Primary structure of the calcium ion-transporting adenosine triphosphatase from rabbit skeletal sarcoplasmic reticulum. Some peptic, thermolytic, tryptic and staphylococcal-proteinase peptides.

The soluble peptides from the peptic digest of the reduced S-carboxymethylated 3-carboxypropionylated adenosine triphosphatase protein have been isolated and most of their structures have been determined. About 397 residues of the protein were represented in these peptides. The reduced S-carboxymethylated protein was digested with thermolysin, and peptides containing arginine or carboxymethylcysteine were isolated and characterized. Some peptides isolated from tryptic and staphylococcal-proteinase digests of the protein are described. The information contained within the structures of these peptides has been used to reconstruct long stretches of the sequence of the ATPase protein that constitute most of the protein structure external to the lipid bilayer (Allen, Trinnaman and Green (1980) Biochem. J. 187, 591-616). The details of some of the chromatographic steps used in the isolation of the peptides and the properties of the peptides are contained in Supplementary Publication SUP 50104 (45 pages), which has been deposited with the British Library Lending Division, Boston Spa, Wetherby, West Yorkshire LS23 7BQ, U.K., from whom copies can be obtained on the terms indicated in Biochem. J. (1978) 169, 5.     

The primary structure of the calcium-transporting adenosine triphosphatase of rabbit skeletal sarcoplasmic reticulum. Soluble tryptic peptides from the succinylated carboxymethylated protein.

The isolation and the determination of the amino-acid sequences of the soluble tryptic peptides, derived by cleavage at arginine residues, of the succinylated (3-carboxypropionylated) S-carboxymethylated adenosine triphosphatase protein of rabbit skeletal sarcoplasmic reticulum are described. Treatment of the protein with succinic anhydride gave a derivative that was readily digested with trypsin, yielding two distinct sets of peptides. One set comprises large, relatively hydrophobic, peptides that are highly aggregated (or insoluble) in aqueous solution and that have been identified, by several criteria, with the portion of the protein embedded in the lipid bilayer in the sarcoplasmic reticulum. The second set, which is described here, comprises peptides that have properties typical of those derived from soluble globular proteins and that constitute that part of the protein external to the lipid bilayer. The sequences of these soluble tryptic peptides contain 586 unique residues. Details of the isolation of the peptides and the determination of the sequences are contained in Supplementary Publication SUP 50102 (88 pages) which has been deposited with the British Library Lending Division, Boston Spa, Wetherby, West Yorkshire LS23 7BQ, U.K., from whom copies can be obtained on the terms indicated in Biochem. J. (1978) 169, 5.     

Primary structures of cysteine-containing peptides from the calcium ion-transporting adenosine triphosphatase of rabbit sarcoplasmic reticulum.

A preliminary investigation of the primary structure of the Ca(2+-transporting ATPase (adenosine triphosphatase) protein of rabbit skeletal-muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum is reported. The preparation of derivatives of delipidated protein in a form suitable for sequence analysis is described. Tryptic peptides containing S-carboxymethylcysteine residues were isolated from the reduced carboxymethylated protein, and their sequences were partially determined. The results are consistent with mol.wt. about 105000 for the polypeptide, and the absence of extended repeated lengths of sequence. The distribution of tryptophan and cysteine residues between large, aggregated peptides and soluble tryptic peptides shows that these residues are concentrated in different regions of the primary structure. This observation agrees with other evidence that these residues are, on the whole, widely separated in the native protein. The details of the procedures used to isolate the peptides, and the evidence for the determination of their sequences, are given Supplementary Publication SUP 50085 (30 pages), which has been deposited at the British Library Lending Division, Boston Spa, Wetherby, West Yorkshire LS23 7BQ, U.K., from whom copies can be obtained on the terms indicated in Biochem.J. (1978) 169, 5.     

The primary structure of actin from rabbit skeletal muscle. Completion and analysis of the amino acid sequence.

