Altered thyroid hormone levels affect the capacity for temperature-induced developmental plasticity in larvae of Rana temporaria and Xenopus laevis

Anuran larvae show phenotypic plasticity in age and size at metamorphosis as a response to temperature variation. The capacity for temperature-induced developmental plasticity is determined by the thermal adaptation of a population. Multiple factors such as physiological responses to changing environmental conditions, however, might influence this capacity as well. In anuran larvae, thyroid hormone (TH) levels control growth and developmental rate and changes in TH status are a well-known stress response to sub-optimal environmental conditions. We investigated how chemically altered TH levels affect the capacity to exhibit temperature-induced developmental plasticity in larvae of the African clawed frog (Xenopus laevis) and the common frog (Rana temporaria). In both species, TH level influenced growth and developmental rate and modified the capacity for temperature-induced developmental plasticity. High TH levels reduced thermal sensitivity of metamorphic traits up to 57% (R. temporaria) and 36% (X. laevis). Rates of growth and development were more plastic in response to temperature in X. laevis (+30%) than in R. temporaria (+6%). Plasticity in rates of growth and development is beneficial to larvae in heterogeneous habitats as it allows a more rapid transition into the juvenile stage where rates of mortality are lower. Therefore, environmental stressors that increase endogenous TH levels and reduce temperature-dependent plasticity may increase risks and the vulnerability of anuran larvae. As TH status also influences metabolism, future studies should investigate whether reductions in physiological plasticity also increases the vulnerability of tadpoles to global change.     

Ontogeny of the Thyroid Glands During Larval Development of South American Horned Frogs (Anura,Ceratophryidae)

The role of thyroid hormone (TH) in anuran metamorphosis has been documented from a variety of approaches, but the sequence of morpho-histological development of the thyroid glands that produce the secretion of the hormone was assumed invariant from studies of relatively few species even when the effects of environmental influences on larval development and metamorphosis have been largely documented. There are anurans in which developmental and growth rates diverge, and the resulting heterochrony in growth and development produces giant/miniature tadpoles, and or rapid/delayed metamorphosis suggesting changes of the activity of the thyroid glands during larval development. Herein, we analyze the morpho-histological variation of the thyroid glands in larval series of Ceratophrys cranwelli, Chacophrys pierottii, Lepidobatrachus laevis and L. llanensis that share breeding sites along semiarid environments of the Chaco in South America, belong to a monophyletic lineage, and present accelerated patterns in growth and development in order to have a morphological evidence about a possible shift of TH physiology. We describe gross morphology and histology of the thyroid glands and find features shared by all studied species such as the presence of supernumerary heterotopic follicles; changes in the volume and number of follicles towards the metamorphic climax, and cuboidal epithelia with occasional intra-cellular vacuoles as signs of low glandular activity without a manifest peak at the climax as it was assumed for anurans. We discuss different lines of evidence to interpret sources of extra supplement of TH to support the rapid metamorphosis. These interpretations highlight the necessity to design a research program to investigate the endocrine variation during development of ceratophryids taking in account their morphology, physiology and ecology in order to learn more about the effects of environmental and developmental interactions involved in the anuran evolution.     

Histology and microscopic anatomy of the thyroid gland during the larval development of Pseudis platensis (Anura,Hylidae)

Several hormones regulate anuran larval development, most notably thyroid hormones (THs). In anurans, metamorphosis fails when the thyroid gland is absent or inactivated, resulting in giant tadpoles. Larval gigantism occurs naturally in neotropical frogs of the genus Pseudis as a result of a prolonged larval period. Its thyroid function is poorly investigated and the focus of this study. We describe qualitative and quantitative variations in larval development for field-captured specimens of Pseudis platensis and compare those to the development of two sympatric species, Phyllomedusa sauvagii and Pithecopus azureus, which have small tadpoles and a shorter larval period. We describe morphological changes in the thyroid glands of larval and adult specimens. In contrast to other species with similar ecological requirements, P. platensis exhibits distinct glandular activity. During premetamorphosis, there was little or no thyroid activity, a period in which the tadpole reached 70% of its maximum size. Development and degree of activity of the thyroid gland determine the duration of the early stages of the larval period. Thyroid gland histology in tadpoles appears to correlate with the TH activity, and in turn with the diversity in anuran life history transitions.     

