Inbreeding depression in Campanula rapunculoides L. I. A comparison of inbreeding depression in plants derived from strong and weak self-incompatibility phenotypes

The evolution of selfing taxa from outcrossing ancestors has occurred repeatedly and is the subject of many theoretical models, yet few empirical studies have examined the immediate consequences of inbreeding in a population with variable expression of self-incompatibility. Because self-incompatibility breaks down with floral age in Campanula rapunculoides, we were able to mate outbred and selfed maternal plants in a crossing design which produced progeny with inbreeding coefficients of 0, 0.25, 0.50 and 0.75. Cumulative inbreeding depression in plants that were selfed for one generation was very high in families derived from strongly self-incompatible plants (average δ = 0.98), and somewhat lower in families derived from plants with weaker expression of self-incompatibility (average δ = 0.90). Relative to outbred progeny, inbred progeny produced fewer seeds, had lower rates of germination, less vegetative growth and fewer flowers per plant. Inbred progeny also took longer to germinate, and longer to produce a first leaf and to flower. Interestingly, inbred plants also produced 40% fewer seeds than outcrossed plants (t-test P < 0.001) even when mated to the same, unrelated pollen donor, suggesting that inbreeding can produce profound maternal effects. Most importantly, our results demonstrate that progeny derived from plants with stronger expression of self-incompatibility exhibited greater levels of inbreeding depression than progeny from plants with weaker expression of self-incompatibility. Moreover, the decline in fitness (cumulative, ln-transformed) over the four inbreeding levels was steeper for the progeny of the strongly self-incompatible lineages. These empirical results suggest that inbreeding depression and mating system phenotype have the potential to coevolve.     

The ARC1 E3 Ligase Gene Is Frequently Deleted in Self-Compatible Brassicaceae Species and Has a Conserved Role in Arabidopsis lyrata Self-Pollen Rejection

Self-pollen rejection is an important reproductive regulator in flowering plants, and several different intercellular signaling systems have evolved to elicit this response. In the Brassicaceae, the self-incompatibility system is mediated by the pollen S-locus Cys-Rich/S-locus Protein11 (SCR/SP11) ligand and the pistil S Receptor Kinase (SRK). While the SCR/SP11-SRK recognition system has been identified in several species across the Brassicaceae, less is known about the conservation of the SRK-activated cellular responses in the stigma, following self-pollen contact. The ARM Repeat Containing1 (ARC1) E3 ubiquitin ligase functions downstream of SRK for the self-incompatibility response in Brassica, but it has been suggested that ARC1 is not required in Arabidopsis species. Here, we surveyed the presence of ARC1 orthologs in several recently sequenced genomes from Brassicaceae species that had diversified ∼20 to 40 million years ago. Surprisingly, the ARC1 gene was deleted in several species that had lost the self-incompatibility trait, suggesting that ARC1 may lose functionality in the transition to self-mating. To test the requirement of ARC1 in a self-incompatible Arabidopsis species, transgenic ARC1 RNA interference Arabidopsis lyrata plants were generated, and they exhibited reduced self-incompatibility responses resulting in successful fertilization. Thus, this study demonstrates a conserved role for ARC1 in the self-pollen rejection response within the Brassicaceae.     

Self-pollen interference is absent in wild radish (Raphanus raphanistrum, Brassicaceae), a species with sporophytic self-incompatibility

Explaining the diversity of mating systems and floral forms in flowering plants is a long-standing concern of evolutionary biologists. One topic of interest is the conditions under which self-pollination can interfere with seed set for flowering plants with a self-incompatibility system. We investigated the effect of self-pollen interference for wild radish, Raphanus raphanistrum, which has sporophytic self-incompatibility. We performed pollinations and determined seed set for plants grown in the greenhouse, using pollen mixtures representing either self- with outcross-pollen or outcross-pollen alone. Stigmas were collected for a subset of pollinated flowers to determine the number of pollen grains applied. Average seed set for the self/cross (5.13 seeds/pollination) and cross treatments (5.09 seeds/pollination) did not differ significantly. Stigmatic pollen loads averaged around 700 grains, an amount close to observed natural pollen loads on R. raphanistrum. We concluded that for R. raphanistrum in natural populations, self-pollen is unlikely to interfere with outcross-pollen success. This study is the first to investigate effects of self-pollen interference on seed set for a homomorphic species with sporophytic self-incompatibility where rejection occurs at the stigmatic surface.     

