Interactions Between the Cytochrome Pathway and the Alternative Oxidase in Isolated Acanthamoeba castellanii Mitochondria

The steady-state activity of the two quinol-oxidizing pathways of Acanthamoeba castellanii mitochondria, the phosphorylating cytochrome pathway (i.e. the benzohydroxamate(BHAM)-resistant respiration in state 3) and the alternative oxidase (i.e. the KCN-resistant respiration), is shown to be fixed by ubiquinone (Q) pool redox state independently of the reducing substrate (succinate or exogenous reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH)), indicating that the active Q pool is homogenous. For both pathways, activity increases with the Q reduction level (up to 80%). However, the cytochrome pathway respiration partially inhibited (about 50%) by myxothiazol decreases when the Q reduction level increases above 80%. The decrease can be explained by the Q cycle mechanism of complex III. It is also shown that BHAM has an influence on the relationship between the rate of ADP phosphorylation and the Q reduction level when alternative oxidase is active, and that KCN has an influence on the relationship between the alternative oxidase activity and the Q reduction level. These unexpected effects of BHAM and KCN observed at a given Q reduction level are likely due to functional connections between the two pathways activities or to protein–protein interaction.     

The Alternative Oxidase: in vivo Regulation and Function

Abstract: This review focuses on the biochemical regulation and function of the alternative oxidase in vivo. About 10 years ago, two activation mechanisms were discovered in isolated mitochondria, namely activation by reducing sulfur bonds in the protein and activation by an allosteric effect of pyruvate. It was proposed that plants would have a regulatory mechanism to modify alternative oxidase activity in vivo. However, more recent studies have shown that these two activation mechanisms may not play such an important role in regulation of alternative oxidase activity in vivo after all. Pyruvate and reduction of the sulfide bonds in the protein are definitely required for alternative oxidase activity, but they do not appear to be regulating the activity in vivo.
Despite the energy wasting nature of the alternative oxidase, there was no obvious physiological function for the pathway for many years. It is now more clear that the alternative oxidase can prevent the production of excess reactive oxygen species radicals by stabilizing the redox state of the mitochondrial ubiquinone pool, while allowing continued activity of the citric acid cycle. This may be important under conditions when the NADH supply is relatively high (reductant overflow), or when the cytochrome pathway is restrained. The cytochrome pathway might be inhibited by naturally occurring cyanide, nitric oxide, sulfide, high concentrations of CO₂, low temperatures, or by limited phosphate supply.     

Electron Partitioning between the Cytochrome and Alternative Pathways in Plant Mitochondria

The contribution of the cyanide-resistant, alternative pathway to plant mitochondrial electron transport has been studied using a modified aqueous phase on-line mass spectrometry-gas chromatography system. This technique permits direct measurement of the partitioning of electrons between the cytochrome and alternative pathways in the absence of added inhibitors. We demonstrate that in mitochondria isolated from soybean (Glycine max L. cv Ransom) cotyledons, the alternative pathway contributes significantly to oxygen uptake under state 4 conditions, when succinate is used as a substrate. However, when NADH is the substrate, addition of pyruvate, an allosteric activator of the alternative pathway, is required to achieve the same level of alternative pathway activity. Under state 3 conditions, when the reduction state of the ubiquinone pool is low, the addition of pyruvate allows the alternative pathway to compete with the cytochrome pathway for electrons from the ubiquinone pool when the cytochrome pathway is not saturated. These results provide direct experimental verification of the kinetics consequences of pyruvate addition on the partitioning of electron flow between the two respiratory pathways. This distribution of electrons between the two unsaturated pathways could not be measured using conventional oxygen electrode methods and illustrates a clear advantage of the mass spectrometry technique. These results have significant ramifications for studies of plant respiration using the oxygen electrode, particularly those studies involving intact tissues.     

