The interaction of rising CO2 and temperatures with water use efficiency

Abstract. Recent data concerning the impact of elevated atmospheric CO₂ upon water use efficiency (WUE) and the related measure, instantaneous transpiration efficiency (ITE), are reviewed. It is concluded from both short and long-term studies that, at the scale of the individual leaf or plant, an increase in WUE or ITE is generally observed in response to increased atmospheric CO₂ levels. However, the magnitude of this increase may decline with time. The opinion that elevated CO₂ may substantially decrease transpiration at the regional scale is discussed. The mechanisms by which elevated CO₂ may cause a change in these measures are discussed in terms of stomatal conductance, assimilation and respiration responses to elevated CO₂. Finally, recent experimental data and model outputs concerning the impact of the interaction of increased temperature with elevated CO₂ on WUE, ITE and yield are reviewed. It is concluded that substantially more data is required before reliable predictions about the regional scale response of WUE and catchment hydrology can be made.     

Effects of raised CO2 on potential CH4 production and oxidation in, and CH4 emission from, a boreal mire

1 In a glasshouse experiment we studied the effect of raised CO₂ concentration (720 p.p.m.) on CH₄ emission at natural boreal peat temperatures using intact cores of boreal peat with living vascular plants and Sphagnum mosses. After the end of the growing season half of the cores were kept unnaturally warm (17–20 °C). The potential for CH₄ production and oxidation was measured at the end of the emission experiment.
2 The vascular cores ('Sedge') consisted of a moss layer with sedges, and the moss cores (' Sphagnum ') of Sphagnum mosses (some sedge seedlings were removed by cutting). Methane efflux was 6–12 times higher from the Sedge cores than from the Sphagnum cores. The release of CH ₄ from Sedge cores increased with increasing temperature of the peat and decreased with decreasing temperature. Methane efflux from Sphagnum cores was quite stable independent of the peat temperatures.
3 In both Sedge and Sphagnum samples, CO₂ treatment doubled the potential CH₄ production but had no effect on the potential CH₄ oxidation. A raised concentration of CO₂ increased CH₄ efflux weakly and only at the highest peat temperatures (17–20 °C).
4 The results suggest that in cool regions, such as boreal wetlands, temperature would restrict decomposition of the extra substrates probably derived from enhanced primary production of mire vegetation under raised CO₂ concentrations, and would thus retard any consequent increase in CH₄ emission.     

Interactions between elevated CO2 concentration, nitrogen and water: effects on growth and water use of six perennial plant species

Two experiments are described in which plants of six species were grown for one full season in greenhouse compartments with 350 or 560 μ mol mol^–1 CO₂. In the first experiment two levels of nitrogen supply were applied to study the interaction between CO₂ and nitrogen. In the second experiment two levels of water supply were added to the experimental set-up to investigate the three-way interaction between CO₂, nitrogen and water. Biomass and biomass distribution were determined at harvests, while water use and soil moisture were monitored throughout the experiments. In both experiments a positive effect of CO₂ on growth was found at high nitrogen concentrations but not at low nitrogen concentrations. However, plants used much less water in the presence of low nitrogen concentrations. Drought stress increased the relative effect of elevated CO₂ on growth. Available soil moisture was used more slowly at high CO₂ during drought or at high nitrogen concentrations, while at low nitrogen concentrations decreased water use resulted in an increase in soil moisture. The response to the treatments was similar in all the species used. Although potentially faster growing species appeared to respond better to high CO₂ when supplied with a high level of nitrogen, inherently slow-growing species were more successful at low nitrogen concentrations.     