Quantitatively determined self-incompatibility

Summary It has been claimed that Borage (Borago officInalis L.) has a multifactorial self-incompatibility system. Such systems may have a high level of ineffective pollination, and we show that this is the case in borage. The ranking of seed set from highest to lowest is as follows: bee-pollination; natural pollination in the absence of bees; artificial cross-pollination between unrelated plants; artificial cross-pollination between related plants; artificial self-pollination. In diallel crosses, significant parental effects were detected but no consistent patterns of seed set, which suggest a simple self-incompatibility system, were detected. The level of outcrossing with natural pollination was very variable but greater than 50%. Thus, there appears to be no straightforward self-incompatibility system in borage.     

配子体自交不亲和信号转导的研究进展

自然界中大多数自交不亲和（self-incompatibility, SI）显花植物表现为配子体SI。配子体SI植物虽然都具有其SI的功能而阻止自我受精,但它们采取的信号转导途径是不同的。目前关于配子体SI信号转导的途径主要有两种：一是茄科、玄参科、蔷薇科中以雌蕊S-RNase为基础的信号转导途径;另一是罂粟科中以花粉管胞质自由钙离子为第二信使的转导途径。文章就配子体SI信号转导的研究进展作一综述。     

Molecular characterization of the S locus in two self-incompatible Brassica napus lines.

In Brassica species, self-incompatibility has been mapped genetically to a single chromosomal location. In this region, there are two closely linked genes coding for the S locus glycoprotein (SLG) and S locus receptor kinase (SRK). They appear to comprise the pistil component of the self-incompatibility reaction. SLG and SRK are thought to recognize an unknown pollen component on the incompatible pollen, and the gene encoding this pollen component must also be linked to the SLG and SRK genes. To further our understanding of self-incompatibility, the chromosomal region carrying the SLG and SRK genes has been studied. The physical region between the SLG-910 and the SRK-910 genes in the Brassica napus W1 line was cloned, and a search for genes expressed in the anther revealed two additional S locus genes located downstream of the SLG-910 gene. Because these two genes are novel and are conserved at other S alleles, we designated them as SLL1 and SLL2 (for S locus-linked genes 1 and 2, respectively). The SLL1 gene is S locus specific, whereas the SLL2 gene is not only present at the S locus but is also present in other parts of the genomes in both self-incompatible and self-compatible Brassica ssp lines. Expression of the SLL1 gene is only detectable in anthers of self-incompatible plants and is developmentally regulated during anther development, whereas the SLL2 gene is expressed in anthers and stigmas in both self-incompatible and self-compatible plants, with the highest levels of expression occurring in the stigmas. Although SLL1 and SLL2 are linked to the S locus region, it is not clear whether these genes function in self-incompatibility or serve some other cellular roles in pollen-pistil functions.     

On the Evolution of Genetic Incompatibility Systems. VI. a Three-Locus Modifier Model for the Origin of Gametophytic Self-Incompatibility

Recent genetic analyses have demonstrated that self-incompatibility in flowering plants derives from the coordinated expression of a system of loci. To address the selective mechanisms through which a genetic system of this kind evolves, I present a three-locus model for the origin of gametophytic self-incompatibility. Conventional models assume that a single locus encodes all physiological effects associated with self-incompatibility and that the viability of offspring depends only on whether they were derived by selfing or outcrossing. My model explicitly represents the genetic determination of offspring viability by a locus subject to symmetrically overdominant selection. Initially, the level of expression of the proto-S locus is insufficient to induce self-incompatibility. Weak gametophytic self-incompatibility arises upon the introduction of a rare allele at an unlinked modifier locus which enhances the expression of the proto-S locus. While conventional models predict that the origin of self-incompatibility requires at least two- to threefold levels of inbreeding depression, I find that the comparatively low levels of inbreeding depression generated by a single overdominant locus can ensure the invasion of an enhancer of self-incompatibility under sufficiently high rates of receipt of self-pollen. Associations among components of the incompatibility system promote the origin of self-incompatibility. Enhancement of heterozygosity at the initially neutral proto-S locus improves offspring viability through associative overdominance. Further, the modifier that enhances the expression of self-incompatibility develops a direct association with heterozygosity at the overdominant viability locus. These results suggest that the evolutionary processes by which incompatibility systems originate may differ significantly from those associated with their breakdown. The genetic mechanism explored here may apply to the evolution of other systems that restrict reproduction, including maternal-fetal incompatibility in mammals.     

