Evaluation of zinc salt based fixatives for preserving antigenic determinants for immunohistochemical demonstration of murine immune system cell markers

Conventional aldehyde based fixatives produce good morphological preservation. However, owing to their cross-linking mechanism of action, epitope loss may occur during fixation compromising the tissue for subsequent immunohistochemical (IHC) analysis. IHC is an important tool for characterizing antigen, cytokine and cytomorphological markers. The increasing use of mouse models for study of pathogenesis has highlighted the need to investigate alternative fixatives. In the study reported here, tissue samples from RIII mice with immune mediated lesions, Mycobacterium bovis infected mice, and uninfected control mice were fixed in either zinc salt fixative or buffered formalin, then tested for IHC using a panel of antibodies (CD3, CD4, CD8, CD45, CD54, F4/80, Interferon-gamma and MIP2). Zinc salt fixation preserved processing-sensitive murine cell markers (CD4, CD8 and CD54) and improved the intensity of immunolabeling for CD45, F4/80 and CD3. Buffered formalin failed to preserve any of the processing-sensitive murine epitopes for demonstration by subsequent IHC.     

A comparison of fixation methods on lung morphology in a murine model of emphysema

Emphysema is characterized by enlargement of the alveoli, which is the most important parameter to assess the presence and severity of this disease. Alveolar enlargement is primarily defined on morphological criteria; therefore, characterization of this disease with morphological parameters is a prerequisite to study the pathogenesis. For this purpose, different methods of lung fixation were evaluated in a murine model of LPS-induced lung emphysema. Five different methods of lung fixation were evaluated: intratracheal instillation of fixatives, in situ fixation, fixed-volume fixation, vascular whole body perfusion, and vacuum inflation. In addition, the effects of three different fixatives (10% formalin, Carnoy's, and agarose/10% formalin solution) and two embedding methods (paraffin and plastic) were investigated on the murine lung morphology. Mice received intranasal administration of LPS to induce alveolar wall destruction. Quantification of air space enlargement was determined by mean linear intercept analysis, and the histological sections were analyzed for the most optimal fixation method. Additionally, routine immunohistological staining was performed on lung tissue of PBS-treated mice. Intratracheal instillation of formalin or agarose/formalin solution, in situ fixation, and fixed-volume fixation provided a normal lung architecture, in contrast to the lungs fixed via whole body perfusion and vacuum inflation. Formalin-fixed lungs resulted in the most optimal lung morphology for lung emphysema analysis when embedded in paraffin, while for Carnoy's fixed lungs, plastic embedding was preferred. The histological findings, the mean linear intercept measurement, and the immunohistochemistry data demonstrated that fixation by intratracheal instillation of 10% formalin or in situ fixation with 10% formalin are the two most optimal methods to fix lungs for alveolar enlargement analysis to study lung emphysema.     

Effect on Tissue Volume of Various Methods of Fixation, Dehydration, and Embedding

A new indirect method is described for following volume changes of homogeneous pieces of tissue during fixation, dehydration and embedding, and area changes during sectioning, staining and mounting. Pieces of rabbit kidney cortex were compared after fixation in Destin's, Orth's, Petrunkevitch's cupric-paranitrophenol, Bouin's, SUSA, Zenker-formol, 10% formalin in distilled water, formalin in saline, Burke's pyridine formalin, CaCOy neutralized formalin, MgCO₃-neutralized formalin, Bensley's vacuum distilled neutral formalin in distilled water, and Bensley's neutral formalin in saline; during dehydration in ethyl alcohol, dioxan, and tertiary butyl alcohol and clearing in xylol and chloroform; and after infiltration and embedding with parowax, with paraffin-nitrocellulose double embedding technic, with hot nitrocellulose, and with cold nitrocellulose. The H-ion concentration of these fixatives was followed during tissue fixation.

