Efficient incorporation of large (>2 kb) heterologies into heteroduplex DNA: Pms1/Msh2-dependent and -independent large loop mismatch repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair in yeast is effected primarily by gene conversion. Conversion can conceivably result from gap repair or from mismatch repair of heteroduplex DNA (hDNA) in recombination intermediates. Mismatch repair is normally very efficient, but unrepaired mismatches segregate in the next cell division, producing sectored colonies. Conversion of small heterologies (single-base differences or insertions <15 bp) in meiosis and mitosis involves mismatch repair of hDNA. The repair of larger loop mismatches in plasmid substrates or arising by replication slippage is inefficient and/or independent of Pms1p/Msh2p-dependent mismatch repair. However, large insertions convert readily (without sectoring) during meiotic recombination, raising the question of whether large insertions convert by repair of large loop mismatches or by gap repair. We show that insertions of 2.2 and 2.6 kbp convert efficiently during DSB-induced mitotic recombination, primarily by Msh2p- and Pms1p-dependent repair of large loop mismatches. These results support models in which Rad51p readily incorporates large heterologies into hDNA. We also show that large heterologies convert more frequently than small heterologies located the same distance from an initiating DSB and propose that this reflects Msh2-independent large loop-specific mismatch repair biased toward loop loss.     

Analysis of yeast pms1, msh2, and mlh1 mutators points to differences in mismatch correction efficiencies between prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells.

Genetic stability relies in part on the efficiency with which post-replicative mismatch repair (MMR) detects and corrects DNA replication errors. In Escherichia coli, endogenous transition mispairs and insertion/deletion (ID) heterologies are corrected with similar efficiencies – but much more efficiently than transversion mispairs – as revealed by mutation rate increases in MMR mutants. To assess the relative efficiencies with which these mismatches are corrected in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, we examined repair of defined mismatches on heteroduplex plasmids and compared the spectra for >1000 spontaneous SUP4-o mutations arising in isogenic wild-type or MMR-deficient (pms1, mlh1, msh2) strains. Heteroduplexes containing G/T mispairs or ID heterologies were corrected more efficiently than those containing transversion mismatches. However, the rates of single base-pair insertion/deletion were increased much more (82-fold or 34-fold, respectively) on average than the rate of base pair substitutions (4.4-fold), with the rates for total transitions and transversions increasing to similar extents. Thus, the relative efficiencies with which mismatches formed during DNA replication are repaired appear to differ in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. In addition, our results indicate that in yeast, and probably other eukaryotes, these efficiencies may not mirror those obtained from an analysis of heteroduplex correction. Received: 15 November 1998 / Accepted: 4 February 1999     

Analysis of yeast pms1, msh2, and mlh1 mutators points to differences in mismatch correction efficiencies between prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells

Genetic stability relies in part on the efficiency with which post-replicative mismatch repair (MMR) detects and corrects DNA replication errors. In Escherichia coli, endogenous transition mispairs and insertion/deletion (ID) heterologies are corrected with similar efficiencies – but much more efficiently than transversion mispairs – as revealed by mutation rate increases in MMR mutants. To assess the relative efficiencies with which these mismatches are corrected in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, we examined repair of defined mismatches on heteroduplex plasmids and compared the spectra for >1000 spontaneous SUP4-o mutations arising in isogenic wild-type or MMR-deficient (pms1, mlh1, msh2) strains. Heteroduplexes containing G/T mispairs or ID heterologies were corrected more efficiently than those containing transversion mismatches. However, the rates of single base-pair insertion/deletion were increased much more (82-fold or 34-fold, respectively) on average than the rate of base pair substitutions (4.4-fold), with the rates for total transitions and transversions increasing to similar extents. Thus, the relative efficiencies with which mismatches formed during DNA replication are repaired appear to differ in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. In addition, our results indicate that in yeast, and probably other eukaryotes, these efficiencies may not mirror those obtained from an analysis of heteroduplex correction.     

Nick-dependent and -independent processing of large DNA loops in human cells

DNA loop heterologies are products of normal DNA metabolism and can lead to severe genomic instability if unrepaired. To understand how human cells process DNA loop structures, a set of circular heteroduplexes containing a 30-nucleotide loop were constructed and tested for repair in vitro by human cell nuclear extracts. We demonstrate here that, in addition to the previously identified 5' nick-directed loop repair pathway (Littman, S. J., Fang, W. H., and Modrich, P. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 7474-7481), human cells can process large DNA loop heterologies in a loop-directed manner. The loop-directed repair specifically removes the loop structure and occurs only in the looped strand, and appears to require limited DNA synthesis. Like the nick-directed loop repair, the loop-directed repair is independent of many known DNA repair pathways, including DNA mismatch repair and nucleotide excision repair. In addition, our data also suggest that an aphidicolin-sensitive DNA polymerase is involved in the excision step of the nick-directed loop repair pathway.     