Actin is the principal constituent of the thin filaments of muscle, and in order to provide information basic to understanding the molecular basis of actin function we have studied its amino acid sequence. The isolation, compositions, and sequences of cyanogen bromide peptides, ranging in size from 3 to 44 residues, have previously been reported (ELZINGA, M. (1971) Biochemistry 10, 224-229, and other papers in the present series). The peptides have been aligned by isolation and characterization of tryptic peptides that contain methionine. The isolation of one of the CNBr peptides (CB-14) was complicated by the presence of a Met-Thr bond that was only partially split under standard conditions for cyanogen bromide cleavage in formic acid. In this paper conditions are described for increasing the cleavage at this bond. CB-14 is a tetrapeptide, Thr-Gln-Ile-Hse, and this sequence completes the characterization of the actin cyanogen bromide peptides. Finally, the position of CB-14 in the actin sequence as residues 120 to 123 was established by isolation of a chymotryptic overlap peptide. The complete sequence of the 374 residues of actin is presented.     

Primary structure of otter (Lutra lutra L.) myoglobin. II. Pepsin peptides of trypsin hydrolysate. Reconstruction of the polypeptide chain of the otter myoglobin globin component

13 peptic peptides have been isolated from the insoluble (at pH 5.0) fraction of the tryptic hydrolysate of main chromatographic component of otter myoglobin and their amino acid composition and N-terminal amino acid sequences have been determined. The isolated peptides contain in total 40 amino acid residues. The results obtained, along with those on tryptic peptides and the comparison with homologous portions of myoglobins of the known primary structure, allowed reconstructing the complete amino acid sequence of otter myoglobin.     

Amino acid sequence of the ribosomal protein L21 of Escherichia coli.

The primary structure of protein L21 from the 50S subunit of Escherichia coli ribosomes has been completely determined by sequencing the peptides obtained by digestion of L21 with trypsin before and after modification of the arginine residues with 1,2-cyclohexanedione, Staphylococcus aureus protease, thermolysin, and pepsin. Automated Edman degradation using a liquid-phase sequenator was carried out on the intact protein as well as on a fragment arising from cleavage with cyanogen bromide. Protein L21 consists of a single polypeptide chain of 103 amino acids of molecular weight 11 565. An estimation of the secondary structure of protein L21 and a comparison with other E. coli ribosomal protein sequences are presented.     

Primary structure of the tail sheath protein of bacteriophage T4 and its gene

Complete sequence determination of gene 18 encoding the tail sheath protein was carried out mainly by the Maxam-Gilbert method. Approximately 40 peptides contained in a tryptic digest and a lysyl endopeptidase digest of gp 18 were isolated by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. All the peptides were identified along the nucleotide sequence of gene 18 based on the amino acid compositions. These peptides cover 88% of the total primary structure. Furthermore, the amino acid sequences of 9 of the 40 peptides were determined by a gas-phase protein sequencer; one of them turned to be the N-terminal one. The C-terminal peptide in the tryptic digest was isolated from the unadsorbed fraction of affinity chromatography on immobilized anhydrotrypsin and the amino acid sequence was also determined. Thus, the complete primary structure of gp 18 was determined; it has 658 amino acid residues and a molecular weight of 71,160.This article was presented during the proceedings of the International Conference on Macromolecular Structure and Function, held at the National Defence Medical College, Tokorozawa, Japan, December 1985.     

ATP synthase from bovine mitochondria. The characterization and sequence analysis of two membrane-associated sub-units and of the corresponding cDNAs

ATP synthase from bovine mitochondria is a complex of 13 different polypeptides, whereas the Escherichia coli enzyme is simpler and contains eight subunits only. Two of the bovine subunits, b and d, which had not been characterized, have been isolated from the purified enzyme. Subunits with sizes corresponding to bovine subunits b and d are evident in preparations of the enzyme from mitochondria of other species. Partial protein sequences have been determined by direct methods. On the basis of some of this information, two oligonucleotide mixtures, 17 and 18 bases in length, have been synthesized and used as hybridization probes in the isolation of clones of the cognate cDNAs. The sequences of the two proteins have been deduced from their DNA sequences. Subunit b is 214 amino acid residues in length and has a free N terminus. Subunit d is 160 amino acid residues long. Its N-terminal alanine is blocked by an N-acetyl group, as demonstrated by fast atom bombardment mass spectrometry of N-terminal peptides. The sequence near the N terminus of the b subunit is made predominantly of hydrophobic residues, whereas the remainder of the protein is mainly hydrophilic. This N-terminal hydrophobic region may be folded into an alpha-helical structure spanning the lipid bilayer. In its distribution of hydrophobic residues, this protein resembles the b subunits of ATP synthase complexes in bacteria and chloroplasts. The b subunit in E. coli forms an important structural link between the extramembrane sector of the enzyme F1, and the intrinsic membrane domain, FO. It is proposed that the bovine mitochondrial subunit b serves a similar function. If this is so, the mitochondrial enzyme, as the chloroplast ATP synthase, contains equivalent subunits to all eight of those that constitute the E. coli enzyme. Subunit d has no extensive hydrophobic sequences, and is not apparently related to any subunit described in the simpler ATP synthases in bacteria and chloroplasts.     

