Delayed DNA methylation is an integral feature of DNA replication in mammalian cells

In the majority of sites of methylation in the DNA of mammalian cells, the symmetry of methylation is restored within a few minutes of the passage of a replication fork. However, it has been shown that daughter strand methylation in immortalised cell lines is delayed in a substantial minority of sites for up to several hours after replication. We report here the results of two new approaches to the determination of the functional significance of delayed DNA methylation in mammalian cells. Firstly, we demonstrate that normal, nontransformed cells (human peripheral lymphocytes in short-term primary culture) have comparable proportions of delayed DNA methylation to many immortalised cell lines, showing that delayed DNA methylation is not just a secondary consequence of abnormally high methionine requirements commonly observed in transformed cells and that delayed DNA methylation would be unlikely not to occur in vivo. Secondly, we have used 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine (5azadCyd) to derive subclones of cells from the Chinese hamster ovary cell line which have stably hypomethylated DNA. In three of these subclones which had lost on average one fourth of the methylation sites from their genomes, the proportion of daughter strand methylation which was delayed after replication was reduced by less than 10%. If delayed DNA methylation were site-specific, this implies that of the order of twice the number of "immediate" methylation sites than delayed methylation sites had been lost from the genomes of these hypomethylated subclones. Thus, delayed DNA methylation is an integral part of the process whereby replicating mammalian cells maintain the pattern of methylation in their genomes. These observations are discussed in relation to the significance of delayed DNA methylation for the accurate maintenance of methylation patterns in the genome and the consequent implications for the possible role of methylated deoxycytidines in mammalian gene control.     

Analysis of DNA methylation in different maize tissues

DNA methylation plays an important role in gene expression regulation during biological development and tissue differentiation in plants. This study adopted methylation-sensitive Amplified fragment length polymorphism （AFLP） to compare the levels of DNA cytosine methylation at CCGG sites in tassel, bracteal leaf, and ear leaf from maize inbred lines, 18 White and 18 Red, respectively, and also examined specific methylation patterns of the three tissues. Significant differences in cytosine methylation level among the three tissues and the same changing tendency in two inbred lines were detected. Both MSAP （methylation sensitive amplification polymorphism） ratio and full methylation level were the highest in bracteal leaf, and the lowest in tassel. Meanwhile, different methylation levels were observed in the same tissue from the inbred lines, 18 White and 18 Red. Full methylation of internal cytosine was the dominant type in the maize genome. The differential methylation patterns in the three tissues were observed. In addition, sequencing of nine differentially methylated fragments and the subsequent blast search revealed that the cytosine methylated 5 ＇ -CCGG-3 ＇ sequences were distributed in repeating sequences, in the coding and noncoding regions. Southern hybridization was used to verify the methylation polymorphism. These results clearly demonstrated the power of the MSAP technique for large-scale DNA methylation detection in the maize genome, and the complexity of DNA methylation change during plant growth and development. The different methylation levels may be related to specific gene expression in various tissues.     

Characterization of DNA methylation in the rat

In the rat, differentiation and cell proliferation both affect DNA methylation. We studied 5-methylcytosine at the inner cytosine of the sequence C-C-G-G, a common methylation site, using endonuclease MspI (which cleaves C-C-G-G- and C-^mC-G-G), and its isoschizomer HpaII (which cleaves only C-C-G-G). DNA from all tissues and cell lines studied was methylated at C-C-G-G, at levels ranging from 45 to 80%, but the methylation sites were not distributed uniformly. Our analysis suggests a model in which cells contain variable amounts of three DNA methylation states, averaging 30–40, 70–80 and 95–100% methylation, respectively. One biological parameter that alters methylation is the prolferative state of the cell. We observed that NRK, a non-transformed cell line, increased its DNA methylation from 45 to 67% when monolayer cultures became confluent and non-dividing. We also observed that a class of repetitive DNA was completely methylated in DNA from all sources except a transformed cell line.     

Sequence specificity of cytosine methylation in the DNA of the Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cell line

We have determined the DNA renaturation kinetics for those DNA sequences of the Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cells in which enzymatic cytosine methylation occurred immediately after strand synthesis and for those in which methylation was delayed after strand synthesis. DNA sequences showing immediate or delayed methylation were found to be distributed throughout all repetition classes of the DNA of these cells, with a slight concentration of immediate methylation in moderately repetitive sequences and with delayed methylation being slightly over-represented in the highly repetitive fraction. However, DNA sequences showing both classes of methylation were represented equally in unique DNA sequences. We interpret these data to mean that the methylase acting near the replication forks (the ‘immediate’ methylase) is a relatively inefficient enzyme, missing some 20% of hemimethylated sites produced by DNA replication in these cells. We suggest that the methylase performing maintenance methylation at sites remote from the replication forks (the ‘delayed’ methylase) is simply a back-up enzyme for the first and that it has no true sequence specificity. The implications of this for the function(s) of DNA methylation in mammalian cells are discussed.     

