Characteristics and mechanism of IFN-gamma-induced protection of human tumor cells from lysis by lymphokine-activated killer cells

IFN-gamma has been shown to reduce the sensitivity of tumor cells to lysis by NK cells. The close relationship between NK cells and lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells has prompted us to investigate whether IFN-gamma pre-treatment also affects the sensitivity of tumor cells to lysis by LAK. We have shown previously that IFN-gamma can induce a significant reduction in the sensitivity of both cultured and fresh (surgically obtained) human tumor cells to lysis by LAK. Herein we show that changes in the sensitivity to LAK lysis of cultured human tumor cells can be induced by as little as 1 to 10 U/ml of IFN-gamma; a dose well within the range that can be achieved in vivo. Protection is induced within hours after treatment with IFN-gamma and is dependent on the continued presence of IFN-gamma. Tumor cells cultured in IFN-gamma for several days remain less sensitive to lysis and do not become refractory to IFN-gamma-mediated protection. In the absence of IFN-gamma, treated tumor cells regain "normal" sensitivity to lysis within 48 to 72 h. We have also investigated the mechanisms by which IFN-gamma reduces tumor cell sensitivity to LAK lysis using cold target competition, monolayer depletion, direct binding, and kinetic assays. IFN-gamma pre-treatment does not alter the kinetics of tumor cell lysis by LAK. Our data are most compatible with a model in which IFN-gamma reduces the ability of a subpopulation of tumor cells to induce the LAK effector cell to initiate lysis. These results are closely parallel to observations made on the IFN-mediated protection of targets from NK lysis and support the notion that NK- and LAK-mediated lysis are closely related. These results may have significance in vivo because high levels of IFN-gamma may be present at the tumor site or may be induced after therapeutic immunomodulation.     

Interferon is able to reduce tumor cell susceptibility to human lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells

It is known that IL-2 induces lymphocytes to produce interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and this IFN type is particularly efficient in inducing tumor cell resistance to natural killer (NK) cell-mediated lysis. We have investigated the effect of IFN on tumor cell sensitivity to LAK cell-mediated cytotoxicity. Pretreatment of the human K562 leukemia and HHMS melanoma with IFN-gamma and the Daudi lymphoma with IFN-alpha caused a significant reduction in sensitivity to lysis by human LAK cells generated in vitro in the presence of human recombinant IL-2 (100 U/ml). The LAK activity was mediated by cells expressing NK cell markers (CD16,NKH1) as well as by cells with T cell markers (CD3, CD5). IFN-treated K562 cells were protected from lysis mediated by all these populations. Supernatants from LAK cultures containing IFN-gamma were able to induce NK and LAK resistance when used to pretreat K562 overnight. Antibodies to IFN-gamma but not to IFN-alpha were able to neutralize this activity. Taken together, these results indicate that the production of IFN-gamma by LAK cells may be of importance in induction of tumor cell resistance to LAK cell-mediated lysis.     

Cytokines alter target cell susceptibility to lysis. II. Evaluation of tumor infiltrating lymphocytes

We studied the susceptibility of autologous and allogeneic tumors to lysis by human tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) after pre-incubation of the tumors with human rIFN-gamma and human rTNF-alpha. Preincubation of the tumor lines with IFN-gamma or TNF enhanced susceptibility to lysis significantly; the combination of both cytokines was more effective than either alone. Pretreatment for at least 24 h was required to enhance lytic susceptibility and maximal lysis was observed after pretreatment for 48 to 72 h. Highly specific TIL lysed only their autologous tumor targets and failed to lyse cytokine pretreated allogeneic tumor cells. In TIL populations with varying specificity, cytokine pretreatment of targets enhanced autologous lysis as well as allogeneic lysis. This cytokine-mediated effect could also be observed in a lectin-dependent cytotoxicity assay and did not correlate directly with enhanced expression of MHC class I Ag or the adhesion molecules LFA-3 and ICAM-1. These results suggest that enhancement of lysis may occur at a postbinding stage by making the target cell more sensitive to the cytotoxic factors delivered by the killer cell. The fact that lysis of cytokine treated targets by cells with LAK activity was not enhanced suggests that cells with lymphokine-activated killer activity and tumor-derived T cells kill tumor targets via different mechanisms.     