The sequence of two peptides isolated from the Ca2+-transporting ATPase of rabbit sarcoplasmic reticulum after cleavage at tryptophan.

Cleavage of reduced, carboxymethylated, delipidated CA2+-transporting ATPase protein from rabbit sarcoplasmic reticulum with dimethyl sulphoxide/HBr yielded two long peptides (38 and 73 residues), distinct from the known major sequences of the ATPase. The longer peptide contained at least two cysteine residues, which were disulphide-linked in the native protein. It was therefore derived from the B-fragment of the ATPase in which the disulphides had previously been located. It probably formed a loop on the luminal side of the membrane, spanning two membrane-buried tryptophan residues. The N-terminal sequence of this peptide, (Trp)-Phe-Met-Tyr-Ala, forms the basis for an oligodeoxynucleotide probe, the use of which to identify cDNA corresponding to the ATPase is described elsewhere [MacLennan, Brandl, Korczak & Green (1985) Nature (London) 316, 696-700].     

The primary structure of E. coli RNA polymerase, Nucleotide sequence of the rpoC gene and amino acid sequence of the beta''-subunit.

The primary structure of the E. coli rpoC gene (5321 base pairs) coding the beta'-subunit of RNA polymerase as well as its adjacent segment have been determined. The structure analysis of the peptides obtained by cleavage of the protein with cyanogen bromide and trypsin has confirmed the amino acid sequence of the beta'-subunit deduced from the nucleotide sequence analysis. The beta'-subunit of E. coli RNA polymerase contains 1407 amino acid residues. Its translation is initiated by codon GUG and terminated by codon TAA. It has been detected that the sequence following the terminating codon is strikingly homologous to known sequences of rho-independent terminators.     

Studying the S-nitrosylation of model peptides and eNOS protein by mass spectrometry.

Oxidative addition of a nitric oxide (NO) molecule to the thiol group of cysteine residues is a physiologically important post-translational modification that has been implicated in several metabolic and pathophysiological events. Our previous studies have indicated that S-nitrosylation can result in the disruption of the endothelial NO synthase (eNOS) dimer. It has been suggested that for S-nitrosylation to occur, the cysteine residue must be flanked by hydrophilic residues either in the primary structure or in the spatial proximity through appropriate conformation. However, this hypothesis has not been confirmed. Thus, the objective of this study was to determine if the nature of the amino acid residues that flank the cysteine in the primary structure has a significant effect on the rate and/or specificity of S-nitrosylation. To accomplish this, we utilized several model peptides based on the eNOS protein sequence. Some of these peptides contained point mutations to allow for different combinations of amino acid properties (acidic, basic, and hydrophobic) around the cysteine residue. To ensure that the results obtained were not dependent on the nitrosylation procedure, several common S-nitrosylation techniques were used and S-nitrosylation followed by mass spectrometric detection. Our data indicated that all peptides independent of the amino acids surrounding the cysteine residue underwent rapid S-nitrosylation. Thus, there does not appear to be a profound effect of the primary sequence of adjacent amino acid residues on the rate of cysteine S-nitrosylation at least at the peptide levels. Finally, our studies using recombinant human eNOS confirm that Cys98 undergoes S-nitrosylation. Thus, our data validate the importance of Cys98 in regulating eNOS dimerization and activity, and the utility of mass spectroscopy to identify cysteine residues susceptible to S-nitrosoylation.     

Sequence motifs important for peptide binding to the human MHC class I molecule, HLA-A2.

