Monitoring denaturation behaviour and comparative stability of DNA triple helices using oligonucleotide–gold nanoparticle conjugates

Gold nanoparticle labels, combined with UV-visible optical absorption spectroscopic methods, are employed to probe the temperature-dependent solution properties of DNA triple helices. By using oligonucleotide–nanoparticle conjugates to characterize triplex denaturation, for the first time triplex to duplex melting transitions may be sensitively monitored, with minimal signal interference from duplex to single strand melting, for both parallel and antiparallel triple helices. Further, the comparative sequence-dependent stability of DNA triple helices may also be examined using this approach. Specifically, triplex to duplex melting transitions for triplexes formed using oligonucleotides that incorporate 8-aminoguanine derivatives were successfully monitored and stabilization of both parallel and antiparallel triplexes following 8-aminoguanine substitutions is demonstrated.     

Parallel and antiparallel G*G.C base triplets in pur*pur.pyr triple helices formed with (GA) third strands.

Triple helices with G*G.C and A*A.T base triplets with third GA strands either parallel or antiparallel with respect to the homologous duplex strand have been formed in presence of Na (+) or Mg(2+) counterions. Antiparallel triplexes are more stable and can be obtained even in presence of only monovalent Na(+) counterions. A biphasic melting has been observed, reflecting third strand separation around 20 degrees C followed by the duplex -> coil transition around 63 degrees C. Parallel triplexes are far less stable than the antiparallel ones. Their formation requires divalent ions and is observed at low temperature and in high concentration conditions. Different FTIR signatures of G*G.C triplets in parallel and antiparallel triple helices with GA rich third strands have been obtained allowing the identification of such base triplets in triplexes formed by nucleic acids with heterogeneous compositions. Only S-type sugars are found in the antiparallel triplex while some N-type sugar conformation is detected in the parallel triplex.     

Evidence for a DNA triplex in a recombination-like motif: I. Recognition of Watson-Crick base pairs by natural bases in a high-stability triplex

Data are presented on a triplex type with two parallel homologous strands for which triplex formation is almost as strong as duplex formation at least for some sequences and even at pH 7 and 0.2 M NaCl. The evidence mainly rests upon comparing thermodynamic properties of similar systems. A paperclip oligonucleotide d(A12C4T12C4A12) with two linkers C4 obviously can form a triplex with parallel back-folded adenine strand regions, because the single melting transition of this complex splits in two transitions by introducing mismatches only in the third strand region. Respectively, a hairpin duplex d(A12C4T12) and a single strand d(A12) form a triplex as a 1:1 complex in which the second adenine strand is parallel oriented to the homologous one in the Watson-Crick paired duplex. In this system the melting temperature T(m) of the triplex is practically the same as that of the duplex d(A12)-d(T12), at least within a complex concentration range of 0.2-4.0 microM. The melting behaviour of complexes between triplex stabilizing ligand BePI and the system hairpin duplex plus single strand supports the triplex model. Non-denaturing gel electrophoresis suggests the existence of a triplex for a system in which five of the twelve A-T*A base triads are substituted by C-G*C base triads. The recognition between any substituted Watson-Crick base pair (X-Y) in the hairpin duplex d(A4XA7C4T7YT4) and the correspondingly replaced base (Z) in the third strand d(A4ZA7) is mutually selective. All triplexes with matching base substitutions (Z = X) have nearly the same stability (T(m) values from 29 to 33.5 degrees C), whereas triplexes with non-matching substitutions (Z not equal X) show a clearly reduced stability (T(m) values from 15 to 22 degrees C) at 2microM equimolar oligonucleotide concentration. Most nucleic acid triple helices hitherto known are limited to homopurine-homopyrimidine sequences in the target duplex. A stable triplex formation is demonstrated for inhomogeneous sequences tolerating at least 50% pyrimidine content in the homologous strands. On the basis of the surprisingly similar thermodynamic parameters for duplex and triplex, and of the fact that this triplex type seems to be more stable than many other natural DNA triplexes known, and on the basis of semiempirical and molecule mechanical calculations, we postulate bridging interactions of the third strand with the two other strands in the triplex according to the recombination motif. This triplex, denoted by us 'recombination-like form', tolerates heterogeneous base sequences.     

Properties of triple helices formed by parallel-stranded hairpins containing 8-aminopurines

Parallel-stranded hairpins with a polypyrimidine sequence linked to a complementary purine carrying 8-aminopurines such as 8-aminoadenine, 8-aminoguanine and 8-aminohypoxanthine bind polypyrimidine sequences complementary (in an antiparallel sense) to the purine part by a triple helix. The relative stabilities of triplexes were assessed by UV-absorption melting experiments as a function of pH and salt concentration. Hairpins carrying 8-aminopurines give very stable triple helical structures even at neutral pH, as confirmed by gel-shift experiments, circular dichroism and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The modified hairpins may be redesigned to cope with small interruptions in the polypyrimidine target sequence.     

