Gene centres,a source for genetic variants in symbiotic nitrogen fixation: The symbiotic response of the cultivated pea toRhizobium leguminosarum strains from Europe and the Middle East

Summary Soil samples from several European countries; Sweden, the Netherlands, Spain, Italy and Greece, contained rhizobial populations capable of forming an effective symbiosis with the cultivated pea cv. Rondo from the Netherlands. The range of variation among the European Rhizobium strains, as expressed on pea cv. Rondo, was not so large and almost the same variation could be found within the rhizobial population within each country. Superior Rhizobium strains for the Dutch pea were not restricted to soils from the Netherlands but were also found in those from Sweden and Italy.Soils from Turkey and Israel also contained Rhizobium strains capable of nodulating pea cv. Rondo. However, the genetic variation among these Middle East Rhizobium strains was much larger than that of the European strains. When tested on pea cv. Rondo the majority of the Middle East strains belonged to the medium or low effective classes and only a few strains were comparable with European Rhizobium strains.Dutch Rhizobium strains induced effective nodules on both the Dutch pea cv. Rondo and the Swedish cv. L 110. However, in association with a Turkish Rhizobium strain effective nodules were formed on pea cv. Rondo and ineffective nodules on cv. L 110.We suggest that the genetic uniformity of EuropeanR. leguminosarum strains is the result of selection and domestication of Rhizobium strains originally derived from the gene centres of the pea plant.     

Some USDA studies on the soybean-Rhizobium symbiosis

Summary The ecology, strain evaluation, genetics of host strain interactions and physiology of nitrogen fixation ofRhizobium japonicum in association with the soybean,Glycine max, were studied. Results of inoculation experiments with selected strains ofRhizobium japonicum indicated that indigenous strains occupied most of the nodules of soybeans grown in highRhizobium japonicum populated soils. Nodule sampling indicated that inoculation did not result in quicker nodulation or a higher incidence of root nodules (primary or secondary) than uninoculated checks. Rhizosphere studies indicated that colonization by introduced strains did occur but did not compete successfully with field strains for nodule sites. Recovery of specific serological types from nodules was influenced by planting intervals. The distribution of the serotypes varied with the time of planting and the age of the plant. Temperature studies indicated that the distribution of serotypes recovered from the nodules was influenced by temperature. Field studies showed the selectivity of soybean genotypes on strains ofRhizobium japonicum. Some strains were more common in the nodules of some varieties than in others. Closely related varieties had similar populations in their nodules. Three genes which control nodule response in soybeans are reported. Nitrogen fixation profiles were determined for some variety-strain interactions. Combinations previously classified as inefficient showed some nitrogenase activity as measured by the acetylene reduction technique. Research Microbiologist; Research Agronomist; Research Plant Physiologist, Soybean Investigations, Crops Research Division, Beltsville, Md. (USDA, ARS); and Plant Pathologist currently located at Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan.     

Response of common bean lines to inoculation: comparison between the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rhizobium tropici</Emphasis> CIAT899 and the native <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rhizobium etli</Emphasis> 12a3 and their persistence in Tunisian soils

Since Phaseolus vulgaris (L) is poorly nodulated in all regions of Tunisia where this crop is grown, the response of common-bean lines CocoT and Flamingo to inoculation with reference Rhizobium tropici CIAT 899 or native rhizobia, namely Sinorhizobium fredii 1a6, Rhizobium etli 12a3, and Rhizobium gallicum 8a3, was studied in a field station. Since R. etli 12a3 was found to be the most effective native rhizobium, it was subsequently compared with R. tropici CIAT 899 in a broader study in two stations over 3 years. A significant interaction between bean and rhizobia was observed for nodule number, shoot dry weight, grain yield, and contents of nitrogen and chlorophyll. The native rhizobia was more efficient than CIAT899 for Flamingo, though not for CocoT. The Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay technique was used with polyclonal antibody to assess the occupancy in nodule and persistence in soil of the inoculated rhizobia. For both stations the nodule occupancy was 100% during the first year for each rhizobium, but during the next 2 years, between 7 and 15% of nodules were formed by the rhizobia inoculated in the neighboring plot. It is concluded that the first-year inoculation is sufficient to maintain an adequate rate of nodulation during three growth cycles, and that the native R etli can be recommended for the common-bean inoculation in similar soils of Tunisia.     

Effect of fungicides on survival of Rhizobium on seeds and the nodulation of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.)

