Variation and robustness of the mechanics of gastrulation: the role of tissue mechanical properties during morphogenesis

Diverse mechanisms of morphogenesis generate a wide variety of animal forms. In this work, we discuss two ways that the mechanical properties of embryonic tissues could guide one of the earliest morphogenetic movements in animals, gastrulation. First, morphogenetic movements are a function of both the forces generated by cells and the mechanical properties of the tissues. Second, cells could change their behavior in response to their mechanical environment. Theoretical studies of gastrulation indicate that different morphogenetic mechanisms differ in their inherent sensitivity to tissue mechanical properties. Those few empirical studies that have investigated the mechanical properties of amphibian and echinoderm gastrula-stage embryos indicate that there could be high embryo-to-embryo variability in tissue stiffness. Such high embryo-to-embryo variability would imply that gastrulation is fairly robust to variation in tissue stiffness. Cell culture studies demonstrate a wide variety of cellular responses to the mechanical properties of their microenvironment. These responses are likely to be developmentally regulated, and could either increase or decrease the robustness of gastrulation movements depending on which cells express which responses. Hence both passive physical and mechanoregulatory processes will determine how sensitive gastrulation is to tissue mechanics. Addressing these questions is important for understanding the significance of diverse programs of early development, and how genetic or environmental perturbations influence development. We discuss methods for measuring embryo-to-embryo variability in tissue mechanics, and for experimentally perturbing those mechanical properties to determine the sensitivity of gastrulation to tissue mechanics.     

Gastrulation in the sea anemone Nematostella vectensis occurs by invagination and immigration: an ultrastructural study

The sea anemone Nematostella vectensis has recently been established as a new model system for the understanding of the evolution of developmental processes. In particular, the evolutionary origin of gastrulation and its molecular regulation are the subject of intense investigation. However, while molecular data are rapidly accumulating, no detailed morphological data exist describing the process of gastrulation. Here, we carried out an ultrastructural study of different stages of gastrulation in Nematostella using transmission electron microscope and scanning electron microscopy techniques. We show that presumptive endodermal cells undergo a change in cell shape, reminiscent of the bottle cells known from vertebrates and several invertebrates. Presumptive endodermal cells organize into a field, the pre-endodermal plate, which undergoes invagination. In parallel, the endodermal cells decrease their apical cell contacts but remain loosely attached to each other. Hence, during early gastrulation they display an incomplete epithelial–mesenchymal transition (EMT). At a late stage of gastrulation, the cells eventually detach and fill the interior of the blastocoel as mesenchymal cells. This shows that gastrulation in Nematostella occurs by a combination of invagination and late immigration involving EMT. The comparison with molecular expression studies suggests that cells expressing snailA undergo EMT and become endodermal, whereas forkhead/brachyury expressing cells at the ectodermal margin of the blastopore retain their epithelial integrity throughout gastrulation.     

Gastrulation in the sea urchin embryo: a model system for analyzing the morphogenesis of a monolayered epithelium

Processes of gastrulation in the sea urchin embryo have been intensively studied to reveal the mechanisms involved in the invagination of a monolayered epithelium. It is widely accepted that the invagination proceeds in two steps (primary and secondary invagination) until the archenteron reaches the apical plate, and that the constituent cells of the resulting archenteron are exclusively derived from the veg2 tier of blastomeres formed at the 60-cell stage. However, recent studies have shown that the recruitment of the archenteron cells lasts as late as the late prism stage, and some descendants of veg1 blastomeres are also recruited into the archenteron. In this review, we first illustrate the current outline of sea urchin gastrulation. Second, several factors, such as cytoskeletons, cell contact and extracellular matrix, will be discussed in relation to the cellular and mechanical basis of gastrulation. Third, differences in the manner of gastrulation among sea urchin species will be described; in some species, the archenteron does not elongate stepwise but continuously. In those embryos, bottle cells are scarcely observed, and the archenteron cells are not rearranged during invagination unlike in typical sea urchins. Attention will be also paid to some other factors, such as the turgor pressure of blastocoele and the force generated by blastocoele wall. These factors, in spite of their significance, have been neglected in the analysis of sea urchin gastrulation. Lastly, we will discuss how behavior of pigment cells defines the manner of gastrulation, because pigment cells recently turned out to be the bottle cells that trigger the initial inward bending of the vegetal plate.     