Protection of cultured human monocytes from lymphokine-activated killer-mediated lysis by IFN-gamma

We have recently reported that IL 2-activated killer (LAK) cells are capable of lysing cultured human monocytes. In an effort to protect autologous monocytes from lysis, we treated monolayer cultures of adherent PBMC with various doses of human rIFN-gamma and assessed their susceptibility to LAK cells. IFN-gamma was shown to lessen the sensitivity of monocytes to lysis in a dose-dependent manner. Similar treatment of FMEX, an NK-resistant melanoma tumor cell line, with IFN-gamma did not affect its susceptibility to LAK lysis. Kinetic studies demonstrated that as little as 2 h incubation with IFN-gamma was sufficient for the protective effects to take effect. Additionally, monocytes that were pulsed with IFN-gamma for 2 h, washed, and then cultured in medium alone retained their resistance to lysis for at least 3 days. Cold target inhibition studies showed that IFN-treated and untreated monocytes could effectively compete with each other for binding sites on LAK cells. Furthermore, binding studies demonstrated that there was no significant difference between the number of conjugates formed by using either IFN-treated or untreated monocytes. This indicates that resistance to lysis induced by IFN treatment affects a post-binding event and not an initial recognition signal. From these studies, it was apparent that treatment of monocytes with IFN-gamma lessened their sensitivity to LAK-mediated lysis. Thus, it may be possible through a specific sequence of IFN-gamma and IL-2 treatment that LAK activity could be manipulated against some tumor cells, but not normal cells, to abrogate some of the toxicity seen with this type of cancer therapy.     

Ability of cell-sized beads bearing tumor cell membrane proteins to stimulate LAK cells to secrete interferon-gamma and tumor necrosis factor-alpha

We recently reported that lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cells were stimulated to release both interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) when stimulated by a variety of tumor cells. We proposed then that the released cytokines may play a role in mediating tumor cell regression in vivo. In this paper, we provide further information on the nature of the signals, provided by the tumor cells (K562 erythroleukemia), that stimulate LAK cells to secrete IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha. Using a previously published protocol for coating tumor-membrane molecules onto cell-sized hydrophobic beads (also called pseudocytes), we demonstrate that the signal provided by the tumor cell is membrane associated. Beads coated with K562 membranes stimulated LAK cells to release IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha. The pretreatment of these beads with trypsin and sodium periodate eliminated the ability of these pseudocytes to stimulate cytokine release in LAK cells. The glycoproteins that stimulate LAK cells to secrete IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha were further enriched by their ability to bind concanavalin A (Con A, Jack Bean). To determine if the tumor-associated molecules that stimulate LAK cells to release IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha are also the molecules involved in mediating tumor cell lysis, we tested the ability of the Con A binding and nonbinding proteins to inhibit the LAK cell-mediated lysis of K562 cells. Our results demonstrate that molecules that inhibited LAK cell-mediated cytotoxicity were not enriched by Con A. These results are therefore consistent with the conclusion that different sets of tumor-associated molecules are involved in the stimulation of LAK cells to secrete cytokine and in the induction of LAK cells to mediate tumor cell cytolysis.     

Interferon-gamma-treated K562 target cells distinguish functional NK cells from lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells

In vitro incubation of the erythroleukemic cell line K562 with interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) renders these cells relatively resistant to natural killer (NK) cell lysis. However, such treatment does not alter their sensitivity to LAK cell lysis. Thus, the lytic susceptibility of interferon-gamma-treated K562 (I-K562) cells to LAK cells as opposed to its relative resistance to NK cell lysis provides a functional assay to help distinguish these two types of effector cells. The relative resistance of I-K562 for NK cell-mediated lysis was not secondary to the release of soluble factors or the frequency of Leu-19+, CD3+ T cells, residual IFN-gamma, or expression of MHC Class I molecules. Coincubation of I-K562 cells with NK or LAK cells overnight did not appreciably change the pattern of lytic responses against K562 and I-K562 target cells. However, incubation of PBMC in vitro with I-K562 but not native K562 in the presence of r-IL-2 leads to a marked decrease in the generation of LAK cells. The inhibition of LAK cell generation was not secondary to differences in the consumption of bioactive levels of IL-2. Differences in the lytic capability of NK and LAK effector cells suggest heterogeneity among cells that mediate such non-MHC-restricted lysis. Use was made of cells from a patient with a large granular lymphocyte lymphoproliferative disease (greater than 85% Leu-19+) to determine if such cells could be used to distinguish clonal population of cells which would represent NK or LAK cell function. Of interest was the finding that such cells, even after incubation in vitro with IL-2, showed lytic function representative of NK cells but not LAK cells. Data concerning the inhibition of LAK cell generation by I-K562 cells have important implications for future therapeutic trials of IFN-gamma and IL-2 in the treatment of human malignancies.     

The human lymphokine-activated killer cell system. V. Purified recombinant interleukin 2 activates cytotoxic lymphocytes which lyse both natural killer-resistant autologous and allogeneic tumors and trinitrophenyl-modified autologous peripheral blood lymphocytes

Culture of human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in purified natural or recombinant interleukin 2 in the absence of exogenous antigen or mitogen causes the differentiation of nonlytic precursor cells into lymphokine-activated killers (LAK). A titration of purified Jurkat IL-2 (BRMP, FCRC, NIH) IL-2 showed that the relatively low concentration of 5 U/ml was optimal for LAK activation. When the responding PBL were pretreated with either mitomycin C or gamma irradiation, LAK activation did not occur, indicating that proliferation, in addition to differentiation, is required. The spectrum of target cells susceptible to LAK lysis in a 4-hr chromium-51-release assay includes fresh NK-resistant tumor cells and trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified autologous PBL. Unmodified PBL are not lysed. Cold target inhibition studies indicated that LAK lysis of autologous TNP-PBL is totally inhibited by fresh tumors cells, and that tumor lysis is inhibited by TNP-PBL. Additionally, allogeneic tumors totally inhibit lysis of autologous tumor cells in other cold target studies. These results demonstrate that the lytic activity expressed by LAK is not HLA restricted, is not limited to tumor cells, and is "polyspecific" as indicated by the cross-reactive recognition of multiple target cell types in these cold target inhibition studies.     

Effects of human alveolar macrophages on the induction of lymphokine (IL 2)-activated killer cells

Normal human alveolar macrophages (AM) significantly and reproducibly suppress induction of IL 2-activated killer (LAK) cell activity against allogeneic Burkitt's lymphoma (Daudi) cells. Incubation of purified peripheral blood lymphocytes for 4 days with autologous AM and 1 U/ml of IL 2 resulted in AM-mediated suppression of LAK activity, whereas peripheral blood monocytes isolated freshly by centrifugal elutriation from the same donor potentiated induction of LAK activity by IL 2. The suppression of LAK cell induction by human AM was dependent on the density of AM added to the lymphocyte cultures. Recombinant IFN-gamma did not affect AM-mediated suppression of LAK cell induction by IL 2. Both AM and monocytes stimulated with lipopolysaccharide markedly suppressed LAK cell induction by IL 2. AM-mediated down-regulation was seen only when AM were added immediately after the start of incubation of lymphocytes with IL 2; AM potentiated LAK activity when added 1 day later. Similar AM-mediated suppression of LAK cell induction was observed with four lines of allogeneic lung cancer cells as targets for LAK activity. These results indicate that AM may be important in regulation of in situ induction of LAK activity in the lung.     

