Mutations of the phage lambda attachment site alter the directionality of resolution of Holliday structures.

Integrative recombination of bacteriophage lambda occurs by two sequential, reciprocal strand exchanges at specific positions within the attachment sites. Both exchanges are promoted by the lambda Int protein; the first forms a Holliday structure, and the second resolves it to recombinant products. Recombination requires sequence homology within the 7 bp 'overlap' region that separates the two points of strand exchange. To see if homology promotes the second strand exchange, we constructed attachment site Holliday structures by annealing DNA strands and then assayed Int-promoted resolution. Holliday structures corresponding to strand exchange between sites with homologous overlap regions were efficiently resolved to give mixtures of recombinants and parents. Holliday structures corresponding to exchanges between heterologous sites fell into two classes. Members of the first class, in which heterology limited but did not completely prevent migration of the branchpoint within the overlap region, were resolved efficiently and preferentially to parental molecules. We propose that resolution to recombinants occurs only if homology allows branch migration from the first to the second exchange site. Members of the second class, in which heterology constrained the branchpoint within an Int binding site, were resolved poorly. We suggest that Holliday structures that have a branchpoint within an Int binding site are poor substrates for Int.     

The bacteriophage lambda int gene product. A filter assay for genetic recombination, purification of int, and specific binding to DNA.

Bacteriophage lambda int gene is required for the integration of viral DNA into the chromosome of Escherichia coli. We have extensively purified the product of the int gene (Int) from a lysogen of E. coli that constitutively expresses this gene. Int was assayed by its ability to promote integrative recombination of supertwisted substrate DNA in vitro using a new method based on filter trapping of a recombinant product DNA. In order to catalyze integrative recombination, Int must be supplemented by other factors that can be extracted from bacterial host cells. By itself, purified Int does not demonstrate detectable endonuclease, exonuclease, or nicking-closing activities. However, Int does make stable complexes with double-stranded lambda-DNA containing an attachment site, the region at which recombination takes place. No stable complexes are observed between Int and lambda-DNA without an attachment site or between Int and DNA containing the bacterial site of integration. Int, therefore, appears to be a specificity element that relies on additional factor(s) to provide or activate the catalytic functions required for recombination.     

Sequence analysis and comparison of int and xis genes from staphylococcal bacteriophages L54a and phi 11.

The DNA fragment encoding the integrase and excisionase genes involved in site-specific recombination of staphylococcal bacteriophage phi 11 was cloned and sequenced. The int and xis genes and the recombination site, attP, were highly clustered in a 1.7-kilobase DNA fragment with the gene order attP-int-xis. The int and xis genes were transcribed divergently, with the int gene transcribed toward the attp site and the xis gene transcribed away from the attP site. The deduced Int is a basic protein of 348 residues with an estimated molecular weight of 41,357. In contrast, the deduced Xis is an acidic protein containing 66 amino acids with an estimated molecular weight of 7,621. The site-specific recombination system of phi 11 was compared with that of a closely related bacteriophage, L54a.     

Heteroduplex substrates for bacteriophage lambda site-specific recombination: cleavage and strand transfer products.

Lambda's Int protein acts as a specific topoisomerase at attachment sites, the DNA segments that are required for site-specific recombination. Int cleaves each strand of an attachment site at a unique place and creates strand exchanges by joining broken ends from two different parents. To study the action of Int topoisomerase in more detail, heteroduplex attachment sites were made by annealing strands that are complementary except for a few base pairs that lie in the region between the points of top and bottom strand exchange in the attachment site core. These heteroduplexes appear to interact normally with Int and its accessory proteins IHF and Xis. Although the heteroduplex sites are specifically cleaved by Int topoisomerase, rejoining of the broken DNA is hindered by the lack of Watson--Crick complementarity adjacent to the break. Because of this, heteroduplexes accumulate broken intermediates which are then processed in novel ways. We have used this feature to provide new information about functional differences between attachment sites, to investigate the way Xis protein controls directionality of site-specific recombination, and to demonstrate that Int protein can join strands indiscriminately and can therefore generate recombinants with either of two genetic polarities.     