Effects of DNA Heterologies on Bacteriophage λ Recombination

Previous studies of bacteriophage λ recombination have provided indirect evidence that substantial sequence nonhomologies, such as insertions and deletions, may be included in regions of heteroduplex DNA. However, the direct products of heterology-containing heteroduplex DNA--heterozygous progeny phage--have not been observed. We have constructed a series of small insertion and deletion mutations in the cI gene to examine the possibility that small heterologies might be accommodated in heterozygous progeny phage. Genetic crosses were carried out between λcI(-) Oam29 and λcI(+) Pam80 under replication-restricted conditions. Recombinant O(+)P(+) progeny were selected on mutL hosts and tested for cI heterozygosity. Heterozygous recombinants were readily observed with crosses involving insertions of 4 to 19 base pairs (bp) in the cI gene. Thus, nonhomologies of at least 19 bp can be accommodated in regions of heteroduplex DNA during λ recombination. In contrast, when a cI insertion or deletion mutation of 26 bp was present, few of the selected recombinants were heterozygous for cI. Results using a substitution mutation, involving a 26-bp deletion with a 22-bp insertion, suggest that the low recovery of cI heterozygotes containing heterologies of 26 bp or more is due to a failure to encapsidate DNA containing heterologies of 26 bp or more into viable phage particles.     

XRCC4 codon 247*A and XRCC4 promoter -1394*T related genotypes but not XRCC4 intron 3 gene polymorphism are associated with higher susceptibility for endometriosis

DNA repair systems act to maintain genome integrity in the face of replication errors, environmental insults, and the cumulative effects of age. Genetic variants in DNA repair genes such as X-ray repair cross-complementing group 4 (XRCC4) might influence the ability to repair damaged DNA. Herein we aimed to investigate whether some XRCC4-related polymorphisms were associated with endometriosis susceptibility. Women were divided: (1) severe endometriosis (rAFS stage IV, n = 136) and (2) nonendometriosis groups (n = 112). The polymorphisms of XRCC4 codon 247, XRCC4 promoter -1394, and XRCC4 intron 3 insertion/deletion (I/D) polymorphism were amplified by PCR and detected by electrophoresis after restriction enzyme (BBS I, Hinc II) digestions. Genotypes and allelic frequencies in both groups were compared. We observed that XRCC4 codon 247*A and XRCC4 promoter -1394*T related genotypes, but not XRCC4 intron 3 I/D polymorphism, are associated with higher susceptibility for endometriosis. Distributions of XRCC4 codon 247*C homozygote/heterozygote/A homozygote, and C/A allele in both groups were: (1) 89/9.5/1.5% and 93.7/6.3%; (2) 97.3/2.7/0%, and 98.7/1.3% (P < 0.05). Proportions of XRCC4 promoter -1394*T homozygote/heterozygote/G homozygote and T/G allele in both groups were: (1) 94.1/5.2/0.7% and 96.7/3.3%, and (2) 79.4/17.9/2.7% and 88.4/11.6% (P < 0.005). Proportions of XRCC4*I homozygote/heterozygote/D homozygote and A/C allele in both groups were: (1) 67.6/30.9/1.5% and 83.2/16.8%, and (2) 70.5/24.1/5.4% and 82.6/17.4% (nondifference). We conclude that XRCC4 codon 247*A and XRCC4 promoter -1394*T related genotypes and alleles, but not XRCC4 intron 3 I/D polymorphism, might be associated with endometriosis susceptibilities and pathogenesis.     

Suppression of intrachromosomal gene conversion in mammalian cells by small degrees of sequence divergence

Pairs of closely linked defective herpes simplex virus (HSV) thymidine kinase (tk) gene sequences exhibiting various nucleotide heterologies were introduced into the genome of mouse Ltk- cells. Recombination events were recovered by selecting for the correction of a 16-bp insertion mutation in one of the tk sequences. We had previously shown that when two tk sequences shared a region of 232 bp of homology, interruption of the homology by two single nucleotide heterologies placed 19 bp apart reduced recombination nearly 20-fold. We now report that either one of the nucleotide heterologies alone reduces recombination only about 2.5-fold, indicating that the original pair of single nucleotide heterologies acted synergistically to inhibit recombination. We tested a variety of pairs of single nucleotide heterologies and determined that they reduced recombination from 7- to 175-fold. Substrates potentially leading to G-G or C-C mispairs in presumptive heteroduplex DNA (hDNA) intermediates displayed a particularly low rate of recombination. Additional experiments suggested that increased sequence divergence causes a shortening of gene conversion tracts. Collectively, our results suggest that suppression of recombination between diverged sequences is mediated via processing of a mispaired hDNA intermediate.     