Altho all fixatives showed specific merences, SUSA and Bouin's gave the best general results and neutral formalin mixtures, especially pyridine-formalin, the poorest. Isotonic saline was found superior to distilled water as a formalin diluent, reducing tissue swelling during formalin fixation. Reagents producing marked decreases in tissue volume render such tissues less susceptible to shrinkage during subsequent procedures. Shrinkage of tissue during dehydration and infiltration with hot parffin may exceed that produced by fixation alone. Excessive heat causes tissue distortion and shrinkage. Inijltration with hot paran causes considerable shrinkage, with hot nitrocellulose Iess, and with cold nitrocellulose the least sbrinkage.     

The effect of different fixatives and length of fixation time on subsequent AgNOR staining for frozen and paraffin-embedded tissue sections

Summary The AgNOR technique has been used extensively in studies investigating the possibility that the numbers and appearances of the intranuclear structures stained are markers of malignancy. The method has the advantage of being applicable to many different types of histological material, including paraffin-embedded tissue. However, it has been suggested that the visualization of AgNORs is dependent on the type and time of fixation employed. This study set out to measure this effect with the following commonly-used fixatives: acetone, absolute ethanol, methanol, Carnoy's fluid, Bouin's fluid, 4% glutaraldehyde, 10% neutral buffered formalin and 10% formol-saline. Both frozen sections and blocks of fresh tonsil were fixed for varying times, the blocks of tissue then being processed routinely. With the frozen sections AgNORs were easier to discern than in sections of paraffin-embedded tissue, and more intranucleolar AgNORs were visible when alcoholic fixatives were used than with aldehyde fixation. The effects of different fixatives on AgNOR appearance in paraffin sections is, however, more complex. Despite the variation caused by different fixatives, AgNORs could be demonstrated adequately with all the fixatives studied. It is concluded that fixation is not a limitation to the study of AgNORs provided that the time and type of fixative is controlled.     

Fixation, processing, and immunochemical reagent effects on preservation of T-lymphocyte surface membrane antigens in paraffin-embedded tissue

Fixatives, fixation additives, paraffin processing reagents, and immunochemical reagents were investigated for effects on preservation of T-lymphocyte surface membrane antigens CD3, CD4, and CD8 in human tonsil. Individual reagent effects were assessed in frozen sections by use of monoclonal antibodies and this information was used to optimize T-cell immunostaining in paraffin sections. Harmful factors were fixation delay, fixation at acid pH, fixation and processing at temperatures above 4 degrees C, hot paraffin wax, proteolytic enzymes, methanolic hydrogen peroxide, Triton X-100, and prolonged iodine treatment. Optimal T-cell demonstration in paraffin sections followed tissue fixation in periodate-lysine-paraformaldehyde dichromate at 4 degrees C, pH 7.5; processing through isopropanol, then xylene or chloroform, at 4 degrees C; and embedding in low melting point wax at 45-50 degrees C. Graded antigen stability occurred: CD3 most stable, CD8 least, and CD4 intermediate. CD4 and CD8 antigen preservation in paraffin sections required critical optimal tissue handling. CD3 was more stable and was also demonstrated in tissue fixed in commercial formalin, glutaraldehyde, and Bouin's fluid when fixation and processing conditions were optimized for pH and temperature. Of the fixation additives studied, polyethylene glycol and several potassium and magnesium salts enhanced immunostaining, whereas calcium chloride and lidocaine were deleterious.     

Comparative usefulness of tissue fixatives for in situ viral nucleic acid hybridization

Traditionally tissues for in situ hybridization of viral nucleic acid have been small pieces obtained from laboratory rodents, and fixatives that are designed for electron microscopy, such as periodate-lysine-paraformaldehyde (PLP) can handle them adequately. However, these fixatives have limited penetrating ability and may produce no appreciable hardening, so alternative fixation methods were evaluated. The intention was to determine whether fixatives adequate for bulky tissues such as whole or halved pig and cow brains would also be compatible with in situ hybridization. Various fixatives were evaluated using a system of intracranial inoculation of BALB/c mice with pseudorabies virus (PRV) followed by in situ hybridization of brain tissue sections with a 35S-labeled PRV DNA probe. Loss of tissue sections was a major problem, particularly with PLP and formalin, but positive results were obtained with five fixatives tested. Cellular morphology was especially good with PLP and with a modification of Carnoy's fluid, MOCA fixative. An incidental but important observation was that formalin is compatible with in situ hybridization. Retroactive studies of viral diseases using routinely processed blocks of tissue (formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded) are therefore conceivable.     

