Application of real-time PCR assay for detection and quantification of Alexandrium tamarense and Alexandrium catenella cysts from marine sediments

The dinoflagellates Alexandrium tamarense (Lebor) Balech and Alexandrium catenella (Whedon and Kofoid) Balech (Dinophyceae) are believed to be the main species responsible for paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) all over the world. It is necessary to identify A. tamarense and A. catenella cysts and to monitor their distribution in sediment in order to minimize the damages caused by PSP to the economy and food quality because cysts are the seed population for blooms caused by motile vegetative cells. In this study, we developed an efficient DNA extraction method from the natural cysts present in marine sediments after they were size fractionated with a plankton net (mesh size of 20–150 μm). The 10–3000 cysts were added to the sediments collected from the Ariake Sea, and for which the primuline-staining method did not reveal any cysts. DNA was then extracted from each sample, and linear standard curves for A. tamarense and A. catenella cysts were obtained from the correlation between the Ct values by real-time PCR and the log of the initial densities of cysts. We monitored the A. tamarense and A. catenella cyst densities in the environmental samples. This assay was demonstrated to be a powerful tool for the identification, detection, and quantification of the cysts of the toxic dinoflagellates.     

Probable origin and toxin profile of Alexandrium tamarense (Lebour) Balech from southern Brazil

The distribution of the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense Lebour has apparently expanded within the southern hemisphere during the last 2 decades. Toxic blooms of A. tamarense were recorded in Argentinean coastal waters since 1980; however, the first documented bloom in southern Brazil was in 1996. In this study, 13 strains of A. tamarense from southern Brazil were isolated and kept in culture. Phylogenetic analysis using RFLP and DNA sequences of the D1–D2 region of large subunit ribosomal DNA (rDNA) clearly indicates that Brazilian strains are most closely related to other South American strains. The strains from South America are placed firmly within a phylogenetic clade which contains strains from North America, northern Europe and northern Asia, previously called the North American clade. Possible dispersal hypotheses are discussed. The cultures were also analyzed for saxitoxin and its derivatives by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The main saxitoxin groups found were the low toxicity N-sulfocarbamoyl group, C1, 2 (30–84%), followed by the high potency carbamate toxins, gonyautoxins 1, 4 (6.6–55%), gonyautoxins 2, 3 (0.3–29%), neosaxitoxin (1.4–24%) and saxitoxin (0–4.4%). The toxin composition is similar to that of other strains from South America, supporting a close relationship between A. tamarense from southern Brazil and other areas of South America. Toxicity values were variable (7.07–65.92 pg STX cell⁻¹), with the higher range falling among the most toxic values recorded for cultures of A. tamarense, indicating the significant risk for shellfish contamination and human intoxication during blooms of this species along the southern Brazilian coast.     

AC29: the most abundant protein of Alexandrium catenella and its potential use in encystment/excystment studies

The objective of this research was to characterize specific protein(s) from Alexandrium catenella to evaluate its use as markers for specific physiological functions. To identify such protein(s) we concentrated our efforts on characterizing proteins with a high level of expression in vegetative cells of A. catenella. The electrophoretic analysis of a total protein cell extract showed the presence of a very abundant 29 kDa protein that we have named AC29. Analysis by 2D SDS-PAGE shows that the 29 kDa band contains one abundant protein (AC29) and various less abundant polypeptides, suggesting the presence of either different proteins with similar molecular weight or isoforms of AC29 protein. Ultracytolocalization using antibodies raised against gel purified AC29 indicates that this protein localizes within the chloroplast and that it is associated with thylakoid membranes, as well as with other membranes surrounding the chloroplast. Western blot analysis of cells grown under light starvation shows that the expression of the AC29 protein is down regulated. A similar analysis shows that this protein is not expressed in natural cysts or by isolated intracellular bacterium. The amino terminus of the AC29 protein that was recovered from 2D SDS-PAGE was sequenced. The sequence shows homology to the peridinin-chlorophyll a-protein from the marine organisms Alexandrium cohorticula, Amphidinium carterae and Symbiodinium. Based on these results, we suggest that the AC29 protein has the potential of being used as a marker for A. catenella encystment and excystment processes.     

