Altered pore properties and kinetic changes in mutants of the Vibrio cholerae Porin OmpU

The electrophysiological technique of patch-clamp was used to characterize the pore properties of site-directed mutants in the Vibrio cholerae general diffusion porin OmpU. Changes in conductance and selectivity were observed, thus confirming the predicted pore location of these residues, based on homology with the Escherichia coli porins OmpF and OmpC. Some mutants acquire a weak selectivity for cations, which mirrors the properties of the homologous, deoxycholic acid sensitive, OmpT porin of V. cholerae. However, the mutants remain insensitive to deoxycholic acid, like wildtype OmpU. This result suggests that channel selectivity is not an important determinant in the sensitivity to this drug, and is in agreement with our finding that the neutral deoxycholic acid, and not deoxycholate, is the actual active form in channel block. Modifications in the kinetics of spontaneous closures were also noted, and are similar to those found for the E. coli channels. In addition, mutants at the D116 residue on the L3 loop display marked transitions to sub-conductance states. The results reported here are compared to a phenotypical characterization of the mutants in terms of permeability to maltodextrins and β-lactam antibiotic sensitivity. No strict correlations are observed, suggesting that distinct, but somewhat overlapping, molecular determinants control electrophysiological properties and substrate permeability.     

The Vibrio cholerae porins OmpU and OmpT have distinct channel properties

Numerous environmental signals regulate the production of virulence factors and the composition of the outer membrane of Vibrio cholerae. In particular, bile promotes the ToxR-dependent expression of the porin OmpU. Strains expressing solely OmpU are more resistant to bile, are better able to colonize the intestine, and produce more cholera toxin than strains expressing solely the OmpT porin. To gain some understanding in the physiological relevance and the molecular mechanism underlying these porin-dependent phenotypes, we have undertaken a thorough electrophysiological characterization of the channel properties of the two porins. Purified OmpU or OmpT was reconstituted in liposomes suitable for patch clamp and in planar lipid bilayers. The high resolution of the patch clamp technique allowed us to analyze in detail the behavior of single OmpU and OmpT channels. Both channels exhibit closing transitions to various conductance states. OmpT is a much more dynamic channel than OmpU, displaying frequent and prolonged closures, even at low transmembrane potentials. With a critical voltage for closure V(c) of approximately +/-90 mV, OmpT is much more voltage-sensitive than OmpU (with a V(c) of approximately +/-160 mV), a feature that is also readily apparent in the voltage dependence of closing probability observed in patch clamp in the +/-100 mV range. OmpT has low ionic selectivity (P(K)/P(Cl) = approximately 4), whereas OmpU is more cation-selective (P(K)/P(Cl) = approximately 14). The distinct functional properties of the two porins are likely to play an integrated role with environmental regulation of their expression. For example, the higher selectivity of OmpU for cations provides a possible explanation for the protective role played by this porin in a bile-containing environment, because this type of selectivity would restrict the flux of anionic bile salts through the outer membrane and thus would reduce the exposure of the cytoplasmic membrane to this natural detergent.     

Porins of Vibrio cholerae: purification and characterization of OmpU.

Three outer membrane proteins with molecular masses of 40, 38, and 27 kDa of the hypertoxinogenic strain 569B of Vibrio cholerae have been purified to homogeneity. The synthesis of all the three proteins is regulated by the osmolarity of the growth medium. The pore-forming ability of the 40-kDa protein, OmpT, and the 38-kDa protein, OmpU, has been demonstrated by using liposomes, in which these proteins were embedded. The 27-kDa protein, OmpX, though osmoregulated, is not a porin. OmpU constitutes 30% of the total outer membrane protein when grown in the presence of 1.0% NaCl in the growth medium and 60% in the absence of NaCl. OmpU is an acidic protein and is a homotrimer of 38-kDa monomeric units. Its secondary structure contains predominantly a beta-sheet, and three to four Ca2+ ions are associated with each monomeric unit. Removal of Ca2+ irreversibly disrupts the structure and pore-forming ability of the protein. The pore size of OmpU is 1.6 nm, and the specific activity of the OmpU channel is two- to threefold higher than that of Escherichia coli porin OmpF, synthesis of which resembles that of OmpU with respect to the osmolarity of the growth medium. The pore size of OmpT, which is analogous to OmpC of E. coli, is smaller than that of OmpU. Southern blot hybridization of V. cholerae genomic DNA digested with several restriction endonucleases with nick-translated E. coli ompF as the probe revealed no nucleotide sequence homology between the ompU and ompF genes. OmpU is also not antigenically related to OmpF. Anti-OmpF antiserum, however, cross-reacted with the 45-kDa V. cholerae outer membrane protein, OmpS, the synthesis of which is regulated by the presence of maltose in the growth medium. OmpU hemagglutinated with rabbit and human blood. This toxR-regulated protein is one of the possible virulence determinants in V. cholerae (V. L. Miller and J. J. Mekalanos, J. Bacteriol. 170:2575-2583, 1988).     

