The effect of sperm storage and timing of mating on offspring sex ratios in the yellow dung fly Scatophaga stercoraria

1. Offspring sex ratios in the yellow dung fly Scatophaga stercoraria were examined in the laboratory. 2. Previous work indicated that females using previously stored sperm to fertilise their eggs produced male‐biased sex ratios. This result may have been due to female influences or the effects of sperm storage per se. 3. This pattern was not reproduced in the study presented here. Females that were allowed to mate just prior to oviposition produced similarly male‐biased sex ratios to those females that used previously stored sperm to fertilise their clutch. 4. Captive‐reared females may have perceived a lack of males in the population and thus produced a male‐biased offspring sex ratio. Alternatively, gamete ageing or extra‐chromosomal sex ratio distorters may have produced the male bias.     

State-dependent male mating tactics in the grey seal: the importance of body size

The purpose of this study was to examine the importance of bodysize and body composition as determinants of conditional matingtactics exhibited in male grey seals. We combined behavioralobservations with measures of energy expenditure and successon 42 known-age individuals during the breeding seasons of 1997–2001at Sable Island, Canada. Males with a large body mass arrivedat the breeding grounds with more body fat and body energy andcatabolized less body protein than smaller males. Males consumed1.9 ± 0.2 MJ day^–1, and those with a smaller percentageof body fat had higher rates of food energy intake. The amountof body energy on arrival was positively correlated with theduration of the breeding period. Males that exhibited the primarymating tactic of consortship were heavier, had absolutely morebody fat and body energy, and sustained breeding longer thanthose males that did not exhibit the primary tactic. Amongstall males, body mass showed a quadratic relationship with thenumber of female consorts mated and the estimated number ofpups sired. Thus, intermediate-sized males mated with the mostconsorts and achieved the highest success. Intermediate bodysize may be optimal during breeding due to greater agility inmale combat. Body size was an important determinant of matingtactics used by male grey seals. A large body size providedan energetic advantage of greater endurance while an intermediatebody size may provide greater competitive ability in acquiringconsortships.     

Trinucleotide microsatellite loci in the yellow dung fly Scathophaga stercoraria (Diptera: Scathophagidae)

We describe six polymorphic, trinucleotide microsatellite loci that were isolated from the yellow dung fly Scathophaga stercoraria (Diptera: Scathophagidae), a model system for examining the mechanisms behind sperm competition in species with internal fertilization. These microsatellites yielded between 3 and 11 alleles per locus in a sample of 20–48 dung flies collected from several sites in Cheshire, UK. Observed and expected heterozygosities varied between 0.195 and 0.900 and 0.335–0.842, respectively. These markers should allow us to investigate postcopulatory sexual selection processes in this fly much more fully than has been possible in the past.     

Sexual conflict over copula timing: a mathematical model and a test in the yellow dung fly

Sexual conflict over mating occurrence, timing, or durationis common in animals. This explains conspicuous female materejection behavior in many species, often involving shaking,fighting, and occasional forced copulations. We present a simplemodel that generates predictions about whether and when copulationoccurs in such conflict situations and how much female rejectionbehavior should be observed. Predictions depend on 2 underlyingparameters affecting female resistance and male persistence.We supply 2 qualitative tests of the model using the yellowdung fly Scathophaga stercoraria (Diptera: Scathophagidae).We manipulated adult age, body size (large and small), and adultfood availability (low and high), independently in males andfemales, staging replicate pairings of all treatment combinations.In agreement with predictions of our model, shaking durationfirst increased to a maximum at intermediate age, when the averagefemale copulated, and then decreased again. Contrary to expectation,body size did not affect copulation timing, female resistance,or male persistence. As predicted, adult food limitation delayedsexual maturity and hence prolonged female resistance, resultingin later copulations after more shaking. However, although foodlimitation equally delayed the increase in male persistencewith age, copulation also occurred later after more shaking,opposite to the model prediction. We conclude that shaking isdriven primarily by female age and male responses to it. Althoughfemale shaking can initially successfully deter males in S.stercoraria, this behavior is subtle and has apparently shiftedfunction from an effective means of mate choice to a signalof nonreceptivity, though its importance in nature remains unclear.     

