Ion competition and micrococcal nuclease digestion studies of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA: Evidence for torus organization by circumferential DNA wrapping

Spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA structures have been studied by ion competition using a sedimentation assay and by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Competitor ions Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺ and putrescine²⁺ show specific ion effects; but all three appear to affect the DNA condensation-decondensation equilibrium caused by spermidine³⁺ in a qualitatively similar manner, suggesting the spermidine³⁺-DNA interaction is largely electrostatic. Our data show a hysteresis in condensation and decondensation transition directions. We interpret this in terms of a kinetic block in the condensation direction with decondensation representing the equilibrium state of the system. These results agree with results obtained from related systems using different measurement techniques. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA produces broad but discrete bands in gel electrophoresis experiments. At least two bands determined to be 760 ± 87 bp and 1355 ± 135 bp, possess the size ratio 1:1.8 ± 0.4 consistent with their forming the monomer and dimer fragments of an arithmetic band series. We rationalize this result in terms of a localized micrococcal nuclease cleavage model of circumferentially-wrapped DNA toruses proposed previously by Marx, K.A. and Reynolds, T.C. (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (1982) 79, 6484–6488). The arithmetic series monomer band (760 ± 87 bp), corresponding to wrapping B̄ DNA once circumferentially about the torus, is in agreement with the electron microscopic measurements of hydrated calf thymus DNA torus circumferences presented by Marx, K.A. and Ruben, G.C. (Nucleic Acids Res. (1983) 11, 1839–1853).     

Micrococcal nuclease digestion study of spermidine-condensed DNA

Spermidine-condensed lambda DNA tertiary structures have been studied by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Broad but discrete DNA bands were observed in gel electrophoresis experiments of digests at sizes of: 1003 +/- 115 bp, 1972 +/- 190 bp and 3100 +/- 350 bp. These bands comprise an arithmetic series, similar to, but larger than, arithmetic DNA band series sizes we have observed previously in calf thymus and phi x-174 DNA condensates. The 1003bp monomer lambda DNA band size corresponds to wrapping B DNA once circumferentially about the toroidal-shaped tertiary structures, the predominant condensed structures present in these preparations, and is consistent with the measured electron microscopic dimensions for hydrated lambda DNA toruses previously presented. DNA fragment length stability was determined by release from the digested condensates. Fragments of 80-85bp and sizes below are thermodynamically unstable in the lambda DNA condensates. This fragment size agrees well with a recent determination of the cooperativity size in DNA condensates.     

A study of phi X-174 DNA torus and lambda DNA torus tertiary structure and the implications for DNA self-assembly

Hydrated torus shaped complexes were examined by transmission electron microscopy in both spermidine-condensed linear and nicked circular phi X-174 DNA and lambda DNA preparations. Freeze-etch replicas of both these torus samples, produced with very low Pt metal deposition levels (9APt/C), were found to have circumferentially wound single DNA double helix size surface fibers in the range of 30A width. Measurements of torus inner and outer circumference as well as ring thickness were performed. Observed differences in the torus dimension distributions from circular phi X-174 DNA and linear phi X-174 DNA may be related to the different topological constraints on DNA folding in these two samples (1). On the basis of annulus thickness measurements phi X-174 DNA toruses, in contrast to lambda DNA toruses, were observed to fall into two classes identified as being formed from monomer DNA condensation and multimer DNA condensation. All of the torus substructure and population dimensions observed here are consistent with the continuous circumferential DNA winding model of torus organization proposed by Marx and Reynolds (1) to explain the micrococcal nuclease cleavage properties of the toruses. End-on view measurements of the torus thickness were made from micrographs obtained by extensive tilting of the object replica. These direct measurements confirmed quaternary structure interpretations made from simple strand packing models. We compared the measured torus properties in this linear DNA size series (5386-48000 bp). With increasing DNA length the pattern of DNA strand self-assembly was found to be more varied producing lambda DNA toruses of varying shape. The relevance of our study to the problem of lambda bacteriophage DNA head packaging was discussed.     

Structure of eukaryotic chromatin. Evaluation of periodicity using endogenous and exogenous nucleases.

