Superfluous Transgene Integration in Plants

Referee: Dr. Paul Hooykass, Institut of Molecular Plant Sciences, Leiden University, Clusius Laboratory, Wassenaarseweg 64, 2333, Al Leiden, Netherlands Recent reports suggest the transfer of superfluous DNA sequences to plant genomes during transformation processes. This review investigates the evidence from the published literature for the prevalence of this phenomenon and highlights methods to limit or prevent DNA transfer and subsequent potentially detrimental evolutionary consequences. Evidence for superfluous foreign DNA transfer using both Agrobacterium-mediated transformation and direct DNA transfer methods such as microprojectile bombardment and PEG-mediated transformation of protoplasts is reported. In the case of Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, the lack of information on the integration of sequences from outside of the T-DNA borders has been due to the general belief by researchers that T-DNA processing is precise. This assumption was based on analysis of T-DNA in tumors and as a result the majority of T-DNA integration events have been identified exclusively using DNA probes, which are homologous only to DNA from within the T-DNA borders. Where direct gene transfer protocols are employed, any part of the transforming plasmid and indeed accompanying carrier DNA may become integrated into the plant genome. The main body of evidence proving that superfluous vector DNA sequences are present in plant genomes transformed using direct transfer methods is confined to the identification of plasmid concatamers integrated into plant genomes. The limited amount of recorded evidence pertaining to superfluous vector DNA integration in transgenic plants and transformed tissues makes it impossible to draw definitive conclusions as to the factors involved in promoting this phenomenon. However, there are methods available for removing superfluous sequences from transgenic plants. These have been developed for the removal of selectable marker genes, whose presence in transgenic plants has been a source of much controversy, but can equally be applied to other DNA sequences. Suggestions have been made in the review that might limit or prevent the integration of superfluous vector sequences during transformation procedures; however, these are not proven and further research is required.     

Tobacco plants were transformed by Agrobacterium rhizogenes infection during their evolution

We discovered that the origin of cT-DNA in the genome of wild-type Nicotiana glauca is the T-DNA of the mikimopine-type Ri plasmid (pRi) harbored in Agrobacterium rhizogenes. The cT-DNA was inserted into the genomic DNA of N. glauca from the position corresponding to the right border of mikimopine-type pRi. The cT-DNA contained two mikimopine synthase gene (mis) homologs, NgmisL and NgmisR, both of which were transcribed at low level in all N. glauca organs. NgMisR protein expressed in Escherichia coli has preserved Mis activity, which converts l-histidine and alpha-ketoglutaric acid to mikimopine. The mis homolog was also found in the genome of three other Nicotiana species: N. tomentosa, N. tomentosiformis, and N. tabacum; however, the site of insertion differed from that in N. glauca, suggesting that A. rhizogenes harboring mikimopine-type pRi independently infected the ancestors of some Nicotiana plants. This is the first clear evidence of a host-parasite relationship during the early evolution of Nicotiana plants. We propose that a new phylogenetic approach using opine type cT-DNA is applicable for presuming divergence in the genus Nicotiana.     

The 35S promoter used in a selectable marker gene of a plant transformation vector affects the expression of the transgene

Positive selection of transgenic plants is essential during plant transformation. Thus, strong promoters are often used in selectable marker genes to ensure successful selection. Many plant transformation vectors, including pPZP family vectors, use the 35S promoter as a regulatory sequence for their selectable marker genes. We found that the 35S promoter used in a selectable marker gene affected the expression pattern of a transgene, possibly leading to a misinterpretation of the result obtained from transgenic plants. It is likely that the 35S enhancer sequence in the 35S promoter is responsible for the interference, as in the activation tagging screen. This affected expression mostly disappeared in transgenic plants generated using vectors without the 35S sequences within their T-DNA region. Therefore, we suggest that caution should be used in selecting a plant transformation vector and in the interpretation of the results obtained from transgenic approaches using vectors carrying the 35S promoter sequences within their T-DNA regions.     