The effects of terminal heterologies on gene targeting by insertion vectors in embryonic stem cells.

We have examined the effects of placing nonhomologous DNA on the ends of an insertion-type gene targeting vector. The presence of terminal heterologies was found to be compatible with insertion targeting, and the terminal heterologies were efficiently removed. Terminal heterologies reduced the frequency of gene targeting to variable extents. The degree of inhibition of targeting was dependent on the length and the position of the heterology: 2.1kb heterologous sequences were more inhibitory than shorter regions of heterology, and heterology placed on the end of the long (4.8kb) arm of homology was more inhibitory than heterology positioned on the end of the short (0.8kb) arm. When heterology was placed on both arms of the targeting vector the targeting efficiencies were similar to or higher than when heterology was present on the long arm only. These results suggest that terminal sequences are removed simultaneously from both ends of targeting vectors. The removal of terminal sequences probably occurs by exonucleolytic degradation of both strands at each end, and removal of at least one of the strands is intimately coupled with the process of homologous recombination. These findings have implications for the design of gene targeting vectors.     

Large Heterologies Impose Their Gene Conversion Pattern onto Closely Linked Point Mutations

We have studied the meiotic non-Mendelian segregation (NMS) pattern of seven large heterologous combinations located in the b2 ascospore gene of Ascobolus. The NMS patterns of these aberration heterozygotes widely differ from each other and from those of point mutations located in the same genetic region. They give lower gene conversion frequencies than point mutations, no postmeiotic segregations (PMS), and either parity or disparity that favors the wild type allele. Two related deletions, G234 and G40, were studied for their effects on the conversion behavior of closely linked point mutations. We found that, when heterozygous, the deletions impose their own NMS pattern onto close mutations. These effects occur on both sides of the heterologies. The effects upon PMS and disparity of linked point mutations gradually disappear as point mutations become more distant. The effects on NMS frequencies and on aberrant 4:4 are polar. They persist for all mutations located downstream from the high conversion end of the gene. This last effect can reflect a blockage of symmetric hDNA formation by large heterologies, whereas the epistasis of the NMS pattern of large heterologies over that of closely linked point mutations suggests that large heterologies and point mutations undergo conversion by means of distinct pathways.     

Minimal extent of homology required for completion of meiotic recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The minimal length of contiguous homology required for successful completion of meiotic recombination was investigated by using heterologous insertions to delimit homologous segments of chromosome III in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Constructs created in vitro by insertion of selectable markers into the LEU2 locus were transplaced into haploid strains, which were then mated to create diploids containing pairs of insertion heterologies at various distances. Analysis of the meiotic products from these diploids revealed a gradient in the frequency of both reciprocal and nonreciprocal recombination declining monotonically from the 5′ end of LEU2. Both types of event were found to be restricted by the presence of the insertion heterologies. The spo 13 single division meiosis was exploited to develop a plating assay in which LEU2 diploid spores containing reciprocally recombinant strands derived from events occurring completely within the interval flanked by the insertion heterologies were selected by random spore methods. Reciprocal recombination frequencies measured with this assay decreased linearly with extent, extrapolating to a minimal homology requirement of 150–250 nucleotides. When homology was most severely restricted, unexpected flanking marker configurations among reciprocal recombinants within LEU2 demonstrated the occurrence of complex recombination events. In addition to detecting reciprocal recombinants, the system is capable of measuring the probability that a non-reciprocal recombination event will have one endpoint between the heterologous inserts and the other lying outside the interval. The minimal length of homology required for this aspect of recombination was found to be 25–60 nucleotides. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Repair of large insertion/deletion heterologies in human nuclear extracts is directed by a 5' single-strand break and is independent of the mismatch repair system

The repair of 12-, 27-, 62-, and 216-nucleotide unpaired insertion/deletion heterologies has been demonstrated in nuclear extracts of human cells. When present in covalently closed circular heteroduplexes or heteroduplexes containing a single-strand break 3' to the heterology, such structures are subject to a low level repair reaction that occurs with little strand bias. However, the presence of a single-strand break 5' to the insertion/deletion heterology greatly increases the efficiency of rectification and directs repair to the incised DNA strand. Because nick direction of repair is independent of the strand in which a particular heterology is placed, the observed strand bias is not due to asymmetry imposed on the heteroduplex by the extrahelical DNA segment. Strand-specific repair by this system requires ATP and the four dNTPs and is inhibited by aphidicolin. Repair is independent of the mismatch repair proteins MSH2, MSH6, MLH1, and PMS2 and occurs by a mechanism that is distinct from that of the conventional mismatch repair system. Large heterology repair in nuclear extracts of human cells is also independent of the XPF gene product, and extracts of Chinese hamster ovary cells deficient in the ERCC1 and ERCC4 gene products also support the reaction.     