DNA isolated from (a) liver chromatin digested in situ with endogenous Ca2+, Mg2+-dependent endonuclease, (b) prostate chromatin digested in situ with micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic DNAase I, and (c) isolated liver chromatin digested with micrococcal nuclease or pancreatic DNAase I has been analyzed electrophoretically on polyacrylamide gels. The electrophoretic patterns of DNA prepared from chromatin digested in situ with either endogenous endonuclease (liver nuclei) or micrococcal nuclease (prostate nuclei) are virtually identical. Each pattern consists of a series of discrete bands representing multiples of the smallest fragment of DNA 200 +/- 20 base pairs in length. The smallest DNA fragment (monomer) accumulates during prolonged digestion of chromatin in situ until it accounts for nearly all of the DNA on the gel; approx. 20% of the DNA of chromatin is rendered acid soluble during this period. Digestion of liver chromatin in situ in the presence of micrococcal nuclease results initially in the reduction of the size of the monomer from 200 to 170 base pairs of DNA and subsequently results in its conversion to as many as eight smaller fragments. The electrophoretic pattern obtained with DNA prepared from micrococcal nuclease digests of isolated liver chromatin is similar, but not identical, to that obtained with liver chromatin in situ. These preparations are more heterogeneous and contain DNA fragments smaller than 200 base pairs in length. These results suggest that not all of the chromatin isolated from liver nuclei retains its native structure. In contrast to endogenous endonuclease and micrococcal nuclease digests of chromatin, pancreatic DNAase I digests of isolated chromatin and of chromatin in situ consist of an extremely heterogeneous population of DNA fragments which migrates as a continuum on gels. A similar electrophoretic pattern is obtained with purified DNA digested by micrococcal nuclease. The presence of spermine (0.15 mM) and spermidine (0.5 mM) in preparative and incubation buffers decreases the rate of digestion of chromatin by endogenous endonuclease in situ approx. 10-fold, without affecting the size of the resulting DNA fragments. The rates of production of the smallest DNA fragments, monomer, dimer, and trimer, are nearly identical when high molecular weight DNA is present in excess, indicating that all of the chromatin multimers are equally susceptible to endogenous endonuclease. These observations points out the effects of various experimental conditions on the digestion of chromatin by nucleases.     

A Study of øX-174 DNA Torus and Lambda DNA Torus Tertiary Structure and the Implications For DNA Self-Assembly

Abstract

Hydrated torus shaped complexes were examined by transmission electron microscopy in both spermidine-condensed linear and nicked circular øX-174 DNA and lambda DNA preparations. Freeze-etch replicas of both these torus samples, produced with very low Pt metal deposition levels (9APt/C), were found to have circumferentially wound single DNA double helix size surface fibers in the range of 30A width. Measurements of torus inner and outer circumference as well as ring thickness were performed. Observed differences in the torus dimension distributions from circular øX-174 DNA and linear øX ?174 DNA may be related to the different topological constraints on DNA folding in these two samples (1). On the basis of annulus thickness measurements øX ?174 DNA toruses, in contrast to lambda DNA toruses, were observed to fall into two classes identified as being formed from monomer DNA condensation and multimer DNA condensation. All of the torus substructure and population dimensions observed here are consistent with the continuous circumferential DNA winding model of torus organization proposed by Marx and Reynolds (1) to explain the micrococcal nuclease cleavage properties of the toruses. End-on view measurements of the torus thickness were made from micrographs obtained by extensive tilting of the object replica. These direct measurements confirmed quaternary structure interpretations made from simple strand packing models. We compared the measured torus properties in this linear DNA size series (5386–48000 bp). With increasing DNA length the pattern of DNA strand self- assembly was found to be more varied producing lambda DNA toruses of varying shape. The relevance of our study to the problem of lambda bacteriophage DNA head packaging was discussed.     

