Canopy N and P dynamics of a southeastern US pine forest under elevated CO2

Forest production is strongly nutrient limited throughout the southeastern US. If nutrient limitations constrain plant acquisition of essential resources under elevated CO₂, reductions in the mass or nutrient content of forest canopies could constrain C assimilation from the atmosphere. We tested this idea by quantifying canopy biomass, foliar concentrations of N and P, and the total quantity of N and P in a loblolly pine (Pinus taeda) canopy subject to 4 years of free-air CO₂ enrichment. We also used N:P ratios to detect N versus P limitation to primary production under elevated CO₂. Canopy biomass was significantly higher under elevated CO₂ during the first 4 years of this experiment. Elevated CO₂ significantly reduced the concentration of N in loblolly pine foliage (5% relative to ambient CO₂) but not P. Despite the slight reduction foliage N concentrations, there were significant increases in canopy N and P contents under elevated CO₂. Foliar N:P ratios were not altered by elevated CO₂ and were within a range suggesting forest production is N limited not P limited. Despite the clear limitation of NPP by N under ambient and elevated CO₂ at this site, there is no evidence that the mass of N or P in the canopy is declining through the first 4 years of CO₂ fumigation. As a consequence, whole-canopy C assimilation is strongly stimulated by elevated CO₂ making this forest a larger net C sink under elevated CO₂ than under ambient CO₂. We discuss the potential for future decreases in canopy nutrient content as a result of limited changes in the size of the plant-available pools of N under elevated CO₂.     

Ponderosa Pine Responses to Elevated CO2and Nitrogen Fertilization

The effects of elevated CO₂ (ambient, +175, and +350 μl l⁻¹) and nitrogen fertilization (0, 100, and 200 kg N ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹ as ammonium sulfate) on C and N accumulations in biomass and soils planted with ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa Laws) over a 6-year study period are reported. Both nitrogen fertilization and elevated CO₂ caused increases in C and N contents of vegetation over the study period. The pattern of responses varied over time. Responses to CO₂ decreased in the +175 μl l⁻¹ and increased in the +350 μl l⁻¹ after the first year, whereas responses to N decreased after the first year and became non-significant by year six. Foliar N concentrations were lower and tree C:N ratios were higher with elevated CO₂ in the early years, but this was offset by the increases in biomass, resulting in substantial increases in N uptake with elevated CO₂. Nitrogen budget estimates showed that the major source of the N for unfertilized trees, with or without elevated CO₂, was likely the soil organic N pool. There were no effects of elevated CO₂ on soil C, but a significant decrease in soil N and an increase in soil C:N ratio in year six. Nitrogen fertilization had no significant effect on tree C:N ratios, foliar N concentrations, soil C content, soil N content, or soil C:N ratios. There were no significant interactions between CO₂ and N treatments, indicating that N fertilization had no effect on responses to CO₂ and that CO₂ treatments had no effect on responses to N fertilization. These results illustrate the importance of long-term studies involving more than one level of treatment to assess the effects of elevated CO₂.     

Effects of elevated CO2 and nitrogen on growth ofPoa pratensis (L.)

The growth responses of a grass,Poa pratensis, to elevated CO₂ and nitrogen were investigated. Light-saturated photosynthetic rate per unit leaf area increased with exposure to elevated CO₂, while dry weight did not respond to increased CO₂. Patterns of biomass allocation within plants, including leaf area, leaf area ratio, specific leaf area, and root to shoot ratios, were not altered by elevated CO₂, but changed considerably with N treatment Shoot and whole-plant tissue N concentrations were significantly diluted by elevated CO₂ (Tukey test, P < 0.05). Total N content did not differ significantly among CO₂ treatments. The absence of a concomitant increase in N uptake under elevated CO₂ may have caused a dilution in plant tissue [N], probably negating the positive effects of increased photosynthesis on biomass accumulation.     