The Regulation of Electron Partitioning between the Cytochrome and Alternative Pathways in Soybean Cotyledon and Root Mitochondria

The regulation of electron partitioning between the cytochrome (Cyt) and alternative pathways in soybean (Glycine max L. cv Ransom) mitochondria in the absence of added inhibitors has been studied using the oxygen isotope fractionation technique. This regulation can depend on several factors, including the amount of alternative oxidase protein, the redox status of the alternative oxidase regulatory sulfhydryl-disulfide system, the degree of activation by [alpha]-keto acids, and the concentration and redox state of the ubiquinone pool. We studied electron partitioning onto the alternative pathway in mitochondria isolated from etiolated and light-grown cotyledons and roots to ascertain how these factors interact in different tissues. In light-grown cotyledon mitochondria there is some partitioning to the alternative pathway in state 4, which is increased dramatically by either pyruvate or dithiothreitol. In etiolated cotyledon mitochondria, the alternative pathway shows little ability to compete for electrons with the Cyt pathway under any circumstances. In root mitochondria, control of alternative pathway activity is exercised by both the ubiquinone pool and the regulatory sulfhydryl-disulfide system. In addition, oxygen isotope fractionation by the Cyt and alternative pathways in mitochondria were identical to the fractionation for the respective pathways seen in intact tissue, suggesting that residual respiration is not present in the absence of inhibitors.     

Alternative respiration and heat evolution in plants

The alternative respiratory pathway dissipates most of the chemical energy of respiratory substrates as heat. We have shown that this heat can be quantified by microcalorimetry and is a measure of alternative pathway activity in vivo. The alternative pathway is known to increase in aged potato (Solanum tuberosum) slices and in chill-stressed leaves. Aging of potato slices for 24 hours was accompanied by an almost fourfold increase in the rate of heat evolution. This heat increase was resistant to KCN but could be blocked by an alternative pathway inhibitor, salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM). In cucumber (Cucumis sativus) leaves subjected to chilling stress (between 4 and 16°C), the rate of heat evolution was inversely related to temperature. As in aged potato slices, the increased rate of heat evolution in cucumber leaves was blocked by SHAM, but not by KCN. Nitrogen or the combination of SHAM and KCN blocked most of the heat evolution in both aged potato slices and chill-stressed cucumber leaves. Calorimetric measurements of the alternative pathway corresponded to respiration measurements performed using an oxygen electrode.     

The Alternative Oxidase of Yarrowia lipolytica Mitochondria Is Unable To Compete with the Cytochrome Pathway for Electrons

The activity of the cyanide-resistant alternative oxidase (pathway) of Yarrowia lipolytica mitochondria was studied as a function of the activity of the major, cyanide-sensitive, cytochrome pathway. The contribution of the alternative oxidase to the total respiration of mitochondria was evaluated by measuring the rate of oxygen consumption in the presence of cyanide (an inhibitor of the cytochrome pathway). The potential activity of the cytochrome pathway was evaluated spectrophotometrically, by measuring the oxidation rate of cytochrome c by ferricyanide, which accepts electrons from complex III (cytochrome c) of this pathway. The oxidation of succinate by mitochondria in the presence of ferricyanide and cyanide was accompanied by oxygen consumption due to the transfer of electrons through the alternative pathway. The subsequent addition of ADP or FCCP (an uncoupler of oxidative phosphorylation in the cytochrome pathway) completely inhibited the consumption of oxygen by the mitochondria. Under these conditions, the inhibition of the alternative pathway by benzohydroxamic acid failed to affect the transfer of electrons from cytochrome c to ferricyanide. Benzohydroxamic acid did not influence the rate of ferricyanide reduction by the cytochrome pathway occurring in controlled state 4, nor could it change the phosphorylation quotient ATP/O upon the oxidation of various substrates. These findings indicate that the alternative pathway is unable to compete with the cytochrome respiratory chain for electrons. The alternative pathway transfers only electrons that are superfluous for the cytochrome chain.     

