Autophagy Modulates Articular Cartilage Vesicle Formation in Primary Articular Chondrocytes

Chondrocyte-derived extracellular organelles known as articular cartilage vesicles (ACVs) participate in non-classical protein secretion, intercellular communication, and pathologic calcification. Factors affecting ACV formation and release remain poorly characterized; although in some cell types, the generation of extracellular vesicles is associated with up-regulation of autophagy. We sought to determine the role of autophagy in ACV production by primary articular chondrocytes. Using an innovative dynamic model with a light scatter nanoparticle counting apparatus, we determined the effects of autophagy modulators on ACV number and content in conditioned medium from normal adult porcine and human osteoarthritic chondrocytes. Healthy articular chondrocytes release ACVs into conditioned medium and show significant levels of ongoing autophagy. Rapamycin, which promotes autophagy, increased ACV numbers in a dose- and time-dependent manner associated with increased levels of autophagy markers and autophagosome formation. These effects were suppressed by pharmacologic autophagy inhibitors and short interfering RNA for ATG5. Caspase-3 inhibition and a Rho/ROCK inhibitor prevented rapamycin-induced increases in ACV number. Osteoarthritic chondrocytes, which are deficient in autophagy, did not increase ACV number in response to rapamycin. SMER28, which induces autophagy via an mTOR-independent mechanism, also increased ACV number. ACVs induced under all conditions had similar ecto-enzyme specific activities and types of RNA, and all ACVs contained LC3, an autophagosome-resident protein. These findings identify autophagy as a critical participant in ACV formation, and augment our understanding of ACVs in cartilage disease and repair.     

The occurrence of hydroxyapatite crystals in extracellular matrix vesicles after surgical manipulation of the rabbit knee joint

Summary Free autologous grafts of synovial tissue were transplanted into experimental defects produced in the articular cartilage of rabbit knee joints. The grafted tissue underwent transformation into fibrocartilage. Extracellular matrix vesicles associated with calcified areas were present at the grafted sites. Hydroxyapatite crystals were found within these vesicles and in their vicinity. No calcification occurred in articular cartilage from sham operated joints in which defects were produced but no grafts made and in normal controls. These tissues showed abundant matrix vesicles devoid of crystalline mineral. A careful study of normal synovial tissue did not reveal matrix vesicles and calcifications. The present observations suggest that matrix vesicles in normal articular cartilage exist in a latent form. Vesicle mineralization following surgical manipulations of the joint is probably a manifestation of the metabolic stage of the tissue.     

Antioxidant additives reduce reactive oxygen species production in articular cartilage during exposure to cryoprotective agents

High concentrations of cryoprotective agents (CPA) are required during articular cartilage cryopreservation but these CPAs can be toxic to chondrocytes. Reactive oxygen species have been linked to cell death due to oxidative stress. Addition of antioxidants has shown beneficial effects on chondrocyte survival and functions after cryopreservation. The objectives of this study were to investigate (1) oxidative stress experienced by chondrocytes and (2) the effect of antioxidants on cellular reactive oxygen species production during articular cartilage exposure to high concentrations of CPAs. Porcine cartilage dowels were exposed to a multi-CPA solution supplemented with either 0.1 mg/mL chondroitin sulfate or 2000 μM ascorbic acid, at 4 °C for 180 min (N = 7). Reactive oxygen species production was measured with 5 μM dihydroethidium, a fluorescent probe that targets reactive oxygen species. The cell viability was quantified with a dual cell membrane integrity stain containing 6.25 μM Syto 13 + 9 μM propidium iodide using confocal microscopy. Supplementation of CPA solutions with chondroitin sulfate or ascorbic acid resulted in significantly lower dihydroethidium counts (p < 0.01), and a lower decrease in the percentage of viable cells (p < 0.01) compared to the CPA-treated group without additives. These results indicated that reactive oxygen species production is induced when articular cartilage is exposed to high CPA concentrations, and correlated with the amount of dead cells. Both chondroitin sulfate and ascorbic acid treatments significantly reduced reactive oxygen species production and improved chondrocyte viability when articular cartilage was exposed to high concentrations of CPAs.     

