Tryptophan in alpha-helix 3 of Tet repressor forms a sequence-specific contact with tet operator in solution

The Tn10-encoded Tet repressor contains two tryptophan residues at positions 43 and 75. The typical tryptophan fluorescence is decreased upon binding of tet operator. The Tet repressor gene was engineered to replace either or both of the Trp codons by Phe codons. The resulting single tryptophan mutants are called F43 and F75 and the double mutant F43F75. The mutant proteins were purified to homogeneity. They recognize tet operator DNA only in the absence of the inducer tetracycline, indicating an intact tertiary structure of the engineered proteins. F75 and wild-type bind tet operator with the same association constant. The association constants of F43 and F43F75 with tet operator are about 3 orders of magnitude smaller. This indicates that Trp43 is important for tet operator recognition. Trp43 fluorescence is completely quenched in the complex with tet operator DNA while Trp75 remains unaffected. Binding to nonspecific DNA leads only to a 40% decrease of Trp43 fluorescence. This is interpreted as the contribution of the changed environment while the complete quench reflects a tight sequence-specific contact of tryptophan 43 to tet operator DNA. Trp43 is solvent-exposed, while Trp75 is buried in the hydrophobic interior of the protein. These results are discussed in light of the alpha-helix turn-alpha-helix DNA binding motif deduced from homology to other repressor proteins.     

Contacts between Tet repressor and tet operator revealed by new recognition specificities of single amino acid replacement mutants.

We have analyzed the DNA binding properties of Tet-repressor mutants with single amino acid residue replacements at eight positions within the alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix DNA-binding motif. A saturation mutagenesis of Gln38, Pro39, Thr40, Tyr42, Trp43 and His44 in the second alpha-helix was performed; in addition, several substitutions of Thr27 and Arg28 in the first alpha-helix were constructed. The abilities of these mutant repressors to bind a set of 16 operator variants were determined and revealed 23 new binding specificities. All repressor mutants with DNA-binding activity were inducible by tetracycline, while mutants lacking binding activity were trans-dominant over the wild-type. All mutant proteins were present at the same intracellular steady-state concentrations as the wild-type. These results suggest the structural integrity of the mutant repressors. On the basis of the new recognition specificities, five contacts between a repressor monomer and each operator half-site and the chemical nature of these repressor-operator interactions are proposed. We suggest that Arg28 contacts guanine of the G.C base-pair at operator position 2 with two H-bonds, Gln38 binds adenine of the A.T base-pair at position 3 with two H-bonds, and the methyl group of Thr40 participates in a van der Waals' contact with cytosine of the G.C base-pair at position 6 of tet operator. A previously unrecognized type of interaction is proposed for Pro39, which inserts its side-chain between the methyl groups of the thymines of T.A and A.T base-pairs at positions 4 and 5. Computer modeling of these proposed contacts reveals that they are possible using the canonical structures of the helix-turn-helix motif and B-DNA. These contacts suggest an inverse orientation of the Tet repressor helix-turn-helix with respect to the operator center as compared with non-inducible repressor-operator complexes, and are supported by similar contacts of other repressor-operator complexes.     

Computer simulations and experimental studies of gel mobility patterns for weak and strong non-cooperative protein binding to two targets on the same DNA: application to binding of tet repressor variants to multiple and single tet operator sites

A series of computer simulations of gel patterns assuming non-cooperative binding of a protein to two targets on the same DNA fragment was performed and applied to interprete gel mobility shift experiments of Tet repressor-tet operator binding. While a high binding affinity leads to the expected distribution of free DNA, DNA bound by one repressor dimer and DNA bound by two repressor dimers, a lower affinity or an increased electrophoresis time results in the loss of the band corresponding to the singly occupied complex. The doubly occupied complex remains stable under these conditions. This phenomenon is typical for protein binding to DNA fragments with two identical sites. It results from statistical disproportionation of the singly occupied complex in the gel. The lack of the singly occupied complex is commonly taken to indicate cooperative binding, however, our analysis shows clearly, that cooperativity is not needed to interprete these results. Tet repressor proteins and small DNA fragments with two tet operator sites have been prepared from four classes of tetracycline resistance determinants. The results of gel mobility shift analyses of various complexes of these compounds confirm the predictions. Furthermore, calculated gel patterns assuming different gel mobilities of the two singly occupied complexes show discrete bands only if the electrophoresis time is shorter than the inverse of the microscopic dissociation rate constant. Simulations assuming increasing dissociation rates predict that the two bands first merge into one, which then disappears. This behavior was verified by gel mobility analyses of Tet repressor-tet operator titrations at increased salt concentrations as well as by direct footprinting of the complexes in the gel. It is concluded that comparison of the intensities of the single and the double occupation bands allow a rough estimation of the dissociation rate constant. On this basis the sixteen possible Tet repressor-tet operator combinations can be ordered with decreasing binding affinities by a simple gel shift experiment. The implications of these results for gel mobility analyses of other protein-DNA complexes are discussed.     