The molecular biology of self-incompatibility systems in flowering plants

Self-incompatibility is a common mechanism by which flowering plants can exert some control over the process of fertilization. Typically, the self-incompatibility response involves the recognition and rejection of self-incompatible pollen which leads to a block in self-fertilization and, as a consequence, promotes outcrossing. In recent years, considerable progress has been made in the molecular understanding of several self-incompatibility systems. Interestingly, a common mechanism for self-incompatibility is not employed by all flowering plants, but in fact quite diverse mechanisms have been recruited for the rejection of self-incompatible pollen. In this review, the recent advances in the self-incompatibility systems of the Solanaceae, Papaveraceae, and Brassicaceae will be described as well as some of the molecular work that is emerging for the Poaceae and the heteromorphic self-incompatibility systems.     

Molecular Determinants and Mechanisms of Gametophytic Self-Incompatibility in Fruit Trees of Rosaceae

Self-incompatibility is an important genetic mechanism that prevents inbreeding and promotes genetic polymorphism and heterosis in flowering plants. Many fruit species in the Rosaceae, including apple, pear, plum, apricot, sweet cherry, Japanese apricot, and almond, exhibit typical gametophytic self-incompatibility (GSI) controlled by an apparently single multi-allelic locus. This locus encodes at least two components from both the pollen and the pistil, and controls recognition of self- and non-self pollen. Recently, the GSI system has been investigated at the molecular and cellular levels in Rosaceae, and findings have provided some important insights as to how these two genes interact within pollen tubes that lead to specific inhibition of germination and/or growth of self-pollen tubes. In this review, molecular features of S-determinants of both pistil and pollen, identification of S-alleles, mechanisms of self-incompatibility break-down, and evolution of S-alleles are presented. Moreover, hypothetical signal transduction models in a self-incompatible system in Rosaceae are proposed based on recent findings that indicate that several signal factors are involved in GSI responses.     

Molecular mechanisms of self-incompatibility in flowering plants and fungi - different means to the same end

Hermaphrodite flowering plants and fungi face the same sexual dilemma - how to avoid self-fertilization. Both have evolved ingenious recognition systems that reduce or eliminate the possibility of selfing. These self-incompatibility (SI) systems offer unique opportunities to study recognition and signalling in non-animal cells and also represent model systems for studying the evolution of breeding systems at a molecular level. In this review, the authors discuss recent molecular data that predict an astonishing diversity in the cellular mechanisms of SI operating in flowering plants and fungi.     

Selection at work in self-incompatible Arabidopsis lyrata: mating patterns in a natural population

Identification and characterization of the self-incompatibility genes in Brassicaceae species now allow typing of self-incompatibility haplotypes in natural populations. In this study we sampled and mapped all 88 individuals in a small population of Arabidopsis lyrata from Iceland. The self-incompatibility haplotypes at the SRK gene were typed for all the plants and some of their progeny and used to investigate the realized mating patterns in the population. The observed frequencies of haplotypes were found to change considerably from the parent generation to the offspring generation around their deterministic equilibria as determined from the known dominance relations among haplotypes. We provide direct evidence that the incompatibility system discriminates against matings among adjacent individuals. Multiple paternity is very common, causing mate availability among progeny of a single mother to be much larger than expected for single paternity.     

Colchicine-induced changes in the self-incompatibility behaviour ofNicotiana

Colchicine treatment ofNicotiana seeds produced both genetic and nongenetic changes in the self-incompatibility reaction of the treated plants. Treatment with 0.25% colchicine produced a high number of tetraploid plants. Polyploidy brought about self-compatibility in all but one genotype ofS heterozygous constitution, which are normally self-incompatible in the diploid state. This genetic phenomenon, reported to be due to competitive interaction between two differentS alleles in the diploid pollen, was found to vary greatly in degree of expression not only between diferent genotypes but also between different plants of the same genotype. Treatment with a much lower strength of colchicine (0.1%) produced virtually no polyploids, but over 25% of the diploid seedlings showed selfcompatibility. This self-compatibility was very erratic, certain flowers in a continuous series of pollinations showing self-compatibility, while others showed self-incompatibility. Alterations of the self-incompatibility reaction, other than that due to competitive interaction, are ascribed here to changes in certain non-genetic, particulate or non-particulate cytoplasmic constituents. The inconsistency between flower pollinations is due to irregular inter-cellular distribution of the particulate elements. The non-particulate element(s) affected by the treatment is believed to be a constituent of the induction or repression system involved in the regulation ofS gene activity in the shoot or root.     