Application of alternative fixatives to formalin in diagnostic pathology

Fixation is a critical step in the preparation of tissues for histopathology. The objective of this study was to investigate the effects of different fixatives vs formalin on proteins and DNA, and to evaluate alternative fixation for morphological diagnosis and nucleic acid preservation for molecular methods. Forty tissues were fixed for 24 h with six different fixatives: the gold standard fixative formalin, the historical fixatives Bouin and Hollande, and the alternative fixatives Greenfix, UPM and CyMol. Tissues were stained (Haematoxylin-Eosin, Periodic Acid Schiff, Trichromic, Alcian-blue, High Iron Diamine), and their antigenicity was determined by immunohistochemistry (performed with PAN-CK, CD31, Ki-67, S100, CD68, AML antibodies). DNA extraction, KRAS sequencing, FISH for CEP-17, and flow cytometry analysis of nuclear DNA content were applied. For cell morphology the alternative fixatives (Greenfix, UPM, CyMol) were equivalent to formalin. As expected, Hollande proved the best fixative for morphology. The morphology obtained with Bouin was comparable to that with formalin. Hollande was the best fixative for histochemistry. Bouin proved equivalent to formalin. The alternative fixatives were equivalent to formalin, although with greater variability in haematoxylin-eosin staining. It proved possible to obtain immunohistochemical staining largely equivalent to that following formalin-fixation with the following fixatives: Greenfix, Hollande, UPM and CyMol. The tissues fixed in Bouin did not provide results comparable to those obtained with formalin. The DNA extracted from samples fixed with alternative fixatives was found to be suitable for molecular analysis.     

Enhancement of suboptimal CD8 cytotoxic T cell effector function in vivo using antigen-specific CD80 defective T cells

T cell upregulation of B7 molecules CD80 and CD86 limits T cell expansion in immunodeficient hosts; however, the relative roles of CD80 separate from CD86 on CD4 versus CD8 T cells in a normal immune system are not clear. To address this question, we used the parent-into-F1 (P→F1) murine model of graft-versus-host disease and transferred optimal and suboptimal doses of CD80 and/or CD86 knockout (KO) T cells into normal F1 hosts. Enhanced elimination of host B cells by KO T cells was observed only at suboptimal donor cell doses and was greatest for CD80 KO→F1 mice. Wild-type donor cells exhibited peak CD80 upregulation at day 10; CD80 KO donor cells exhibited greater peak (day 10) donor T cell proliferation and CD8 T cell effector CTL numbers versus wild-type→F1 mice. Fas or programmed cell death-1 upregulation was normal as was homeostatic contraction of CD80 KO donor cells from days 12-14. Mixing studies demonstrated that maximal host cell elimination was seen when both CD4 and CD8 T cells were CD80 deficient. These results indicate an important role for CD80 upregulation on Ag-activated CD4 and CD8 T cells in limiting expansion of CD8 CTL effectors as part of a normal immune response. Our results support further studies of therapeutic targeting of CD80 in conditions characterized by suboptimal CD8 effector responses.     

Expression of macrophage-selective markers in human and rodent adipocytes

CD14, CD68 and/or mouse F4/80 or human epidermal growth factor module-containing mucin-like receptor 1 (EMR1) are widely used as macrophage-specific markers. Since macrophages infiltrate several tissues during inflammatory processes, CD14, CD68 and EMR1-F4/80 have been employed to discriminate between tissue-containing macrophages, like adipose tissue (AT), and other cells. Using real-time PCR experiments, we show that isolated adipocytes from humans and mice AT express high levels of CD14 and CD68 mRNA, whereas EMR1-F4/80 is mainly present in the macrophage-containing stroma-vascular fraction. Furthermore, fibroblasts-like cells (adipoblasts), preadipocytes and adipocytes from the murine cell lines, 3T3-F442A and BFC-1, express CD14 and CD68 mRNA and protein as determined by fluorescence-activated cell sorter, but not F4/80 which, as expected, is strongly expressed in the macrophage cell line RAW264.7. These results reinforce the view that EMR1-F4/80 is the best macrophage marker to date and show that CD14 and CD68 are not macrophage-specific proteins.     

