Biophysical studies of engineered mutant proteins based on calbindin D9k modified in the pseudo EF-hand

The genes for four mutant proteins from calbindin D9k, all with mutations in the N-terminal Ca2+-binding domain (pseudo EF-hand) have been synthesized and expressed in Escherichia coli. The purification scheme has been modified to minimize the formation of deamidated proteins. The set of modifications in the pseudo EF-hand is an attempt to turn this site into a structure resembling an archetypal EF-hand, with its characteristic 113Cd-NMR shift (-80 to -110 ppm) and high calcium-binding constants, whereas the C-terminal Ca2(+)-binding site (EF-hand) is kept intact in all mutant proteins. The mutant proteins studied here all have pseudo EF-hands with a lower calcium-binding constant and a higher calcium off-rate to the pseudo EF-hand than the wild-type protein. From the results obtained it is obvious that proline 20 in the pseudo EF-hand, which has been deleted or replaced by glycine in three of the mutants, has a stabilizing effect on calcium binding to that site. Furthermore, the modifications in the pseudo EF-hand seem to have only a local effect, leaving the tertiary structure of the protein and the calcium-binding properties of the unmodified site virtually unchanged.     

Long-range effects on calcium binding and conformational change in the N-domain of calmodulin

Proteins within the EF-hand protein family exhibit different conformational responses to Ca(2+) binding. Calmodulin and other members of the EF-hand protein family undergo major changes in conformation upon binding Ca(2+). However, some EF-hand proteins, such as calbindin D9k (Clb), bind Ca(2+) without a significant change in conformation. Here, we investigate the effects of replacement of a leucine at position 39 of the N-terminal domain of calmodulin (N-Cam) with a phenylalanine derived from Clb. This variant is studied alone and in the context of other mutations that affect the conformational properties of N-Cam. Strikingly, the introduction of Phe39, which is distant from the calcium binding sites, leads to a significant enhancement of Ca(2+) binding affinity, even in the context of other mutations which trap the protein in the closed form. The results yield novel insights into the evolution of EF-hand proteins as calcium sensors versus calcium buffers.     

The EF-hand domain: A globally cooperative structural unit

EF-hand Ca(2+)-binding proteins participate in both modulation of Ca(2+) signals and direct transduction of the ionic signal into downstream biochemical events. The range of biochemical functions of these proteins is correlated with differences in the way in which they respond to the binding of Ca(2+). The EF-hand domains of calbindin D(9k) and calmodulin are homologous, yet they respond to the binding of calcium ions in a drastically different manner. A series of comparative analyses of their structures enabled the development of hypotheses about which residues in these proteins control the calcium-induced changes in conformation. To test our understanding of the relationship between protein sequence and structure, we specifically designed the F36G mutation of the EF-hand protein calbindin D(9k) to alter the packing of helices I and II in the apoprotein. The three-dimensional structure of apo F36G was determined in solution by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and showed that the design was successful. Surprisingly, significant structural perturbations also were found to extend far from the site of mutation. The observation of such long-range effects provides clear evidence that four-helix EF-hand domains should be treated as a single globally cooperative unit. A hypothetical mechanism for how the long-range effects are transmitted is described. Our results support the concept of energetic and structural coupling of the key residues that are crucial for a protein's fold and function.     

Site-site communication in the EF-hand Ca2+-binding protein calbindin D9k

The cooperative binding of Ca2+ ions is an essential functional property of the EF-hand family of Ca2+-binding proteins. To understand how these proteins function, it is essential to characterize intermediate binding states in addition to the apo- and holo-proteins. The three-dimensional solution structure and fast time scale internal motional dynamics of the backbone have been determined for the half-saturated state of the N56A mutant of calbindin D9k with Ca2+ bound only in the N-terminal site. The extent of conformational reorganization and a loss of flexibility in the C-terminal EF-hand upon binding of an ion in the N-terminal EF-hand provide clear evidence of the importance of site-site interactions in this family of proteins, and demonstrates the strength of long-range effects in the cooperative EF-hand Ca2+-binding domain.     

