Different specificities of ribonuclease II and polynucleotide phosphorylase in 3'mRNA decay

We review recent evidence on the in vivo and in vitro mRNA degradation properties of 2 3'-exonucleases, ribonuclease II and polynucleotide phosphorylase. Although secondary structures in the RNA can act as protective barriers against 3' exonucleolytic degradation, it appears that this effect depends on the stability of these structures. The fact that RNase II is more sensitive to RNA secondary structure than PNPase, could account for some differences observed in messenger degradation by the 2 enzymes in vivo. Terminator stem-loop structures are often very stable and 3' exonucleolytic degradation proceeds only after they have been eliminated by an endonucleolytic cleavage. Other secondary structures preceding terminator stem-loop seem to contribute to mRNA stability against exonucleolytic decay.     

Action of RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase against RNAs containing stem-loops of defined structure

The 3'-->5' exoribonucleases, RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase), play an essential role in degrading fragments of mRNA generated by prior cleavages by endonucleases. We have assessed the ability of small RNA substrates containing defined stem-loop structures and variable 3' extensions to impede the exonucleolytic activity of these enzymes. We find that stem-loops containing five G-C base pairs do not block either enzyme; in contrast, more stable stem-loops of 7, 9, or 11 bp block the processive action of both enzymes. Under conditions where enzyme activity is limiting, both enzymes stall and dissociate from their substrates six to nine residues, on average, from the base of a stable stem-loop structure. Our data provide a clear mechanistic explanation for the previous observation that RNase II and PNPase behave as functionally redundant.     

Stability of RNA stem-loop structure and distribution of non-random structure in the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-I).

The stability of potential RNA stem-loop structures in human immunodeficiency virus isolates, HTLV-III and ARV, has been calculated, and the relevance to the local significant secondary structures in the sequence has been tested statistically using a Monte Carlo simulation method. Potentially significant structures exist in the 5'non-coding region, the boundary regions between the protein coding frames, and the 3' non-coding region. The locally optimal secondary structure occurring in the 5' terminal region has been assessed using different overlapping segment sizes and the Monte Carlo method. The results show that the most favorable structure for the 5' mRNA leader sequence of HIV has two stem-loops folded at nucleotides 5-104 in the R region (stem-loop I, 5-54 and stem-loop II, 58-104). A large fluctuation of segment score of the local optimal secondary structure also occurs in the boundary between the exterior glycosylated protein or outer membrane protein and transmembrane protein coding region. This finding is surprising since no RNA signals or RNA processing are expected to occur at this site. In addition, regions of the genome predicted to have significantly more open structure at the RNA level correlate closely with hypervariable sites found in these viral genomes. The possible importance of local secondary structure to the biological function of the human immunodeficiency virus genome is discussed.     

Polyadenylation accelerates degradation of chloroplast mRNA.

The expression of chloroplast genes is regulated by several mechanisms, one of which is the modulation of RNA stability. To understand how this regulatory step is controlled during chloroplast development, we have begun to define the mechanism of plastid mRNA degradation. We show here that the degradation petD mRNA involves endonucleolytic cleavage at specific sites upstream of the 3' stem-loop structure. The endonucleolytic petD cleavage products can be polyadenylated in vitro, and similar polyadenylated RNA products are detectable in vivo. PCR analysis of the psbA and psaA-psaB-rps14 operons revealed other polyadenylated endonucleolytic cleavage products, indicating that poly(A) addition appears to be an integral modification during chloroplast mRNA degradation. Polyadenylation promotes efficient degradation of the cleaved petD RNAs by a 3'-5' exoribonuclease. Furthermore, polyadenylation also plays an important role in the degradation of the petD mRNA 3' end. Although the 3' end stem-loop is usually resistant to nucleases, adenylation renders the secondary structure susceptible to the 3'-5' exoribonuclease. Analysis of 3' ends confirms that polyadenylation occurs in vivo, and reveals that the extent of adenylation increases during the degradation of plastid mRNA in the dark. Based on these results, we propose a novel mechanism for polyadenylation in the regulation of plastid mRNA degradation.     

5'-to-3' exoribonuclease activity in bacteria: role of RNase J1 in rRNA maturation and 5' stability of mRNA

Although the primary mechanism of eukaryotic messenger RNA decay is exoribonucleolytic degradation in the 5'-to-3' orientation, it has been widely accepted that Bacteria can only degrade RNAs with the opposite polarity, i.e. 3' to 5'. Here we show that maturation of the 5' side of Bacillus subtilis 16S ribosomal RNA occurs via a 5'-to-3' exonucleolytic pathway, catalyzed by the widely distributed essential ribonuclease RNase J1. The presence of a 5'-to-3' exoribonuclease activity in B. subtilis suggested an explanation for the phenomenon whereby mRNAs in this organism are stabilized for great distances downstream of "roadblocks" such as stalled ribosomes or stable secondary structures, whereas upstream sequences are never detected. We show that a 30S ribosomal subunit bound to a Shine Dalgarno-like element (Stab-SD) in the cryIIIA mRNA blocks exonucleolytic progression of RNase J1, accounting for the stabilizing effect of this element in vivo.     