An open-top chamber for measuring soil respiration and the influence of pressure difference on CO2 efflux measurement

1. A new open-top chamber for measuring CO₂ efflux from the soil is reported here. The new design enables measurement of the equilibrium CO₂ efflux, when there is no detectable pressure difference between the chamber and outside nor leakage of CO₂ into or out of the chamber.
2. In previous dynamic-chamber techniques, the measured CO₂ efflux is dependent on the pressure difference between the inside and outside of the chamber, and a negative pressure difference of –1Pa may cause an order of magnitude increase in measured CO₂ efflux. Although the measured CO₂ efflux is less sensitive to a positive pressure difference than to a negative one, a positive pressure difference of even a few tenths of a Pa will lead to a considerable underestimation in soil CO₂ evolution.
3. The influence of pressure difference on measured CO₂ efflux is negligible in the new design and the estimated CO₂ efflux is close to the undisturbed soil respiration rate. Flow rates up to 8lmin^–1, or air movement over the soil surface up to 55cmmin^–1, will not affect CO₂ evolution from the soil. The influence of pressure difference is related to the type of soil being measured and this has also been reported here for the new design.     

Canopy photosynthesis of crops and native plant communities exposed to long-term elevated CO2

Abstract. There have been seven studies of canopy photosynthesis of plants grown in elevated atmospheric CO₂: three of seed crops, two of forage crops and two of native plant ecosystems. Growth in elevated CO₂ increased canopy photosynthesis in all cases. The relative effect of CO₂ was correlated with increasing temperature: the least stimulation occurred in tundra vegetation grown at an average temperature near 10°C and the greatest in rice grown at 43°C. In soybean, effects of CO₂ were greater during leaf expansion and pod fill than at other stages of crop maturation. In the longest running experiment with elevated CO₂ treatment to date, monospecific stands of a C₃ sedge, Scirpus olneyi (Grey), and a C₄ grass, Spartina patens (Ait.) Muhl., have been exposed to twice normal ambient CO₂ concentrations for four growing seasons, in open top chambers on a Chesapeake Bay salt marsh. Net ecosystem CO₂ exchange per unit green biomass (NCE_b) increased by an average of 48% throughout the growing season of 1988, the second year of treatment. Elevated CO₂ increased net ecosystem carbon assimilation by 88% in the Scirpus olneyi community and 40% in the Spartina patens community.     

Effect of enhanced atmospheric CO2 on mycorrhizal colonization and phosphorus inflow in 10 herbaceous species of contrasting growth strategies

1. Ten herbaceous species were grown over a 4-month period under ambient (360 μmol mol^–1) and elevated (610 μmol mol^–1) atmospheric CO₂ conditions. Plants were inoculated with the arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungus Glomus mosseae and given a phosphorus (P) supply which was not immediately available to the plants.
2. Multiple harvests were taken in order to determine whether the effect of elevated CO₂ on mycorrhizal colonization and phosphorus inflow was independent of its effect on plant growth.
3. All species grew faster under elevated CO₂ and carbon partitioning was altered, generally in favour of the shoots. All species responded similarly to elevated CO₂.
4. Elevated CO₂ did not affect the percentage of root length colonized by AM fungi, but the total amount of colonized root length was increased, because the plants were bigger.
5. Elevated CO₂ increased total P content, but had little or no effect on P concentration. At a given age, P inflow was stimulated by elevated CO₂, but when root length was taken into account the CO₂ effect disappeared.
6. In these host species there is no evidence for a direct effect of elevated CO₂ on mycorrhizal functioning, because both internal mycorrhizal colonization and P inflow are unaffected.
7. Future research should concentrate on the potential for carbon flow to the soil via the external mycelial network.     

Exposure to preindustrial, current and future atmospheric CO2 and temperature differentially affects growth and photosynthesis in Eucalyptus

To investigate if Eucalyptus species have responded to industrial-age climate change, and how they may respond to a future climate, we measured growth and physiology of fast- ( E. saligna ) and slow-growing ( E. sideroxylon ) seedlings exposed to preindustrial (290), current (400) or projected (650 μL L⁻¹) CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) and to current or projected (current +4 °C) temperature. To evaluate maximum potential treatment responses, plants were grown with nonlimiting soil moisture. We found that: (1) E. sideroxylon responded more strongly to elevated [CO₂] than to elevated temperature, while E. saligna responded similarly to elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature; (2) the transition from preindustrial to current [CO₂] did not enhance eucalypt plant growth under ambient temperature, despite enhancing photosynthesis; (3) the transition from current to future [CO₂] stimulated both photosynthesis and growth of eucalypts, independent of temperature; and (4) warming enhanced eucalypt growth, independent of future [CO₂], despite not affecting photosynthesis. These results suggest large potential carbon sequestration by eucalypts in a future world, and highlight the need to evaluate how future water availability may affect such responses.     

