Compensatory growth response in three-spined stickleback in relation to feed-deprivation protocols

Different protocols of food deprivation were used to bring two groups of juvenile three-spined sticklebacks Gasterosteus aculeatus to the same reduced body mass in comparison with a control group fed daily ad libitum . One group experienced 1 week of deprivation then 2 weeks on maintenance rations. The second group experienced 1 week of ad libitum feeding followed by 2 weeks of deprivation. The deprived groups were reduced to a mean mass of c . 80% of controls. The compensatory growth response shown when ad libitum feeding was resumed was independent of the trajectory by which the three-spined sticklebacks had reached the reduced body mass. The compensatory response was sufficient to return the deprived groups to the mass and length trajectories shown by the control group within 4 weeks. There was full compensation for dry mass and total lipid, but incomplete compensation for lipid-free dry mass. Hyperphagia and increased growth efficiency were present in the re-feeding phase, but there was a lag of a week before the hyperphagia was established. The consistency of the compensatory response of immature three-spined sticklebacks provides a potential model system for the analysis and prediction of appetite and growth in teleosts.     

Comparison of compensatory growth responses of juvenile three-spined stickleback and minnow following similar food deprivation protocols

The compensatory growth responses of individual juveniles of two co- existing species were compared after identical periods of starvation to determine inter-specific similarities and differences. The carnivorous stickleback Gasterosteus aculeatus was compared with the omnivorous minnow Phoxinus phoxinus. Both species experienced 1 or 2 weeks of starvation before being re-fed ad libitum. The two species differed in their response to the starvation periods, with minnows showing a lower weight-specific loss. Both species showed compensatory responses in appetite, growth and to a lesser extent, growth efficiency. Minnows wholly compensated for 1 and 2 weeks of starvation. At the end of the experiment, sticklebacks starved for 2 weeks were still showing a compensatory response and had not achieved full compensation. The compensatory responses of the sticklebacks showed a lag of a week before developing in the re-feeding phase, whereas the response of the minnows was immediate. Analysis of lipid and dry matter concentrations suggested that the compensatory response restored reserve lipids while also bringing the fish back to the growth trajectory of continuously fed fish.     

Pattern of hyperphagia in immature three-spined sticklebacks after short-term food deprivation

Juvenile three-spined sticklebacks Gasterosteus aculeatus were fed live enchytraeid worms, and mean daily ad libitum consumption in the absence of periods of deprivation was 11·7% of initial body weight. Then, six groups of five replicate fish were subjected to 1, 3 and 6 days without food. Each period of deprivation was followed by 1 day of ad libitum feeding. The sequential order of deprivations differed between groups. Over the sequence of deprivations and re-feedings, mean cumulative consumption did not differ between groups. Mean daily consumption was 19·8% of initial body weight after a 1-day deprivation, 22·3% after 3 days and 19·5% after 6 days. However, consumption in the 24 h after a given length of deprivation also depended on the prior history of deprivation. Specific growth rate over the experiment did not differ between groups. The results provide evidence for an effective regulation of appetite in growing sticklebacks.     

Fast-growing transgenic common carp mounting compensatory growth

Compensatory growth is a phase of accelerated growth apparent when favourable conditions are restored after a period of growth depression. To investigate if F₂ common 'all-fish' growth hormone gene transgenic common carp ( Cyprinus carpio ) could mount compensatory growth, a 9 week study at 29° C was performed. The control group was fed to satiation twice a day throughout the experiment. The other two groups were deprived of feed for 1 or 2 weeks, respectively, and then fed to satiation during the re-feeding period. At the end of the experiment, the live masses of fish in the deprived groups were still significantly lower than those of the controls. During the re-feeding period, size-adjusted mean specific growth rates and mean feed intakes were significantly higher in the deprived fish than in the controls, indicating a partial compensatory growth response in these fish. No significant differences were found in food conversion efficiency between the deprived and control fish during re-feeding, suggesting that hyperphagia was the mechanism responsible for increased growth rates. The proximate composition of the deprived fish at the end of the experiment was similar to that of the control fish. This study is, to our knowledge, the first to report that fast-growing transgenic fish can achieve partial compensation of growth following starvation.     

