In vitro evolution of recognition specificity mediated by SH3 domains reveals target recognition rules

We have designed a repertoire of 10(7) different SH3 domains by grafting the residues that are represented in the binding surfaces of natural SH3 domains onto the scaffold of the human Abl-SH3 domain. This phage-displayed library was screened by affinity selection for SH3 domains that bind to the synthetic peptides, APTYPPPLPP and LSSRPLPTLPSP, which are peptide ligands for the human Abl or Src SH3 domains, respectively. By characterizing the isolates, we have observed that as few as two or three amino acid substitutions lead to dramatic changes in recognition specificity. We propose that the ability to shift recognition specificity with a small number of amino acid replacements is an important evolutionary characteristic of protein binding modules. Furthermore, we have used the information obtained by these in vitro evolution experiments to generate a scoring matrix that evaluates the probability that any SH3 domain binds to the peptide ligands for the Abl and Src SH3 domains. A table of predictions for the 28 SH3 domains of baker's yeast is presented.     

The impact of either 4-R-hydroxyproline or 4-R-fluoroproline on the conformation and SH3m-cort binding of HPK1 proline-rich peptide

SH3 domains are probably the most abundant molecular-recognition modules of the proteome. A common feature of these domains is their interaction with ligand proteins containing Pro-rich sequences. Crystal and NMR structures of SH3 domains complexes with Pro-rich peptides show that the peptide ligands are bound over a range of up to seven residues in a PPII helix conformation. Short proline-rich peptides usually adopt little or no ordered secondary structure before binding interactions, and consequently their association with the SH3 domain is characterized by unfavorable binding entropy due to a loss of rotational freedom on forming the PPII helix. With the aim to stabilize the PPII helix conformation into the proline-rich decapeptide PPPLPPKPKF (P2), we replaced some proline residues either with the 4(R)-4-fluoro-l-proline (FPro) or the 4(R)-4-hydroxy-l-proline (Hyp). The interactions of P2 analogues with the SH3 domain of cortactin (SH3_m-cort) were analyzed by circular dichroism spectroscopy, while CD thermal transition experiments have been used to determine their propensity to adopt a PPII helix conformation. Results show that the introduction of three residues of Hyp efficiently stabilizes the PPII helix conformation, while it does not improve the affinity towards the SH3 domain, suggesting that additional forces, e.g., electrostatic interactions, are involved in the SH3_m-cort substrate recognition.     

Identification of Src, Fyn, Lyn, PI3K and Abl SH3 domain ligands using phage display libraries.

Many proteins involved in intracellular signal transduction contain a small, 50-60 amino acid domain, termed the Src homology 3 (SH3) domain. This domain appears to mediate critical protein-protein interactions that are involved in responses to extracellular signals. Previous studies have shown that the SH3 domains from several proteins recognize short, contiguous amino acid sequences that are rich in proline residues. While all SH3 recognition sequences identified to date share a conserved P-X-X-P motif, the sequence recognition specificity of individual SH3 domains is poorly understood. We have employed a novel modification of phage display involving biased libraries to identify peptide ligands of the Src, Fyn, Lyn, PI3K and Abl SH3 domains. With biased libraries, we probed SH3 recognition over a 12 amino acid window. The Src SH3 domain prefers the sequence XXXRPLPPLPXP, Fyn prefers XXXRPLPP(I/L)PXX, Lyn prefers RXXRPLPPLPXP, PI3K prefers RXXRPLPPLPP while the Abl SH3 domain selects phage containing the sequence PPPYPPPP(I/V)PXX. We have also analysed the binding properties of Abl and Src SH3 ligands. We find that although the phage-displayed Abl and Src SH3 ligands are proline rich, they are distinct. In surface plasmon resonance binding assays, these SH3 domains displayed highly selective binding to their cognate ligands when the sequences were displayed on the surface of the phage or as synthetic peptides. The selection of these high affinity SH3 peptide ligands provides valuable information on the recognition motifs of SH3 domains, serve as new tools to interfere with the cellular functions of SH3 domain-mediated processes and form the basis for the design of SH3-specific inhibitors of disease pathways.     

4-Fluoroproline derivative peptides: effect on PPII conformation and SH3 affinity.

