Mechanisms of ascorbic acid recycling in human erythrocytes.

Vitamin C, or ascorbic acid, is efficiently recycled from its oxidized forms by human erythrocytes. In this work the dependence of this recycling on reduced glutathione (GSH) was evaluated with regard to activation of the pentose cycle and to changes in pyridine nucleotide concentrations. The two-electron-oxidized form of ascorbic acid, dehydroascorbic acid (DHA) was rapidly taken up by erythrocytes and reduced to ascorbate, which reached intracellular concentrations as high as 2 mM. In the absence of D-glucose, DHA caused dose-dependent decreases in erythrocyte GSH, NADPH, and NADH concentrations. In the presence of 5 mM D-glucose, GSH and NADH concentrations were maintained, but those of NADPH decreased. Reduction of extracellular ferricyanide by erythrocytes, which reflects intracellular ascorbate recycling, was also enhanced by D-glucose, and ferricyanide activated the pentose cycle. Diethylmaleate at concentrations up to 1 mM was found to specifically deplete erythrocyte GSH by 75-90% without causing oxidant stress in the cells. Such GSH-depleted erythrocytes showed parallel decreases in their ability to take up and reduce DHA to ascorbate, and to reduce extracellular ferricyanide. These results show that DHA reduction involves GSH-dependent activation of D-glucose metabolism in the pentose cycle, but that in the absence of D-glucose DHA reduction can also utilize NADH.     

Role of ascorbic acid in dopamine beta-hydroxylation. The endogenous enzyme cofactor and putative electron donor for cofactor regeneration

The role(s) of ascorbic acid in dopamine beta-hydroxylation was studied in primary cultures of bovine adrenomedullary chromaffin cells and in isolated bovine adrenomedullary chromaffin vesicles. Dopamine beta-hydroxylase activity was assessed by measuring the rate of conversion of tyramine to octopamine. The ascorbic acid content of chromaffin cells declined with time in culture and the dopamine beta-hydroxylase activity of ascorbate-depleted cells was low. Ascorbate additions to ascorbate-depleted cells increased both the intracellular ascorbate concentrations and the rates of dopamine beta-hydroxylation. Ascorbate uptake into the cells was rapid; however, the onset of enhanced octopamine synthesis by added ascorbate was delayed by several hours and closely followed the time course for accumulation of the newly taken up ascorbate into the chromaffin vesicle. The amount of octopamine synthesized by the chromaffin cells exceeded the intracellular ascorbate content and ascorbate levels were maintained during dopamine beta-hydroxylation in the absence of external ascorbate. This suggests an efficient recycling of ascorbate. In contrast to intact cells, ascorbic acid was depleted during octopamine synthesis in isolated chromaffin vesicles. The molar ratio of octopamine formed to ascorbate depleted was close to unity. Thus, the recycling of intravesicular ascorbate depends on an extravesicular factor(s). The depletion of intravesicular ascorbate during dopamine beta-hydroxylation was prevented by the addition of nonpermeant extravesicular electron donors such as ascorbate or glucoascorbate. This suggests that intravesicular ascorbate is maintained in the reduced state by electron transport across the vesicle membrane. These results are compatible with the hypothesis that both intra- and extravesicular ascorbate participate in the regulation of dopamine beta-hydroxylase. Intravesicular ascorbate is the cofactor for the enzyme. Cytosolic ascorbate is most likely the electron donor for the vesicle-membrane electron transport system which maintains the intravesicular cofactor concentration.     