A novel double T-DNA system for producing stack and marker-free transgenic plants

This study aimed to develop a new vector system to remove selection genes and to introduce two or more genes of interest into plants in order to express them in a coordinated manner. A multigene expression vector was established based on pCamBIA2300 using a selectable marker gene (SMG)-free system based on the combination of the isocaudamer technique and double T-DNA. The vector DT7 containing seven target genes was constructed and introduced into tobacco using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Twenty-one of 27 positive transgenic plants contained both T-DNA regions. The co-transformation frequency was 77.8 %. The frequency of unlinked integration of two intact T-DNAs was 22.22 % (6/27). The frequency of removal of SMG from transgenic T1 plants was 19.10 %. These results suggest that this vector system was functional and effective for multigene expression and SMG-free transgenic plant cultivation. At least seven target genes can be co-expressed using this system. Overall, these findings provide a new and highly effective platform for multigene and marker-free transgenic plant production.     

A quick method to estimate the T-DNA copy number in transgenic plants at an early stage after transformation,using inverse PCR

Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of plants is known to result in transgenic plants with a variable number of integrated T-DNA copies [1, 2, 3, 7]. Our aim was to obtain transgenic tobacco plants containing one integrated T-DNA copy per genome. Therefore, a quick method was developed to estimate the T-DNA copy number of young transgenic plantlets within 10 weeks after transformation. Inverse polymerase chain reaction (IPCR) was used to amplify junction fragments, i.e. plant genomic DNA sequences flanking the known T-DNA sequences [5].     

Formation of Complex Extrachromosomal T-DNA Structures in Agrobacterium tumefaciens-Infected Plants

Agrobacterium tumefaciens is a unique plant pathogenic bacterium renowned for its ability to transform plants. The integration of transferred DNA (T-DNA) and the formation of complex insertions in the genome of transgenic plants during A. tumefaciens-mediated transformation are still poorly understood. Here, we show that complex extrachromosomal T-DNA structures form in A. tumefaciens-infected plants immediately after infection. Furthermore, these extrachromosomal complex DNA molecules can circularize in planta. We recovered circular T-DNA molecules (T-circles) using a novel plasmid-rescue method. Sequencing analysis of the T-circles revealed patterns similar to the insertion patterns commonly found in transgenic plants. The patterns include illegitimate DNA end joining, T-DNA truncations, T-DNA repeats, binary vector sequences, and other unknown "filler" sequences. Our data suggest that prior to T-DNA integration, a transferred single-stranded T-DNA is converted into a double-stranded form. We propose that termini of linear double-stranded T-DNAs are recognized and repaired by the plant's DNA double-strand break-repair machinery. This can lead to circularization, integration, or the formation of extrachromosomal complex T-DNA structures that subsequently may integrate.     

水稻T-DNA插入突变体库的构建及突变类型的分析

利用农杆菌介导的转化系统转化中花11成熟胚愈伤组织,获得1489个独立转化的T-DNA插入再生株系。PCR和Southern杂交的结果表明,69．8％转化株系被整合了T-DNA,通过Tail-PCR也从转化植株中扩增出T-DNA侧翼序列。同时对1066个T1转化株系的抽穗期、株高、单株穗数的调查结果表明,不同株系中分离出了突变植株。     

Transformation of cereals via Agrobacterium and the pollen pathway: a critical assessment

It has been proposed that transgenic plants of cereals can be generated by inoculating florets with Agrobacterium at or near anthesis. This procedure is shown to lead to the production of embryos of wheat and barley with enhanced resistance to antibiotic selection. It has also been possible to recover plants of wheat, barley and maize that gave positive hybridization signals with probes produced from within the T-DNA of the Agrobacterium vector. However, no evidence was found for transmission of the bands detected by hybridization in the progeny of the putative transgenic plants nor could enzyme activity associated with the resistance genes be found in plant extracts. Furthermore, undigested genomic DNA from the plants that were positive when probed with the T-DNA, showed hybridization to bands smaller than the genomic DNA. It is suggested that the apparent transformation is an artifact of the procedure and does not reflect transformation of the plant nuclear genome.     