Gastrulation in Halocordyle disticha (Hydrozoa,Athecata)

Summary

Previous reports of development in Halocordyle disticha have described gastrulation as occurring by gradual differentiation of the inner and outer cells of the stereoblastula. In 1984, however, Martin and Thomas described an indentation on the surface of the embryo at the time of gastrulation. They hypothesized from morphological data that the indentation represented a blastopore. Here we provide results of marking studies which demonstrate that the indentation is in fact a site of cellular ingression. This is the first example known of gastrulation that involves unipolar ingression in a form with a stereoblastula. Possible functions of gastrulation by unipolar ingression are discussed, and the possible phylogenetic significance of the occurrence of such a mode of gastrulation in H. disticha is considered.     

Non-redundant roles for Profilin2 and Profilin1 during vertebrate gastrulation

Gastrulation is a critical morphogenetic event during vertebrate embryogenesis, and it is comprised of directional cell movement resulting from the polarization and reorganization of the actin cytoskeleton. The non-canonical Wnt signaling pathway has emerged as a key regulator of gastrulation. However, the molecular mechanisms by which the Wnt pathway mediates changes to the cellular actin cytoskeleton remains poorly defined. We had previously identified the Formin protein Daam1 and an effector molecule XProfilin1 as links for Wnt-mediated cytoskeletal changes during gastrulation. We report here the identification of XProfilin2 as a non-redundant and distinct effector of Daam1 for gastrulation. XProfilin2 interacts with FH1 domain of Daam1 and temporally interacts with Daam1 during gastrulation. In the Xenopus embryo, XProfilin2 is temporally expressed throughout embryogenesis and it is spatially expressed in cells undergoing morphogenetic movement during gastrulation. While we have previously shown XProfilin1 regulates blastopore closure, overexpression or depletion of XProfilin2 specifically affects convergent extension movement independent of mesodermal specification. Specifically, we show that XProfilin2 modulates cell polarization and axial alignment of mesodermal cells undergoing gastrulation independent of XProfilin1. Together, our studies demonstrate that XProfilin2 and XProfilin1 are non-redundant effectors for Daam1 for non-canonical Wnt signaling and that they regulate distinct functions during vertebrate gastrulation.     

mRNA localization studies suggest that murine FGF-5 plays a role in gastrulation.

During gastrulation in the mouse, the pluripotent embryonic ectoderm cells form the three primary germ layers, ectoderm, mesoderm and endoderm. Little is known about the mechanisms responsible for these processes, but evidence from previous studies in amphibians, as well as expression studies in mammals, suggest that signalling molecules of the Fibroblast Growth Factor (FGF) family may play a role in gastrulation. To determine whether this might be the case for FGF-5 in the mouse embryo, we carried out RNA in situ hybridization studies to determine when and where in the early postimplantation embryo the Fgf-5 gene is expressed. We chose to study this particular member of the FGF gene family because we had previously observed that its pattern of expression in cultures of teratocarcinoma cell aggregates is consistent with the proposal that Fgf-5 plays a role in gastrulation in vivo. The results reported here show that Fgf-5 expression increases dramatically in the pluripotent embryonic ectoderm just prior to gastrulation, is restricted to the cells forming the three primary germ layers during gastrulation, and is not detectable in any cells in the embryo once formation of the primary germ layers is virtually complete. Based on this provocative expression pattern and in light of what is known about the functions in vitro of other members of the FGF family, we hypothesize that in the mouse embryo Fgf-5 functions in an autocrine manner to stimulate the mobility of the cells that contribute to the embryonic germ layers or to render them competent to respond to other inductive or positional signals.     