The survival of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli on seeds of bean was tested, using the cultivar Carioca. The seeds were treated seven days before inoculation with Benlate, Vitavax, Banrot, Difolatan or Ridomil fungicides. The rhizobial strains used were: CIAT 899, CPAC 1135 and CIAT 652. Strain CIAT 899 showed greater survival on the seed with fungicide than the other strains. Two hours after the contact with fungicides strains CIAT 652 and CPAC 1135 had significantly lower numbers of rhizobia than the treatment without fungicide. The Benlate and Banrot fungicides had the greatest effect on survival of rhizobial strains. There was a drastic mortality of the two strains, CIAT 652 and CPAC 1135, on seeds treated with Benlate and Ridomil. Under field conditions, granular inoculation produced fewer nodules, but a similar total nodule weight as seed inoculation. Serological tests (ELISA) showed that seed treatment with Benlate in connection with seed inoculation reduced drastically the occurrence of inoculated strains in nodules, while the same fungicide treatment and inoculation applied in the seed furrow did not affect the survival of the inoculated strain.     

On the resistance of effectiveness ofRhizobium trifolii to a low pH

Summary ThreeRhizobium trifolii strains were subcultured repeatedly on agar medium of pH values ranging from 3.5 to 7.0. Growth was retarded at pH 4.5 and very poor at pH 4.0 and 3.5, although the cells were not killed at the lowest pH. After 12 subcultures during a period of 300 days on these media, the symbiotic effectiveness was estimated by inoculating aseptic seedlings of white clover in test tubes containing Jensen's agar medium at pH 6.5.The number of nodules formed on the plants and the effectiveness of some strains seemed to be affected by growing the rhizobium for a long period at a low pH. All test plants produced nodules with red pigment.     

Characteristics of rhizobia isolated from three legumes indigenous to the Canadian high arctic:Astragalus alpinus,Oxytropis maydelliana,andOxytropis arctobia

Summary Forty-eight strains of rhizobia were isolated from the root nodules ofAstragalus alpinus (21),Oxytropis maydelliana (19) andOxytropis arctobia (8), three species of arctic legumes found in the Melville Peninsula, Northwest Territories, Canada. On the basis of 74 characteristics (cultural, physiological, biochemical and host nodulation range) the 48 arctic rhizobia could be divided into 11 distinct groups by numerical analysis techniques. All 48 arctic rhizobia were able to nodulate the three arctic legume species and also sainfoin (Onobrychis viciifolia), however, milkvetch (Astragalus cicer) was only nodulated by 33 strains. In general, the arctic rhizobia showed properties found in both Rhizobium and Bradyrhizobium. The adaptation of the arctic strains to low temperature is indicated by their ability to grow in liquid culture at 5°C. Contribution no 293 of Agriculture Canada Research Station at Sainte-Foy.     

Metal resistant rhizobia and ultrastructure of Anthyllis vulneraria nodules from zinc and lead contaminated tailing in Poland

This present paper studies the response of Anthyllis vulneraria-Rhizobium symbiosis to heavy metal stress. The symbiotic rhizobium bacteria isolated from root nodules of A. vulneraria from zinc and lead wastes were examined in this project. Light microscopy (LM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) were used to analyze the nodule anatomy and ultrastructure and conduct a comparison with nonmetal-treated nodules. 16S ribosomal DNA sequence analysis of bacteria isolated from metal-treated nodules revealed the presence of Rhizobium metallidurans and Bradyrhizobium sp. In regard to heavy metal resistance/tolerance, a similar tolerance to Pb was shown by both strains, and a high tolerance to Zn and a lower tolerance to Cd and Cu by R. metallidurans, whereas a high tolerance to Cd and Cu and a lower tolerance to Zn by Bradyrhizobium were found. The nodules of Anthyllis from metal-polluted tailing sites were identified as the typical determinate type of nodules. Observed under TEM microscopy changes in nodules ultrastructure like: (1) wall thickening; (2) infection thread reduction; (3) vacuole shrinkage; (4) synthesis of phenolics in vacuoles; (5) various differentiation of bacteroids and (6) simultaneous symbiosis with arbuscular mycorrhiza fungi could be considered as a form of the A.vulneraria-Rhizobium symbiosis adaptation to metal stress.     