Eukaryotic signal transduction involves the assembly of transient protein-protein complexes mediated by modular interaction domains. Specific Pro-rich sequences with the consensus core motif PxxP adopt the PPII helix conformation upon binding to SH3 domains. For short Pro-rich peptides, little or no ordered secondary structure is usually observed before binding interactions. The association of a Pro-rich peptide with the SH3 domain involves unfavorable binding entropy due to the loss of rotational freedom on forming the PPII helix. With the aim of stabilizing the PPII helix conformation in the Pro-rich HPK1 decapeptide PPPLPPKPKF (P2), a series of P2 analogues was prepared, in which specific Pro positions were alternatively occupied by 4(S)- or 4(R)-4-fluoro-L-proline. The interactions of these peptides with the SH3 domain of the HPK1-binding partner HS1 were quantitatively analyzed by the NILIA-CD approach. A CD thermal analysis of the P2 analogues was performed to assess their propensity to adopt the PPII helix conformation. Contrary to our expectations, the K(d) values of the analogues were lower than that of the parent peptide P2. These results clearly show that the induction of a stable PPII helix conformation in short Pro-rich peptides is not sufficient to increase their affinity toward the SH3 domain and that the effect of 4-fluoroproline strongly depends on the position of this residue in the sequence and the chirality of the substituent in the pyrrolidine ring.     

Thermodynamic dissection of the binding energetics of proline-rich peptides to the Abl-SH3 domain: implications for rational ligand design

The inhibition of the interactions between SH3 domains and their targets is emerging as a promising therapeutic strategy. To date, rational design of potent ligands for these domains has been hindered by the lack of understanding of the origins of the binding energy. We present here a complete thermodynamic analysis of the binding energetics of the p41 proline-rich decapeptide (APSYSPPPPP) to the SH3 domain of the c-Abl oncogene. Isothermal titration calorimetry experiments have revealed a thermodynamic signature for this interaction (very favourable enthalpic contributions opposed by an unfavourable binding entropy) inconsistent with the highly hydrophobic nature of the p41 ligand and the Abl-SH3 binding site. Our structural and thermodynamic analyses have led us to the conclusion, having once ruled out any possible ionization events or conformational changes coupled to the association, that the establishment of a complex hydrogen-bond network mediated by water molecules buried at the binding interface is responsible for the observed thermodynamic behaviour. The origin of the binding energetics for proline-rich ligands to the Abl-SH3 domain is further investigated by a comparative calorimetric analysis of a set of p41-related ligands. The striking effects upon the enthalpic and entropic contributions provoked by conservative substitutions at solvent-exposed positions in the ligand confirm the complexity of the interaction. The implications of these results for rational ligand design are discussed.     

Application of ring-closing metathesis to Grb2 SH3 domain-binding peptides

Molecular processes depending on protein–protein interactions can use consensus recognition sequences that possess defined secondary structures. Left-handed polyproline II (PPII) helices are a class of secondary structure commonly involved with cellular signal transduction. However, unlike -helices, for which a substantial body of work exists regarding applications of ring-closing metathesis (RCM), there are few reports on the stabilization of PPII helices by RCM methodologies. The current study examined the effects of RCM macrocyclization on left-handed PPII helices involved with the SH3 domain-mediated binding of Sos1–Grb2. Starting with the Sos1-derived peptide “Ac-V1-P2-P3-P4-V5-P6-P7-R8-R9-R10-amide,” RCM macrocyclizations were conducted using alkenyl chains of varying lengths originating from the pyrrolidine rings of the Pro4 and Pro7 residues. The resulting macrocyclic peptides showed increased helicity as indicated by circular dichroism and enhanced abilities to block Grb2–Sos1 interactions in cell lysate pull-down assays. The synthetic approach may be useful in RCM macrocyclizations, where maintenance of proline integrity at both ring junctures is desired.     

High affinity Grb2-SH3 domain ligand incorporating Cbeta-substituted prolines in a Sos-derived decapeptide

Peptide ligands that disrupt MAPK pathways are of great interest for a better understanding of these signalling cascades and represent therefore an attractive target to control cell degenerative processes. In that context, selective disruption of the upstream Grb2/Sos complex in the Ras/MAPK cascade has focused extensive work. The Sos PPII decapeptide, which interacts with the Grb2-SH3 domains, has been modified in various positions and the best inhibitors designed so far are either dimeric ligands or peptoid analogues of the VPPPVPPRRR sequence. We report the synthesis of new Grb2 ligands in which the key Val5 residue has been replaced by a cis C(beta)-substituted proline. Both fluorescence and ITC assays have been employed to measure the affinity of these substituted peptides for a recombinant Grb2 protein. Whereas proline in position 5 completely abolished the binding potency, a cis C(beta)-methyl-L-proline restored the affinity. Other cis C(beta)-proline substituents led to a complete loss of binding potency. Combining the best modifications: a cis C(beta)-methylproline 5, N-acetylation, C-carboxamide and dimerization yielded a 560-fold affinity enhancement compared to the wild-type VPPPVPPRRR sequence. This study shows that C(beta)-substituted prolines may constitute a new alternative for PPII ligands, combining entropy and enthalpy beneficial effects.     