Immunolocalization of theca antigens on Alexandrium catenella and their use to isolate cells from fixed phytoplankton samples

Murine monoclonal antibodies were generated and selected for their ability to specifically recognize theca antigens of Alexandrium catenella (Whedon et Kafoid) Balech cells. The specificity of the monoclonal antibodies for theca antigens was shown by indirect immunofluorescence and by confocal microscopic analysis. Using these antibodies we demonstrate, for the first time, the presence of different theca antigens on the cell surface. The fluorescent signal analysis suggests that these antigens differ in their distribution and quantities in the theca.Also, using the antibodies we developed a rapid method to isolate A. catenella cells from a lugol-fixed phytoplanktonic sample. The method uses a mixture of different monoclonal antibodies to bind the cells, which then are pulled off from the sample by means of a second anti-mouse antibody coupled to 0.8 μm magnetic beads.     

Growth and toxin production in batch cultures of a marine dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense HK9301 isolated from the South China Sea

Nutritional and environmental conditions were characterized for a batch culture of the marine dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense HK9301 isolated from the South China Sea for its growth (cells ml⁻¹), cellular toxin content (Qt in fmol cell⁻¹) and toxin composition (mol%). Under a nutrient replete condition, Qt increased with cell growth and peaked at the late stationary phase. Toxin content increased with the nitrate concentration in the culture while it reached a maximum at 5 μM phosphate. When nitrate was replaced with ammonia, Qt decreased by 4.5-fold. Salinity and light intensity were important factors affecting Qt. The latter increased two-fold over the range of salinity from 15 to 30‰, while decreased 38% as light intensity increased from 80 to 220 μE m⁻² s⁻¹. Toxin composition varied with growth phase and culture conditions. In nutrient replete cultures, toxin composition varied greatly in the early growth phase (first 3 days) and then C1/C2, C3/C4 and GTX1 remained relatively constant while GTX4 increased from 32 to 46% and GTX5 decreased from 28 to 15%. In general, the composition of GTXs was affected in a much greater extent than C toxins by changes in nutrient conditions, salinity and light intensity. This is especially true with GTX4 and GTX5. These data indicate that the cellular toxin content and toxin composition of A. tamarense HK9301 are not constant, but that they vary with growth phase and culture conditions. Use of toxin composition to identify a toxigenic marine dinoflagellate is not always valid. The data also reveal that high salinity and low light intensity, together with high nitrate and low phosphate concentrations, would favor toxin production by this species.     

Rapid detection of natural cells of Alexandrium tamarense and A. catenella (Dinophyceae) by fluorescence in situ hybridization

The marine toxic dinoflagellates Alexandrium tamarense (Lebor) Balech and A. catenella (Whedon and Kofoid) Taylor that cause paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) are identified on the basis of morphological features in routine monitoring. Rapid and simple identification is, however, often difficult because of the morphological similarity. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) using ribosomal RNA (rRNA)-targeted probes has been studied as a method of easily identifying and enumerating species responsible for harmful algal blooms (HABs). Its application to monitoring natural populations of HAB species, however, is limited. Here, we applied the FISH method to identify and enumerate cells of A. tamarense and A. catenella in natural plankton assemblages collected from Japanese coastal waters. A. tamarense-specific (Atm1) and A. catenella-specific (Act1) probes were established based on the D2 region of the large-subunit ribosomal RNA gene (28S rDNA). With these two probes, natural cells of A. tamarense or A. catenella in field samples could easily be identified when the following three conditions were met. First, cells should be concentrated by filtration, not centrifugation, in order to avoid the loss of cells. Second, autofluorescence should be minimized; acetone was an effective decolorization reagent. Third, samples should be stored at −20 or −80 °C for long-term preservation. The results indicate that FISH is a useful tool for the rapid identification of toxic Alexandrium spp. and can facilitate the analysis of numerous natural samples.     