Tumor targets stimulate IL-2 activated killer cells to produce interferon-gamma and tumor necrosis factor

Lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells are cytotoxic for a variety of autologous and allogeneic tumor cells as well as modified autologous cells. It is assumed that LAK cells lyse their targets solely by direct cell to cell contact, possibly involving the degranulation and exocytosis of pore-forming elements, similar to that observed with cytotoxic T lymphocytes and NK cells. Reported here are studies demonstrating that LAK cells release factor(s) that are cytotoxic for a human breast carcinoma cell line, MCF-7, when stimulated with tumor cells. The factor(s) are slow acting and maximum cytotoxicity is observed only in a 72-h cytotoxic assay. The ability of LAK cells to secrete cytotoxic factor(s) is dependent on both the ratio of LAK cells to stimulating tumor cells as well as the length of their coincubation. A number of similarly slow acting cytokines that are cytostatic and/or cytotoxic for tumor cells have been described. We tested the ability of specific polyclonal antibodies directed against TNF, IFN-alpha, IFN-beta, and IFN-gamma to neutralize the cytotoxic supernatant activity. Only antibodies specific for IFN-gamma and TNF were neutralizing. We measured the amounts of IFN-gamma and TNF in the cytotoxic supernatants and determined that increased amounts of IFN-gamma and TNF were released after LAK cell-tumor cell interactions compared to supernatants of LAK cells alone or tumor cell alone. Comparable concentrations of human rIFN-gamma and rTNF resulted in similar levels (50 to 90%) of MCF-7 cell cytotoxicity as those observed with the stimulated LAK cell supernatants. We thus concluded that the majority of the cytotoxic activity released by LAK cells when stimulated with tumor cells was attributed to the synergistic activities of IFN-gamma and TNF. The significance of these observations in relation to the possible mechanisms by which LAK cells mediate cytolysis is discussed.     

Sensitivity of ovarian tumor cells to effector cells generated by various biological response modifiers

The sensitivity of freshly derived human ovarian tumors (FOT) to various allogeneic cytotoxic effector cells stimulated by recombinant interleukin 2 (rIL-2), recombinant interferon alpha 2 (rIFN-alpha 2), OK-432, and concanavalin A was examined using the 51Cr release assay. Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of normal female donors were used as source of effector cells. Incubation of PBL with these biological response modifiers for 24 h generated effector cells with high natural killer activity, and only 20% (1/5) of the FOT examined were susceptible to lysis. By contrast, 83% (5/6) of the FOT were sensitive to lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells generated by rIL-2. OK-432 and concanavalin A activation of PBL also generated cytotoxic cells, though the cytotoxic activity against FOT was much less than that obtained by LAK cells. The addition of OK-432 to LAK culture medium containing rIL-2 generated effector cells with higher cytotoxicity against FOT than cultures with IL-2 alone. However, the addition of rIFN-alpha 2 in LAK culture medium resulted in the generation of effector cells with lower cytotoxicity. The addition of rIL-2, rIFN-alpha 2, or OK-432 to LAK cells during the in vitro cytotoxicity assay had no significant effect. When FOT target cells were pretreated with OK-432 they became more sensitive to LAK than nontreated tumor cells. However, pretreatment with rIL-2 or rIFN-alpha 2 did not influence cytolysis. These results suggest that the generation of LAK cells in vitro using rIL-2 plus OK-432 may be a more effective way to prepare these cells for adoptive immunotherapy in the treatment of ovarian cancer.     

Induction of lymphokine-activated killer cell against human leukemia cells in vitro

The induction of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells against fresh human leukemia cells was investigated. Two thirds of the 62 leukemias examined were susceptible to the lytic effect of allogeneic IL-2 induced LAK cells in vitro. No substantial differences could be detected between myeloid or lymphoid leukemias or with regard to the FAB subtype or the immunophenotype. Culturing mononuclear cells from peripheral blood or bone marrow of leukemia patients with IL-2 resulted in an expansion of residual large granular lymphocytes and development of cytotoxic activity. The combination of IL-2 with IFN-gamma or the presence of tumor cells during the activation process led to an enhancement of LAK cell cytotoxicity. These results suggest that LAK cells may be useful in the treatment of leukemia.     

CEA and NCA expressed by colon carcinoma cells affect their interaction with and lysability by activated lymphocytes.