Chromosomal localization of foreign genes in Petunia hybrida

Summary A F1 hybrid of Petunia hybrida, heterozygous for at least one marker on each of the seven chromosomes, was transformed with a modified strain of Agrobacterium tumefaciens in which the phytohormone biosynthetic genes in the transferred DNA (T-DNA) were replaced with a NOS/NPTII/NOS chimeric gene and a wildtype nopaline synthase (NOS) gene. The chimeric gene, which confers kanamycin resistance, was used as selectable marker during the transformation process and the NOS gene was used as a scorable marker in the genetic studies. After plants had been regenerated from the transformed tissues, the transgenic plants that expressed both of these markers were backcrossed to the parental lines. The offspring were examined for the segregation of the NOS gene and the Petunia markers. Genetic mapping was thus accomplished in a single generation.By Southern hybridization analysis we confirmed the presence of the expected T-DNA fragments in the transformed plants. Four out of the six plants presented here, had just one monomeric T-DNA insertion. The sizes of the plant/T-DNA junction fragments suggest that the integration occurred in different sites of the Petunia genome. One transformant gave a more complicated hybridization pattern and possibly has two T-DNA inserts. Another transgenic plant was earlier reported (Fraley et al. 1985) to have two, possibly tandemly repeated T-DNAs.Data is presented on the genetic localization of the T-DNA inserts in six independently obtained transgenic plants. The T-DNA inserts in three plants were mapped to chromosome I. However, the distances between the NOS gene and the marker gene on this chromosome were significantly different. In another transgenic plant the NOS gene was coinherited with the marker on chromosome IV. Two other transgenic plants have the T-DNA insert on chromosome III. A three point cross enabled us to determine that both plants have the NOS gene distally located from the peroxidaseA (prxA) marker and both plants showed about 18% recombination. However, Southern hybridization analysis shows that the sizes of the plant/T-DNA junction fragments in these transgenic plants are different, thus suggesting that the integrations occurred in different sites.     

Transgene repeats in aspen: molecular characterisation suggests simultaneous integration of independent T-DNAs into receptive hotspots in the host genome

Rearrangements of T-DNAs during genetic transformation of plants can result in the insertion of transgenes in the form of repeats into the host genome and frequently lead to loss of transgene expression. To obtain insight into the mechanism of repeat formation we screened 45 transgenic lines of aspen and hybrid aspen transformed with six different gene constructs. The frequency of T-DNA repeat formation among randomly screened transgenic lines was found to be about 21%. In ten transgenic lines direct repeats were detected. An inverted repeat was found in one other transgenic line. Sequencing of the junctions between the T-DNA inserts revealed identical residual right-border repeat sequences at the repeat junctions in all ten transgenic lines that had direct repeats. Formation of "precise" junctions based on short regions of sequence similarity between recombining strands was observed in three transgenic lines transformed with the same plasmid. Additional DNA sequences termed filler DNAs were found to be inserted between the T-DNA repeats at eight junctions where there was no similarity between recombining ends. The length of the filler DNAs varied from 4 to almost 300 bp. Small filler DNAs--a few base pairs long--were in most cases copied from T-DNA near the break points. The large filler sequences of about 300 bp in two transgenic lines were found to be of host plant origin, suggesting that transgene repeat formation occurred as a result of the simultaneous invasion of a receptive site in the host genome by two independent T-DNA strands. On the basis of the results obtained, and in the light of previous reports on T-DNA/plant DNA junctions in aspen and other crop plants, a mechanistic model for transgene rearrangement and filler formation is suggested.     

The Method of Transformation of Moroccan Toadflax (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Linaria maroccana</Emphasis> Hook. f.)

Plants of the genus Linaria are scientifically interesting owing to the presence of natural-transgenic forms containing a set of agrobacterial genes (so-called cT-DNA). Many Linaria species are valuable ornamental plants. However, until recently, the literature did not describe the method of genetic transformation of plants of the genus Linaria. In this paper, we present the method of in vitro agrobacterial transformation of plants of Moroccan toadflax (Linaria maroccana Hook. f.). Method of adaptation for in vivo conditions is also described. This technique will be used in further studies of the functioning of сT-DNA and can also be recommended for solving applied problems.     

Screening of transgenic plants by amplification of unknown genomic DNA flanking T-DNA.