Allocation of epiblast cells to germ layer derivatives during mouse gastrulation as studied with a retroviral vector

The embryonic ectoderm, or epiblast, is the source of the three primary germ layers that form during gastrulation in the mouse embryo. Previous studies have investigated the fate of epiblast cells in early gastrulation stages using clonal analysis of cell lineage and in late gastrulation stages using transplantation of labeled grafts. In this study, we studied the fate of late gastrulation stage epiblast using a clonal analysis based on a retroviral vector encoding the Escherichia coli lacZ gene. We found that by reducing the volume of viral suspension injected into each embryo, it was possible to achieve single infectious events. Our analysis of 20 embryos singly infected at the late streak stage and 21 at the head fold stage revealed clonal descendants in only a single germ layer in each embryo. These results indicate that allocation of epiblast progenitors to a single germ layer fate has occurred by late gastrulation in mouse embryos. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Phosphoinositide 3-kinase is required for process outgrowth and cell polarization of gastrulating mesendodermal cells

BACKGROUND: During vertebrate gastrulation, cell polarization and migration are core components in the cellular rearrangements that lead to the formation of the three germ layers, ectoderm, mesoderm, and endoderm. Previous studies have implicated the Wnt/planar cell polarity (PCP) signaling pathway in controlling cell morphology and movement during gastrulation. However, cell polarization and directed cell migration are reduced but not completely abolished in the absence of Wnt/PCP signals; this observation indicates that other signaling pathways must be involved. RESULTS: We show that Phosphoinositide 3-Kinases (PI3Ks) are required at the onset of zebrafish gastrulation in mesendodermal cells for process formation and cell polarization. Platelet Derived Growth Factor (PDGF) functions upstream of PI3K, while Protein Kinase B (PKB), a downstream effector of PI3K activity, localizes to the leading edge of migrating mesendodermal cells. In the absence of PI3K activity, PKB localization and cell polarization are strongly reduced in mesendodermal cells and are followed by slower but still highly coordinated and directed movements of these cells. CONCLUSIONS: We have identified a novel role of a signaling pathway comprised of PDGF, PI3K, and PKB in the control of morphogenetic cell movements during gastrulation. Furthermore, our findings provide insight into the relationship between cell polarization and directed cell migration at the onset of zebrafish gastrulation.     

Intercellular bridges in vertebrate gastrulation

The developing zebrafish embryo has been the subject of many studies of regional patterning, stereotypical cell movements and changes in cell shape. To better study the morphological features of cells during gastrulation, we generated mosaic embryos expressing membrane attached Dendra2 to highlight cellular boundaries. We find that intercellular bridges join a significant fraction of epiblast cells in the zebrafish embryo, reaching several cell diameters in length and spanning across different regions of the developing embryos. These intercellular bridges are distinct from the cellular protrusions previously reported as extending from hypoblast cells (1-2 cellular diameters in length) or epiblast cells (which were shorter). Most of the intercellular bridges were formed at pre-gastrula stages by the daughters of a dividing cell maintaining a membrane tether as they move apart after mitosis. These intercellular bridges persist during gastrulation and can mediate the transfer of proteins between distant cells. These findings reveal a surprising feature of the cellular landscape in zebrafish embryos and open new possibilities for cell-cell communication during gastrulation, with implications for modeling, cellular mechanics, and morphogenetic signaling.     

TRPM7 regulates gastrulation during vertebrate embryogenesis

During gastrulation, cells in the dorsal marginal zone polarize, elongate, align and intercalate to establish the physical body axis of the developing embryo. Here we demonstrate that the bifunctional channel-kinase TRPM7 is specifically required for vertebrate gastrulation. TRPM7 is temporally expressed maternally and throughout development, and is spatially enriched in tissues undergoing convergent extension during gastrulation. Functional studies reveal that TRPM7's ion channel, but not its kinase domain, specifically affects cell polarity and convergent extension movements during gastrulation, independent of mesodermal specification. During gastrulation, the non-canonical Wnt pathway via Dishevelled (Dvl) orchestrates the activities of the GTPases Rho and Rac to control convergent extension movements. We find that TRPM7 functions synergistically with non-canonical Wnt signaling to regulate Rac activity. The phenotype caused by depletion of the Ca²⁺- and Mg²⁺-permeant TRPM7 is suppressed by expression of a dominant negative form of Rac, as well as by Mg²⁺ supplementation or by expression of the Mg²⁺ transporter SLC41A2. Together, these studies demonstrate an essential role for the ion channel TRPM7 and Mg²⁺ in Rac-dependent polarized cell movements during vertebrate gastrulation.     