The role of the S1 domain in exoribonucleolytic activity: substrate specificity and multimerization

RNase II is a 3'-5' exoribonuclease that processively hydrolyzes single-stranded RNA generating 5' mononucleotides. This enzyme contains a catalytic core that is surrounded by three RNA-binding domains. At its C terminus, there is a typical S1 domain that has been shown to be critical for RNA binding. The S1 domain is also present in the other major 3'-5' exoribonucleases from Escherichia coli: RNase R and polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase). In this report, we examined the involvement of the S1 domain in the different abilities of these three enzymes to overcome RNA secondary structures during degradation. Hybrid proteins were constructed by replacing the S1 domain of RNase II for the S1 from RNase R and PNPase, and their exonucleolytic activity and RNA-binding ability were examined. The results revealed that both the S1 domains of RNase R and PNPase are able to partially reverse the drop of RNA-binding ability and exonucleolytic activity resulting from removal of the S1 domain of RNase II. Moreover, the S1 domains investigated are not equivalent. Furthermore, we demonstrate that S1 is neither responsible for the ability to overcome secondary structures during RNA degradation, nor is it related to the size of the final product generated by each enzyme. In addition, we show that the S1 domain from PNPase is able to induce the trimerization of the RNaseII-PNP hybrid protein, indicating that this domain can have a role in the biogenesis of multimers.     

Roles of polyadenylation and nucleolytic cleavage in the filamentous phage mRNA processing and decay pathways in Escherichia coli.

To define basic features of mRNA processing and decay in Escherichia coli, we have examined a set of mRNAs encoded by the filamentous phage f1 that have structures typical of bacterial mRNAs. They bear a stable hairpin stem-loop on the 3' end left from rho-independent termination and are known to undergo processing by RNase E. A small percentage of the f1 mRNAs were found to bear poly(A) tails that were attached to heterogeneous positions near the common 3' end. In a poly(A) polymerase-deficient host, the later-appearing processed mRNAs were stabilized, and a novel small RNA accumulated. This approximately 125-nt RNA proved to arise via RNase E cleavage from the 3'-terminal region of the mRNAs bearing the terminator. Normally ribosomes translating gene VIII appear to protect this cleavage site from RNase E, so that release of the fragment from the mRNAs occurs very slowly. The data presented define additional steps in the f1 mRNA processing and decay pathways and clarify how features of the pathways are used in establishing and maintaining the persistent filamentous phage infection. Although the primary mode of decay is endonucleolytic cleavage generating a characteristic 5' --> 3' wave of products, polyadenylation is involved in part in degradation of the processed mRNAs and is required for turnover of the 125-nt mRNA fragment. The results place polyadenylation at a later rather than an initiating step of decay. They also provide a clear illustration of how stably structured RNA 3' ends act as barriers to 3' --> 5' exonucleolytic mRNA decay.     

Regulated alpha-globin mRNA decay is a cytoplasmic event proceeding through 3'-to-5' exosome-dependent decapping

The alpha-globin mRNA contains a C-rich stability element (CRE) in its 3' untranslated region (3' UTR) which is critical for the stability of this long-lived mRNA. A protein complex, termed the alpha-complex, forms on the CRE and has been shown to contribute to stabilization of the mRNA by at least two mechanisms, first by interacting with the poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) to prevent deadenylation, and second by protecting the mRNA from attack by an erythroid endoribonuclease. In this report, we demonstrate that the alpha-globin 3' UTR can confer stability on a heterologous mRNA in cells, and this stability is dependent on the alpha-complex. Moreover, the stability was exclusively detected with cytoplasmic mRNA, suggesting that the regulation of alpha-globin mRNA stability is a cytoplasmic event. An additional mechanism by which the alpha-complex can confer stability on an RNA in vitro was also identified and shown to involve inhibition of 3' to 5' exonucleolytic degradation. Furthermore, using an in vitro mRNA decay system, we were able to follow the demise of the alpha-globin RNA and demonstrate that the decay was initiated by deadenylation followed by 3'-to-5' decay carried out by the exosome and ultimately hydrolysis of the residual cap structure.     

The mammalian exosome mediates the efficient degradation of mRNAs that contain AU-rich elements.

