A boronic-acid-based probe for fluorescence polarization assays with penicillin binding proteins and β-lactamases

Penicillin binding proteins (PBPs) and β-lactamases are involved in interactions with β-lactam antibiotics connected with both antibacterial activity and mediation of bacterial β-lactam resistance. Current methods for identifying inhibitors of PBPs and β-lactamases can be inefficient and are often not suitable for studying weakly and/or reversibly binding compounds. Therefore, improved ligand binding assays for PBPs and β-lactamases are needed. We report the development of a fluorescence polarization (FP) assay for PBPs and "serine" β-lactamases using a boronic-acid-based, reversibly binding "tracer." The tracer was designed based on a crystal structure of a covalent complex between a boronic acid and PBP1b from Streptococcus pneumoniae. The tracer bound to three different PBPs with modest affinity (K(d)=4-12 μM) and more tightly to the TEM1 serine β-lactamase (K(d)=109 nM). β-Lactams and other boronic acids were able to displace the tracer in competition assays. These results indicate that fluorescent boronic acids are suited to serve as reversibly binding tracers in FP-based assays with PBPs and β-lactamases and potentially with other related enzymes.     

Equilibrium competition binding assay: inhibition mechanism from a single dose response

Inhibition of a receptor by a small-molecule compound in many cases is achieved via a competitive, uncompetitive or non-competitive mechanism. The receptor-inhibitor interaction is often probed through the displacement of a ligand in an equilibrium competition binding experiment. The previous solutions to receptor inhibition mechanisms were borrowed from steady-state enzyme inhibition mechanisms. The inhibition mechanism is determined by a visual inspection or a global fit of ligand dose response curves at a series of inhibitor concentrations. However these solutions only apply to situations when both the ligand and the inhibitor are not significantly depleted by the receptor. In most published equilibrium receptor binding studies, only the relative potency of the inhibitor is calculated. Ranking inhibitors tested under differing experimental conditions is often not possible. In the current paper, we offer exact mathematical solutions to uncompetitive and non-competitive inhibition, and demonstrate that in most cases both the inhibition mechanism and absolute potency of an inhibitor can be simultaneously determined from a single dose response of the inhibitor at a fixed concentration of the ligand. Therefore, an equilibrium competition assay provides a quick and facile method to determine the inhibition mechanism of a large number of inhibitors. The theory herein described is applicable to equilibrium competition binding experiments such as radioligand assays and fluorescence polarization assays.     

A rapid, homogeneous, fluorescence polarization binding assay for peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors alpha and gamma using a fluorescein-tagged dual PPARalpha/gamma activator

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors (PPARs) and other members of the nuclear hormone receptor family are important drug targets for the treatment of metabolic diseases. PPARalpha and PPARgamma play crucial roles in lipid and glucose metabolism, respectively. Therefore, screening methods that help to rapidly identify activators of these receptors should be of considerable value. A homogeneous fluorescence polarization (FP) ligand binding assay capable of rapidly identifying ligands that bind to both PPARalpha and PPARgamma has been developed using purified PPARalpha or PPARgamma ligand binding domains and a fluorescein-labeled analog (FLA) of a potent dual PPARalpha/gamma activator. FLA activator showed good binding affinity toward both PPARalpha (K(i)=0.7microM) and PPARgamma (K(i)=0.4microM). The binding of FLA activator was rapid and reached a plateau within 10 min. The resulting FP signal was stable for at least 18h. The FP binding assay performed robustly in a 384-well format, and the average Z' value was 0.77. There was a good correlation between the binding potency (IC(50) values) and rank order of binding potency for a panel of standard PPAR ligands obtained in FP binding assay and scintillation proximity assay or gel filtration binding assays using (3)H-labeled PPARalpha (r(2)=0.99) and PPARgamma (r(2)=0.99) ligands. There was also a good correlation of IC(50) values obtained by FP binding assay and scintillation proximity assay for the clinically used PPAR activators. Thus, the FP binding assay with a single fluorescein-labeled PPARalpha/gamma dual activator offers a homogeneous nonradioactive, sensitive, robust, and less expensive high-throughput assay for detecting compounds that bind to both PPARgamma and PPARalpha. Using this FP binding assay, we have identified a large number of PPARalpha/gamma dual activators. A similar assay platform may be easily adapted to other members of the nuclear hormone receptor family.     