Antibiotic treatment enhances C2 toxin production by Alexandrium tamarense in batch cultures

The effects of a mixture of penicillin G and streptomycin on the growth and C2 toxin production of a marine dinoflagellate, Alexandrium tamarense CI01, were investigated to determine if antibiotic treatment would increase the toxin yield of the cultured algae in batch cultures. Algal growth and toxin production were both enhanced markedly when the culture was supplemented with the antibiotics, each at an initial concentration of 100 unit ml⁻¹ in medium,² but were severely inhibited when the concentration was 500 unit ml⁻¹ or higher. Short-term pretreatment of algal inocula with the antibiotics at 100, 500, and 1000 unit ml⁻¹ all produced the enhancing effects on the algal cultures in an autoclaved medium. A prolonged antibiotic pretreatment of the algal culture followed by repeated sterile cultivation resulted in an algal culture free of cultivable bacteria. This “drug-treated” culture became more resistant to the toxicity and more responsive to the enhancing effects of the antibiotics. Our results indicated that the antibiotics can enhance growth and C2 toxin productivity not only through their inhibition of the growth of bacteria that compete for nutrients with the coexisting algae, but also through their direct effects on the physiology of the algae. Supplementation of the two antibiotics therefore is an efficient way to increase the yield of C2 toxin in the production cultures of A. tamarense CI01.     

Effect of five chinese traditional medicines on the biological activity of a red-tide causing alga—Alexandrium tamarense

The activity of algal cells plays an important role in the development of a red tide. Thus, when mass sedimentation of algae occurs, the scale of the red tide is reduced to some degree. Using cell suspension ability as an indicator, we studied the inhibitory effect of five Chinese traditional medicines/Chinese herbs on the activity of the red tide causing alga, Alexandrium tamarense, strain DH01. The results showed that among the five herbs, golden thread (Rhizoma coptidis Huang Lian) and areca seed (Semen arecae Bing Lang) had the best inhibitory effect, followed by indigowoad (Isatis tinctoria L.), and the least effect was found in lightyellow sophora (Sophora flavescens Ait.) and chameleon plant (Houttuynia cordata Thunb.). The 1hLC₅₀ of golden thread and areca seed was 0.054% (w/v) and 0.074% (w/v), respectively. Moreover, the higher the concentration of the herbs, the higher the inhibitory rate (IR), and the shorter reaction time needed. Combination of two herbs improved, to some extent, the inhibitory effect on the algae. A mixture of golden thread and areca seed was the most effective treatment against cell mobility of this red tide alga, and the 1 h inhibitory rate was 70.7%. Next most effective was the combination of indigowoad root and lightyellow sophora. The best inhibition results in the experiments using absorbents were golden thread and indigowoad with aloe (Aloe vera L. var. chinensis (Haw.) Berg.); followed by areca seed with aloe, and golden thread and areca seed with kelp (Laminaria japonica). In general, the zeolite based algal inhibitors were less effective. The inhibitory rates of the algal inhibitors LA, LI, KG, KA and KG were all above 90%, and remained high for 72 h. Our research results showed that the red tide inhibitors made with Chinese herbs, such as golden thread and areca seed, had the merits of low concentration, fast reaction time, and demonstrated a promising future for use in the control of red tides.     

Effects of winds, tides and river water runoff on the formation and disappearance of the Alexandrium tamarense bloom in Hiroshima Bay, Japan

Effects of winds, tides and river water runoff on the formation and disappearance of Alexandrium tamarense blooms in Hiroshima Bay, Japan were investigated using data from March to June of 1992–1998. The north wind at the initial growth phase of A. tamarense appeared to have prevented bloom formation by dispersing the organism offshore and/or through turbulent mixing. The decrease in the cell density at the end of the blooms was significantly affected by tidal mixing, indicating that the turbulent mixing induced by tidal excursions may be one of the factors terminating the bloom. Box model analyses applied to the data collected from the observations in 1996 and 1997 showed that river water runoff apparently dispersed the bloom, implying that stratification of the water column due to river water runoff is not necessary for the bloom formation. In conclusion, calm conditions with less wind and tidal mixing along with less river water runoff are considered to be important for the formation of the A. tamarense bloom in Hiroshima Bay, Japan.     

Use of PCR and partial sequencing of the large-subunit rRNA gene to identify Alexandrium catenella (Dinophyceae) from the South of Chile

A fragment of the large-subunit ribosomal DNA gene (LSU rDNA) from Chilean Alexandrium catenella clones isolated from two different geographic regions (XI and XII) was amplified by PCR and the products cloned and sequenced. Based on the analysis of the PCR products it is possible to distinguish two strains of A. catenella, denominated strain type 1 (a single PCR product band) and strain type 2 (two PCR product bands). These two strains proliferate in both, the XI and XII regions. Only in the XI region, there is evidence that they bloom simultaneously. The LSU rDNA sequence analysis indicate that the Chilean A. catenella isolated clones are more related to the North American ribotype-Western subribotype.     

