Fungal and Bacterial Colonization of Submerged Leaf Litter in a Mediterranean Stream

Microbial colonization dynamics of fungi and bacteria were analyzed in an intermittent Mediterranean forested stream using two different leaf substrata (Platanus acerifolia and Populus nigra). Results showed that fungal and bacterial biomass accumulation was stimulated on both leaves due to a flooding episode that increased dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) and dissolved oxygen (DO) availability in the stream water. Leaf mass loss coincided with the parallel increase in microbial biomass and extracellular enzymatic activities after the flood event. Differences in litter quality favoured bacterial biomass accumulation and β‐glucosidase and cellobiohydrolase enzymatic activities in the soft Populus species. Microbial heterotrophs colonization of submerged leaf litter and organic matter use in Mediterranean‐type streams are modulated by environmental conditions, especially the hydrological variability. (© 2011 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)     

Palatability of Leaves Conditioned in Streams Affected by Mine Drainage: A Feeding Experiment with Gammarus Pulex (L.)

Both the absence of leaf shredding macroinvertebrates and low microbial activity are of major importance in determining slow and incomplete leaf decay in extremely acidic (pH<3.5) mining streams. These streams are affected by a heavy ochre deposition causing the formation of massive iron plaques on leaf surfaces that hinder microbial exploitation. An investigation was carried out to determine whether iron plaques and leaf conditioning status (acid conditioned with and without iron plaques, neutral conditioned, unconditioned) affect the feeding preference of the shredder Gammarus pulex (L.). Leaf respiration rates and fungal biomass (ergosterol contents) were measured to determine microbial colonization. Neutral conditioned leaves had significantly higher microbial colonization than acid conditioned leaves with iron plaques. Notwithstanding, leaves of both conditioning types were consumed at high rates by G. pulex. The microbial colonization had no influence on feeding preference in the experiment. It is presumed that iron adsorbed organic material caused the high palatability of leaves with iron plaques. The results indicate that the large deposits of leaves coated with iron plaques will be available to the stream food web when water quality will be restored to neutral as planed in scenarios for the future development of mining streams.     

Leaf breakdown in streams differing in catchment land use

1. The impact of changes in land use on stream ecosystem function is poorly understood. We studied leaf breakdown, a fundamental process of stream ecosystems, in streams that represent a range of catchment land use in the Piedmont physiographic province of the south‐eastern United States. 2. We placed bags of chalk maple (Acer barbatum) leaves in similar‐sized streams in 12 catchments of differing dominant land use: four forested, three agricultural, two suburban and three urban catchments. We measured leaf mass, invertebrate abundance and fungal biomass in leaf bags over time. 3. Leaves decayed significantly faster in agricultural (0.0465 day^?1) and urban (0.0474 day^?1) streams than in suburban (0.0173 day^?1) and forested (0.0100 day^?1) streams. Additionally, breakdown rates in the agricultural and urban streams were among the fastest reported for deciduous leaves in any stream. Nutrient concentrations in agricultural streams were significantly higher than in any other land‐use type. Fungal biomass associated with leaves was significantly lower in urban streams; while shredder abundance in leaf bags was significantly higher in forested and agricultural streams than in suburban and urban streams. Storm runoff was significantly higher in urban and suburban catchments that had higher impervious surface cover than forested or agricultural catchments. 4. We propose that processes accelerating leaf breakdown in agricultural and urban streams were not the same: faster breakdown in agricultural streams was due to increased biological activity as a result of nutrient enrichment, whereas faster breakdown in urban streams was a result of physical fragmentation resulting from higher storm runoff.     

Effect of sudden flow reduction on the decomposition of alder leaves (Alnus glutinosa [L.] Gaertn.) in a temperate lowland stream: a mesocosm study

