The specific binding, bending, and unwinding of DNA by RsrI endonuclease, an isoschizomer of EcoRI endonuclease

To determine whether RsrI endonuclease recognizes and cleaves the sequence GAATTC in duplex DNA similarly to its isoschizomer EcoRI we initiated a functional comparison of the two enzymes. Equilibrium binding experiments showed that at 20 degrees C RsrI endonuclease binds to specific and nonspecific sequences in DNA with affinities similar to those of EcoRI. At 0 degrees C the affinity of RsrI for its specific recognition sequence is reduced 7-fold whereas the affinity for noncanonical sequences remains relatively unchanged. Unlike EcoRI, incubation of RsrI endonuclease with N-ethylmaleimide inactivates the enzyme; however, preincubation with DNA prevents the inactivation. The N-ethylmaleimide-treated enzyme fails to bind DNA as assayed by gel mobility shift assays. Comparison of the deduced amino acid sequences of RsrI and EcoRI endonucleases suggests that modification of Cys245 is responsible for the inactivation. Fe(II). EDTA and methidiumpropyl-EDTA.Fe(II) footprinting results indicate that RsrI, like EcoRI, protects 12 base pairs from cleavage when bound to its specific recognition sequence in the absence of Mg2+. RsrI bends DNA by approximately 50 degrees, as determined by measuring the relative electrophoretic mobilities of specific RsrI-DNA complexes with the binding site in the center or near the end of the DNA fragment. This value is similar to that reported for EcoRI. RsrI also unwinds the DNA helix by 25 degrees +/- 5 degrees, a value close to that reported for EcoRI endonuclease. Collectively, these results indicate that the overall structural changes induced in the DNA by the binding of RsrI and EcoRI endonucleases to DNA in the absence of Mg2+ are similar. In the accompanying paper (Aiken, C. R., McLaughlin, L. W., and Gumport, R. I. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 19070-19078) we present results of studies of RsrI endonuclease using oligonucleotide substrates containing base analogues which suggest differences in the ways the two enzymes cleave DNA.     

Purification and characterization of the restriction endonuclease RsrI, an isoschizomer of EcoRI

Rhodobacter sphaeroides strain 630 produces restriction enzyme RsrI which is an isoschizomer of EcoRI. We have purified this enzyme and initiated a comparison with the EcoRI endonuclease. The properties of RsrI are consistent with a reaction mechanism similar to that of EcoRI: the position of cleavage within the -GAATTC-site is identical, the MgCl2 optimum for the cleavage is identical, and the pH profile is similar. Methylation of the substrate sequence by the EcoRI methylase protects the site from cleavage by the RsrI endonuclease. RsrI cross-reacts strongly with anti-EcoRI serum indicating three-dimensional structural similarities. We have determined the sequence of 34 N terminal amino acids for RsrI and this sequence possesses significant similarity to the EcoRI N terminus.     

Purification, cloning and sequence analysis of RsrI DNA methyltransferase: lack of homology between two enzymes, RsrI and EcoRI, that methylate the same nucleotide in identical recognition sequences.

RsrI DNA methyltransferase (M-RsrI) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides has been purified to homogeneity, and its gene cloned and sequenced. This enzyme catalyzes methylation of the same central adenine residue in the duplex recognition sequence d(GAATTC) as does M-EcoRI. The reduced and denatured molecular weight of the RsrI methyltransferase (MTase) is 33,600 Da. A fragment of R. sphaeroides chromosomal DNA exhibited M.RsrI activity in E. coli and was used to sequence the rsrIM gene. The deduced amino acid sequence of M.RsrI shows partial homology to those of the type II adenine MTases HinfI and DpnA and N4-cytosine MTases BamHI and PvuII, and to the type III adenine MTases EcoP1 and EcoP15. In contrast to their corresponding isoschizomeric endonucleases, the deduced amino acid sequences of the RsrI and EcoRI MTases show very little homology. Either the EcoRI and RsrI restriction-modification systems assembled independently from closely related endonuclease and more distantly related MTase genes, or the MTase genes diverged more than their partner endonuclease genes. The rsrIM gene sequence has also been determined by Stephenson and Greene (Nucl. Acids Res. (1989) 17, this issue).     