Loblolly pine grown under elevated CO2 affects early instar pine sawfly performance

Seedlings of loblolly pine Pinus taeda (L.), were grown in open-topped field chambers under three CO₂ regimes: ambient, 150 l l^–1 CO₂ above ambient, and 300 l l^–1 CO₂ above ambient. A fourth, non-chambered ambient treatment was included to assess chamber effects. Needles were used in 96 h feeding trials to determine the performance of young, second instar larvae of loblolly pine's principal leaf herbivore, red-headed pine sawfly, Neodiprion lecontei (Fitch). The relative consumption rate of larvae significantly increased on plants grown under elevated CO₂, and needles grown in the highest CO₂ regime were consumed 21% more rapidly than needles grown in ambient CO₂. Both the significant decline in leaf nitrogen content and the substantial increase in leaf starch content contributed to a significant increase in the starch:nitrogen ratio in plants grown in elevated CO₂. Insect consumption rate was negatively related to leaf nitrogen content and positively related to the starch:nitrogen ratio. Of the four volatile leaf monoterpenes measured, only -pinene exhibited a significant CO₂ effect and declined in plants grown in elevated CO₂. Although consumption changed, the relative growth rates of larvae were not different among CO₂ treatments. Despite lower nitrogen consumption rates by larvae feeding on the plants grown in elevated CO₂, nitrogen accumulation rates were the same for all treatments due to a significant increase in nitrogen utilization efficiency. The ability of this insect to respond at an early, potentially susceptible larval stage to poorer food quality and declining levels of a leaf monoterpene suggest that changes in needle quality within pines in future elevated-CO₂ atmospheres may not especially affect young insects and that tree-feeding sawflies may respond in a manner similar to herb-feeding lepidopterans.     

Individual vs. population plastic responses to elevated CO2, nutrient availability, and heterogeneity: a microcosm experiment with co-occurring species

We conducted an experiment to evaluate the plastic phenotypic responses of individuals, growing under intra-specific competition, and populations of three co-occurring grassland species (Lolium perenne, Plantago lanceolata, and Holcus lanatus) to joint variations in atmospheric CO₂ partial pressure (P _CO2; 37.5 vs. 70 Pa), nutrient availability (NA; 40 vs. 120 mg N added as organic material), and the spatial pattern of nutrient supply (SH; homogeneous vs. heterogeneous nutrient supply). At both the population and individual levels, the aboveground biomass of the three species significantly increased when the nutrients were heterogeneously supplied. Significant two- (SH × NA) and three-term (P _CO2 × NA × SH) interactions determined the response of traits measured on populations (aboveground biomass and below: aboveground biomass ratio, BAR) and individuals (aboveground biomass and specific leaf area). The combination of a high SH and NA elicited the highest plasticity of aboveground biomass in populations and individuals of the three species evaluated, and of BAR in Holcus. Soil heterogeneity and elevated P _CO2 elicited the highest plasticity in the SLA of Plantago and Lolium individuals. Our results show that populations, and not only individuals, respond to soil heterogeneity in a plastic way, and that plastic responses to elevated P _CO2 are complex since they vary across traits and species, and are influenced by the availability of nutrients and by their spatial distribution. They also emphasize the importance of soil heterogeneity as a modulator of plant responses to global change drivers. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Responsible Editor: Angela Hodge     

Decomposition of tree leaf litters grown under elevated CO2: Effect of litter quality