Experimental confirmation of ecosystem model predictions comparing transient and equilibrium plant responses to elevated atmospheric CO2

Ecosystem models predict that short-term responses to elevated atmospheric CO₂ may differ substantially from the "real" long-term responses expected at equilibrium. Experimental validation of these model predictions is difficult as the data available are from short-term studies that do not include biogeochemical feedbacks typical of long-term exposure. Using a reciprocal transplant design at a natural CO₂ spring, we generated combinations of atmospheric and soil conditions that represented both short- and long-term elevated CO₂ conditions. Plant responses were significantly different between these treatments, confirming model predictions that there is not a simple relationship between transient and equilibrium responses to elevated CO₂.     

Non-stomatal limitation of CO2 assimilation in three tree species during natural drought conditions

The effect of drought on CO₂ assimilation and leaf conductance was studied in three northern hardwood species: Quercus rubra L., Acer rubrum L. and Populus grandidentata Michx. Leaf gas exchange characteristics at two CO₂ levels (320 and 620 μl I⁻¹) and temperatures from 20 to 35°C were measured at the end of a dry period and shortly after 10 cm of rainfall. The effects of drought varied with species, temperature and CO₂ level. Calculated values of internal CO₂ concentration showed little or no decline during drought. Differences in assimilation, before vs after the rains, were most apparent at the higher CO₂ level. These latter two observations indicate nonstomatal disruption of CO₂ assimilation during the dry period. In P. grandidentata there was a substantial interaction between drought and temperature, with a resultant shift in the temperature for maximum assimilation to lower temperatures during drought. During drought, internal CO₂ concentrations increased sharply in all three species under the combined conditions of high temperatures and the higher CO₂ level.     

Increasing growth temperature reduces the stimulatory effect of elevated CO2 on photosynthesis or biomass in two perennial species

We examined how anticipated changes in CO₂ concentration and temperature interacted to alter plant growth, harvest characteristics and photosynthesis in two cold-adapted herbaceous perennials, alfalfa ( Medicago sativa L. cv. Arc) and orchard grass ( Dactylis glomerata L. cv. Potomac). Plants were grown at two CO₂ concentrations (362 [ambient] and 717 [elevated] μmol mol⁻¹ CO₂) and four constant day/night temperatures of 15, 20, 25 and 30°C in controlled environmental chambers. Elevated CO₂ significantly increased total plant biomass and protein over a wide range of temperatures in both species. Stimulation of photosynthetic rate, however, was eliminated at the highest growth temperature in M. sativa and relative stimulation of plant biomass and protein at high CO₂ declined as temperature increased in both species. Lack of a synergistic effect between temperature and CO₂ was unexpected since elevated CO₂ reduces the amount of carbon lost via photorespiration and photorespiration increases with temperature. Differences between anticipated stimulatory effects of CO₂ and temperature and whole plant single and leaf measurements are discussed. Data from this study suggest that stimulatory effects of atmospheric CO₂ on growth and photosynthesis may decline with anticipated increases in global temperature, limiting the degree of carbon storage in these two perennial species.     

