Mechanism of interferon action. Kinetics of decay of the antiviral state and protein phosphorylation in mouse fibroblasts treated with natural and cloned interferons

The kinetics of decay of the antiviral state and protein phosphorylation induced with natural mouse interferon (IFN) and with cloned human IFN were examined in monolayer cultures of mouse Ll929 fibroblast cells. The antiviral state measured by single cycle virus yield reduction with either vesicular stomatitis virus or reovirus decayed significantly within 2 to 3 days following removal of IFN and by 5 to 8 days virus yields had returned to the level of untreated control cells. Trypsinization of IFN-treated cells did not detectably alter the rate of decay of the antiviral state; however, the decay occurred slightly more rapidly in actively growing as compared to stationary cell cultures. The decay of the IFN-induced protein kinase which catalyzes the phosphorylation of endogenous protein P1 and purified initiation factor eIF-2 alpha correlated with the decay of the antiviral state. The decay rates of the antiviral state and protein kinase observed in mouse L929 cells that had been treated with natural mouse IFN synthesized in Newcastle disease virus-induced L929 cells were comparable to the decay rates observed in L929 cells that had been treated with recombinant human IFN-alpha A/D synthesized in Escherichia coli. The induction and decay of the antiviral state and protein kinase following treatment with a single dose of IFN did not significantly affect the sensitivity of the cell population to a subsequent treatment with a single dose of IFN. However, continuous treatment of L929 cells with natural mouse IFN or recombinant human IFN prevented the decay of both the antiviral state and protein kinase but also ultimately lead to cell death. The results suggest that protein phosphorylation may play an important role in the mechanism of IFN action in mouse L929 fibroblasts.     

Identification of a novel pathway essential for the immediate-early, interferon-independent antiviral response to enveloped virions

Viral infection elicits the activation of numerous cellular signal transduction pathways, leading to the induction of both innate and adaptive immunity. Previously we showed that entry of virion particles from a diverse array of enveloped virus families was capable of eliciting an interferon regulatory factor 3 (IRF-3)-mediated antiviral state in human fibroblasts in the absence of interferon production. Here we show that extracellular regulated kinase 1/2, p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase, and Jun N-terminal kinase/stress-activated protein kinase activities are not required for antiviral state induction. In contrast, treatment of cells with LY294002, an inhibitor of the phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI3 kinase) family, prevents the induction of interferon-stimulated gene 56 (ISG56) and an antiviral response upon entry of virus particles. However, the prototypic class I p85/p110 PI3 kinase and its downstream effector Akt/PKB are dispensable for ISG and antiviral state induction. Furthermore, DNA-PK and PAK1, LY294002-sensitive members of the PI3 kinase family shown previously to be involved in IRF-3 activation, are also dispensable for ISG and antiviral state induction. The LY294002 inhibitor fails to prevent IRF-3 homodimerization or nuclear translocation upon virus particle entry. Together, these data suggest that virus entry triggers an innate antiviral response that requires the activity of a novel PI3 kinase family member.     

Mechanism of interferon action. Kinetics of induction of the antiviral state and protein phosphorylation in mouse fibroblasts treated with natural and cloned interferons

The induction of phosphorylation of both protein P1 and protein synthesis initiation factor eIF-2 alpha and the inhibition of virus replication were examined in mouse L929 fibroblasts treated with either natural mouse or individual cloned human interferons (IFN). Natural mouse IFN synthesized in Newcastle disease virus-induced L929 cells and two cloned human leukocyte IFN subspecies synthesized in Escherichia coli, IFN-alpha D and IFN-alpha A/D, possessed antiviral activity in L929 cells as measured by single cycle virus yield reduction with both vesicular stomatitis virus and reovirus. Natural L929 IFN and cloned IFNs, alpha D and alpha A/D, also induced the protein kinase that catalyzed the phosphorylation of endogenous ribosome-associated protein P1 and the alpha subunit of purified initiation factor eIF-2. Two other cloned human IFNs, alpha A and alpha D/A, were poor inducers of both the antiviral state and the phosphorylation of P1 and eIF-2 alpha in mouse L929 cells. The ability of individual human IFN-alpha subspecies to induce P1 and eIF-2 alpha phosphorylation in mouse L929 cells correlated with their ability to induce an antiviral state. Furthermore, the detailed kinetics of induction, in mouse L929 cells, of P1 and eIF-2 alpha phosphorylation and of the antiviral state by the heterologous cloned human IFN-alpha A/D were equivalent to the kinetics of induction by the homologous natural mouse L929 IFN. These results suggest that different subspecies of biologically active IFN induce equivalent antiviral activities and biochemical changes in mouse L929 cells, and that protein phosphorylation may play a major role in the antiviral mechanism of IFN action in mouse L929 fibroblasts.     