Reduction of dehydroascorbic acid by homocysteine

To determine the reductive process of extracellular dehydroascorbic acid (DHA), molecules (homocysteine, homocysteine thiolactone, methionine, cysteine, and homoserine) were tested to identify those with the potential to reduce DHA to ascorbic acid (AA). Homocysteine (Hcy) was the most potent of the molecules tested. The efficacy of Hcy was compared with that of other molecules able to reduce DHA (reduced glutathione (GSH) and cysteine (Cy)). Although all three molecules were able to reduce DHA, GSH and Cy were not to reduce DHA to AA at concentrations lower than 100 micromol/l, and only less than 5% DHA was reduced to AA at concentrations of 200-300 micromol/l. In contrast, Hcy reduced DHA to AA stoichiometrically at concentrations as low as 10 micromol/l. In Jurkat and U937 cells, the increasing concentrations of extracellular Hcy suppressed intracellular dehydroascorbic acid uptake, indicating that extracellular reduction of DHA by Hcy leads to decreasing extracellular DHA available for its intracellular uptake. Simultaneous oxidation and reduction of Hcy and DHA were accelerated extracellularly in the presence of quercetin, an inhibitor of DHA uptake, suggesting that extracellular ascorbic acid concentration increased via blocking DHA uptake by quercetin and reducing extracellular DHA by Hcy. The effect of homocysteine on DHA reduction and uptake was confirmed with human umbilical vein endothelial cells. The oxidation of Hcy also prevented the decrease in DNA synthesis in human umbilical vein endothelial cells, which would occur following exposure to Hcy.     

Nitroxide metabolism in the human keratinocyte cell line HaCaT

Metabolism of different nitroxides with piperidine structure used as spin labels in electron spin resonance (ESR) studies in vitro and in vivo was investigated in human keratinocytes of the cell line HaCaT by GC and GC-MS technique combined with S-band ESR. Besides the well known reduction of the nitroxyl radicals to the ESR silent hydroxylamines as primary products our results indicate the formation of the corresponding secondary amines. These reductions are inhibited by the thiol blocking agent N-ethylmaleimide and by the strong inhibitors of the thioredoxin reductase (TR) 2-chloro-2,4-nitrobenzene and 2,6-dichloroindophenol. The competitive inhibitor TR inhibitor azelaic acid and the cytochrome P-450 inhibitor metyrapone lack any effects. The rates of reduction to the hydroxylamines and secondary amines were dependent on the lipid solubility of the nitroxides. Therefore, it can be assumed that the nitroxides must enter the cells for their bioreduction. The mostly discussed intracellular nitroxide reducing substances ascorbic acid and glutathione were unable to form the secondary amines. In conclusion, our results suggest that the secondary amine represents one of the major metabolites of nitroxides besides the hydroxylamine inside keratinocytes formed via the flavoenzyme thioredoxin reductase most probably. Further metabolic conversions were detected with 4-oxo-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl and the benzoate of 4-hydroxy-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl as substrates.     

Ascorbic acid decreases oxidant stress in endothelial cells caused by the nitroxide tempol

Stable nitroxide radicals have been considered as therapeutic antioxidants because they can scavenge more toxic radicals in biologic systems. However, as radicals they also have the potential to increase oxidant stress in cells and tissues. We studied the extent to which this occurs in cultured EA.hy926 endothelial cells exposed to the nitroxide Tempol (4-hydroxy-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-N-oxyl). Tempol was rapidly reduced by the cells, as manifest by an increase in the ability of the cells to reduce extracellular ferricyanide and by disappearance of the Tempol EPR signal. Cells loaded with ascorbic acid, which directly reacts with Tempol, showed increased rates of Tempol-dependent ferricyanide reduction, and a more rapid loss of the Tempol EPR signal than cells not containing ascorbate. In this process, intracellular ascorbate was oxidized, and was depleted at lower Tempol concentrations than was GSH, another important intracellular low molecular weight antioxidant. Further evidence that Tempol concentrations of 100-1000 μM induced an oxidant stress was that it caused an increase in the oxidation of dihydrofluorescein in cells and inhibited ascorbate transport at concentrations as low as 50-100 μM. The presence of intracellular ascorbate both prevented dihydrofluorescein oxidation and spared GSH from oxidation by Tempol. Such sparing was not observed when GSH was depleted by other mechanisms, indicating that it was likely due to protection against oxidant stress. These results show that whereas Tempol may scavenge other more toxic radicals, care must be taken to ensure that it does not itself induce an oxidant stress, especially with regard to depletion of ascorbic acid.     