Identification ofRhizobium strains and evaluation of their competitiveness

Six strains ofRhizobium leguminosarum bv.viciœ, three strains ofBradyrhizobium japonicum and three strains ofRhizobium fredii were evaluated by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). The possibility of identification of individual rhizobial strains and the way of product analysis were verified. The result of amplifications proved rich spectra along the whole length scale. Numerous identical bands could be found in related strains. Verification of the expected identity of some strains confirmed the applicability of this method for identification of individual bacterial strains of generaRhizobium andBradyrhizobium. Furthermore, competitiveness of two strains ofR. leguminosarum bv.viciœ against the native rhizobial population was evaluated in a pot experiment. When using PCR as the identification method, the presence of the strains in host plant's nodules was ascertained after inoculation by different rates of inoculum strains. With increasing the inoculum rate, the presence of inoculum strains in pea nodules also increased. On the basis of mathematical models by Amarger and Lobreu the competitiveness of the mentioned strains was estimated at certain inoculum rates. Both tested strains displayed a higher competitiveness than native rhizobia in the soil used. As they are also effective N₂ fixators (one strain being HUP⁺), one may expect successful field inoculations with them.     

Discrete differences between strains of different Rhizobium spp. for competitive nodule occupancy on beans

Rhizobium etli strain TAL182 and R. leguminosarum bv phaseoli strain 8002, both of which produce melanin pigment, were tested for their nodulation competitiveness on beans by paired inoculation with two strains which do not produce melanin: R. tropici strain CIAT899 and Rhizobium sp. strain TAL1145. An assay was developed to distinguish nodules formed by the melanin-producing and non-producing strains. Strain TAL182 had discrete competitive superiority over CIAT899 and TAL1145 for nodulation of beans. Nodulation competitiveness was not correlated with the ability to produce melanin pigment or the host range of the Rhizobium strains tested.The authors are with the Department of Plant Molecular Physiology, University of Hawaii, 3050 Maile Way, Gillmore 402, Honolulu, HI 96822, USA     

Gene centres,a source for genetic variants in symbiotic nitrogen fixation: Host-induced ineffectivity inPisum sativum ecotype fulvum

Summary Pisum sativum ecotype fulvum forms ineffective nodules with Rhizobium strains, isolated from effective nodules of the cultivated pea in Europe. Rhizobium strains isolated from nodules of fulvum peas in Israel are fully effective on this host plant, but in association with the cultivated pea they induce nodules of poor N₂-fixing activity. The distribution of these fulvum-specific Rhizobium strains is restricted to regions where the fulvum pea occurs naturally. Rhizobium strains from other geographical regions induce mainly ineffective, or partially effective nodules on fulvum plants.A wide genetic variation, with regard to symbiotic response to a standard set of Rhizobium strains, was demonstrated in the fulvum plants collected in Israel. Based on variation in N₂-fixation three groups of plants can be distinguished. These plants offer the possibility for the study of host-genetic control on symbiotic nitrogen fixation.     

Ability of selected accessions of Phaseolus vulgaris L. to restrict nodulation by particular rhizobia

Plant genotypes that limit nodulation by indigenous rhizobia while nodulating normally with inoculant-strain nodule occupancy in Phaseolus vulgaris. In this study, eight of nine Rhizobium tropici strains and six of 15 Rhizobium etli strains examined, showed limited ability to nodulate and fix nitrogen with the two wild P. vulgaris genotypes G21117 and G10002, but were effective in symbiosis with the cultivated bean genotypes Jamapa and Amarillo Gigante. Five of the R. etli strains restricted in nodulation by G21117 and G10002 produced an alkaline reaction in yeast mannitol medium. In a competition experiment in which restricted strains were tested in 1:1 mixtures with the highly effective R. etli strain CIAT632, the restricted strains produced a low percentage of the nodules formed on G2117, but produced over 40% of the nodules formed on Jamapa. The interaction of the four Rhizobium strains with the two bean genotypes, based on the percentage of nodules formed, was highly significant (P<0.001).     

Symbiotic effectiveness of Rhizobium meliloti at low root temperature

Laboratory, growth chamber and field experiments were conducted to select among 226 isolates of Rhizobium meliloti for the ability to grow, nodulate alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) and support N₂-dependent plant growth between 9° and 12°C. There was wide variation in the abilities of R. meliloti isolates to grow and form nodules at 10°C. Culture doubling times (t_d) varied from 1 to 155h, and the number of nodules formed on alfalfa in growth pouches in 2 weeks varied from 0 to 3.8 nodules per plant. Nodulation occurred at 9°C, but there was no significant N₂-dependent plant growth at this temperature. However, several isolates of R. meliloti had the ability to nodulate alfalfa and produce N₂-dependent growth at root temperatures between 10° and 12°C root temperature than did 14 other isolates tested. In field experiments, inoculation with strain NRG-34 resulted in greater nodule numbers, nodule weight, proportion of nodules occupied by the inoculant strain and plant weight than did inoculation with a commercial strain (NRG-185). These results permitted selection of a strain with better low-temperature competitive abilities than the currently available commercial strains.     