Analysis of mouse Evx genes: Evx-1 displays graded expression in the primitive streak.

Two mouse genes, Evx-1 and Evx-2, each encoding a homeodomain closely related to that of the Drosophila even-skipped gene were isolated using a PCR-based strategy. The structure and sequence of these genes are described. Mapping studies localized Evx-1 to chromosome 6, near the Hox-1 gene cluster, and Evx-2 to chromosome 2, near the Hox-4 cluster. The evolutionary implications of these linkages are discussed. RNA in situ hybridization analysis of Evx expression in embryos demonstrated a striking pattern of Evx-1 expression during gastrulation, whereas Evx-2 RNA could not be detected at any stage by this technique. Evx-1 RNA is first detected shortly before the onset of gastrulation in a region of ectoderm containing cells that will soon be found in the primitive streak. This localized expression of Evx-1 provides the first molecular evidence for regional differences in the mouse embryonic ectoderm before gastrulation. Throughout gastrulation, Evx-1 expression is limited to cells near and within the streak and that expression is graded, with a posterior-to-anterior decrease in the level of RNA. Based on fate-mapping studies indicating that different types of mesoderm emerge from different regions of the primitive streak and our observation that high levels of expression are localized to the region that will give rise to extraembryonic and ventral mesoderm, we speculate that Evx-1 plays a role in the dorsoventral specification of mesodermal cell fate.     

A cell-based model of Nematostella vectensis gastrulation including bottle cell formation, invagination and zippering

The gastrulation of Nematostella vectensis, the starlet sea anemone, is morphologically simple yet involves many conserved cell behaviors such as apical constriction, invagination, bottle cell formation, cell migration and zippering found during gastrulation in a wide range of more morphologically complex animals.In this article we study Nematostella gastrulation using a combination of morphometrics and computational modeling. Through this analysis we frame gastrulation as a non-trivial problem, in which two distinct cell domains must change shape to match each other geometrically, while maintaining the integrity of the embryo. Using a detailed cell-based model capable of representing arbitrary cell-shapes such as bottle cells, as well as filopodia, localized adhesion and constriction, we are able to simulate gastrulation and associate emergent macroscopic changes in embryo shape to individual cell behaviors.We have developed a number of testable hypotheses based on the model. First, we hypothesize that the blastomeres need to be stiffer at their apical ends, relative to the rest of the cell perimeter, in order to be able to hold their wedge shape and the dimensions of the blastula, regardless of whether the blastula is sealed or leaky. We also postulate that bottle cells are a consequence of cell strain and low cell–cell adhesion, and can be produced within an epithelium even without apical constriction. Finally, we postulate that apical constriction, filopodia and de-epithelialization are necessary and sufficient for gastrulation based on parameter variation studies.     

The cessation of gastrulation

An integral component of gastrulation in all organisms is epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT), a fundamental morphogenetic event through which epithelial cells transform into mesenchymal cells. The mesenchymal cells that arise from epithelial cells during gastrulation contribute to various tissue rudiments during subsequent development, including the notochord, somites, heart, gut, kidney, body wall, and lining of the coelom. The process of gastrulation has been the subject of several hundred scientific papers. Despite all that has been written, it is likely that what we currently know about gastrulation is still considerably less than what remains to be learned. One critical remaining question that we consider here is how does gastrulation cease at the right place along the body axis, and at the right time? In this commentary, we focus on the molecular mechanism for the cessation of gastrulation, using the chick embryo as a model system.     