Patterns of DNA methylation are indistinguishable in different individuals over a wide range of human DNA sequences.

Patterns of DNA methylation at 5'-CCGG-3' and 5'-GCGC-3' sequences were determined in about 570 kb, equivalent to about 0.02% of the human genome, by using HpaII and HhaI restriction endonucleases, respectively, and randomly selected cosmid clones of human DNA as hybridization probes. Many of these human DNA sequences were of the repetitive type. The DNAs from human lymphocytes, from a mixture of all blood cells or from several established human cell lines (HeLa, KB, 293, or DEV) were included in these analyses. In the segments of the human genome investigated, the patterns of DNA methylation were characterized by often completely or partly methylated 5'-CCGG-3' or by partly methylated 5'-GCGC-3' sequences. Even among individuals of different genetic origins (East-Asian or Caucasian), these patterns of DNA methylation proved indistinguishable by the method applied. The cytokine-dependent stimulation of human lymphocytes to replicate in culture did not affect the stability of these patterns. In the same DNA sequences from several human cell lines, much lower levels of DNA methylation were observed. In human cell lines some of the investigated sequences were unmethylated. The results presented lend credence to the notion that the human genome exhibits highly cell type-specific patterns of DNA methylation which are often indistinguishable among different individuals even of different genetic backgrounds.     

Spreading of DNA methylation across integrated foreign (adenovirus type 12) genomes in mammalian cells.

The establishment of de novo-generated patterns of DNA methylation is characterized by the gradual spreading of DNA methylation (I. Kuhlmann and W. Doerfler, J. Virol. 47:631-636, 1983; M. Toth, U. Lichtenberg, and W. Doerfler, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86:3728-3732, 1989; M. Toth, U. Müller, and W. Doerfler J. Mol. Biol. 214:673-683, 1990). We have used integrated adenovirus type 12 (Ad12) genomes in hamster tumor cells as a model system to study the mechanism of de novo DNA methylation. Ad12 induces tumors in neonate hamsters, and the viral DNA is integrated into the hamster genome, usually nearly intact and in an orientation that is colinear with that of the virion genome. The integrated Ad12 DNA in the tumor cells is weakly methylated at the 5'-CCGG-3' sequences. These sequences appear to be a reliable indicator for the state of methylation in mammalian DNA. Upon explantation of the tumor cells into culture medium, DNA methylation at 5'-CCGG-3' sequences gradually spreads across the integrated viral genomes with increasing passage numbers of cells in culture. Methylation is reproducibly initiated in the region between 30 and 75 map units on the integrated viral genome and progresses from there in either direction on the genome. Eventually, the genome is strongly methylated, except for the terminal 2 to 5% on either end, which remains hypomethylated. Similar observations have been made with tumor cell lines with different sites of Ad12 DNA integration. In contrast, the levels of DNA methylation do not seem to change after tumor cell explanation in several segments of hamster cell DNA of the unique or repetitive type. Restriction (HpaII) and Southern blot experiments were performed with selected cloned hamster cellular DNA probes. The data suggest that in the integrated foreign DNA, there exist nucleotide sequences or structures or chromatin arrangements that can be preferentially recognized by the system responsible for de novo DNA methylation in mammalian cells.     

DNA methylation levels in porcine fetal fibroblasts induced by an inhibitor of methylation, 5-azacytidine

Removal of the somatic DNA methylation pattern from donor cells and remodeling of embryonic status have been suggested as integral processes for successful nuclear transfer (NT) reprogramming. This study has investigated the effects of 5-azacytidine (5-azaC), a DNA methylation inhibitor, on global methylation changes in porcine fetal fibroblasts (PFF); this may improve NT attributable to the potential reprogramming of the methyl groups. PFF in 5th passage cultures were treated with 0, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, and 3.0 μM 5-azaC for 96 h; 5-azaC inhibited the growth at all tested concentrations. At the higher concentrations of 5-azaC used, cells appeared to exhibit morphological changes and to become apoptotic as observed by TUNEL assay. Thus, cells were negatively affected by 5-azaC. Differences in cellular ploidy were also observed at higher concentrations. Analysis showed no considerable changes in the proportion of cells at the G₁-phase of the cell cycle with 5-azaC concentrations. The fractional part of the methylated DNA of these cells was significantly reduced by 5-azaC treatment. Confocal microscopy confirmed the inhibition of methylation levels in PFF with increased concentrations of 5-azaC. Exposure to 5-azaC altered the expression of genes involved in imprinting (IGF2) or pro-apoptosis (BAX), whereas there was a reduction in the expression of the main enzyme responsible for replicating the DNA methylation pattern (DNMT1) and anti-apoptosis (BCL2L1). Therefore, 5-azaC induces a relative reduction in methylation in PFF, and cells treated with 0.5 μM 5-azaC may have enhanced potential for porcine NT.The financial support of BioGreen 21 (grant no. 100052004002000) and KOSEF (grant no. R05-2004-000-10702-0) in Korea is gratefully acknowledged.     