Functional properties of calbindin D9K mutants with exchanged Ca2+ binding sites

We have constructed three different engineered proteins based on calbindin D9K by either exchanging the two calcium binding sites within the protein or making the amino acid sequence of the two calcium binding sites identical. The individual calcium binding sites of the engineered proteins retain most of their ion binding characteristics as well as the basal structure of their Ca2+ ligand sphere in the new environment. Even the protein with its sites interchanged, a mutation involving 30 amino acids out of a total of 75, still binds calcium with an affinity as high as that of many natural EF-hand proteins.     

Actin-binding proteins are conserved from slime molds to man

DNA clones encoding the actin-binding proteins alpha-actinin and severin from Dictyostelium discoideum were isolated and sequenced. Comparisons of the deduced amino acid sequences with proteins from other species showed striking similarities at distinct regions. The F-actin cross-linking molecule alpha-actinin carries two characteristic EF-hand structures highly homologous to the Ca2+-binding loops of proteins from the calmodulin superfamily. An N-terminal region that is conserved in alpha-actinin from D. discoideum and vertebrates is also related to parts of the dystrophin sequence and might represent the F-actin binding site. Severin, gelsolin, villin, and fragmin share homologous sequences that are believed to participate in the severing activity of these proteins.     

Parallel measurement of Ca2+ binding and fluorescence emission upon Ca2+ titration of recombinant skeletal muscle troponin C. Measurement of sequential calcium binding to the regulatory sites

Calcium binding to chicken recombinant skeletal muscle TnC (TnC) and its mutants containing tryptophan (F29W), 5-hydroxytryptophan (F29HW), or 7-azatryptophan (F29ZW) at position 29 was measured by flow dialysis and by fluorescence. Comparative analysis of the results allowed us to determine the influence of each amino acid on the calcium binding properties of the N-terminal regulatory domain of the protein. Compared with TnC, the Ca(2+) affinity of N-terminal sites was: 1) increased 6-fold in F29W, 2) increased 3-fold in F29ZW, and 3) decreased slightly in F29HW. The Ca(2+) titration of F29ZW monitored by fluorescence displayed a bimodal curve related to sequential Ca(2+) binding to the two N-terminal Ca(2+) binding sites. Single and double mutants of TnC, F29W, F29HW, and F29ZW were constructed by replacing aspartate by alanine at position 30 (site I) or 66 (site II) or both. Ca(2+) binding data showed that the Asp --> Ala mutation at position 30 impairs calcium binding to site I only, whereas the Asp --> Ala mutation at position 66 impairs calcium binding to both sites I and II. Furthermore, the Asp --> Ala mutation at position 30 eliminates the differences in Ca(2+) affinity observed for replacement of Phe at position 29 by Trp, 5-hydroxytryptophan, or 7-azatryptophan. We conclude that position 29 influences the affinity of site I and that Ca(2+) binding to site I is dependent on the previous binding of metal to site II.     

Structural basis for the negative allostery between Ca(2+)- and Mg(2+)-binding in the intracellular Ca(2+)-receptor calbindin D9k.

The three-dimensional structures of the magnesium- and manganese-bound forms of calbindin D9k were determined to 1.6 A and 1.9 A resolution, respectively, using X-ray crystallography. These two structures are nearly identical but deviate significantly from both the calcium bound form and the metal ion-free (apo) form. The largest structural differences are seen in the C-terminal EF-hand, and involve changes in both metal ion coordination and helix packing. The N-terminal calcium binding site is not occupied by any metal ion in the magnesium and manganese structures, and shows little structural deviation from the apo and calcium bound forms. 1H-NMR and UV spectroscopic studies at physiological ion concentrations show that the C-terminal site of the protein is significantly populated by magnesium at resting cell calcium levels, and that there is a negative allosteric interaction between magnesium and calcium binding. Calcium binding was found to occur with positive cooperativity at physiological magnesium concentration.     