Analysis of protein-ligand interactions by fluorescence polarization

Quantification of the associations between biomolecules is required both to predict and understand the interactions that underpin all biological activity. Fluorescence polarization (FP) provides a nondisruptive means of measuring the association of a fluorescent ligand with a larger molecule. We describe an FP assay in which binding of fluorescein-labeled inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate (IP(3)) to N-terminal fragments of IP(3) receptors can be characterized at different temperatures and in competition with other ligands. The assay allows the standard Gibbs free energy (ΔG°), enthalpy (ΔH°) and entropy (ΔS°) changes of ligand binding to be determined. The method is applicable to any purified ligand-binding site for which an appropriate fluorescent ligand is available. FP can be used to measure low-affinity interactions in real time without the use of radioactive materials, it is nondestructive and, with appropriate care, it can resolve ΔH° and ΔS°. The first part of the protocol, protein preparation, may take several weeks, whereas the FP measurements, once they have been optimized, would normally take 1-6 h.     

Influence of Fluorescent Tag on the Motility Properties of Kinesin-1 in Single-Molecule Assays

Molecular motors such as kinesin and dynein use the energy derived from ATP hydrolysis to walk processively along microtubule tracks and transport various cargoes inside the cell. Recent advancements in fluorescent protein (FP) research enable motors to be fluorescently labeled such that single molecules can be visualized inside cells in multiple colors. The performance of these fluorescent tags can vary depending on their spectral properties and a natural tendency for oligomerization. Here we present a survey of different fluorescent tags fused to kinesin-1 and studied by single-molecule motility assays of mammalian cell lysates. We tested eight different FP tags and found that seven of them display sufficient fluorescence intensity and photostability to visualize motility events. Although none of the FP tags interfere with the enzymatic properties of the motor, four of the tags (EGFP, monomeric EGFP, tagRFPt, and mApple) cause aberrantly long motor run lengths. This behavior is unlikely to be due to electrostatic interactions and is probably caused by tag-dependent oligomerization events that appear to be facilitated by fusion to the dimeric kinesin-1. We also compared the single-molecule performance of various fluorescent SNAP and HALO ligands. We found that although both green and red SNAP ligands provide sufficient fluorescent signal, only the tetramethyl rhodamine (TMR) HALO ligand provides sufficient signal for detection in these assays. This study will serve as a valuable reference for choosing fluorescent labels for single-molecule motility assays.     

An affinity-based fluorescence polarization assay for protein tyrosine phosphatases

Protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTPs) are important signaling enzymes that control such fundamental processes as proliferation, differentiation, survival/apoptosis, as well as adhesion and motility. Potent and selective PTP inhibitors serve not only as powerful research tools, but also as potential therapeutics against a variety illness including cancer and diabetes. PTP activity-based assays are widely used in high throughput screening (HTS) campaigns for PTP inhibitor discovery. These assays suffer from a major weakness, in that the reactivity of the active site Cys can cause serious problems as highly reactive oxidizing and alkylating agents may surface as hits. We describe the development of a fluorescence polarization (FP)-based displacement assay that makes the use of an active site Cys to Ser mutant PTP (e.g., PTP1B/C215S) that retains the wild-type binding affinity. The potency of library compounds is assessed by their ability to compete with the fluorescently labeled active site ligand for binding to the Cys to Ser PTP mutant. Finally, the substitution of the active site Cys by a Ser renders the mutant PTP insensitive to oxidation and alkylation and thus will likely eliminate "false" positives due to modification of the active site Cys that destroy the phosphatase activity.     

