Activating the DNA damage checkpoint in a developmental context

BACKGROUND: Studies in unicellular systems have established that DNA damage by irradiation invokes a checkpoint that acts to stall cell division. During metazoan development, the modulation of cell division by checkpoints must occur in the context of gastrulation, differential gene expression and changes in cell cycle regulation. To understand the effects of checkpoint activation in a developmental context, we examined the effect of X-rays on post-blastoderm embryos of Drosophila melanogaster. RESULTS: In Drosophila, DNA damage was previously found to delay anaphase chromosome separation during cleavage cycles that lack a G2 phase. In post-blastoderm cycles that included a G2 phase, we found that irradiation delayed the entry into mitosis. Gastrulation and the developmental program of string (Cdc25) gene expression, which normally regulates the timing of mitosis, occurred normally after irradiation. The radiation-induced delay of mitosis accompanied the exclusion of mitotic cyclins from the nucleus. Furthermore, a mutant form of the mitotic kinase Cdk1 that cannot be inhibited by phosphorylation drove a mitotic cyclin into the nucleus and overcame the delay of mitosis induced by irradiation. CONCLUSIONS: Developmental changes in the cell cycle, for example, the introduction of a G2 phase, dictate the response to checkpoint activation, for example, delaying mitosis instead of or in addition to delaying anaphase. This unprecedented finding suggests that different mechanisms are used at different points during metazoan development to stall cell division in response to checkpoint activation. The delay of mitosis in post-blastoderm embryos is due primarily to inhibitory phosphorylation of Cdk1, whereas nuclear exclusion of a cyclin-Cdk1 complex might play a secondary role. Delaying cell division has little effect on gastrulation and developmentally regulated string gene expression, supporting the view that development generally dictates cell proliferation and not vice versa.     

Cytosine arabinoside is a potent clastogen and does not affect the repair of X-ray-induced chromosome fragments in unstimulated human lymphocytes

The metabolic inhibitor of DNA synthesis cytosine arabinoside (ara-C) is known to induce chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes. It has been recently argued, however, that there is no unequivocal evidence that ara-C can damage chromosomes directly. Therefore, the effect of ara-C on unstimulated human lymphocytes was examined directly by means of the premature chromosome condensation technique. In about 50% of the cells, ara-C effectively induced chromosome fragments, which did not show rejoining even after the chemical was washed out. These results suggest that a possible selection against damaged cells in their progress to mitosis could result in the low yields of ara-C-induced chromosome aberrations reported in the literature. The effect of ara-C on the repair of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations was also examined. Ara-C did not affect the rejoining of the chromosome fragments induced in unstimulated human lymphocytes by 6 Gy of X-rays.     

A comparative study of the potentiating effect of caffeine and poly-D-lysine on chromosome damage induced by X-rays in plant cells.

X-Ray-induced chromosomal aberrations (CA) were potentiated by post-treatments in G2 with either caffeine (caff) or poly-D-lysine (PDL) in root-tip cells of Allium cepa. The enhancement of the yield of CA was concomitant with an increase in the frequency of mitosis. Our results seem to support the idea of a direct relationship between radiation-induced G2 delay and repair of chromosome damage. Here we report on similarities between caffeine and PDL in both decreasing G2 delay and enhancing chromatid aberration yield. The possible molecular mechanism(s) of action responsible for the cytogenetic effects observed are discussed.     

Detection of chromosome aberrations by FISH as a function of cell division cycle (harlequin-FISH)

Chromosome aberrations are a sensitive indicator of genetic change, and the measurement of chromosome aberration frequency in peripheral blood lymphocytes is often used as a biological dosimeter of exposure (1,4). The length of time that cells are maintained in culture before cytogenetic analysis is probably the most important in vitro factor that influences both the frequency and types of aberrations that are seen following exposure to mutagens. Therefore, for accurate cytogenetic measurements of genetic damage, cells must be analyzed in their first mitosis following exposure. As cells progress through subsequent mitotic division cycles, cells with unstable types of aberrations, e.g., dicentrics and acentric fragments, are eliminated (1,3,4). Even the use of synchronized populations of cells does not guarantee that all cells analyzed will be in their first division following treatment. Small variations in growth rate after irradiation can lead to large variations in the proportion of cells that are in their first vs. a subsequent mitosis. For example, 48 h after G0 lymphocytes are stimulated to enter the cell cycle (the standard sampling time for cytogenetic analysis), up to 50% of the cells in mitosis can be in their second division cycle (10). While there are methods available to distinguish cells in different division cycles (see Introduction), they are not easily adapted for use with standard fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) procedures. The goal of this study was to develop a simple approach to detect aberrations by FISH whereby cells in different division cycles could be distinguished.     

