT dithiothreitol - EGTA ethyleneglycol-bis-(-aminoethyl ether) N,N-tetraacetic acid - SDS-PAGE sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis - TBS Tris buffered saline     

Clathrin light chain: importance of the conserved carboxy terminal domain to function in living cells

Clathrin triskelions assemble into coats capable of packaging membrane and receptors for transport to intracellular destinations. A triskelion is formed from three heavy chains bound to three light chains. All clathrin light chains (clc) contain an acidic amino terminal domain, a central coiled segment, and a carboxy terminal domain conserved in amino acid sequence. To assess their functional contribution in vivo, we expressed tagged segments of the Dictyostelium clcA in clc-minus Dictyostelium (clc null) cells. We examined the ability of these clcA fragments to rescue clathrin phenotypic deficiencies, to cluster into punctae on membranes, and to bind to the heavy chain. When expressed in clc null cells, a clcA fragment containing the amino terminal domain and the central coiled domain bound heavy chain but was dispensable for clathrin function. Instead, the carboxy terminal domain of clcA was a critical determinant for association with punctae, for clathrin function and for robust binding to the heavy chain. A 70 amino acid carboxy terminal fragment was necessary and sufficient for full function, and for localization into punctae on intracellular membranes. A shorter 49 amino acid carboxy terminal fragment could distribute into punctae but failed to rescue developmental deficiencies. These results reveal the importance of the carboxy terminal domain of the light chain in vivo.     

Light-chain-independent binding of adaptors, AP180, and auxilin to clathrin

Binding of coated vesicle assembly proteins to clathrin causes it to assemble into regular coat structures. The assembly protein fraction of bovine brain coated vesicles comprises AP180, auxilin, and HA1 and HA2 adaptors. Clathrin heavy chains, separated from their light chains, polymerize with unimpaired efficiency when assembly proteins are added. The reassembled coats were purified by sucrose gradient centrifugation and examined for composition by SDS-PAGE and immunoblotting. We found that all four major coat proteins are incorporated in the presence and absence of light chains. Moreover, each of the purified coat proteins is able to associate directly with clathrin heavy chains in preassembled cages as efficiently as with intact clathrin. We conclude that light chains are not essential for the interaction of AP180, auxilin, and HA1 and HA2 with clathrin.     

Image averaging of flexible fibrous macromolecules: the clathrin triskelion has an elastic proximal segment.

We have developed computational techniques that allow image averaging to be applied to electron micrographs of filamentous molecules that exhibit tight and variable curvature. These techniques, which involve straightening by cubic-spline interpolation, image classification, and statistical analysis of the molecules' curvature properties, have been applied to purified brain clathrin. This trimeric filamentous protein polymerizes, both in vivo and in vitro, into a wide range of polyhedral structures. Contrasted by low-angle rotary shadowing, dissociated clathrin molecules appear as distinctive three-legged structures, called "triskelions" (E. Ungewickell and D. Branton (1981) Nature 289, 420). We find triskelion legs to vary from 35 to 62 nm in total length, according to an approximately bell-shaped distribution (mu = 51.6 nm). Peaks in averaged curvature profiles mark hinges or sites of enhanced flexibility. Such profiles, calculated for each length class, show that triskelion legs are flexible over their entire lengths. However, three curvature peaks are observed in every case: their locations define a proximal segment of systematically increasing length (14.0-19.0 nm), a mid-segment of fixed length (approximately 12 nm), and a rather variable end-segment (11.6-19.5 nm), terminating in a hinge just before the globular terminal domain (approximately 7.3 nm diameter). Thus, two major factors contribute to the overall variability in leg length: (1) stretching of the proximal segment and (2) stretching of the end-segment and/or scrolling of the terminal domain. The observed elasticity of the proximal segment may reflect phosphorylation of the clathrin light chains.     

Clathrin light chains are calcium-binding proteins

Clathrin light chains have been purified to near homogeneity. When analyzed by sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis followed by silver stain for proteins, no bands corresponding to light chains were detected. As calmodulin and troponin C are known to behave in the same manner on silver staining, the possibility that clathrin light chains were Ca2+-binding proteins was investigated. Light chains fixed to nitrocellulose filters were found to bind 45Ca2+ in the presence of 5 mM Mg2+. The Ca2+-binding capacity of the light chains was further investigated, using gel filtration and equilibrium dialysis. The light chains were shown to bind, in the presence of 3 mM Mg2+, 1 mol of Ca2+ per mol of light chain with a Kd of 25-55 microM. Nitrocellulose binding and gel filtration studies showed that light chains present in triskelions are still capable of binding Ca2+, in this case with a calculated Kd of 45 microM.     

Analysis of clathrin light chain-heavy chain interactions using truncated mutants of rat liver light chain LCB3

Clathrin light chains are extended molecules located along the proximal segment of each of the three heavy chain legs of a clathrin trimer. All mammalian light chains share a central segment with 10 repeated heptad motifs believed to mediate the interaction with clathrin heavy chains. In order to test this model in more detail, we have expressed intact rat liver clathrin light chain LCB3 in Escherichia coli and find that it binds tightly to calf clathrin heavy chains. Using a set of expressed truncated mutants of LCB3, we show that the presence of seven to eight heptads is indeed necessary for a successful interaction. More extensive deletions of the central segment completely abolish the ability to bind to heavy chains. Neither the amino- nor the carboxyl-terminal domain is essential for binding, but competition experiments show that the presence of the carboxyl-terminal domain does enhance the interaction with heavy chains.     