Previous studies have indicated that most HLA-A2-binding peptides are 9 amino acid (aa) residues long, with a Leu at position 2 (P2), and a Val or Leu at P9. We compared the binding properties of different peptides by measuring the rate of dissociation of beta 2-microglobulin from peptide-specific HLA-A2 complexes. The simplest peptide that we identified that could form HLA-A2 complexes had the sequence (in single letter aa code) GLFGGGGGV, indicating that three nonglycine aa are sufficient for binding to HLA-A2. To determine whether most nonapeptides that contained Leu at P2 and Val or Leu at P9 could bind to HLA-A2, we tested the binding of nonapeptides selected from published HIV and melanoma protein sequences, and found that six of seven tested formed stable HLA-A2 complexes. We identified an optimal antigenic undecapeptide from the cytomegalovirus gB protein that could form stable HLA-A2 complexes that contained apparent anchor residues at P2 and P11 (sequence FIAGN-SAYEYV), indicating that the spacing between anchor residues can be somewhat variable. Finally, we tested the importance of every aa in the influenza A matrix peptide 58-66 (sequence GILGFVFTL) for binding to HLA-A2, by using Ala-substituted and Lys-substituted peptides. We found that multiple positions were important for stable binding, including P2, P3, P5-P7, and P9. We conclude that the P2 and P9 anchor residues are of prime importance for peptide binding to HLA-A2. However, other peptide side chains (especially at P3) contribute to the stability of the interaction. In certain cases, the optimal length for peptide binding can be longer than 9 residues.     

Primary structure of 20S,22R-cholesterol-hydroxylating cytochrome P-450 from bovine adrenal cortex mitochondria. IV. Structure of peptides of thermolytic and limited tryptic hydrolysis of the fragment F1; peptides of cyanogen bromide hydrolysis of cytochrome P-450. Complete amino acid sequence

A thermolytic hydrolysis of maleinated fragment F1 has been performed, resulted in isolation of 44 peptides; their complete amino acid sequence has been determined. Non-overlapping thermolytic peptides of fragment F1 involve 178 amino acid residues, which comprises about 71% of its amino acid sequence. Also, the cleavage and structural investigation of some tryptophan-containing peptides obtained from the limited trypsinolysis of fragment F1 were carried out; reconstitution of the polypeptide chain of the fragment is completed. The cyanogen bromide cleavage of carboxymethylated cytochrome P-450 was achieved and 17 peptides, comprising almost the whole polypeptide chain of the protein molecule (91%), was isolated. To investigate structure of the cyanogen bromide peptides, we hydrolysed them at tryptophan residues with trypsin, chymotrypsin, proteinase from Staphylococcus aureus, and BNPS-skatole. The data obtained and those published earlier led to the complete primary structure of the cholesterol-hydroxylating cytochrome P-450. The proteins polypeptide chain consists of 481 amino acid residues and has the precise molecular mass 56 407.7.     

Neurotoxins from the venoms of the sea snakes Hydrophis ornatus and Hydrophis lapemoides.

The main neurotoxic components, toxins Hydrophis ornatus a and Hydrophis lapemoides a, were isolated from the venoms of the sea snakes Hydrophis ornatus and Hydrophis lapemoides respectively. The amino acid sequence of toxin Hydrophis ornatus a was deduced to be identical with that of toxin Astrotia stokesii a [Maeda & Tamiya (1978) Biochem. J. 175, 507-517] on the basis of identity of the tryptic peptide 'map' and the amino acid composition of each peptide. The amino acid sequence of toxin Hydrophis lapemoides a was determined mainly on the basis of identity of the amino acid compositions, mobilities on paper electrophoresis and migration positions on paper chromatography of the tryptic peptides with those of other sea-snake toxins whose sequences are known. Both toxins Hydrophis ornatus a and Hydrophis lapemoides a consisted of 60 amino acid residues and there were six amino acid replacements between them. The taxonomy of sea snakes in the Hydrophis ornatus complex has long been confused, and the above snakes were originally assigned to taxa that proved to be inconsistent with the relationships indicated by the neurotoxin amino acid sequences obtained. A subsequent re-examination of the specimens revealed an error in the original identifications and demonstrated the value of the protein amino acid sequences in systematic and phylogenetic studies. The isolation procedure and results of amino acid analysis of the tryptic peptides have been deposited as Supplementary Publication SUP 50121 (8 pages) with the British Library Lending Division, Boston Spa, Wetherby, West Yorkshire LS23 7BQ, U.K., from whom copies may be obtained as indicated in Biochem. J. (1983) 209, 5.     