Elevated CO2 concentration, nitrogen use, and seed production in annual plants

Elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) stimulates seed mass production in many species, but the extent of stimulation shows large variation among species. We examined (1) whether seed production is enhanced more in species with lower seed nitrogen concentrations, and (2) whether seed production is enhanced by elevated [CO₂] when the plant uses more N for seed production. We grew 11 annuals in open top chambers that have different [CO₂] conditions (ambient: 370 μmol mol⁻¹, elevated: 700 μmol mol⁻¹). Elevated [CO₂] significantly increased seed production in six out of 11 species with a large interspecific variation (0.84–2.12, elevated/ambient [CO₂]). Seed nitrogen concentration was not correlated with the enhancement of seed production by elevated [CO₂]. The enhancement of seed production was strongly correlated with the enhancement of seed nitrogen per plant caused by increased N acquisition during the reproductive period. In particular, legume species tended to acquire more N and produced more seeds at elevated [CO₂] than non-nitrogen fixing species. Elevated [CO₂] little affected seed [N] in all species. We conclude that seed production is limited primarily by nitrogen availability and will be enhanced by elevated [CO₂] only when the plant is able to increase nitrogen acquisition.     

The effect of nitrogen source on photosynthesis of carob at high CO2 concentrations

Carob seedlings ( Ceratonia siliqua L. cv. Mulata), fed with nitrate or ammonium, were grown in growth chambers containing two levels of CO₂ (360 or 800 μl l⁻¹), three root temperatures (15, 20 or 25°C), and the same shoot temperature (20/24°C, night/day temperature). The response of the plants to CO₂ enrichment was affected by environmental factors such as the type of inorganic nitrogen in the medium and root temperature. Increasing root temperature enhanced photosynthesis rate more in the presence of nitrate than in the presence of ammonium. Differences in photosynthetic products were also observed between nitrate- and ammonium-fed carob seedlings. Nitrate-grown plants showed an enhanced content of sucrose, while ammonium led to enhanced storage of starch. Increase in root temperature caused an increase in dry mass of the plants of similar proportions in both nitrogen sources. The enhancement of the rates of photosynthesis by CO₂ enrichment was proportionally much larger than the resulting increases in dry mass production when nitrate was the nitrogen source. Ammonium was the preferred nitrogen source for carob at both ambient and high CO₂ concentrations. The level of photosynthesis of a plant is limited not only by atmospheric CO₂ concentration but also by the nutritional and environmental conditions of the root.     

The role of temperature in determining the stimulation of CO2 assimilation at elevated carbon dioxide concentration in soybean seedlings

Soybean ( Glycine max cv. Clark) was grown at both ambient (ca 350 μmol mol⁻¹) and elevated (ca 700 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ concentration at 5 growth temperatures (constant day/night temperatures of 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40°C) for 17–22 days after sowing to determine the interaction between temperature and CO₂ concentration on photosynthesis (measured as A, the rate of CO₂ assimilation per unit leaf area) at both the single leaf and whole plant level. Single leaves of soybean demonstrated increasingly greater stimulation of A at elevated CO₂ as temperature increased from 25 to 35°C (i.e. optimal growth rates). At 40°C, primary leaves failed to develop and plants eventually died. In contrast, for both whole plant A and total biomass production, increasing temperature resulted in less stimulation by elevated CO₂ concentration. For whole plants, increased CO₂ stimulated leaf area more as growth temperature increased. Differences between the response of A to elevated CO₂ for single leaves and whole plants may be related to increased self-shading experienced by whole plants at elevated CO₂ as temperature increased. Results from the present study suggest that self-shading could limit the response of CO₂ assimilation rate and the growth response of soybean plants if temperature and CO₂ increase concurrently, and illustrate that light may be an important consideration in predicting the relative stimulation of photosynthesis by elevated CO₂ at the whole plant level.     