Adaptive response in different mitotic cycles after irradiation

The frequency of cells with chromosome aberrations and the number of aberrations per cell have been studied by metaphase analysis in the nonirradiated progeny of irradiated human blood lymphocytes. DNA fragmentation (DNA double-stranded breaks) has been investigated by DNA comet assay. To study the adaptive response (AR), PHA-stimulated lymphocytes were irradiated by the adaptive dose (0.05 Gy) in 24 h and by challenge dose (1 Gy) in 48 h after stimulation. The first through fourth mitoses were identified by 5-bromodeoxyuridine. It was found that the frequency of chromosome aberrations and double-strand breaks were increased in all mitotic cycles after the challenge irradiation. In most individuals, the adaptive response is induced by adaptive and challenge irradiations in the first and the second mitotic cycles (48 and 72 h after stimulation, respectively); however, it is absent in the third and the fourth mitoses. In the first mitosis (1Gy in 48 h after stimulation), only chromatid aberrations are observed; chromosome aberrations were registered in subsequent mitoses. DNA comet assay showed that the adaptive response was obvious at 48–72 h, but not 96 h, after stimulation. It can be concluded that the nonirradiated progeny of irradiated lymphocytes have genomic instability. The adaptive response is manifested up to the third mitosis and is explained by the decreasing number of chromatid and chromosome aberrations and DNA fragmentation. We suppose that double-stranded DNA breaks may be damage signals for the induction of adaptive response.     

Cell survival and radiation induced chromosome aberrations

Human peripheral lymphocytes were irradiated in whole blood with 0.5-4.0 Gy of 220 kVp X-rays and the frequency of chromosome aberrations was determined in 1st or 2nd division metaphases discriminated by fluorescence plus giemsa staining. Using the empirical distributions of aberrations among cells, cell survival and transmission of aberrations were investigated. Considering both daughter cells, we found that 20% of fragments and 55% of dicentrics or ring chromosomes are lost during the 1st cell division; i.e. cell survival rate from 1st to 2nd generation is mainly influenced by anaphase bridging of these two-hit aberrations. Cell survival to 2nd mitosis was calculated considering this situation and compared with the survival derived from the fraction of M 1 cells without unstable aberrations. The resulting shouldered survival curves showed significantly different slopes, indicating that cell reproductive death is overestimated in the latter approach.     

Modeling radiation-induced cell cycle delays

Ionizing radiation is known to delay the cell cycle progression. In particular after particle exposure significant delays have been observed and it has been shown that the extent of delay affects the expression of damage, such as chromosome aberrations. Thus, to predict how cells respond to ionizing radiation and to derive reliable estimates of radiation risks, information about radiation-induced cell cycle perturbations is required. In the present study we describe and apply a method for retrieval of information about the time-course of all cell cycle phases from experimental data on the mitotic index only. We study the progression of mammalian cells through the cell cycle after exposure. The analysis reveals a prolonged block of damaged cells in the G2 phase. Furthermore, by performing an error analysis on simulated data valuable information for the design of experimental studies has been obtained. The analysis showed that the number of cells analyzed in an experimental sample should be at least 100 to obtain a relative error <20%.     

Possible mechanisms of the occurrence of chromosome restructurings. IV. Chromosome restructurings in spontaneous mutagenesis

An attempt was undertaken to modify the spontaneous mutation process by varying its conditions in somatic cells of different species and tissues. The rate of chromosome aberrations and their types were studied in anaphase and metaphase. Under normal conditions, chromosome breaks were only found to occur. Breakage of chromosomes occurs during interphase, and as a result, acentric fragments are located outside the equatorial plate during metaphase. This process of chromosome breakage leads to elimination of some genetic material, without concomitant exchanges, and therefore, it has been named "elimination" process. Spontaneous chromosome mutagenesis manifesting itself at cytogenetic level was concluded to be an elimination process directed to elimination of a portion of chromatin from chromosomes. When the conditions of spontaneous mutagenesis are altered, in particular, by cardiovascular diseases in man, by partial inhibition of DNA repair in mice and pea cells, by transformation of Chinese hamster cells, upon ageing of pea seeds-qualitative changes in the chromosomal aberrations are registered, connected with the appearance of chromosome exchanges and acentric fragments situated within the equatorial plate during metaphase. These two types of chromosome aberrations are proposed to be considered as new criteria of pathology. A system of processes was suggested to exist, preventing the appearance of aberrations during mitosis, and it is supposed to be one of the most significant homeostatic systems.     