完全或部分的食物剥夺对中华鳖(Pelodiscus sinensis)幼体补偿生长反应的影响:生长率的时间变化模式与体组成的变化

为了探究中华鳖（Pelodiscus sinensis）幼体的补偿生长能力,我们对中华鳖幼鳖（平均湿重9．56g）进行如下6种处理：饥饿0（对照）、1、2、3、4周,或者食物限制4周,即只投喂体湿重百分之一的食物;然后对各组进行饱食处理直到10周的实验结束为止。结果发现在饱食期的第一周各饥饿处理组的特殊生长率均显著高于对照组（P〈0．05）,但是终体重均没有赶上对照组。当饥饿或食物限制结束时,脂肪含量随着饥饿期的延长而降低,灰分和水分则表现出相反的变化趋势：脂肪含量显著低于对照（P〈0．05）,而灰分和水分则显著高于对照（P〈0．05）。蛋白含量则没有显著变化（P〉0．05）。实验结束时,除了灰分外（P〈0．05）,其他个体组成指标均恢复到对照组的水平。以上结果表明中华鳖幼体在饥饿胁迫下首先利用脂肪作为主要能源以维持生存,以及在该研究条件下完全的食物剥夺可以诱发其部分补偿生长反应．而部分食物剥夺则不能诱发此反应。     

The influence of previous feeding regime on the compensatory growth response of maturing and immature Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus

Alternating periods of food deprivation with those of unlimited provision of food depressed the growth of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus , below that of controls. Fish that were deprived of food and then fed on alternate weeks (1:1) were larger than those that were exposed to periods of 1 5- or 3-week deprivation and feeding (1·5:1·5 or 3:3). On receiving excess food supplies following 24 weeks on the restricted feeding regimes the previously-restricted fish grew more rapidly than the controls. The greatest compensatory growth was displayed after the 3:3 regime, followed by the 1·5: 1·5 and then the 1:1 feeding regime. At the termination of the experiment there were no significant differences in body weight between fish fed according to the different regimes during the period that food restriction was imposed. Growth patterns of the immature males and females were similar, but mature males were significantly lighter than the immature fish by the end of the experiment. Both immature and maturing fish displayed a compensatory growth response on return to adequate feeding. Beginning food restriction in May did not influence the proportions of male fish ( c . 60%) which were mature in the autumn.     

Compensatory growth in juvenile roach Rutilus caspicus: effect of starvation and re‐feeding on growth and digestive surface area

The aim of this study was to investigate compensatory growth in juvenile Rutilus caspicus during starvation and re‐feeding periods. The results confirmed the existence of compensatory growth in R. caspicus which depended on the duration of food deprivation. Complete compensatory growth occurred in the fish that were food deprived for at least 3 weeks. Starvation and re‐feeding had no significant effect on the digestive somatic index and intestinal surface areas in the fish that were food deprived for 1 week, while they showed a significant decrease and increase, during starvation and re‐feeding in the fish that were food deprived for 2 and 3 weeks. This knowledge may have application in aquaculture, as appropriate exploitation of compensatory growth can give increased growth rate and feeding efficiency.     

The tradeoff between catch-up growth and escape speed: variation between habitats in the cost of compensation

Compensatory growth is the faster-than-normal growth that some species exhibit after a period of resource deprivation. Using three-spined sticklebacks as model species we tested the impact of compensatory growth on subsequent escape performance in populations from diverse habitats. We found clear population differences in the rate of compensatory growth, and strong inter-habitat differences in the impact that catch-up growth had on burst swimming performance when measured weeks later. In pond populations growth compensation had little effect on burst swimming, whereas fish from stream populations that exhibited rapid catch-up growth subsequently had slower escape speeds. Those differences could be explained by the non-linear nature of the tradeoff curve, suggesting that habitat-specific selection pressures lead to differences in the importance of burst swimming performance.     

Capacity for growth compensation in juvenile three-spined sticklebacks experiencing cycles of food deprivation