Effect of amino acid substitutions and deletions on the thermal stability, the pH stability and unfolding by urea of bovine calbindin D9k

The influence of amino acid substitutions and deletions on the stability of bovine calbindin D9k, the smallest protein known with a pair of EF-hand calcium-binding sites, has been studied using circular dichroism and ultraviolet absorption spectroscopy. The five modifications are confined to one of the two Ca2+ -binding sites. The Ca2+-loaded forms of the wild-type and mutant calbindins are too stable to be significantly denatured by heating at 90 degrees C or by adding 8 M urea. For the Ca2+-free (apo) forms thermal unfolding appears to be only half complete at 90 degrees C, while denaturation is complete in 7-8 M urea. Four of the mutant proteins show reduced resistance towards unfolding by urea, but one of the modified proteins (Glu-17----Gln) shows an increased stability, presumably because of a reduced electrostatic repulsion in the native state. According to X-ray crystallographic data the OH group of the single tyrosine of calbindin (Tyr-13) is hydrogen-bonded to the carboxyl group of Glu-35, thus linking the two alpha helices flanking the N-terminal Ca2+ site. The pK of ionization of the Tyr-13 hydroxyl group was over 13 for calcium forms of the wild-type protein, between 12.3 and 12.8 for the calcium form of three mutants and between 11.5 and 11.7 for the apoproteins. Significant differences in pH stability between wild type and mutants were observed in the calcium forms, but were not apparent in the apo forms.     

Ca(2+)- and H(+)-dependent conformational changes of calbindin D(28k)

Calbindin D(28k) is a member of a large family of intracellular Ca(2+) binding proteins characterized by EF-hand structural motifs. Some of these proteins are classified as Ca(2+)-sensor proteins, since they are involved in transducing intracellular Ca(2+) signals by exposing a hydrophobic patch on the protein surface in response to Ca(2+) binding. The hydrophobic patch serves as an interaction site for target enzymes. Other members of this group are classified as Ca(2+)-buffering proteins, because they remain closed after Ca(2+) binding and participate in Ca(2+) buffering and transport functions. ANS (8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid) binding and affinity chromatography on a hydrophobic column suggested that both the Ca(2+)-free and Ca(2+)-loaded form of calbindin D(28k) have exposed hydrophobic surfaces. Since exposure of hydrophobic surface is unfavorable in the aqueous intracellular milieu, calbindin D(28k) most likely interacts with other cellular components in vivo. A Ca(2+)-induced conformational change was readily detected by several optical spectroscopic methods. Thus, calbindin D(28k) shares some of the properties of Ca(2+)-sensor proteins. However, the Ca(2+)-induced change in exposed hydrophobic surface was considerably less pronounced than that in calmodulin. The data also shows that calbindin D(28k) undergoes a rapid and reversible conformational change in response to a H(+) concentration increase within the physiological pH range. The pH-dependent conformational change was shown to reside mainly in EF-hands 1-3. Urea-induced unfolding of the protein at pH 6, 7, and 8 showed that the stability of calbindin D(28k) was increased in response to H(+) in the range examined. The results suggest that calbindin D(28k) may interact with targets in a Ca(2+)- and H(+)-dependent manner.     

Role of four conserved aspartic acid residues of EF-loops in the metal ion binding and in the self-assembly of ciliate <Emphasis Type="Italic">Euplotes octocarinatus</Emphasis> centrin

Ciliate Euplotes octocarinatus centrin (EoCen) is an EF-hand calcium-binding protein closely related to the prototypical calcium sensor protein calmodulin. Four mutants (D37K, D73K, D110K and D146K) were created firstly to elucidate the importance of the first aspartic acid residues (Asp37, Asp73, Asp110 and Asp146) in the beginning of the four EF-loops of EoCen. Aromatic-sensitized Tb³⁺ fluorescence indicates that the aspartic acid residues are very important for the metal-binding of EoCen, except for Asp73 (in EF-loop II). Resonance light scattering (RLS) measurements for different metal ions (Ca²⁺ and Tb³⁺) binding proteins suggest that the order of four conserved aspartic acid residues for contributing to the self-assembly of EoCen is Asp37 > Asp146 > Asp110 > Asp73. Cross-linking experiment also exhibits that Asp37 and Asp146 play critical role in the self-assembly of EoCen. Asp37, in site I, which is located in the N-terminal domain, plays the most important role in the metal ion-dependent self-assembly of EoCen, and there is cooperativity between N-terminal and C-terminal domain (especially the site IV). In addition, the dependence of Tb³⁺ induced self-assembly of EoCen and the mutants on various factors, including ionic strength and pH, were characterized using RLS. Finally, 2-p-toluidinylnaphthalene-6-sulfonate (TNS) binding, ionic strength and pH control experiments indicate that in the process of EoCen self-assembly, molecular interactions are mediated by both electrostatic and hydrophobic forces, and the hydrophobic interaction has the important status.     