The highly homologous isoschizomers RsrI endonuclease and EcoRI endonuclease do not recognize their target sequence identically

Using a series of decadeoxyribonucleotides containing base analogues as substrates we measured the steady-state kinetic parameters for the reaction catalyzed by RsrI endonuclease and compared the results to those with its isoschizomer EcoRI. The kinetics of RsrI cleavage are affected by each substitution, with the effects being generally more deleterious than with EcoRI, as shown by the greater reduction in the specificity constant kcat/KM. The magnitudes of the effects of several substitutions are consistent with the formation of direct enzyme-nucleobase contacts at the indicated positions. With substrates containing 2-amino-purine or 2,6-diaminopurine at the central adenine or uracil at the outermost thymine in the recognition sequence, cleavage by RsrI was very slow, less than one-tenth the rate of the corresponding EcoRI-catalyzed reaction. The lower tolerance of RsrI endonuclease for functional group changes in its recognition site may reflect differences in the mechanisms of DNA recognition by the two enzymes. Although RsrI and EcoRI endonucleases bind with similar affinities to specific and nonspecific DNA sequences and appear to introduce similar structural distortions in DNA upon binding, the use of substrate analogues reveals significant differences at the level of catalysis in the mechanisms by which these two endonucleases recognize the duplex sequence GAATTC.     

Comparison of the nucleotide and amino acid sequences of the RsrI and EcoRI restriction endonucleases

The RsrI endonuclease, a type-II restriction endonuclease (ENase) found in Rhodobacter sphaeroides, is an isoschizomer of the EcoRI ENase. A clone containing an 11-kb BamHI fragment was isolated from an R. sphaeroides genomic DNA library by hybridization with synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotide probes based on the N-terminal amino acid (aa) sequence of RsrI. Extracts of E. coli containing a subclone of the 11-kb fragment display RsrI activity. Nucleotide sequence analysis reveals an 831-bp open reading frame encoding a polypeptide of 277 aa. A 50% identity exists within a 266-aa overlap between the deduced aa sequences of RsrI and EcoRI. Regions of 75-100% aa sequence identity correspond to key structural and functional regions of EcoRI. The type-II ENases have many common properties, and a common origin might have been expected. Nevertheless, this is the first demonstration of aa sequence similarity between ENases produced by different organisms.     

An EcoRI-RsrI chimeric restriction endonuclease retains parental sequence specificity

To test their structural and functional similarity, hybrids were constructed between EcoRI and RsrI, two restriction endonucleases recognizing the same DNA sequence and sharing 50% amino acid sequence identity. One of the chimeric proteins (EERE), in which the EcoRI segment His147-Ala206 was replaced with the corresponding RsrI segment, showed EcoRI/RsrI-specific endonuclease activity. EERE purified from inclusion bodies was found to have approximately 100-fold weaker activity but higher specific DNA binding affinity, than EcoRI. Increased binding is consistent with results of molecular dynamics simulations, which indicate that the number of hydrogen bonds formed with the recognition sequence increased in the chimera as compared to EcoRI. The success of obtaining an EcoRI-RsrI hybrid endonuclease, which differs from EcoRI by 22 RsrI-specific amino acid substitutions and still preserves canonical cleavage specificity, is a sign of structural and functional similarity shared by the parental enzymes. This conclusion is also supported by computational studies, which indicate that construction of the EERE chimera did not induce substantial changes in the structure of EcoRI. Surprisingly, the chimeric endonuclease was more toxic to cells not protected by EcoRI methyltransferase, than the parental EcoRI mutant. Molecular modelling revealed structural alterations, which are likely to impede coupling between substrate recognition and cleavage and suggest a possible explanation for the toxic phenotype.     

Purification and characterization of the M.RsrI DNA methyltransferase from Escherichia coli.

The gene (rsrIM) encoding the RsrI DNA methyltransferase (M.RsrI) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides was cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli. Under the control of a bacteriophage T7 promoter, 2% of the total protein in a crude extract was M.RsrI. This level of expression represents an approximately 50-fold increase over that present in the natural host. Chromatography using DNA cellulose and the S-adenosylmethionine analogue, sinefungin, was useful in purifying the enzyme to homogeneity. The purification yielded 100 times more enzyme than was obtained from the same quantity of R. sphaeroides cell paste. M.RsrI deposits one methyl group per productive DNA-binding event, as does its functional but sequence-nonhomologous analogue, M.EcoRI. Unlike M.EcoRI, the R. sphaeroides enzyme is a dimer at micromolar concentrations.     