For the screening of transfer DNA (T-DNA) integration in transgenic plant material, we developed a method based on specific amplification of genomic plant DNA flanking T-DNA borders. This approach is possible because the length of the region flanking T-DNA extremity on a restriction fragment is specific to the integration locus. We have modified an adaptor ligation PCR technique developed for amplification of unknown DNA flanking known sequence. The PCR patterns obtained were specific and reproducible for different plants from a given transgenic line. Furthermore, the number of PCR products obtained could be considered a good estimation of the T-DNA copy number. When compared to Southern blot analysis, the PCR results give valuable complementary information about the complexity of the T-DNA integration pattern and also about the integrity of the T-DNA borders. We describe the applications of this approach to populations of transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana plants.     

Transgene integration in aspen: structures of integration sites and mechanism of T-DNA integration

To obtain insight into the mechanism of transferred DNA (T-DNA) integration in a long-lived tree system, we analysed 30 transgenic aspen lines. In total, 27 right T-DNA/plant junctions, 20 left T-DNA/plant junctions, and 10 target insertions from control plants were obtained. At the right end, the T-DNA was conserved up to the cleavage site in 18 transgenic lines (67%), and the right border repeat was deleted in nine junctions. Nucleotides from the left border repeat were present in 19 transgenic lines out of 20 cases analysed. However, only four (20%) of the left border ends were conserved to the processing end, indicating that the T-DNA left and right ends are treated mechanistically differently during the T-DNA integration process. Comparison of the genomic target sites prior to integration to the T-DNA revealed that the T-DNA inserted into the plant genome without any notable deletion of genomic sequence in three out of 10 transgenic lines analysed. However, deletions of DNA ranging in length from a few nucleotides to more than 500 bp were observed in other transgenic lines. Filler DNAs of up to 235 bp were observed on left and/or right junctions of six transgenic lines, which in most cases originated from the nearby host genomic sequence or from the T-DNA. Short sequence similarities between recombining strands near break points, in particular for the left T-DNA end, were observed in most of the lines analysed. These results confirm the well-accepted T-DNA integration model based on single-stranded annealing followed by ligation of the right border which is preserved by the VirD2 protein. However, a second category of T-DNA integration was also identified in nine transgenic lines, in which the right border of the T-DNA was partly truncated. Such integration events are described via a model for the repair of genomic double-strand breaks in somatic plant cells based on synthesis-dependent strand-annealing. This report in a long-lived tree system provides major insight into the mechanism of transgene integration.     

Agrobacterium proteins VirD2 and VirE2 mediate precise integration of synthetic T-DNA complexes in mammalian cells

Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated plant transformation, a unique example of interkingdom gene transfer, has been widely adopted for the generation of transgenic plants. In vitro synthesized transferred DNA (T-DNA) complexes comprising single-stranded DNA and Agrobacterium virulence proteins VirD2 and VirE2, essential for plant transformation, were used to stably transfect HeLa cells. Both proteins positively influenced efficiency and precision of transgene integration by increasing overall transformation rates and by promoting full-length single-copy integration events. These findings demonstrate that the virulence proteins are sufficient for the integration of a T-DNA into a eukaryotic genome in the absence of other bacterial or plant factors. Synthetic T-DNA complexes are therefore unique protein:DNA delivery vectors with potential applications in the field of mammalian transgenesis.     

培育具有安全选择标记或无选择标记的转基因植物

转基因植物中选择标记的安全性已成为植物基因工程研究的热点之一。从两个方面可以解决转基因植物中的选择标记问题。一是选用安全的正向选择标记,主要是与糖代谢和激素代谢相关的基因。二是构建能去除选择标记基因的转化系统,主要有共转化系统、双T-DNA边界载体系统、位点特异性重组系统和转座子系统等。这些植物基因工程的方法将有助于培育安全的转基因植物。 Abstract:The bio-safety of selective markers in transgenic plants has been a hot spot in the field of plant genetic engineering.To solve the problem of selective markers in the transgenic plants,two means of producing transgenic plants have been developed.One is the utilization of bio-safe positive selective markers which are genes mainly related to metabolism of auxins and carbohydrates.The other is the establishment of transformation systems allowing marker genes to be eliminated from the transgenic plants,which include co-ransformation,double T-DNA border vectors,site-specific recombination and transposition.All these approaches of plant genetic engineering will benefit breeding transgenic plants with bio-safety.     