Purification of the bacteriophage lambda xis gene product required for lambda excisive recombination

Excision of the lambda prophage from the chromosome of its Escherichia coli host requires the products of the two viral genes int and xis. This paper reports a purification of the lambda xis gene product using a complementation assay in which functional Xis must be added to purified Int and an E. coli-derived host factor extract. Excisive recombination between a left (attL) and right (attR) prophage attachment site cloned on the same plasmid DNA substrate occurred efficiently under these conditions. Purified Int and Xis together could not carry out excision in vitro unless an extract derived from the E. coli host was added; purified integration host factor satisfied this requirement. Xis appears to have a molecular weight of 8800 as determined by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. It possesses no detectable endonuclease or topoisomerase activities, does not appear to bind DNA to filters, and does not increase the ability of Int to bind DNA. The addition of Xis not only stimulated excisive recombination in vitro but also inhibited integrative recombination. Xis protected Int protein from heat inactivation, suggesting a possible interaction between the two proteins. In light of these observations, possible roles for Xis in recombination are discussed.     

Cost-benefit analysis of recombination and its application for understanding of chiasma interference.

A cost-benefit analysis of recombination was undertaken. The beneficial effects of crossing-over are proportional to the frequency of recombinant offspring, while its harmful effects (errors of crossing-over leading to mutations) are proportional to the number of crossover exchanges. An equilibrium point should exist where the beneficial effects of crossing-over are balanced by its harmful effects. It is suggested that natural selection sustains a number of crossover exchanges per meiosis at the level that provides highest benefit-cost difference. Chiasma interference prevents the arising of closely located exchanges which are less effective in the production of recombinants than exchanges separated by some "interference distance". Computer simulation shows that chiasma interference increases the recombination effectiveness of the multiple crossover exchanges as compared to the case without interference.     

The Effect of Attachment Site Mutations on Strand Exchange in Bacteriophage λ Site-Specific Recombination

Recombination of phage λ attachment sites occurs by sequential exchange of the DNA strands at two specific locations. The first exchange produces a Holliday structure, and the second resolves it to recombinant products. Heterology for base substitution mutations in the region between the two strand exchange points (the overlap region) reduces recombination; some mutations inhibit the accumulation of Holliday structures, others inhibit their resolution to recombinant products. To see if heterology also alters the location of the strand exchange points, we determined the segregation pattern of three single and one multiple base pair substitution mutations of the overlap region in crosses with wild type sites. The mutations are known to differ in the severity of their recombination defect and in the stage of strand exchange they affect. The three single mutations behaved similarly: each segregated into both products of recombination,, and the two products of a single crossover were frequently nonreciprocal in the overlap region. In contrast, the multiple mutation preferentially segregated into one of the two recombinant products, and the two products of a single crossover appeared to be fully reciprocal. The simplest explanation of the segregation pattern of the single mutations is that strand exchanges occur at the normal locations to produce recombinants with mismatched base pairs that are frequently repaired. The segregation pattern of the multiple mutation is consistent with the view that both strand exchanges usually occur to one side of the mutant site. We suggest that the segregation pattern of a particular mutation is determined by which stage of strand exchange it inhibits and by the severity of the inhibition.     

Interactions between lambda Int molecules bound to sites in the region of strand exchange are required for efficient Holliday junction resolution