Species specificity of interferon action: maintenance and establishment of the antiviral state in the presence of a heterospecific nucleus.

The expression of the interferon-induced antiviral state was studied in heterokaryons and cytoplasmic hybrids (cybrids). An autoradiographic assay for the antiviral state, in which the percentage of cells containing vaccinia viral DNA factories was determined, was used. The expression of the antiviral state was dominant in homokaryons and heterokaryons formed by fusion of interferon-treated cells with untreated cells. Cytoplasts derived from treated cells conferred resistance to virus growth on cybrids formed by fusing such cytoplasts with untreated cells. Treatment of L cell x HeLa cell heterokaryons with human interferon or mouse interferon was much less effective in inducing a detectable antiviral state than was similar treatment of parental cells with homospecific interferon. The antiviral state was fully induced when heterokaryons were treated simultaneously with both types of interferon. Cybrids formed by fusing L cell cytoplasts with HeLa cells or HeLa cytoplasts with L cells did not enter a detectable antiviral state after treatment with interferon specific for the cell type of the enucleated parent. However, treatment of cybrids with interferon specific for the cell type of the nucleated parent was effective in inducing a detectable antiviral state.     

Mouse peritoneal cells confer an antiviral state on mouse cell monolayers: role of interferon.

Vesicular stomatitis virus and encephalomyocarditis virus do not multiply in the majority of peritoneal macrophages freshly explanted from 4- to 8-week-old male or female mice. However, when peritoneal macrophages were cultivated in vitro for 3 to 5 days, these cells became permissive for both viruses. The loss of antiviral state in "aged" macrophages paralleled a significant decrease in the intracellular levels of (2'-5')oligo-adenylate synthetase activity. Although biologically active interferon was not detected in the nutrient medium of macrophage cultures, freshly harvested peritoneal cells could confer an antiviral state on monolayer cultures of mouse cells (aged macrophages, embryonic fibroblasts, and L cells) but not on heterologous chicken embryo, rabbit kidney, or human cells infected with vesicular stomatitis virus or encephalomyocarditis virus. The conferred antiviral state required at least 7 h to develop in target cells and was totally inhibited by the presence of antibody to mouse interferon alpha/beta but not to interferon gamma in the cocultures. Heterologous guinea pig and rabbit peritoneal cells could not transfer an antiviral state to target mouse cells. Donor peritoneal cells from mice preinjected with antibody to interferon alpha/beta could not transfer an antiviral state to target mouse cells. This ensemble of results indicating that freshly harvested peritoneal cells transfer interferon (which is responsible for inducing an antiviral state in susceptible mouse target cells) adds further experimental evidence that interferon is spontaneously expressed in normal mice and plays an important role in maintaining some host cells in an antiviral state.     

The relationship between the antiviral action of interferon and prostaglandins in virus-infected murine cells

The relationship between prostaglandins (PG) and interferon (IFN) was investigated. IFN induced the synthesis of immunoreactive PGE and PGA at early and late stages, respectively, of vaccinia virus infection in mouse L fibroblasts. Only species-specific IFN possessed this activity and PG synthesis was stimulated in virus-infected cells, while normal L cells were not affected. The vaccinia virus infection did not significantly alter PG synthesis in the absence of IFN. Indomethacin increased the rate of vaccinia virus replication and partially inhibited the IFN-induced protection of L cells. The addition of exogenous PGA1 only partially reversed this effect. Finally, short-term PGA treatment induced the synthesis of two enzymes (protein kinase and 2,5A synthetase) thought to be partially responsible for the antiviral action of interferon. These findings suggest that a prostaglandin or PG-related compound seems to mediate at least one aspect of IFN action.     