The capacity of three‐spined sticklebacks Gasterosteus aculeatus (initial mean mass 0.280 g) to compensate for recurrent periods of food deprivation of 2, 4 or 6 days followed by 2 days of ad libitum feeding on enchytraeid worms over 56 days was assessed by measuring appetite and growth. Control fish were fed daily. The total number of days on which fish were fed ranged from 14 (6‐day cycle) to 56 (controls). Deprived sticklebacks were hyperphagic on the first day of re‐feeding in a cycle and this hyperphagia increased with successive cycles. Mean daily consumption on first day of refeeding was: controls, 62.9 mg; 2 days, 108 mg; 4 days, 98.8 mg; 6 days, 101 mg. The hyperphagia did not increase as the preceding period of deprivation within a cycle increased. Hyperphagia was not maintained on the second day of re‐feeding. The 4 day and 6 day groups initially showed hypophagia on the second day of re‐feeding. Mean daily consumption on second day of re‐feeding was: controls, 62.6 mg; 2 days, 62.2 mg; 4 days, 54.2 mg; 6 days, 50.0 mg. Over the experiment, consumption on the second day of the 4 day and 6‐day groups increased towards the control level, suggesting a developing compensatory response. The highest mean daily consumption per days fed was shown by the 2 day group. The relationship between number of days fed and total food consumption and specific growth rate suggested that the 2 day group almost compensated for the periods of deprivation. Performance declined for the 4 day and 6 day groups, although even at the highest level of deprivation, a positive growth was achieved. Mean specific growth rate in mass (% per day) was: controls, 2.33; 2 days, 1.89; 4 days, 1.21; 6 days, 0.86. Initial mass and total food consumption accounted for most of the variance in specific growth rate. Other indices of performance including lipid concentration, dry matter concentration and the RNA:DNA ratio in white muscle were positively related to quantity of food consumed by each group. Growth efficiency of sticklebacks in terms of wet mass gained and wet mass consumed over the experimental period was 19.4% and did not differ among control and treatment groups. The growth rates of the sticklebacks experiencing cyclical deprivation were comparable to growth rates previously recorded for sticklebacks fed daily, but consuming similar mean daily rations.     

Partial compensatory growth in hybrid tilapia Oreochromis mossambicus × O. niloticus following food deprivation

The capacity of hybrid tilapia Oreochromis mossambicus × O. niloticus [23.2 ± 0.2 g (mean ± SE)] to show compensatory growth was assessed in an 8‐week experiment. Fish were deprived of feed for 1, 2 and 4 weeks, and then fed to satiation for 4 weeks; fish fed to satiation during the experiment served as control. Water temperature gradually declined from 28.1 to 25.5°C throughout the experiment. Specific growth rate (SGR) decreased with progressive food deprivation. At the end of deprivation, body weight was lower in the deprived fish than in the control. Fish deprived for 4 weeks exhibited lower contents of lipids and energy in whole body, and higher moisture content and ratio of protein to energy (P/E) than those of the control; they also consumed feed faster than the control when normal feeding was resumed. All deprived fish showed higher food intake (FI) than that of the control during re‐alimentation; however, enhanced SGR was only observed in the fish deprived for 4 weeks. There were no significant differences in digestibility of protein and energy, food efficiency (FE) or energy retention efficiency between the control and deprived fish. At the end of re‐alimentation, deprived fish failed to catch up in body weight with the control, while content of moisture, lipids and energy, and P/E in whole body of the deprived fish did not significantly differ from that of the control. The results of the experiment revealed that the hybrid tilapia reared in freshwater showed partial capacity for compensatory growth following food deprivation of 4 weeks, and that growth compensation was due mainly to increased FI, rather than to improved FE.     

The effect of feeding frequency on utilization of algal nutrients by the marine herbivore, the luderick, Girella tricuspidata (Quoy and Gaimard)

Utilization of whole algae, lipid, protein and total nitrogen and total carbon by the luderick, Girella tricuspidata , fed ad libitum were found to be comparable with published results obtained for other species. Periods of food deprivation were found to cause reduced efficiency of utilization for all nutrients measured, with a 4–day deprivation period having a greater effect than a 24–h deprivation period.
Only animals fed ad libitum were able to obtain a greater amount of lipid from their food than was defaecated. Utilization of protein and non–protein nitrogen is similar in fish fed ad libitum , but a greater reliance upon the non–protein nitrogen content of the food for nutrition is apparent when the fish are subjected to periods of food deprivation. Nitrogen utilization, relative to other nutrients, by fish subjected to periods of food deprivation is greatest immediately after a feeding bout. Total carbon utilization relative to other nutrients increases with increasing time of deprivation following a feeding bout.
It is suggested that these changes in nutrient utilization with time after feeding are the result of rapid utilization of the nitrogen–rich cell contents, followed later by utilization of the algal cell wall.     