lambda Site-specific recombination proceeds via two sequential single-strand exchanges that first generate and then resolve a Holliday recombination intermediate. The resolution of artificial Holliday junctions (chi-forms) is well suited to studying the mechanisms involved in reciprocal strand exchange because the linear products of this reaction are stable and easily quantitated. To study the interactions between Int molecules bound at the sites of strand exchange, artificial Holliday junctions containing only the seven base-pair overlap region and the four core-type Int binding sites were used as a model system. In vitro resolution of these structures yields products of both top- and bottom-strand exchange. An abortive product resulting from simultaneous cleavage of the top and bottom strands also occurs at low frequency. Inactivation of one of the four Int binding sites by multiple base substitutions does not significantly affect the efficiency of resolution but has a dramatic effect on the directionality, i.e. the choice of top- or bottom-strand exchange. When any two of the four core-type sites are similarly inactivated, strand exchange is very inefficient and the amount of aberrant cleavage is somewhat greater than for the Holliday junction with four intact Int binding sites. Analysis of the resolution products of Holliday junctions with various combinations of defective Int binding sites leads to the following conclusions: (1) three functional core-type Int binding sites are necessary and sufficient for a strand exchange; (2) the Int molecules that are partners in a strand exchange interact with Int bound to a "cross-core" site that is not directly involved in carrying out the reaction; (3) Int molecules bound to the core-type sites interact in a way that reduces the occurrence of abortive double-strand cleavage events.     

The effect of attachment site mutations on strand exchange in bacteriophage lambda site-specific recombination

Recombination of phage lambda attachment sites occurs by sequential exchange of the DNA strands at two specific locations. The first exchange produces a Holliday structure, and the second resolves it to recombinant products. Heterology for base substitution mutations in the region between the two strand exchange points (the overlap region) reduces recombination; some mutations inhibit the accumulation of Holliday structures, others inhibit their resolution to recombinant products. To see if heterology also alters the location of the strand exchange points, we determined the segregation pattern of three single and one multiple base pair substitution mutations of the overlap region in crosses with wild type sites. The mutations are known to differ in the severity of their recombination defect and in the stage of strand exchange they affect. The three single mutations behaved similarly: each segregated into both products of recombination, and the two products of a single crossover were frequently nonreciprocal in the overlap region. In contrast, the multiple mutation preferentially segregated into one of the two recombinant products, and the two products of a single crossover appeared to be fully reciprocal. The simplest explanation of the segregation pattern of the single mutations is that strand exchanges occur at the normal locations to produce recombinants with mismatched base pairs that are frequently repaired. The segregation pattern of the multiple mutation is consistent with the view that both strand exchanges usually occur to one side of the mutant site. We suggest that the segregation pattern of a particular mutation is determined by which stage of strand exchange it inhibits and by the severity of the inhibition.     

DNA double strand break repair and crossing over mediated by RuvABC resolvase and RecG translocase

DNA double-strand breaks threaten the stability of the genome, and yet are induced deliberately during meiosis in order to provoke homologous recombination and generate the crossovers needed to promote faithful chromosome transmission. Crossovers are secured via biased resolution of the double Holliday junction intermediates formed when both ends of the broken chromosome engage an intact homologue. To investigate whether the enzymes catalysing branch migration and resolution of Holliday junctions are directed to favour production of either crossover or noncrossover products, we engineered a genetic system based on DNA breakage induced by the I-SceI endonuclease to detect analogous exchanges in Escherichia coli where the enzymology of recombination is more fully understood. Analysis of the recombinants generated revealed approximately equal numbers of crossover and noncrossover products, regardless of whether repair is mediated via RecG, RuvABC, or the RusA resolvase. We conclude that there little or no control of crossing over at the level of Holliday junction resolution. Thus, if similar resolvases function during meiosis, additional factors must act to bias recombination in favour of crossover progeny.     

The efficiency of mispaired ligations by lambda integrase is extremely sensitive to context

The integrase protein (Int) of phage lambda is a well-studied representative of the tyrosine recombinase family, whose defining features are two sequential pairs of DNA cleavage/ligation reactions that proceed via a 3' phosphotyrosine covalent intermediate to first form and then resolve a Holliday junction recombination intermediate. We devised an assay that takes advantage of DNA hairpin formation at one Int target site to trap Int cleavages at a different target site, and thereby reveal iterative cycles of cleavage and ligation that would otherwise be undetected. Using this assay and others to compare wild-type Int and a mutant (R169D) defective in forming proper dimer/tetramer interfaces, we found that the efficiency of "bottom-strand" DNA cleavage by wild-type Int, but not R169D, is very sensitive to the base-pair at the "top-strand" cleavage site, seven base-pairs away. We show that this is related to the finding that hairpin formation involving ligation of a mispaired base is much faster for R169D than for wild-type Int, but only in the context of a multimeric complex. During resolution of Holliday junction recombination intermediates, wild-type Int, but not R169D, is very sensitive to homology at the sites of ligation. A long-sought insight from these results is that during Holliday junction resolution the tetrameric Int complex remains intact until after ligation of the product helices has been completed. This contrasts with models in which the second pair of DNA cleavages is a trigger for dissolution of the recombination complex.     