The role of cell membrane in the antiviral effect of interferon

The mechanism of interferon action in human fibroblasts has been studied by use of both antisera to human fibroblast interferon and the antisera to the surface of human fibroblast cell. The anti-interferon serum completely neutralized the antiviral effect of human fibroblast interferon. Interferon antiserum prevented the intracellular antiviral state from developing when added to the medium of the cells in which interferon synthesis had already been induced by poly (I · C). This suggests that development of the antiviral state involves interferon interaction with the external part of the producing cell. Treatment with the serum directed against the surface of human fibroblast cells failed to inhibit the antiviral activity of human interferon in these cells. In addition, the effect of gangliosides on the antiviral activity of human interferon was studied and it was found that human interferon binds to gangliosides and that this interaction leads to inactivation of the antiviral effect of interferon. Pretreatment of human fibroblasts with gangliosides had no effect on the sensitivity of these cells to exogenous interferon.     

The antiviral action of interferon

On interferon treatment cells develop an antiviral state. This requires time and RNA and protein synthesis. At least six polypeptides and two enzymes have been reported to be synthesized in increased amounts in response to interferon and a multiplicity of effects have been attributed to it. Interferon has been reported to inhibit virus growth at the level of the uncoating of the virus, virus RNA and protein synthesis and virus maturation. This has led to the acceptance of a multisite model for interferon action. The evidence for this and for the role of two known interferon-mediated enzymes, the 2-5A synthetase and protein kinase, are reviewed.     

Chloroquine impairs the interferon-induced antiviral state without affecting the 2',5'-oligoadenylate synthetase

Chloroquine, a weak base which raises the pH in acidic cellular compartments such as lysosomes and endosomes, counteracts the induction by interferon of the antiviral state but not that of the 2',5'-oligoadenylate synthetase in three different types of cell lines (MDBK, WISH, and L929). Active interferon is recovered in crude extracts of cells which have been treated with interferon and chloroquine together, but not in extracts of cells treated with interferon alone, indicating that chloroquine has inhibited the intralysosomal proteolysis of interferon. A low pH-dependent event in the intracellular fate of interferon (perhaps its intralysosomal degradation) is, therefore, necessary for the establishment of the antiviral state but not for the induction of the 2',5'-oligoadenylate synthetase.     

Interferon-associated, dsRNA-dependent enzyme activities in a mutant 3T6 cell engaged in the semiconstitutive synthesis of interferon

Cytoplasmic extracts of untreated cultures of a virus-resistant mutant of mouse 3T6 cells, designated 3T6-VrB2, contain two double-stranded, RNA-activated enzyme activities associated with interferon action. These are the synthesis of a low molecular weight oligonucleotide inhibitor of cell-free protein synthesis from ATP, and the phosphorylation of a 67,000 dalton polypeptide by transfer of the gamma phosphate of ATP. Basal levels of both enzyme activities are detectable in extracts of untreated parental 3T6 cells, and are greatly enhanced upon interferon pretreatment. A procedure was developed, using a nonionic detergent to effect cell lysis, which allowed the analysis of the protein kinase activity from as few as 2 x 10(7) cells. Using this procedure, direct proportionalities were demonstrated between the concentration of interferon to which 3T6 cells were exposed, and both the level of protein kinase activity and the magnitude of the antiviral state were established in these cells. Furthermore, untreated cultures of 3T6-VrB2 exhibited both an antiviral state and an intracellular protein kinase activity equal to that of cultures of the parental 3T6 cells pretreated with a single concentration of mouse interferon.     

Interferon-induced antiviral state is inhibited by neomycin and mimicked by diacylglycerols

The antiviral effect of human interferons alpha and beta was inhibited in dose-dependent manner by submillimolar concentrations of neomycin, known to block phosphoinositide hydrolysis and therefore the diacylglycerol formation. On the contrary, the synthetic permeant diacylglycerols (1-oleoyl-2-acetyl-sn or rac-glycerol) were able to induce an interferon-like antiviral state when tested against the vesicular stomatitis virus and herpes simplex type I virus. Hidaka's compound H-8 (1.2 microM), expected to inhibit cAMP- and cGMP-dependent protein kinases, did not modify the antiviral effect of interferon. Our data suggest that the phosphoinositide pathway is involved in transducing the interferon antiviral signal, but, since the exogenous phospholipase C (0.1-1 U/ml) failed to induce an antiviral state, this pathway, although implicated, seems not the only one.     