Tet repressor binding induced curvature of tet operator DNA.

Tet repressor dimer binds to two tet operator sites spaced by 30 bp in the Tn10 encoded tet regulatory DNA. The effect of repressor binding on the gel mobility of circular permutated DNA fragments containing either one or both operator sequences is reported. The EcoRI induced bending of DNA is used to compare the results with other protein binding induced structural perturbations of DNA. Tet repressor bends a DNA fragment with a single tet operator to an angle of 42 degrees +/- 7 degrees. The apparent bend angle of DNA fragments containing the tandem tet operator arrangement occupied by two Tet repressor dimers turns out to be 52 degrees +/- 9 degrees. These results are interpreted with respect to the end to end distances of the bent DNA fragments. They indicate that either the intervening tet regulatory DNA between the operators or the bound operator sequences themselves contain additional perturbations from the canonical B-DNA structure. This finding is discussed in the light of previously obtained results from CD, neutron scattering, and electrooptical studies.     

Engineered Tet repressor mutants with single tryptophan residues as fluorescent probes. Solvent accessibilities of DNA and inducer binding sites and interaction with tetracycline

Mutants of the Tn10-encoded Tet repressor containing single or no tryptophan residues were constructed by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. The Trp-75 to Phe exchange reduces the dissociation rate of the complex with the inducer tetracycline by a factor of 2. The Trp-43 to Phe exchange has no effect on inducer binding. The fluorescence emission spectra of both tryptophan residues are quenched to a different extent by binding of tetracycline: Trp-75 is quenched to zero and Trp-43 to only 50%. It is concluded that Trp-75 is in the vicinity of the inducer binding site. The different fluorescence emission spectra of both tryptophan residues depend on the native structure of Tet repressor. Quenching studies with iodide indicate that the DNA binding motif is solvent exposed in free repressor and moves towards the interior of the protein upon inducer binding. The inducer binding site is in the interior of the protein. The fluorescence of tetracycline is enhanced upon binding to Tet repressor. The excitation at 280 nm results mainly from the change in environment and in part from energy transfer from tryptophan to the drug.     

UV-induced cross-linking of Tet repressor to DNA containing tet operator sequences and 8-azidoadenines.

The synthesis of 8-azido-2'-deoxyadenosine-5'-triphosphate is described. The photoreactive dATP analog was characterized by thin layer chromatography, proton resonance spectroscopy, infrared spectroscopy and UV spectroscopy. Its photolysis upon UV irradiation was studied. After incorporation of this dATP analog into DNA containing the tet operator sequence the investigation of the interactions between tet operator DNA and Tet repressor protein by UV photocross-linking becomes possible. Photocross-linking of protein to DNA was demonstrated by the reduced migration of the DNA in SDS polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Addition of the inducer tetracycline prior to UV irradiation significantly reduces the DNA-protein cross-linking rate. The long wave UV light applied here does not significantly alter the DNA or the protein under the photocross-linking conditions.     

Fluorescence and Phosphorescence Study of Tet Repressor–Operator Interaction

Fluorescence and phosphorescence measurements have been carried out on single-p tryptophan (Trp 43 or Trp 75)-containing mutants of Tet repressor (Tet R). Tet R containing Trp 43, the residue localized in the DNA recognition helix of the repressor, has been used to observe the binding of Tet R to two 20-bp DNA sequences of tet O₁ and tet O₂ operators. Binding of Tet R to tet O₁ operator leads to a 78% decrease of the repressor fluorescence intensity, with an accompanying 20-nm blue shift of its fluorescence emission maximum to 330 nm. Upon binding of Tet R to tet O₂ operator, the Trp 43 fluorescence intensity is quenched by 60%, and a 10-nm shift of its emission maximum to 340 nm occurs. Solute fluorescence quenching studies, using acrylamide, performed at low ionic strength indicate that in both the complex of Tet R with the O₁ and that with the O₂ operator, Trp 43 is moderately buried, as indicated by a bimolecular rate quenching constant of about 1.8 × 10⁹ M^–1 sec^–1. In contrast to the Tet R–tet O₂ complex, the Stern–Volmer acrylamide quenching constant K _sv of the complex with tet O₁ operator changes from 7.5 M^–1 at 5 mM NaCl to 22 M^–1 at 200 mM NaCl, indicating different exposures of Trp 43 in the two complexes in solutions of higher ionic strength. Phosphorescence studies showed a 0–0 vibronic transition at 408 and 403 nm for Trp 43 and Trp 75, respectively. Upon binding of Tet R to the tet operators, we observed red shifts of 0–0 vibronic bands of Trp 43 to 413 and 412 nm for tet O₁ and tet O₂ operator, respectively, and the phosphorescence triplet lifetime of Trp 43 at 75 K was quenched from 6.0–5.5 to 3.5–3.3 sec. The thermal phosphorescence quenching profile ranged from –200°C to –20°C, and differed drastically for the two complexes, suggesting different dynamics of the microenvironment of the Trp 43 residue. The luminescence data for Trp 43 of Tet R suggest that the recognition helix of Tet R interacts in different fashions with the tet O₁ and tet O₂ operators.     