HeLa cytoplasmic extracts contain both 3'-5' and 5'-3' exonuclease activities that may play important roles in mRNA decay. Using an in vitro RNA deadenylation/decay assay, mRNA decay intermediates were trapped using phosphothioate-modified RNAs. These data indicate that 3'-5' exonucleolytic decay is the major pathway of RNA degradation following deadenylation in HeLa cytoplasmic extracts. Immunodepletion using antibodies specific for the exosomal protein PM-Scl75 demonstrated that the human exosome complex is required for efficient 3'-5' exonucleolytic decay. Furthermore, 3'-5' exonucleolytic decay was stimulated dramatically by AU-rich instability elements (AREs), implicating a role for the exosome in the regulation of mRNA turnover. Finally, PM-Scl75 protein was found to interact specifically with AREs. These data suggest that the interaction between the exosome and AREs plays a key role in regulating the efficiency of ARE-containing mRNA turnover.     

A 5'-3' exonuclease activity involved in forming the 3' products of histone pre-mRNA processing in vitro.

Histone RNA 3' processing in vitro produces one or more 5' cleavage products corresponding to the mature histone mRNA 3' end, and a group of 3' cleavage products whose 5' ends are mostly located several nucleotides downstream of the mRNA 3' end. The formation of these 3' products is coupled to the formation of 5' products and dependent on the U7 snRNP and a heat-labile processing factor. These short 3' products therefore are a true and general feature of the processing reaction. Identical 3' products are also formed from a model RNA containing all spacer nucleotides downstream of the mature mRNA 3' end, but no sequences from the mature mRNA. Again, this reaction is dependent on both the U7 snRNP and a heat-labile factor. Unlike the processing with a full-length histone pre-mRNA, this reaction produces only 3' but no 5' fragments. In addition, product formation is inhibited by addition of cap structures at the model RNA 5' end, indicating that product formation occurs by 5'-3' exonucleolytic degradation. This degradation of a model 3' product by a 5'-3' exonuclease suggests a mechanism for the release of the U7 snRNP after processing by shortening the cut-off histone spacer sequences base paired to U7 RNA.     

Chicken transferrin receptor gene: conservation 3'' noncoding sequences and expression in erythroid cells.

Recombinant clones of the chicken transferrin receptor gene and cDNA have been isolated and sequenced. Two highly conserved regions have been identified in the 3' noncoding sequence of the human and chicken TR gene. The conserved regions include sequences that have been shown to be involved in the iron-dependent regulation of human TR mRNA stability. These sequences can be modeled as two different types of RNA secondary structures, one containing stem-loop structures that are similar to the iron-responsive elements found in ferritin mRNA and the other being a stable, duplex/stem-loop structure. Both forms show considerable similarity between chicken and human mRNA. The expression of TR is developmentally regulated during erythroid maturation, and immature erythroid cells express exceptionally high levels of TR mRNA.     

Emerging features of mRNA decay in bacteria

The problem of mRNA decay in E. coli has recently seen exciting progress, with the discoveries that key degradation enzymes are associated together in a high molecular weight degradosome and that polyadenylation promotes decay. Recent advances make it clear that mRNA decay in bacteria is far more interesting enzymatically than might have been predicted. In-depth study of specific mRNAs has revealed multiple pathways for degradation. Which pathway a given mRNA follows appears to depend in large part on the location of the initiating endonucleolytic cleavage within the mRNA. During the steps of mRNA decay, stable RNA structures pose formidable barriers to the 3' --> 5' exonucleases. However, polyadenylation is now emerging as a process that plays an important role in maintaining the momentum of exonucleolytic degradation by adding single-stranded extensions to the 3' ends of mRNAs and their decay intermediates, thereby facilitating further exonuclease digestion.     

Thermodynamic stability and statistical significance of potential stem-loop structures situated at the frameshift sites of retroviruses.

RNA stem-loop structures situated just 3' to the frameshift sites of the retroviral gag-pol or gag-pro and pro-pol regions may make important contributions to frame-shifting in retroviruses. In this study, the thermodynamic stability and statistical significance of such secondary structural features relative to others in the sequence have been assessed using a newly developed method that combines calculations of the lowest free energy of formation of RNA secondary structures and the Monte Carlo simulations. Our results show that stem-loop structures situated just 3' to the frameshift sites are both highly stable and statistically significant relative to others in the gag-pol or gag-pro and pro-pol junction domains (both 300 nucleotides upstream and downstream from the possible frameshift sites are included) of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1), bovine leukemia virus (BLV), human T-cell leukemia virus type II (HTLV-II), and mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV). No other more stable, or significant folding regions are predicted in these domains.