Deoxycholic acid blocks vibrio cholerae OmpT but not OmpU porin

OmpT and OmpU are general diffusion porins of the human intestinal pathogen Vibrio cholerae. The sole presence of OmpT in the outer membrane sensitizes cells to the bile component deoxycholic acid, and the repression of OmpT in the intestine may play an important role in the adaptation of cells to the host environment. Here we report a novel important functional difference between the two porins, namely the sensitivity to deoxycholic acid. Single channel recordings show that submicellar concentrations of sodium deoxycholate induce time-resolved blocking events of OmpT but are devoid of any effect on OmpU. The effects are dose-, voltage-, and pH-dependent. They are elicited by deoxycholate applied to either side of the membrane, with some asymmetry in the sensitivity. The voltage dependence remains even when deoxycholate is applied symmetrically, indicating that it is intrinsic to the binding site. The pH dependence suggests that the active form is the neutral deoxycholic acid and not the negatively charged species. The results are interpreted as deoxycholic acid acting as an open-channel blocker, which may relate to deoxycholic acid permeation.     

Size and Dynamics of the Vibrio cholerae Porins OmpU and OmpT Probed by Polymer Exclusion

The trimeric OmpU and OmpT porins form large, triple-barrel hydrophilic channels in the outer membrane of the pathogen Vibrio cholerae. They have distinct pore properties, such as conductance, block by deoxycholic acid, and sensitivity to acidic pH. Their three-dimensional structures are unknown, but they share significant sequence homologies. To gain insight into the molecular basis for the distinct functional properties of these two similar porins, we carried out polymer exclusion experiments using planar lipid bilayer and patch-clamp electrophysiology. By studying the partitioning of polyethylene glycols (PEGs) of different molecular weights into each porin, we determined an effective radius of 0.55 nm and 0.43 nm for OmpU and OmpT respectively, and found an increased OmpU effective radius at acidic pH. PEGs or high buffer ionic strength promotes the appearance of single step closures in OmpU similar to the acidic-pH induced closures we documented previously. In addition, these closing events can be triggered by nonpenetrating PEGs applied asymmetrically. We believe our results support a model whereby acidic pH, high ionic strength, or exposure to PEGs stabilizes a less conductive state that corresponds to the appearance of an additional resistive element on one side of the OmpU protein and common to the three monomers.     

Properties of chemically modified porin from Escherichia coli in lipid bilayer membranes

Purified porin OmpF from Escherichia coli outer membrane was chemically modified by acetylation and succinylation of amino groups and by amidation of the carboxyl groups. Native and chemically modified porins were incorporated into lipid bilayer membranes and the permeability properties of the pores were studied. Acetylation and succinylation of the porin trimers had almost no influence on the single channel conductance in the presence of small cations and anions and the cation selectivity remained essentially unchanged as compared with the native porin. Amidation had also only little influence on the single channel conductance and changed the pore conductance at maximum by less than 50%, whereas the cation selectivity of the porin is completely lost after amidation. The results suggest that the structure of the porin pore remains essentially unchanged after chemical modification of the pores and that their cation selectivity is caused by an excess of negatively charged groups inside the pore and/or on the surface of the protein. Furthermore, it seems very unlikely that the pore contains any positively charged group at neutral pH.     

Identification of the pore-forming region of the outer chloroplast envelope protein OEP16

The chloroplast outer envelope protein OEP16 forms a cation-selective high conductance channel with permeability to amines and amino acids. The region of OEP16 directly involved in channel formation has been identified by electrophysiological analysis of a selection of reconstituted OEP16 mutants. Because analysis of these mutants depended on the use of recombinant protein, we evaluated the electrophysiological properties of OEP16 isolated directly from pea chloroplasts and of the recombinant protein produced in Escherichia coli. The results show that the basic properties like conductance, selectivity, and open probability of the channel formed by native pea OEP16 are comparable with the channel activity formed by the recombinant source of the protein. Following electrophysiological analysis of OEP16 mutants we found that point mutations and insertion of additional amino acid residues in the region of the putative helix 1 (Glu(73) to Val(91)) did not change the properties of the OEP16 channel. The only exception was a Cys(71)-->Ser mutation, which led to a loss of the CuCl(2) sensitivity of the channel. Analysis of N- and C-terminal deletion mutants of OEP16 and mutants containing defined shuffled domains indicated that the minimal continuous region of OEP16, which is able to form a channel in liposomes, lies in the first half of the protein between amino acid residues 21 and 93.     