A comparison of chromosomal radiosensitivities of somatic cells of mouse and man.

A cell culture technique for quantitative analysis of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in somatic cells has been developed and used for the comparison of chromosomal sensitivity of skin cells of mouse and man to 60Co-gamma-rays. This includes culture of irradiated tissues or cells in culture in arginine and isoleucine-deficient medium and subsequent refeeding with complete medium (CM). With this technique, radiation-induced chromosome aberrations can be analyzed selectively in the cells exposed in G1 phase and recovered at their first post-irradiation mitosis. When tested on the human embryonic cells, the dicentric yield was essentially the same whether they were skin cells irradiated in silu or cultured cells at various in vitro passages irradiated in vitro. In contrast, when studied in the skin cells irradiated in silu, mouse embryos and newborns were insensitive to the induction of dicentrics. In young mice on day II however, the sensitivity was at a level comparable to that in human embryonic cells and it was intermediate on day 4. Such embryonic insensitivity of the mouse cells was rapidly lost during serial transfer in vitro; and, when tested at 4th or later subculture generations, mouse and human cells were equally sensitive to the induction of dicentrics. These results suggest that the chromosomal radiosensitivity is essentially the same for mouse and human cells but can be modified by some biological factors, possibly DNA repair mechanisms, which differ between species as well as among the states of differentiation of particular cell types. Special attention was paid to the parellelism between the age-dependent changes in the chromosomal, mutational and carcinogenic radiosensitivities in the mouse. If this parallelism can be carried over to man, human pre-natal irradiation will not present any reduced genetic hazards.     

DNA damage during mitosis in human cells delays the metaphase/anaphase transition via the spindle-assembly checkpoint

BACKGROUND: DNA damage during mitosis triggers an ATM kinase-mediated cell cycle checkpoint pathway in yeast and fly embryos that delays progression through division. Recent data suggest that this is also true for mammals. Here we used laser microsurgery and inhibitors of topoisomerase IIalpha to break DNA in various mammalian cells after they became committed to mitosis. We then followed the fate of these cells and emphasized the timing of mitotic progression, spindle structure, and chromosome behavior. RESULTS: We find that DNA breaks generated during late prophase do not impede entry into prometaphase. If the damage is minor, cells complete mitosis on time. However, more significant damage substantially delays exit from mitosis in many cell types. In human (HeLa, CFPAC-1, and hTERT-RPE) cells, this delay occurs during metaphase, after the formation of a bipolar spindle and the destruction of cyclin A, and it is not dependent on a functional p53 pathway. Pretreating cells with ATM kinase inhibitors does not abrogate the metaphase delay due to chromosome damage. Immunofluorescence studies reveal that cells blocked in metaphase by chromosome damage contain one or more Mad2-positive kinetochores, and the block is rapidly overridden when the cells are microinjected with a dominant-negative construct of Mad2 (Mad2deltaC). CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that the delay in mitosis induced by DNA damage is not due to an ATM-mediated DNA damage checkpoint pathway. Rather, the damage leads to defects in kinetochore attachment and function that, in turn, maintain the intrinsic Mad-2-based spindle assembly checkpoint.     

Increase in the frequency of gamma-ray induced chromosomal aberrations in mammalian cells by post-treatment with novobiocin

The effect of novobiocin (an inhibitor of DNA topoisomerase and polymerase) on the frequency of chromosomal aberrations was examined in Chinese hamster V79 cells irradiated with gamma-rays in the plateau phase of growth and subcultured in the presence of novobiocin until the first mitosis after irradiation. Novobiocin alone affected cell survival, DNA synthesis and the mitotic frequency of unirradiated cells in a dose-dependent manner, without causing any significant increase in the frequency of chromosome- or chromatid-type aberrations. The frequency of chromosome-type aberrations induced by gamma-radiation was not influenced by novobiocin at 200 microM, but the frequency of chromosome deletions (but not rings and dicentrics) showed a two-fold increase when 300 microM novobiocin was present. Irradiation produced a low level of chromatid-type aberrations and post-treatment with novobiocin at concentrations greater than 100 microM significantly increased the frequency of chromatid gaps and breaks. The results support the idea that different radiation-induced lesions lead to chromosome- as opposed to chromatid-type aberrations.     