The search for an optimal DNA, RNA, and protein detection by in situ hybridization, immunohistochemistry, and solution-based methods

Clinical trials and correlative laboratory research are increasingly reliant upon archived paraffin-embedded samples. Therefore, the proper processing of biological samples is an important step to sample preservation and for downstream analyses like the detection of a wide variety of targets including micro RNA, DNA and proteins. This paper analyzed the question whether routine fixation of cells and tissues in 10% buffered formalin is optimal for in situ and solution phase analyses by comparing this fixative to a variety of cross linking and alcohol (denaturing) fixatives. We examined the ability of nine commonly used fixative regimens to preserve cell morphology and DNA/RNA/protein quality for these applications. Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) and bovine papillomavirus (BPV)-infected tissues and cells were used as our model systems. Our evaluation showed that the optimal fixative in cell preparations for molecular hybridization techniques was "gentle" fixative with a cross-linker such as paraformaldehyde or a short incubation in 10% buffered formalin. The optimal fixatives for tissue were either paraformaldehyde or low concentration of formalin (5% of formalin). Methanol was the best of the non cross-linking fixatives for in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry. For PCR-based detection of DNA or RNA, some denaturing fixatives like acetone and methanol as well as "gentle" cross-linking fixatives like paraformaldehyde out-performed other fixatives. Long term fixation was not proposed for DNA/RNA-based assays. The typical long-term fixation of cells and tissues in 10% buffered formalin is not optimal for combined analyses by in situ hybridization, immunohistochemistry, or--if one does not have unfixed tissues--solution phase PCR. Rather, we recommend short term less intense cross linking fixation if one wishes to use the same cells/tissue for in situ hybridization, immunohistochemistry, and solution phase PCR.     

A Detailed Analysis of the Effects of Various Fixatives on Animal Tissue with Particular Reference to Muscle Tissue

Nine different fixatives (Carnoy's, Susa, Baker's formalin, 5% formalin, 10% formalin, 10% formol saline, Bouin, Zenker, and 2.5% glutaraldehyde) were compared by two methods. Gelatin-albumin gels were used to study volum changes after fixation and after various stages of subsequent processing. The appearance and hardness of the gels were also noted. The fixatives either shrunk or swelled the gels, but dehydration and clearing shrunk the gels in all cases. Sampkes of muscle tissue from one location in beef longissimus dorsi muscle were also placed in the different fixatives and processed. Various features were noted for each fixative, including the ease with which the paraffin wax blocks were cut and the staining ability of the sections in Mallory's triple stain. The diameters of the muscle fibers were measured from transverse sections of these samples and compared with the mean diameter of muscle fibera in a frozen unfixed section of muscle tissue. It was found that the fixatives had the same shrinkage effects on both the gels and the muscle samples. Analysis of variance tests showed that the various fuatives caused different degrees of shrinkage. Statistical details are given for the amounts of shrinkage caused by each fixative. Both the general histological picture and the amount of shrinkage were considered when deciding the bcst fixative. Carnoy was found to be the best of the fixatives investigated.     

Effects of Prolonged Formalin Fixation on Diagnostic Immunohistochemistry in Domestic Animals

Immunohistochemistry (IHC) is routinely used in diagnostic pathology to detect infectious agents, to immunophenotype neoplastic cells, and to prognosticate neoplastic diseases. Formalin fixation is considered a limiting factor for IHC because formalin can cross-link antigens and mask epitopes. Prolonged formalin fixation is presumed to result in decreased antigen detection; however, this effect has only been evaluated with a few antibodies. The goal of this study was to evaluate the effect of prolonged formalin fixation on the immunohistochemical detection of 61 different antigens. Approximately 5-mm-thick tissue slices were fixed in 10% neutral-buffered formalin. Tissue slices were removed from formalin, processed, and paraffin-embedded at 1-day, 3-day, and then at ∼1-week intervals. IHC was performed on all sections in tandem after all tissues were processed. Immunoreactions were evaluated by three pathologists according to a four-tier grading system. Immunoreactivity of cytokeratin 7, high-molecular-weight cytokeratin, and laminin was diminished by prolonged formalin fixation. However, immunohistochemical reactivity remained moderate to strong with up to 7 weeks of fixation for all other antibodies. These results suggest that prolonged formalin fixation has minimal effects on antigen detection for most commonly used antibodies. These results further validate the use of IHC in diagnostic pathology. (J Histochem Cytochem 57:753–761, 2009)     