Lac repressor — Lac operator complexes

Complexes between the Lac repressor and a small DNA operator fragment (29 base pairs) were investigated using polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and solution X-ray scattering. Titration of the DNA fragment with the repressor, followed by gel electrophoresis showed that only two types of complexes are formed with repressor/operator ratios of 0.5 and 2. Radii of gyration and forward scattered intensities were obtained from Guinier plots for repressor/operator ratios ranging from 0.3 to 2. They demonstrated that the first complex contains one repressor and two operators, whereas the second one contains four repressors and two operators. Mixing operator and repressor in equimolar concentrations leads to a mixture of both complexes. A possible model for the four repressor/two operator complex is proposed.     

Independent regulation of two genes in Escherichia coli by tetracyclines and Tet repressor variants

We report a regulation system in Escherichia coli for independent regulation of two distinct reporter genes by application of Tet repressors with different specificities. One Tet repressor variant comprises wild-type tet operator (tetO) recognition and exclusive induction with the novel inducer 4-dedimethylamino-anhydrotetracycline. The other Tet repressor variant shows tetO-4C recognition and induction with tetracycline. We demonstrate that both variants are independently active in vivo and allow selective regulation of two genes in the same cell without any cross talk.     

TET repressor.tet operator complex formation induces conformational changes in the tet operator DNA.

The structural changes of the tet operator DNA upon binding of the TET repressor protein are examined by circular dichroism. For this purpose a 70 bp DNA fragment was prepared which contains both tet operators. About 67% of the base pairs of this DNA are involved in specific interaction with the TET repressor. A rather large change in the CD of the DNA is induced by binding of the TET repressor. The shape of the CD difference spectrum is similar to the respective difference found for the lac operator DNA upon complex formation with the lac repressor. However, the effect induced by the TET repressor on tet operator DNA seems to comprise both the specific and non-specific effect of the lac repressor on the structure of DNA [Culard, F. and Maurizot, J.C. (1981) Nucl. Acids Res. 9, 5157-5184]. Specificity of binding is confirmed by the lack of any effect of the TET repressor on the CD of a 95 bp lac operator containing DNA fragment, by the reduced mobility of TET repressor.tet operator complexes on polyacrylamide gels under CD conditions, and by a titration experiment of tet operator DNA with TET repressor employing the CD change. The latter experiment reveals a stoichiometry of four TET repressors per tet operon control region.     

A point mutation at the C-terminal half of the repressor of temperate mycobacteriophage L1 affects its binding to the operator DNA

The wild-type repressor CI of temperate mycobacteriophage L1 and the temperature-sensitive (ts) repressor CIts391 of a mutant L1 phage, L1cIts391, have been separately overexpressed in E. coli. Both these repressors were observed to specifically bind with the same cognate operator DNA. The operator-binding activity of CIts391 was shown to differ significantly than that of the CI at 32 to 42 degrees C. While 40-95% operator-binding activity was shown to be retained at 35 to 42 degrees C in CI, more than 75% operator-binding activity was lost in CIts391 at 35 to 38 degrees C, although the latter showed only 10% less binding compared to that of the former at 32 degrees C. The CIts391 showed almost no binding at 42 degrees C. An in vivo study showed that the CI repressor inhibited the growth of a clear plaque former mutant of the L1 phage more strongly than that of the CIts391 repressor at both 32 and 42 degrees C. The half-life of the CIts391-operator complex was found to be about 8 times less than that of the CI-operator complex at 32 degrees C. Interestingly, the repressor-operator complexes preformed at 0 degrees C have shown varying degrees of resistance to dissociation at the temperatures which inhibit the formation of these complexes are inhibited. The CI repressor, but not that of CIts391, regains most of the DNA-binding activity on cooling to 32 degrees C after preincubation at 42 to 52 degrees C. All these data suggest that the 131(st) proline residue at the C-terminal half of CI, which changed to leucine in the CIts391, plays a crucial role in binding the L1 repressor to the cognate operator DNA, although the helix-turn-helix DNA-binding motif of the L1 repressor is located at its N-terminal end.     

