Ionizing radiation and genetic risks. III. Nature of spontaneous and radiation-induced mutations in mammalian in vitro systems and mechanisms of induction of mutations by radiation

This paper (1) presents an analysis of published data on the molecular nature of spontaneously arising and radiation-induced mutations in mammalian somatic cell systems and (2) examines whether the molecular nature and mechanisms of origin of radiation-induced mutations, in mammalian in vivo and in vitro systems, as currently understood, are consistent with expectations based on the biophysical and microdosimetric properties of ionizing radiation. Depending on the test system (CHO cells, human T lymphocytes and human lymphoid cell line TK6), 80-97% of spontaneous HPRT mutations show normal Southern patterns; the remainder is due to gross changes, predominantly partial (intragenic) deletions. Total gene deletions at the HPRT locus are rare except in the TK6 cell line. At the APRT locus in CHO cells, 80-97% of spontaneous mutations are due to base-pair changes, the remainder being, mostly, partial deletions. The latter can extend upstream in the 5' direction but not beyond the APRT gene in the 3' direction. At the human HLA-A locus (T lymphocytes), the percentage of mutations with normal Southern patterns is lower than that for HPRT, and in the range of 50-60%. At the HLA-A locus, mitotic recombination contributes substantially to the mutation spectrum (approximately 30% of mutations recovered) and this is likely to be true of the TK locus in the TK6 cell line as well. With a few exceptions, most of the radiation-induced mutations show altered Southern patterns and are consistent with their being deletions and/or other gross changes (HPRT, 70-90% (CHO); 50-85% (TK6); 50-75% (T lymphocytes); TK, 60-80% (TK6); HLA-A, 80% (T lymphocytes); DHFR, 100% (CHO]. The exceptions are APRT mutations in CHO cells (16-20% of mutants with deletions or other changes) and HPRT mutations in T lymphocytes from A-bomb survivors (15-25%); the latter finding is consistent with the occurrence of in vivo selection against HPRT mutant cells. In cases of HPRT intragenic deletions analyzed (CHO cells and V79 Chinese hamster cells), there is evidence for a non-random distribution of breakpoints. The spontaneous mutation frequencies vary widely, from about 0.04/10(6) cells (sickle cell mutations at the human HBB locus) to 30.8/10(6) cells (HLA-A mutations in T lymphocytes) and are dependent on the locus, the system employed and a number of other factors. Those for the other loci fall between these limits.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The HLA-A mutation assay: improved technique and normal results

The HLA-A assay for detection of mutant lymphocytes has been modified, principally by incorporation of an overnight-incubation step which has resulted in improved immunoselection. For 83 estimations on cells from 21 normal individuals with a mean age of 35, the in vivo mutant frequency was 2.99 X 10(-5) +/- 1.48 X 10(-5) (mean +/- 1 SD). For 11 estimations on cells from 10 elderly individuals with a mean age of 78, the mutant frequency was significantly greater, being 7.16 X 10(-5) +/- 4.06 X 10(-5). Similar results were obtained when HLA-A2 or HLA-A3 mutants were enumerated. Mutant frequency measured at the HLA-A locus is almost an order of magnitude greater than that measured at the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyl transferase locus, but at least the major part of this difference is likely to be due to factors other than a difference in genetic stability between the two loci.     

Both the rate and spectrum of loss of heterozygosity differ between human lymphoblastoid cells derived from various donors