Heterogeneous lysability by interleukin-2 activated lymphocytes (LAK) and other immune effectors was observed in the human colon-carcinoma lines LoVo/Dx, LoVo/H and HT29. The tumor cells with high susceptibility to LAK (LoVo/Dx, HT29) expressed higher amounts of the adhesion molecules ICAMl, LFA3 and NCA/CEA than cells with low LAK sensitivity (LoVo/H). Monoclonal antibodies against these molecules caused a marked reduction of lysis by LAK of LoVo/Dx and HT29. A pool of these antibodies induced a nearly complete inhibition of the LAK lysis of both lines. Treatment of LoVo/Dx with differentiating agents (dimethylformamide and retinoic acid) led to a decreased expression of the adhesion molecules, including NCA, accompanied by increased resistance to LAK-mediated lysis. Moreover, the presence of CEA soluble antigen drastically inhibited the cytotoxic activity of LAK effectors against HT29 and LoVo/Dx cells, in a dose-dependent manner. These data indicate that sensitivity of colon-carcinoma cells to activated lymphocytes depends on the level of expression of adhesion molecules, including CEA and NCA. Given the role of CEA-related antigens in tumor/lymphocyte interaction, soluble CEA, frequently released by colon-carcinoma, may be involved in immunosuppressive effects induced in vivo by tumor cells.     

Preadministration of a T-suppressor factor enhances tumor immunity in DBA/2 mice

Summary Human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBM) activated with recombinant interleukin-2 (IL-2) generate potent lytic activity (LAK) against a variety of malignant cells. IL-2 alone is sufficient for LAK generation, but high concentrations are needed to generate optimal cytotoxicity. Our recent studies based on combinations of biological agents indicated that alternative activation pathways may exist. Synergy for LAK induction was investigated using IL-2 and tumor necrosis factor- (TNF). Single-cell suspensions of primary human lung carcinomas were prepared from seven established cell lines and 32 fresh tumor specimens. Not only were all cell lines sensitive to allogeneic LAK, but also all fresh tumors were sensitive to some degree to both autologous and allogeneic LAK lysis measured by a 4-h ⁵¹Cr-release assay. LAK-mediated cytotoxicity, induced with a combination of human recombinant IL-2 (Cetus, 100 U/ml) and TNF (Genentech, 500 U/ml), showed a mean fourfold increase (range 0.7–16.3) over IL-2 alone. No lytic activity was generated from PBM incubated with media or TNF alone. The sequence dependence of adding IL-2 and TNF in enhancing cytolytic activity was also studied. In vitro kinetics data revealed that the addition of TNF 2–6 h before the addition of IL-2 greatly increased LAK activity over that obtained from the simultaneous addition of the two cytokines. These results demonstrated (a) the synergy of IL-2 and TNF for generating LAK; (b) the lysis of fresh primary lung cancer cells by LAK; and (c) the sequence dependence of IL-2 and TNF for the induction of optimal LAK activity.This work was supported by NCI Grants RO2-CA45225 and CAO 9611-01, and by an award from the Prouss Foundation     

Use of lymphokine-activated killer cells to prevent bone marrow graft rejection and lethal graft-vs-host disease

Prompted by our recent finding that lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells mediate both veto and natural suppression, we tested the ability of adoptively transferred LAK cells to block two in vivo alloreactions which complicate bone marrow transplantation: resistance to transplanted allogeneic bone marrow cells, and lethal graft-vs-host disease. Adoptive transfer of either donor type B6D2 or recipient-type B6 lymphokine-activated bone marrow cells, cells found to have strong LAK activity, abrogated or inhibited the resistance of irradiated B6 mice to both B6D2 marrow and third party-unrelated C3H marrow as measured by CFU in spleen on day 7. The ability of lymphokine-activated bone marrow cells to abrogate allogeneic resistance was eliminated by C lysis depletion of cells expressing asialo-GM1, NK1.1, and, to a variable degree, Thy-1, but not by depletion of cells expressing Lyt-2, indicating that the responsible cells had a LAK cell phenotype. Similar findings were obtained by using splenic LAK cells generated by 3 to 7 days of culture with rIL-2. Demonstration that allogeneic resistance could be blocked by a cloned LAK cell line provided direct evidence that LAK cells inhibit allogeneic resistance. In addition to inhibiting allogeneic resistance, adoptively transferred recipient-type LAK cells prevented lethal graft-vs-host disease, and permitted long term engraftment of allogeneic marrow. Irradiation prevented LAK cell inhibition of both allogeneic resistance and lethal graft-vs-host disease. These findings suggest that adoptive immunotherapy with LAK cells may prove useful in preventing graft rejection and graft-versus-host disease in human bone marrow transplant recipients.     