Cell-cell interactions during remodeling of the intestine at metamorphosis in Xenopus laevis

Amphibian metamorphosis is accompanied by extensive intestinal remodeling. This process, mediated by thyroid hormone (TH) and its nuclear receptors, affects every cell type. Gut remodeling in Xenopus laevis involves epithelial and mesenchymal proliferation, smooth muscle thickening, neuronal aggregation, formation of intestinal folds, and shortening of its length by 75%. Transgenic tadpoles expressing a dominant negative TH receptor (TRDN) controlled by epithelial-, fibroblast-, and muscle-specific gene promoters were studied. TRDN expression in the epithelium caused abnormal development of virtually all cell types, with froglet guts displaying reduced intestinal folds, thin muscle and mesenchyme, absence of neurons, and reduced cell proliferation. TRDN expression in fibroblasts caused abnormal epithelia and mesenchyme development, and expression in muscle produced fewer enteric neurons and a reduced inter-muscular space. Gut shortening was inhibited only when TRDN was expressed in fibroblasts. Gut remodeling results from both cell-autonomous and cell-cell interactions.     

Enzyme patterns in two species of Xenopus and their hybrids

Differences in the isozyme patterns of Xenopus laevis and Xenopus mulleri have been utilized to examine the expression of alleles of both species in hybrid animals. Mitochondrial MDH and tetrazolium oxidase phenotypes were examined during the development of non-hybrid embryos of each species and of reciprocal hybrids. Early stages of the hybrids resemble the enzyme phenotype of the maternal parent. Appearance of paternal enzyme takes place just prior to the active feeding tadpole stage for both mitochondrial MDH and oxidase. The maternal effect disappears shortly thereafter in early feeding tadpoles, at which point reciprocal hybrids have identical isozyme patterns. There is no evidence for a predominance of one species over the other. Examination of feeding tadpoles and adult toads indicates that both laevis and mulleri expression is stable. The appearance of paternal mitochondrial MDH does not correspond to the time when other mitochondrial components begin to increase in Xenopus. Multiple bands of MDH in both species and of oxidase in laevis are probably not due to the aggregation of subunits produced by different alleles at the same locus. There is no evidence for the formation of “hybrid” molecules consisting of subunits of both species.     

Patterns of protein synthesis in livers of Xenopus laevis during metamorphosis: Effects of estrogen in normal and thyrostatic animals

Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis has been used to analyse protein synthesis in the livers of Xenopus laevis larvae during metamorphosis. The patterns found at different developmental stages have been characterised and compared to those found in developmentally static tadpoles and estrogen-treated tadpoles. The results suggest that the majority of proteins synthesized by the larval liver during metamorphosis can be divided equally into three main categories: those which are synthesized continuously, those whose synthesis is lost, and those whose synthesis is gained during development. The synthesis of proteins tends to be lost earlier in metamorphosis than it is gained. The pattern of liver protein synthesis in thyrostatic animals is not characteristic of any single stage of normal development, and displays features characteristic of many different stages. About half the changes in protein synthesis which occur during normal metamorphosis are dependent upon it. All the stages examined are responsive to estrogen, and each has a characteristic response. Half of the estrogen-induced changes in protein synthesis are independent of metamorphosis, while the other half require metamorphosis.     

Apoptosis in amphibian organs during metamorphosis

During amphibian metamorphosis, the larval tissues/organs rapidly degenerate to adapt from the aquatic to the terrestrial life. At the cellular level, a large quantity of apoptosis occurs in a spatiotemporally-regulated fashion in different organs to ensure timely removal of larval organs/tissues and the development of adult ones for the survival of the individuals. Thus, amphibian metamorphosis provides us a good opportunity to understand the mechanisms regulating apoptosis. To investigate this process at the molecular level, a number of thyroid hormone (TH) response genes have been isolated from several organs of Xenopus laevis tadpoles and their expression and functional analyses are now in progress using modern molecular and genetic technologies. In this review, we will first summarize when and where apoptosis occurs in typical larva-specific and larval-to-adult remodeling amphibian organs to highlight that the timing of apoptosis is different in different tissues/organs, even though all are induced by the same circulating TH. Next, to discuss how TH spatiotemporally regulates the apoptosis, we will focus on apoptosis of the X. laevis small intestine, one of the best characterized remodeling organs. Functional studies of TH response genes using transgenic frogs and culture techniques have shown that apoptosis of larval epithelial cells can be induced by TH either cell-autonomously or indirectly through interactions with extracellular matrix (ECM) components of the underlying basal lamina. Here, we propose that multiple intra- and extracellular apoptotic pathways are coordinately controlled by TH to ensure massive but well-organized apoptosis, which is essential for the proper progression of amphibian metamorphosis.     