Substrate recognition by the EcoRI endonuclease

The EcoRI restriction endonuclease is one of the most widely used tools for recombinant DNA manipulations. Because the EcoRI enzyme has been extremely well characterized biochemically and its structure is known at 3 A resolution as an enzyme-DNA complex, EcoRI also serves as a paradigm for other restriction enzymes and as an important model of DNA-protein interactions. To facilitate a genetic analysis of the EcoRI enzyme, we devised an in vivo DNA scission assay based on our finding that DNA double-strand breaks induce the Escherichia coli SOS response and thereby increase beta-galactosidase expression from SOS::lacZ gene fusions. By site-directed mutagenesis, 50 of 60 possible point mutations were generated at three amino acids (E144, R145, and R200) implicated in substrate recognition by the crystal structure. Although several of these mutant enzymes retain partial endonuclease activity, none are altered in substrate specificity in vivo or in vitro. These findings argue that, in addition to the hydrogen bond interactions revealed by the crystal structure, the EcoRI enzyme must make additional contacts to recognize its substrate.     

The kinetic mechanism of EcoRI endonuclease.

Steady-state parameters governing cleavage of pBR322 DNA by EcoRI endonuclease are highly sensitive to ionic environment, with K(m) and k(cat) increasing 1,000-fold and 15-fold, respectively, when ionic strength is increased from 0.059 to 0.23 M. By contrast, pre-steady-state analysis has shown that recognition, as well as first and second strand cleavage events that occur once the enzyme has arrived at the EcoRI site, are essentially insensitive to ionic strength, and has demonstrated that the rate-limiting step for endonuclease turnover occurs after double-strand cleavage under all conditions tested. Furthermore, processive cleavage of a pBR322 variant bearing two closely spaced EcoRI sites is governed by the same turnover number as hydrolysis of parental pBR322, which contains only a single EcoRI sequence, ruling out slow release of the enzyme from the cleaved site or a slow conformational change subsequent to double-strand cleavage. We attribute the effects of ionic strength on steady-state parameters to nonspecific endonuclease.DNA interactions, reflecting facilitated diffusion processes, that occur prior to EcoRI sequence recognition and subsequent to DNA cleavage.     

Mutants of the EcoRI endonuclease with promiscuous substrate specificity implicate residues involved in substrate recognition.

The EcoRI restriction endonuclease cleaves DNA molecules at the sequence GAATTC. We devised a genetic screen to isolate EcoRI mutants with altered or broadened substrate specificity. In vitro, the purified mutant enzymes cleave both the wild-type substrate and sites which differ from this by one nucleotide (EcoRI star sites). These mutations identify four residues involved in substrate recognition and catalysis that are different from the amino acids proposed to recognize the substrate based on the EcoRI-DNA co-crystal structure. In fact, these mutations suppress EcoRI mutants altered at some of the proposed substrate binding residues (R145, R200). We argue that these mutations permit cleavage of additional DNA sequences either by perturbing or removing direct DNA-protein interactions or by facilitating conformational changes that allosterically couple substrate binding to DNA scission.     

A new affinity reagent for the site-specific, covalent attachment of DNA to active-site nucleophiles: application to the EcoRI and RsrI restriction and modification enzymes.