Prolonged feed deprivation does not permanently compromise digestive function in migrating European glass eels Anguilla anguilla

The effects of prolonged feed deprivation (40 days at 18° C) and re-feeding (30 days) on body mass, growth and the activity of selected pancreatic and intestinal enzymes were evaluated in migrating European glass eels Anguilla anguilla by comparison with a control group fed to satiation with hake Merluccius merluccius roe for the duration of the experiment. Feed deprivation resulted in mass loss and a reduction in digestive function, as revealed by a decrease in the total and specific activities of pancreatic (trypsin and α-amylase) and intestinal brush border (alkaline phosphatase and leucine aminopeptidase) enzymes. The total activity of intestinal brush border enzymes diminished after 5 days of feed deprivation, whereas that of pancreatic enzymes did not decrease until 10 days, indicating that the intestine is more sensitive to feed deprivation than the pancreas. Re-feeding A. anguilla that were starved for 40 days resulted in compensatory growth, with specific growth rates that were 2·6 times higher than the control group. This compensatory growth was associated with the recovery of trypsin and intestinal brush border enzyme activities, which were restored to control levels within 5 days of re-feeding. The ability to maintain pancreatic enzyme activity during 40 days of feed deprivation, and rapidly recover capacity for protein digestion upon re-feeding, would enable A. anguilla at this glass eel stage to withstand periods without food but rapidly provide amino acids for protein synthesis and growth when suitable food was available.     

The effect of hunger and cestode parasitism on the shoaling decisions of small freshwater fish

Individual minnows Phoxinus phoxinus and three-spined sticklebacks Gasterosteus aculeatus were provided with a mutually exclusive choice between joining a shoal of conspecifics and foraging alone in a maze. The shoaling decisions and foraging behaviour of individual fish were studied when the fish were satiated and after 24- and 48-h periods of food deprivation. Hunger level was found to have a significant effect on shoaling behaviour. When satiated, fish of both species spent a greater proportion of time within one body length of the shoal and spent less time out of visual contact with the shoal than after periods of food deprivation. The effect of the cestode parasite Schistocephalus solidus on the shoaling behaviour of stickleback hosts was complex. When satiated, infected fish spent less time than uninfected fish within one body length of the shoal, preferring to remain outside the shoal, yet within visual contact, although when food deprived there was no difference in the proportion of time spent by infected and uninfected fish close to the shoal. The possible ecological significance of this change in behaviour is discussed with reference to the manipulation hypothesis of host-parasite interactions.     

The stability of standard metabolic rate during a period of food deprivation in juvenile Atlantic salmon

Among juvenile Atlantic salmon Salmo salar either being fed ad libitum throughout a 3 month experiment or deprived of food in the middle month, food deprivation led to a decrease in SMR, which increased again once food was supplied ad libitum again. While the rank order of SMR among fish fed throughout remained relatively stable, that within the deprived group was inconsistent, suggesting that individual fish vary in their ability to reduce metabolic costs when food availability is low.     

中国对虾继饥饿后的补偿生长研

1999年7至8月份,在25.0±0.5℃条件下对中国对虾（湿重,1.454±0.150g）进行了不同时间的饥饿处理后再供食的恢复生长实验。对照组C连续饱食投喂32d;处理组S4、S8和S12分别饥饿4、8和12d后再饱食投喂28、24和20d。主要结果如下饥饿结束时各处理组的干重和湿重显著低于对照组（P<0.05）;实验结束时S4组和对照组间的干重和湿重差异不显著（P>0.05）,而S8和S12两组的干重和湿重仍显著低于对照组（P<0.05）;恢复生长后各处理组的湿重摄食率显著高于对照组（P<0.05）。实验结果表明,中国对虾继饥饿后再恢复喂食出现完全或部分补偿生长效应,且这种补偿生长效应主要是通过恢复生长阶段食欲增大,摄食水平提高实现的。     

The impact of dietary restriction, intermittent feeding and compensatory growth on reproductive investment and lifespan in a short-lived fish

While dietary restriction usually increases lifespan, an intermittent feeding regime, where periods of deprivation alternate with times when food is available, has been found to reduce lifespan in some studies but prolong it in others. We suggest that these disparities arise because in some situations lifespan is reduced by the costs of catch-up growth (following the deprivation) and reproductive investment, a factor that has rarely been measured in studies of lifespan. Using three-spined sticklebacks, we show for the first time that while animals subjected to an intermittent feeding regime can grow as large as continuously fed controls that receive the same total amount of food, and can maintain reproductive investment, they have a shorter lifespan. Furthermore, we show that this reduction in lifespan is linked to rapid skeletal growth rate and is due to an increase in the instantaneous risk of mortality rather than in the rate of senescence. By contrast, dietary restriction caused a reduction in reproductive investment in females but no corresponding increase in longevity. This suggests that in short-lived species where reproduction is size dependent, selection pressures may lead to an increase in intrinsic mortality risk when resources are diverted from somatic maintenance to both growth and reproductive investment.     