Histo-morphology of the thyroid gland during the larval development of Pleurodema borellii (Anura,Leptodactylidae)

The thyroid gland is essential in anurans, since thyroid hormones (TH) are the main regulators of larval development. Its absence or inactivity interrupts development and precludes metamorphosis. Histological changes are important diagnostic criteria for evaluating thyroid gland activity. However, there is a large larval diversity where the development of the thyroid gland development has not been studied. Pleurodema borellii is an anuran from northwest of Argentina with typical omnivorous pond tadpoles that can be easily raised in captivity. This study explores the histo-morphological changes of the thyroid gland architecture during larval development. Histological parameters indicate peak glandular activity in parallel with the intensity of the metamorphic transformations. These parameters regress towards the end of metamorphosis, indicating low TH release. P. borellii's thyroid gland does not appear to have relevant activity in post-metamorphic juvenile stages. This study is a first step towards understanding endocrine regulation during the development of Pleurodema borellii, and a reference to future studies in this species involving thyroid-dependent processes.     

Developmental changes in interrenal responsiveness in anuran amphibians

Basal activity of the hypothalamo-pituitary-interrenal (HPI)axis changes over development in larval amphibians, but developmentof the responsiveness of this axis to an external stressor hasnot been studied. We compared developmental changes in whole-bodycorticosterone content of two anuran amphibian species, Ranapipiens (family Ranidae) and Xenopus laevis (family Pipidae).We also examined developmental changes in the responsivenessof the HPI axis by subjecting tadpoles of different developmentalstages to a laboratory shaking/confinement stress and to ACTHinjection. We measured whole-body corticosterone content asan indicator of the activity of the HPI axis. Whole-body corticosteronecontent of R. pipiens remained low during premetamorphosis andprometamorphosis but increased dramatically at metamorphic climaxand remained elevated in juvenile frogs. By contrast, whole-bodycorticosterone content of X. laevis was highest during premetamorphosis,declined at the onset of prometamorphosis, increased at metamorphicclimax and remained at climax levels in juvenile frogs. Premetamorphicand prometamorphic tadpoles of both species showed strong corticosteroneresponses to both shaking stress and ACTH injection. The magnitudeand pattern of response differed among developmental stages,with premetamorphic tadpoles of both species showing greaterresponsiveness to stress and ACTH. Our results show that interrenalresponsiveness is developed in premetamorphic tadpoles, suggestingthat at these stages tadpoles are capable of mounting an increasein stress hormone production in response to changes in the externalenvironment. Our results also highlight the importance of comparativestudies in understanding the development of the stress axis.     

Remodeling of insulin producing β-cells during Xenopus laevis metamorphosis

Insulin-producing β-cells are present as single cells or in small clusters distributed throughout the pancreas of the Xenopus laevis tadpole. During metamorphic climax when the exocrine pancreas dedifferentiates to progenitor cells, the β-cells undergo two changes. Insulin mRNA is down regulated at the beginning of metamorphic climax (NF62) and reexpressed again near the end of climax. Secondly, the β-cells aggregate to form islets. During climax the increase in insulin cluster size is not caused by cell proliferation or by acinar-to-β-cell transdifferentiation, but rather is due to the aggregation of pre-existing β-cells. The total number of β-cells does not change during the 8 days of climax. Thyroid hormone (TH) induction of premetamorphic tadpoles causes an increase in islet size while prolonged treatment of tadpoles with the goitrogen methimazole inhibits this increase. Expression of a dominant negative form of the thyroid hormone receptor (TRDN) driven by the elastase promoter not only protects the exocrine pancreas of a transgenic tadpole from TH-induced dedifferentiation but also prevents aggregation of β-cells at climax. These transgenic tadpoles do however undergo normal loss and resynthesis of insulin mRNA at the same stage as controls. In contrast transgenic tadpoles with the same TRDN transgene driven by an insulin promoter do not undergo down regulation of insulin mRNA, but do aggregate β-cells to form islets like controls. These results demonstrate that TH controls the remodeling of β-cells through cell-cell interaction with dedifferentiating acinar cells and a cell autonomous program that temporarily shuts off the insulin gene.     