TEL1 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae suppresses chromosome aberrations induced by ionizing radiation in ataxia-telangiectasia cells without affecting cell cycle checkpoints

The TEL1 gene from Saccharomyces cere- visiae has been shown to be the closest sequence homologue to ATM, the gene mutated in ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) patients. Functional homology shared between the ATM and Tel1 proteins has recently been demonstrated based on heterologous expression of the TEL1 gene in human cells derived from A-T patients. TEL1 expression complemented specific cellular A-T deficiencies, i.e. increased radiation-induced apoptosis, telomere shortening and spontaneous hyperrecombination. The mechanism of cellular A-T complementation by TEL1 appears to be independent of p53-dependent signaling cascades, since the deficiency of A-T cells to properly induce p53 upon ionizing radiation was not corrected by TEL1. We now find that the basic number of chromosome aberrations is increased and the number of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations is suppressed in A-T cells upon TEL1 expression. In cell cycle analyses, we find no changes in basic cell cycle distribution or in radiation-induced cell cycle checkpoints following TEL1 expression. We conclude that the radioprotective function of the Tel1 protein includes suppression of apoptosis and suppression of chromosome aberrations, and that both cellular endpoints can be uncoupled from ionizing radiation-induced cell cycle checkpoints. Received: 6 November 2000 / Accepted: 1 October 2001     

A delay in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell cycle that is induced by a dicentric chromosome and dependent upon mitotic checkpoints.

Dicentric chromosomes are genetically unstable and depress the rate of cell division in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We have characterized the effects of a conditionally dicentric chromosome on the cell division cycle by using microscopy, flow cytometry, and an assay for histone H1 kinase activity. Activating the dicentric chromosome induced a delay in the cell cycle after DNA replication and before anaphase. The delay occurred in the absence of RAD9, a gene required to arrest cell division in response to DNA damage. The rate of dicentric chromosome loss, however, was elevated in the rad9 mutant. A mutation in BUB2, a gene required for arrest of cell division in response to loss of microtubule function, diminished the delay. Both RAD9 and BUB2 appear to be involved in the cellular response to a dicentric chromosome, since the conditionally dicentric rad9 bub2 double mutant was highly inviable. We conclude that a dicentric chromosome results in chromosome breakage and spindle aberrations prior to nuclear division that normally activate mitotic checkpoints, thereby delaying the onset of anaphase.     

Relation between the dynamics of the cell cycle and the frequency of chromosome aberrations in cultured irradiated human lymphocytes

The method of differential staining of sister chromatids was used to study the dynamics of cell divisions at different periods of fixation (48, 56, 68, 80 h) of human lymphocyte cultures in control and after gamma-irradiation in vitro in doses of 150 and 300 rad. It is shown that the cell population of lymphocytes is extremely asynchronous by the time of first and subsequent cell divisions. Administration of gamma-rays before PHA stimulation results in a mitotic delay whose duration is proportional to the irradiation dose. The frequency of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations does not reliably differ in early- and late-dividing cells.     

Characterization of the cytotoxic mechanism of Mana-Hox, an analog of manzamine alkaloids

Mana-Hox is a synthetic analog of manzamines, which are beta-carboline alkaloids isolated from marine sponges. Mana-Hox exhibited cytotoxicity against various tumor cell lines with the IC(50) range from 1 to 5 microM. Cell cycle synchronization and flow cytometric analysis showed that Mana-Hox delayed cell cycle progression at mitosis. At the concentration that delayed mitotic progression, bipolar spindle with lagged chromosomes and multipolar spindle with disorganized chromosomes were detected. The presence of such aberrant mitotic cells accompanied by the activation of spindle checkpoint that delayed cells exit from mitosis. However, after a short delay, lagged chromosomes were able to display in the abnormal metaphase plates, and subsequent cell division resulting in chromosome missegregation. Furthermore, the aberrant mitotic cells showed lower viability, indicating that Mana-Hox-induced cell death resulting from chromosome missegregation. This study is the first to explore cytotoxic mechanism of a manzamine-related compound and understand its potential as a lead compound for the development of future anticancer agents.     

Cytogenetic effects of densely ionising radiation in human lymphocytes: impact of cell cycle delays

The classical cytogenetic assay to estimate the dose to which an individual has been exposed relies on the measurement of chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes at the first post-irradiation mitosis 48 h after in vitro stimulation. However, evidence is accumulating that this protocol results in an underestimation of the cytogenetic effects of high LET radiation due to a selective delay of damaged cells. To address this issue, human lymphocytes were irradiated with C-ions (25-mm extended Bragg peak, LET: 60-85 keV/ micro m) and aberrations were measured in cells reaching the first mitosis after 48, 60, 72 and 84 h and in G2-phase cells collected after 48 h by calyculin A induced premature chromosome condensation (PCC). The results were compared with recently published data on the effects of X-rays and 200 MeV/u Fe-ions (LET: 440 keV/ micro m) on lymphocytes of the same donor (Ritter et al., 2002a). The experiments show clearly that the aberration yield rises in first-generation metaphase (M1) with culture time and that this effect increases with LET. Obviously, severely damaged cells suffer a prolonged arrest in G2. The mitotic delay has a profound effect on the RBE: RBE values estimated from the PCC data were about two times higher than those obtained by conventional metaphase analysis at 48 h. Altogether, these observations argue against the use of single sampling times to quantify high LET induced chromosomal damage in metaphase cells.     