Refolding and functional assembly of the Vibrio cholerae porin OmpU recombinantly expressed in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli

OmpU is one of the major outer membrane porins of Vibrio cholerae. OmpU has been biochemically characterized previously for its 'porin'-property. However, previous studies have used the OmpU protein extracted from the bacterial outer membrane envelope fractions. Such method of isolation imposes limitations on the availability of the protein reagent, and also enhances the possibility of the OmpU preparation being contaminated with lipid molecules of bacterial outer membrane origin, especially lipopolysaccharides (LPS). Here we report a strategy of purifying the V. cholerae OmpU protein recombinantly overexpressed in heterologous protein expression system in Escherichia coli, without its being incorporated into the bacterial membrane fraction. In our strategy, the majority of the protein was expressed as insoluble inclusion body in the E. coli cytoplasm, the protein was dissolved by denaturation in 8M urea, refolded, and purified to homogeneity in presence of detergent. Our strategy allowed isolation of the recombinant OmpU protein with significantly enhanced yield as compared to that of the wild type protein extracted from the V. cholerae membrane fraction. The recombinant V. cholerae OmpU protein generated in our study displayed functional channel-forming property in the synthetic liposome membrane, thus confirming its 'porin'-property. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report showing an efficient refolding and functional assembly of the V. cholerae OmpU porin recombinantly expressed as inclusion body in the cytoplasm of a heterologous host E. coli.     

Modulation of Vibrio cholerae porin function by acidic pH

The outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria contains porins, large pore-forming proteins which allow the traffic of hydrophilic compounds between the external medium and the periplasm. The oral mode of infection of Vibrio cholerae, the agent of cholera, implies that the bacteria must adapt to severe changes in the environment, such as acidic pH and the presence of bile. Because of their localization and the regulation of their expression in response to these external factors, the OmpU and OmpT porins of V. cholerae are thought to be involved in the adaptation of the bacteria to the host environment. Using patch clamp and planar lipid bilayer electrophysiology, we assessed the effect of pH on the channel properties of OmpU and OmpT. OmpT does not show any major modification in its activity between pH 4 and pH 7.2. In the case of OmpU, the effect of acidic pH is manifested by promoting single-step closures, whose duration, frequency and current size increase as pH is lowered, thereby producing a pH-dependent decrease in the channel open probability. Surprisingly, the increase in current size of this single-step closure is not coupled with an increase of the total current through the porin, indicating that the trimeric conductance remains unchanged. This observation suggests that coordinated events take place at the level of the trimer, and various explanations for this peculiar effect of acidic pH on porin gating and conductance are provided.     

Identification of positively charged residues of FomA porin of Fusobacterium nucleatum which are important for pore function.

FomA porin is the major outer-membrane protein of Fusobacterium nucleatum. It exhibits the functional properties of a general diffusion porin, but has no sequence similarity to other porins. According to the proposed topology model, each monomer of this trimeric protein is a beta-barrel consisting of 16 transmembrane segments with eight surface-exposed loops. Several conserved charged residues are proposed to extend from the beta-barrel wall into the aqueous channel lumen, and may contribute to a transverse electric field similar to that at the pore constriction of porins with known structure. The goal of our study was to identify particular basic residues contributing to such an electric field in FomA. Several arginines and lysines were replaced by negatively charged glutamates or uncharged alanines. The mutated FomA porins were expressed in Escherichia coli, and the effects on pore function were studied in vivo, by assaying the uptake rate of beta-lactam antibiotics, and in vitro after reconstitution of the purified proteins in lipid bilayer membranes. Some of the point mutations had a significant impact on the channel properties. The substitution R92A produced a 130% increased permeability of the zwitterionic beta-lactam cephaloridine, and the cation selectivity of R92E increased by 70%. The effects of the R90E substitution on channel properties were similar. Most of the point mutations had a minor effect on the voltage gating of the FomA channel, resulting in an increased sensitivity, except for K78E, which showed a decreased sensitivity. The latter mutation had no effect on cation selectivity, but the K78A substitution improved the uptake rate of cephaloridine. The results presented here indicate that arginines 90 and 92 are probably part of the constriction zone of the FomA porin, and lysine 78 and arginines 115 and 117 are probably in close proximity to this region as well.     