Cutting out the φC31 prophage

To establish a lysogenic lifestyle, the temperate bacteriophage φC31 integrates its genome into the chromosome of its Streptomyces host, by site-specific recombination between attP (the attachment site in the phage DNA) and attB (the chromosomal attachment site). This reaction is promoted by a phage-encoded serine recombinase Int. To return to the lytic lifestyle, the prophage excises its DNA by a similar Int-mediated reaction between the recombinant sites flanking the prophage, attL and attR. φC31 Int has been developed into a popular experimental tool for integration of transgenic DNA into the genomes of eukaryotic organisms. However, until now it has not been possible to use Int to promote the reverse reaction, excision. In many other phages, the presence of a recombination directionality factor (RDF) protein biases the phage-encoded integrase towards prophage excision, whereas absence of the RDF favours integration; but the φC31 RDF had proved elusive. In this issue of Molecular Microbiology, Khaleel et al. (2011) report the identification and purification of the φC31 RDF, and show that it both promotes excision and inhibits integration by direct protein-protein interactions with Int itself.     

Directional control of site-specific recombination by bacteriophage lambda. Evidence that a binding site for Int protein far from the crossover point is required for integrative but not excisive recombination

Phage lambda controls its integration and excision by differential catalysis of the forward and reverse reactions. The lambda Int protein is required for both directions, but Xis for excision only. To investigate the substrate requirements for directional control, we have characterized two mutations of the phage attachment site that are defective in integrative but not excisive recombination. Both of these mutations produce the same base change in the P'3 binding site for Int protein 79 base-pairs from the center of the crossover region for site-specific recombination. We infer that differential utilization of this distant binding site is crucial for directional control of recombination.     

Dissecting the resolution reaction of lambda integrase using suicide Holliday junction substrates.

A reciprocal strand exchange between two DNA helices generates the crossed-strand intermediate, or Holliday junction, which is common to many pathways of homologous and site-specific recombination. The Int family of recombinases are unique in their ability to both make and resolve Holliday junctions. Previous experiments utilizing 'synthetic' att site Holliday junctions to study the mechanisms associated with the cleavage, transfer and ligation of DNA strands have been confined to studying reciprocal strand exchanges (a pair of temporally overlapping strand cleavages). To circumvent this limitation, we have designed synthetic suicide Holliday junctions that make it possible to monitor individual DNA strand cleavage events. These substrates contain a pre-existing nick in the vicinity of the Int binding site; when Int introduces a second nick into these substrates, the 5'OH nucleophile required for ligation (in either the forward or reverse reaction) is lost by diffusion, thus trapping the covalent protein-DNA intermediate. The results indicate that resolution (involving two partner Ints) is stimulated by additional 'cross-core' Ints as a result of enhanced cleavage rates, and not as a result of enhanced co-ordination of cleavage. Several models for the role of the 'cross-core' Ints during resolution are discussed, as well as the usefulness of these substrates for studying additional aspects of the Holliday junction resolution reaction.     

Identification of Site-Specific Recombination Genes int and xis of the Rhizobium Temperate Phage 16-3

Phage 16-3 is a temperate phage of Rhizobium meliloti 41 which integrates its genome with high efficiency into the host chromosome by site-specific recombination through DNA sequences of attB and attP. Here we report the identification of two phage-encoded genes required for recombinations at these sites: int (phage integration) and xis (prophage excision). We concluded that Int protein of phage 16-3 belongs to the integrase family of tyrosine recombinases. Despite similarities to the cognate systems of the lambdoid phages, the 16-3 int xis att system is not active in Escherichia coli, probably due to requirements for host factors that differ in Rhizobium meliloti and E. coli. The application of the 16-3 site-specific recombination system in biotechnology is discussed.     