Factors determining the ability of cytokine-activated killer cells to lyse human ovarian carcinoma targets

Lysis of human ovarian carcinoma cells by natural killer (NK) cells, interferon-alpha activated NK cells (alpha-NK) and lymphokine-activated killers cells (LAK) was studied using both fresh tumor cells and a cell line (HEY) as targets. A clonogenic assay to measure cell kill was more sensitive than a 4-h 51Cr release assay. Both assays showed that single cells were more effectively lysed than were tumor clumps (spheroids). Freshly isolated tumor cells studied in the 51Cr release assay appeared equally susceptible to lysis by LAK cells whether in the form of clumps or single cells, but NK and alpha-NK effectors appeared much less effective in lysing susceptible target cells when they were in clumps. Tumor cells from some patients showed marked resistance to lysis by NK and alpha-NK cells in fractions enriched for clonogenic cells, even when tested in a single cell-suspension, whereas LAK cells were always cytolytic. These data suggest that intrinsic resistance of ovarian carcinoma to lysis by LAKs is unlikely to explain failure of LAK + IL-2 therapy to eradicate tumor in vivo.     

Antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity mediated by murine lymphocytes activated in recombinant interleukin 2

The incubation of murine splenocytes in recombinant interleukin 2 (RIL 2) gives rise to lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells that can lyse fresh, NK-resistant tumor cells but not normal cells in 4-hr 51Cr-release assays. Lysis by this IL 2-activated cell population was enhanced up to 100-fold by prior reaction of target cells with specific antisera reactive with antigens on the target cells. This antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC) also resulted in lysis of fresh normal target cells, which are not usually susceptible to LAK lysis. The ADCC was evident after 24 hr of incubation of splenocytes in RIL 2, but peak lytic activity was reached after 3 to 4 days of incubation. The concentrations of RIL 2 needed for the in vitro activation of the effectors in order to attain maximal ADCC was between 100 and 3000 U/ml and parallel the IL 2 concentrations required to generate LAK cells. ADCC mediated by IL 2-activated splenocytes was completely blocked by anti-FcR monoclonal antibodies. Although antisera directed against MHC antigens were used in most experiments, anti-B16 monoclonal antibodies have also shown the ability to induce ADCC mediated by RIL 2-activated syngeneic and allogeneic cells. Treatment of the precursor splenocyte populations with anti-asialo GM1 and complement eliminated the direct LAK activity and the antibody-dependent cytotoxicity, suggesting that both direct and indirect tumor cell lysis may be caused by the same effector cell. ADCC mediated by LAK cell populations represents another possible mechanism for the in vivo therapeutic effects of these cells.     

Inhibition of lymphokine-activated killer cell generation by cultured tumor cell lines in vitro

Summary The co-culture of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) with high concentrations of interleukin 2 normally generates lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells capable of indiscriminate lysis of tumor targets. However, the addition of certain cell-line-derived tumor cells to the LAK generation cultures within the first 48 h of culture initiation resulted in the suppression of the LAK cytotoxicity measured after 3–4 days of culture. Suppression could be achieved with tumor cell:PBMC ratios as low as 1:50 when tumor cells were derived from melanoma and colorectal cancer (G361, COLO320, HT-29), but suppression was not observed with cells from the breast cancer cell line SKBr3. No suppression of LAK generation was observed with normal epithelial cells from colon or breast, with autologous or allogeneic lymphoblasts, or with allogeneic vascular endothelial cells. Suppression was independent of the removal of adherent cells from PBMC, could not be prevented by indomethacin and was not attributable to interleukin 2 absorption/adsorption by tumor cells. The suppressive activity of some tumor cells could be augmented by preculture in recombinant gamma interferon. Serum-free supernatants from G361, COLO320 and HT-29 (but not SKBr3 or endothelial cells) were also highly suppressive towards the generation of LAK cells. The elaboration by tumor cells of fractors capable of inhibiting LAK generation may partially explain the failure of LAK/interleukin 2 therapy in some experimental and clinical protocols.     