Ash (Fraxinus excelsior L.), birch (Betula pubescens Ehrh.), sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus L.) and Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis (Bong.) Carr.) leaf litters were monitored for decomposition rates and nutrient release in a laboratory microcosm experiment. Litters were derived from solar domes where plants had been exposed to two different CO₂ regimes: ambient (350 L L^-1 CO₂) and enriched (600 L L^-1 CO₂).Elevated CO₂ significantly affected some of the major litter quality parameters, with lower N, higher lignin concentrations and higher ratios of C/N and lignin/N for litters derived from enriched CO₂. Respiration rates of the deciduous species were significantly decreased for litters grown under elevated CO₂, and reductions in mass loss at the end of the experiment were generally observed in litters derived from the 600 ppm CO₂ treatment. Nutrient mineralization, dissolved organic carbon, and pH in microcosm leachates did not differ significantly between the two CO₂ treatments for any of the species studied. Litter quality parameters were examined for correlations with cumulative respiration and decomposition rates: N concentration, C/N and lignin/N ratios showed the highest correlations, with differences between litter types. The results indicate that higher C storage will occur in soil as a consequence of litter quality changes resulting from higher atmospheric concentrations of CO₂.Abbreviations CHO soluble carbohydrates - DOC dissolved organic carbon - HCel holocellulose - WTREM weight remaining     

Daily and seasonal CO2 exchange in Scots pine grown under elevated O3 and CO2: experiment and simulation

Starting in early spring of 1994, naturally regenerated, 30-year-old Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) trees were grown in open-top chambers and exposed in situ to doubled ambient O₃,doubled ambient CO₂ and a combination of O₃ and CO₂ from 15 April to 15 September. To investigate daily and seasonal responses of CO₂ exchange to elevated O₃ and CO₂, the CO₂ exchange of shoots was measured continuously by an automatic system for measuring gas exchange during the course of one year (from 1 Januray to 31 December 1996). A process-based model of shoot photosynthesis was constructed to quantify modifications in the intrinsic capacity of photosynthesis and stomatal conductance by simulating the daily CO₂ exchange data from the field. Results showed that on most days of the year the model simulated well the daily course of shoot photosynthesis. Elevated O₃ significantly decreased photosynthetic capacity and stomatal conductance during the whole photosynthetic period. Elevated O₃ also led to a delay in onset of photosynthetic recovery in early spring and an increase in the sensitivity of photosynthesis to environmental stress conditions. The combination of elevated O₃ and CO₂ had an effect on photosynthesis and stomatal conductance similar to that of elevated O₃ alone, but significantly reduced the O₃-induced depression of photosynthesis. Elevated CO₂ significantly increased the photosynthetic capacity of Scots pine during the main growing season but slightly decreased it in early spring and late autumn. The model calculation showed that, compared to the control treatment, elevated O₃ alone and the combination of elevated O₃ and CO₂ decreased the annual total of net photosynthesis per unit leaf area by 55% and 38%, respectively. Elevated CO₂ increased the annual total of net photosynthesis by 13%.     

Defense characteristics of seral deciduous broad-leaved tree seedlings grown under differing levels of CO2 and nitrogen

Mixed broad-leaved forests are abundantly populated by several kinds of herbivore species in northern Japan. The life of herbivores depends strongly on the quality of food leaves. Leaf quality is changing with increasing atmospheric CO₂ and nitrogen deposition. Four seral species of deciduous broad-leaved tree seedlings (alder, birch, oak and maple) were raised in all four combinations of two levels of CO₂ and two levels of nutrient, to examine foliar defense traits. To evaluate the relative defense capacity of the four tree species, we used wild silkworms (Erisan; a generalist herbivore) as a bioassay material. Except with alder, the survival rate and longevity (ML₅₀) of the silkworms were least when they were fed with leaves of seedlings raised under high CO₂ and infertile soil conditions, and longest on a diet of leaves grown in ambient CO₂ and fertile soil, especially in birch and maple. The longevity of Erisan decreased in the order birch, oak, and maple. The longevity of Erisan fed with alder leaves was independent of CO₂ levels and was longer on alder seedlings grown in infertile soil conditions. Alder is an actinorhizal plant that can fix atmospheric nitrogen in root nodules formed by the actinomycetes Frankia sp. The activity of symbiotic microbes would have been enhanced by the greater amount of photosynthates received from the host plants at high CO₂, improving the food quality for the silkworms. It was concluded that in all but alder, leaf chemical traits, especially C/N ratio, affect the ML₅₀ of Erisan larvae.     