The latent membrane protein 1 of Epstein-Barr virus establishes an antiviral state via induction of interferon-stimulated genes

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infection is associated with several human cancers. Latent membrane protein 1 (LMP-1) is one of the key viral proteins required for transformation of primary B cells in vitro and establishment of EBV latency. In this report, we show that LMP-1 is able to induce the expression of several interferon (IFN)-stimulated genes (ISGs) with antiviral properties such as 2'-5' oligoadenylate synthetase (OAS), stimulated trans-acting factor of 50 kDa (STAF-50), and ISG-15. LMP-1 inhibits vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) replication at low multiplicity of infection (0.1 pfu/cell). The antiviral effect of LMP-1 is associated with the ability of LMP-1 to induce ISGs; an LMP-1 mutant that cannot induce ISGs fails to induce an antiviral state. High levels of ISGs are expressed in EBV latency cells in which LMP-1 is expressed. EBV latency cells have antiviral activity that inhibits replication of superinfecting VSV. The antiviral activity of LMP-1 is apparently not related to IFN production in our experimental systems. In addition, EBV latency is responsive to viral superinfection: LMP-1 is induced and EBV latency is disrupted by EBV lytic replication during VSV superinfection of EBV latency cells. These data suggest that LMP-1 has antiviral effect, which may be an intrinsic part of EBV latency program to assist the establishment and/or maintenance of EBV latency.     

Microinjection of anti-interferon antibodies into cells does not inhibit the induction of an antiviral state by interferon.

Affinity-purified polyclonal antibodies directed against human lymphoblastoid interferon (IFN), Escherichia coli-derived human IFN-alpha 2, or two synthetic fragments of human IFN-alpha 1 all neutralized the antiviral activity of human alpha IFNs when added to the culture medium of MDBK cells together with IFNs. However, when these antibodies were microinjected into the cytoplasm or the nucleus of cells, subsequent treatment of the cells with IFNs induced full protection against vesicular stomatitis virus. This suggests that IFNs themselves need not act in the cytoplasmic compartment or the nucleus to induce an antiviral state.     

The role of interferon-beta 1 and the 26-kDa protein (interferon-beta 2) as mediators of the antiviral effect of interleukin 1 and tumor necrosis factor

This study confirms our earlier finding that human interleukin (IL)-1 beta exerts an antiviral effect on diploid fibroblasts and on MG-63 osteosarcoma cells. It also extends the observation in that a similar effect was noted on aged but not freshly trypsinized HEp-2 cells, and that not only IL-1 beta but also IL-1 alpha and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha exerted similar antiviral effects on cells. The antiviral effects of these cytokines were neutralized by addition to the assay system of an antibody that was specific for interferon (IFN)-beta 1, indicating that IFN-beta 1 or a structurally or functionally related substance is involved in the antiviral activity observed. Both IL-1 and TNF were able to induce production of the 26-kDa protein, also known as IFN-beta 2, hybridoma/plasmacytoma growth factor (HPGF) or B-cell stimulatory factor-2 (BSF-2) and previously proposed as an alternative to IFN-beta 1 for mediating the antiviral effect of TNF. However, no good correlation was found between the antiviral effects of TNF and its potential to induce production of the 26-kDa protein. Furthermore, the anti-IFN-beta 1 serum which neutralized the antiviral activity of IL-1 and TNF did not cross-react with the 26-kDa protein. Conversely, the antiviral effect of IL-1 and TNF was only weakly neutralized by an antibody that did react with the 26-kDa protein and showed low cross-reactivity with IFN-beta 1. These observations, together with the low specific activity of the 26-kDa protein as an antiviral agent (less than 10(5) U/mg protein) provide strong arguments against this protein and in favor of IFN-beta 1 (or still another IFN-beta 1-related molecule) as the ultimate mediator of the antiviral effect of IL-1 and TNF.     