Nascent DNA in nucleosome like structures from chromatin

We have used chromatin sensitivity to cleavage by micrococcal nuclease as a probe for differences between chromatin containing nascent DNA and that containing bulk DNA. Micrococcal nuclease digested the nascent DNA in chromatin of swimming blastulae of sea urchins more rapidly to acid-soluble nucleotides than the DNA of bulk chromatin. A part of the nascent DNA occurred in micrococcal nuclease-resistant structures which were either different from, or temporary modifications of, the bulk nucleosomes. This was inferred from the size differences between bulk and nascent DNA fragments in 10% polyacrylamide gels after micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclei from a mixture of ¹⁴C-thymidine long- and ³H-thymidine pulse-labeled embryos. Bulk monomer and dimer DNA fragments contained about 170 and 410 base pairs (bp), respectively, when 18% of the bulk DNA had been rendered acid-soluble. At this level of digestion, “nascent monomer DNA” fragments of about 150 bp as well as 305 bp “large nascent DNA fragments” were observed. Increasing levels of digestion indicated that the large nascent DNA fragment was derived from a chromatin structure which was more resistant to micrococcal nuclease cleavage than bulk dimer chromatin subunits. Peaks of ³H-thymidine-labeled DNA fragments from embryos which had been pulse-labeled and then chased or labeled for several minutes overlapped those of ¹⁴C-thymidine long-labeled monomer, dimer and trimer fragments. This indicated that the chromatin organization at or near the replication fork which had temporarily changed during replication had returned to the organization of its nonreplicating state.     

Sequence specific cleavage of African green monkey alpha-satellite DNA by micrococcal nuclease

The sequence specificity of micrococcal nuclease complicates its use in experiments addressed to the still controversial issue of nucleosome phasing. In the case of alpha-satellite DNA containing chromatin from African green monkey (AGM) cells cleavage by micrococcal nuclease in the nucleus was reported to occur predominantly at only one location around position 126 of the satellite repeat unit (Musich et al. (1982) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 118-122). DNA control experiments conducted in the same study indicated the presence of many preferential cleavage sites for micrococcal nuclease on the 172 bp long alpha-satellite repeat unit. This difference was taken as evidence for a direct and simple phase relationship between the alpha-satellite DNA sequence and the position of the nucleosomes on the DNA. We have quantitatively analyzed the digestion products of the protein-free satellite monomer with micrococcal nuclease and found that 50% of all cuts occur at positions 123 and 132, 5% at position 79, and to a level of 1-3% at about 20 other positions. We also digested high molecular weight alpha-satellite DNA from AGM nuclei with micrococcal nuclease. Again cleavage occurred mostly at positions 123 and 132 of the satellite repeat unit. Thus digestion of free DNA yields results very similar to those reported by Musich et al. for the digestion of chromatin. Therefore no conclusions on a possible phase relationship can be drawn from the chromatin digestion experiments.     

DNA sequence directs placement of histone cores on restriction fragments during nucleosome formation.

Restriction fragments, 203 and 144 base pairs in length, bearing the Escherichia coli lac control region have been reconstituted with the core histones from calf thymus to form nucleosomes. By several criteria the reconstituted nucleosomes are similar to native nucleosomes obtained by micrococcal nuclease digestion of calf thymus nuclei. However, sensitive nuclease digestion studies reveal subtle and important differences between native monosomes and the lac reconstitutes. Each reconstitute consists mainly of nucleosomes containing histone cores placed nonrandomly with respect to the DNA sequence. The shorter reconstitute forms asymmetric nucleosomes as evidenced by the DNase I digestion pattern. Exonuclease III digestion followed by 5'-end analysis of the larger reconstitute suggests that, of the many possible arrangements of histone core with DNA sequence, only two are highly favored.     

Activation of (ADP-ribose) polymerase by DNA fragmented by micrococcal nuclease and DNAase I]

Activation of (ADP-ribose) polymerase by DNA fragments obtained by digestion of calf thymus DNA with micrococcal nuclease and DNAase I was studied. It was found that activation of the enzyme is due to its interaction with the terminal parts of double-stranded DNA fragments, the level of activation being independent of the size of DNA fragments.     

The role of terminal DNA groups in the activation of (ADP-ribose)polymerase]

Some peculiarities of activation of (ADP-ribose) polymerase by DNA fragments were studied. DNA fragments were produced by the digestion of calf thymus DNA by micrococcal nuclease and with a subsequent enzymatic modification of their end groups by nuclease S1, polynucleotide kinase of phage T4 and alkaline phosphatase. The dependence of the activating effect of DNA on the chemical structure of its end groups was established. It was shown that the terminal phosphate groups are involved in the formation of a catalytically active complex of (ADP-ribose) polymerase with DNA.     