In vitro formation of mineralized cartilagenous tissue by articular chondrocytes

Summary Study of the deep articular cartilage and adjacent calcified cartilage has been limited by the lack of an in vitro culture system which mimics this region of the cartilage. In this paper we describe a method to generate mineralized cartilagenous tissue in culture using chondrocytes obtained from the deep zone of bovine articular cartilage. The cells were plated on Millipore CM^R filters. The chondrocytes in culture accumulated extracellular matrix and formed cartilagenous tissue which calcified when β-glycerophosphate was added to the culture medium. The cartilagenous tissue generated in vitro contains both type II and type X collagens, large sulfated proteoglycans, and alkaline phosphatase activity. Ultrastructurally, matrix vesicles were seen in the extracellular matrix. Selected area electron diffraction confirmed that the calcification was composed of hydroxyapatite crystals. The chondrocytes, as characterized thus far, appear to maintain their phenotype under these culture conditions which suggests that these cultures could be used as a model to examine the metabolism of cells from the deep zone of cartilage and mineralization of cartilagenous tissue in culture.     

Long noncoding RNA MALAT-1 inhibits apoptosis and matrix metabolism disorder in interleukin-1β-induced inflammation in articular chondrocytes via the JNK signaling pathway

Proinflammatory cytokine such as interleukin (IL)-1β causes inflammation of articular cartilage. In this current study, we explored the chondroprotective effects of long noncoding RNA (lncRNA) MALAT-1 on cell proliferation, apoptosis, and matrix metabolism in IL-1β-induced inflammation in articular chondrocytes. Articular chondrocytes from knee joints of normal rats were isolated and cultured, followed by identification through observation of toluidine blue and COL II immunocytochemical stainings. The proliferation of chondrocytes at passage 2 was detected by the 3-(4,5-dimethyl-2-thiazolyl)-2,5-diphenyl-2H-tetrazolium bromide (MTT) assay. The inflammatory chondrocytes induced by 10 ng/mL IL-1β were observed and identified by toluidine blue and COL II immunocytochemical stainings. pcDNA 3.1 and pcDNA-MALAT-1 were transfected in the chondrocytes. Ultrastructure of chondrocytes was observed by using a transmission electron microscope. The MTT assay was carried out to evaluate chondrocyte viability. Hoechst 33258 staining and flow cytometry were adopted to assess chondrocyte apoptosis. The chondrocytes at passage 2 with the biological characteristics of chondrocytes were used for subsequent experiments. In IL-1β-treated chondrocytes, the growth rate of chondrocytes slowed down, the cells became narrow and long, the vacuoles were seen in the cells, and the morphology of the chondrocytes was irregular. The toluidine blue staining and the immunohistochemical staining of COL II became weaker. In response to IL-1β induction, articular chondrocytes showed reduced MALAT-1 expression; moreover, obvious cartilage injury was observed with decreased chondrocyte viability and Col II expression and elevated chondrocyte apoptosis, MMP-13 expression, and p-JNK expression. With the treatment of pcDNA-MALAT-1, the cartilage injury was alleviated with increased chondrocyte viability and type II collagen (Col II) expression and reduced chondrocyte apoptosis, MMP-13 expression and p-JNK expression. Taken together these results, lncRNA MALAT-1 blocked the activation of the JNK signaling pathway; thereby, IL-1β-induced inflammation in articular chondrocytes was reduced with enhanced chondrocyte proliferation and suppressed chondrocyte apoptosis and extracellular matrix degradation.     

Comparison of nonlinear mechanical properties of bovine articular cartilage and meniscus

Nonlinear, linear and failure properties of articular cartilage and meniscus in opposing contact surfaces are poorly known in tension. Relationships between the tensile properties of articular cartilage and meniscus in contact with each other within knee joints are also not known. In the present study, rectangular samples were prepared from the superficial lateral femoral condyle cartilage and lateral meniscus of bovine knee joints. Tensile tests were carried out with a loading rate of 5 mm/min until the tissue rupture. Nonlinear properties of the toe region, linear properties in larger strains, and failure properties of both tissues were analysed. The strain-dependent tensile modulus of the toe region, Young's modulus of the linear region, ultimate tensile stress and toughness were on average 98.2, 8.3, 4.0 and 1.9 times greater (p<0.05) for meniscus than for articular cartilage. In contrast, the toe region strain, yield strain and failure strain were on average 9.4, 3.1 and 2.3 times greater (p<0.05) for cartilage than for meniscus. There was a significant negative correlation between the strain-dependent tensile moduli of meniscus and articular cartilage samples within the same joints (r=−0.690, p=0.014). In conclusion, the meniscus possesses higher nonlinear and linear elastic stiffness and energy absorption capability before rupture than contacting articular cartilage, while cartilage has longer nonlinear region and can withstand greater strains before failure. These findings point out different load carrying demands that both articular cartilage and meniscus have to fulfil during normal physiological loading activities of knee joints.     