Fixation-dependent immunolocalization shift and immunoreactivity of intracellular growth factors in cartilage

The effects of fixation on immunolocalization and immunoreactivity in cartilage tissues were studied using monoclonal antibodies against peptides that can effectively stimulate chondrocytes in vitro and have been shown to play a role in musculoskeletal tissue regeneration: transforming growth factor 1, transforming growth factor 3, insulin-like growth factor I, insulin-like growth factor II and fibroblast growth factor 2. Paraffin sections fixed in buffered formalin, buffered paraformaldehyde, Carnoy and methacarn, as well as cryosections, were tested. A strong immunoreaction was observed in tissue fixed in formaldehyde-based fixatives, with a resemblance to that in cryopreserved tissues. Immunoreactivity was reduced in alcohol-fixed tissues. Furthermore, a striking intracellular immunolocalization shift from cytoplasm to nucleus was observed using alcohol-based fixatives as compared to cryopreserved or formaldehyde-based fixatives. We concluded that, for the detection and localization of growth factors in cartilage tissues, fixation in buffered formalin or paraformaldehyde is optimal.     

Feulgen Cytophotometry of Pine Nuclei; Effects of Fixation, Role of Formaline

The effects of 5 fixatives: FAA, Carnoy's, Craf III, formalin and glutaraldehyde were analyzed for use in quantitative Feulgen cytophotometry of pine embryo tissues. Craf III and glutaraldehyde had serious deficiencies because they depressed the absorption peak, severely interfered with DNA extraction and in the case of glutaraldehyde there was considerable cytoplasmic dye-binding. Neutral 10% formalin gave good tissue fixation but did not permit the degree of enzymatic or acid extraction of DNA as did Carnoy's solution. Haupt's adhesive, with the usual 4% formalin as a hardener, at temperatures of 45-56 C completely prevented the enzymatic extraction of nuclear DNA by DNase and also greatly increased the resistance of the DNA to mineral acid hydrolysis. Denaturation of DNA by formalin appeared to be responsible for these results. Absorption was linearly related to both section thickness and DNA concentration per nucleus.     

Immunohistochemistry of Colorectal Cancer Biomarker Phosphorylation Requires Controlled Tissue Fixation

Phosphorylated signaling molecules are biomarkers of cancer pathophysiology and resistance to therapy, but because phosphoprotein analytes are often labile, poorly controlled clinical laboratory practices could prevent translation of research findings in this area from the bench to the bedside. We therefore compared multiple biomarker and phosphoprotein immunohistochemistry (IHC) results in 23 clinical colorectal carcinoma samples after either a novel, rapid tissue fixation protocol or a standard tissue fixation protocol employed by clinical laboratories, and we also investigated the effect of a defined post-operative “cold” ischemia period on these IHC results. We found that a one-hour cold ischemia interval, allowed by ASCO/CAP guidelines for certain cancer biomarker assays, is highly deleterious to certain phosphoprotein analytes, specifically the phosphorylated epidermal growth factor receptor (pEGFR), but shorter ischemic intervals (less than 17 minutes) facilitate preservation of phosphoproteins. Second, we found that a rapid 4-hour, two temperature, formalin fixation yielded superior staining in several cases with select markers (pEGFR, pBAD, pAKT) compared to a standard overnight room temperature fixation protocol, despite taking less time. These findings indicate that the future research and clinical utilities of phosphoprotein IHC for assessing colorectal carcinoma pathophysiology absolutely depend upon attention to preanalytical factors and rigorously controlled tissue fixation protocols.     

Immunohistochemical markers for quantitative studies of neurons and glia in human neocortex.