Developmental abnormalities of NT mouse embryos appear early after implantation

In mammals, cloning by nuclear transfer (NT) into an enucleated oocyte is a very inefficient process, even if it can generate healthy adults. We show that blastocysts derived from embryonic stem (ES) donor cells develop at a high rate, correctly express the pluripotential marker gene Oct4 in ICM cells and display normal growth in vitro. Moreover, the majority of them implant in the uterus of recipient females. We combine embryological studies, gene expression analysis during gastrulation and generation of chimaeric embryos to identify the developmental origin (stage and tissue affected) of NT embryo mortality. The majority died before mid-gestation from defects arising early, either at peri-implantation stages or during the gastrulation period. The first type of defect is a non-cell autonomous defect of the epiblast cells and is rescued by complementation of NT blastocysts with normal ES or ICM cells. The second type of defect affects growth regulation and the shape of the embryo but does not directly impair the initial establishment of the patterning of the embryo. Only chimaeras formed by the aggregation of NT and tetraploid embryos reveal no growth abnormalities at gastrulation. These studies indicate that the trophoblast cell lineage is the primary source of these defects. These embryological studies provide a solid basis for understanding reprogramming errors in NT embryos. In addition, they unveil new aspects of growth regulation while increasing our knowledge on the role of crosstalk between the extra-embryonic and the embryonic regions of the conceptus in the control of growth and morphogenesis.     

Xoom is required for epibolic movement of animal ectodermal cells in Xenopus laevis gastrulation

Gastrulation is the most dynamic cell movement and initiates the body plan in amphibian development. In contrast to numerous molecular studies on mesodermal induction, the driving force of gastrulation is as yet poorly understood. A novel transmembrane protein, Xoom, was previously reported, which is required for Xenopus gastrulation. In the present study, the role of Xoom during Xenopus gastrulation was further examined in detail. Overexpression and misexpression of Xoom induced overproduction of Xoom protein, but not a changed phenotype. However, Xoom antisense ribonucleic acid (RNA) injection reduced the Xoom protein and caused gastrulation defects without any influence on the involution and translation levels of mesodermal marker genes. Normal migrating activity of dorsal mesodermal cells was recognized in the antisense RNA-injected explant. Morphological examination using artificial exogastrulation showed that convergent extension of mesodermal cells occurred normally, but the ectodermal cell layer significantly shrank in the antisense RNA-injected embryo. Comparison of cell shape among various experimental conditions showed that inhibition of cell spreading occurs specifically in the outer ectodermal layer of the antisense RNA-injected embryo. Cytochemical examination indicated disorganization of F-actin in the ectodermal cells of the antisense RNA-injected embryo. These results suggest that Xoom plays an important role in the epibolic movement of ectodermal cells through some regulation of actin filament organization.     

Gastrulation in Calcareous Sponges: In Search of Haeckel's Gastraea

Haeckel's studies of development in calcareous sponges (1872)led him to develop the "Gastraea Theory," which proposes thatthe ancestral mode of germ layer formation, or gastrulation,was by invagination to produce a functional gut. His observationsthat gastrulation in the Calcarea occurs by invagination ofa ciliated larva upon settlement and metamorphosis were supportedby remarkable photomicrographs of the stage by Hammer in 1908.Although no later work found the same stage, these conceptsare repeated in texts today. We have re-examined embryogenesisand metamorphosis in Sycon sp. cf. S. raphanus in order to understandwhen gastrulation occurs. Almost all larvae settle on theirciliated anterior pole and metamorphose into a bilayered juvenilewhose interior cells rapidly differentiate into choanocytesand other cells of the young sponge. After a four-year searchwe have found the transitory stage shown by Hammer in whichthe anterior cells invaginate into the posterior half of thelarva. The hole closes and it is not until some days later thatthe sponge forms an osculum at its apical pole. To understandwhether invagination comprises gastrulation and if the holecan be considered to be a blastopore we have carried out a reviewof the literature dealing with this brief moment in calcaroneansponge development. Despite the intrigue of this type of metamorphosis,we conclude that gastrulation occurs earlier, during formationof the two cellular regions of the larva, and that metamorphosisinvolves the reorganization of these already differentiatedregions. Considering the pivotal position occupied by the Calcareaas the possible sister-group to all other Metazoa, these resultscall for a reassessment of germ layer formation and of the relationshipsof the primary germ layers among basal metazoan phyla.     