Type X collagen expression in osteoarthritic and rheumatoid articular cartilage

Type X collagen is a short chain, non-fibrilforming collagen synthesized primarily by hypertrophic chondrocytes in the growth plate of fetal cartilage. Previously, we have also identified type X collagen in the extracellular matrix of fibrillated, osteoarthritic but not in normal articular cartilage using biochemical and immunohistochemical techniques (von der Mark et al. 1992 a). Here we compare the expression of type X with types I and II collagen in normal and degenerate human articular cartilage by in situ hybridization. Signals for cytoplasmic α1(X) collagen mRNA were not detectable in sections of healthy adult articular cartilage, but few specimens of osteoarthritic articular cartilage showed moderate expression of type X collagen in deep zones, but not in the upper fibrillated zone where type X collagen was detected by immunofluorescence. This apparent discrepancy may be explained by the relatively short phases of type X collagen gene activity in osteoarthritis and the short mRNA half-life compared with the longer half-life of the type X collagen protein. At sites of newly formed osteophytic and repair cartilage, α1(X) mRNA was strongly expressed in hypertrophic cells, marking the areas of endochondral bone formation. As in hypertrophic chondrocytes in the proliferative zone of fetal cartilage, type X collagen expression was also associated with strong type II collagen expression.     

In vitro effect of a synthesized sulfonamido-based gallate on articular chondrocyte metabolism

Autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) is a promising strategy for cartilage repair and reconstitution. However, limited cell numbers and the dedifferentiation of chondrocytes present major difficulties to the success of ACI therapy. Therefore, it is important to find effective pro-chondrogenic agents that restore these defects to ensure a successful therapy. In this study, we synthesized a sulfonamido-based gallate, namely N-[4-(4,6-dimethyl-pyrimidin-2-ylsulfamoyl)-phenyl]-3,4,5-trihydroxy-benzamide (EJTC), and investigated its effects on rabbit articular chondrocytes through an examination of its specific effects on cell proliferation, morphology, viability, GAG synthesis, and cartilage-specific gene expression. The results show that EJTC can effectively promote chondrocyte growth and enhance the secretion and synthesis of cartilage ECM by upregulating the expression levels of the aggrecan, collagen II, and Sox9 genes. The expression of the collagen I gene was effectively downregulated, which indicates that EJTC inhibits chondrocytes dedifferentiation. Chondrocyte hypertrophy, which may lead to chondrocyte ossification, was also undetectable in the EJTC-treated groups. The recommended dose of EJTC ranges from 3.125 μg/mL to 7.8125 μg/mL, and the most profound response was observed with 7.8125 μg/mL. This study may provide a basis for the development of a novel agent for the treatment of articular cartilage defects.     

Up-regulation of matrix in bovine articular cartilage explants by electric fields

Electric stimulation has long been used as a tool to promote connective tissue healing, but the mechanism(s) by which this is accomplished are not yet known. We have previously determined, using mass cultures of fetal bovine articular chondrocytes, a specific set of capacitively coupled electrical stimulation parameters (e.g., duration of stimulation, response time, amplitude, frequency, and duty cycle) that significantly elevated production of collagen and proteoglycan, and up-regulated type II collagen and aggrecan mRNA expression in vitro. In the present study, we applied our best signal parameters (30-min continuous stimulation (100% duty cycle) followed by a pulsed (1h on, 5h off, 4x/day) 50% (1 min on, 1 min off) duty cycle) to cultures of adult bovine articular cartilage explants and obtained similar results. Since the latter system more closely mimics the in vivo chondrocyte environment, these data argue for the utility of electric stimulation for the maintenance of adult cartilage matrix in situ.     