Nitric oxide-induced oxidant stress in endothelial cells: amelioration by ascorbic acid

Nitric oxide has multiple beneficial effects in the blood vessel wall. However, high concentrations of nitric oxide in the presence of hydroperoxides have been shown to damage cultured cells. In this work, the effect of relatively high concentrations of nitric oxide alone on the function and antioxidant status of a human endothelial cell line (EA.hy926) was tested. Nitric oxide generated from 0.1 to 0.5mM spermine NONOate generated reactive species in the cells detected by triazole formation from diaminofluorescein and by oxidation of dihydrofluorescein. Intracellular ascorbic acid decreased this oxidant stress. Spermine NONOate also decreased intracellular ascorbate concentrations, although reduced glutathione was not affected unless cells had also been caused to reduce dehydroascorbic acid to ascorbate. Nitric oxide predictably inhibited both endothelial nitric oxide synthase and glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase, and ascorbate partially prevented inhibition of the latter enzyme. These results suggest that relatively high concentrations of nitric oxide can cause oxidant stress in endothelial cells that is ameliorated by ascorbic acid.     

Cellular metabolism of water-soluble nitroxides: Effect on rate of reduction of cell/nitroxide ratio,oxygen concentrations and permeability of nitroxides

In order to interpret more accurately studies that have used nitroxides and to improve the efficacy of the use of nitroxides in both basic studies of cells and as contrast agents for in vivo NMR, we have initiated a systematic study of the distribution and metabolism of nitroxides in biological systems. Overall, the results provide a reasonably coherent picture of some aspects of the interactions between nitroxides and cells. Reduction of the nitroxides appears to be an intracellular process, so that one of the principal variables that affects the rate of reduction is the ability of a nitroxide to enter cells. The entrance of nitroxides into cells shows considerable variability and ranges from essentially no penetration (e.g., 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-N-oxyl-4-trimethylamine) through rates that are comparable to rates of reduction (e.g., 2,2,5,5-tetramethylpyrrolidine-N-oxyl-3-carboxylic acid), to rates that are so fast that there is complete equilibrium between intracellular and extracellular compartments (e.g., Tempone). The presence of a charged group on the nitroxide appears to be the important variable that affects their ability to enter cells. Once a nitroxides enters the cell, the structure of the nitroxide, e.g., piperidine vs. pyrrolidine ring, is major factor that affects the rate of reduction. The rates of reduction increase with increasing concentrations of nitroxides. This indicates that the principal mechanism(s) of reduction do not saturate in the concentration range we studied. We observed no abrupt changes in the rates of reduction over the entire concentration range of cells and nitroxides that we studied, which suggests that the mechanism(s) of nitroxide reduction did not change. The presence of oxygen decreased the observed rate of reduction of many of the nitroxides and this effect was independent of the concentration of nitroxide.     

Prooxidative effects of TEMPO on human erythrocytes

The prooxidative effects of 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO) were observed in human erythrocytes. Incubation of red blood cells with the membrane-permeable TEMPO leads to a decrease in the concentration of intracellular reduced glutathione, accompanied by the reduction of TEMPO. Extracellular ferricyanide inhibited the loss of glutathione and reduction of TEMPO. TEMPO induced glutathione release from the cells and oxidation of hemoglobin to methemoglobin; ferricyanide prevented these effects. These results indicate that TEMPO may act as an oxidant to erythrocytes, whilst extracellular ferricyanide protects against its effects.     

Metabolism of nitroxide spin labels in subcellular fractions of rat liver. II. Reduction in the cytosol

As part of an ongoing study of the role of subcellular fractions on the metabolism of nitroxides, we studied the metabolism of a set of five nitroxides in cytosol derived from rat hepatocytes. The nitroxides were chosen to provide information on the effects of the type of charge and the ring on which the nitroxyl group is located. The rates of reduction were fastest for a six-membered positively charged nitroxide ('CAT-1') and slowest for an anionic five-membered ring nitroxide ('PCA'). Changing levels of glutathione, sulphydryl groups in general, NADPH or NADH had little or no effect on the rates of reduction, while the addition of ascorbate oxidase essentially abolished reduction of the nitroxides. The products of reduction by the cytosol were the corresponding hydroxylamines. The overall rates of reduction of neutral or anionic nitroxides were much slower than those observed with intact cells. We conclude that the primary source of metabolism of nitroxides by cytosol is reduction by ascorbate and that under most conditions reduction of nitroxides in the cytosol is not a major factor in the metabolism of nitroxides by cells.     