Effects of conjugated and unconjugated bile acids on the activity of the Vibrio cholerae porin OmpT

During infection, the enteric pathogen Vibrio cholerae encounters a bile-containing environment. Previous studies have shown that bile and/or bile acids exert several effects on the virulence and physiology of the bacterial cells. These observations have led to the suggestion that bile acids may play a signaling role in infection. We have previously reported that the bile component deoxycholic acid blocks the general diffusion porin OmpT in a dose-dependent manner, presumably as it transits through the pore. V. cholerae colonizes the distal jejunum and ileum, where a mixture of various conjugated and unconjugated bile acids are found. In this work, we have used patch clamp electrophysiology to investigate the effects of six bile acids on OmpT. Two bile acids (deoxycholic and chenodeoxycholic acids) were found to block OmpT at physiological concentrations below 1 mM, while glycodeoxycholic acid was mildly effective and cholic, lithocholic and taurodeoxycholic acids were ineffective in this range. The block was also voltage-dependent. These observations suggest the presence of a specific binding site inside the OmpT pore. Since deconjugation is due to the activity of the endogenous flora, the preferential uptake of some unconjugated bile acids by OmpT may signal the presence of a hospitable environment. The results are also discussed in terms of the possible molecular interactions between the penetrating bile acid molecule and the channel wall.     

Outer-membrane protein PhoE from Escherichia coli forms anion-selective pores in lipid-bilayer membranes

Porin PhoE of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli was isolated and purified. Reconstitution experiments with lipid bilayer membranes showed that this protein formed pores which had a single channel conductance of 210 pS at 0.1 M KCl. The PhoE pores were obviously not voltage-controlled or regulated. In contrast to pores formed by the OmpF porin from E. coli the PhoE channel was found to be anion-selective at neutral pH. Chloride is about three to ten times more permeable through the pore than alkali ions. On the basis of the observed pH dependence of the permeability ratio of anions and cations, this anionic selectivity is explained by the assumption that the PhoE pore contains an excess of fixed positive charges.     

Brownian dynamics simulation of ion flow through porin channels

Bacterial porins, which allow the passage of solutes across the outer bacterial membrane, are structurally well characterized. They therefore lend themselves to detailed studies of the determinants of ion flow through transmembraneous channels. In a comparative study, we have performed Brownian dynamics simulations to obtain statistically significant transfer efficiencies for cations and anions through matrix porin OmpF, osmoporin OmpK36, phosphoporin PhoE and two OmpF charge mutants.The simulations show that the electrostatic potential at the highly charged channel constriction serves to enhance ion permeability of either cations or anions, dependent on the type of porin. At the same time translocation of counterions is not severely impeded. At the constriction, cations and anions follow distinct trajectories, due to the segregation of basic and acidic protein residues.Simulated ion selectivity and relative conductance agree well with experimental values, and are dependent crucially on the charge constellation at the pore constriction. The experimentally observed decrease in ion selectivity and single channel conductance with increasing ionic strength is well reproduced and can be attributed to electrostatic shielding of the pore lining.     

Ion selectivity reversal and induction of voltage-gating by site-directed mutations in the Paracoccus denitrificans porin

The porin from Paracoccus denitrificans, a slightly anion specific outer membrane pore protein, was expressed in Escherichia coli, isolated from inclusion bodies, and refolded in the presence of urea and detergents. The purified recombinant protein was reconstituted into black lipid bilayer membranes and showed no difference in its functional properties in comparison to the native porin isolated from P.denitrificans membranes. To investigate the molecular basis of its ion selectivity and voltage-gating, a series of site-directed mutants was constructed, comprising acidic residues located on the third extracellular loop (L3), which forms the constriction zone of the channel, and basic residues along the opposing barrel wall. Measurements using zero-current membrane potentials indicated that the selectivity changed drastically from a slight anion to a distinct cation selectivity with the exchange of residues R29 and R31 by glutamate, whereas replacements on the L3 loop went largely unaffected. However, when assaying the voltage-dependent closure of channels, only mutations located on the L3 loop showed an effect, in contrast to the voltage-independent recombinant and native Paracoccus porin.     