Alternative mode of binding to phosphotyrosyl peptides by Src homology-2 domains

Src homology-2 (SH2) domains recognize specific phosphotyrosyl (pY) proteins and promote protein-protein interactions. In their classical binding mode, the SH2 domain makes specific contacts with the pY residue and the three residues immediately C-terminal to the pY, although for a few SH2 domains, residues N-terminal to pY have recently been shown to also contribute to the overall binding affinity and specificity. In this work, the ability of an SH2 domain to bind to the N-terminal side of pY has been systematically examined. A pY peptide library containing completely randomized residues at positions -5 to -1 (relative to pY, which is position 0) was synthesized on TentaGel resin and screened against the four SH2 domains of phosphatases SHP-1 and SHP-2. Positive beads that carry high-affinity ligands of the SH2 domains were identified using an enzyme-linked assay, and the peptides were sequenced by partial Edman degradation and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry. The N-terminal SH2 domain of SHP-2 binds specifically to peptides of the consensus sequence (H/F)XVX(T/S/A)pY. Further binding studies with individually synthesized pY peptides show that pY and the five residues N-terminal to pY, but not any of the C-terminal residues, are important for binding. The other three SH2 domains also bound to the library beads, albeit more weakly, and the selected peptides did not show any clear consensus. These results demonstrate that at least some SH2 domains can bind to pY peptides in an alternative mode by recognizing only the residues N-terminal to pY.     

Targeting the SH3 domain of human osteoclast‐stimulating factor with rationally designed peptoid inhibitors

Human osteoclast‐stimulating factor (hOSF) is an intracellular protein produced by osteoclasts that induces osteoclast formation and bone resorption. The protein contains a modular Src homology 3 (SH3) domain that mediates the intermolecular recognition and interaction of hOSF with its biological partners. Here, we proposed targeting the hOSF SH3 domain to disrupt hOSF–partner interactions for bone disease therapy by using SH3 inhibitors. In the procedure, the primary sequences of three known hOSF‐interacting proteins (c‐Src, SMN and Sam68) were parsed, from which totally 31 octapeptide segments that contain the core SH3‐binding motif PXXP were extracted, and their binding behavior to hOSF SH3 domain was investigated at structural level using a biomolecular modeling protocol. Several SH3‐binding candidates were identified theoretically and then determined to have high or moderate affinity for the domain using fluorescence spectroscopy assays. One potent peptide ⁴²⁵APP ARP VK⁴³² (K_d = 3.2 μM), which corresponds to the residues 425–432 of Sam68 protein, was used as template to derive N substitution of peptides (peptoids). Considering that proline is the only endogenous N‐substituted amino acid that plays a critical role in SH3–peptide binding, the substitution was addressed at the two key proline residues (Pro427 and Pro430) of the template peptide with nine N‐substituted amino acid types. By systematically evaluating the structural and energetic effects of different N‐substituted amino acids presenting at the two proline sites on peptide binding, we rationally designed five peptoid inhibitors and then determined in vitro their binding affinity to hOSF SH3 domain. Consequently, two designed peptoids APP AR( N ‐Clp) VK and APP AR( N ‐Ffa) VK with Pro430 replaced by N‐Clp and N‐Ffa were confirmed to have increased (K_d = 0.87 μM) and comparable (K_d = 2.9 μM) affinities relative to the template, respectively. In addition, we also found that the Pro427 residue plays an essential role in restricting peptide/peptoid conformations to polyproline II (PPII) helix as the basic requirement of SH3 binding so that the residue cannot be modified. Copyright © 2016 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Analysis of the thermodynamics of binding of an SH3 domain to proline-rich peptides using a chimeric fusion protein