Genetic processes and the problem of the target in chromosomal mutagenesis

Based on analysis of literature data and the data of the authors, it is assumed that there are two main mechanisms of formation of structural chromosome mutations in eukaryotic cells: 1) homologous recombination, resulting in formation of all kinds of chromosome exchanges; 2) the process of telomere formation, resulting in generation of true deletions. Some chromosome breaks registered in the first K mitosis of cells after exposure reflect temporary disturbance of chromatin condensation. These aberrations are able to repair in the next nuclear cycle. The facts are presented that argue in favour of existence of minor fraction of DNA sequences that serve as molecular basis of specific targets of chromosome mutagenesis. These sequences can play essential role in the normal structural and functional organization of nucleus.     

The radioenhancement of two human head and neck squamous cell carcinomas by 2'-2' difluorodeoxycytidine (gemcitabine; dFdC) is mediated by an increase in radiation-induced residual chromosome aberrations but not residual DNA DSBs

PURPOSE: The present study aimed at investigating if 2'-2' difluorodeoxycytidine (dFdC) radioenhancement was mediated by an effect on induction and/or repair of radiation-induced DNA DSBs and chromosome aberrations in cells with different intrinsic radiosensitivity. METHODS: Confluent human head and neck squamous cell carcinoma cell lines designated SCC61 and SQD9 were treated with 5 microM dFdC for 3 or 24 h prior to irradiation. DNA DSBs induction and repair were analyzed by PFGE. Radiation-induced chromosome aberrations were examined with a FISH technique. RESULTS: In both cell lines, dFdC did not modify radiation-induced DNA DSBs in a dose range between 0 and 40 Gy. After a single dose of 40 Gy, dFdC affected neither the kinetic of repair nor the residual amount of DNA DSBs up to 4 h after irradiation. Whereas dFdC did not increase the induction of chromosome aberrations, after a single dose of 5 Gy, the percentage of aberrant cells and the number of aberrations per aberrant cells were significantly higher in combination with dFdC. CONCLUSION: Our data suggest that under experimental conditions yielding substantial radioenhancement, dFdC decreases the repair of genomic lesions inducing secondary chromosome breaks but has no effect on DNA DSBs repair as measured by PFGE.     

Radiosensitive strains of Drosophila. XII. Realization of the effect of mutation rad(2)201G1 at the cell and organism levels

Two effects of gamma-rays were studied on radiosensitive mutant rad(2)201G1 and wild type strain rad+ of Drosophila: the rate of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in somatic cells and lethality of individuals irradiated at different stages of preimaginal development. It has been shown that mutant strain is characterized by the increased rate of chromosome aberrations in somatic cells and lethality of developing flies. Control strain rad+ is characterized by more complicated relationship between the effects analyzed. The results obtained are discussed in connection with the action of rad(2)201G1 gene on repair of genetic damages and with existence of postradiation compensation mechanisms intrinsic in development of multicellular organisms.     

Different effects of 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine and aphidicolin in S-phase cells--chromosome aberrations, cell-cycle delay and cytotoxicity

Some effects of a 2-h exposure to either aphidicolin (APC) or cytosine arabinoside (ara-C) on S-phase cells of the cell line JU56 have been measured. At a concentration of 1.5 X 10(-5) M of either drug, incorporation of tritiated thymidine into log-phase cultured was reduced by 97-99%. A 2-h exposure to either drug at the same concentration induced chromosome aberrations in cells in S when they subsequently reached mitosis. However, exposure to ara-C induced small numbers of aberrations per damaged cells, and most cells were undamaged. Exposure to APC induced gross chromosomal damage (pulverized chromosomes) in damaged cells. More cells were delayed, and for longer, after exposure to APC than after exposure to ara-C. The results of clonal assays were consistent with the assumption that chromosome aberrations are the proximal cause of reproductive cell death. In the case of ara-C, the results of this and a previous study are consistent with the assumption that cell death and chromosome aberrations are correlated with incorporation of ara-C into DNA in S-phase cells, but that these biological effects manifest themselves only with doses when inhibition of semi-conservative DNA synthesis is greater than 97%.