Tn10 tet operator mutations affecting Tet repressor recognition.

The effect of single base pair alterations of the Tn10 encoded tet operator on recognition of Tet repressor was studied in vivo using a repressor titration system and in vitro by dissociation rate determinations of the respective complexes. Both methods reveal that the two operators, O1 and O2, which are in a tandem arrangement in the wild type, are recognized with a two-fold different affinity when separated. Studies on synthetic operator sequences indicate that the Tet repressor binds with higher affinity to the non-palindromic O2 wildtype than to the respective palindromic sequences. The in vivo repressor titration system links the expression of lacZ to the affinity of tet operator to Tet repressor. It was used to isolate tet operator mutations with reduced affinity to the repressor. The in vivo and in vitro obtained results with these mutants agree quantitatively and indicate, that the GC base pairs at positions 2, 6, and 8 are involved in interaction with the Tet repressor. Their importance for recognition decreases in that order. Transitions at position 7 of the tet operator show smaller effects on recognition than transversions.     

Arc repressor-operator DNA interactions and contribution of Phe10 to binding specificity

Solution properties of Arc repressors (wild-type and F10H variant) from Salmonella bacteriophage P22 and their complexes with operator DNA (Arc-wt-DNA and Arc-F10H-DNA) were characterized by circular dichroism, fluorescence, and Raman difference spectroscopy and compared with the crystal structures of free and DNA-bound Arc repressors (wild-type and F10V variant). From the crystal structure of Arc-wt-operator DNA complex, it is known that amino acids Phe10/10' flip out of the hydrophobic protein core, and in the Arc-F10V-DNA complex, the methyl groups of Val10/10' rotate toward the DNA. Arc-wt and Arc-F10H significantly perturb the Raman signatures of the operator DNA upon complex formation. The two proteins induce similar changes in the DNA spectra. Raman markers in the difference spectra (spectrum of the complex minus spectra of DNA and Arc) indicate binding of Arc in the major groove, several direct contacts, e.g., hydrogen bonds of protein residues with bases, and slight perturbations of the deoxyribose ring systems that are consistent with bending of the operator DNA. Trp14, the only one tryptophan of Arc repressor monomers, serves as a very sensitive tool for changes of the hydrophobic core of the protein. The Raman spectra identify in the free Arc-F10H variant a largely different chi(2,1) rotation angle of Trp14 compared to that in wild-type Arc. In the Arc-wt-DNA and Arc-F10H-DNA complexes, however, the Trp14 chi(2,1) rotation angles are similar in both proteins. Furthermore, in both complexes, a strengthening of the van der Waals interactions of the aromatic ring of Trp14 is indicated compared to these interactions in the free proteins. According to the fluorescence and Raman data, His10 is buried in the hydrophobic core of free Arc-F10H, resembling the "core" conformation of Phe10 in Arc-wt, but His10 is looped out in the complex with DNA resembling the "bound" conformation of Phe10 in the Arc-wt-operator DNA complex.     

Tet repressor-tet operator contacts probed by operator DNA-modification interference studies

Contacts between tet operator DNA and Tet repressor protein are characterized by modification interference studies. The modified DNA fragments are separated into fractions with high, intermediate and low affinities for Tet repressor by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Ethylation of the phosphates with N-ethylnitrosourea reveals 12 contacts of a repressor dimer to tet operator. Eight of these contacts appear to be important for Tet repressor binding, as judged by the strong interference at these positions, while four contacts are probably less important. All of the phosphate contacts are located on the same side of the B-DNA structure. The sequences of tet operators proposed to interact with the recognition alpha-helix of Tet repressor are TCTATC in three cases and CCTATC in one case. After methylation of N-7 with dimethylsulfate, strong interference is observed at the guanine residues at positions +/- 2. None of the N-7 functions of other guanine residues seems to be involved in tight contacts to Tet repressor. Tet repressor subunits form identical phosphate and guanine N-7 contacts with each half side of the two tet operators indicating twofold dyad symmetry of the complexes. Attempts to analyze the methylation interference at the adenine N-3 sites reveal different results for the operators. Modification of DNA fragments with diethylpyrocarbonate yields hypersensitive sites in the tet operators, indicating different local DNA structures. Carbethoxylation interference studies confirm the contacts at the purines found by methylation interference. All of the sequence-specific protein-DNA contacts detected in this study are centered at the inside four base-pairs in each tet operator half side. The contacts are discussed with respect to the structure of the repressor-operator complex.     