Heterogeneity in imprinted methylation patterns of pluripotent embryonic germ cells derived from pre-migratory mouse germ cells

Pluripotent stem cells, termed embryonic germ (EG) cells, have been generated from both human and mouse primordial germ cells (PGCs). Like embryonic stem (ES) cells, EG cells have the potential to differentiate into all germ layer derivatives and may also be important for any future clinical applications. The development of PGCs in vivo is accompanied by major epigenetic changes including DNA demethylation and imprint erasure. We have investigated the DNA methylation pattern of several imprinted genes and repetitive elements in mouse EG cell lines before and after differentiation. Analysed cell lines were derived soon after PGC specification, “early”, in comparison with EG cells derived after PGC colonisation of the genital ridge, “late” and embryonic stem (ES) cell lines, derived from the inner cell mass (ICM). Early EG cell lines showed strikingly heterogeneous DNA methylation patterns, in contrast to the uniformity of methylation pattern seen in somatic cells (control), late EG cell and ES cell lines. We also observed that all analysed XX cell lines exhibited less methylation than XY. We suggest that this heterogeneity may reflect the changes in DNA methylation taking place in the germ cell lineage soon after specification.     

Characteristics of enzymatic DNA methylation in cultured cells of human and hamster origin,and the effect of DNA replication inhibition

In mammalian cells, inhibitors of DNA replication have been shown to induce chromosomal aberrations, cell death and changes in gene control. Inhibition of DNA synthesis has been reported to induce hypermethylation of mammalian DNA (enzymatic postsynthetic formation of 5-methylcytosine). These 5-methylcytosines in mammalian DNA have variously been suggested to be important in gene control, DNA repair, and control of DNA replication. In establishing the normal characteristics of enzymatic DNA methylation, we have demonstrated that, in asynchronously growing cells of both human and hamster origin, some cytosine methylation is delayed for several hours after strand synthesis and that this delayed methylation is completed before the DNA strand acts as a template for DNA replication in the next S-phase. Further, in testing whether the deleterious effects on mammalian cells of DNA synthesis inhibitors might be mediated via changes in enzymatic DNA methylation, we have found, contrary to some previous findings, no evidence for any change in the level of DNA methylation in DNA strands synthesized during 6 h of treatment of cells of human origin with high concentrations of four different inhibitors of DNA replication or during the 4 h following the 6 h treatment. Almost totally blocking DNA replication had no effect on the small amount of delayed methylation of DNA strands not involved in semi-conservative replication during the time of the experiment. This lack of effect on DNA methylation was obtained when the labelling medium contained normal, undialysed serum. In contrast, if dialysed serum was used in the labelling medium in order to maximize l-[Me-³H]methionine utilization, highly variable, totally irreproducible patterns of apparent DNA hypermethylation were obtained.     

Flow cytometry analysis of early DNA content changes in human and monkey cells following infection with simian virus 40

Simian virus 40 (SV₄₀) is capable of inducing cellular DNA synthesis in permissive and nonpermissive cells. Utilizing flow cytometry, we analyzed the DNA content changes in two diploid human cell strains and two monkey cell lines. The osteogenesis imperfects (OI) human skin fibroblasts were induced into DNA synthesis, and within one to two cell generations, a polyploid cell population was produced. With WI-38 phase II cells, a similar pattern of increased cycling of cells into DNA synthesis was observed; however, the majority (～60%) of the cells were blocked in the G₂ + M phase of the cell cycle. At later time intervals, an increase in the G₁ population was demonstrated. The two monkey cell lines responded to SV₄₀ virus with an accumulation of cells in the G₂ + M phase of the cell cycle. Thus, two diploid human cell strains exhibited different cell cycle kinetics early after infection with SV₄₀ virus. The one strain (WI-38) behaved similarly to the two monkey cell lines studied. The other strain (OI) responded similarly to nonpermissive (transformin) cells infected with SV₄₀ virus.     