Elevated CO2 concentrations and stomatal density: observations from 17 plant species growing in a CO2 spring in central Italy

Stomatal density (SD) and stomatal conductance ( g _s) can be affected by an increase of atmospheric CO₂ concentration. This study was conducted on 17 species growing in a naturally enriched CO₂ spring and belonging to three plant communities. Stomatal conductance, stomatal density and stomatal index (SI) of plants from the spring, which were assumed to have been exposed for generations to elevated [CO₂], and of plants of the same species collected in a nearby control site, were compared. Stomatal conductance was significantly lower in most of the species collected in the CO₂ spring and this indicated that CO₂ effects on g _s are not of a transitory nature but persist in the long term and through plant generations. Such a decrease was, however, not associated with changes in the anatomy of leaves: SD was unaffected in the majority of species (the decrease was only significant in three out of the 17 species examined), and also SI values did not vary between the two sites with the exception of two species that showed increased SI in plants grown in the CO₂-enriched area. These results did not support the hypothesis that long-term exposure to elevated [CO₂] may cause adaptive modification in stomatal number and in their distribution.     

Soil microbial responses to increased concentrations of atmospheric CO2

Terrestrial ecosystems respond to an increased concentration of atmospheric CO₂. While elevated atmospheric CO₂ has been shown to alter plant growth and productivity, it also affects ecosystem structure and function by changing below-ground processes. Knowledge of how soil microbiota respond to elevated atmospheric CO₂ is of paramount importance for understanding global carbon and nutrient cycling and for predicting changes at the ecosystem-level. An increase in the atmospheric CO₂ concentration not only alters the weight, length, and architecture of plant roots, but also affects the biotic and abiotic environment of the root system. Since the concentration of CO₂ in soil is already 10–50 times higher than that in the atmosphere, it is unlikely that increasing atmospheric CO₂ will directly influence the rhizosphere. Rather, it is more likely that elevated atmospheric CO₂ will affect the microbe–soil–plant root system indirectly by increasing root growth and rhizodeposition rates, and decreasing soil water deficit. Consequently, the increased amounts and altered composition of rhizosphere-released materials will have the potential to alter both population and community structure, and activity of soil- and rhizosphere-associated microorganisms. This occurrence could in turn affect plant health and productivity and plant community structure. This review covers current knowledge about the response of soil microbes to elevated concentrations of atmospheric CO₂.     

Elevated atmospheric [CO2] promotes frost damage in evergreen tree seedlings

Growth under elevated [CO₂] promoted spring frost damage in field grown seedlings of snow gum ( Eucalyptus pauciflora Sieb. ex Spreng.), one of the most frost tolerant of eucalypts. Freezing began in the leaf midvein, consistent with it being a major site of frost damage under field conditions. The average ice nucleation temperature was higher in leaves grown under elevated [CO₂] (– 5·7 °C versus – 4·3 °C), consistent with the greater incidence of frost damage in these leaves (34% versus 68% of leaves damaged). These results have major implications for agriculture, forestry and vegetation dynamics, as an increase in frost susceptibility may reduce potential gains in productivity from CO₂ fertilization and may affect predictions of vegetation change based on increasing temperature.     

Growth and photosynthetic response of three soybean cultivars to simultaneous increases in growth temperature and CO2

Three soybean ( Glycine max L. Merr.) cultivars (Maple Glen, Clark and CNS) were exposed to three CO₂ concentrations (370, 555 and 740 μmol mol⁻¹) and three growth temperatures (20/15°, 25/20° and 31/26°C, day/night) to determine intraspecific differences in single leaf/whole plant photosynthesis, growth and partitioning, phenology and final biomass. Based on known carboxylation kinetics, a synergistic effect between temperature and CO₂ on growth and photosynthesis was predicted since elevated CO₂ increases photosynthesis by reducing photorespiration and photorespiration increases with temperature. Increasing CO₂ concentrations resulted in a stimulation of single leaf photosynthesis for 40–60 days after emergence (DAE) at 20/15°C in all cultivars and for Maple Glen and CNS at all temperatures. For Clark, however, the onset of flowering at warmer temperatures coincided with the loss of stimulation in single leaf photosynthesis at elevated CO₂ concentrations. Despite the season-long stimulation of single leaf photosynthesis, elevated CO₂ concentrations did not increase whole plant photosynthesis except at the highest growth temperature in Maple Glen and CNS, and there was no synergistic effect on final biomass. Instead, the stimulatory effect of CO₂ on growth was delayed by higher temperatures. Data from this experiment suggest that: (1) intraspecific variation could be used to select for optimum soybean cultivars with future climate change; and (2) the relationship between temperature and CO₂ concentration may be expressed differently at the leaf and whole plant levels and may not solely reflect known changes in carboxylation kinetics.     