Reduction kinetics and electrochemistry of tetracarboxylate nitroxides

Abstract

Tetracarboxylate pyrroline nitroxides undergo very fast reduction with ascorbate/glutathione (GSH), with second-order rate constants that are five orders of magnitude greater than those for gem-diethyl pyrroline nitroxides. For tetracarboxylate nitroxides, the electrochemical reduction potentials, measured by square wave voltammetry, are much less negative (by about 0.8 V), compared with the corresponding gem-diethyl nitroxides, while the oxidation potentials become more positive (by about 0.7 V). Electrochemical potentials correlate well via simple regressions with field/inductive parameters such as Swain/Lupton F-parameters (and/or Charton σ_I-parameters). Rates of reduction with ascorbate/GSH similarly correlate well for four pyrroline nitroxides, except for the slowest reducing gem-diethyl nitroxide. These results suggest that the electron withdrawing groups adjacent to the nitroxide moiety have a strong accelerating impact on the reduction rates, and thus they are not suitable for the design of hydrophilic nitroxides for in vivo applications.     

Quercetin prevents glutathione depletion induced by dehydroascorbic acid in rabbit red blood cells

Exposure of rabbit red blood cells to dehydroascorbic acid (DHA) caused a significant decline in glutathione content which was largely prevented by quercetin, whereas it was insensitive to various antioxidants, iron chelators or scavengers of reactive oxygen species. This response was not mediated by chemical reduction of either extracellular DHA or intracellular glutathione disulfide. In addition, the flavonoid did not affect the uptake of DHA or its reduction to ascorbic acid. Rather, quercetin appeared to specifically stimulate downstream events promoting GSH formation.     

Quercetin prevents glutathione depletion induced by dehydroascorbic acid in rabbit red blood cells

Exposure of rabbit red blood cells to dehydroascorbic acid (DHA) caused a significant decline in glutathione content which was largely prevented by quercetin, whereas it was insensitive to various antioxidants, iron chelators or scavengers of reactive oxygen species. This response was not mediated by chemical reduction of either extracellular DHA or intracellular glutathione disulfide. In addition, the flavonoid did not affect the uptake of DHA or its reduction to ascorbic acid. Rather, quercetin appeared to specifically stimulate downstream events promoting GSH formation.     

Recycling of vitamin C from its oxidized forms by human endothelial cells

Endothelial cells encounter oxidant stress due to their location in the vascular wall, and because they generate reactive nitrogen species. Because ascorbic acid is likely involved in the antioxidant defenses of these cells, we studied the mechanisms by which cultures of EA.hy926 endothelial cells recycle the vitamin from its oxidized forms. Cell lysates reduced the ascorbate free radical (AFR) by both NADH- and NADPH-dependent mechanisms. Most NADH-dependent AFR reduction occurred in the particulate fraction of the cells. NADPH-dependent reduction resembled that due to NADH in having a high affinity for the AFR, but was mediated largely by thioredoxin reductase. Reduction of dehydroascorbic acid (DHA) required GSH and was both direct and enzyme dependent. The latter was saturable, half-maximal at 100 microM DHA, and comparable to rates of AFR reduction. Loading cells to ascorbate concentrations of 0.3-1.6 mM generated intracellular DHA concentrations of 20-30 microM, indicative of oxidant stress in culture. Whereas high-affinity AFR reduction is the initial and likely the preferred mechanism of ascorbate recycling, any DHA that accumulates during oxidant stress will be reduced by GSH-dependent mechanisms.     

Selenium spares ascorbate and alpha-tocopherol in cultured liver cell lines under oxidant stress.

The selenoenzyme thioredoxin reductase (TR) can recycle ascorbic acid, which in turn can recycle alpha-tocopherol. Therefore, we evaluated the role of selenium in ascorbic acid recycling and in protection against oxidant-induced loss of alpha-tocopherol in cultured liver cells. Treatment of HepG2 or H4IIE cultured liver cells for 48 h with sodium selenite (0-116 nmol/l) tripled the activity of the selenoenzyme TR, measured as aurothioglucose-sensitive dehydroascorbic acid (DHA) reduction. However, selenium did not increase the ability of H4IIE cells to take up and reduce 2 mM DHA, despite a 25% increase in ascorbate-dependent ferricyanide reduction (which reflects cellular ascorbate recycling). Nonetheless, selenium supplements both spared ascorbate in overnight cultures of H4IIE cells, and prevented loss of cellular alpha-tocopherol in response to an oxidant stress induced by either ferricyanide or diazobenzene sulfonate. Whereas TR contributes little to ascorbate recycling in H4IIE cells, selenium spares ascorbate in culture and alpha-tocopherol in response to an oxidant stress.     