Effect of elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration on soil and root respiration in winter wheat by using a respiration partitioning chamber

Soil respiration in a cropland is the sum of heterotrophic (mainly microorganisms) and autotrophic (root) respiration. The contribution of both these types to soil respiration needs to be understood to evaluate the effects of environmental change on soil carbon cycling and sequestration. In this paper, the effects of free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) on hetero- and autotrophic respiration in a wheat field were differentiated and evaluated by a novel split-root growth and gas collection system. Elevated atmospheric pCO₂ of approximately 200 μmol mol⁻¹ above the ambient pCO₂ significantly increased soil respiration by 15.1 and 14.8% at high nitrogen (HN) and low nitrogen (LN) application rates, respectively. The effect of elevated atmospheric pCO₂ on root respiration was not consistent across the wheat growth stages. Elevated pCO₂ significantly increased and decreased root respiration at the booting-heading stage (middle stage) and the late-filling stage (late stage), respectively, in HN and LN treatments; however, no significant effect was found at the jointing stage (early stage). Thus, the effect of increased pCO₂ on cumulative root respiration for the entire wheat growing season was not significant. Cumulative root respiration accounted for approximately 25–30% of cumulative soil respiration in the entire wheat growing season. Consequently, cumulative microbial respiration (soil respiration minus root respiration) increased by 22.5 and 21.1% due to elevated pCO₂ in HN and LN, respectively. High nitrogen application significantly increased root respiration at the late stage under both elevated pCO₂ and ambient pCO₂; however, no significant effects were found on cumulative soil respiration, root respiration, and microbial respiration. These findings suggest that heterotrophic respiration, which is influenced by increased substrate supplies from the plant to the soil, is the key process to determine C emission from agro-ecosystems with regard to future scenarios of enriched pCO₂.     

Competition for nitrogen between Pinus sylvestris and ectomycorrhizal fungi generates potential for negative feedback under elevated CO2

We investigated fungal species-specific responses of ectomycorrhizal (ECM) Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris) seedlings on growth and nutrient acquisition together with mycelial development under ambient and elevated CO₂. Each seedling was associated with one of the following ECM species: Hebeloma cylindrosporum, Laccaria bicolor, Suillus bovinus, S. luteus, Piloderma croceum, Paxillus involutus, Boletus badius, or non-mycorrhizal, under ambient, and elevated CO₂ (350 or 700 μl l⁻¹ CO₂); each treatment contained six replicates. The trial lasted 156 days. During the final 28 days, the seedlings were labeled with ¹⁴CO₂. We measured hyphal length, plant biomass, ¹⁴C allocation, and plant nitrogen and phosphorus concentration. Almost all parameters were significantly affected by fungal species and/or CO₂. There were very few significant interactions. Elevated CO₂ decreased shoot-to-root ratio, most strongly so in species with the largest extraradical mycelium. Under elevated CO₂, ECM root growth increased significantly more than hyphal growth. Extraradical hyphal length was significantly negatively correlated with shoot biomass, shoot N content, and total plant N uptake. Root dry weight was significantly negatively correlated with root N and P concentration. Fungal sink strength for N strongly affected plant growth through N immobilization. Mycorrhizal fungal-induced progressive nitrogen limitation (PNL) has the potential to generate negative feedback with plant growth under elevated CO₂. Responsible Editor: Herbert Johannes Kronzucker     

Growth and senescence in plant communities exposed to elevated CO2 concentrations on an estuarine marsh

Summary Three high marsh communities on the Chesapeake Bay were exposed to a doubling in ambient CO₂ concentration for one growing season. Open-top chambers were used to raise CO₂ concentrations ca. 340 ppm above ambient over monospecific communities of Scirpus olneyi (C₃) and Spartina patens (C₄), and a mixed community of S. olneyi, S. patens, and Distichlis spicata (C₄). Plant growth and senescence were monitored by serial, nondestructive censuses. Elevated CO₂ resulted in increased shoot densities and delayed sensecence in the C₃ species. This resulted in an increase in primary productivity in S. olneyi growing in both the pure and mixed communities. There was no effect of CO₂ on growth in the C₄ species. These results demonstrate that elevated atmospheric CO₂ can cause increased aboveground production in a mature, unmanaged ecosystem.     