Evidence for hydrated spermidine-calf thymus DNA toruses organized by circumferential DNA wrapping

In spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA preparations, torus-shaped condensates were shown by transmission electron microscopy to exist under the hydrated conditions of the freeze fracture experiment. Using extremely low Pt metal deposition levels (9 A Pt/C) high-contrast replicas of the spermidine-DNA toruses were obtained that showed circumferential wrapping of single DNA double helix-size surface fibres. Stereoscopic analysis of high magnification stereomicrographs established some details of the three-dimensional organization of two DNA double helix sections winding circumferentially on the inner surface of one such torus. These measurements demonstrate the usefulness of stereoscopic analysis of these high macromolecular organization magnification. Measurements on a number of torus-shaped complexes (n = 16) yielded these average dimensions: inner circumference (1840 +/- 204 A) outer circumference (2800 +/- 222 A), torus ring thickness (143 +/- 18 A). These data support a continuous circumferential DNA-winding model of torus organization proposed by Marx & Reynolds.     

The structure of sub-nucleosomal particles. The octameric (H3/H4)4--125-base-pair-DNA complex

Chicken erythrocyte chromatin was depleted of histones H1, H5, H2A and H2B. The resulting (H3/H4)-containing chromatin was digested with micrococcal nuclease to yield monomer, dimer, trimer etc. units, irregularly spaced on the DNA, with even-number multimers being more prominent. Sucrose density gradient centrifugation separated monomers and dimers (7.7 S and 10.5 S). Sodium dodecyl sulphate gel electrophoresis and cross-linking indicated: the monomer contains 50-base-pair (bp), 60-bp and 70-bp DNA and the dimer 125-bp DNA; the monomer contains a tetramer and the dimer an octamer of H3 and H4. Partial association of monomer units to dimers inhibits structural studies of monomers. The internal structure of the dimer, i.e. and (H3/H4)4-125-bp-DNA particle, was studied using circular dichroism, thermal denaturation and nuclease digestion. Both micrococcal nuclease and DNase I digestion indicate that, unlike core particles, accessible sites occur in the centre of the particle and it is concluded that the (H3/H4)4-125-bp-DNA particle is not a 'pseudo-core particle' in which the 'extra' H3 and H4 replace H2A and H2B. It is proposed that the octamer particle is formed by the sliding together of two 'monomer' units, each containing the (H3/H4)2 tetramer and 70 bp of DNA. Excision of this dimer unit with micrococcal nuclease results in the loss of 10 readily digestible base pairs at each end, leaving 125 bp.     

Closely spaced nucleosome cores in reconstituted histone.DNA complexes and histone-H1-depleted chromatin

It has been demonstrated by digestion studies with micrococcal nuclease that reconstitution of complexes from DNA and a mixture of the four small calf thymus histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4 leads to subunits closely spaced in a 137 +/- 7-nucleotide-pair register. Subunits isolated from the reconstituted complex contain nearly equimolar amounts of the four histones and sediment at 11.6S. On DNase I digestion both the reconstituted complex and the separated subunits gave rise to series of single-stranded DNA fragments with a 10-nucleotide periodicity. This indicates that the reconstitution leads to subunits very similar to nucleosome cores. Nucleosome cores closely spaced in a 140-nucleotide-pair register were also obtained upon removal of histone H1 from chromatin by dissociation with 0.63 M NaCl and subsequent ultracentrifugation. In reconstitution experiments with all five histones (including histone H1) our procedure did not lead to tandemly arranged nucleosomes containing about 200 nucleotide pairs of DNA. In the presence of EDTA, DNase II cleaved calf thymus nuclei and chromatin at about 200-nucleotide-pair intervals whereas in the presence of Mg2+ cleavage at intervals of approximately half this size was observed. The change in the nature of the cleavage pattern, however, was no longer found after removal of histone H1 from chromatin. This indicates that H1 influences the accessibility of DNase II cleavage sites in chromatin. This finding is discussed with respect to the influence of histone H1 on chromatin superstructure.     

Changes in chromatin structure at the replication fork. II The DNPs containing nascent DNA and a transient chromatin modification detected by DNAase I.