<Emphasis Type="Italic">Rhizobium etli</Emphasis> maize populations and their competitiveness for root colonization

Rhizobium etli, which normally forms nitrogen-fixing nodules on Phaseolus vulgaris (common bean), is a natural maize endophyte. The genetic diversity of R. etli strains from bulk soil, bean nodules, the maize rhizosphere, the maize root, and inside stem tissue in traditional fields where maize is intercropped with P. vulgaris-beans was analyzed. Based on plasmid profiles and alloenzymes, it was determined that several R. etli types were preferentially encountered as putative maize endophytes. Some of these strains from maize were more competitive maize-root colonizers than other R. etli strains from the rhizosphere or from bean nodules. The dominant and highly competitive strain Ch24-10 was the most tolerant to 6-methoxy-2-benzoxazolinone (MBOA), a maize antimicrobial compound that is inhibitory to some bacteria and fungi. The R. tropici strain CIAT899, successfully used as inoculant of P. vulgaris, was also found to be a competitive maize endophyte in inoculation experiments.     

Effect of salinity on growth of four strains of Rhizobium and their infectivity and effectiveness on two species of Acacia

Two Rhizobium strains (WU1001 and WU1008) were isolated from nodules of Acacia redolens growing in saline areas of south-west Australia, and two strains selected from the University of Western Australia's culture collection (WU429 isolated from A. saligna and WU433 from A. cyclops). The growth of each in buffered, yeast extract mannitol broth culture was largely unaffected by salt up to 300 mM NaCl. A slight increase in lag time occurred at concentrations of 120 mM NaCl and above, but cell number at the static phase was not affected. Each of the four Rhizobium strains tested accumulated Na⁺ but showed decreasing levels of sugar with increasing salt in the external medium. Amino acid levels also increased, in some cases by more than tenfold. However, the relative proportion of each remained fairly constant in the bacteria, irrespective of salt treatment. Only trace quantities of proline were detected and there was no increase in this amino acid with salt. Acidic amino acids (glutamate and aspartate) remained as a constant proportion.Rhizobium strains WU429, WU1001 and WU1008 produced effective nodules on both A. cyclops and A. redolens grown in sand with up to 80 mM NaCl (added in nutrient solutions free of nitrogen). Strain WU433 was highly infective on both Acacia species tested at low salt concentrations (2–40 mM NaCl), but infection was sensitive to salt levels at 120 mM NaCl and above. Nodules formed with strain WU433 were, however, ineffective on both A. redolens and on A. cyclops and showed nil or negligible rates of acetylene reduction at all salt concentrations. Strains WU429, WU1001 and WU1008 in combination with a highly salt-tolerant provenance of A. redolens formed symbioses which did not vary significantly in nodule number and mass, specific nodule activity or total N content irrespective of salt level up to 160 mM NaCl. On a more salt sensitive provenance of A. redolens and on A. cyclops the infectivity and effectivity of the Rhizobium strains tested usually decreased as the external salt concentration increased. These data are interpreted to indicate that tolerance of the legume host was the most important factor determining the success of compatible Rhizobium strains in forming effective symbioses under conditions of high soil salinity.     

Competition for Astragalus sinicus root nodule infection between its native microsymbiont Rhizobium huakuii bv. renge B3 and Rhizobium sp. ACMP18 strain, specific for Astragalus cicer

Rhizobium huakuii bv. renge B3, a native symbiont of Astragalus sinicus, outcompeted Rhizobium sp. strain ACMP18, which was isolated from Astragalus cicer nodules, in the formation of root nodules on A.␣sinicus when plants were co-inoculated with these strains. The strains occupying the nodules were identified by antibiotic resistance and phage sensitivity markers and also by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) genomic fingerprintings, which were performed by using enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus sequences. In PCR genomic fingerprintings, the total genomic DNA isolated from pure bacterial culture and from squashed root nodules showed identical profiles, indicating that this technique can be a useful tool for identification of rhizobia in ecological studies. When Rhizobium sp. strain ACMP18 outnumbered R. huakuii bv. renge strain B3 by a factor of ten, and even when strain ACMP18 was added to plants 1 week before bacterization with strain B3, the strain B3 occupied most nodules. Dually infected nodules were not observed, although Rhizobium sp. ACMP18 formed active nodules on A. sinicus when the bacterial strain was inoculated alone. Received: 5 February 1998 / Received revision: 23 March 1998 / Accepted: 27 April 1998     