A complete understanding of the thermodynamic determinants of binding between SH3 domains and proline-rich peptides is crucial to the development of rational strategies for designing ligands for these important domains. Recently we engineered a single-chain chimeric protein by fusing the α-spectrin Src homology region 3 (SH3) domain to the decapeptide APSYSPPPPP (p41). This chimera mimics the structural and energetic features of the interaction between SH3 domains and proline-rich peptides. Here we show that analysing the unfolding thermodynamics of single-point mutants of this chimeric fusion protein constitutes a very useful approach to deciphering the thermodynamics of SH3-ligand interactions. To this end, we investigated the contribution of each proline residue of the ligand sequence to the SH3-peptide interaction by producing six single Pro-Ala mutants of the chimeric protein and analysing their unfolding thermodynamics by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). Structural analyses of the mutant chimeras by circular dichroism, fluorescence and NMR together with NMR-relaxation measurements indicate conformational flexibility at the binding interface, which is strongly affected by the different Pro-Ala mutations. An analysis of the DSC thermograms on the basis of a three-state unfolding model has allowed us to distinguish and separate the thermodynamic magnitudes of the interaction at the binding interface. The model assumes equilibrium between the “unbound” and “bound” states at the SH3-peptide binding interface. The resulting thermodynamic magnitudes classify the different proline residues according to their importance in the interaction as P2∼P7∼P10 > P9∼P6 > P8, which agrees well with Lim's model for the interaction between SH3 domains and proline-rich peptides. In addition, the thermodynamic signature of the interaction is the same as that usually found for this type of binding, with a strong enthalpy-entropy compensation for all the mutants. This compensation appears to derive from an increase in conformational flexibility concomitant to the weakening of the interactions at the binding interface. We conclude that our approach, based on DSC and site-directed mutagenesis analysis of chimeric fusion proteins, may serve as a suitable tool to analyse the energetics of weak biomolecular interactions such as those involving SH3 domains.     

Molecular dynamics study of amyloid formation of two Abl-SH3 domain peptides.

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were carried out for two-strand and ten-strand beta-sheets constructed from two peptides corresponding to the diverging turn of two homologous Abl-SH3 domains, DLSFMKGE (MK; from Drosophila) and DLSFKKGE (KK; from man), in explicit water at the temperatures of 30, 170/190 and 300 K. It was found that the 2 x MK beta-sheet is more stable than the 2 x KK beta-sheet, and that the 10 x MK beta-sheet is more stable than the 10 x KK beta-sheet; this suggests that the MK systems are fibril-creating and the KK systems are not. These results might explain why most SH3 domains possess two conserved basic residues at the diverging turn, which may act as gatekeepers in order to avoid aggregation.     

The importance of being proline: the interaction of proline-rich motifs in signaling proteins with their cognate domains.

Acommon focus among molecular and cellular biologists is the identification of proteins that interact with each other. Yeast two-hybrid, cDNA expression library screening, and coimmunoprecipitation experiments are powerful methods for identifying novel proteins that bind to one's favorite protein for the purpose of learning more regarding its cellular function. These same techniques, coupled with truncation and mutagenesis experiments, have been used to define the region of interaction between pairs of proteins. One conclusion from this work is that many interactions occur over short regions, often less than 10 amino acids in length within one protein. For example, mapping studies and 3-dimensional analyses of antigen-antibody interactions have revealed that epitopes are typically 4-7 residues long (1). Other examples include protein-interaction modules, such as Src homology (SH) 2 and 3 domains, phosphotyrosine binding domains (PTB), postsynaptic density/disc-large/ZO1 (PDZ) domains, WW domains, Eps15 homology (EH) domains, and 14-3-3 proteins that typically recognize linear regions of 3-9 amino acids. Each of these domains has been the subject of recent reviews published elsewhere (2 3 4 5 6 7). Among the primary structures of many ligands for protein-protein interactions, the amino acid proline is critical. In particular, SH3, WW, and several new protein-interaction domains prefer ligand sequences that are proline-rich. In addition, even though ligands for EH domains and 14-3-3 domains are not proline-rich, they do include a single proline residue. This review highlights the analysis of those protein-protein interactions that involve proline residues, the biochemistry of proline, and current drug discovery efforts based on proline peptidomimetics.-Kay, B. K., Williamson, M. P., Sudol, M. The importance of being proline: the interaction of proline-rich motifs in signaling proteins with their cognate domains.     

Promiscuous binding nature of SH3 domains to their target proteins

SH3 domains are small but important domains in cell-signaling and function through protein-protein interactions. Their promiscuous nature in binding to polyproline peptides makes them much more important because many SH3 domains from different proteins bind to different proteins having polyproline template on their surface. Very subtle changes in the sequence of SH3 domains and the binding peptides determine the specificity of the peptide binding. Recent observation that SH3 domains bind to non- proline peptides makes the scenario of peptide binding involving SH3 domains complicated. If domain swapped dimerization as observed in Eps8-SH3 domain also binds different peptides, it proves the versatility of the SH3 domains in binding to peptides in various ways. An overview of the promiscuity of SH3 domains has been discussed.     

