The interaction between calmodulin and microtubule proteins. IV. Quantitative analysis of the binding between calmodulin and tubulin dimer

We reported previously that calmodulin binds to tubulin in a Ca2+-dependent manner, thereby inhibiting microtubule assembly. In this work, we quantitatively investigated the binding between calmodulin and tubulin by applying two analytical methods. One was the frontal analysis using affinity chromatography originally developed by Kasai and Ishii (J. Biochem. 84, 1061-1069, 1978). The use of tubulin-Sepharose columns gave a dissociation constant of 4.0 microM. The other was the equilibrium gel filtration developed by Hummel and Dreyer (Biochim. Biophys. Acta 63, 532-534, 1962). This method using a Sephadex G-100 column provided a dissociation constant of 3.5 microM under the same medium conditions as in the frontal analysis, and it was found that 2 mol calmodulin could bind to 1 mol tubulin. Furthermore, the frontal analysis method was convenient for studies on the effect of temperature and ionic strength on the binding. Upon elevating the temperature, the dissociation constant increased. Increase in the ionic strength also increased the dissociation constant.     

Polymerization and colchicine binding. Two independent properties of tubulin

When stored frozen in 1 M sucrose and 1 mM GTP, tubulin loses polymerizing ability exponentially. Since addition of diethiothreitol does not change the decay half-life, this decrease in activity can not be attributed to disulfide bond formation. When tubulin is stored frozen in dithiothreitol and GTP only, the decay half-life increases by a factor of four, indicating that sucrose destabilizes polymerizing ability. Frozen storage in sucrose has the opposite effect on colchicine binding, which remains at 100% for 40 days. This temporal divergence indicates that colchine binding and polymerization are two independent properties of tubulin.     

Linkage between ligand binding and control of tubulin conformation.

The effect of both antimitotic drugs and nucleotide analogues on the magnesium-induced self-association of purified tubulin into 42S double rings has been examined by sedimentation velocity. In the absence of magnesium, all complexes sedimented as the 5.8S species. The binding of colchicine to tubulin led to a small but consistent (-0.1 to -0.2 kcal/mol) enhancement in the self-association of tubulin alpha-beta dimers. In the absence of nucleotide at the exchangeable site, tubulin retained a weak ability (K2 = 7.5 x 10(3) M-1) to self-associate, which was unchanged by the addition of guanosine or GMP. Analogues with altered P-O-P bonds (GMPPCP, GMPPNP) did not support ring formation at the protein concentrations examined, although GMPPCP supported microtubule assembly. When the exchangeable site was occupied by nucleotides altered on the gamma-phosphate (GTP gamma S, GTP gamma F), rings were formed; tubulin-GTP gamma F formed rings to an extent slightly greater than did tubulin-GTP, and tubulin-GTP gamma S to about the same extent as tubulin-GDP. Both of these analogues are inhibitors of microtubule assembly. These results are consistent with a model [Melki, R., Carlier, M.-F., Pantaloni, D., & Timasheff, S. N. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 9143-9152] in which an equilibrium exists between straight (microtubule-forming) and curved (ring-forming) conformations of tubulin. Furthermore, the present results indicate that the "switch" which controls the nature of the final polymeric product via free energy linkages is the occupancy of the gamma-phosphate binding locus of the exchangeable site by a properly coordinated metal-nucleotide complex.     

The interaction between subunits in the tubulin dimer.

Limited proteolysis and chemical cross-linking techniques have been used to study the interaction between alpha- and beta-tubulin subunits. Trypsin digestion of tubulin dimer resulted in the cleavage of the alpha-subunit into two fragments, whereas chymotrypsin cleaved the beta-subunit into two distinct fragments. All of these fragments have been mapped on the tubulin subunits by further proteolysis with formic acid. Cross-linking of trypsin- and chymotrypsin-cleaved subunits has been performed with two different cross-linker agents of different cross-linking distance. The addition of formaldehyde resulted in the cross-linking of the alpha-tubulin N-terminal fragment with beta-tubulin C-terminal domain. The same result was obtained when methyl 4-mercaptobutyrimidate was used.     