Vitamin C homeostasis in skeletal muscle cells

In skeletal muscle, vitamin C not only enhances carnitine biosynthesis but also protects cells against ROS generation induced by physical exercise. The ability to take up both ascorbic and dehydroascorbic acid from the extracellular environment, together with the ability to recycle the intracellular vitamin, maintains high cellular stores of ascorbate. In this study, we examined vitamin C transport and recycling, by using the mouse C2C12 and rat L6C5 muscle cell lines, which exhibit different sensitivity to oxidative stress and GSH metabolism. We found that: (1) both cell lines express SVCT2, whereas SVCT1 is expressed at very low levels only in proliferating L6C5 cells; furthermore L6C5 myoblasts are more efficient in ascorbic acid transport than C2C12 myoblasts; (2) C2C12 cells are more efficient in dehydroascorbic acid transport and ascorbyl free radical/dehydroascorbic acid reduction; (3) differentiation is paralleled by decreased ascorbic acid and dehydroascorbic acid transport and reduction and increased ascorbyl free radical reduction; (4) differentiated cells are more responsive to oxidative stress induced by glutathione depletion; indeed, myotubes showed increased SVCT2 expression and thioredoxin reductase-mediated dehydroascorbic acid reduction. From our data, SVCT2 and NADPH-thioredoxin-dependent DHA reduction appears to belong to an inducible system activated in response to oxidative stress.     

Interaction of photosynthetic pigments with various organic solvents. Magnetic circular dichroism approach and application to chlorosomes

Reduction of extracellular ferricyanide by intact cells reflects the activity of an as yet unidentified trans-plasma membrane oxidoreductase. In human erythrocytes, this activity was found to be limited by the ability of the cells to recycle intracellular ascorbic acid, its primary trans-membrane electron donor. Ascorbate-dependent ferricyanide reduction by erythrocytes was partially inhibited by reaction of one or more cell-surface sulfhydryls with p-chloromercuribenzene sulfonic acid, an effect that persisted in resealed ghosts prepared from such treated cells. However, treatment of intact cells with the sulfhydryl reagent had no effect on NADH-dependent ferricyanide or ferricytochrome c reductase activities of open ghosts prepared from treated cells. When cytosol-free ghosts were resealed to contain trypsin or pronase, ascorbate-dependent reduction of extravesicular ferricyanide was doubled, whereas NADH-dependent ferricyanide and ferricytochrome c reduction were decreased by proteolytic digestion. The trans-membrane ascorbate-dependent activity was also found to be inhibited by reaction of sulfhydryls on its cytoplasmic face. These results show that the trans-membrane ferricyanide oxidoreductase is limited by the ability of erythrocytes to recycle intracellular ascorbate, that it does not involve the endofacial NADH-dependent cytochrome b(5) reductase system, and that it is a trans-membrane protein that contains sensitive sulfhydryl groups on both membrane faces.     

Mechanisms related to reduction of radical in mouse lung using an L-band ESR spectrometer

Reduction of radicals in mouse lung was characterized in whole animals using an L-band ESR technique and nitroxide radicals as probes. An aqueous solution of nitroxide radical was immediately instilled intratracheally to mouse after euthanasia. Nitroxide radicals without charged groups were reduced significantly in the lung, while radicals with charged groups were only slightly reduced. Permeation rates across lung plasma membrane were not rate limiting of the stage of reduction of the noncharged nitroxides. Michaelis parameters, apparent Km and apparent Vmax, were obtained from the Lineweaver-Burk plots of the reduction. Among noncharged nitroxides with constant apparent Vmax, radicals with a larger n-octanol/water partition coefficient showed a lower apparent Km, thereby suggesting that the concentration of these nitroxides in the membrane contributes to apparent Km. The reduction rate of noncharged nitroxide, hydroxy-TEMPO, was influenced by noncharged SH reagents instilled together with the nitroxide; dithiothreitol stimulated the reduction, while the oxidized reagent inhibited it. The Lineweaver-Burk plots of the nitroxide reduction in the presence of various concentrations of dithiothreitol suggest the possibility that the reduction system for hydroxy-TEMPO is based on a kind of ping pong bi-reactant mechanism, and that the reduction system utilizes SH as an electron donor. Endogenous glutathione contributed partially to the reduction.     