Carbon gains by desiccation-tolerant plants at elevated CO2

1. There have been no reports of the long-term responses of the desiccation-tolerant (DT) plants to elevated CO₂. Xerophyta scabrida is a DT woody shrub, which loses chlorophylls and thylakoids during desiccation: a so-called poikilochlorophyllous desiccation-tolerant species (PDT). When the leaves of X. scabria are allowed to desiccate, the species shows many of the normal features of (P)DT plants.
2. However, the duration of photosynthesis in X. scabria is prolonged by 300% when the measurements are made at 700 as opposed to 350p.p.m. CO₂. The implication is that the carboxylating enzymes must still have been active at this time to enable appreciable photosynthetic activity. This response could have far-reaching implications for the success of such species in a future climate.
3. Lichens and mosses, representing the homoiochlorophyllous DTs (HDT), retain their chlorophyll content and photosynthetic apparatus during desiccation. We show the desiccation responses of two common HDT species ( Cladonia convoluta and Tortula ruralis ) to elevated CO₂ for comparison. Both HDT species showed increased net CO₂ uptake in the material grown at high CO₂ by more than 30% in moss and by more than 50% in lichen. It is concluded that desiccation-tolerant plants will be among the main beneficiaries of a high CO₂ future.     

Spatial variability in forest soil CO2 efflux assessed with a calibrated soda lime technique

Accurate estimates of soil CO₂ efflux are important in the current discussion on the carbon balance of forests, and can be used to validate models and remotely sensed data. Due to the typically large spatial variability, large sample numbers are required to estimate mean forest soil CO₂ efflux with reasonable confidence intervals. Most infrared gas analysis (IRGA) systems are not well suited to simultaneously produce daily means and handle this spatial variability problem. The soda lime technique gives daily means and allows the required large sample numbers, but is less accurate than the IRGA systems. Using an elaborate cross-calibration, we tried to combine the accuracy of an IRGA method with the spatial integration potential of the soda lime technique. This paper reports on the calibration technique used to improve the accuracy of the soda lime technique and confirms the spatial variability in soil CO₂ efflux in a heterogeneous forest.     

Potential effects of elevated CO2 and changes in temperature on tropical plants

Abstract. Very little attention has been directed at the responses of tropical plants to increases in global atmospheric CO₂ concentrations and the potential climatic changes. The available data, from greenhouse and laboratory studies, indicate that the photosynthesis, growth and water use efficiency of tropical plants can increase at higher CO₂ concentrations. However, under field conditions abiotic (light, water or nutrients) or biotic (competition or herbivory) factors might limit these responses. In general, elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations seem to increase plant tolerance to stress, including low water availability, high or low temperature, and photoinhibition. Thus, some species may be able to extend their ranges into physically less favourable sites, and biological interactions may become relatively more important in determining the distribution and abundance of species. Tropical plants may be more narrowly adapted to prevailing temperature regimes than are temperate plants, so expected changes in temperature might be relatively more important in the tropics. Reduced transpiration due to decreased stomatal conductance could modify the effects of water stress as a cue for vegetative or reproductive phenology of plants of seasonal tropical areas. The available information suggests that changes in atmospheric CO₂ concentrations could affect processes as varied as plant/herbivore interactions, decomposition and nutrient cycling, local and geographic distributions of species and community types, and ecosystem productivity. However, data on tropical plants are few, and there seem to be no published tropical studies carried out in the field. Immediate steps should be undertaken to reduce our ignorance of this critical area.