Direct interaction between prion protein and tubulin

Recently published data show that the prion protein in its cellular form (PrP(C)) is a component of multimolecular complexes. In this report, zero-length cross-linking with 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide (EDC) allowed us to identify tubulin as one of the molecules interacting with PrP(C) in complexes observed in porcine brain extracts. We found that porcine brain tubulin added to these extracts can be cross-linked with PrP(C). Moreover, we observed that the 34 kDa species identified previously as full-length diglycosylated prion protein co-purifies with tubulin. Cross-linking of PrP(C) species separated by Cu(2+)-loaded immobilized metal affinity chromatography confirmed that only the full-length protein but not the N-terminally truncated form (C1) binds to tubulin. By means of EDC cross-linking and cosedimentation experiments, we also demonstrated a direct interaction of recombinant human PrP (rPrP) with tubulin. The stoichiometry of cosedimentation implies that rPrP molecules are able to bind both the alpha- and beta-isoforms of tubulin composing microtubule. Furthermore, prion protein exhibits higher affinity for microtubules than for unpolymerized tubulin.     

Studies on the interaction between titin and myosin.

This study examines the interaction of titin and myosin. In order to analyze the domains of myosin contributing to the binding for titin, we conducted a solid phase binding assay. Different portions of myosin (heavy chains, light chains and myosin fragments) were coated on the microtiter wells and reacted with biotinylated titin. Then the binding of biotinylated titin to these polypeptides was detected by using the avidinbiotin-peroxidase method. The results demonstrated that light meromyosin and subfragment 1 were the major domains of myosin interacting with titin. Titin fragments obtained by trypsin digestion were allowed to react with myosin in an affinity column, and the bound fragments were isolated by an acidic elution. Immunoblot analysis of myosin-bound titin fragments revealed that an A-band domain of titin was responsible for the binding of myosin. In addition, biotinylated titin labelled the outer A-bands and Z-bands in intact myofibrils, thus confirming the in situ binding of titin to myosin.     

Fluorescence energy transfer measurement of distances between ligand binding sites of tubulin and its implication for protein-protein interaction.

9-(Dicyanovinyl) julolidine (DCVJ) is a fluorescent probe, which binds to a unique site on the tubulin dimer and exhibits different properties that are dependent upon its oligomeric state (Kung & Reed, 1989). DCVJ binds to tubulin, the tubulin-colchicine complex, and the tubulin-ruthenium red complex equally well, but binds tighter to the ANS-tubulin complex than to tubulin alone. The energy transfer studies indicate a small amount of energy transfer with colchicine, but a significant energy transfer with ANS. It was shown previously that ruthenium red binds near the C-terminal tail region of the alpha-subunit. Ruthenium red causes major quenching of fluorescence of the tubulin-DCVJ complex, suggesting proximity of binding sites. The derived distances are consistent with DCVJ binding near the alpha beta interface, but on the opposite face of the colchicine binding site. Location of the binding site correlates with the observed effect of a different polymerized state of tubulin on the DCVJ spectroscopic properties. The effect of dimer-dimer association on DCVJ binding, at high protein concentrations (Kung & Reed, 1989), suggests that such an association may occur through lateral contacts of the elongated tubulin dimer, at least in a significant fraction of the cases. Transmission of ANS-induced conformational change to the DCVJ binding site, which is near important dimer-dimer contact sites, makes it possible that such conformational changes may be responsible for polymerization inhibition by anilino-naphthalene sulfonates.     

Some optical properties of myosin and tropomyosin

The optical rotatory dispersion (ORD), and to a lesser extent the circular dichroism (CD) of the proteins tropomyosin and myosin have been extensively studied. The effect of aging and of certain reagents on these optical properties, relating to helical contents, were observed. As expected, spectra typical of right-handed, α-helices were found, with helical contents of 60–65% for myosin and 97–100% for tropomyosin. Studies were made to find which aqueous salt solutions would permit rotation observations in the far ultraviolet and also dissolve these proteins. The presence or absence of sulfhydryl groups (SH) were found to have no effect on helicity, and it is suggested that both proteins have an identical helical portion of 40%.     

Polymerization and colchicine binding: Two independent properties of tubulin

When stored frozen in 1 M sucrose and 1 mM GTP, tubulin loses polymerizing ability exponentially. Since addition of dithiothreitol does not change the decay half-life, this decrease in activity can not be attributed to disulfide bond formation. When tubulin is stored frozen in dithiothreitol and GTP only, the decay half-life increases by a factor of four, indicating that sucrose destabilizes polymerizing ability. Frozen storage in sucrose has the oppostite effect on colchicine binding, which remains at 100% for 40 days. This temporal divergence indicates that colchicine binding and polymerization are two independent properties of tubulin.     