A modified oligodeoxyribonucleotide duplex containing an unnatural internucleotide trisubstituted 3' to 5' pyrophosphate bond in one strand [5'(oligo1)3'-P(OCH3)P-5'(oligo2) 3'] reacts with nucleophiles in aqueous media by acting as a phosphorylating affinity reagent. When interacted with a protein, a portion of the oligonucleotide [--P-5'(oligo2)3'] becomes attached to an amino acid nucleophilic group through a phosphate of the O-methyl-modified pyrophosphate linkage. We demonstrate the affinity labeling of nucleophilic groups at the active sites of the EcoRI and RsrI restriction and modification enzymes with an oligodeoxyribonucleotide duplex containing a modified scissile bond in the EcoRI recognition site. With the EcoRI and RsrI endonucleases in molar excess approximately 1% of the oligonucleotide becomes attached to the protein, and with the companion methyltransferases the yield approaches 40% for the EcoRI enzyme and 30% for the RsrI methyltransferase. Crosslinking proceeds only upon formation of a sequence-specific enzyme-DNA complex, and generates a covalent bond between the 3'-phosphate of the modified pyrophosphate in the substrate and a nucleophilic group at the active site of the enzyme. The reaction results in the elimination of an oligodeoxyribonucleotide remnant that contains the 3'-O-methylphosphate [5'(oligo1)3'-P(OCH3)] derived from the modified phosphate of the pyrophosphate linkage. Hydrolysis properties of the covalent protein-DNA adducts indicate that phosphoamide (P-N) bonds are formed with the EcoRI endonuclease and methyltransferase.     

Role of the 2-amino group of deoxyguanosine in sequence recognition by EcoRI restriction and modification enzymes.

The dG residues within the EcoRI recognition sequence of ColE1 DNA have been selectively replaced with dI. Methylation of the altered sequence by the EcoRI modification enzyme is extremely slow as compared with methyl transfer to the natural recognition site. Since the affinity of the modification enzyme for the dI-containing sequence is considerably less than that for the natural sequence, we have concluded that the 2-amino group of dG has an important role in DNA site recognition by this enzyme. In contrast, the altered site is subject to cleavage by EcoRI endonuclease at rates essentially identical with those observed with the natural sequence. These results strongly suggest that the two enzymes utilize different contacts within the EcoRI site and are consisted with our conclusion (Rubin, R. A., and Modrich, P. (1977) J. Biol. Chem. 252, 7265-7272) that the two proteins interact with their common recognition sequence in different ways.     

The EcoRI restriction endonuclease with bacteriophage lambda DNA. Equilibrium binding studies.

The EcoRI restriction endonuclease was found by the filter binding technique to form stable complexes, in the absence of Mg2+, with the DNA from derivatives of bacteriophage lambda that either contain or lack EcoRI recognition sites. The amount of complex formed at different enzyme concentrations followed a hyperbolic equilibrium-binding curve with DNA molecules containing EcoRI recognition sites, but a sigmoidal equilibrium-binding curve was obtained with a DNA molecule lacking EcoRI recognition sites. The EcoRI enzyme displayed the same affinity for individual recognition sites on lambda DNA, even under conditions where it cleaves these sites at different rates. The binding of the enzyme to a DNA molecule lacking EcoRI sites was decreased by Mg2+. These observations indicate that (a) the EcoRI restriction enzyme binds preferentially to its recognition site on DNA, and that different reaction rates at different recognition sites are due to the rate of breakdown of this complex; (b) the enzyme also binds to other DNA sequences, but that two molecules of enzyme, in a different protein conformation, are involved in the formation of the complex at non-specific consequences; (c) the different affinities of the enzyme for the recognition site and for other sequences on DNA, coupled with the different protein conformations, account for the specificity of this enzyme for the cleavage of DNA at this recognition site; (d) the decrease in the affinity of the enzyme for DNA, caused by Mg2+, liberates binding energy from the DNA-protein complex that can be used in the catalytic reaction.     

Glu-111 is required for activation of the DNA cleavage center of EcoRI endonuclease

Gap repair in the presence of 2'-deoxycytosine 5'-O-(1-thiotriphosphate) has been utilized to mutagenize the amino-terminal one-half of the structural gene for EcoRI endonuclease. This approach has led to identification of over 200 mutants defective in endonuclease function. One mutant protein, which binds to the EcoRI sequence but displays greatly reduced cleavage activity, is the consequence of a Glu to Gly change at position 111. This protein has been purified to homogeneity and characterized in detail. Subunit interactions governing the tetramer to dimer transition of the mutant endonuclease are near normal as are parameters governing its interaction with specific and nonspecific DNA sequences. However, the rate constants for first and second strand cleavage steps are reduced by 60,000- and 30,000-fold, respectively, as a consequence of the Glu----Gly change. The defect in chemical cleavage steps can be partially overcome by elevating the pH of the reaction buffer from 7.6 to 8.5, conditions which enhance the rate of EcoRI* strand cleavage by wild type enzyme to a similar degree. We suggest that the Glu-111 mutation affects an interface between recognition and cleavage functions of the enzyme, an idea consistent with the suggestion that the cleavage center of the endonuclease is subject to activation upon specific recognition of the EcoRI sequence.     