Sulfur signaling: is the agent sulfide or sulfane?

Triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) are sequence-dependent DNA binders that may be useful for DNA targeting and detection. A sensitive and convenient method to monitor triplex formation by a TFO and its target DNA duplex is required for the application of TFO probes. Here we describe a novel design by which triplex formation can be monitored homogeneously without prelabeling the target duplex. The design uses a TFO probe tagged with a fluorophore that undergoes fluorescence resonance energy transfer with fluorescent dyes that intercalate into the target duplex. Through color compensation analysis, the specific emission of the TFO probe reveals the status of the triple helices. We used this method to show that triple helix formation with TFOs is magnesium dependent. We also demonstrated that the TFO probe can be used for detection of sequence variation in melting analysis and for DNA quantitation in real-time polymerase chain reaction.     

Circular dichroism and UV melting studies on formation of an intramolecular triplex containing parallel T*A:T and G*G:C triplets: netropsin complexation with the triplex.

We have used circular dichroism and UV absorption spectroscopy to characterize the formation and melting behaviour of an intramolecular DNA triple helix containing parallel T*A:T and G*G:C triplets. Our approach to induce and to stabilize a parallel triplex involves the oligonucleotide 5'-d(G4A4G4[T4]C4T4C4-[T4]G4T4G4) ([T4] represents a stretch of four thymine residues). In a 10 mM sodium cacodylate, 0.2 mM disodium EDTA (pH 7) buffer, we have shown the following significant results. (i) While in the absence of MgCl2 this oligonucleotide adopts an intramolecular hairpin duplex structure prolonged by the single strand extremity 5'-d([T4]G4T4G4), the presence of millimolar concentrations of MgCl2generates an intramolecular triplex (via double hairpin formation). (ii) In contrast to the antiparallel triplex formed by the oligonucleotide 5'-d(G4T4G4[T4]G4A4G4[T4]C4T4C4), the parallel triplex melts in a biphasic manner (a triplex to duplex transition followed by a duplex to coil transition) and is less stable than the antiparallel one. The enthalpy change associated with triplex formation (-37 kcal/mol) is approximately half that of duplex formation (-81 kcal/mol). (iii) The parallel triple helix is disrupted by increasing the concentration of KCl(>10 mM), whereas, under the same conditions, the antiparallel triplex remains stable. (iv) Netropsin, a natural DNA minor groove-binding ligand, binds to the central site A4/T4of the duplex or triplex in an equimolar stoichiometry. Its association constant K is smaller for the parallel triplex ( approximately 1 x 10(7) M-1) than for the antiparallel one ( approximately 1 x 10(8) M-1). In contrast to the antiparallel structure, netropsin binding has no apparent effect on thermal stability of the parallel triple helix.     

Stabilities of intrastrand pyrimidine motif DNA and RNA triple helices

Nucleic acid triple helices have provoked interest since their discovery more than 40 years ago, but it remains unknown whether such structures occur naturally in cells. To pursue this question, it is important to determine the stabilities of representative triple helices at physiological temperature and pH. Previous investigations have concluded that while both DNA and RNA can participate in the pyrimidine triplex motif under mildly acidic conditions, these structures are often relatively unstable at neutral pH. We are now explorin g the stability of intrastrand DNA and RNA pyrimidine motif triplexes at physiological temperature and pH. Duplex and triplex formation were monitored by thermal denaturation analysis, circular dichroism spectroscopy and gel shift experiments. Short intrastrand triplexes were observed to form in the pyrimidine motif in both DNA and RNA. In the presence of physiological concentrations of Mg²⁺ and at physiological pH, all detected triplexes were sufficiently stable to persist at physiological temperature. If sequences specifying such intrastrand triplexes are encoded in genomes, the potential exists for the formation of stable structures in RNA or DNA in vivo.     

Triple helix formation with Drosophila satellite repeats. Unexpected stabilization by copper ions

The Drosophila melanogaster (AAGAGAG)(n) satellite repeat represents up to 1.5% of the entire fly genome and may adopt non-B DNA structures such as pyrimidine triple helices. UV melting and electrophoretic mobility shift assay experiments were used to monitor the stability of intermolecular triple helices as a function of size, pH, and backbone or base modification. Three to four repeats of the heptanucleotide motif were sufficient to allow the formation of a stable complex, especially when modified TFOs were used. Unexpectedly, low concentrations (40-100 microM) of Cu(2+) were found to favor strongly pyrimidine triplex formation under near-physiological conditions. In contrast, a much higher magnesium concentration was required to stabilize these triplexes significantly, suggesting that copper may be an essential stabilizing factor for pyrimidine triplexes.     