Rapid copy number expansion and recent recruitment of domains in S-receptor kinase-like genes contribute to the origin of self-incompatibility

More than half of flowering plants have a sophisticated mechanism for self-pollen rejection, named self-incompatibility. In the Brassicaceae family, the recognition specificity of a self-incompatibility system is achieved by the interaction of the stigmatic S-receptor kinase and its ligand S-locus cysteine-rich protein, which are encoded by two tightly linked polymorphic genes. During the last two decades, many studies have explored their functions, although their origin and evolutionary history have still not been elucidated clearly. In the present study, an extensive survey in nine whole-genome sequenced plants, including one moss, one fern and seven flowering plants, was conducted to clarify these issues. The data obtained showed that S_locus_glycop domain-related genes, which are land plant specific, have an ancient origin that can be traced back to early land plants and also have a significantly expansion in flowering plants. In the four predominant domain architectures (Types I to IV) of these proteins, Type III genes had absolute predominance and appeared to be raw materials for diversification of the S_locus_glycop domain-related genes by frequent domain re-organizations. S-receptor kinase-like sequences (Type IV) might have originated from Type III genes by domain gains, and S-locus glycoprotein-like sequences (Type I) might have arisen by partial duplication of its linked S-receptor kinase genes. Although similar topologies were detected in S-receptor kinase and S-locus cysteine-rich protein trees, their physical linkage were found only in Brassicaceae, suggesting that the strong linkage disequilibrium and their co-evolution may be a key factor for the origin and maintenance of the S-receptor kinase-based self-incompatibility system in Brassicaceae.     

A molecular description of mutations affecting the pollen component of the Nicotiana alata S locus.

Mutations affecting the self-incompatibility response of Nicotiana alata were generated by irradiation. Mutants in the M1 generation were selected on the basis of pollen tube growth through an otherwise incompatible pistil. Twelve of the 18 M1 plants obtained from the mutagenesis screen were self-compatible. Eleven self-compatible plants had mutations affecting only the pollen function of the S locus (pollen-part mutants). The remaining self-compatible plant had a mutation affecting only the style function of the S locus (style-part mutant). Cytological examination of the pollen-part mutant plants revealed that 8 had an extra chromosome (2n + 1) and 3 did not. The pollen-part mutation in 7 M1 plants was followed in a series of crosses. DNA blot analysis using probes for S-RNase genes (encoding the style function of the S locus) indicated that the pollen-part mutation was associated with an extra S allele in 4 M1 plants. In 3 of these plants, the extra S allele was located on the additional chromosome. There was no evidence of an extra S allele in the 3 remaining M1 plants. The breakdown of self-incompatibility in plants with an extra S allele is discussed with reference to current models of the molecular basis of self-incompatibility.     

Self/nonself perception and recognition mechanisms in plants: a comparison of self-incompatibility and innate immunity

Analyses of emerging concepts indicate that parallels exist between self-incompatibility and pathogen recognition. In the case of surveillance of 'nonself', plant immune responses are triggered either by pattern recognition receptors (PRRs) that detect conserved pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) or by resistance (R) proteins recognizing isolate-specific pathogen effectors. PAMP detection is an important component of innate immunity in plants and serves as an early warning system for the presence of potential pathogens and activation of plant defense mechanisms. In the Brassicaceae, the recognition of 'self' and self-incompatibility are components of a receptor-ligand based mechanism that utilizes an S receptor kinase (SRK) to perceive and reject 'self'-pollen. SRK is an S-domain receptor-like kinase (RLK), which in turn is part of the RLK family, some members of which represent PRRs involved in the detection of PAMPs. S-domain RLKs also occur in species that do not exhibit self-incompatibility and are up-regulated in response to wounding, PAMPs and pathogen recognition. Although evolution may have driven expansion of certain RLK families to serve roles in particular physiological processes, this may not exclude these receptor types from functioning in different programs. Recent findings on self/nonself recognition are reviewed and conceptual and mechanistic links between microbial recognition and self-incompatibility are discussed.     