Facilitated diffusion during catalysis by EcoRI endonuclease. Nonspecific interactions in EcoRI catalysis

The potential for processive EcoRI endonuclease hydrolysis has been examined on several DNA substrates containing two EcoRI sites which were embedded in identical sequence environments. With a 388-base pair circular DNA, in which the two recognition sites are separated by 51 base pairs (shorter distance) or 337 base pairs (longer distance), 77 and 34% of all events involved processive hydrolysis at ionic strengths of 0.059 and 0.13, respectively. However, the frequency of processive action on linear substrates, in which the two sites were separated by 51 base pairs, was only 42 and 17% at these ionic strengths, values half those observed with the circular DNA. Processive action was not detectable on circular or linear substrates at an ionic strength of 0.23. These findings indicate that DNA search by the endonuclease occurs by facilitated diffusion, a mechanism in which the protein locates and leaves its recognition sequence by interacting with nonspecific DNA sites. We suggest that processivity on linear substrates is limited to values half that for small circles due to partitioning of the enzyme between the two products generated by cleavage of a linear molecule. Given such topological effects, measured processivity values imply that the endonuclease can diffuse within a DNA domain to locate and recognize an EcoRI site 50 to 300 base pairs distant from an initial binding site, with minimum search efficiencies being 80 and 30% at ionic strengths of 0.059 and 0.13, respectively. The high efficiency of processive action indicates that a positionally correlated mode of search plays a major role in facilitated diffusion in this system under such conditions. Also consistent with this view was the identification of a striking position effect when two closely spaced EcoRI sites were asymmetrically positioned near the end of a linear DNA. The endonuclease displays a substantial preference for the more centrally located recognition sequence. This preference does not reflect differential sensitivity of the two sites to cleavage per se, but can be simply explained by preferential entry of the enzyme via the larger nonspecific target available to the more centrally positioned recognition sequence. These conclusions differ from those of a previous qualitative analysis of endonuclease processivity over short distances (Langowski, J., Alves, J., Pingoud, A., and Maass, G. (1983) Nucleic Acids Res. 11, 501-513).     

The negative charge of Glu-111 is required to activate the cleavage center of EcoRI endonuclease

King et al. (King, K., Benkovic, S. J., and Modrich, P. (1989) 264, 11807-11815) have shown that Glu-111 is required for DNA cleavage by EcoRI endonuclease and have suggested that this residue is required for activation of the cleavage center upon specific recognition. We have substituted Gln or Asp for Glu-111 by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. First and second strand cleavage rate constants are reduced by a factor of more than 10(4) by the Gln-111 substitution. However, these rate constants are enhanced 9-fold when pH is increased from 7.6 to 8.5, which enhances strand cleavage at EcoRI sites by wild type endonuclease to a similar degree. The specific affinity of Gln-111 endonuclease for EcoRI sites is 1000 times greater than that of wild type enzyme reflecting a decrease in the rate constant governing specific complex dissociation. In contrast to Gln-111 endonuclease, the equilibrium specific affinity of Asp-111 endonuclease for the EcoRI sequence is similar to that of wild type enzyme, and first and second strand cleavage rate constants are reduced only 100-fold relative to wild type enzyme. These results suggest that a negative charge on residue 111 is required for strand cleavage and are consistent with participation of Glu-111 in activation of the DNA cleavage center, with energy associated with specific sequence recognition driving this process.     