Studies of the interaction between titin and myosin

The interaction of titin with myosin has been studied by binding assays and electron microscopy. Electron micrographs of the titin-myosin complex suggest a binding site near the tip of the tail of the myosin molecule. The distance from the myosin head-tail junction to titin indicates binding 20-30 nm from the myosin COOH terminus. Consistent with this, micrographs of titin-light meromyosin (LMM) show binding near the end of the LMM molecule. Plots of myosin- and LMM-attachment positions along the titin molecule show binding predominantly in the region located in the A band in situ, which is consistent with the proposal that titin regulates thick filament assembly. Estimates of the apparent dissociation constant of the titin-LMM complex were approximately 20 nM. Assays of LMM cyanogen bromide fragments also suggested a strong binding site near the COOH terminus. Proteolysis of a COOH-terminal 17.6-kD CNBr fragment isolated from whole myosin resulted in eight peptides of which only one, comprising 17 residues, bound strongly to titin. Two isoforms of this peptide were detected by protein sequencing. Similar binding data were obtained using synthetic versions of both isoforms. The peptide is located immediately COOH- terminal of the fourth "skip" residue in the myosin tail, which is consistent with the electron microscopy. Skip-4 may have a role in determining thick filament structure, by allowing abrupt bending of the myosin tail close to the titin-binding site.     

Some motile properties of fast characean myosin

We improved a motility assay system by using an affinity-purified antibody against the C-terminal globular domain of characean myosin. This improvement allowed us to study the sensitivity to ionic strength or the processivity of characean myosin. The sliding velocity of actin filaments on a characean myosin-coated surface was unaffected by ionic strength. This property is unlike that of skeletal or smooth muscle myosin and suggests that the binding manner of characean myosin to actin is different from that in other muscle myosins. The sliding velocity decreased when the MgADP concentration was raised. The extent of inhibition by MgADP on the motile activity of characean myosin was almost the same as in skeletal muscle or cardiac myosin. The number of sliding filaments on the characean myosin-coated surface decreased drastically with a decrease in the motor density. The motor density required to produce a successful movement of actin filament was about 200 molecules/microm(2). These results suggest that the characean myosin is not a processive motor protein.     

Stathmin family proteins display specific molecular and tubulin binding properties

Stathmin family phosphoproteins (stathmin, SCG10, SCLIP, and RB3/RB3'/RB3") are involved in signal transduction and regulation of microtubule dynamics. With the exception of stathmin, they are expressed exclusively in the nervous system, where they display different spatio-temporal and functional regulations and hence play at least partially distinct and possibly complementary roles in relation to the control of development, plasticity, and neuronal activities. At the molecular level, each possesses a specific "stathmin-like domain" and, with the exception of stathmin, various combinations of N-terminal extensions involved in their association with intracellular membrane compartments. We show here that each stathmin-like domain also displays specific biochemical and tubulin interaction properties. They are all able to sequester two alpha/beta tubulin heterodimers as revealed by their inhibitory action on tubulin polymerization and by gel filtration. However, they differ in the stabilities of the complexes formed as well as in their interaction kinetics with tubulin followed by surface plasmon resonance as follows: strong stability and slow kinetics for RB3; medium for SCG10, SCLIP, and stathmin; and weak stability and rapid kinetics for RB3'. These results suggest that the fine-tuning of their stathmin-like domains contributes to the specific functional roles of stathmin family proteins in the regulation of microtubule dynamics within the various cell types and subcellular compartments of the developing or mature nervous system.     

Nucleotide-dependent bisANS binding to tubulin.

Non-covalent hydrophobic probes such as 5, 5'-bis(8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonate) (bisANS) have become increasingly popular to gain information about protein structure and conformation. However, there are limitations as bisANS binds non-specifically at multiple sites of many proteins. Successful use of this probe depends upon the development of binding conditions where only specific dye-protein interaction will occur. In this report, we have shown that the binding of bisANS to tubulin occurs instantaneously, specifically at one high affinity site when 1 mM guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) is included in the reaction medium. Substantial portions of protein secondary structure and colchicine binding activity of tubulin are lost upon bisANS binding in absence of GTP. BisANS binding increases with time and occurs at multiple sites in the absence of GTP. Like GTP, other analogs, guanosine 5'-diphosphate, guanosine 5'-monophosphate and adenosine 5'-triphosphate, also displace bisANS from the lower affinity sites of tubulin. We believe that these multiple binding sites are generated due to the bisANS-induced structural changes on tubulin and the presence of GTP and other nucleotides protect those structural changes.     