Mitotic gene conversion of large DNA heterologies in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Summary Gene conversion of large DNA heterologous fragments has been shown to take place efficiently in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. It has been found that a 2.6 kb LEU2 DNA fragment in a multicopy plasmid was replaced by a 3.1 kb PG11 chromosomal DNA fragment, when both fragments were flanked by homologous DNA regions. Gene conversion was asymmetric in a total of 481 recombinants analyzed. In contrast, truncated PG11 or LEU2 genes in multicopy plasmids, gave no recombinants that restored a complete plasmid copy of these genes in a total of 242 recombinants studied, confirming that a conversion tract is disrupted by a heterologous region. The asymmetry of the events detected suggest that gene conversion of large DNA heterologies involves a process whereby a gap first covers one heterologous fragment and then this is followed by new DNA synthesis using the other heterologous fragment as a template. Therefore, it is likely that large DNA heterologies are converted by a double-strand gap repair mechanism.     

Mismatch Repair-Induced Meiotic Recombination Requires the Pms1 Gene Product

The presence of multiple heterologies in a 9-kilobase (kb) interval results in a decrease in meiotic crossovers from 26.0% to 10.1%. There is also an increase from 3.5% to 11.1% in gene conversions and ectopic recombinations between the flanking homologous MAT loci. The hypothesis that mismatch repair of heteroduplex DNA containing several heterologies would lead to a second round of recombination has now been tested by examining the effect of a mutation that reduces mismatch correction. The repair-defective pms1-1 allele restores the pattern of recombination to nearly that seen in congenic diploids without the heterologies. Mismatch repair-induced recombination causes a significant increase in MAT conversions and ectopic recombination events with as few as two heterozygosities separated by 0.3-0.7 kb, but not when the mismatches are separated by greater than 1 kb. The frequency of these events depends on both the number and position of the heterozygosities relative to the flanking homologous MAT loci used to detect the events. The creation of recombinogenic lesions by mismatch repair in yeast could be analogous to the creation of recombinogenic lesions in dam- Escherichia coli. We suggest that the repair of heteroduplex DNA containing multiple mismatches may produce chromosomal rearrangements and gamete inviability when naturally polymorphic chromosomes undergo meiotic recombination.     

Minimal extent of homology required for completion of meiotic recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

The minimal length of contiguous homology required for successful completion of meiotic recombination was investigated by using heterologous insertions to delimit homologous segments of chromosome III in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Constructs created in vitro by insertion of selectable markers into the LEU2 locus were transplaced into haploid strains, which were then mated to create diploids containing pairs of insertion heterologies at various distances. Analysis of the meiotic products from these diploids revealed a gradient in the frequency of both reciprocal and nonreciprocal recombination declining monotonically from the 5' end of LEU2. Both types of event were found to be restricted by the presence of the insertion heterologies. The spo13 single division meiosis was exploited to develop a plating assay in which LEU2 diploid spores containing reciprocally recombinant strands derived from events occurring completely within the interval flanked by the insertion heterologies were selected by random spore methods. Reciprocal recombination frequencies measured with this assay decreased linearly with extent, extrapolating to a minimal homology requirement of 150-250 nucleotides. When homology was most severely restricted, unexpected flanking marker configurations among reciprocal recombinants within LEU2 demonstrated the occurrence of complex recombination events. In addition to detecting reciprocal recombinants, the system is capable of measuring the probability that a non-reciprocal recombination event will have one end-point between the heterologous inserts and the other lying outside the interval. The minimal length of homology required for this aspect of recombination was found to be 25-60 nucleotides.     