Cation dependence of restriction endonuclease EcoRI activity

Restriction endonuclease EcoRI cleaves the DNA sequence 5'd(-G-A-A-T-T-C-) under optimum digestion conditions. A variation in pH and ionic strength can result in EcoRI activity when 5'd(-A-A-T-T-) is cut. A divalent cation, usually Mg2+, is required for enzyme activity, though Mn2+ can also be used. Eight different cations with ionic radius/charge ratios similar to Mg2+ were tested and Co2+ and Zn2+ were also found to act as cofactors for EcoRI. A comprehensive study has been made of the effect of NaCl and pH on the EcoRI/EcoRI transition in the presence of the above four cations. Generally, a decrease in NaCl and/or an increase in pH caused a decrease in enzyme specificity. The changeover depended on the cation. They may be placed in order of their ability to increase EcoRI specificity thus: Co2+ greater than Zn2+ greater than Mg2+ greater than Mn2+. The Km of EcoRI for ColE1 DNA, in the presence of Co2+, was found to be 0.4 nM, compared to 3 nM with Mg2+, whereas the turnover was only one double-stranded scission/min with Co2+ compared to eight/min with Mg2+. The implications of all these findings on the enzyme's mechanism are discussed.     

Simultaneous DNA binding, bending, and base flipping: evidence for a novel M.EcoRI methyltransferase-DNA complex

We measured the kinetics of DNA bending by M.EcoRI using DNA labeled at both 5'-ends and observed changes in fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Although known to bend its cognate DNA site, energy transfer is decreased upon enzyme binding. This unanticipated effect is shown to be robust because we observe the identical decrease with different dye pairs, when the dye pairs are placed on the respective 3'-ends, the effect is cofactor- and protein-dependent, and the effect is observed with duplexes ranging from 14 through 17 base pairs. The same labeled DNA shows the anticipated increased energy transfer with EcoRV endonuclease, which also bends this sequence, and no change in energy transfer with EcoRI endonuclease, which leaves this sequence unbent. We interpret these results as evidence for an increased end-to-end distance resulting from M.EcoRI binding, mediated by a mechanism novel for DNA methyltransferases, combining DNA bending and an overall expansion of the DNA duplex. The M.EcoRI protein sequence is poorly accommodated into well defined classes of DNA methyltransferases, both at the level of individual motifs and overall alignment. Interestingly, M.EcoRI has an intercalation motif observed in the FPG DNA glycosylase family of repair enzymes. Enzyme-dependent changes in anisotropy and fluorescence resonance energy transfer have similar rate constants, which are similar to the previously determined rate constant for base flipping; thus, the three processes are nearly coincidental. Similar fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments following AdoMet-dependent catalysis show that the unbending transition determines the steady state product release kinetics.     

Transformation of the substrate specificity of EcoRI restrictase under the influence of glycerin]

The restriction endonuclease EcoRI hydrolyzes DNA to a greater number of fragments in the presence of glycerol than under normal conditions. This enzyme begins to work by the so-called EcoRI-type of restriction when glycerol concentration reaches 50%. The EcoRI activity appeared in experiments only when the ionic strength of the solution was decreased and pH of the solution was increased. However, under such extreme conditions the enzyme was quickly inactivated and it was difficult to obtain reproducible results especially for hydrolysis of the high-molecular DNA. The suggested conditions for the EcoRI activity permit to obtain reproducible results, this being practically equivalent to discovery of the new restriction endonuclease.     

EcoRV restrictase: physical and catalytic properties of homogenous enzyme

With the use of the strain-overproducer restriction endonuclease R.EcoRV was isolated and purified to homogeneity. The molecular mass of the enzyme was determined by gel filtration and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to be 25 000 daltons. According to the data of immunological tests R.EcoRV differs in its antigenic characteristics from restriction endonucleases R.EcoRI and R.EcoRII. Dependence of enzyme activity on pH, ionic strength, temperature, presence of divalent cations (Mn2+, Mg2+, Co2+, Zn2+, Ni2+ and Cd2+) and organic solvents (glycerol, dimethylsulfoxide, ethanol) has been studied. It was shown that under conditions of replacement of Mg2+ for Mn2+ or after addition of organic solvents relaxation of R.EcoRV specificity takes place. It was shown also that R.EcoRV is able to digest T-even bacteriophage DNAs with different types and extents of modification. DNA modified by the action of MR.EcoRV system in vivo is susceptible to R.EcoRV in vitro. Under conditions of relaxed specificity noncanonical sites are susceptible to R.EcoRV attack. The fragments resulted may be cloned in canonical pBR322 EcoRV site.