Responses in stomatal conductance to elevated CO2 in 12 grassland species that differ in growth form

Responses in stomatal conductance (g _st ) and leaf xylem pressure potential ( _leaf ) to elevated CO₂ (2x ambient) were compared among 12 tallgrass prairie species that differed in growth form and growth rate. Open-top chambers (OTCs, 4.5 m diameter, 4.0 m in height) were used to expose plants to ambient and elevated CO₂ concentrations from April through November in undisturbed tallgrass prairie in NE Kansas (USA). In June and August, _leaf was usually higher in all species at elevated CO₂ and was lowest in adjacent field plots (without OTCs). During June, when water availability was high, elevated CO₂ resulted in decreased g _st in 10 of the 12 species measured. Greatest decreases in g _st (ca. 50%) occurred in growth forms with the highest potential growth rates (C₃ and C₄ grasses, and C₃ ruderals). In contrast, no significant decrease in g _st was measured in the two C₃ shrubs. During a dry period in September, reductions in g _st at elevated CO₂ were measured in only two species (a C₃ ruderal and a C₄ grass) whereas increased g _st at elevated CO₂ was measured in the shrubs and a C₃ forb. These increases in g _st were attributed to enhanced _leaf in the elevated CO₂ plants resulting from increased soil water availability and/or greater root biomass. During a wet period in September, only reductions in g _st were measured in response to elevated CO₂. Thus, there was significant interspecific variability in stomatal responses to CO₂ that may be related to growth form or growth rate and plant water relations. The effect of growth in the OTCs, relative to field plants, was usually positive for g _st and was greatest (>30%) when water availability was low, but only 6–12% when _leaf was high.The results of this study confirm the importance of considering interactions between indirect effects of high CO₂ of plant water relations and direct effects of elevated CO₂ on g _st , particularly in ecosystems such as grasslands where water availability often limits productivity. A product of this interaction is that the potential exists for either positive or negative responses in g _st to be measured at elevated levels of CO₂.     

Effects of CO2 and nutrient enrichment on tissue quality of two California annuals

The effects of CO₂ enrichment and soil nutrient status on tissue quality were investigated and related to the potential effect on growth and decomposition. Two California annuals, Avena fatua and Plantago erecta, were grown at ambient and ambient plus 35 Pa atmospheric CO₂ in nutrient unamended and amended serpentine soil. Elevated CO₂ led to significantly increased Avena shoot nitrogen concentrations in the nutrient amended treatment. It also led to decreased lignin concentrations in Avena roots in both nutrient treatments, and in Plantago shoots and roots with nutrient addition. Concentrations of total nonstructural carbohydrate (TNC) and carbon did not change with elevated CO₂ in either species. As a consequence of increased biomass accumulation, increased CO₂ led to larger total pools of TNC, lignin, total carbon, and total nitrogen in Avena with nutrient additions. Doubling CO₂ had no significant effect on Plantago. Given the limited changes in the compounds related to decomposibility and plant growth, effects of increased atmospheric CO₂ mediated through tissue composition on Avena and Plantago are likely to be minor and depend on site fertility. This study suggests that other factors such as litter moisture, whether or not litter is on the ground, and biomass allocation among roots and shoots, are likely to be more important in this California grassland ecosystem. CO₂ could influence those directly as well as indirectly.     