Peptide analogs from E-cadherin with different calcium-binding affinities.

Cadherins are a family of calcium-dependent cell-surface proteins that are fundamental in controlling the development and maintenance of tissues. Motif B of E-cadherin seems to be a crucial calcium-binding site as single point mutations (D134A and D134K) completely inactivate its adhesion activity. We analyzed peptide models corresponding to motif B (amino acids 128-144) as well as selected mutations of this motif. Our NMR studies showed that this motif B sequence is actually an active calcium-binding region, even in the absence of the rest of the cadherin molecule. We found that the binding affinity of this motif is very sensitive to mutations. For example, our peptide P128-144 with the native calcium-binding sequence has an affinity of Kd 0.4 mM, whereas the mutants P128-144/ D134A and P128-144/D134K containing the replacement of Asp134 by Ala and Lys, have Kd values of only 1.5 and 11 mM, respectively. Removing Asp at position 134, which correlates with the loss of adhesion activity, decreases calcium-binding affinity 20-fold. Ala132, along with residues Asp134, Asp136 and Asn143, is involved in calcium binding in solution. We also demonstrated that the calcium-binding affinity can be increased 3-fold when an additional Asp is introduced at position 132. In 50% organic solvent, this binding affinity of peptide P128-144/A132D (17-mer) from E-cadherin is similar to that of peptide P72-100/C73-77-91A (29-mer) from alpha-lactalbumin.     

Engineering new metal specificity in EF-hand peptides

Peptides (33-34 amino acids long) corresponding to the helix-turn-helix (EF-hand) motif of the calcium binding site I of Paramecium tetraurelia calmodulin have been synthesized. The linear sequence was unable to acquire a native-like conformation and calcium binding. However, incorporation of a well-positioned disulfide bond bridging the two putative helical regions greatly improved the ordered structure and binding properties. Analyzed by electrospray mass spectrometry, circular dichroism and time-resolved laser-induced fluorescence, such a disulfide-stabilized peptide is shown to acquire a calcium-dependent helical conformation and exhibits native-like affinity for calcium, terbium and europium ions with 30+/-1, 3.5+/-0.6 and 0.6+/-0.1 microM dissociation constants, respectively. Comparable affinities were calculated within the biological construct comprising the entire domain I of Arabidopsis taliana calmodulin. Single sequence mutation (Glu25Asp) in the binding loop of the peptide abolishes calcium affinity, but preserves lanthanide affinity, showing that metal selectivity can be modulated by specific mutations. Such disulfide-stabilized peptides represent useful models to engineer metal specificity in new calmodulin proteins, facilitating the development of new systems to monitor metal pollution in biosensors and to increase metal binding capability of bacterial and plant cells in bioremediation techniques.     

Expression in Escherichia coli of full-length and mutant rat brain calbindin D28. Comparison with the purified native protein

Studies of vitamin D-dependent 28-kilodalton calcium binding protein (calbindin D28) have been hindered by difficulties in purifying large amounts of the protein. In order to overcome this problem, we cloned and expressed a full-length rat brain calbindin D28 cDNA. In addition, we isolated and purified to homogeneity, native rat brain calbindin D28. The isolated native protein has an apparent molecular mass of 27 kDa and properties similar to those of the well-characterized chicken calbindin D28. It has an acidic isoelectric point (approximately 4.5), a high affinity for calcium, and an amino terminus blocked to Edman degradation. The properties of the native and the recombinant proteins were examined by gel electrophoresis, isoelectric focusing, protein sequencing, amino acid composition analysis, and calcium binding assays. We demonstrated that: (i) the authentic and the full-length recombinant proteins have similar molecular weights and isoelectric points; (ii) the proteins have the same amino acid composition; (iii) the proteins bind calcium in a similar manner; (iv) the absence of a blocking NH2-terminal group in the recombinant protein does not appreciably influence the binding of calcium. To further examine the calcium binding properties of this protein, we constructed deletion mutants lacking one or both of the two putative degenerated calcium binding sites (EF hand regions). These deletions resulted in smaller proteins that still bound calcium. The ability to express and purify calbindin D28 and mutants thereof should allow the systematic elucidation of structure-function relationships in this class of calcium binding proteins.     