Adenovirus E4 ORF3 protein inhibits the interferon-mediated antiviral response

The PML oncogenic domain (POD/ND10/PML body) is a common target of DNA viruses, which replicate their genomes in proximity to this nuclear structure. The adenovirus early protein E4 ORF3 is both necessary and sufficient to rearrange PODs from punctate bodies into track-like structures. Although multiple hypotheses exist, the precise reason for this activity has not yet been elucidated. PML, the protein responsible for nucleating PODs, is an interferon (IFN)-stimulated gene, implicating the participation of this nuclear body in an innate antiviral response. Here, we demonstrate that E4 ORF3 is critical to the replicative success of adenovirus during the IFN-induced antiviral state. When cells are pretreated with either IFN-alpha or IFN-gamma, a mutant virus that does not express E4 ORF3 is severely compromised for replication. This result suggests the functional significance of ORF3 track formation is the inhibition of a POD-mediated, antiviral mechanism. Replication of the E4 ORF3 mutant virus can be rescued following the introduction of E4 ORF3 from evolutionarily divergent adenoviruses, suggesting a conserved function for E4 ORF3 inhibition of the IFN-induced antiviral state. Furthermore, E4 ORF3 inhibition of an IFN-induced response is unrelated to the inhibition of adenovirus replication by the Mre11-Rad50-Nbs1 DNA repair complex. We propose that the evolutionarily conserved function of the adenovirus E4 ORF3 protein is the inhibition of a host interferon response to viral infection via disruption of the PML oncogenic domain.     

Herpes simplex virus triggers and then disarms a host antiviral response

Virus infection induces an antiviral response that is predominantly associated with the synthesis and secretion of soluble interferon. Here, we report that herpes simplex virus type 1 virions induce an interferon-independent antiviral state in human embryonic lung cells that prevents plaquing of a variety of viruses. Microarray analysis of 19,000 human expressed sequence tags revealed induction of a limited set of host genes, the majority of which are also induced by interferon. Genes implicated in controlling the intracellular spread of virus and eliminating virally infected cells were among those induced. Induction of the cellular response occurred in the absence of de novo cellular protein synthesis and required viral penetration. In addition, this response was only seen when viral gene expression was inhibited, suggesting that a newly synthesized viral protein(s) may function as an inhibitor of this response.     

Inhibition of vesicular stomatitis virus replication in dexamethasone-treated L929 cells

We previously demonstrated that dexamethasone treatment of L929 cells inhibited plaque formation by vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), encephalomyocarditis virus, or vaccinia virus. We now have characterized the antiviral effects of glucocorticoids in L929 cells. Dexamethasone did not directly inactivate VSV nor did steroid treatment of L929 cells affect virion adsorption or penetration. The VSV yield in L929 cells treated with dexamethasone for a period of only 4 or 8 hr was decreased by 50% when cells were infected the day following steroid treatment. Treating L929 cells with dexamethasone for a longer period resulted in greater inhibitions of virus synthesis. Interferon activity (less than 5 units/ml) was not detected in L929 cell culture fluids and cell sonicates from steroid-treated cells and the addition of antiserum to murine alpha/beta-interferon had no effect on the ability of dexamethasone to inhibit VSV replication. Dexamethasone treatment of L929 cells did not induce the production of double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase but did result in a slight elevation of 2-5A oligoadenylate synthetase activity, two enzymatic activities associated with the antiviral state induced by interferon. However, the elevated 2-5A synthetase activity was not associated with an inhibition of VSV RNA accumulation in dexamethasone-treated L929 cells. By contrast, the synthesis of all five VSV proteins was reduced by 50-75% in dexamethasone-treated L929 cells as early as 4 hr after infection. Thus, the dexamethasone-mediated inhibition of VSV replication in L929 cells is associated with decreased production of VSV structural proteins.     

A large component of the antiviral activity of mouse interferon-gamma may be due to its induction of interferon-alpha

The finding that interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) may require two rounds of protein synthesis to induce the antiviral state raises the possibility that this IFN may not be directly antiviral. We, therefore, examined the possibility that IFN-gamma induces one or both of the other IFNs (alpha and/or beta) which in turn induce the antiviral state. Evidence is presented showing that under certain conditions a large portion of IFN-gamma's antiviral activity in mouse L-929 cells is mediated by its induction of IFN-alpha based on the findings that: 1) the antiviral activity of IFN-gamma in cells at low densities can be blocked by poly and monoclonal antibody to IFN-alpha and, 2) IFN-alpha can be demonstrated in the supernatant fluids of IFN-gamma treated cells. This report raises the possibility that a major antiviral mechanism of IFN-gamma is via induction of IFN-alpha in the mouse system. If the majority of the antiviral activity of IFN-gamma is via induction of other IFNs, then the role and mechanism of IFN-gamma might have to be reevaluated.