Toxin profile of Alexandrium catenella from the Chilean coast as determined by liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection and liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry

The profile of tetrahydropurine neurotoxins associated with paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) was determined from a Chilean strain of the marine dinoflagellate Alexandrium catenella. The toxin composition was compared with that of toxic shellfish, presumably contaminated by natural blooms of A. catenella from the same region in southern Chile. Ion pair-liquid chromatography with post-column derivatization and fluorescence detection (LC-FD) was employed for relative quantitative analysis of the toxin components, whereas unambiguous identification of the toxins was confirmed by tandem mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS). In the dinoflagellate strain from Chile, the N-sulfocarbamoyl derivatives (C1/C2, B1) and the carbamoyl gonyautoxins GTX1/GTX4 comprise >90% of the total PSP toxin content on a molar basis. This toxin composition is consistent with that determined for A. catenella populations from the Pacific coast in the northern hemisphere. The characteristic toxin profile is also reflected in the shellfish, but with evidence of epimerization and metabolic transformations of C1 and C2 to GTX2 and GTX3, respectively. This work represents the first unequivocal identification and confirmation of such PSP toxin components from the Chilean coast.     

Intracellular damage and death caused by protease inhibitors on Alexandrium catenella natural cysts and vegetative cells

Proteases from a Chilean clone of Alexandrium catenella were studied using gelatin–zymogram gel and protease fluorescent substrate to facilitate their visual identification in vitro and in vivo, respectively. Proteolytic activity bands were grouped arbitrarily according to their molecular weight as P1 (150 and 120 kDa), P2 (100 kDa), P3 (70 and 65 kDa), P4 (60, 55 and 50 kDa) and P5 (25 kDa). Protease inhibitors affect differentially P2 and P3 proteases. Only P2 activity increased in the presence of 1–10 phenanthroline (σPhe), pepstatin A (pepA), leupeptin (leup) and phenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride (PMSF), while P2 and P3 become inactivated with ρ-aminobenzamidine. The protease inhibitors lethal dose was determined by incubating cells with different concentration of the protease inhibitor and evaluating their effect on cell viability. Furthermore, cells treated for 4 h with one lethal dose of 1–10 phenanthroline and ρ-aminobenzamidine, caused serious damage to the intracellular vacuolar system and nuclear material. Live cysts also die when treated independently with these two protease inhibitors. Future work will be aimed at chemically designing species-specific inhibitors for their potential use in killing cysts transported within the sediment of ship ballast water before washing them off to the environment.     

Non-toxic and toxic subclones obtained from a toxic clonal culture of Alexandrium tamarense (Dinophyceae): Toxicity and molecular biological feature

Alexandrium tamarense (Lebour) Taylor strain OF935-AT6 is a rare strain of paralytic shellfish toxin (PST)-producing dinoflagellate, in which non-toxic and toxic cells are found in an approximately 1:1 ratio, isolated in Japan. The non-toxic characteristics of UAT-014-009, an axenic non-toxic subclone of OF935-AT6, have been confirmed at the attomole per cell level. Three out of nine toxic subclones of OF935-AT6 became non-toxic over a relatively short period of time (4–6 years), while the other toxic subclones retained their toxicity and the non-toxic subclones retained to be non-toxic. Two axenic subclones from OF935-AT6, UAT-014-009 (non-toxic) and Axat-2 (toxic) are indistinguishable from one another, and from popularly known A. tamarense by rDNA sequence analysis. The most significant difference identified by subtractive hybridization of cDNA pertains to gene fragments homologous with mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase polypeptide three (cox3) and cytochrome b (cob). Thus, the polymorphism targeting these regions was investigated by comparison of the gene length amplified by PCR using total DNA from other subclones with a range of toxicities. No direct correlation between any allele and toxicity was observed in this study.     