Climate change leads to summer low flow conditions and premature litter input in lowland streams in Central Europe. This may cause a sudden reduction of flow and fragmentation into isolated pools of permanently flowing streams, with a simultaneous increase in the food supply for detrivores during summer months. We performed a mesocosm study to investigate shredder and microbial mediated litter decomposition under these conditions. Leaf litter was placed in a lowland stream with a natural flow regime (reference) and in a stream mesocosm with significant flow reduction (FR) and a representative density of macroinvertebrates and detritus. Physicochemical parameters, leaf mass loss, macroinvertebrate abundance and biomass, leaf-associated respiration, fungal sporulation, and biomass were measured at regular intervals for 6 weeks. Coarse and fine-mesh bags were used to include or exclude macroinvertebrate shredders. In the coarse-mesh bags, leaf mass loss was significantly lower in the FR system than in the reference regime. In the fine-mesh bags, leaf respiration, fungal sporulation, and biomass but not leaf mass losses were substantially lower with flow reduction. Chironomid larvae (Micropsectra spp.) appeared to effectively fragment leaf litter in fine-mesh bags. In the FR system, leaf respiration was higher in the coarse-than in the fine-mesh bags. Our results suggest that, in temperate lowland streams, premature litter input during or after a sudden fragmentation into isolated pools and a reduction of stream flow reduces direct shredder-mediated litter decomposition, but shredders may indirectly influence the decomposition process. Handling editor: B. Oertli     

Breakdown and detritivore colonisation of leaves in three New Zealand streams

Breakdown of leaves from three native riparian tree species, and their colonisation by shredding and collecting insect larvae, were investigated in three streams on Banks Peninsula, New Zealand. Leaves were introduced in baskets at the time of leaf fall. Breakdown rates of leaves were faster than previously recorded in New Zealand streams and were comparable to those of many northern hemisphere deciduous species. Shredder and total detritivore densities and biomass in leaf baskets were also greater than previously found in New Zealand streams. Peaks of shredder biomass on red beech and mahoe leaves were found when only about 20% of leaf biomass remained. No shredder peak was recorded on fuchsia leaves, and no collector peaks occurred in any of the streams. Relative shredder and collector biomass (per g DW leaf) in leaf baskets did not exceed or was smaller than in leaf litter accumulations of mixed origin and conditioning throughout the streams during leaf breakdown although absolute shredder and collector biomass (per m² stream bottom) was occasionally larger in baskets than in the rest of the stream. These findings support contentions that spatial and temporal relationships between detrital inputs and detritivore biomass and life histories are weak in New Zealand streams.     

Riparian plant species loss alters trophic dynamics in detritus-based stream ecosystems

Riparian vegetation is closely connected to stream food webs through input of leaf detritus as a primary energy supply, and therefore, any alteration of plant diversity may influence aquatic ecosystem functioning. We measured leaf litter breakdown rate and associated biological parameters in mesh bags in eight headwater streams bordered either with mixed deciduous forest or with beech forest. The variety of leaf litter types in mixed forest results in higher food quality for large-particle invertebrate detritivores (‘shredders’) than in beech forest, which is dominated by a single leaf species of low quality. Breakdown rate of low quality (oak) leaf litter in coarse mesh bags was lower in beech forest streams than in mixed forest streams, a consequence of lower shredder biomass. In contrast, high quality (alder) leaf litter broke down at similar rates in both stream categories as a result of similar shredder biomass in coarse mesh bags. Microbial breakdown rate of oak and alder leaves, determined in fine mesh bags, did not differ between the stream categories. We found however aquatic hyphomycete species richness on leaf litter to positively co-vary with riparian plant species richness. Fungal species richness may enhance leaf litter breakdown rate through positive effects on resource quality for shredders. A feeding experiment established a positive relationship between fungal species richness per se and leaf litter consumption rate by an amphipod shredder (Gammarus fossarum). Our results show therefore that plant species richness may indirectly govern ecosystem functioning through complex trophic interactions. Integrating microbial diversity and trophic dynamics would considerably improve the prediction of the consequences of species loss.     

Macroconsumer effects on insect detritivores and detritus processing in a tropical stream

1. Few studies have assessed the effects of macroconsumers, such as fishes and shrimps, on detritus and detritivores.
2. We used an underwater electric field to prevent macroconsumers from feeding in and on leaf packs in a lowland stream in Costa Rica and thus to determine their effects on the density of insect detritivores and decay rates of leaves.
3. Exclusion of macroconsumers resulted in significantly higher densities of small invertebrates inhabiting leaf packs. Most of these were collector–gatherers, none were shredders.
4. Despite the increase in invertebrate density, decay rates of leaves were not statistically different. These findings contrast with results from temperate streams showing that increases in the density of invertebrates in leaf packs typically result in an increased rate of decay.
5. Leaf decay rates and invertebrate densities were also compared between leaf packs placed in electric exclusion treatments and those placed in coarse (2 cm) plastic net bags (as used in many previous studies). Our results suggest that using such netting in tropical streams may deter macroconsumers, which can affect insect density and, potentially, decay rates of organic matter.     