Role of charged residues at the OmpF porin channel constriction probed by mutagenesis and simulation

The channel constriction of OmpF porin, a pore protein in the bacterial outer membrane, is highly charged due to the presence of three arginines (R42, R82, and R132) and two acidic residues (D113 and E117). The influence of these charges on ion conductance, ion selectivity, and voltage gating has been studied with mutants D113N/E117Q, R42A/R82A/R132A/D113N/E117Q, and V18K/G131K, which were designed to remove or add protein charge at the channel constriction. The crystal structures revealed no or only local changes compared to wild-type OmpF, thus allowing a comparative study. The single-channel conductance of the isosteric D113N/E117Q variant was found to be 2-fold reduced, and that of the pentuple mutant was 70% of the wild-type value, despite a considerably larger pore cross section. Ion selectivity was drastically altered by the mutations with cation/anion permeability ratios ranging from 1 to 12. Ion flow through these and eight other mutants, which have been characterized previously, was simulated by Brownian dynamics based on the detailed crystal structures. The calculated ion selectivity and relative channel conductance values agree well with the experimental data. This demonstrates that ion translocation through porin is mainly governed by pore geometry and charge, the two factors that are properly represented in the simulations.     

Ionic selectivity of pores formed by the matrix protein (porin) of Escherichia coli.

Incorporation of the matrix protein (porin) from the outer membrane of Escherichia coli into black lipid films results in the formation of ion-permeable pores with a single-pore conductance of the order of 2 nS (in 1 M KCl). Information on the structure of this pore has been obtained by determining the selectivity for various species differing in charge and size. From the permeability of the pore for large organic ions (Tris+, glucosamine+, Hepes-) a minimum pore diameter of 0.8 nm is estimated. At neutral pH the pore is two to four times more permeable for alkali ions than for chloride. On the basis of the observed pH dependence of permeability, this cationic selectivity is explained by the assumption that the pore contains fixed negative charges.     

Chemical modification of the bacterial porin OmpF: gain of selectivity by volume reduction

OmpF is an essentially nonselective porin isolated from the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. Here we report on the manipulation of the ion selectivity of OmpF by chemical modification with MTS reagents (MTSET, MTSEA, and MTSES) and the (rather bulky) tripeptide glutathione, all cysteine specific. When recorded in a gradient of 0.1//1 M CaCl2 or 0.1//1 M NaCl, pH 7.4 solutions, measured reversal potentials of the most cation-selective modified mutants were (virtually) identical to the Nernst potential of Ca2+ or Na+. Compared to this full cation selectivity, the anion-selective modified mutants performed somewhat less but nevertheless showed high anion selectivity. We conclude that a low permanent charge in combination with a narrow pore can render the same selectivity as a highly charged but wider pore. These results favor the view that both the electrostatic potential arising form the fixed charge in the pore and the space available at the selectivity filter contribute to the charge selection (i.e., cation versus anion selectivity) of a biological ion channel.     

A new mechanism of antibiotic resistance in Enterobacteriaceae induced by a structural modification of the major porin

In Enterobacter aerogenes, multidrug resistance involves a decrease in outer membrane permeability associated with changes in an as yet uncharacterized porin. We purified the major porin from the wild-type strain and a resistant strain. We characterized this porin, which was found to be an OmpC/OmpF-like protein and analysed its pore-forming properties in lipid bilayers. The porin from the resistant strain was compared with the wild-type protein and we observed (i) that its single-channel conductance was 70% lower than that of the wild type; (ii) that it was three times more selective for cations; (iii) a lack of voltage sensitivity. These results indicate that the clinical strain is able to synthesize a modified porin that decreases the permeability of the outer membrane. Mass spectrometry experiments identified a G to D mutation in the putative loop 3 of the porin. Given the known importance of this loop in determining the pore properties of porins, we suggest that this mutation is responsible for the novel resistance mechanism developed by this clinical strain, with changes in porin channel function acting as a new bacterial strategy for controlling beta-lactam diffusion via porins.     

One single lysine residue is responsible for the special interaction between polyphosphate and the outer membrane porin PhoE of Escherichia coli

Site-directed mutagenesis was performed with the phosphate starvation-inducible outer membrane porin PhoE of Escherichia coli K-12 to study the molecular basis of its anion selectivity. Lysines 18, 29, 64, and 125 were replaced by glutamic acids, and the properties of the mutant porins were investigated in in vivo and in vitro experiments. Lipid bilayer experiments showed that all these mutations had no influence on the pore structure because PhoE and the mutants had the same single channel conductance in KCl solution. Selectivity measurements revealed that the mutations changed the ionic selectivity of PhoE, but the change was dependent on the location of the lysine. Replacement of Lys18 and Lys29 by glutamic acid had a relatively small influence. The effect of the Lys64 substitution was somewhat larger, and the effect of the replacement of Lys125 resulted in the most drastic change in selectivity and in the loss of the interaction of PhoE with polyphosphate, whereas the replacement of the other lysines had no effect on the polyphosphate interaction behavior. The results are consistent with the assumption that the charge spot in PhoE consists of only 1 lysine per monomer, located in position 125 of the primary sequence and probably close to the pore interior.