Comparative analysis of sequences of protein D2 from photosystem 2 reaction center and various Ca 2+-binding proteins

The amino acid sequence of D2 protein was compared with those of calcium binding proteins and receptor for calcium channel blockers in connection with the data showing the participation of Ca2+ in photosystem 2 electron transport and the inhibition of this process by calmodulin antagonists, calcium channel blockers and local anesthetics. Protein D2 possesses a pattern analogous to the "EF-hand" sites of the calcium binding proteins. Comparison of the amino acid sequence of the calmodulin fragment binding the phenothiazine type calmodulin antagonists with the amino acid sequence of D2 protein and calcium channel protein revealed a high degree of sequence identity. Common structural features take place also between the membrane spanning segment III of D2 protein, which contains the tyrosine residue (161), responsible for ESR-signal IIS, and the membrane segment IVS5 of calcium channel protein. A model explaining the mechanism of calcium function in the oxygen-evolving system is proposed.     

Calbindin D28k exhibits properties characteristic of a Ca2+ sensor

Calbindin D(28k) is a member of the calmodulin superfamily of Ca(2+)-binding proteins and contains six EF-hands. The protein is generally believed to function as a Ca(2+) buffer, but the studies presented in this work indicate that it may also act as a Ca(2+) sensor. The results show that Mg(2+) binds to the same sites as Ca(2+) with an association constant of approximately 1.4.10(3) m(-1) in 0.15 m KCl. The four high affinity sites in calbindin D(28k) bind Ca(2+) in a non-sequential, parallel manner. In the presence of physiological concentrations of Mg(2+), the Ca(2+) affinity is reduced by a factor of 2, and the cooperativity, which otherwise is modest, increases. Based on the binding constants determined in the presence of physiological salt concentrations, we estimate that at the Ca(2+) concentration in a resting cell calbindin D(28k) is saturated to 40-75% with Mg(2+) but to less than 9% with Ca(2+). In contrast, the protein is expected to be nearly fully saturated with Ca(2+) at the Ca(2+) level of an activated cell. A substantial conformational change is observed upon Ca(2+) binding, but only minor structural changes take place upon Mg(2+) binding. This suggests that calbindin D(28k) undergoes Ca(2+)-induced structural changes upon Ca(2+) activation of a cell. Thus, calbindin D(28k) displays several properties that would be expected for a protein involved in Ca(2+)-induced signal transmission and hence may function not only as a Ca(2+) buffer but also as a Ca(2+) sensor. Digestion patterns resulting from limited proteolysis of the protein suggest that the loop of EF-hand 2, a variant site that does not bind Ca(2+), becomes exposed upon Ca(2+) binding.     

Structure of the N-terminal calcium sensor domain of centrin reveals the biochemical basis for domain-specific function

Centrin is an essential component of microtubule-organizing centers in organisms ranging from algae and yeast to humans. It is an EF-hand calcium-binding protein with homology to calmodulin but distinct calcium binding properties. In a previously proposed model, the C-terminal domain of centrin serves as a constitutive anchor to target proteins, and the N-terminal domain serves as the sensor of calcium signals. The three-dimensional structure of the N-terminal domain of Chlamydomonas rheinhardtii centrin has been determined in the presence of calcium by solution NMR spectroscopy. The domain is found to occupy an open conformation typical of EF-hand calcium sensors. Comparison of the N- and C-terminal domains of centrin reveals a structural and biochemical basis for the domain specificity of interactions with its cellular targets and the distinct nature of centrin relative to other EF-hand proteins. An NMR titration of the centrin N-terminal domain with a fragment of the known centrin target Sfi1 reveals binding of the peptide to a discrete site on the protein, which supports the proposal that the N-terminal domain serves as a calcium sensor in centrin.     

Quantitative measurements of the cooperativity in an EF-hand protein with sequential calcium binding.