Compression-induced changes in the shape and volume of the chondrocyte nucleus

Changes in cell shape and volume are believed to play a role in the process of mechanical signal transduction by chondrocytes in articular cartilage. One proposed pathway through which chondrocyte deformation may be transduced to an intracellular signal is through cytoskeletally mediated deformation of intracellular organelles, and more specifically, of the cell nucleus. In this study, confocal scanning laser microscopy was used to perform in situ three-dimensional morphometric analyses of the nuclei of viable condrocytes during controlled compression of articular cartilage explants from the canine patellofemoral groove. Unconfined compression of the tissue to a 15% surface-to-surface strain resulted in a significant decrease of chondrocyte height and volume by 14.7 ± 6.4 and 11.4 ± 8.4%, respectively, and of nuclear height and volume by 8.8 ± 6.2% and 9.8 ± 8.8%, respectively. Disruption of the actin cytoskeleton using cytochalasin D altered the relationship between matrix deformation and changes in nuclear height and shape, but not volume. The morphology and deformation behavior of the chondrocytes were not affected by cytochalasin treatment. These results suggest that the actin cytoskeleton plays an important role in the link between compression of the extracellular matrix and deformation of the chondrocyte nuclei and imply that chondrocytes and their nuclei undergo significant changes in shape and volume in vivo.     

Accumulation of procollagen in the degenerative articular cartilage of dogs with osteoarthritis

Collagen metabolism was studied in degenerative articular cartilage of dogs with spontaneous, early onset osteoarthritis. A fraction of collagen which represented about 1.5.% of the total was extracted from cartilage samples with dilute phosphate buffer (pH 7.4) containing 0.2% sodium dodecyl sulfate. Agarose gel filtration in the presence of sodium dodecul sulfate revealed that extracts of degenerative cartilage had about 24% procollagen whereas extracts of normal samples had only 3%. The isolated procollagen fraction was rechromatographed on agarose columns in the presence of mercaptoethanol. This resulted in the identification of a collagen species which migrated between marker β and α collagen chains. The molecular weight of this collagen was estimated to be 150000. Based on incorporation of [¹⁴C]proline, its ratio of hydroxy[¹⁴C]proline to total ¹⁴C was 0.32. Procollagen was not found after limited pepsin digestion (pH 3,4°C, 16 h) of degenerative cartilage samples.Since the total collagen content (μg hydroxyproline/mg cartilage), hydroxy[¹⁴C]proline/mg cartilage, specific radioactivity of hydroxy[¹⁴C]proline (cpm/μg), in the whole cartilage, and the specific radioactivity of hydroxyproline in the extractable collagen fraction were similar for normal and degenerative cartilage we propose that procollagen accumulated in the degenerative cartilage due to a partial defect in conversion of procollagen to collagen.     

Mesenchyme-specific Knockout of ESET Histone Methyltransferase Causes Ectopic Hypertrophy and Terminal Differentiation of Articular Chondrocytes

The exact molecular mechanisms governing articular chondrocytes remain unknown in skeletal biology. In this study, we have found that ESET (an ERG-associated protein with a SET domain, also called SETDB1) histone methyltransferase is expressed in articular cartilage. To test whether ESET regulates articular chondrocytes, we carried out mesenchyme-specific deletion of the ESET gene in mice. ESET knock-out did not affect generation of articular chondrocytes during embryonic development. Two weeks after birth, there was minimal qualitative difference at the knee joints between wild-type and ESET knock-out animals. At 1 month, ectopic hypertrophy, proliferation, and apoptosis of articular chondrocytes were seen in the articular cartilage of ESET-null animals. At 3 months, additional signs of terminal differentiation such as increased alkaline phosphatase activity and an elevated level of matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)-13 were found in ESET-null cartilage. Staining for type II collagen and proteoglycan revealed that cartilage degeneration became progressively worse from 2 weeks to 12 months at the knee joints of ESET knock-out mutants. Analysis of over 14 pairs of age- and sex-matched wild-type and knock-out mice indicated that the articular chondrocyte phenotype in ESET-null mutants is 100% penetrant. Our results demonstrate that expression of ESET plays an essential role in the maintenance of articular cartilage by preventing articular chondrocytes from terminal differentiation and may have implications in joint diseases such as osteoarthritis.     