The high-resolution NMR structure of the R21A Spc-SH3:P41 complex: Understanding the determinants of binding affinity by comparison with Abl-SH3

Background  

SH3 domains are small protein modules of 60–85 amino acids that bind to short proline-rich sequences with moderate-to-low affinity and specificity. Interactions with SH3 domains play a crucial role in regulation of many cellular processes (some are related to cancer and AIDS) and have thus been interesting targets in drug design. The decapeptide APSYSPPPPP (p41) binds with relatively high affinity to the SH3 domain of the Abl tyrosine kinase (Abl-SH3), while it has a 100 times lower affinity for the α-spectrin SH3 domain (Spc-SH3).     

Novel Src homology 3 domain-binding motifs identified from proteomic screen of a Pro-rich region

The Src homology (SH) 3 domain has been shown recently to bind peptide sequences that lack the canonical PXXP motif. The diverse specificity in ligand recognition for a group of 15 SH3 domains has now been investigated using arrays of peptides derived from the proline-rich region of the SH2 domain-containing leukocyte protein of 76 kDa (SLP-76). A screen of the peptide arrays using individual or mixed SH3 domains has allowed the identification of a number of candidate SH3-binding peptides. Although some peptides contain the conventional PXXP motif, most are devoid of such a motif and are instead enriched in basic residues. Fluorescent polarization measurements using soluble peptides and purified SH3 domains demonstrated that several SH3 domains, including those from growth factor receptor-bound protein 2 (Grb2), NCK, and phospholipase C (PLC)-gamma1, bound with moderate affinities (10-100 microm) to a group of non-conventional peptides. Of particular interest, the PLC-gamma1 SH3 domain was found to associate with SLP-76 through at least three distinct sites, two of which bore a novel KKPP motif and the other contained the classic PXXP sequence. Intriguingly mutation of critical residues for the three sites not only affected binding of SLP-76 to the PLC-gamma1 SH3 domain but also to the Grb2 C-terminal SH3 domain, indicating that the binding sites in SLP-76 for the two SH3 domains are overlapped. Our studies suggest that the SH3 domain is an inherently promiscuous interaction module capable of binding to peptides that may or may not contain a PXXP motif. Furthermore the identification of numerous non-conventional SH3-binding peptides in SLP-76 implies that the global ligand pool for SH3 domains in a mammalian proteome may be significantly greater than previously acknowledged.     

A propensity scale for type II polyproline helices (PPII): aromatic amino acids in proline-rich sequences strongly disfavor PPII due to proline-aromatic interactions

Type II polyproline helices (PPII) are a fundamental secondary structure of proteins, common in globular and nonglobular regions and important in cellular signaling. We developed a propensity scale for PPII using a host-guest system with sequence Ac-GPPXPPGY-NH(2), where X represents any amino acid. We found that proline has the highest PPII propensity, but most other amino acids display significant PPII propensities. The PPII propensity of leucine was the highest of all propensities of non-proline residues. Alanine and residues with linear side chains displayed the next highest PPII propensities. Three classes of residues displayed lower PPII propensities: β-branched amino acids (Thr, Val, and Ile), short amino acids with polar side chains (Asn, protonated Asp, Ser, Thr, and Cys), and aromatic amino acids (Phe, Tyr, and Trp). tert-Leucine particularly disfavored PPII. The basis of the low PPII propensities of aromatic amino acids in this context was significant cis-trans isomerism, with proline-rich peptides containing aromatic residues exhibiting 45-60% cis amide bonds, due to Pro-cis-Pro-aromatic and aromatic-cis-Pro amide bonds.     

Reexamination of the recognition preference of the specificity pocket of the Abl SH3 domain

Src homology-3 (SH3) domains mediate important protein-protein interactions in a variety of normal and pathological cellular processes, thus providing an attractive target for the selective interference of SH3-dependent signaling events that govern these processes. Most SH3 domains recognize proline-rich peptides with low affinity and poor selectivity, and the goal to design potent and specific ligands for various SH3 domains remains elusive. Better understanding of the molecular basis for SH3 domain recognition is needed in order to design such ligands with potency and specificity. In this report, we seek to define a clear recognition preference of the specificity pocket of the Abl SH3 domain using targeted synthetic peptide libraries. High-resolution affinity panning coupled with mass spectrometric readout allows for quick identification of Trp as the preferred fourth residue in the decapeptide ligand APTWSPPPPP, which binds to Abl SH3 four times stronger than does the decapeptide containing Tyr or Phe in the fourth position. This finding is in contrast to several reports that Tyr is the only residue selected from phage displayed peptide libraries that interacts with the specificity pocket of Abl SH3. This simple, unbiased approach can fine-tune the affinity and selectivity of both natural and unnatural SH3 ligands whose consensus binding sequence has been pre-defined by combinatorial library methods.