Open top chambers for exposing plant canopies to elevated CO2 concentration and for measuring net gas exchange

Open top chamber design and function are reviewed. All of the chambers described maintain CO₂ concentrations measured at a central location within ±30 ppm of a desired target when averaged over the growing season, but the spatial and temporal range within any chamber may be closer to 100 ppm. Compared with unchambered companion plots, open top chambers modify the microenvironment in the following ways: temperatures are increased up to 3°C depending on the chamber design and location of the measurement; light intensity is typically diminished by as much as 20%; wind velocity is lower and constant; and relative humidity is higher. The chamber environment may significantly alter plant growth when compared with unchambered controls, but the chamber effect on growth has not been clearly attributed to a single or even a few environmental factors.A method for modifying an open top chamber for tracking gas exchange between natural vegetation and the ambient air is described. This modification consists of the addition of a top with exit chimney to reduce dilution of chamber CO₂ by external ambient air, is quickly made and permits estimation of the effects of elevated CO₂ and water vapor exchange.The relatively simple design and construction of open top chambers make them the most likely method to be used in the near future for long-term elevated CO₂ exposure of small trees, crops and grassland ecosystems. Improvements in the basic geometry to improve control of temperature, reduce the variation of CO₂ concentrations, and increase the turbulence and wind speed in the canopy boundary layer are desirable objectives. Similarly, modifications for measuring water vapor and carbon dioxide gas exchange will extend the usefulness of open top chambers to include non-destructive monitoring of the responses of ecosystems to rising atmospheric CO₂.     

The impact of long-term elevated CO2 on C and N retention in stable SOM pools

Elevated atmospheric CO₂ frequently increases plant production and concomitant soil C inputs, which may cause additional soil C sequestration. However, whether the increase in plant production and additional soil C sequestration under elevated CO₂ can be sustained in the long-term is unclear. One approach to study C–N interactions under elevated CO₂ is provided by a theoretical framework that centers on the concept of progressive nitrogen limitation (PNL). The PNL concept hinges on the idea that N becomes less available with time under elevated CO₂. One possible mechanism underlying this reduction in N availability is that N is retained in long-lived soil organic matter (SOM), thereby limiting plant production and the potential for soil C sequestration. The long-term nature of the PNL concept necessitates the testing of mechanisms in field experiments exposed to elevated CO₂ over long periods of time. The impact of elevated CO₂ and ¹⁵N fertilization on L. perenne and T. repens monocultures has been studied in the Swiss FACE experiment for ten consecutive years. We applied a biological fractionation technique using long-term incubations with repetitive leaching to determine how elevated CO₂ affects the accumulation of N and C into more stable SOM pools. Elevated CO₂ significantly stimulated retention of fertilizer-N in the stable pools of the soils covered with L. perenne receiving low and high N fertilization rates by 18 and 22%, respectively, and by 45% in the soils covered by T. repens receiving the low N fertilization rate. However, elevated CO₂ did not significantly increase stable soil C formation. The increase in N retention under elevated CO₂ provides direct evidence that elevated CO₂ increases stable N formation as proposed by the PNL concept. In the Swiss FACE experiment, however, plant production increased under elevated CO₂, indicating that the additional N supply through fertilization prohibited PNL for plant production at this site. Therefore, it remains unresolved why elevated CO₂ did not increase labile and stable C accumulation in these systems.     

Combined effects of elevated CO2 and soil drought on carbon and nitrogen allocation of the desert shrub Caragana intermedia

Impacts of either elevated CO₂ or drought stress on plant growth have been studied extensively, but interactive effects of these on plant carbon and nitrogen allocation is inadequately understood yet. In this study the response of the dominant desert shrub, Caragana intermedia Kuanget H.c.Fu, to the interaction of elevated CO₂ (700 ± 20 μmol mol⁻¹) and soil drought were determined in two large environmental growth chambers (18 m²). Elevated CO₂ increased the allocation of biomass and carbon into roots and the ratio of carbon to nitrogen (C:N) as well as the leaf soluble sugar content, but decreased the allocation of biomass and carbon into leaves, leaf nitrogen and leaf soluble protein concentrations. Elevated CO₂ significantly decreased the partitioning of nitrogen into leaves, but increased that into roots, especially under soil drought. Elevated CO₂ significantly decreased the carbon isotope discrimination (Δ) in leaves, but increased them in roots, and the ratio of Δ values between root and leaf, indicating an increased allocation into below-ground parts. It is concluded that stimulation of plant growth by CO₂ enrichment may be negated under soil drought, and under the future environment, elevated CO₂ may partially offset the negative effects of enhanced drought by regulating the partitioning of carbon and nitrogen.     