Leaf litter breakdown, microbial respiration and shredder production in metal-polluted streams

1. If species disproportionately influence ecosystem functioning and also differ in their sensitivities to environmental conditions, the selective removal of species by anthropogenic stressors may lead to strong effects on ecosystem processes. We evaluated whether these circumstances held for several Colorado, U.S.A. streams stressed by Zn. 2. Benthic invertebrates and chemistry were sampled in five second–third order streams for 1 year. Study streams differed in dissolved metal concentrations, but were otherwise similar in chemical and physical characteristics. Secondary production of leaf‐shredding insects was estimated using the increment summation and size‐frequency methods. Leaf litter breakdown rates were estimated by retrieving litter‐bags over a 171 day period. Microbial activity on leaf litter was measured in the laboratory using changes in oxygen concentration over a 48 h incubation period. 3. Dissolved Zn concentrations varied eightfold among two reference and three polluted streams. Total secondary production of shredders was negatively associated with metal contamination. Secondary production in reference streams was dominated by Taenionema pallidum. Results of previous studies and the current investigation demonstrate that this shredder is highly sensitive to metals in Colorado headwater streams. Leaf litter breakdown rates were similar between reference streams and declined significantly in the polluted streams. Microbial respiration at the most contaminated site was significantly lower than at reference sites. 4. Our results supported the hypothesis that some shredder species contribute disproportionately to leaf litter breakdown. Furthermore, the functionally dominant taxon was also the most sensitive to metal contamination. We conclude that leaf litter breakdown in our study streams lacked functional redundancy and was therefore highly sensitive to contaminant‐induced alterations in community structure. We argue for the necessity of simultaneously measuring community structure and ecosystem function in anthropogenically stressed ecosystems.     

Decomposition of Fire Exposed Eucalyptus Leaves in a Portuguese Lowland Stream

We compared fire exposed with normal abscised eucalyptus leaves incubated in a stream running through eucalyptus plantations in central Portugal, in terms of breakdown rates, microbial activity, diversity and macroinvertebrate abundance. Although leaves exposed to fire had lower nutritional value, mass loss was similar for both leaf types (k = 0.0089–0.0095 d^–1 for fire and k = 0.0084–0.00103 d^–1 for normal leaves). Fungal biomass was similar among treatments, whereas sporulation and microbial respiration were lower in fire exposed leaves. Both leaf types had similar aquatic hyphomycetes communities. Physical fragmentation was important in fire exposed leaves breakdown. Invertebrates colonized leaves in low numbers in both treatments. Alteration of leaf litter quality determined by fires in streams does not seem to determine changes in ecosystem functioning in a short term. (© 2007 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)     

Aggregation among resource patches can promote coexistence in stream-living shredders

1. We conducted a new single‐site study and a meta‐analysis of pre‐existing studies from multiple streams to assess whether intraspecific aggregation among leaf packs promotes coexistence among leaf‐eating invertebrates (shredders) in Swedish streams. 2. In the single‐site study, 48 standardised leaf bags were exposed for 1 month for shredder colonisation in a homogeneous glide of a forested stream. Current velocity, water depth and substratum composition were additionally assessed to investigate how these factors affected shredder distributions. 3. The meta‐analysis included information on shredder colonisation of leaf packs from seven other studies of detritus decomposition to assess patterns of aggregation. Intra‐ and interspecific aggregation and their relative strength were assessed using indices (J, C and A respectively) originally developed for terrestrial insects also dependent on patchy and ephemeral resources. 4. In both parts of the study, intraspecific aggregation was much stronger than interspecific aggregation, which was weak overall, indicating that the conditions under which aggregation is expected to facilitate coexistence were fulfilled in our shredder assemblages. 5. In the single‐site study, shredder abundances were weakly associated with environmental variables suggesting that habitat heterogeneity only partly explains aggregation patterns. 6. Our results strongly suggest that shredder diversity in streams, particularly during periods of leaf limitation (such as might occur in spring), is promoted by the aggregation of individual species among patches of resource.     