STUDIES ON INDUCED VARIATION IN THE RHIZOBIA. III. HOST RANGE MODIFICATION OF RHIZOBIUM TRIFOLII BY SPONTANEOUS AND RADIATION-INDUCED MUTATION

Schwinghamer , E. A. (Brookhaven Natl. Lab., Upton, New York.) Studies on induced variation in the rhizobia. III. Host range modification of Rhizobium trifolii by spontaneous and radiation-induced mutation. Amer. Jour. Bot. 49(3): 269–277. Illus. 1962.—Mutant strains capable of nodulating pea seedings ineffectively (incapable of nitrogen fixation) have been obtained from 2 antibiotic-resistant marked strains of Rhizobium trifolii which normally do not form nodules on this host. Such variant forms apparently occur spontaneously in these strains at a low frequency which can be significantly increased by irradiation with ultraviolet light, X rays, and fast neutrons. Nodulation of vetch, sweet peas and several varieties of peas by the mutant strains suggests a close parallelism of the extended host range with the range of R. leguminosarum, although nitrogen fixation by the mutants on the new hosts is negligible or absent. The mutant nodules on these hosts also differ from those of the pea strains in slightly smaller size, spherical form, and lighter pink color. Nodule morphology on the homologous host, clover. appears unaltered but a slight loss of effectiveness was noted on red clover. This loss may be attributed partly to a reduction in infective ability since the average number of nodules formed per plant of clover or pea is appreciably lower than for comparable inoculation by strains of nonmutant R. trifolii or R. leguminosarum, respectively. Cultural characteristics of mutant strains resemble those of the nonmutant R. trifolii strains.     

Assessment of faba bean (Vicia faba) response to inoculation with Rhizobium leguminosarum in clay loam Nile Delta soil

A field experiment was conducted to assess the response to inoculation with rhizobia in a clay loam soil of the Nile Delta using faba bean (Vicia faba) for two successive winter seasons (1985/6 and 1986/7). Three selected strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum, TAL 634, NRC 65 and TAL 1400, were used singly or in combination as peat-based inocula in 1985/6 winter season. Strain TAL 1400 was replaced by strain F9 in the 1986/7 winter season. A significant seed yield response was obtained only with strain TAL 1400, in the 1985/6 season. In the 1986/7 season, no significant yield response was observed with any of the strains. The serotyping of nodules collected in the 1985/6 season showed that strain TAL 1400 was more competitive than either the indigenous rhizobia or the two inoculant strains. However, the majority of nodules formed in the 1986/7 season were formed from strains other than the inoculant ones.     

Phage sensitivity and host range of Rhizobium strains isolated from root nodules of temperate legumes

Twenty-five Rhizobium strains were isolated from root nodules of Astragalus spp. (10), Hedysarum alpinum (7), Glycyrrhiza pallidiflora (3) and Ononis arvensis (5). The sensitivity of these strains to bacteriophages of Rhizobium loti, R. meliloti, R. galegae and R. leguminosarum was studied. Phages specific to R. loti strains were shown to induce the phage lysis of several Astragalus, Hedysarum and Ononis rhizobia. Ten R. loti strains tested for nodulation abilities on the plant hosts under investigation were able to develop nitrogen-fixing nodules on the Ononis arvensis roots. On the other hand, rhizobia from Ononis and Glycyrrhiza could form an effective symbiosis with Lotus corniculatus plants, so these bacteria are considered to belong to the Rhizobium loti taxon. Bacterial strains isolated from Astragalus and Hedysarum were observed to cross-nodulate their plant hosts as well as Oxytropis campestris, Glycyrrhiza uralensis and Ononis arvensis plants, whereas they could not nodulate Lotus plants. It is concluded that these Rhizobium strains comprise a cross-inoculation group related to Rhizobium loti. ei]{gnR O D}{fnDixon}     

Determination of the Hydrogenase Status of Individual Legume Nodules by a Methylene Blue Reduction Assay

We adapted a method for the rapid screening of colonies of free-living Rhizobium japonicum for hydrogenase activity to determine the hydrogenase status of individual soybean nodules. Crude bacteroid suspensions from nodules containing strains known to be hydrogen uptake positive (Hup⁺) caused a localized decolorization of filter paper disks, whereas suspensions from nodules arising from inoculation with hydrogen uptake-negative (Hup⁻) mutants or strains did not decolorize the disks. The reliability of the method was demonstrated by its successful application to 29 slow-growing rhizobia. The Hup phenotype on methylene blue filters agreed with that determined amperometrically with either methylene blue or oxygen as the electron acceptor.