Effect of sulphur crosslinking on the stability and transition of triple helical DNA

In continuation to our work on order-order and order-disorder transition in triple stranded DNA when it is bounded to netropsin, we report in this communication the stabilizing/destabilizing effect of disulphide linkage on the phase dynamics of the triplex using the amended Zimm-Bragg theory. It is observed that in contrast to the sequential triplex-->duplex -->single strand melting of the uncrosslinked triplex, crosslinking causes the triplex state to melt directly to the single stranded state, with no apparent intermediary of a duplex state. Since there is no overall difference in the enthalpy of crosslinked and uncrosslinked triplexes, the transition is entropy driven.     

Spectroscopic studies on ethidium bromide binding to intramolecular parallel and antiparallel triple helices containing T*A:T and G*G:C triplets

The interaction of ethidium bromide (EB), a DNA intercalator, with two intramolecular triplexes 5'd(G4A4G4-[T4]-C4T4C4-[T4]-G4T4G4), 5'd(G4T4G4-[T4]-G4A4G4-[T4]-C4T4C4) ([T4] represents a stretch of 4 thymine residues) and their precursor duplexes has been investigated by circular dichroism, fluorescence and UV absorption spectroscopy. Binding of EB induces a circular dichroism band in the region around 310 nm which is positive for the duplex forms but negative for the triplex forms. We observed that the binding of EB to the duplex form does not induce the formation of the triplex structures. Thermal denaturation experiments demonstrate that EB stabilizes more the parallel triple helix than the antiparallel one. Analysis of the binding process from fluorescence measurements shows that binding constants to the triple helical forms and to the hairpin reference duplex [T4]-G4A4G4-[T4]-C4T4C4) are close. However the binding site size is larger for the triplexes (4-6 base triplets) than for the duplex (2 base pairs).     

Triple helix DNA oligomer melting measured by fluorescence polarization anisotropy

A synthetic DNA triple helix sequence was formed by annealing a pyrimidinic 21 mer single strand sequence onto the complementary purinic sequence centred on a 27 mer duplex DNA. Melting of the third strand was monitored by UV spectrophotometry in the temperature range 10-90 degrees C. The T(m) of the triplex, 37 degrees C, was well separated from the onset of duplex melting. When the same triple helix was formed on the duplex bearing one nick in the center of the pyrimidinic sequence the T(m) of the triplex was shifted to approximately 32 degrees C and overlapped the melting of the duplex. We have used fluorescence polarization anisotropy (FPA) measurements of ethidium bromide (EB) intercalated in duplex and triplex samples to determine the hydrodynamic parameters in the temperature range 10-40 degrees C. The fluorescence lifetime of EB in the samples of double and triple stranded DNA is the same (21.3 +/- 0.5 ns) at 20 degrees C, indicating that the geometries of the intercalation sites are similar. The values for the hydration radii of the duplex, normal triplex, and nicked triplex samples were 10.7 +/- 0.2, 12.2 +/- 0.2, and 12.0 +/- 0.2 A. FPA measurements on normal triplex DNA as a function of temperature gave a melting profile very similar to that derived by UV absorption spectroscopy. For the triplex carrying a nick, the melting curve obtained using FPA showed a clear shift compared with that obtained for the normal triplex sample. The torsional rigidity of the triplex forms was found to be higher than that of the duplex form.     

Sequence-dependent stability of intramolecular DNA triple helices

A set of 21 oligodeoxynucleotides were designed to fold into intramolecular triple helices of the pyrimidine motif under appropriate conditions. UV melting experiments on the triplexes which only differ in the number and distribution of third strand cytosines reveal the influence of sequence and pH on triplex stability and can be summarized as follows: (1) increasing the cytosine content in the third strand results in a higher thermal stability of the triplex at acidic pH but lowers the triplex to duplex melting temperature at neutral pH; (2) cytosines at terminal positions destabilize the triple helical structure as compared to non-terminal positions; (3) contiguous cytosines lead to a pH dependent destabilization of the triplex, the destabilizing effect being more pronounced at higher pH. Analysis of these effects in terms of the various interactions within a triple helical complex indicate that the sequence-dependent stabilities are largely determined by the extent of protonation for individual third strand cytosines.     