Effects of stream phosphorus levels on microbial respiration

SUMMARY 1. We examined microbial respiration among streams in lowland Costa Rica comprising a natural phosphorus gradient (5–350 μg SRP L^?1) resulting from variable inputs of solute‐rich (e.g. P, SO₄ and Cl) groundwater. 2. Microbial respiration rates were determined by measuring oxygen change in situ in nine low‐order streams on three substrate types: mixed leaves collected from the stream bottom, conditioned Ficus leaves and sediments. 3. Respiration rates on both leaf types were positively related to phosphorus and negatively related to N : P ratios. Microbial respiration rates on sediments were not related to any of the variables [i.e. soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP), N‐NO₃ and N : P] measured. 4. Respiration rates on newly colonised Ficus leaves formed an asymptotic curve increasing to a plateau, suggesting that saturation with phosphorus occurred at concentrations <15 μg SRP L^?1. 5. To test the hypothesis that phosphorus was the main solute in solute‐rich water that was driving observed differences in microbial respiration rates, we artificially enriched a small stream with phosphorus and measured changes in respiration before and after enrichment. 6. Experimental phosphorus enrichment produced increases in respiration rates similar in magnitude to those observed in the nine streams forming the natural phosphorus gradient, supporting our hypothesis that phosphorus was the major variable driving interstream differences in microbial respiration rates. Respiration rates were higher in this study than those reported for most other tropical streams and rivers with the exception of those reported for tropical Asian streams. 7. Results indicate that variations in phosphorus concentrations can potentially affect patterns of microbial respiration rates at a landscape level via differential inputs of solute‐rich groundwater into streams.     

Detrital processing in streams exposed to acidic precipitation in the Central Appalachian Mountains

Continuing high rates of acidic deposition in the eastern United States may lead to long-term effects on stream communities, because sensitive catchments are continuing to lose anions and cations. We conducted a two-year study of the effects of pH and associated water chemistry variables on detrital processing in three streams with different bedrock geology in the Monongahela National Forest, West Virginia. We compared leaf pack processing rates and macroinvertebrate colonization and microbial biomass (ATP concentration) on the packs in the three streams. Breakdown rates of red maple and white oak leaf packs were significantly lower in the most acidic stream. The acidic stream also had significantly lower microbial and shredder biomass than two more circumneutral streams. Shredder composition differed among streams; large-particle detritivores dominated the shredder assemblages of the two circumneutral streams, and smaller shredders dominated in the acidic stream. Within streams, processing rates for three leaf species were not significantly different between the two years of the study even though invertebrate and microbial communities were different in the two years. Thus, macroinvertebrate and microbial communities differed both among streams that differed in their capacity to buffer the effects of acidic precipitation and among years in the same stream; these differences in biotic communities were not large enough to affect rates of leaf processing between the two years of the study, but they did significantly affect processing rates between acidic and circumneutral streams.The Unit is jointly sponsored by the National Biological Service, the West Virginian Division of Natural Resources, West Virginia University, and the Wildlife Management Institute.The Unit is jointly sponsored by the National Biological Service, the West Virginian Division of Natural Resources, West Virginia University, and the Wildlife Management Institute.     

Comparison of leaf processing rates under different temperature regimes in three headwater streams

1. We studied the effects of different temperature regimes on leaf litter processing in three forested Appalachian headwater streams of different pH (mean pH = 4.2, 6.5, 7.5).
2. We compared leaf breakdown rates, microbial biomass and macroinvertebrate shredder density and biomass between two 12-week processing periods (October–January and November–February) in each stream. Leaf processing rates were calculated both as k (day^–1) and k _d (degree day^–1).
3. There were no significant differences in processing rates ( k day^–1) between the two study periods for any leaf species in any stream. The average difference in temperature between the two study periods was 175 degree days. Shredder density was significantly higher during the earlier study period on 40% of the sample dates, but shredder biomass was not significantly different between the two study periods. ATP concentration was significantly higher during the early study period for 60% of the sample dates.
4. More significant differences in these variables (shredder density and biomass, ATP concentration) were seen among the three study streams than between the two study periods. This indicates that in this study other factors, particularly stream pH, contributed more to processing rate variation than did differences in thermal regime.     