Comprehensive DNA methylation analysis of human peripheral blood leukocytes and lymphoblastoid cell lines

DNA methylation is involved in development and in human diseases. Genomic DNA derived from lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCLs) is commonly used to study DNA methylation. There are potential confounding factors regarding the use of LCL-derived DNA, however, such as Epstein-Barr (EB) viral infection and artifacts induced during cell culture. Recently, several groups compared the DNA methylation status of peripheral blood leukocytes (PBLs) and LCLs and concluded that the DNA methylation profiles between them might be consistent. To confirm and extend theses results, we performed a comprehensive DNA methylation analysis using both PBLs and LCLs derived from the same individuals. Using the luminometric methylation assay, we revealed that the global DNA methylation level was different between PBLs and LCLs. Furthermore, the direction of change was not consistent. Comparisons of genome-wide DNA methylation patterns of promoter regions revealed that methylation profiles were largely conserved between PBLs and LCLs. A preliminary analysis in a small number of samples suggested that the methylation status of an LCL may be better correlated with PBLs from the same individual than with LCLs from other individuals. Expectedly, DNA methylation in promoter regions overlapping with CpG islands was associated with gene silencing in both PBLs and LCLs. With regard to methylation differences, we found that hypermethylation was more predominant than hypomethylation in LCLs compared with PBLs. These findings suggest that LCLs should be used for DNA methylation studies with caution as the methylation patterns of promoter regions in LCLs are not always the same as those in PBLs.     

Chromosomal position effects determine transcriptional potential of integrated mammary tumor virus DNA

We have investigated two mammary tumor virus proviruses that are integrated at different chromosomal sites in the genomes of two clonal isolates of cultured rat hepatoma cells. One of these cell lines, J2.17, expresses MTV² RNA only in the presence of glucocorticoid hormones. In contrast, the proviral genes in the other line, J2.15, fail to be transcribed in the presence or absence of glucocorticoids, despite the fact that the viral genes and the cellular components that mediate hormone responses appear intact and normal. Low-level DNAase I digestion of chromosomes in isolated nuclei reveals that the J2.17 MTV DNA sequences are packaged in chromatin that is highly sensitive to DNAase I attack, whereas the chromatin of the J2.15 provirus is relatively resistant to DNAase I. These results demonstrate that the same genetic element located at two different chromosomal loci within a single cell line can differ in both chromatin structure and gene expression. Analysis of the chromatin structure of the appropriate DNA sequences in uninfected HTC cells suggests that the difference in the chromatin structure of the two proviruses may reflect a “spreading effect”, in which heterologous integrating DNA is packaged into chromatin that is similar in configuration to the surrounding chromatin. Thus, we propose that chromosomal position determines the folding pattern of the newly introduced DNA sequences, and that this pattern in turn determines whether the genes can subsequently be expressed in response to the hormonal inducing signal.     

Nucleic acids methylation of synchronized BHK 21 HS 5 fibroblasts during the mitotic phase

The methylation of nucleic acids has been investigated during the cell cycle of an asparagine dependent strain of transformed fibroblasts (BHK 21 HS 5). The synchrony was carried out by a partial asparagine starvation of cells for 24 hours. The amino acid supply induced all cells to enter synchronously the G₁ phase. Methylation and DNA synthesis were respectively measured by pulsed [methyl-¹⁴C] methionine and [methyl-³H] thymidine incorporation. DNA methylation followed a biphasic pattern with maximal methyl incorporations during both S phase and mitosis. A partial desynchronisation induced the S phase of the second cycle to proceed before all the cells have achieved their division. Hydroxyurea was used in order to inhibit the DNA synthesis of cells entering the second cell cycle, which might interfer with the mitosis of the first one. The inhibitor was added either at the first beginning of cell division or during all the G₁ phase. In both conditions it suppressed ³H thymidine incorporation of the second cycle. However, mitosis took place and methylations occurred as in previous experiments. The DNA methylation of the mitotic phase in the first cell cycle could thus be dissociated from the classical post-synthetic DNA maturation and did not correspond to any DNA methylation appearing in the course of the second cell cycle.     

PCR amplification following restriction to detect site-specific DNA methylation

A procedure to test for DNA methylation at sites recognized by methylation-sensitive restriction endonucleases is described. The procedure is based on the assumption that the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) will amplify sequences between two primers only if the target DNA is intact after digestion. A carrot (Daucus carota) cell line that is heterozygous for two sequenced alleles ofDc8, a gene which is expressed during the later stages of embryogenesis provided an ideal source of DNA for developing and testing protocols. The promoters of the two alleles differs significantly in length between two sites used for primers, and only one promoter has a GATC (Sau 3A1 orMbo I) site. This allowed development of a protocol where only the sequence lacking the GATC site was amplified to detectable levels following digestion of DNA withMbo I which is insensitive to symmetric methylation with^m4C or^m5C.