Sequence-Dependent Stability of Intramolecular DNA Triple Helices

Abstract

A set of 21 oligodeoxynucleotides were designed to fold into intramolecular triple helices of the pyrimidine motif under appropriate conditions. UV melting experiments on the triplexes which only differ in the number and distribution of third strand cytosines reveal the influence of sequence and pH on triplex stability and can be summarized as follows: (1) increasing the cytosine content in the third strand results in a higher thermal stability of the triplex at acidic pH but lowers the triplex to duplex melting temperature at neutral pH; (2) cytosines at terminal positions destabilize the triple helical structure as compared to non-terminal positions; (3) contiguous cytosines lead to a pH dependent destabilization of the triplex, the destabilizing effect being more pronounced at higher pH. Analysis of these effects in terms of the various interactions within a triple helical complex indicate that the sequence-dependent stabilities are largely determined by the extent of protonation for individual third strand cytosines.     

pH and cation effects on the properties of parallel pyrimidine motif DNA triplexes

The effects of cytosine protonation and various cations on the properties of parallel pyrimidine motif DNA triplexes were intensively investigated and characterized by several different techniques, such as circular dichroism (CD) conformation, ultraviolet (UV) melting, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) thermal denaturation, and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) real-time dynamics. The comparative CD spectra of the triplex and the corresponding homoduplexes showed that the negative peak at approximately 218 nm would be the eigenpeak of the Hoogsteen paired strand, and moreover, the formation pathway of a triplex was significantly pH-dependent and fell into three groups: under acidic conditions, the triplex is formed by a one-step docking, under near physiological conditions, the Watson-Crick duplex is first structured and then accepts the Hoogsteen third strand into its major groove, and under basic conditions, the triplex is not formed. The pH-dependent thermodynamics of the global triplex, the Watson-Crick antiparallel duplex, and the Crick-Hoogsteen parallel duplex were comparatively discussed for the first time. These data revealed that the thermodynamic stabilities of the Watson-Crick-Hoogsteen triplex and the Crick-Hoogsteen duplex would be strongly dependent on cytosine protonation, but a low-pH environment somewhat destabilized the Watson-Crick duplex. The binding energy of triplex formation would be different from the unfolding energy of triplex melting under acidic conditions due to the disparity in the pathway between the formation and unfolding of a triplex. Real-time dynamic measurements showed that the association and dissociation rate constants of a duplex-to-triplex formation are (1.98 +/- 0.24) x 10(3) M(-1) s(-1) and (4.09 +/- 0.96) x 10(-4) s(-1) at 20 degrees C and pH 6.0, respectively. The formation energy of the duplex-to-triplex transition derived from SPR measurements was in agreement with the unfolding energy of the free Hoogsteen paired duplex derived from UV measurements. The calorimetric enthalpies of the triplex-to-duplex-to-single transition were 39.3 and 75.3 kcal/mol under near physiological conditions (pH 7.0), respectively, which were underestimated relative to the van't Hoff enthalpies. In addition, the effects of various cations, ionic strength, mixed-valent cations, and the position of the C(+)xG.C triplets on the thermodynamics of the triplexes were addressed under near physiological conditions. The interaction of metal ions with the triplexes clearly depended on the type and ionic strength of the cations, and the efficiency with which the cations stabilized the global triplex was in the order Mg(2+) > Mn(2+) > Ca(2+) > Ba(2+) > Na(+). These observations would be useful for the design of triplex-forming oligonucleotides for antigene drugs and therapeutic purposes.     

Nucleosides and nucleotides. 218. Alternate-strand triple-helix formation by the 3'-3'-linked oligodeoxynucleotides using a purine motif

In this paper, we describe the synthesis of the 3'-3'-linked TFOs that can form the antiparallel triplexes with the duplex DNA target by reverse Hoogsteen hydrogen bonds. Stability of the alternate-strand triplexes between these TFOs and the target DNAs was investigated using the electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA). It was found that the alternate-strand triplexes were significantly stabilized by linking the TFO fragments with the pentaerythritol linker. And, unlike the alternate-strand triplexes composed of the pyrimidine motif, the terminal ammonium ion of the aminobutyl-linker and the intercalator of the TFOs did not contribute to the stability of the alternate-strand triplex comprised of the purine motif. We also tested the ability of the 3'-3'-linked TFOs to inhibit cleavage of the duplex DNA target 17 by the restriction enzyme EcoT14I and found that the 3'-3'-linked TFOs 12 and 13 inhibited the cleavage by the enzyme more effectively than the unlinked decamer 8. Thus, the TFOs linked with pentaerythritol may be useful as the antigene oligonucleotide to the DNA targets, which have alternating oligopyrimidine-oligopurine sequences.     