Heritability of three condition surrogates in the yellow dung fly

Condition capture has been proposed as a general mechanism maintainingadditive genetic variation, V_a, in sexually selected traitsunder directional selection. It relies on two main assumptions:condition-dependent trait expression and V_a in condition. Althoughthere is evidence for the former, direct evidence that conditionis heritable is scarce, although this is a requirement of mostmodels of handicap sexual selection. We used a parent–offspring,full-sib, two-container laboratory breeding design in the yellowdung fly Scathophaga stercoraria to demonstrate the broad- andnarrow-sense heritability of three surrogates of condition commonlyused in sexual selection studies: lipid and glycogen reserves(i.e., physiological condition), body size, and fluctuatingasymmetry. All three measures are nutrition dependent and havebeen linked to sexual selection in free-living yellow dung flies.While lipid reserves and body size were heritable, asymmetryand glycogen reserves were not. Moreover, the evolvability ofphysiological condition was higher than that of the other twotraits. Of the three surrogates, physiological condition ismost akin to the original definition, but all have their limitations.We conclude that condition is a useful heuristic concept inevolutionary ecology, but its practical value may be limitedby the fact that it cannot be measured directly.     

Directional selection on body size but no apparent survival cost to being large in wild New Zealand giraffe weevils

When an individual's reproductive success relies on winning fights to secure mating opportunities, bearing larger weapons is advantageous. However, sexual selection can be extremely complex, and over an animal's life the opportunity to mate is influenced by numerous factors. We studied a wild population of giraffe weevils (Lasiorhynchus barbicornis) that exhibit enormous intra and intersexual size variation. Males bear an elongated rostrum used as a weapon in fights for mating opportunities. However, small males also employ sneaking behavior as an alternative reproductive tactic. We investigated sexual selection on size by tracking individual males and females daily over two 30‐day periods to measure long‐term mating success. We also assessed how survival and recapture probabilities vary with sex and size to determine whether there might be a survival cost associated with size. We found evidence for directional selection on size through higher mating success, but no apparent survival trade‐off. Instead, larger individuals mate more often and have a higher survival probability, suggesting an accumulation of benefits to bigger individuals. Furthermore, we found evidence of size assortative mating where males appear to selectively mate with bigger females. Larger and more competitive males secure matings with larger females more frequently than smaller males, which may further increase their fitness.     

An experimental test of frequency-dependent selection on male mating strategy in the field

We provide field-based experimental evidence for the frequency-dependent nature of the fitness of alternative mating strategies. We manipulated the frequency of genetically determined phenotypic strategies in six wild populations of the side-blotched lizard, Uta stansburiana. The within-population pattern of mating was assessed using nine microsatellite loci to assign paternity. Within populations of the side-blotched lizard exist three colour morphs (orange, blue and yellow) associated with male mating strategy. The frequency of these morphs has previously been found to oscillate over a 4- to 5-year period. We found, as predicted, that the common phenotype lost fitness to its antagonist. The mating patterns of all six populations adhered to a priori predictions that were derived from previous empirical and theoretical observations on this system. We found that the frequency-dependent nature of male fitness could be accounted for by the composition of their competitors at a small local population level, driven by associations within a focal female's social neighbourhood.     

Measuring the sperm competition successes of field males of the yellow dung fly

Abstract 1. Sperm competition is extremely common in many species but conclusions about the relative successes of males, measured as the proportion of a female's offspring fertilised by the second male to mate with it, are based largely on laboratory studies using two laboratory-bred males or on interrupted last copulations.
2. A study was conducted in which virgin female yellow dung flies Scathophaga stercoraria mated uninterrupted with two field-captured males.
3. The results confirmed two previous conclusions: the proportion of a female's offspring fertilised by the second male was related strongly to the copula duration of the second male, and the proportion of a female's offspring fertilised by the second male was lower in larger females, though this effect was weak.
4. The results indicate that previous experiments on laboratory populations of this species are likely to be relevant to wild situations, but researchers are urged to conduct studies that will improve the confidence with which laboratory measures of the proportion of a female's offspring fertilised by the second male can be assumed to reflect the sperm precedence of the last male to mate in natural situations.     

The effects of body size on mating and reproduction in Brachinus lateralis (Coleoptera: Carabidae)

Abstract. 1. The causes and reproductive consequences of body size variation of Brachinus lateralis Dejean, a parasitic carabid beetle, were investigated.
2. Body size variation occurs within and between sites. Host size has a major influence on body size of the adult.
3. Fecundity is positively correlated with body size. Egg size is not correlated with body size.
4. Mating males tend to be larger than non-mating males. There is a positive correlation of body sizes in mating pairs.
5. Limited opportunity for host choice may maintain size variation despite the advantages of large size.
6. The non-random patterns of mating for a species without obvious intrasexual aggression suggest that subtle means of male-male competition or female choice may be important.     