Lymphokine activated killer cells

Various subpopulations of human leukocytes may be induced by lymphokines to exert cytotoxic activity. In man major histocompatibility complex non-restricted tumor cell lysis by interleukin-2 (IL-2) induced peripheral blood lymphocytes is attributed mainly to natural killer cells. These T cell receptor negative large granular lymphocytes are called lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cells. In order to explore the potential of LAK cells in tumor therapy, several clinical studies have been conducted, using IL-2 alone or in combination with ex vivo IL-2-activated peripheral blood lymphocytes. Objective responses have reproducibly been achieved only in renal cell carcinoma and malignant melanoma and were associated with considerable toxicity. In view of restricted efficacy and increasing doubts as to whether LAK cells indeed account for the in vivo observed responses, more recent strategies focus on tumor antigen specific cytotoxic T cells or tumor infiltrating lymphocytes. Successful translation of this approach into clinical practice, however, may be dependent on some basic problems of tumor immunology to be solved which were thought to be by-passed by the LAK cell approach.     

Mouse tumors are heterogeneous in their susceptibility to syngeneic lymphokine-activated killer cells and delineate functional subsets in such effectors

We have analyzed whether lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells, generated from C57BL/6J (B6) spleen cells at different times after recombinant interleukin-2 (rIL-2) culture, could be heterogeneous in their ability to lyse a variety of tumor targets. When tested 3 days after exposure to 250 U/ml rIL-2 (day-3 LAK cells) a significant lysis was detected with the natural-killer(NK)-sensitive YAC lymphoma, the NK-resistant P815 mastocytoma, three different syngeneic melanomas and a syngeneic fibrosarcoma (group 1 targets), whereas no lysis was observed with a reticulum cell sarcoma, two different lymphomas or concanavalin A blasts, all of B6 origin (group 2 targets). LAK cells cultured for 5 days, however, lysed group 2 targets and showed a parallel increase of cytotoxic activity against group 1 targets. At day 7, LAK activity declined on all targets examined. In cold-target inhibition studies, the lysis of group 1 tumor targets by day-3 or day-5 LAK cells could be inhibited only by group 1 and not by group 2 unlabelled tumor cells. All group 1 tumors could effectively compete each other. Conversely, the lysis of group 2 tumor targets by day-5 LAK cells was inhibited by both group 1 and group 2 targets. These data indicate the presence of separate LAK effectors that appear to arise with different time kinetics and have different recognition structures. In vitro antibody depletion at the effector level showed that day-3 LAK cells with cytotoxic activity against group 1 tumors were ASGM1+. Day-5 LAK cells included both ASGM1+ and Lyt2+ effectors and both populations, although to a different extent, contributed to the lysis of all targets. Our results indicate that LAK cells are functionally heterogeneous. This heterogeneity is defined by their susceptible target cells and cannot be ascribed to different (Lyt2+ versus ASGM1+) lineages.     

Toxic effects of interleukin-2-activated lymphocytes on vascular endothelial cells

IL-2-activated lymphocytes (LAK cells) show increased adherence to, and killing of, human vascular endothelial cells compared to resting lymphocytes. In the present work, we have found that supernatants from LAK cell cultures also are toxic to human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC) when tested for 48 h in a neutral red uptake assay. Recombinant TNF-alpha and IFN-gamma at high concentrations are also toxic under the same test conditions, and TNF-alpha was directly detected in LAK cell supernatants. An inconsistent inhibition of toxicity was found with anti-TNF-alpha whereas anti IFN-gamma antibodies had a partial inhibitory effect. The susceptibility of HUVEC to cellular killing by LAK cells could be up- and down-regulated with insulin-like growth factor I and IFN-gamma, respectively. It is concluded that damage to vascular endothelium during high dose IL-2 treatments may be partially related to an excessive production of lymphokines such as IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha. IFN-gamma may, in addition, be protective for HUVEC during cellular interactions with LAK cells.