Human erythrocyte recycling of ascorbic acid: relative contributions from the ascorbate free radical and dehydroascorbic acid

Recycling of ascorbic acid from its oxidized forms helps to maintain the vitamin in human erythrocytes. To determine the relative contributions of recycling from the ascorbate radical and dehydroascorbic acid, we studied erythrocytes exposed to a trans-membrane oxidant stress from ferricyanide. Ferricyanide was used both to induce oxidant stress across the cell membrane and to quantify ascorbate recycling. Erythrocytes reduced ferricyanide with generation of intracellular ascorbate radical, the concentrations of which saturated with increasing intracellular ascorbate and which were sustained over time in cells incubated with glucose. Ferricyanide also generated dehydroascorbic acid that accumulated in the cells and incubation medium to concentrations much higher than those of the radical, especially in the absence of glucose. Ferricyanide-stimulated ascorbate recycling from dehydroascorbic acid depended on intracellular GSH but was well maintained at the expense of intracellular ascorbate when GSH was severely depleted by diethylmaleate. This likely reflects continued radical reduction, which is not dependent on GSH. Erythrocyte hemolysates showed both NAD- and NADPH-dependent ascorbate radical reduction. The latter was partially due to thioredoxin reductase. GSH-dependent dehydroascorbate reduction in hemolysates, which was both direct and enzyme-dependent, was greater than that of the radical reductase activity but of lower apparent affinity. Together, these results suggest an efficient two-tiered system in which high affinity reduction of the ascorbate radical is sufficient to remove low concentrations of the radical that might be encountered by cells not under oxidant stress, with back-up by a high capacity system for reducing dehydroascorbate under conditions of more severe oxidant stress.     

Mammalian thioltransferase (glutaredoxin) and protein disulfide isomerase have dehydroascorbate reductase activity

Homogeneous native and recombinant porcine liver thioltransferase (glutaredoxin), bovine thymus and human placenta thioltransferase (glutaredoxin) were examined for dehydroascorbate reductase activity (EC 1.8.5.1) involving the direct catalytic reduction of dehydroascorbic acid (DHA) by glutathione. Each enzyme had substantial activity with apparent Km and Vmax for dehydroascorbate between 0.2 and 2.2 mM and 6-27 nmol min-1, respectively, and for gluathione between 1.6 and 8.7 mM and 11-30 nmol min-1, respectively. In the presence of purified bovine liver thioredoxin reductase, homogeneous bovine liver thioredoxin failed to reduce DHA to ascorbic acid as measured by NADPH oxidation. Highly purified bovine liver protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) reacted directly with DHA and GSH to catalyze the reduction of DHA to ascorbic acid. The apparent Km for DHA was 1.0 mM and the Vmax was 8 nmol min-1, and for GSH were 3.9 mM and 14 nmol min-1, respectively. These results suggest that thioltransferase and PDI contribute to the regeneration of oxidized ascorbic acid in mammalian cells, and based on their cellular location, thioltransferase is proposed to be the major cytoplasmic activity, whereas interaction of DHA with microsomal membrane PDI may catalyze regeneration of ascorbic acid and initiate oxidation of intralumenal protein thiols to disulfides.     

Structural dependence of nitroxide spin labels and nitroxide spin adducts on their reducibility by ascorbate ion

Summary

The reducibility of a series of nitroxides (aminoxyls) by ascorbate was tested by measuring the nitroxide decay rates with a stopped-flow electron paramagnetic resonance technique in aqueous phosphate buffer solution. The dependence of reactivity on the structures and pH of the medium was found for both cyclic nitroxides and nitroxide adducts of phenyl N-tert butyl nitrone (PBN). In cyclic nitroxides, the ring size is a dominant factor in determining reaction rates but substituents have additional effects on the rate depending on their electronegativity. For alkyl and hydroxyalkyl adducts of PBN, at fixed ascorbate concentration, half-lives increase with lengthening of the substituent, suggesting that a long chain in the substituent sterically protects the nitroxide group and thus prevents its reduction by ascorbate.