The effects of temperature and body size on the mating pattern of a gregariously nesting bee, Colletes cunicularius (Hymenoptera: Colletidae)

Abstract. 1. In a 3-year study of the solitary bee Colletes cunicularius L. in Sweden, average body size and population density fluctuated greatly between years.
2. In this protandrous population, females mated just once and the sex ratio was slightly male biased. Males were smaller than females.
3. Size assortative mating (homogamy), associated with an increase in population density during the central days of female emergence and mating, was observed in two out of three years. Homogamy was also observed in pairs with remating males.
4. Most of the mating males had emerged the day they mated, but 42% were older. We found no support for a general large-male mating advantage.
5. Weight of emerging females and mating males were negatively correlated with ground temperature, indicating thermoregulatory influence on the process of sexual selection in this species.     

The scale‐of‐choice effect and how estimates of assortative mating in the wild can be biased due to heterogeneous samples

The mode in which sexual organisms choose mates is a key evolutionary process, as it can have a profound impact on fitness and speciation. One way to study mate choice in the wild is by measuring trait correlation between mates. Positive assortative mating is inferred when individuals of a mating pair display traits that are more similar than those expected under random mating while negative assortative mating is the opposite. A recent review of 1134 trait correlations found that positive estimates of assortative mating were more frequent and larger in magnitude than negative estimates. Here, we describe the scale‐of‐choice effect (SCE), which occurs when mate choice exists at a smaller scale than that of the investigator's sampling, while simultaneously the trait is heterogeneously distributed at the true scale‐of‐choice. We demonstrate the SCE by Monte Carlo simulations and estimate it in two organisms showing positive (Littorina saxatilis) and negative (L. fabalis) assortative mating. Our results show that both positive and negative estimates are biased by the SCE by different magnitudes, typically toward positive values. Therefore, the low frequency of negative assortative mating observed in the literature may be due to the SCE's impact on correlation estimates, which demands new experimental evaluation.     

Assortative mating by size: A meta-analysis of mating patterns in water striders

Summary Assortative mating by size is a common mating pattern that can be generated by several different behavioural mechanisms, with different evolutionary implications. Assortative mating is typically associated with sexual selection and has been regarded as an attribute of populations, species, mating systems or even higher order taxa. In most animal groups, however, appropriate analyses of assortative mating at these different levels are lacking and the causes and forms of assortative mating are poorly understood. Here, we analyse 45 different population level estimates of assortative mating and non-random mating by size in seven confamiliar species of water striders that share a common mating system. A hierarchical comparative analysis shows that virtually all the variance within the clade occurs among samples within species. We then employ meta-analysis to estimate the overall strength of assortative mating, to determine the form of assortative mating and to further assess potential differences among species as well as the probable causes of assortative mating in this group of insects. We found overall weak but highly significant positive assortative mating. We show that analyses of the degree of heteroscedasticity in plots of male versus female size are critical, since the evolutionary implications of true and apparent assortative mating differ widely and conclude that the positive assortative mating observed in water striders was of the true rather than the apparent form. Further, within samples, mating individuals were significantly larger than non-mating individuals in both males and females. All of these non-random mating patterns were consistent among species and we conclude that weak positive assortative mating by size is a general characteristic of those water strider species that share this mating system. We use our results to illustrate the importance of distinguishing between different forms of assortative mating, to discriminate between various behavioural causes of assortative mating and to assess potential sources of interpopulational variance in estimates of assortative mating. Finally, we discuss the value of using meta-analytic techniques for detecting overall patterns in multiple studies of non-random mating.     

Mating preference of female zebrafish, Danio rerio, in relation to male dominance

Mating success tends to be skewed toward dominant males, thoughfemale mate preferences may not always correlate with male dominance.In this study, we investigated the mating preferences of femalezebrafish, Danio rerio, in the absence of male–male competition.We paired females sequentially with males of known dominancerank, using a nested, repeated measures design, with egg productionas a measure of female mate preference. We predicted that femaleswould spawn more frequently and produce larger clutches whenpaired with males of higher dominance rank. We found significantdifferences among females in the size of clutches produced andamong males in the size of clutches received, but these differenceswere independent of male dominance rank. Male body size wasnot related to either dominance rank or clutch size received.These results indicate that females vary clutch size in relationto the males with which they are paired but that they do notfavor dominant males. Thus, male competition may normally overridefemale mate preference in zebrafish.     