Positive cooperativity, defined as an enhancement of the ligand affinity at one site as a consequence of binding the same type of ligand at another site, is a free energy coupling between binding sites. It can be present both in systems with sites having identical ligand affinities and in systems where the binding sites have different affinities. When the sites have widely different affinities such that they are filled with ligand in a sequential manner, it is often difficult to quantify or even detect the positive cooperativity, if it occurs. This study presents verification and quantitative measurements of the free energy coupling between the two calcium binding sites in a mutant form of calbindin D9k. Wild-type calbindin D9k binds two calcium ions with similar affinities and positive cooperativity--the free energy coupling, delta delta G, is around -8 kJ.mol-1 (Linse S, et al., 1991, Biochemistry 30: 154-162). The mutant, with the substitution Asn 56-->Ala, binds calcium in a sequential manner. In the present work we have taken advantage of the variations among different metal ions in terms of their preferences for the two binding sites in calbindin D9k. Combined studies of the binding of Ca2+, Cd2+, and La3+ have allowed us to conclude that in this mutant delta delta G < -6.4 kJ.mol-1, and that Cd2+ and La3+ also bind to this protein with positive cooperativity. The results justify the use of the (Ca2+)1 state of the Asn 56-->Ala mutant, as well as the (Cd2+)1 state of the wild type, as models for the half-saturated states along the two pathways of cooperative Ca2+ binding in calbindin D9k.     

Identification of a novel human subfamily of mitochondrial carriers with calcium-binding domains

Aralar1 and citrin were identified as calcium binding aspartate/glutamate carriers (AGC) in mitochondria. The presence of calcium binding motifs facing the extramitochondrial space allows the regulation of the transport activity of these carriers by cytosolic calcium and provides a new mechanism to transduce calcium signals in mitochondria without the requirement of calcium entry in the organelle. We now report the complete characterization of a second subfamily of human calcium binding mitochondrial carriers named SCaMC (short calcium-binding mitochondrial carriers). We have identified three SCaMC genes in the human genome. All code for highly conserved proteins (about 70-80% identity), of about 500 amino acids with a characteristic mitochondrial carrier domain at the C terminus, and an N-terminal extension harboring four EF-hand binding motifs with high similarity to calmodulin. All SCaMC proteins were found to be located exclusively in mitochondria, and their N-terminal extensions were dispensable for the correct mitochondrial targeting of the polypeptides. SCaMC-1 is the human orthologue of the rabbit Efinal protein, which was reported to be located in peroxisomes, and SCaMC-2 is the human orthologue of the rat MCSC protein, described as up-regulated by dexamethasone in AR42J cells. One of the SCaMC genes, SCaMC-2, has four variants generated by alternative splicing, resulting in proteins with a common C terminus but with variations in their N-terminal halves, including the loss of one to three EF-hand motifs. These results make SCaMC one of most complex subfamilies of mitochondrial carriers and suggest that the large number of isoforms and splice variants may confer different calcium sensitivity to the transport activity of these carriers.     

Distribution of Calretinin, Calbindin D28k, and Parvalbumin in Subcellular Fractions of Rat Cerebellum: Effects of Calcium

Abstract: The distribution of calretinin, calbindin D28k, and parvalbumin was examined in subcellular fractions prepared from rat cerebellum and analyzed by immunoblot. Calretinin was also quantified by radioimmunoassay. As expected, all three soluble, EF-hand calcium-binding proteins were predominantly localized in the cytosolic fraction. Calretinin and calbindin D28k were also detected in membrane fractions. Calretinin was more abundant in synaptic membrane than in microsomal fractions. The cerebellar microsomal fraction contained the greatest concentration of membrane-associated calbindin D28k. The association of calretinin and calbindin D28k with membrane fractions was decreased in samples prepared or incubated in low calcium. Quantification of calretinin in subcellular fractions of rat cerebellum revealed a greater amount of calretinin in cytosolic fractions prepared or incubated in low calcium and reduced amounts of calretinin in all membrane fractions incubated in low calcium with the exception of the mitochondrial fraction. These results imply that calretinin and calbindin D28k might have physiological target molecules that are associated with, or are components of, brain membranes.