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) contributes significantly to the inactivation of tumor suppressor genes and may involve a variety of mechanisms. Studying loss of HLA-A2 alleles in human lymphoblastoid cell lines, we previously showed that mitotic recombination and chromosome loss with concomitant duplication of the non-selected chromosome were the most frequent mechanisms of LOH. In the present study we used the HLA system to determine the rate and spectrum of LOH mutations in the EBV transformed lymphoblastoid cell line R83-4915. Spontaneous loss of HLA-A2 in R83-4915 occurred with a rate of 7.9x10-7 which was 5 to 10-times lower compared to the previously observed rate of loss of HLA-A2 in other lymphoblastoid cell lines. Among the HLA-A2 mutants, 27% did not show LOH of additional chromosome 6 markers. Molecular analysis showed that neither large deletion nor gene conversion was the cause for their mutant phenotype. The remaining mutants showed LOH, which was caused by mitotic recombination (40%) and chromosome loss (33%). However, the chromosome loss observed in mutants of R83-4915 was not accompanied by the duplication of the remaining chromosome. Instead 3 out of 5 mutants became polyploid suggesting that different mechanisms exist to compensate for chromosome loss. In conclusion, the rate and types of LOH that can be observed in cell lines obtained from various donors may depend on the genetic make-up or the transformation status of these cells     

Development of a flow-cytometric HLA-A locus mutation assay for human peripheral blood lymphocytes.

A flow-cytometric technique was developed to measure the frequency of variant lymphocytes lacking expression of HLA-A2 or A24 allele products among donors heterozygous for HLA-A2 or A24. It was found that the variant frequency of lymphocytes in peripheral blood was of the order of 10(-4) and increased with donor age. Molecular analyses of mutant clones revealed that about one-third were derived from somatic recombinations and that the remaining two-thirds did not show any alterations after Southern blotting analysis. In contrast, mutants obtained after in vitro X-ray mutagenesis study were found to be mostly derived from large chromosomal deletions. A small-scale study on atomic bomb survivors did not show a significant dose effect.     

Mapping of class I DNA sequences within the human major histocompatibility complex

Mutants that had lost expression of alleles of one or more HLA loci were isolated with immunoselection after gamma-irradiation of a human lymphoblastoid cell line LCL 721. DNAs from the mutants were digested with restriction endonucleases and analyzed by Southern blotting using probes for class I HLA genes. Eight polymorphic cut sites for HindIII and PvuII were discovered in class I-associated sequences of LCL 721. Losses of specific fragments generated by restriction enzymes could be associated with losses of specific antigenic expressions and it was possible in this way to assign HLA-A1, HLA-A2, and HLA-B8 to specific DNA fragments. Patterns of gamma-ray-induced segregations of DNA fragments permitted rough linkage alignment of about 30% of the fragments generated by PvuII. The resultant map showed that there are class I HLA genes on the telomeric side of the HLA-A locus. Restriction enzyme site polymorphisms were also examined in a panel of DNAs isolated from peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) of HLA-typed individuals. This panel of PBL DNA complemented the analysis using the HLA deletion mutants.     

"Illegal" transformation of red adenine-dependent mutants of the yeast Pichia pinus by the pYE(ADE2)2 plasmid

The red adenine-dependent mutants ade1 of the yeast Pichia pinus blocked in the VI step of adenine biosynthesis (lack of AIR-carboxylase) and ade2 mutants blocked in the VII step of adenine biosynthesis (lack of SAIKAR-synthase) were transformed with the plasmid pYE(ADE2)2 containing ADE2 gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae encoding AIR-carboxylase. The appearance of white Ade+ clones with the frequency 2-7.10(-8) (which is ten-fold higher than reversion frequency) was only observed in the case of ade2 transformation. Genetic analysis points to connection of the "illegitimate" transformants' appearance with the change in the mutant ade2 locus or in a locus closely linked to the former. Ade+ phenotype was stable during 20 generations of mitotic budding. Southern blotting assay of transformant chromosomal DNA indicates that reconstitution of ade2 defective gene is related with its "correction", owing to integration of pYE(ADE2)2 sequence in the vicinity of the mutant locus.     

Localization of the nucleotide excision repair gene ERCC6 to human chromosome 10q11-q21.