The binding of isocolchicine to tubulin. Mechanisms of ligand association with tubulin

Isocolchicine is a structurally related isomer of colchicine altered in the methoxytropone C ring. In spite of virtual structural homology of colchicine and isocolchicine, isocolchicine is commonly believed to be inactive in binding to tubulin and inhibiting microtubule assembly. We have found that isocolchicine does indeed bind to the colchicine site on tubulin, as demonstrated by its ability to competitively inhibit [3H]colchicine binding to tubulin with a KI approximately 400 microM. Isocolchicine inhibits tubulin assembly into microtubules with an I50 of about 1 mM, but the affinity of isocolchicine for the colchicine receptor site, 5.5 +/- 0.9 x 10(3) M-1 at 23 degrees C, is much less (approximately 500-fold) than that of colchicine. Unlike colchicine, isocolchicine binds rapidly, and the absorption and fluorescence properties of the complex are only modestly altered compared to free ligand. It is proposed that the binding of isocolchicine to tubulin may be rationalized either in terms of conformational states of colchicinoids when liganded to tubulin or by the structural requirements for C-10 substituents for high affinity binding to the colchicine receptor.     

Enhanced microtubule binding and tubulin assembly properties of conformationally constrained paclitaxel derivatives

Microtubule binding and tubulin assembly promotion by a series of conformationally restricted paclitaxel (PTX) derivatives was investigated. In these derivatives, the C-4 acetate of the taxane is tethered to the C-3' phenyl at ortho and meta positions with different length linkers. The apparent affinity of these derivatives for GMPCPP-stabilized microtubules was assessed by a competition assay, and their influence on microtubule polymerization was evaluated by measuring the critical concentration of GDP-tubulin in the presence of the respective molecule. In general, taxane derivatives with higher apparent affinity for microtubules induced tubulin assembly more efficiently. Among the derivatives, molecules with the shortest tether display the strongest affinity for microtubules. These derivatives exhibited enhanced microtubule stabilization properties and efficiently induced GDP-tubulin assembly into microtubules at low temperature of 12 degrees C and in the absence of Mg2+ ions in 0.1 M PIPES. Based on molecular dynamics simulations, we propose that the enhanced ability to assemble microtubules by these taxane derivatives is linked to their ability to effectively shape the conformation of the M-loop of tubulin for cross-protofilament interaction.     

The solution structure of the N-terminal domain of human tubulin binding cofactor C reveals a platform for tubulin interaction

Human Tubulin Binding Cofactor C (TBCC) is a post-chaperonin involved in the folding and assembly of α- and β-tubulin monomers leading to the release of productive tubulin heterodimers ready to polymerize into microtubules. In this process it collaborates with other cofactors (TBC's A, B, D, and E) and forms a supercomplex with TBCD, β-tubulin, TBCE and α-tubulin. Here, we demonstrate that TBCC depletion results in multipolar spindles and mitotic failure. Accordingly, TBCC is found at the centrosome and is implicated in bipolar spindle formation. We also determine by NMR the structure of the N-terminal domain of TBCC. The TBCC N-terminal domain adopts a spectrin-like fold topology composed of a left-handed 3-stranded α-helix bundle. Remarkably, the 30-residue N-terminal segment of the TBCC N-terminal domain is flexible and disordered in solution. This unstructured region is involved in the interaction with tubulin. Our data lead us to propose a testable model for TBCC N-terminal domain/tubulin recognition in which the highly charged N-terminus as well as residues from the three helices and the loops interact with the acidic hypervariable regions of tubulin monomers.     

Polarization microfluorimetry study of interaction between myosin head and F-actin in muscle fibers.

Changes in conformation of F-actin induced by the binding of myosin molecule subfragment 1 were studied in myosin-free single ghost muscle fibers with the method of polarization microfluorimetry. The modification of the structure of subfragment 1 by proteolytic digestion with one or two cuts in subfragment 1 or degradation of 50 kDa domain did not influence the character of changes in the conformation of F-actin. The use of preparations of subfragment 1 devoid of the 20 kDa domain or both cross-linked SH1 and SH2-groups changed the character of conformational rearrangements in F-actin. The present data show that a site of interaction with actin in the 20 kDa domain plays a key role in inducing the changes in actin conformation corresponding to a "strong" form of the binding. It is supposed that transmission of changes in the conformation of the myosin head to F-actin might be important for muscle contraction.