Reproducible visualization of neurons and glia in human brain is essential for quantitative studies of the cellular changes in neurological disease. However, immunohistochemistry in human brain specimens is often compromised because of prolonged fixation. To select cell lineage-specific antibodies for quantitative studies of neurons and the major types of glia, we used 29 different antibodies, different epitope retrieval methods, and different detection systems to stain tissue arrays of formalin-fixed human brain. The screening pointed at CD45/leukocyte common antigen (LCA), CD68(KP1), 2',3' cyclic nucleotide phosphatase (CNPase), glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), HLA-DR, Ki67, neuronal nuclei (NeuN), p25alpha-antigen, and S100beta as candidates for future cell counting purposes, because these markers visualized specific neuronal and glial cell bodies. However, significant negative correlation between staining result and formalin fixation was observed by blinded scoring of staining for CD45/LCA, CNPase, GFAP, and NeuN in brain specimens fixed by immersion and stored up to 10 years in 4% formalin solution at room temperature, independent of donor sex and postmortem interval. In contrast, improved preservation of NeuN and CNPase staining, and full preservation of GFAP and CD45/LCA staining in tissue fixed by perfusion and stored for up to 3 years in 0.1% paraformaldehyde solution at 4C, indicated that immunohistochemistry can be performed in well-preserved biobank material.     

Commercial Formalin Substitutes for Histopathology

We compared the performance of six commercial fixatives proposed to be formalin substitutes with the performance of buffered formalin, Clarke's ethanol-acetic acid, and ethanol, using rat liver, small intestine, and kidney. We investigated the rate of penetration, mode of fixation, extent of protein and structural immobilization, quality of histology and cellular structure following routine dehydration and paraffin embedding, and performance as a fixative for immunohistochemistry. Furthermore, we evaluated the effects of the various fixatives on ultrastructure. Only buffered formalin performed equally well on all tissues tested. While several of the commercial fixatives appeared to preserve liver tissue at 200, the preservation of kidney, intestinal villi, and smooth muscle was unacceptable. Histological distortion, cell shrinkage and vacuolization were prominent when the substitutes or ethanol were used. In contrast, these artifacts were found occasionally and to a minor degree when buffered formalin or Clarke's fixative were used. Immunohistochemistry demonstrated a total loss of low molecular weight antigen (serotonin) and patchy reactions for high molecular weight antigens for all fixatives except buffered formalin. The best immunostaining was obtained by combining formalin fixation with antigen retrieval. We conclude that none of the proposed commercial substitutes for buffered formalin are adequate for critical histology or histopathology.     

Protocol for quantitative shape analysis of deformities in early larval European seabass Dicentrarchus labrax

This study established an optimized protocol for quantifying the shape variation of newly hatched larvae of European seabass Dicentrarchus labrax, focusing on the effect of fixatives and mounting on body shape from hatching until 14 days post hatching, while also minimizing the error introduced by handling. This assessment was performed based on both biometric and geometric shape data, with the latter relying on outline based elliptic Fourier analysis. The fixation and mounting effect on the total length and shape of newly hatched larvae of D. labrax was tested for four fixation treatments: (1) 8% formalin, (2) 70% ethanol, (3) 8% formalin for 48 h and then to 70% ethanol and (4) 3% phosphate‐buffered glutaraldehyde. The analyses showed that no significant size and shape effect was observed on anaesthetized specimens 5 months post‐fixation in glutaraldehyde, and that the glycerol mounting process of specimens fixed in glutaraldehyde provided the best results for further ontogenetic qualitative and quantitative analysis. The protocol proved to be sufficiently sensitive to even quantify and visualize subtle pre‐fixation shape differences originating from a different egg batch.     

A histological comparison of phase-partition fixation with fixation in aqueous solutions

In phase-partition fixation, tissue is immersed in a non-aqueous solvent at equilibrium with an aqueous solution of a fixing agent to minimize osmotic effects. Preservation of morphology afforded by phase-partition fixation using formalin and glutaraldehyde and several organic solvents was compared to aqueous 10% neutral buffered formalin fixation for five tissues. It was shown that phase-partition fixation can provide excellent fixation for light microscopy if the proper combinations of fixatives and solvents are used.