A protein dissection study demonstrates that two specific hydrophobic clusters play a key role in stabilizing the core structure of the molten globule state of human alpha-lactalbumin

The molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin (alpha LA) has served as a paradigm for understanding the role of these partially folded states in protein folding. We previously showed that a peptide construct consisting of the A and B helices (residues 1-38) cross-linked to the D- and C-terminal 3(10) helices (residues 101-120) of alpha LA is capable of folding to a stable molten globule-like state. Here, we report the study of three peptide constructs that are designed to investigate the contribution two short hydrophobic sequences located near the C-terminus of alpha LA make to the structure and stability of the alpha LA molten globule state. These regions of the protein have been shown to form stable non-native structures in isolation. The three peptide constructs contain residues 1-38 cross-linked to three separate C-terminal peptides via the native 28-111 disulfide bond. The C-terminal peptides consist of residues 101-114, 106-120, and 106-114. The results of CD, fluorescence, ANS binding, and urea denaturation experiments indicate that constructs that lack either of the hydrophobic sequences (residues 101-105 and 115-120) are significantly less structured. These results highlight the importance of long-range, mutually stabilizing interactions within the molten globule state of the protein. Proteins 2001;42:237-242.     

Complete amino acid sequence of a cytochrome P-450 isolated from beta-naphthoflavone-induced rabbit liver microsomes. Comparison with phenobarbital-induced and constitutive isozymes and identification of invariant residues

The complete covalent structure of a cytochrome P-450, form 4, isolated from liver microsomes of beta-naphthoflavone-induced rabbits was determined. The S-carboxyamidomethylated protein was cleaved with cyanogen bromide, endoproteinase Lys-C, and trypsin before and after succinylation. Selected peptides from CNBr digests of alkylated rabbit cytochrome P-450 forms 3a and 3c were also isolated and sequenced. Form 4 exhibited microheterogeneity due to the presence of several truncated forms. The existence of multiple NH2-terminal residues for form 4 was confirmed by the isolation and sequence analysis of the corresponding tryptic peptides. The predominant form contained 514 residues, corresponding to Mr 58,030. A peptide having Gly-232 and Gln-246 replaced by Ser and Asn residues, respectively, was also found in the isozyme preparation investigated here. The amino acid sequences of form 4 and selected peptide sequences from forms 3a and 3c were compared with the primary structures of forms 2 and 3b (previously determined in this laboratory). This comparison identified some 90 invariant residues. A cysteinyl residue at position 456, earlier reported as the heme-binding cysteine 436 (Heineman, F. S., and Ozols, J. (1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 14988-14999), was also present in forms 4, 3a, and 3c. Other single invariant residues identified were form 4/forms 2,3b, Trp-132/121, and His 270/252. The tyrosyl residues at positions 71/62 and 365/348 were also invariant. The latter is present in the "conserved segment" of the protein, residues 363/346 to 375/359, and may be involved in the substrate binding of cytochrome P-450. Also a lysyl residue, formerly identified by other laboratories to be involved in the electron transfer between the reductase and cytochrome P-450 form 2, was invariant in all five species. This lysyl residue corresponds to Lys-402 in form 4 or Lys-384 in the other forms.     

Analysis of 15 adenovirus hexon proteins reveals the location and structure of seven hypervariable regions containing serotype-specific residues.

The first full-length hexon protein DNA and deduced amino acid sequences of a subgenus D adenovirus (AV) were determined from candidate AV48 (85-0844). Comprehensive comparison of this sequence with hexon protein sequences from human subgenera A, B, C, D, F, bovine AV3, and mouse AV1 revealed seven discrete hypervariable regions (HVRs) among the 250 variable residues in loops 1 and 2. These regions differed in length between serotypes, from 2 to 38 residues, and contained > 00% of hexon serotype-specific residues among human serotypes. Alignment with the published crystal structure of AV2 established the location and structure of the type-specific regions. Five HVRs were shown to be part of linear loops on the exposed surfaces of the protein, analogous to the serotype-specific loops or "puffs" in picornavirus capsid proteins. The HVRs were supported by a common framework of conserved residues, of which 68 to 75% were hydrophobic. Unique sequences were limited to the seven HVRs, so that one or more of these regions contain the type-specific neutralization epitopes. A neutralizing AV48 hexon-specific antiserum recognized linear peptides that corresponded to six HVRs by enzyme immunoassay. Affinity-purification removal of all peptide-reactive antibodies did not significantly decrease the neutralization titer. Eluted peptide-reactive antibodies did not neutralize. Human antisera that neutralized AV48 did not recognize linear peptides. Purified trimeric native hexon inhibited neutralization, but monomeric heat-denatured hexon did not. We conclude that the AV48 neutralization epitope(s) is complex and conformational.     