Regulation of Alternative Oxidase Activity by Pyruvate in Soybean Mitochondria

The regulation of alternative oxidase activity by the effector pyruvate was investigated in soybean (Glycine max L.) mitochondria using developmental changes in roots and cotyledons to vary the respiratory capacity of the mitochondria. Rates of cyanide-insensitive oxygen uptake by soybean root mitochondria declined with seedling age. Immunologically detectable protein levels increased slightly with age, and mitochondria from younger, more active roots had less of the protein in the reduced form. Addition of pyruvate stimulated cyanide-insensitive respiration in root mitochondria, up to the same rate, regardless of seedling age. This stimulation was reversed rapidly upon removal of pyruvate, either by pelleting mitochondria (with succinate as substrate) or by adding lactate dehydrogenase with NADH as substrate. In mitochondria from cotyledons of the same seedlings, cyanide-insensitive NADH oxidation was less dependent on added pyruvate, partly due to intramitochondrial generation of pyruvate from endogenous substrates. Cyanide-insensitive oxygen uptake with succinate as substrate was greater than that with NADH, in both root and cotyledon mitochondria, but this difference became much less when an increase in external pH was used to inhibit intramitochondrial pyruvate production via malic enzyme. Malic enzyme activity in root mitochondria declined with seedling age. The results indicate that the activity of the alternative oxidase in soybean mitochondria is very dependent on the presence of pyruvate: differences in the generation of intramitochondrial pyruvate can explain differences in alternative oxidase activity between tissues and substrates, and some of the changes that occur during seedling development.     

Cyanide-resistant respiration in light- and dark-grown soybean cotyledons

Measurements of respiration were made on intact tissue and mitochondria isolated from soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr. cv `Corsoy') cotyledons from seedlings of different ages grown in light and darkness. Effects of cyanide (KCN) and salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM) on O₂ uptake rates were determined. O₂ uptake was faster in light-grown tissue and was inhibited by both KCN and SHAM in all except light-grown tissue older than 9 days. Both inhibitors stimulated O₂ uptake in tissues more than 9 days old. Mitochondria in which O₂ uptake was coupled to ATP synthesis were isolated from all tissues. O₂ uptake by mitochondrial preparations from light- and dark-grown cotyledons was equally sensitive to KCN. Similarly, age did not affect KCN sensitivity, but sensitivity to SHAM declined with age both in the presence and absence of KCN. Estimated capacities of the cytochrome and alternative pathways of the mitochondrial preparations indicated considerably larger cytochrome than alternative pathway capacities. The cytochrome pathway capacities paralleled the state 3 mitochondrial respiration rates, which increased from day 5 to day 7 then declined thereafter. The alternative pathway capacities were not affected by light. The uncoupler, p-trifluoromethoxycarbonylcyanide phenylhydrazone (FCCP), increased the flow of electrons through the cytochrome pathway at the expense of flow through the alternative pathway in isolated mitochondria. However, the combined capacities did not exceed the rate in the presence of FCCP. The results are interpreted to indicate that the stimulation of respiration by KCN and SHAM observed in the 12-day-old green cotyledons and previously observed in older soybean leaves is not explained by characteristics of the mitochondria.     

Influence of the alternative respiratory pathway on the adenylate pools in heterotrophic Euglena gracilis

Etiolated Euglena gracilis Pringsheim, strain Z, were cultured in a lactate medium either in the presence of 2 μ M antimycin A for cells adapted to this inhibitor, or in the absence of antimycin A for controls. The adenylates (ATP, ADP and AMP) and the energy charge (EC) were followed during the growth of both types of cells. The effects of KCN, salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM) and rotenone on the respiration and the adenylate pool, were investigated during the exponental and stationary phases. EC values of controls and antimycin-adapted cells were not significantly different during culture. In the logarithmic phase, EC of controls was unaffected by 3 m M SHAM, an inhibitor of the alternative pathway, but markedly decreased by 0.3 m M KCN, which inhibits the cytochrome pathway. In contrast, in antimycin-adapted Euglena , in which the cytochrome pathway was blocked, ATP content and EC were markedly lowered in the presence of SHAM but slightly increased by 0.3 m M KCN. The combination of the preceeding treatments, as well as 15 m M KCN alone, were deleterious for both types of cells, in the logarithmic and the late stationary phases. The data indicate that the energy level in Euglena was dependent on the alternative pathway when the cytochrome pathway was blocked. Such dependence could be explained by the engagement of the first rotenone-sensitive site of phosphorylation. Indeed, 50 μ M rotenone caused a similar relative decrease of oxygen consumption and ATP content in controls and in antimycin-adapted Euglena . In the absence of cytochrome respiration, the alternative pathway allowed electrons to flow through this first segment of the respiratory chain, and ATP production by the first site of phosphorylation.     