Amoebae of the genera Vannella Bovee, 1965 and Platyamoeba isolated from fish and their phylogeny inferred from SSU rRNA gene and ITS sequences

Twenty strains of flattened amoebae including 17 isolated from fish were characterised morphologically both at light microscopical and ultrastructural levels and assigned to either the genus Vannella Bovee, 1965 or the genus Platyamoeba Page, 1969. Sequence-based phylogenetic analyses of SSU rRNA genes from a data set representing a total of 29 strains of flattened amoebae strongly indicated that morphological features discriminating between these genera do not reflect phylogenetic relationships of representative strains. Contrary to a previous study, strains of this expanded assemblage formed clusters that did not reflect their environmental origin. Monophyletic groups were of mixed origins and contained freshwater as well as marine strains of both genera isolated in geographically distant localities of various continents. These findings were supported by results of phylogenetic analyses of selected strains based on ITS sequences. However, topologies of acquired ITS trees were not congruent with results inferred from SSU rRNA analyses.     

Morphological and genetic study of Prorocentrum donghaiense Lu from the East China Sea, and comparison with some related Prorocentrum species

In this paper, the detailed morphology of Prorocentrum donghaiense Lu from both field samples and cultures was examined, and a taxonomic comparison was made between P. donghaiense and some related Prorocentrum spp. using morphological and molecular data and other published information. There were distinct differences among these species in morphological characteristics that historically have been presented as conservative features. The discrepancies extended beyond that of individual variations within the same species due to environmental factors. Therefore, these morphological features may not be conservative but, rather, polymorphic depending on environmental conditions. Based on this analysis, we suggest that the high-biomass bloom-forming species in the East China Sea, previously reported as Prorocentrum dentatum Stein, is P. donghaiense Lu. The species reported from the East China Sea and Japanese and Korean waters appear to be the same species. Molecular data also suggest that P. dentatum (CCMP1517) and P. donghaiense are genetically identical. Therefore, the geographic distribution of P. donghaiense may be much wider than expected.     

Wind-driven river plume dynamics and toxic Alexandrium tamarense blooms in the St. Lawrence estuary (Canada): A modeling study

In the lower St. Lawrence estuary (LSLE, eastern Canada), blooms of the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense are a recurrent phenomenon, resulting in paralytic shellfish poisoning outbreaks every summer. A first coupled physical–biological model of A. tamarense blooms was developed for this system in order to explore the interactions between cyst germination, cellular growth and water circulation and to identify the effect of physical processes on bloom development and transport across the estuary. The simulated summer (1998) was characterized by an A. tamarense red tide with concentrations reaching 2.3 × 10⁶ cells L⁻¹ along the south shore of the LSLE. The biological model was built with previously observed A. tamarense cyst distribution, cyst germination rate and timing, and A. tamarense growth limitation by temperature and salinity. The coupled model successfully reproduced the timing of the A. tamarense bloom in 1998, its coincidence with the combined plumes from the Manicouagan and Aux-Outardes (M-O) rivers on the north shore of the estuary, and the temporal variations in the north-south gradients in cell concentrations. The simulation results reveal that the interaction between cyst germination and the estuarine circulation generates a preferential inoculation of the surface waters of the M-O river plume with newly germinated cells which could partly explain the coincidence of the blooms with the freshwater plume. Furthermore, the results suggest that the spatio-temporal evolution of the bloom is dominated by alternating periods of retention and advection of the M-O plume: east or north-east winds favor the retention of the plume close to the north shore while west or north-west winds result in its advection toward the south shore. The response of the simulated freshwater plume to fluctuating wind forcing controls the delivery of the A. tamarense bloom from the northern part of the estuary to the south shore. In addition, our results suggest that a long residence time of the M-O plume and associated A. tamarense population in the LSLE during the summer 1998 contributed to the development of the red tide. We thus hypothesize that the wind-driven dynamics of the M-O plume could partly determine the success of A. tamarense blooms in the LSLE by influencing the residence time of the blooms and water column stability, which in turn affects A. tamarense vertical migrations and growth.     