Microanalysis of the amino-acid sequence of monomeric beta-lactoglobulin I from donkey (Equus asinus) milk. The primary structure and its homology with a superfamily of hydrophobic molecule transporters

The complete primary structure of donkey beta-lactoglobulin I was determined by pulsed-liquid phase microsequencing of tryptic peptides. The protein has been isolated in monomeric form and it corresponds to monomeric beta-lactoglobulin of type I. With the inclusion of donkey beta-lactoglobulin I there are 13% common residues amongst the members of the beta-lactoglobulin family. Donkey beta-lactoglobulin I is homologous to the retinol-binding protein, bilin-binding protein and five other proteins belonging to the new superfamily of hydrophobic molecule transporters. A rapid method for peptide isolation and the strategy for microsequencing of this protein have been described.     

Human liver fatty acid binding protein cDNA and amino acid sequence. Functional and evolutionary implications

Human liver fatty acid binding protein (L-FABP) cDNA clones were identified in a liver cDNA library. The two longest clones were completely sequenced. The nucleotide sequence predicts a protein of 127 amino acid residues. Identity of the clones was confirmed by limited amino acid sequence analysis of purified human L-FABP peptides and Edman degradation of radiolabeled in vitro translated FABP. Statistical analysis of the amino acid and mRNA sequences of human L-FABP, rat L-FABP, rat intestinal (I-) FABP, and mouse 422 protein indicates that the human and rat L-FABPs are highly homologous and that L-FABP and I-FABP diverged a long time ago (approximately 650-690 million years ago), although they are more closely related to each other than either of them is to 422 protein. Secondary structure predictions from the primary sequence of human and rat L-FABP reveal a region (residues 12-30) that might be the putative fatty acid binding domain of the two L-FABPs. Knowledge of the primary amino acid sequence of L-FABP and possible functional domains will be pivotal in further defining and understanding the mechanism of ligand binding and transfer by this protein.     

The occurrence of two types of collagen proalpha-chain in the abalone Haliotis discus muscle.

Acid-soluble collagens were prepared from connective tissues in the abalone Haliotis discus foot and adductor muscles with limited proteolysis using pepsin. Collagen preparation solubilized with 1% pepsin contained two types of alpha-chains which were different in their N-terminal amino acid sequences. Accordingly, two types of full-length cDNAs coding for collagen proalpha-chains were isolated from the foot muscle of the same animal and these proteins were named Hdcols (Haliotis discus collagens) 1alpha and 2alpha. The two N-terminal amino acid sequences of the abalone pepsin-solubilized collagen preparation corresponded to either of the two sequences deduced from the cDNA clones. In addition, several tryptic peptides prepared from the pepsin-solubilized collagen and fractionated by HPLC showed N-terminal amino acid sequences identical to those deduced from the two cDNA clones. Hdcols 1alpha and 2alpha consisted of 1378 and 1439 amino acids, respectively, showing the primary structure typical to those of fibril-forming collagens. The N-terminal propeptides of the two collagen proalpha-chains contained cysteine-rich globular domains. It is of note that Hdcol 1alpha completely lacked a short Gly-X-Y triplet repeat sequence in its propeptide. An unusual structure such as this has never before been reported for any fibril-forming collagen. The main triple-helical domains for both chains consisted of 1014 amino acids, where a supposed glycine residue in the triplet at the 598th position from the N-terminus was replaced by alanine in Hdcol 1alpha and by serine in Hdcol 2alpha. Both proalpha-chains of abalone collagens contained six cysteine residues in the carboxyl-terminal propeptide, lacking two cysteine residues usually found in vertebrate collagens. Northern blot analysis demonstrated that the mRNA levels of Hdcols 1alpha and 2alpha in various tissues including muscles were similar to each other.