Phosphorylation Characteristics of Brain Clathrin-Coated Vesicle Endogenous Proteins

Clathrin-coated vesicles purified from bovine brain express protein kinase activity on two principal endogenous vesicle-associated substrates: a 50,000-Mr polypeptide (pp50) and clathrin-associated protein2 (CAP2; the faster-migrating clathrin light chain). Various exogenous substrates, e.g., casein, phosvitin, histone II, and histone III, also are phosphorylated. The pp50 protein kinase activity of clathrin-coated vesicles is not modulated by Ca2+, calmodulin, phosphatidylserine, or cyclic AMP. On the other hand, phosphorylation of the other endogenous substrates requires certain activators, including histone, polylysine, polyarginine, or polyethylenimine. Phosphate incorporation into pp50 was sensitive to divalent cations that inhibit sulfhydryl-dependent enzymes in the following order of potency: Zn2+ greater than Hg2+ greater than Cd2+, Cu2+, and Pb2+. Phosphate incorporation into CAP2 with polylysine present was insensitive to divalent cations. The alkylating agents dithiodinitrobenzene, phenacyl bromide, and N-ethylmaleimide inhibited phosphate incorporation into pp50 up to 90% without affecting incorporation into the other substrates. Vanadium pentoxide inhibited phosphorylation of CAP2 but had a minimal effect on pp50. CAP2 kinase activity was separated from the coated vesicle membrane and from dis-assembled clathrin triskelions, coeluting with the assembly polypeptide complex on a Sepharose 4B column. It retained phosphorylation properties similar to those of intact vesicles. These data imply that clathrin-coated vesicle kinases are elements of the coat proteins and may be involved in the assembly/disassembly of clathrin triskelions or interactions of coated vesicles with other cellular components.     

Clathrin cubes: an extreme variant of the normal cage

Clathrin triskelions form polyhedral cages with hexagonal and pentagonal faces when dialyzed against suitable assembly buffers. However, when the buffer is made 12% saturated in ammonium sulfate and the dialysis is performed at 4 degrees C, clathrin polymerizes into cubes. The cube is constructed from eight triskelions with one at each corner. The edge length of the cube is approximately 45 nm, equivalent to the length of the leg of a triskelion. Thus, each edge of the cube is composed of two antiparallel legs overlapping over their whole length. The interactions between the legs in the cube are a subset of those postulated to occur in cages. Indeed, the cube can be derived from a pentagonal dodecahedron by removing 12 of the 20 triskelions with only slight adjustment of the legs of the remaining triskelions. The cube forms regular arrays and appears to be a favorable species for crystallization of clathrin.     

Protein organization in clathrin trimers

We have prepared a homogeneous, soluble 8.6S species (“8.6S clathrin”) from calf-brain coated vesicles. Crosslinking experiments show that this 8.6S clathrin is composed of three heavy chains (molecular weight 180,000) and three light chains (molecular weights 33,000 and 36,000). Each heavy chain is in close contact with a single light chain, and the light chains appear not to be in contact with each other. Intact 8.6S clathrin can reassemble into cages without participation of additional protein species.     

Yeast clathrin has a distinctive light chain that is important for cell growth

The structure and physiologic role of clathrin light chain has been explored by purification of the protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, molecular cloning of the gene, and disruption of the chromosomal locus. The single light chain protein from yeast shares many physical properties with the mammalian light chains, in spite of considerable sequence divergence. Within the limited amino acid sequence identity between yeast and mammalian light chains (18% overall), three regions are notable. The carboxy termini of yeast light chain and mammalian light chain LCb are 39% homologous. Yeast light chain contains an amino-terminal region 45% homologous to a domain that is completely conserved among mammalian light chains. Lastly, a possible homolog of the tissue-specific insert of LCb is detected in the yeast gene. Disruption of the yeast gene (CLC1) leads to a slow-growth phenotype similar to that seen in strains that lack clathrin heavy chain. However, light chain gene deletion is not lethal to a strain that cannot sustain a heavy chain gene disruption. Light chain-deficient strains frequently give rise to variants that grow more rapidly but do not express an immunologically related light chain species. These properties suggest that clathrin light chain serves an important role in cell growth that can be compensated in light chain deficient cells.     

Identification of a distinct 9S form of soluble clathrin in cultured cells and tissues

We have used a monoclonal antibody (CHC5.9) to identify clathrin (Mr 180,000; 'heavy chain') in coated vesicles, triskelion structures prepared in vitro and in high-speed supernatants (HSS) of cell homogenates from a variety of tissues and species (e.g., brain and liver from rat, cow and man; Xenopus ovaries). HSS proteins were subjected to sucrose density gradient centrifugation and gel filtration, and the fractions obtained were assayed for clathrin by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE), followed by immunoblotting. The native soluble clathrin identified in such fractions was indistinguishable from triskelions produced in vitro from purified bovine brain clathrin by several criteria, e.g. by its sedimentation coefficient (9S) and elution profile on gel filtration using Sephacryl S 300. No other major forms of soluble clathrin were detected. The results indicate that cells contain a soluble pool of clathrin and that the predominant molecular form of this soluble clathrin has properties similar to those of the triskelion obtained by dissociation studies in vitro. We hypothesize that this distinct 9S form represents a major oligomeric subunit involved in assembly and disassembly of clathrin polyhedron coats in the living cell.