Leaf and canopy responses to elevated CO2 in a pine forest under free-air CO2 enrichment

Physiological responses to elevated CO₂ at the leaf and canopy-level were studied in an intact pine (Pinus taeda) forest ecosystem exposed to elevated CO₂ using a free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) technique. Normalized canopy water-use of trees exposed to elevated CO₂ over an 8-day exposure period was similar to that of trees exposed to current ambient CO₂ under sunny conditions. During a portion of the exposure period when sky conditions were cloudy, CO₂-exposed trees showed minor (7%) but significant reductions in relative sap flux density compared to trees under ambient CO₂ conditions. Short-term (minutes) direct stomatal responses to elevated CO₂ were also relatively weak (5% reduction in stomatal aperture in response to high CO₂ concentrations). We observed no evidence of adjustment in stomatal conductance in foliage grown under elevated CO₂ for nearly 80 days compared to foliage grown under current ambient CO₂, so intrinsic leaf water-use efficiency at elevated CO₂ was enhanced primarily by direct responses of photosynthesis to CO₂. We did not detect statistical differences in parameters from photosynthetic responses to intercellular CO₂ (A _net-C _i curves) for Pinus taeda foliage grown under elevated CO₂ (550 mol mol^–1) for 50–80 days compared to those for foliage grown under current ambient CO₂ from similar-sized reference trees nearby. In both cases, leaf net photosynthetic rate at 550 mol mol^–1 CO₂ was enhanced by approximately 65% compared to the rate at ambient CO₂ (350 mol mol^–1). A similar level of enhancement under elevated CO₂ was observed for daily photosynthesis under field conditions on a sunny day. While enhancement of photosynthesis by elevated CO₂ during the study period appears to be primarily attributable to direct photosynthetic responses to CO₂ in the pine forest, longer-term CO₂ responses and feedbacks remain to be evaluated.     

Effects of elevated CO2 and nitrogen on nutrient uptake in ponderosa pine seedlings

This paper reports on the results of a controlled-environment study on the effects of CO₂ (370, 525, and 700 mol mol^-1) and N [0, 200, and 400 g N g soil^-1 as (NH₄)SO₄] on ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) seedlings. Based upon a review of the literature, we hypothesized that N limitations would not prevent a growth response to elevated CO₂. The hypothesis was not supported under conditions of extreme N deficiency (no fertilizer added to a very poor soil), but was supported when N limitations were less severe but still suboptimal (lower rate of fertilization). The growth increases in N-fertilized seedlings occurred mainly between 36 and 58 weeks without any additional N uptake. Thus, it appeared that elevated CO₂ allowed more efficient use of internal N reserves in the previously-fertilized seedlings, whereas internal N reserves in the unfertilized seedlings were insufficient to allow this response. Uptake rates of other nutrients were generally proportional to growth. Nitrogen treatment caused reductions in soil exchangeable K⁺, Ca²⁺, and Mg²⁺ (presumably because of nitrification and NO₃ ^- leaching) but increases in extractable P (presumably due to stimulation of phosphatase activity).The results of this and other seedling studies show that elevated CO₂ causes a reduction in tissue N concentration, even under N-rich conditions. The unique response of N is consistent with the hypothesis that the efficiency of Rubisco increases with elevated CO₂. These results collectively have significant implications for the response of mature, N-deficient forests to evevated CO₂.