DNA-binding site of lac repressor probed by dimethylsulfate methylation of lac operator.

In order to compare the structures of the DNA-binding sites on variants of the lac repressor, we have studied the influence of these variants on the dimethylsulfate methylation of the lac operator. Since a bound protein changes the availability of specific purines in the operator to this chemical attack, comparisons of the methylation patterns will show similarities or differences in the protein DNA contacts. We compared lac repressor, induced lac repressor (repressor bound to the gratuitous inducer isopropyl-β-d-thiogalactoside), mutant repressors having increased operator affinities (X86, I12 and the X86-I12 double mutant) and repressor peptides (long headpiece, residues 1 to 59 and short headpiece. residues 1 to 51). All of these repressors and repressor peptides exhibit the same general pattern of protection and enhancement in the operator; however, the short headpiece pattern differs most from that of the repressor while the induced repressor and the long headpiece show intermediate patterns that are strikingly similar to each other. The mutant repressors do not show an isopropyl-β-d-thiogalactoside effect but otherwise are almost indistinguishable from wild-type repressor. These results demonstrate that all molecules bind to the operator using basically the same protein-DNA contacts; they imply that (1) most and possibly all repressor contacts to operator lie within amino acids 1 to 51, (2) inducer weakens many contacts rather than totally disrupting one or even a few and (3) the tight-binding mutants do not make additional contacts to the DNA.These results are consistent with a model in which the amino-terminal portions of two repressor monomers make the DNA contacts. We show that one can understand the affinity of binding as related to the accuracy of the register of the two amino-terminal portions along the DNA. Furthermore, the action of inducer and the behaviour of the tight binding mutants can be accomodated within a two-state model in which the strongly or weakly binding states correspond to structures in which the amino-terminal regions are rigidly or loosely held with respect to each other.     

Trp scanning analysis of Tet repressor reveals conformational changes associated with operator and anhydrotetracycline binding.

We analysed the conformational states of free, tet operator-bound and anhydrotetracycline-bound Tet repressor employing a Trp-scanning approach. The two wild-type Trp residues in Tet repressor were replaced by Tyr or Phe and single Trp residues were introduced at each of the positions 162-173, representing part of an unstructured loop and the N-terminal six residues of alpha-helix 9. All mutants retained in vivo inducibility, but anhydrotetracycline-binding constants were decreased up to 7.5-fold when Trp was in positions 169, 170 and 173. Helical positions (168-173) differed from those in the loop (162-167) in terms of their fluorescence emission maxima, quenching rate constants with acrylamide and anisotropies in the free and tet operator-complexed proteins. Trp fluorescence emission decreased drastically upon atc binding, mainly due to energy transfer. For all proteins, either free, tet operator bound or anhydrtetracycline-bound, mean fluorescence lifetimes were determined to derive quenching rate constants. Solvent-accessible surfaces of the respective Trp side chains were calculated and compared with the quenching rate constants in the anhydrotetracycline-bound complexes. The results support a model, in which residues in the loop become more exposed, whereas residues in alpha-helix 9 become more buried upon the induction of TetR by anhydrotetracycline.     

Saturation mutagenesis of the Tn10-encoded tet operator O1. Identification of base-pairs involved in Tet repressor recognition

Saturation mutagenesis of Tn10-encoded tet operator O1 was performed by chemical synthesis of 30 sequence variants yielding all possible point mutations of an operator half side. Their effect on Tet repressor binding was scored by an in-vivo repressor titration system. Tet repressor affinities of selected operator mutants were further characterized in vitro by dissociation rate measurements. The O1 sequence spans 19 base-pairs. Out of these, all 18 palindromic base-pairs are involved in Tet repressor recognition. The central base-pair does not contribute to sequence-specific binding of Tet repressor. At position 1 a pyrimidine residue is sufficient for maximal affinity to the repressor. At positions 2, 3 and 4, each mutation reduces repressor binding at least tenfold. Mutations at positions 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 result in less drastic reductions of Tet repressor binding. Differential effects of mutations at a given position are used to deduce the chemical functions contacted by Tet repressor. The T.A to A.T transversion at position 9 increases Tet repressor affinity slightly, while all other mutations decrease repressor binding. The increased affinity of the wild-type tet operator O2 compared to wild-type O1 results from the addition of two favorable transversions at positions +/- 9 and an unfavorable T.A to C.G transition at position -7. Deletion or palindromic doubling of the central base-pair of the O1 palindrome reveals that the wild-type spacing of both operator half sides is crucial for efficient Tet repressor binding.