Interactions between cardiac glycosides and sodium/potassium-ATPase: three-dimensional structure-activity relationship models for ligand binding to the E2-Pi form of the enzyme versus activity inhibition

Sodium/potassium-ATPase (Na/K-ATPase) is a transmembrane enzyme that utilizes energy gained from ATP hydrolysis to transport sodium and potassium ions across cell membranes in opposite directions against their chemical and electrical gradients. Its transport activity is effectively inhibited by cardiac glycosides, which bind to the extracellular side of the enzyme and are of significant therapeutic value in the treatment of congestive heart failure. To determine the extent to which high-affinity binding of cardiac glycosides correlates with their potency in inhibiting pump activity, we determined experimentally both the binding affinities and inhibitory potencies of a series of 37 cardiac glycosides using radioligand binding and ATPase activity assays. The observed variations in key structural elements of these compounds correlating with binding and inhibition were analyzed by comparative molecular similarity index analysis (CoMSIA), which allowed a molecular level characterization and comparison of drug-Na/K-ATPase interactions that are important for ligand binding and activity inhibition. In agreement with our earlier comparative molecular field analysis studies [Farr, C. D., et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 1137-1148], the CoMSIA models predicted favorable inhibitor interactions primarily at the alpha-sugar and lactone ring moieties of the cardiac glycosides. Unfavorable interactions were located about the gamma-sugar group and at several positions about the steroid ring system. Whereas for most compounds a correlation between binding affinity and inhibitory potency was found, some notable exceptions were identified. Substitution of the five-membered lactone of cardenolides with the six-membered lactone of bufadienolides caused binding affinity to decline but inhibitory potency to increase. Furthermore, while the removal of ouabain's rhamnose moiety had little effect on inhibitory potency, it caused a dramatic decline in ligand binding affinity.     

Imidazole derivatives as a novel class of hybrid compounds with inhibitory histamine N-methyltransferase potencies and histamine hH3 receptor affinities

In this study, a novel series of imidazole-containing compounds with dual properties, that is, inhibitory potency at the enzyme histamine N(tau)-methyltransferase (HMT) and antagonist potency at histamine H(3) receptors was designed and synthesized. Pharmacologically, these new hybrid drugs were evaluated in functional assays for their inhibitory potencies at rat kidney HMT and for their antagonist activities on synaptosomes of rat cerebral cortex. For selected compounds, binding affinities at recombinant human histamine H(3) receptors were determined. The first compounds (1-10) of the series proved to be H(3) receptor ligands of high potency at rat synaptosomes or of high binding affinity at human H(3) receptors, respectively, but of only moderate activity as inhibitors of rat kidney HMT. In contrast, aminoquinoline- or tetrahydroacridine-containing derivatives 11-17 also displayed HMT inhibitory potency in the nanomolar concentration range. Preliminary data from molecular modeling investigations showed that the imidazole derivative 15 and the HMT inhibitor quinacrine possess identical binding areas. The most interesting compound (14) is simultaneously a highly potent H(3) receptor ligand (K(i)=4.1nM) and a highly potent HMT inhibitor (IC(50)=24nM), which makes this derivative a valuable pharmacological tool for further development.     

Synthesis and characterization of high affinity inhibitors of the H+/peptide transporter PEPT2.

In this study, we describe the rational synthesis and functional analysis of novel high affinity inhibitors for the mammalian peptide transporter PEPT2. Moreover, we demonstrate which structural properties convert a transported compound into a non-translocated inhibitor. Starting from Lys[Z(NO(2))]-Pro (where Z is benzyloxycarbonyl), which we recently identified as the first competitive high affinity inhibitor of the intestinal peptide transporter PEPT1, a series of different lysine-containing dipeptide derivatives was synthesized and studied for interaction with PEPT2 based on transport competition assays in Pichia pastoris yeast cells expressing PEPT2 heterologously and in renal SKPT cells expressing PEPT2. In addition, the two-electrode voltage clamp technique in Xenopus laevis oocytes expressing PEPT2 was used to determine whether the compounds are transported electrogenically or block the uptake of dipeptides. Synthesis and functional analysis of Lys-Lys derivatives containing benzyloxycarbonyl or 4-nitrobenzyloxycarbonyl side chain protections provided a set of inhibitors that reversibly inhibited the uptake of dipeptides by PEPT2 with K(i) values as low as 10 +/- 1 nm. This is the highest affinity of a ligand of PEPT2 ever reported. Moreover, based on the structure-function relationship, we conclude that the spatial location of the side chain amino protecting group in a dipeptide containing a diaminocarbonic acid and its intramolecular distance from the Calpha atom are key factors for the transformation of a substrate into an inhibitor of PEPT2.     