Mesenchymal stem cells as a potent cell source for articular cartilage regeneration

Since articular cartilage possesses only a weak capac-ity for repair, its regeneration potential is considered one of the most important challenges for orthopedic surgeons. The treatment options, such as marrow stimulation techniques, fail to induce a repair tissue with the same functional and mechanical properties of native hyaline cartilage. Osteochondral transplantation is considered an effective treatment option but is as-sociated with some disadvantages, including donor-site morbidity, tissue supply limitation, unsuitable mechani-cal properties and thickness of the obtained tissue. Although autologous chondrocyte implantation results in reasonable repair, it requires a two-step surgical pro-cedure. Moreover, chondrocytes expanded in culture gradually undergo dedifferentiation, so lose morpho-logical features and specialized functions. In the search for alternative cells, scientists have found mesenchymal stem cells(MSCs) to be an appropriate cellular mate-rial for articular cartilage repair. These cells were origi-nally isolated from bone marrow samples and further investigations have revealed the presence of the cells in many other tissues. Furthermore, chondrogenic dif-ferentiation is an inherent property of MSCs noticedat the time of the cell discovery. MSCs are known to exhibit homing potential to the damaged site at which they differentiate into the tissue cells or secrete a wide spectrum of bioactive factors with regenerative proper-ties. Moreover, these cells possess a considerable im-munomodulatory potential that make them the general donor for therapeutic applications. All of these topics will be discussed in this review.     

Transient anabolic effects accompany epidermal growth factor receptor signal activation in articular cartilage in vivo

Introduction

Signals from the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) have typically been considered to provide catabolic activities in articular cartilage, and accordingly have been suggested to have a causal role in osteoarthritis progression. The aim of this study was to determine in vivo roles for endogenous EGFR signal activation in articular cartilage.

Methods

Transgenic mice with conditional, limb-targeted deletion of the endogenous intracellular EGFR inhibitor Mig-6 were generated using CreLoxP (Mig-6-flox; Prx1Cre) recombination. Histology, histochemical staining and immunohistochemistry were used to confirm activation of EGFR signaling in the articular cartilage and joints, and to analyze phenotypic consequences of Mig-6 loss on articular cartilage morphology, proliferation, expression of progenitor cell markers, presence of chondrocyte hypertrophy and degradation of articular cartilage matrix.

Results

The articular cartilage of Mig-6-conditional knockout (Mig-6-cko) mice was dramatically and significantly thicker than normal articular cartilage at 6 and 12 weeks of age. Mig-6-cko articular cartilage contained a population of chondrocytes in which EGFR signaling was activated, and which were three to four times more proliferative than normal Mig-6-flox articular chondrocytes. These cells expressed high levels of the master chondrogenic regulatory factor Sox9, as well as high levels of putative progenitor cell markers including superficial zone protein (SZP), growth and differentiation factor-5 (GDF-5) and Notch1. Expression levels were also high for activated β-catenin and the transforming growth factor beta (TGF-β) mediators phospho-Smad2/3 (pSmad2/3). Anabolic effects of EGFR activation in articular cartilage were followed by catabolic events, including matrix degradation, as determined by accumulation of aggrecan cleavage fragments, and onset of hypertrophy as determined by type × collagen expression. By 16 weeks of age, the articular cartilage of Mig-6-cko knees was no longer thickened and was degenerating.

Conclusions

These results demonstrate unexpected anabolic effects of EGFR signal activation in articular cartilage, and suggest the hypothesis that these effects may promote the expansion and/or activity of an endogenous EGFR-responsive cell population within the articular cartilage.     

Extracellular matrix changes in knee joint cartilage following bone-active drug treatment

Certain drugs or treatments that are known to affect bone quality or integrity might have side effects on the extracellular matrix of articular cartilage. We investigated the effects of vitamin D and calcium deficiency, estrogen deficiency, and hypercortisolism alone or in combination with bisphosphonates or sodium fluoride in an animal model, viz., the Göttingen miniature pig (n=29). The articular cartilage from knee joints was analyzed for its content of glycosaminoglycans (GAGs, as macromolecules responsible for the elasticity of articular cartilage) by a spectrometric method with dimethylene blue chloride. In cryo- or paraffin sections, alkaline phosphatase (AP, as an enzyme indicating mineralization or reorganization of articular cartilage matrix) was localized by enzyme histochemistry, and positive cells were counted, whereas differently sulfated GAGs were stained histochemically. A significant decrease in GAG content was measured in ovariectomized and long-term glucocorticoid-treated animals compared with untreated animals. In the glucocorticoid/sodium fluoride group, GAGs were significantly diminished, and significantly fewer AP-positive chondrocytes were counted compared with the control. GAG content was slightly higher, and significantly more AP-positive chondrocytes were counted in short-term glucocorticoid-treated animals then in the control group. GAGs, as part of proteoglycans, are responsible for the water-storage capacity that gives articular cartilage its unique property of elasticity. Thus, ovariectomy and long-term glucocorticoid therapy, especially when combined with sodium fluoride, have detrimental effects on this tissue.This work was in part supported by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) project no. Schr 430/5–1, 5–2 and G 1289/1–1, 1–2     