Precocious testicular growth in metamorphosis-arrested larvae of a salamander Hynobius retardatus: role of thyroid-stimulating hormone

Precocious maturation of testes occurs in goitrogen-treated larvae of a salamander Hynobius retardatus, a particular population of which has been reported to show a neotenic reproduction in a specific environment. Similar precocious growth of testes also was confirmed in thyroidectomized larvae in this study. A possible involvement of thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) in the precocious maturation of testes was examined in metamorphosis-arrested larvae whose thyroid or pituitary glands had been removed surgically at embryonic stages or which had been reared in goitrogens. The pituitary glands of both the thyroidectomized and goitrogen-treated larvae contained extraordinarily large number of TSH cells, which were called "thyroidectomy cells." When homogenates of the pituitary glands from the goitrogen-treated larvae were injected into the hypophysectomized larvae for a month, the testes grew larger than those in larvae injected with the pituitary glands from normally metamorphosed controls. These results are consistent with the idea that an extraordinarily high concentration of TSH, which is induced by either thyroidectomy or goitrogen-treatment, causes the precocious maturation of testes in the metamorphosis-arrested larvae of Hynobius retardatus. In contrast to the precocious testicular development, ovarian development in the metamorphosis-arrested larvae was almost identical to that in normally metamorphosed animals within our experimental period. This also suggests that in males the absence of thyroid hormones allows a gonadal response that in females may require another activator in addition to or following thyroid axis stimulation.     

Tissue sensitivity to thyroid hormone in athyroid Xenopus laevis larvae

Tadpoles that spontaneously arrest development and remain as larvae occur occasionally in Xenopus laevis populations. These non-metamorphosing tadpoles continue to grow, and they develop into grossly deformed giant individuals which come as close as any anurans to being truly neotenic. Giant X. laevis tadpoles that fail to metamorphose lack thyroid glands. In this study, the hypothesis that the tissues of these tadpoles nevertheless remain thyroid hormone sensitive was tested, by exposing isolated tadpole tail tips to exogenous thyroid hormone in tissue culture. The tail tips from giant tadpoles significantly shrank in response to the thyroid hormone treatment, showing that their tissue was still capable of metamorphosis. However, the amount of shrinkage was less than that observed in tail tissue from normal tadpoles. It was hypothesized that complete induction of metamorphosis may not be possible in the giant tadpoles due to a disproportionate growth and development of tissues and organs.     

Sequential up-regulation of thyroid hormone β receptor,ornithine transcarbamylase,and carbamyl phosphate synthetase mRNAs in the liver of Rana catesbeiana tadpoles during spontaneous and thyroid hormone-induced metamorphosis

During both spontaneous and thyroid hormone (TH)-induced metamorphosis, the Rana catesbeiana tadpole undergoes postembryonic developmental changes in its liver which are necessary for its transition from an ammonotelic larva to a ureotelic adult. Although this transition ultimately results from marked increases in the activities and/or de novo synthesis of the urea cycle enzymes, the precise molecular means by which TH exerts this tissue-specific response are presently unknown. Recent reports, using RNA from whole Xenopus laevis tadpole homogenates and indirect means of measuring TH receptor (TR) mRNAs, suggest a correlation between the up-regulation of TRβ-mRNAs and the general morphological changes occurring during amphibian metamorphosis. To assess whether or not this same relationship exists in a TH-responsive tissue, such as liver, we isolated and characterized a cDNA clone containing the complete nucleotide sequence for a R. catesbeiana urea cycle enzyme, ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC), as well as a genomic clone containing a portion of the hormone-binding domain of a R. catesbeiana TRβ gene. Through use of these homologous sequences and a heterologous cDNA fragment encoding rat carbamyl phosphate synthetase (CPS), we directly determined the relative levels of the TRβ, OTC, and CPS mRNAs in liver from spontaneous and TH-induced tadpoles. Our results establish that TH affects an up-regulation of mRNAs for its own receptor prior to up-regulating CPS and OTC mRNAs. Moreover, results with cultured tadpole liver demonstrate that TH, in the absence of any other hormonal influence, can affect an up-regulation of both the TRβ and OTC mRNAs. © 1992 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The effect of exposure to black background and to α-MSH on black-white background preference in the amphibian Xenopus laevis (Daudin)