Determination of affinity and activity of ligands at the human neuropeptide Y Y4 receptor by flow cytometry and aequorin luminescence

Fluorescence-labeled neuropeptide Y (NPY) has been used in flow cytometric binding assays for the determination of affinity constants of NPY Y1, Y2, and Y5 receptor ligands. Because the binding of fluorescent NPY is insufficient for competition studies at the human Y4 receptor (hY4R), we replaced Glu-4 in hPP with Lys for the derivatization with cyanine-5. Because cy5-[K(4)]hPP has high affinity (Kd 5.6 nM) to the hY4R, it was used as a probe in a flow cytometric binding assay. Specific binding of cy5-[K(4)]hPP to hY4R was visualized by confocal microscopy. The hY(4)R, the chimeric G protein G(qi5) and mitochondrially targeted apoaequorin were stably coexpressed in CHO cells. Aequorin luminescence was quantified in a microplate reader and by a CCD camera. By application of these methods 3-cyclohexyl-N-[(3-1H-imidazol-4-ylpropylamino)(imino)methyl]propanamide (UR-AK49) was discovered as the first nonpeptidic Y4R antagonist (pKi 4.17), a lead to be optimized in terms of potency and selectivity.     

A novel method for determination of the affinity of protein: protein interactions in homogeneous assays

Nonradioactive homogeneous assays are widely used to screen for inhibitors of biomolecular interactions. To ensure optimal sensitivity for the detection of competitive inhibitors, reagent concentrations should be fixed at or below the K(D) of the protein-protein interaction. Accurate measurement of K(D) during assay development is therefore critical. Although conventional methods work well with heterogeneous assays, they are generally unsatisfactory with homogeneous systems. Here the authors describe an alternative method to determine the K(D) of protein-protein interactions in homogeneous assays. The method uses a rearrangement of the Cheng-Prusoff equation: IC(50)= (([K(i)]/K(D)) x [L]) + K(i). A competitive inhibitor is titrated into the ligand-receptor binding assay at a range of ligand concentrations and IC(50) values are calculated. Plotting measured IC(50) versus concentration of ligand gives a linear plot with y-intercept (K(i)) and gradient (K(i)/K(D)). K(D) is the affinity constant for the ligand-receptor interaction. Here the authors use homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence (HTRF((R))) in 2 model systems (TRAIL/TRAIL receptor 4 and OX40 ligand/OX40 receptor) and demonstrate that measured K(D) values calculated using the linearized Cheng-Prusoff plot compare favorably with those from independent experiments. The advantages and limitations of the method are discussed.     

Ligand specificity in the CRAL-TRIO protein family

Intracellular trafficking of hydrophobic ligands is often mediated by specific binding proteins. The CRAL-TRIO motif is common to several lipid binding proteins including the cellular retinaldehyde binding protein (CRALBP), the alpha-tocopherol transfer protein (alpha-TTP), yeast phosphatidylinositol transfer protein (Sec14p), and supernatant protein factor (SPF). To examine the ligand specificity of these proteins, we measured their affinity toward a variety of hydrophobic ligands using a competitive [(3)H]-RRR-alpha-tocopherol binding assay. Alpha-TTP preferentially bound RRR-alpha-tocopherol over all other tocols assayed, exhibiting a K(d) of 25 nM. Binding affinities of other tocols for alphaTTP closely paralleled their ability to inhibit in vitro intermembrane transfer and their potency in biological assays. All other homologous proteins studied bound alpha-tocopherol but with pronouncedly weaker (> 10-fold) affinities than alpha-TTP. Sec14p demonstrated a K(d) of 373 nM for alpha-tocopherol, similar to that for its native ligand, phosphatidylinositol (381 nM). Human SPF had the highest affinity for phosphatidylinositol (216 nM) and gamma-tocopherol (268 nM) and significantly weaker affinity for alpha-tocopherol (K(d) 615 nM). SPF bound [(3)H]-squalene more weakly (879 nM) than the other ligands. Our data suggest that of all known CRAL-TRIO proteins, only alphaTTP is likely to serve as the physiological mediator of alpha-tocopherol's biological activity. Further, ligand promiscuity observed within this family suggests that caution should be exercised when suggesting protein function(s) from measurements utilizing a single ligand.     