Effects of rapid cooling on articular cartilage

In order to improve the technique and protocols of cryopreservation of articular cartilage, a study was carried out to assess the effects of rapid cooling on the intact articular cartilage. Cartilage slices with a thickness ranging from 0.2 to 0.5 mm taken from bovine metacarpal-phalangeal joints were subjected to rapid cooling by immersing them in liquid nitrogen with and without treatment of the VS55 cryoprotective agent (CPA). The ultrastructure, chondrocyte viability, swelling property, and glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content were then examined before and after cryopreservation to give qualitative and quantitative evaluation on the functional state of both chondrocytes and extracellular matrix. The transmission electron microscopy study demonstrated that damage to chondrocytes without CPA was far more pronounced than those with VS55 protection while the structure of the extracellular matrix altered little in either group. The cell viability assay showed that although the exposure to VS55 led to about 36% chondrocytes losing membrane integrity, the VS55 could provide protection to chondrocytes during rapid cooling and thawing, with approximately 51% of the cells having survived rapid cooling compared to fewer than 5% in the absence of CPA. There were no significant differences in degrees of swelling or the GAG contents of cartilage slices after cryopreservation indicating rapid freezing caused little damage to the matrix. Future research activities include searching improved CPA formulation, optimising the treatment protocol and investigating the long-term effects of rapid cooling on articular cartilage.     

Bioengineered chondrocyte sheets may be potentially useful for the treatment of partial thickness defects of articular cartilage

Some treatments for full thickness defects of articular cartilage, such as cultured chondrocyte transplantation, have already been done. However, to overcome osteoarthritis, we must further study the partial thickness defect of articular cartilage. It is much more difficult to repair a partial thickness defect because few repairing cells can address such injured sites. We herein show that bioengineered layered chondrocyte sheets using temperature-responsive culture dishes may be a potentially useful treatment for partial thickness defects. We evaluated the property of these sheets using real-time PCR and histological findings, and allografted these sheets to evaluate the effect of treatment using a rabbit partial model. In conclusion, layered chondrocyte sheets were able to maintain the cartilageous phenotype, and could be attached to the sites of cartilage damage which acted as a barrier to prevent a loss of proteoglycan from these sites and to protect them from catabolic factors in the joint.     

Comparison of three multi-cryoprotectant loading protocols for vitrification of porcine articular cartilage

Vitrification is a cryopreservation technique for the long-term storage of viable tissue, but the success of this technique relies on multiple factors. In 2012, our group published a working vitrification protocol for intact human articular cartilage and reported promising chondrocyte recovery after using a four-step multi-cryoprotectant (CPA) loading method that required 570 min. However, this protocol requires further optimization for clinical practice. Herein, we compared three multi-step CPA loading protocols to investigate their impact on chondrocyte recovery after vitrification of porcine articular cartilage on a bone base, including our previous four-step protocol (original: 570 min), and two shorter three-step protocols (optimized: 420 min, and minimally vitrifiable: 310 min). Four different CPAs were used including glycerol, dimethyl sulfoxide, ethylene glycol and propylene glycol. As vitrification containers, two conical tubes (50 ml and 15 ml) were evaluated for their heat transfer impact on chondrocyte recovery after vitrification. Osteochondral dowels were cored into two diameters of 10.0 mm and 6.9 mm with an approximately 10-mm thick bone base, and then allocated into the twelve experimental groups based on CPA loading protocol, osteochondral dowel size, and vitrification container size. After vitrification at −196 °C and tissue warming and CPA removal, samples in all groups were assessed for both chondrocyte viability and metabolic activity. The optimized protocol proposed based on mathematical modelling resulted in similar chondrocyte recovery to our original protocol and it was 150 min shorter. Furthermore, this study illustrated the role of CPA permeation (dowel size) and heat transfer (container size) on vitrification protocol outcome.