Litter decomposition in a temperate and a tropical stream: the effects of species mixing,litter quality and shredders

相似文献   

Comparison of leaf processing rates under different temperature regimes in three headwater streams

1. We studied the effects of different temperature regimes on leaf litter processing in three forested Appalachian headwater streams of different pH (mean pH = 4.2, 6.5, 7.5).
2. We compared leaf breakdown rates, microbial biomass and macroinvertebrate shredder density and biomass between two 12-week processing periods (October–January and November–February) in each stream. Leaf processing rates were calculated both as k (day^–1) and k _d (degree day^–1).
3. There were no significant differences in processing rates ( k day^–1) between the two study periods for any leaf species in any stream. The average difference in temperature between the two study periods was 175 degree days. Shredder density was significantly higher during the earlier study period on 40% of the sample dates, but shredder biomass was not significantly different between the two study periods. ATP concentration was significantly higher during the early study period for 60% of the sample dates.
4. More significant differences in these variables (shredder density and biomass, ATP concentration) were seen among the three study streams than between the two study periods. This indicates that in this study other factors, particularly stream pH, contributed more to processing rate variation than did differences in thermal regime.     

Understanding of colonization and breakdown of leaves by invertebrates in a tropical stream is enhanced by using biomass as well as count data

We hypothesized that (i) the importance of shredders for leaf breakdown is more evident in terms of their biomass than their abundance, due to the large bodies and high-feeding efficiencies of some typical shredders; (ii) non-shredder invertebrates select more refractory leaves because these are a more stable substrate for colonization or to obtain other forms of food. To test these hypotheses, we performed a decomposition experiment with leaves of contrasting chemical composition in a tropical stream, and determined the changes in the ash-free dry mass (AFDM) of the litter, and the invertebrate abundance and biomass during a 44-day period. The biomass of shredders showed a positive relationship with AFDM remaining, whereas their abundance was unrelated to AFDM. While shredder abundance represented only 4–12% of total invertebrate abundance, shredder biomass constituted 19–36% of total invertebrate biomass. We conclude that (i) shredder biomass expresses better than abundance the role of this guild in the decomposition of leaf detritus, demonstrating that they are important for the functioning of tropical streams; (ii) incubation time rather than stability of leaf litter as a substrate influences colonization by non-shredder invertebrates.     

The importance of crayfish in the breakdown of rhododendron leaf litter

1. Rhododendron (Rhododendron maximum) is a common evergreen shrub in riparian areas of the southern Appalachians, where its leaves can comprise a large proportion of leaf litter in streams. However, they are relatively refractory and generally considered a low quality food resource for detritivores. 2. Our objective was to assess whether macroconsumers [primarily crayfish (Cambarus bartonii)] influence rhododendron leaf breakdown in a forested southern Appalachian stream in both summer (when leaves other than rhododendron are relatively scarce) and autumn (when other leaves are relatively abundant). We conducted two leaf decay experiments, one in summer and one in autumn, using pre‐conditioned leaves. Macroconsumers were excluded from the benthos of a fourth‐order stream using electric ‘fences’; we predicted that excluding macroconsumers would reduce the decay rate of rhododendron leaves in both summer and autumn. 3. In both experiments, breakdown rate was lower in exclusion treatments. Macroconsumers accounted for approximately 33 and 54% of rhododendron decay in summer and autumn, respectively. We attribute this effect to direct shredding of rhododendron by crayfish. Biomass of insect shredders, insect predators and fungi did not differ between control and exclusion treatments, indicating that insectivorous sculpins (Cottus bairdi) had no effect on rhododendron decay and that omnivorous crayfish did not exert an indirect effect via alteration of insect or fungal biomass. 4. The influence of shredding insects varied between summer and autumn. In summer, when other, more palatable leaf types were not available, rhododendron leaf packs appeared to provide ‘resource islands’ for insect shredders. There was a significant inverse relationship between insect shredders and leaf pack mass in the summer exclusion treatment: insects were the only organisms eating leaves in this treatment and, as shredder biomass increased, remaining leaf pack mass decreased. In the control treatment, however, we did not see this relationship; here, the effect of insect shredders was presumably swamped by the impact of crayfish. In autumn, when other leaves were abundant, insect shredder biomass in rhododendron leaf packs was less than one‐third of summer values. 5. Even at low density (approximately 2 m^–2) crayfish were able to influence an ecosystem process such as leaf decay in both summer and autumn. Given the threatened status of many crayfish species in the United States, this finding is especially relevant. Even small alterations in crayfish assemblages, whether via loss of native species and/or introduction of exotic species, may have significant repercussions for ecosystem function.     