S-RNase-mediated gametophytic self-incompatibility is ancestral in eudicots

The evolutionary relationship between self-incompatibility systems in different families of flowering plants has long been a topic of interest. Physiological differences in the mode of gene action and the enormous sequence differences between genes with different modes of action suggest that many instances of self-incompatibility have arisen independently. In contrast, previous analyses of the S-RNase associated with gametophytic self-incompatibility in the eudicot families (Solanaceae, Scrophulariaceae, and Rosaceae) have suggested that sequences within families form well-supported and distinct lineages. In this study we demonstrate that in fact, S-RNase-mediated gametophytic self-incompatibility evolved only once in the eudicots.     

Screening and characterization of apple Rho-like GTPase (MdROPs) genes related to S-RNase mediated self-incompatibility

ROP/Rac GTPase is a conserved class of proteins which play diverse signalling roles in plants. They regulate many fundamental cellular processes such as F-actin dynamics, cell polarity and polar growth. Using apple genomic database analyses, nine ROP family members were cloned for the first time in a fruit tree (apple). Phylogenetic analyses indicated that the nine MdROPs were distributed into two groups, as previously described in the literature for model plants. Expression analyses show all MdROPs were highly expressed in pollen, in particular MdROP1, 3, 4 and 8. Yeast two hybrid and bimolecular fluorescence complementation analyses indicated MdROP8 interacts with S-RNase, a pistil determinate factor in gametophyte self-incompatibility. The pollen tube microtubule is shown to depolymerize in response to S-RNase treatment, during which the expression of MdROP8 rapidly decreased. These results indicate MdROP8 is related to S-RNase mediated self-incompatibility, and gives some useful evidence in modeling the relationship between cytoskeleton depolymerization and pollen tube growth inhibition during the apple SI reaction.     

Is Eucalyptus Cryptically Self-incompatible?

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The probability that seeds will be fertilized from self- versus cross-pollen depends strongly on whether plants have self-incompatibility systems, and how these systems influence the fate of pollen tubes. METHODS: In this study of breeding systems in Eucalyptus urophylla and Eucalyptus grandis, epifluorescence microscopy was used to study pollen tube growth in styles following self- and cross-pollinations. KEY RESULTS: Pollen tubes from self-pollen took significantly longer than those from cross-pollen to grow to the base of the style in both E. urophylla (120 h vs. 96 h) and E. grandis (96 h vs. 72 h). In addition, both species exhibited reduced seed yields following self-pollination compared with cross-pollination. CONCLUSIONS: The present observations suggest that, in addition to a late-acting self-incompatibility barrier, cryptic self-incompatibility could be a mechanism responsible for the preferential out-crossing system in these two eucalypt species.     

Loss of callose in the stigma papillae does not affect the Brassica self-incompatibility phenotype

As part of the Brassicaceae self-incompatibility response, callose is deposited in the stigma papillar cells. To determine if callose plays an important role in the rejection of incompatible pollen by the stigma, transgenic Brassica napus. L. plants were produced which express the tobacco β-1,3-glucanase cDNA (the enzyme which degrades callose) in the stigma papillae. Using aniline blue fluorescence, little or no callose was detected in the papillar cells of transgenic stigmas. However, the self-incompatibility system appeared to be unaffected based on the lack of pollen tube growth and the subsequent lack of seed set. The transgene had no effect on compatible pollinations. Thus, while callose deposition is associated with the B. napus self-incompatibility response, it is not required for the rejection of incompatible pollen. Received: 14 March 1997 / Accepted: 15 April 1997     

Signaling in pollen-pistil interactions.

A complex set of cell interactions is required to achieve fertilization. The pollen grain must be recognized by the pistil, take up water, and grow a pollen tube directionally through the style in order to deliver the sperm to the ovule. In many families of flowering plants, self-fertilization can be prevented by recognition mechanisms that allow self-pollen rejection by the pistil. The self-incompatibility response is under the genetic control of a single multi-allelic locus, the (Self-incompatibility) locus. There are two major classes of self-incompatibility systems. Gametophytic self-incompatibility has been well characterized in the Solanaceae and in the Papaveraceae, while sporophytic self-incompatibility has been well characterized in the Brassicaceae. In this review article, we present recent advances in understanding the signals mediating pollen recognition and pollen tube growth, in both compatible and incompatible interactions.