Analysis of Respiratory Chain Regulation in Roots of Soybean Seedlings

Changes in the respiratory rate and the contribution of the cytochrome (Cyt) c oxidase and alternative oxidase (COX and AOX, respectively) were investigated in soybean (Glycine max L. cv Stevens) root seedlings using the ¹⁸O-discrimination method. In 4-d-old roots respiration proceeded almost entirely via COX, but by d 17 more than 50% of the flux occurred via AOX. During this period the capacity of COX, the theoretical yield of ATP synthesis, and the root relative growth rate all decreased substantially. In extracts from whole roots of different ages, the ubiquinone pool was maintained at 50% to 60% reduction, whereas pyruvate content fluctuated without a consistent trend. In whole-root immunoblots, AOX protein was largely in the reduced, active form at 7 and 17 d but was partially oxidized at 4 d. In isolated mitochondria, Cyt pathway and succinate dehydrogenase capacities and COX I protein abundance decreased with root age, whereas both AOX capacity and protein abundance remained unchanged. The amount of mitochondrial protein on a dry-mass basis did not vary significantly with root age. It is concluded that decreases in whole-root respiration during growth of soybean seedlings can be largely explained by decreases in maximal rates of electron transport via COX. Flux via AOX is increased so that the ubiquinone pool is maintained in a moderately reduced state.     

Cytochrome and alternative pathway respiration in green algae : measurements using inhibitors and o(2) discrimination

Inhibitor titration curves and discrimination against ¹⁸O₂ by mitochondrial respiration in three strains of green algae (Selenastrum minutum [Naeg.] Collins, and two strains of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii Dangeard) with differing respiratory capabilities were determined. Discrimination for cytochrome pathway respiration ranged from 19.89 to 20.43%. Discrimination for alternative pathway respiration by wild-type C. reinhardtii (measured in the presence of KCN) was 25.46%, while discrimination values for a cytochrome oxidase deficient mutant of C. reinhardtii ranged from 24.24 to 24.96%. In the absence of KCN, the alternative pathway was not engaged in wild-type C. reinhardtii, the only algal strain that possessed both cytochrome and alternative pathway capacities.     

Partitioning of Electrons between the Cytochrome and Alternative Pathways in Intact Roots

To test the hypothesis that the cytochrome pathway is not invariably saturated when the alternative pathway is engaged, we titrated root respiration of several species with KCN (an inhibitor of the cytochrome pathway), both in the absence and presence of an inhibitor of the alternative pathway (salicylhydroxamic acid, SHAM). The slopes of the resultant KCN [rho] plots ([rho]cyt) were then used to determine whether the cytochrome pathway was saturated in each species. The species used were Festuca ovina ssp. ovina L., Phaseolus vulgaris L., and six Poa species (Poa pratensis L., Poa compressa L., Poa trivialis L., Poa alpina L., Poa costiniana Vick., and Poa fawcettiae Vick.). Although the cytochrome pathway was saturated in a number of species (i.e. [rho]cyt values were 1.0), several others exhibited [rho]cyt values of less than 0.5. Alternative pathway capacity correlated negatively with [rho]cyt, with [rho]cyt values of less than 1.0 occurring in tissues in which the alternative pathway capacity was greater than 25 to 30% of total respiration. The species that did not show full engagement of the cytochrome pathway rarely exhibited SHAM inhibition in the absence of KCN. We conclude that this lack of SHAM inhibition is not due to a lack of alternative pathway engagement but rather to the diversion of electrons from the alternative pathway to the unsaturated cytochrome path following the addition of SHAM.     