Impact of highway construction on leaf processing in aquatic habitats of eastern Tennessee

Rates of leaf litter processing at eight sites were used in conjunction with other methods to evaluate the impact of highway construction on aquatic habitats. Monthly processing of white oak leaves from four different mesh size bags at unimpacted reference sites indicated that the three larger mesh sizes were useful for comparing sites, as they did not restrict invertebrate colonization and provided similar rates of processing within sites. Small mesh size (0.12 mm) prevented leaf shredding macroinvertebrates from colonizing bags, and caused significantly slower leaf processing in a riffle.Leaf processing was fastest in a reference riffle above an area of highway construction but was significantly slower in the reference pool due to low current velocity and the absence of shredders. Leaf processing in a riffle below the highway was slower than the reference riffle, and the number of shredders was reduced. Removal of streamside vegetation during highway construction caused increased stream temperatures and reduced the amount of natural leaf accumulations, thereby reducing shredder habitat. At other sites highway construction caused less of an impact than preexisting environmental influences. Leaf processing in an riffle of a lower pH stream was significantly slower than in the reference riffle. Shredders were absent from the low pH stream, and rates of leaf processing in the acid impacted riffle and pool were similar to those of the reference pool. Comparisons of the low pH stream with the reference stream indicated that physical processes were less important than biological processes of leaf decay. Leaf processing in ponds was similar to that of stream pools. Processing was faster in a small versus large pond, and a high density of invertebrates was associated with leaf bags in the small pond after one year.     

Leaf litter breakdown rates in boreal streams: does shredder species richness matter?

1. Leaf litter breakdown rates were assessed in 23 boreal streams of varying size (first–seventh order) in central and northern Sweden. 2. Shredders were most abundant in small streams, while shredder species richness showed a hump-shaped relationship with stream order, with most species in fourth order streams. 3. In a partial least-squares regression analysis, year, water temperature, shredder species richness and shredder abundance were those factors correlating most strongly with leaf breakdown rates. Shredder species richness was more strongly correlated with leaf litter breakdown rates than shredder abundance, and shredder biomass showed no such correlation. 4. These data suggest that shredder species richness is an important variable in terms of leaf litter dynamics in streams.     

Leaf‐litter colonisation and breakdown in relation to stream typology: insights from Mediterranean low‐order streams

1. Scant information is available on leaf breakdown in streams of arid and semiarid regions, including the Mediterranean, where environmental heterogeneity can be high and the relationship between stream characteristics and leaf breakdown is poorly known. We tested the hypotheses that differences in leaf breakdown metrics would be substantially higher between mountain and lowland Mediterranean streams than among streams within each subregion and that variability among streams would be substantially higher in the lowlands, because permanent reaches in the semiarid lowland streams are rare and isolated. 2. We compared leaf breakdown and associated dynamics of nutrients, fungi and invertebrates in low‐order Mediterranean streams draining sub‐humid forests in the Sierra Nevada Mountains and nearby semiarid lowlands of south‐eastern Spain. Streams differed between the two subregions mainly in water ion content, temperature and riparian tree cover. We detected higher environmental heterogeneity among streams within the lowlands compared to the Sierra Nevada mountain range. In the lowlands, breakdown coefficients (k) of alder leaves spanned almost the entire range reported for this species from temperate streams, overlapping with less variable breakdown coefficients in the Sierra Nevada. 3. The high variability of k values among the lowland sites appeared to be caused primarily by variability in the composition and abundance of a few leaf‐consuming invertebrate taxa, particularly the snail Melanopsis praemorsa. Fungal and nutrient dynamics were less variable among sites within each subregion. 4. These results indicate that the critical condition for stream functional assessment of well‐constrained breakdown rates, or related metrics, could be met at reference sites within homogenous bio‐geo‐climatic regions such as the Sierra Nevada. By contrast, in heterogeneous areas such as the semiarid lowland streams, natural variability of breakdown rates can greatly exceed the magnitude of effects expected in response to anthropogenic disturbances.