Appetite and growth compensation in the European minnow,Phoxinus phoxinus (Cyprinidae), following short periods of food restriction

Synopsis Changes in the daily appetite and weekly growth rates of individual adult minnows,Phoxinus phoxinus, on ad libitum rations were recorded before and after they had experienced 4 or 16 days of food restriction. Feeding levels during the restriction periods were either starvation or a maintenance ration. The latter was estimated from a previously determined regression model. Water temperature was 15°C and the photoperiod 9L15D in all experiments. The mean weight of fish used ranged from 1.06 to 2.15 g. The 4 day restriction had no detectable effects on appetite or growth. After the 16 day restriction, the minnows showed hyperphagia and had increased specific growth rates and growth efficiencies compared with control fish. The compensatory increases in appetite and growth were not sustained and within three weeks had declined to levels not significantly different from those of the control fish. At the end of the experiments, there were no significant differences between the mean weights or cumulative food consumption of the restricted and control groups. The results suggest that adult minnows regulate their appetite and growth rate in relation to their previous nutritional history.     

Physiological effects in juvenile three-spined sticklebacks feeding on toxic cyanobacterium Nodularia spumigena-exposed zooplankton

Feeding rate, growth and nutritional condition as well as nodularin concentration of juvenile three-spined sticklebacks Gasterosteus aculeatus were assessed in an experimental study where field-collected fish were given a diet of zooplankton fed with toxic Nodularia spumigena for 15 days. Food consumption was higher in N. spumigena bloom conditions compared with the cyanobacterium-free control, but despite this the growth rate of exposed fish did not improve. Control fish and fish fed N. spumigena -exposed zooplankton had higher RNA:DNA ratios and protein content than fish grown in cyanobacterial bloom conditions indicating good nutritional condition and recent growth of fish, whereas in bloom conditions metabolic transformation of nodularin to less toxic compounds may cause an energetic cost to the fish affecting the growth rate of the whole organism. Juvenile three-spined sticklebacks collected from the field contained higher concentrations of nodularin at the beginning of the experiment (mean 503·1 μg kg⁻¹). After 15 days, the lowest nodularin concentrations in fish were measured in the control treatment, suggesting that fish fed with non-toxic food are able to detoxify nodularin from their tissues more effectively than fish in continuing exposure.     

Refuge use by fish as a function of body weight changes

Refuge use provides a good model for the study of trade-offs between the benefits of predator avoidance and the costs of lost feeding opportunities. We manipulated the latter costs by subjecting similar-sized three-spine sticklebacks to 2 days of food deprivation followed by a 2-day re-feeding period and recorded associated changes in body weight and refuge use. Food deprivation resulted in a decrease and re-feeding in an increase in the duration of refuge use by fish. Emergence times of fish from the refuge were extremely variable (with a ratio of 1:127 between the shortest and the longest ones) but individual ranks were highly consistent between different days of testing, suggesting that emergence times were individually characteristic. Percentage weight change of fish in response to the experimental treatments also showed a high level of inter-individual variation ranging from 0–17%. A significant positive correlation was found between the percentage weight lost and the percentage decrease in emergence time from a refuge after food deprivation and similarly between the percentage weight gained and the percentage increase in refuge use after re-feeding. The relationship between energy turnover and behavioural strategies is discussed. Received: 13 December 1998 / Received in revised form: 2 May 1999 / Accepted: 7 June 1999     

The cost of catching up: increased winter mortality following structural growth compensation in the wild

Although laboratory and observational studies suggest that many animals are capable of compensatory growth after periods of food shortage, few field experiments have demonstrated structural growth compensation in the wild. Here, we addressed the hypotheses that (i) food restriction can induce structural compensatory growth in free-living animals, (ii) that compensation is proportional to the level of body size retardation and (iii) that compensation induces mortality costs. To test these, wild brown trout (Salmo trutta) yearlings were brought to the lab, tagged individually, subjected to four levels of food deprivation (including a control), released back into the native stream and recaptured after one, five and ten months. Brown trout fully restored condition and partially restored mass within a month, whereas compensation in structure (i.e. body length) was not evident until after five months, supporting hypothesis 1. As the level of growth compensation was similar among the three deprived groups, hypothesis 2 was not supported. A final recapture after winter revealed delayed mortality, apparently induced by the compensatory response in the deprived groups, which is consistent with hypothesis 3. To our knowledge, this is the first field experiment demonstrating structural compensatory growth and associated costs in a wild animal population.