Studies on the import and processing of the alternative oxidase precursor by isolated soybean mitochondria

Import of the synthetic precursor of the alternative oxidase from soybean was shown to be dependent on a membrane potential and ATP. The membrane potential in soybean mitochondria may be formed either by respiration through the cytochrome pathway, or through the alternative oxidase pathway with NAD⁺-linked substrates. Import of the alternative oxidase precursor in the presence of succinate as respiratory substrate was inhibited by KCN. Import in the presence of malate was insensitive to KCN and SHAM added separately, but was inhibited by KCN and SHAM added together (inhibitors of the cytochrome and alternative oxidases respectively). Import of the alternative oxidase was accompanied by processing of the precursor to a single 32 kDa product in both cotyledon and root mitochondria. This product had a different mobility than the two alternative oxidase bands detected by immunological means (34 and 36 kDa), suggesting that the enzyme had been modified in situ. When the cDNA clone of the alternative oxidase was modified by a single mutation (–2 Arg changed to –2 Gly), the processing of the precursor was inhibited.     

Evidence for a significant contribution by peroxidase-mediated O2 uptake to root respiration of Brachypodium pinnatum

This study describes the O₂ uptake characteristics of intact roots of Brachypodium pinnatum. In the presence of 25 mM salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM), concentrations of KCN below 3.5 νM had no effect on the rate of root respiration, whereas in the absence of 25 mM SHAM a significant inhibition of approx. 18% was observed. This indicates that an O₂-consuming reaction, not associated with the cytochrome pathway, the alternative pathway or the “residual component”, operates in the absence of any inhibitors in roots of B. pinnatum. We demonstrate here that this fourth O₂-consuming reaction is mediated by a peroxidase. A peroxidase which catalyzed O₂ reduction in the presence of NADH was readily washed from the roots of B. pinnatum. This peroxidase was stimulated by 5 mM SHAM, whereas ascorbic acid, catalase, catechol, gentisic acid, low concentrations potassium cyanide (3.5 μM), sodium azide, sodium sulfide, superoxide dismutase and high concentrations SHAM (25 mM) inhibited this reaction. Except for high concentrations of SHAM and concentrations of KCN higher than approx. 3.5 μM, these effectors could not be used to inhibit the peroxidase-mediated O₂ uptake in intact roots of B. pinnatum. Concentrations of SHAM below 10 mM stimulated O₂ uptake up to 15% of the control rate, depending on concentration, whereas 25 mM SHAM inhibited O₂ uptake by 35%. The stimulation at low concentrations resulted from a SHAM-stimulated peroxidase activity, whereas 25 mM SHAM completely inhibited both the peroxidase-mediated O₂ uptake and the activity of the alternative pathway. A method is presented for determining the relative contributions of each of the four O₂-consuming reactions, i.e. the cytochrome pathway, the alternative pathway, the “residual component” and the peroxidase-mediated O₂ uptake. The peroxidase-mediated O₂ uptake contributed 21% to the total rate of oxygen uptake in roots of B. pinnatum, the cytochrome pathway contributed 41%, the alternative pathway 14% and the “residual component” 24%.     