Mating games: the evolution of human mating transactions

We propose a new, evolutionary, game-theoretic model of conditionalhuman mating strategies that integrates currently disconnectedbodies of data into a single mathematically-explicit theoryof human mating transactions. The model focuses on the problemof how much resource a male must provide to a female to secureand retain her as a mate. By using bidding-game models, we showhow the male's minimally required resource incentive variesas a function of his own mate value, the value of the female,and the distribution of the mate values of their available alternativemates. The resulting theory parsimoniously accounts for strategicpluralism within the sexes, mate choice differences betweenthe sexes, and assortative mating, while generating a rich setof testable new predictions about human mating behavior.     

Centris pallida (Hymenoptera: Apidae) male body size decreases across five decades

Historical data suggest that many bee species have declined in body size. Larger-bodied bees with narrow phenological and dietary breadth are most prone to declines in body size over time. This may be especially true in solitary, desert-adapted species that are vulnerable to climate change such as Centris pallida (Hymenoptera: Apidae). In addition, body size changes in species with size-linked behaviours could threaten the prevalence of certain behavioural phenotypes long-term. C. pallida solitary bees are found in the Sonoran Desert. Males use alternative reproductive tactics (ARTs) and are dimorphic in both morphology and behaviour. C. pallida male body size has been studied since the 1970s in the same population. The authors collected body size data in 2022 and combined it with published records from 1974–2022. The authors find a persistent decline in the mean head width of patrolling males, and shifts towards smaller body sizes in the populations of males found foraging and hovering. Both morphs declined in average body size, and the proportion of large-morph males in the population decreased by 8%. Mating males did not decline in mean body size over the last five decades. The authors discuss hypotheses related to the decline in C. pallida male head width. Finally, the authors advocate for C. pallida as an excellent study system for understanding the stability of ARTs with size-linked behavioural phenotypes.     

Spatial relationships between mate acquisition probability and aggregation size in a gregarious coreid bug, (Colpula lativentris): A case of the ideal free distribution under perceptual constraints

Spatial relationships of mate acquisition probability for individuals of both sexes of a gregariously-mating coreid bug, Colpula lativentris, were studied in relation to aggregation size. Operational sex ratio was always strongly male biased. Mate acquisition probability of females was rather constant and independent of aggregation size, as predicted by an ideal free distribution. Moreover laboratory experiments showed that both multiple mating and rearing density little affected female fecundity, suggesting ideal free distribution of females in terms of reproductive success. On the other hand, mate acquisition probability of males was higher in larger aggregations, where more receptive females were available. This male discrepancy from an ideal free distribution was similar to the patterns predicted by an ideal free distribution under perceptual constraints (Abrahams, 1986), but not by that under unequal competitive ability.     

Effect of male body size on sperm precedence in the polyandrous butterfly Pieris napi L. (Lepidoptera: Pieridae)

Male Lepidoptera produce an ejaculate during copulation thatcontains both sperm and accessory gland nutrients and may functionas paternal investment and/or male mating effort Several studieshave examined how ejaculates function as paternal investment,but few have determined the influence of sperm competition onmale investment This study examines the effect of male bodysize on sperm precedence in the polyandrous butterfly Pierisnapi L. We used male body mass as an indicator of the size ofejaculate transferred and found that relative male size hada significant effect on paternity. The offspring of twice-matedfemales showed a low incidence of mixed paternity. Larger malesobtained the majority of fertilizations, and the degree of second-malesperm precedence was influenced by relative body size of matingmales. In general, second mates obtained fewer fertilizationsthe larger the size of the first mate. The interval betweenthe first and second mating was influenced by the size of thefirst male mate Females first mated to small males remated soonerthan females first mated to larger males Our results suggestthat large males may have a selective advantage over small maleswhen both a male's fertilization success and a female's refractoryperiod are influenced by the size of ejaculate transferred.Furthermore, the effect of male body size on the proportionof offspring sired lends support to the hypothesis that spermcompetition has played a major role in the evolution of ejaculatesize.