Subtle mutagenesis by ends-in recombination in malaria parasites

The recent advent of gene-targeting techniques in malaria (Plasmodium) parasites provides the means for introducing subtle mutations into their genome. Here, we used the TRAP gene of Plasmodium berghei as a target to test whether an ends-in strategy, i.e., targeting plasmids of the insertion type, may be suitable for subtle mutagenesis. We analyzed the recombinant loci generated by insertion of linear plasmids containing either base-pair substitutions, insertions, or deletions in their targeting sequence. We show that plasmid integration occurs via a double-strand gap repair mechanism. Although sequence heterologies located close (less than 450 bp) to the initial double-strand break (DSB) were often lost during plasmid integration, mutations located 600 bp and farther from the DSB were frequently maintained in the recombinant loci. The short lengths of gene conversion tracts associated with plasmid integration into TRAP suggests that an ends-in strategy may be widely applicable to modify plasmodial genes and perform structure-function analyses of their important products.     

Slipped Misalignment Mechanisms of Deletion Formation: In Vivo Susceptibility to Nucleases

Misalignment of repeated sequences during DNA replication can lead to deletions or duplications in genomic DNA. In Escherichia coli, such genetic rearrangements can occur at high frequencies, independent of the RecA-homologous recombination protein, and are sometimes associated with sister chromosome exchange (SCE). Two mechanisms for RecA-independent genetic rearrangements have been proposed: simple replication misalignment of the nascent strand and its template and SCE-associated misalignment involving both nascent strands. We examined the influence of the 3′ exonuclease of DNA polymerase III and exonuclease I on deletion via these mechanisms in vivo. Because mutations in these exonucleases stimulate tandem repeat deletion, we conclude that displaced 3′ ends are a common intermediate in both mechanisms of slipped misalignments. Our results also confirm the notion that two distinct mechanisms contribute to slipped misalignments: simple replication misalignment events are sensitive to DNA polymerase III exonuclease, whereas SCE-associated events are sensitive to exonuclease I. If heterologies are present between repeated sequences, the mismatch repair system dependent on MutS and MutH aborts potential deletion events via both mechanisms. Our results suggest that simple slipped misalignment and SCE-associated misalignment intermediates are similarly susceptible to destruction by the mismatch repair system.     

Angiotensin I-converting enzyme insertion-related genotypes and allele are associated with higher susceptibility of endometriosis and leiomyoma

Endometriosis and leiomyoma display features similar to malignancy, requiring neovascularization to proliferation and growth. Altered vascular-related genes might be related to the development of endometriosis and leiomyoma. Polymorphisms of the angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) insertion/deletion (I/D) genes have been linked with some vascular diseases. This study investigates whether ACE I/D gene polymorphisms could be used as markers of susceptibility in endometriosis and leiomyoma. Women were divided into three groups: (1) endometriosis (n = 125); (2) leiomyoma (n = 120); (3) normal controls (n = 128). Genomic DNA was obtained from peripheral leukocyte. ACE I/D gene polymorphisms in intron 16 were amplified by polymerase chain reaction and restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) Genotypes and allelic frequencies in both groups were compared. We observed the genotype distribution and allele frequency of ACE I/D gene polymorphisms in both groups were significantly different. Proportions of ACE*I homozygote/heterozygote/D homozygote in both groups were: (1) 50.4/24/25.6%; (2) 25/23.33/51.67%; (3) 10.2/29.7/60.1%. Proportions of I/D alleles in each group were: (1) 62.4/37.6%; (2) 36.7/63.3%; (3) 25/75%. We concluded that ACE*I/D gene polymorphisms are associated with endometriosis and leiomyoma susceptibilities. ACE*I-related genotypes and allele are strongly related to the occurrence of endometriosis and moderately related to the occurrence of leiomyoma.     

Intron length evolution in Drosophila

I present data on the evolution of intron lengths among 3 closely related Drosophila species, D. melanogaster, Drosophila simulans, and Drosophila yakuba. Using D. yakuba as an outgroup, I mapped insertion and deletion mutations in 148 introns (spanning approximately 30 kb) to the D. melanogaster and D. simulans lineages. Intron length evolution in the 2 sister species has been different: in D. melanogaster, X-linked introns have increased slightly in size, whereas autosomal ones have decreased slightly in size; in D. simulans, both X-linked and autosomal introns have decreased in size. To understand the possible evolutionary causes of these lineage- and chromosome-specific patterns of intron evolution, I studied insertion-deletion (indel) polymorphism and divergence in D. melanogaster. Small insertion mutations segregate at elevated frequencies and enjoy elevated probabilities of fixation, particularly on the X chromosome. In contrast, there is no detectable X chromosome effect on fixations in D. simulans. These findings suggest X chromosome-specific selection or biased gene conversion-gap repair favoring insertions in D. melanogaster but not in D. simulans. These chromosome- and lineage-specific patterns of indel substitution are not easily explained by existing general population genetic models of intron length evolution. Genomic data from D. melanogaster further suggest that the forces described here affect introns and intergenic regions similarly.