Alternate strand recognition of double-helical DNA by (T,G)-containing oligonucleotides in the presence of a triple helix-specific ligand.

Triple helix formation requires a polypurine- polypyrimidine sequence in the target DNA. Recent works have shown that this constraint can be circumvented by using alternate strand triplex-forming oligonucleotides. We have previously demonstrated that (T,G)-containing triplex- forming oligonucleotides may adopt a parallel or an antiparallel orientation with respect to an oligopurine target, depending upon the sequence and, in particular, upon the number of 5'-GpT-3' and 5'-TpG-3' steps [Sun et al. (1991) C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris Ser III, 313, 585-590]. A single (T,G)-containing oligonucleotide can therefore interact with two oligopurine stretches which alternate on the two strands of the target DNA. The (T,G) switch oligonucleotide contains a 5'-part targeted to one of the oligopurine sequences in a parallel orientation followed by a 3'-part that adopts an antiparallel orientation with respect to the second oligopurine sequence. We show that a limitation to the stability of such a triplex may arise from the instability of the antiparallel part, composed of reverse-Hoogsteen C.GxG and T.AxT base triplets. Using DNase I footprinting and ultraviolet absorption experiments, we report that a benzo[e]pyridoindole derivative [(3-methoxy- 7H-8-methyl-11-[(3'-amino-propyl) amino] benzo[e]pyrido [4,3-b]indole (BePI)], a drug interacting more tightly with a triplex than with a duplex DNA, strongly stabilizes triplexes with reverse-Hoogsteen C.GxG and T.AxT triplets thus allowing a stabilization of the triplex-forming switch (T,G) oligonucleotide on alternating oligopurine- oligopyrimidine 5'-(Pu)14(Py)14-3' duplex sequences. These results lead to an extension of the range of oligonucleotide sequences for alternate strand recognition of duplex DNA.     

Energetics of strand-displacement reactions in triple helices: a spectroscopic study.

DNA triple helices offer exciting new perspectives toward oligonucleotide-directed inhibition of gene expression. Purine and GT triplexes appear to be the most promising motifs for stable binding under physiological conditions compared to the pyrimidine motif, which forms at relatively low pH. There are, however, very little data available for comparison of the relative stabilities of the different classes of triplexes under identical conditions. We, therefore, designed a model system which allowed us to set up a competition between the oligonucleotides of the purine and pyrimidine motifs targeting the same Watson-Crick duplex. Several conclusions may be drawn: (i) a weak hypochromism at 260 nm is associated with purine triplex formation; (ii) delta H degree of GA, GT and TC triplex formation (at pH 7.0) was calculated as -0.1, -2.5 and -6.1 kcal/mol per base triplet, respectively. This unexpectedly low delta H degree for the purine triple helix formation implies that its delta G degree is nearly temperature-independent and it explains why these triplexes may still be observed at high temperatures. In contrast, the pyrimidine triplex is strongly favoured at lower temperatures; (iii) as a consequence, in a system where two third-strands compete for triplex formation, displacement of the GA or GT strand by a pyrimidine strand may be observed at neutral pH upon lowering the temperature. This original purine-to-pyrimidine triplex conversion shows a significant hypochromism at 260 nm and a hyperchromism at 295 nm which is similar to the duplex-to-triplex conversion in the pyrimidine motif. Further evidence for this triplex-to-triplex conversion is provided by mung bean-nuclease foot-printing assay.     

The influence of intercalator binding on DNA triplex stability: correlation with effects on A-tract duplex structure

The triplex form of DNA is of interest because of a possible biological role as well as the potential therapeutic use of this structure. In this paper the stabilizing effects of two intercalating drugs, ethidium and the quinoxaline derivative 9-OH-B220, on DNA triplexes have been studied by thermal denaturation measurements. The corresponding duplex structures of the DNA triplex systems investigated are either A-tract or normal B-DNA. The largest increases in the triplex melting temperatures caused by the intercalators were found for sequences having A-tract duplex structures. Inserting a single base pair with an N2-amino group in the minor groove, e.g. a G-C pair, breaks up the A-tract duplex structure and also reduces the stabilizing effect of the drugs on the triplex melting temperatures. The large drug-induced increase in triplex melting temperature for complexes having an original duplex A-tract structure is correlated with a low initial melting point of the triplex, not with the triplex being unusually stable in the presence of the drug. Hence, we conclude that the large thermal stabilizing effect exhibited by ethidium and 9-OH-B220 on dTn.dAn-dTn triplexes is partly caused by the intercalators breaking up the intrinsic A-tract structure of the underlying duplex.