Balance between Cyanide-Sensitive and -Insensitive Respiration in Wheat Root Mitochondria, as Influenced by Salt Concentration in the Plant Growth Medium

Mitochondria were isolated from 7-day-old wheat roots (Triticum vulgare Vill. cv. Svenno Spring Wheat) grown in either a full-strength culture medium (100%) or in the same medium diluted 100 times (1%). Outer membrane integrity was assayed using the cytochrome c reduction assay. This indicated about 20% damage. Using an oxygen electrode the respiration of the mitochondria was measured with either malate or succinate as the substrate (both 40 mM). KCN (3 mM) and salicylhydroxamic acid (SHAM, 1 mM) were used as inhibitors. The properties of the isolated mitochondria (STATE 3 rate, ADP/O ratio, and KCN-sensitivity) depend upon the ionic concentration of the growth medium of the roots. In the mitochondria isolated from roots grown in the 1% medium (1% mitochondria) there is a synergistic effect of KCN and SHAM. This means that electrons can be shifted from one pathway to the other when only one of the inhibitors is added. This flexibility between the electron pathways is almost nil in the mitochondria isolated from roots grown in the 100% medium (100% mitochondria). The maximal capacity of the alternative electron pathway (= rate in the presence of KCN) is higher in 1% (40 nmol O₂ min^?1 (mg protein)^?1) than in 100% mitochondria (20 nmol O₂ min^?1 (mg protein)^?1. In 100% mitochondria the alternative pathway seems to be operating at maximal capacity in the absence of KCN with both substrates and in both STATES 3 and 4. In 1% mitochondria the alternative pathway functions at >50% of its capacity in the absence of KCN.     

Specificity of the Organic Acid Activation of Alternative Oxidase in Plant Mitochondria

The claim that succinate and malate can directly stimulate the activity of the alternative oxidase in plant mitochondria (A.M. Wagner, C.W.M. van den Bergen, H. Wincencjusz [1995] Plant Physiol 108: 1035-1042) was reinvestigated using sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas L.) mitochondria. In whole mitochondria, succinate (in the presence of malonate) and both L- and D-malate stimulated respiration via alternative oxidase in a pH- (and NAD+)-dependent manner. Solubilized malic enzyme catalyzed the oxidation of both L- and D-malate, although the latter at only a low rate and only at acid pH. In submitochondrial particle preparations with negligible malic enzyme activity, neither L- nor D-malate stimulated alternative oxidase activity. However, even in the presence of high malonate concentrations, some succinate oxidation was observed via the alternative oxidase, giving the impression of stimulation of the oxidase. Neither L-malate nor succinate (in the presence of malonate) changed the dependence of alternative oxidase activity on ubiquinone reduction state in submitochondrial particles. In contrast, a large change in this dependence was observed upon addition of pyruvate. Half-maximal stimulation of alternative oxidase by pyruvate occurred at less than 5 [mu]M in submitochondrial particles, one-twentieth of that reported for whole mitochondria, suggesting that pyruvate acts on the inside of the mitochondrion. We suggest that malate and succinate do not directly stimulate alternative oxidase, and that reports to the contrary reflect intra-mitochondrial generation of pyruvate via malic enzyme.     

Differential Expression of Alternative Oxidase Genes in Soybean Cotyledons during Postgerminative Development

The expression of the alternative oxidase (AOX) was investigated during cotyledon development in soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) seedlings. The total amount of AOX protein increased throughout development, not just in earlier stages as previously thought, and was correlated with the increase in capacity of the alternative pathway. Each AOX isoform (AOX1, AOX2, and AOX3) showed a different developmental trend in mRNA abundance, such that the increase in AOX protein and capacity appears to involve a shift in gene expression from AOX2 to AOX3. As the cotyledons aged, the size of the mitochondrial ubiquinone pool decreased. We discuss how this and other factors may affect the alternative pathway activity that results from the developmental regulation of AOX expression.     

Alternative pathway of respiration in Physarum polycephalum plasmodia

The external application of inhibitors of glycolysis in the presence of KCN shows a lethal effect on plasmodia of Physarum polycephalum. However, alpha-ketoglutarate, but not succinate, maintains the contraction-relaxation cycle of plasmodial actomyosin in spite of the fact that glycolysis and cytochrome oxidase are inhibited. The oscillations supported by ketoglutarate disappear in the presence of SHAM, an inhibitor of alternative oxidase. These results imply the existence of KCN-resistant, alternative pathway of electron transport in the mitochondria of Physarum polycephalum.