Discrete deoxyribonucleoproteins (DNPs) containing nascent and/or bulk DNA, were obtained by fractionating micrococcal nuclease digests of nuclei form 3H-thymidine pulse (15-20 sec) and 14C-thymidine long (16 h) labeled sea urchin embryos in polyacrylamide gels. One of these DNPs was shown to contain the micrococcal nuclease resistant 300 bp "large nascent DNA" described in Cell 14, 259-267, 1978. The bulk and nascent mononucleosome fractions provided evidence for the preferential digestion by micrococcal nuclease of nascent over bulk linker regions to yield mononucleosome cores with nascent DNA. DNAase I was used to probe whether any nascent DNA is in nucleosomes. Nascent as well as bulk single-stranded DNA fragments occurred in multiples of 10.4 bases with higher than random frequencies of certain fragment sizes (for instance 83 bases) as expected from a nucleosome structure. However, a striking background of nascent DNA between nascent DNA peaks was observed. This was eliminated by a pulse-chase treatment or by digestion of pulse-labeled nuclei with micrococcal nuclease together with DNAase I. One of several possible interpretations of these results suggests that a transient change in nucleosome structure may have created additional sites for the nicking of nascent DNA by DNAase I; the micrococcal nuclease sensitivity of the interpeak radioactivity suggest its origin from the linker region. Endogenous nuclease of sea urchin embryos cleaves chromatin DNA in a manner similar to that of DNAase I.     

The effects of salt concentration and H-1 depletion on the digestion of calf thymus chromatin by micrococcal nuclease.

We have removed histone H1 specifically from calf thymus nuclei by low pH treatment, and studied the digestion of such nuclei in comparison with undepleted nuclei. By a number of criteria the nuclei do not appear damaged. The DNA repeat-length in nuclear chromatin is found to be the same (192 +/- 4 bp) in the presence or absence of H1. These experiments demonstrate that the core histone complex of H2A, H2B, H3, and H4 can itself protect DNA sequences as long as 168 bp from nuclease. Our interpretation is that this represents an important structural element in chromatin, carrying two full turns of superhelical DNA. Depending on conditions of digestion this 168 bp fragment may be metastable and is normally rapidly converted by exonucleolytic trimming to the well-known "core-particle" containing 145 bp. Larger stable DNA fragments observed indigestion of H-1 depleted nuclei appear to arise from oligomers assembled from 168 bp cores in close contact exhibiting trimming of 0-20 bp at the ends. Electrophorograms of undepleted nuclear digests reveal oligomer bands in several size classes, each corresponding to one or more combinations of 168 bp particles, H1-protected spacers of about 20 bp length, and particles with ends trimmed to varying degrees.     

Isolation of chromatin subcore particles by chromatography on Biogel 1.5 m

The method is described for separation and purification by chromatography on Biogel 1.5 m of subnucleosomal nucleoprotein particles obtained by extensive digestion of calf thymus nuclei with micrococcal nuclease.     

Preliminary characterization of chelation-sensitive nucleoprotein particles

Nucleoprotein particles (B2), isolated following digestion of calf thymus chromatin with micrococcal nuclease, are resolved on a non-chelating Bio-Gel A-5m column. B2 protein electrophoresis showed the presence of several H1 species and several nonhistone proteins but was depleted in core histones. DNA electrophoresis demonstrated that native B2 DNA has a length of about 46 base pairs. On DNA sequencing gels, the length distribution of denatured B2 DNA ranged from 12 to 35 bases with a weighted average chain length of about 26 bases. Depletion of a 20 base band in B2 DNA suggested specific protection of internucleosomal DNA sites during the nuclease digestion.     

Binding of androgen receptor to prostatic chromatin requires intact linker DNA.

Receptor-chromatin complexes were recovered from prostatic chromatin digested with micrococcal nuclease. The fragments of chromatin were separated on linear 7.6 to 76% (v/v) glycerol density gradients. With extensive digestion of DNA, receptor labeled with [1,2-3H]dihydrotestosterone was released from the chromatin. After 5% digestion of DNA to acid-soluble products, only a trace amount of labeled receptor was detected in the unbound form. In the latter instance, most of the labeled receptor was recovered from the gradients in association with five A260 peaks representing oligomeric and monomeric nucleosomes with a repeat length of 182 +/- 14 (mean +/- S.D.) base pairs. The concentration of receptors was highest in the A260 peaks, which contained large oligomers of nucleosomes, and lowest in fractions containing primarily monomer structures. Hence, the extent to which receptors remained bound to chromatin was dependent on the relative amount of intact, linker DNA present.