Nucleotide sequence and genetic characterization of staphylococcal bacteriophage L54a int and xis genes.

The nucleotide sequence of a staphylococcal bacteriophage L54a DNA fragment containing genes involved in site-specific recombination was determined. Mutations generated by in vitro mutagenesis were used to map and characterize the int and xis genes. The site-specific recombination functions are tightly clustered within a 1.75-kilobase stretch of DNA fragment with the gene order of attP-int-xis. The int and xis genes are transcribed divergently. The Int protein deduced from the nucleotide sequence has a molecular weight of 41,000. Int is a basic protein with 354 amino acids of which 72 are basic and 38 are acidic. The Xis protein consists of only 59 amino acids with a molecular weight of 7,180. Unlike the Xis proteins of the lambdoid bacteriophages which are all basic proteins, L54a Xis is an acidic protein containing 13 acidic and 8 basic amino acids. The Int protein is required in both integrative and excisive reactions, whereas Xis is only required in excisive reaction. A well-conserved 40-residue region, including three perfectly conserved residues found in 15 site-specific recombinases of the integrase family that have been characterized, was also found in the L54a Int protein.     

Alterations in the directionality of lambda site-specific recombination catalyzed by mutant integrases in vivo.

Phage lambda integrative and excisive recombination normally proceeds by a pair of sequential strand exchanges. During the first exchange reaction, the "top" strand in each recombination site is cleaved, exchanged, and religated generating a Holliday junction intermediate. This intermediate DNA structure is resolved through a pair of reciprocal "bottom" strand exchanges, leading to recombinant products. The strict co-ordination of exchange reactions ensures religation between correct partner strands only. Here we show that the directionality of recombination is altered in vivo by two mutant integrases, Int-h (E174 K) and a double mutant Int-h/218 (E174 K/E218 K). This change in directionality leads to deletion instead of inversion on substrates that carry inverted attachment sites and, depending on the pair of target sites employed, requires the presence or absence of integration host factor. Neither Fis nor Xis is involved in deletion. Sequence analyses of deletion products reveal that the newly generated hybrid attachment site exhibits a reversed genetic polarity. We demonstrate that only one of two possible hybrid site configurations is generated and discuss two pathways leading to deletion. In the first, deletion results from a wrong alignment of the two recombination sites within the synaptic complex. In the second pathway, the unco-ordinated cleavage by the mutant integrases of all four DNA strands present in a conventional Holliday junction intermediate leads to two double-stranded breaks, whereby the subsequent rejoining between "wrong" partner strands appears restricted to only two strands.     

The topological mechanism of phage lambda integrase.

Bacteriophage lambda integrase (Int) is a versatile site-specific recombinase. In concert with other proteins, it mediates phage integration into and excision out of the bacterial chromosome. Int recombines intramolecular sites in inverse or direct orientation or sites on separate DNA molecules. This wide spectrum of Int-mediated reactions has, however, hindered our understanding of the topology of Int recombination. By systematically analyzing the topology of Int reaction products and using a mathematical method called tangles, we deduce a unified model for Int recombination. We find that, even in the absence of (-) supercoiling, all Int reactions are chiral, producing one of two possible enantiomers of each product. We propose that this chirality reflects a right-handed DNA crossing within or between recombination sites in the synaptic complex that favors formation of right-handed Holliday junction intermediates. We demonstrate that the change in linking number associated with excisive inversion with relaxed DNA is equally +2 and -2, reflecting two different substrates with different topology but the same chirality. Additionally, we deduce that integrative Int recombination differs from excisive recombination only by additional plectonemic (-) DNA crossings in the synaptic complex: two with supercoiled substrates and one with relaxed substrates. The generality of our results is indicated by our finding that two other members of the integrase superfamily of recombinases, Flp of yeast and Cre of phage P1, show the same intrinsic chirality as lambda Int.