Intra-population clonal variability in allelochemical potency of the toxigenic dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense

Clonal variability in exponential growth rate and production of secondary metabolites was determined from clonal isolates of Alexandrium tamarense originating from a single geographical population from the east coast of Scotland. To assess variability in the selected phenotypic characteristics over a wide spectrum, 10 clones were chosen for experimentation from 67 clonal isolates pre-screened for their lytic capacity in a standardized bioassay with the cryptophyte Rhodomonas salina. Specific growth rates (μ) of the 10 clonal isolates ranged from 0.28 to 0.46 d⁻¹ and were significantly different among clones. Cell content (fmol cell⁻¹) and composition (mol%) of paralytic shellfish toxins (PSTs), analyzed by liquid chromatography with fluorescence detection (LC–FD), varied widely among these isolates, with total PST quotas ranging from 20 to 89 fmol cell⁻¹. Except for strain 3, the toxins C1/C2, neosaxitoxin (NEO), saxitoxin (STX), and gonyautoxins-1 and -4 (GTX1/GTX4), were consistently the most relatively abundant, with lesser amounts of GTX2/GTX3 evident among all isolates. Only clone 3 contained >20 mol% of toxin B1, with C1/C2, GTX2/GTX3 and NEO in almost equimolar ratios.Eight of the 10 clones caused cell lysis of both R. salina and the heterotrophic dinoflagellate Oxyrrhis marina, as quantified from the dose–response curves from short-term (24 h) co-incubation bioassays. For two clones, no significant mortality even at high Alexandrium cell concentrations (ca. 10⁴ mL⁻¹) was observed. Allelochemical activity expressed as EC₅₀ values, defined as the Alexandrium cell concentration causing lysis of 50% of target cells, varied by about an order of magnitude and was significantly different among clones. No correlation was observed between growth rate und allelochemical potency (as EC₅₀) indicating that at least under non-limiting growth conditions no obvious growth reducing costs are associated with the production of allelochemically active secondary metabolites.     

Phylogeny, biogeography, and species boundaries within the Alexandrium minutum group

The geographic range and bloom frequency of the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum and other members of the A. minutum group have been increasing over the past few decades. Some of these species are responsible for paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) outbreaks throughout the world. The origins of new toxic populations found in previously unaffected areas are typically not known due to a lack of reliable plankton records with sound species identifications and to the lack of a global genetic database. This paper provides the first comprehensive study of minutum-group morphology and phylogeny on a global scale, including 45 isolates from northern Europe, the Mediterranean, Asia, Australia and New Zealand.Neither the morphospecies Alexandrium lusitanicum nor A. angustitabulatum was recoverable morphologically, due to large variation within and among all minutum-group clonal strains in characters previously used to distinguish these species: the length:width of the anterior sulcal plate, shape of the 1′ plate, connection between the 1′ plate and the apical pore complex, and the presence of a ventral pore. DNA sequence data from the D1 to D2 region of the LSU rDNA also fail to recognize these species. Therefore, we recommend that all isolates previously designated as A. lusitanicum or A. angustitabulatum be redesignated as A. minutum. A. tamutum, A. insuetum, and A. andersonii are clearly different from A. minutum on the basis of both genetic and morphological data.A. minutum strains from Europe and Australia are closely related to one another, which may indicate an introduction from Europe to Australia given the long history of PSP in Europe and its recent occurrence in Australia. A minutum from New Zealand and Taiwan form a separate phylogenetic group. Most strains of A. minutum fit into one of these two groups, although there are a few outlying strains that merit further study and may represent new species. The results of this paper have greatly improved our ability to track the spread of A. minutum species and to understand the evolutionary relationships within the A. minutum group by correcting inaccurate taxonomy and providing a global genetic database.     

Phylogeny of Caragana (Fabaceae) based on DNA sequence data from rbcL, trnS–trnG, and ITS

Phylogenetic relationships of 48 species of Caragana (Fabaceae: tribe Hedysareae) and one representative each of Astragalus, Calophaca, Halimodendron, and Hedysarum are estimated from DNA sequences of the rbcL gene, trnS–trnG intron and spacer, and ITS region. At least one representative of all five sections and 12 series within Caragana are included. Analyses yielded strongly supported clades corresponding to sections Caragana, Bracteolatae, and Frutescentes. The species of section Jubatae are distributed among three strongly supported clades, i.e., one with the species of section Bracteolatae, another with two species of section Spinosae, and a third as sister to section Frutescentes. All but the last of these six clades are corroborated by at least one unambiguously traced morphological character. The placement of the other four species of section Spinosae are not well supported and lack unambiguous morphological synapomorphies, and the samples of Calophaca and Halimodendron nest within Caragana with weak support.