Young frogs, Xenopus laevis, raised on a white background showed a slight preference for the black background of a black-white preference testing apparatus. Keeping frogs for either 24 hr or 20 days on a black background resulted in a further increase in their preference for black. Injecting 1 μg of synthetic α-MSH into white-adapted frogs had no effect on their black-white preference. On the other hand, Xenopus laevis tadpoles, at an early stage of metamorphosis, raised on a white background showed a significant preference for white. Keeping these tadpoles for 24 hr on a black background resulted in a shift from white to black preference. Injecting synthetic α-MSH into white-adapted tadpoles resulted in an increase in their preference for black. A behavioral feedback mechanism appears to exist between the release of endogenous MSH when a tadpole is exposed to a black background and its subsequent preference for background color.     

Expression of a cardiac myosin gene in non-heart tissues of developing frogs

Direct developing frogs, like Eleutherodactylus coqui, provide opportunities to investigate limb early development in anuran amphibians that are less available in species with tadpoles. We have found that myosin heavy chain 6 (myh6), a myosin gene usually considered heart-specific in Xenopus and other animals, is expressed in limbs of E. coqui embryos. The gene for microRNA(miR)-208 is contained in an intron of the E. coqui myh6 gene as in mammals, and miR -208 was detected as a microRNA, more highly expressed in a microarray of E. coqui limb buds, compared to Xenopus laevis limb buds. Myh6 is also expressed in several muscles of tadpoles and froglets of Xenopus tropicalis. These connections raise the possibility of an involvement of myh6 and miR-208 in the thyroid dependent metamorphosis of anurans.     

A role of unliganded thyroid hormone receptor in postembryonic development in Xenopus laevis

A fascinating feature of thyroid hormone (T3) receptors (TR) is that they constitutively bind to promoter regions of T3-response genes, providing dual functions. In the presence of T3, TR activates T3-inducible genes, while unliganded TR represses these same genes. Although this dual function model is well demonstrated at the molecular level, few studies have addressed the presence or the role of unliganded TR-induced repression in physiological settings. Here, we analyze the role of unliganded TR in Xenopus laevis development. The total dependence of amphibian metamorphosis upon T3 provides us a valuable opportunity for studying TR function in vivo. First, we designed a dominant negative form of TR-binding corepressor N-CoR (dnN-CoR) consisting of its receptor interacting domain. We confirmed its dominant negative activity by showing that dnN-CoR competes away the binding of endogenous N-CoR to unliganded TR and relieves unliganded TR-induced gene repression in frog oocytes. Next, we overexpressed dnN-CoR in tadpoles through transgenesis and analyzed its effect on gene expression and development. Quantitative RT-PCR revealed significant derepression of T3-response genes in transgenic animals. In addition, transgenic tadpoles developed faster than wild type siblings, with an acceleration of as much as 7 days out of the 30-day experiment. These data thus provide in vivo evidence for the presence and a role of unliganded TR-induced gene repression in physiological settings and strongly support our earlier model that unliganded TR represses T3-response genes in premetamorphic tadpoles to regulate the progress of development.     

Expression and regulation of miR-1, -133a, -206a, and MRFs by thyroid hormone during larval development in Paralichthys olivaceus

MiR-1, miR-133a, and miR-206a have been identified as muscle-specific miRNAs. They play multiple crucial roles in the regulation of muscle development. Here, we show that these miRNAs were differentially expressed during the larval development of flounder, and specifically expressed in skeletal muscle and heart in adult tissues/organs. The expression levels of these miRNAs were significantly changed by thyroid hormone (TH) or thiourea (TU) treatment during metamorphosis from 17 dph (days post hatching) to 42 dph. In addition, the expression levels of MyoD and Myf5 mRNAs markedly increased at 14 dph (pre-metamorphosis) compared to metamorphic stages, and their expression levels are far above the myogenin during larval development. Moreover, these MRFs (myogenic regulatory factors) expression were directly or indirectly regulated by thyroid hormone or thiourea during metamorphosis. All the results suggest that miRNAs and MRFs might be involved in signaling pathway of TH or TU-mediated flounder metamorphosis.