Synthesis and in vitro evaluation of α-synuclein ligands

Accumulation of misfolded α-synuclein in Lewy bodies and Lewy neurites is the pathological hallmark of Parkinson's disease (PD). To identify ligands having high binding potency toward aggregated α-synuclein, we synthesized a series of phenothiazine derivatives and assessed their binding affinity to recombinant α-synuclein fibrils using a fluorescent thioflavin T competition assay. Among 16 new analogues, the in vitro data suggest that compound 11b has high affinity to α-synuclein fibrils (K(i)=32.10 ± 1.25 nM) and compounds 11d, 16a and16b have moderate affinity to α-synuclein fibrils (K(i)≈50-100 nM). Further optimization of the structure of these analogues may yield compounds with high affinity and selectivity for aggregated α-synuclein.     

Fluorescent retinoid X receptor ligands for fluorescence polarization assay

Retinoid X receptor (RXR) agonists are candidate agents for the treatment of metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes via activation of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR)/RXR or liver X receptor (LXR)/RXR-heterodimers, which control lipid and glucose metabolism. Reporter gene assays or binding assays with radiolabeled compounds are available for RXR ligand screening, but are unsuitable for high-throughput screening. Therefore, as a first step towards stabilizing a fluorescence polarization (FP) assay system for high-throughput RXR ligand screening, we synthesized fluorescent RXR ligands by modification of the lipophilic domain of RXR ligands with a carbostyril fluorophore, and selected the fluorescent RXR agonist 6-[ethyl(1-isobutyl-2-oxo-4-trifluoromethyl-1,2-dihydroquinolin-7-yl)amino]nicotinic acid 8d for further characterization. Compound 8d showed FP in the presence of RXR and the FP was decreased in the presence of the RXR agonist LGD1069 (2). This compound should be a lead compound for use in high-throughput assay systems for screening RXR ligands.     

Parsing the effects of binding,signaling, and trafficking on the mitogenic potencies of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor analogues

The pharmacodynamic potency of a therapeutic cytokine interacting with a cell-surface receptor can be attributed primarily to three central properties: [1] cytokine/receptor binding affinity, [2] cytokine/receptor endocytic trafficking dynamics, and [3] cytokine/receptor signaling. Thus, engineering novel or second-generation cytokines requires an understanding of the contribution of each of these to the overall cell response. We describe here an efficient method toward this goal in demonstrated application to the clinically important cytokine granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (GCSF) with a chemical analogue and a number of genetic mutants. Using a combination of simple receptor-binding and dose-response proliferation assays we construct an appropriately scaled plot of relative mitogenic potency versus ligand concentration normalized by binding affinity. Analysis of binding and proliferation data in this manner conveniently indicates which of the cytokine properties-binding, trafficking, and/or signaling-are contributing substantially to altered potency effects. For the GCSF analogues studied here, two point mutations as well as a poly(ethylene glycol) chemical conjugate were found to have increased potencies despite comparable or slightly lower affinities, and trafficking was predicted to be the responsible mechanism. A third point mutant exhibiting comparable binding affinity but reduced potency was predicted to have largely unchanged trafficking properties. Surprisingly, another mutant possessing an order-of-magnitude weaker binding affinity displayed enhanced potency, and increased ligand half-life was predicted to be responsible for this net beneficial effect. Each of these predictions was successfully demonstrated by subsequent measurements of depletion of these five analogues from cell culture medium. Thus, for the GCSF system we find that ligand trafficking dynamics can play a major role in regulating mitogenic potency. Our results demonstrate that cytokine analogues can exhibit pharmacodynamic behaviors across a diverse spectrum of "binding-potency space" and that our analysis through normalization can efficiently elucidate hypotheses for the underlying mechanisms for further dedicated testing. We have also extended the Black-Leff model of pharmacological agonism to include trafficking effects along with binding and signaling, and this model provides a framework for parsing the effects of these factors on pharmacodynamic potency.