Analysis of extraembryonic mesodermal structure formation in the absence of morphological primitive streak

During mouse gastrulation, the primitive streak is formed on the posterior side of the embryo. Cells migrate out of the primitive streak to form the future mesoderm and endoderm. Fate mapping studies revealed a group of cell migrate through the proximal end of the primitive streak and give rise to the extraembryonic mesoderm tissues such as the yolk sac blood islands and allantois. However, it is not clear whether the formation of a morphological primitive streak is required for the development of these extraembryonic mesodermal tissues. Loss of the Cripto gene in mice dramatically reduces, but does not completely abolish, Nodal activity leading to the absence of a morphological primitive streak. However, embryonic erythrocytes are still formed and assembled into the blood islands. In addition, Cripto mutant embryos form allantoic buds. However, Drap1 mutant embryos have excessive Nodal activity in the epiblast cells before gastrulation and form an expanded primitive streak, but no yolk sac blood islands or allantoic bud formation. Lefty2 embryos also have elevated levels of Nodal activity in the primitive streak during gastrulation, and undergo normal blood island and allantois formation. We therefore speculate that low level of Nodal activity disrupts the formation of morphological primitive streak on the posterior side, but still allows the formation of primitive streak cells on the proximal side, which give rise to the extraembryonic mesodermal tissues formation. Excessive Nodal activity in the epiblast at pre‐gastrulation stage, but not in the primitive streak cells during gastrulation, disrupts extraembryonic mesoderm development.     

Cell movements during the initial phase of gastrulation in the sea urchin embryo.

The morphogenetic processes responsible for the initial phase of gastrulation in sea urchin embryos are not known. Here we report observations of the size and position of clones of cells derived from horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-injected mesomeres and macromeres. The displacement of these clones during the initial phase of gastrulation suggests that involution is a mechanism involved in primary invagination. Experiments with embryos marked with vital dyes indicate that movements occur only during a brief phase coincident with the invagination of the vegetal plate. Counts of cells derived from HRP-injected mesomeres and macromeres suggest it unlikely that localized growth in the vegetal plate is involved in gastrulation. An analysis of changes in cell shape during the initial phase of gastrulation indicates that there is a stage-dependent shift from cells being columnar to having their apices skewed toward the vegetal plate and an increase in the proportion of cells having basal processes during gastrulation. When embryos are grown in the presence of monoclonal antibodies to the apical lamina or monovalent fragments of these antibodies, the initial phase of gastrulation is delayed and they form partial exogastrulae. Analysis of embryos marked with HRP indicate that the antibody treatments interfere with the cellular movements observed in untreated embryos. We conclude that directed movements of cells within the blastoderm, probably employing tractoring on components of the hyaline layer, cause the buckling of the vegetal plate and displacement of presumptive endoderm cells seen during the initial phase of gastrulation.     

The cessation of gastrulation: BMP signaling and EMT during and at the end of gastrulation

An integral component of gastrulation in all organisms is epithelial to mesenchymal transition (EMT), a fundamental morphogenetic event through which epithelial cells transform into mesenchymal cells. The mesenchymal cells that arise from epithelial cells during gastrulation contribute to various tissue rudiments during subsequent development, including the notochord, somites, heart, gut, kidney, body wall and lining of the coelom. The process of gastrulation has been the subject of several hundred scientific papers. Despite all that has been written, it is likely that what we currently know about gastrulation is still considerably less than what remains to be learned. One critical remaining question that we consider here is how does gastrulation cease at the right place along the body axis, and at the right time? In this commentary, we focus on the molecular mechanism for the cessation of gastrulation, using the chick embryo as a model system.Key words: epithelial to mesenchymal transition (EMT), gastrulation, basal membrane, tail bud, ventral ectodermal ridge (VER), BMP, noggin, E-cadherin, chick embryo