Rapid and accurate early-stage detection of T-DNA/plant flanking sequences of resistant kumquats

Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation is a widely applied tool in plant biotechnology. In this process, genes of interest are integrated into plant genomes via T-DNAs present on plasmids in Agrobacteria. Classical and standard methods for screening transformants, such as Southern blot, are inconvenient for most woodland plants because of extremely low transformation efficiency. For the purpose of identifying transgenic woody lines at early selection stages, a right-border T-DNA/plant conjunction sequence analysis was carried out. By analyzing these sequences, 15 out of 17 kanamycin-resistant kumquats were found to be integrated with foreign genes, and two or more copies were present in 33.3% of the transgenic lines, which is completely concordant with Southern blots. Moreover, T-DNA integration into plant nuclear DNA was random without any sequence hotspots, and cleavage sites are any base of the sequence ‘TGAC’. These results showed that this screening method could not only detect resistant woodland plants rapidly at the early selection stage, but unequivocally detect copy numbers. Compared with other screening technique, this method could save time and effort for conducting genetic transformation in woody plants, and also provides accurate integration information for transgenic plants.     

Generation of marker-free transgenic maize by regular two-border <Emphasis Type="Italic">Agrobacterium</Emphasis> transformation vectors

By introducing additional T-DNA borders into a binary plasmid used in Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation, previous studies have demonstrated that the marker gene and the gene of interest (GOI) can be carried by independent T-strands, which sometimes integrate in unlinked loci in the plant genome. This allows the recovery of marker-free transgenic plants through genetic segregation in the next generation. In this study, we have found that by repositioning the selectable marker gene in the backbone and leaving only the GOI in the T-DNA region, a regular two-border binary plasmid was able to generate marker-free transgenic maize plants more efficiently than a conventional single binary plasmid with multiple T-DNA borders. These results also provide evidence that both the right and left borders can initiate and terminate T-strands. Such non-canonical initiation and termination of T-strands may be the basis for the elevated frequencies of cotransformation and unlinked insertions.     

Number and Accuracy of T-DNA Insertions in Transgenic Banana (Musa spp.) Plants Characterized by an Improved Anchored PCR Technique

Nineteen transgenic banana plants, produced via Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, were analyzed for the integration of T-DNA border regions using an improved anchored PCR technique. The method described is a relatively fast, three-step procedure (restriction digestion of genomic DNA, ligation of ‘vectorette’-type adaptors, and a single round of suppression PCR) for the amplification of specific T-DNA border-containing genomic fragments. Most transgenic plants carried a low number of inserts and the method was suitable for a detailed characterization of the integration events, including T-DNA border integrity as well as the insertion of non-T-DNA vector sequences, which occurred in 26% of the plants. Furthermore, the particular band pattern generated by four enzyme/primer combinations for each individual plant served as a fingerprint, allowing the identification of plants representing identical transformation events. Genomic Southern hybridization and nucleotide sequence analysis of amplification products confirmed the data obtained by anchored PCR. Sequencing of seven right or left border junction regions revealed different T-DNA processing events for each plant, indicating a relatively low frequency of precisely nicked T-DNA integration among the plants studied.     

Site-specific integration of Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-DNA via double-stranded intermediates

Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated genetic transformation involves transfer of a single-stranded T-DNA molecule (T strand) into the host cell, followed by its integration into the plant genome. The molecular mechanism of T-DNA integration, the culmination point of the entire transformation process, remains largely obscure. Here, we studied the roles of double-stranded breaks (DSBs) and double-stranded T-DNA intermediates in the integration process. We produced transgenic tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) plants carrying an I-SceI endonuclease recognition site that, upon cleavage with I-SceI, generates DSB. Then, we retransformed these plants with two A. tumefaciens strains: one that allows transient expression of I-SceI to induce DSB and the other that carries a T-DNA with the I-SceI site and an integration selection marker. Integration of this latter T-DNA as full-length and I-SceI-digested molecules into the DSB site was analyzed in the resulting plants. Of 620 transgenic plants, 16 plants integrated T-DNA into DSB at their I-SceI sites; because DSB induces DNA repair, these results suggest that the invading T-DNA molecules target to the DNA repair sites for integration. Furthermore, of these 16 plants, seven plants incorporated T-DNA digested with I-SceI, which cleaves only double-stranded DNA. Thus, T-strand molecules can be converted into double-stranded intermediates before their integration into the DSB sites within the host cell genome.