We have cloned the human DNA excision repair gene ERCC6 by virtue of its ability to correct the uv sensitivity of Chinese hamster overy cell mutant UV61. This mutant is a member of complementation group 6 of the nucleotide excision repair-deficient rodent mutants. By means of in situ hybridization and Southern blot analysis of mouse x human somatic cell hybrids, the gene was localized to human chromosome 10q11-q21. An RFLP detected within the ERCC6 locus can be helpful in linkage analysis.     

Molecular analyses of in vivo hprt mutations in human T-lymphocytes. III. Longitudinal study of hprt gene structural alterations and T-cell clonal origins

The hprt clonal assay detects mutations occurring in vivo in the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphpribosyltransferase (hprt) gene of human T-lymphocytes. Analysis of 94 wild-type and 326 hprt mutant clones from 3 normal males was performed using Southern blotting with hprt and T-cell receptor (TCR) gene probes. Gross structural alterations of the hprt gene occurred in 14% of the in vivo derived mutants. Breakpoints were randomly distributed across the gene with one possible mutational “hot spot” observed. Most hprt mutants were independent as judge by TCR gene rearrangement patterns indicating that the measured hprt mutant frequency is a good measure of the actual hprt mutation frequency. However, sibling mutants (generally doublets and triplets except for one nonamer) were detected. Information on the timing in vivo of the hprt mutational events and the persistence in vivo of sibling mutants was also obtained.     

Characterization of Null Mutants of the RAD55 Gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae: Effects of Temperature, Osmotic Strength and Mating Type

RAD55 belongs to a group of genes required for resistance to ionizing radiation, RAD50-RAD57, which are thought to define a pathway of recombinational repair. Since all four alleles of RAD55 are temperature conditional (cold sensitive) for their radiation phenotype, we investigated the phenotype produced by null mutations in the RAD55 gene, constructed in vitro and transplaced to the yeast chromosome. The X-ray sensitivity of these null mutant strains was surprisingly suppressed by increased temperature, osmotic strength of the growth medium and heterozygosity at the mating-type locus. These first two properties, temperature conditionality and osmotic remediability, are commonly associated with missense mutations; these rad55 null mutants are unique in that they exhibit these properties although the mutant gene cannot be expressed. X-ray-induced mitotic recombination was also cold sensitive in rad55 mutant diploids. Although mitotic growth was unaffected in these strains, meiosis was a lethal event at both high and low temperatures. Whereas the phenotype of rad55 null mutants is consistent with a role of RAD55 in recombination and recombinational repair, there is evidence for considerable RAD55-independent recombination, at least in mitotic cells, which is influenced by temperature and MAT. We discuss models for the role of RAD55 in recombination to explain the unusual properties of rad55 mutants.     

Induction of mutations by bismuth-212 alpha particles at two genetic loci in human B-lymphoblasts.

The human lymphoblast cell line TK6 was exposed to the alpha-particle-emitting radon daughter 212Bi by adding DTPA-chelated 212Bi directly to the cell suspension. Cytotoxicity and mutagenicity at two genetic loci were measured, and the molecular nature of mutant clones was studied by Southern blot analysis. Induced mutant fractions were 2.5 x 10(-5)/Gy at the hprt locus and 3.75 x 10(-5)/Gy at the tk locus. Molecular analysis of HPRT- mutant DNAs showed a high frequency (69%) of clones with partial or full deletions of the hprt gene among radiation-induced mutants compared with spontaneous mutants (31%). Chi-squared analyses of mutational spectra show a significant difference (P < or = 0.005) between spontaneous mutants and alpha-particle-induced mutants. Comparison with published studies of accelerator-produced heavy-ion exposures of TK6 cells indicates that the induction of mutations at the hprt locus, and perhaps a subset of mutations at the tk locus, is a simple linear function of particle fluence regardless of the ion species or its LET.     

Induction, detection and characterization of cell differentiation mutants in Drosophila

Summary Mitotic recombination has been used as a tool for detecting cell differentiation mutants in clones of heterozygous individuals. With this method, previously mutagenized (ethyl methanesulfonate) genomes can be screened for mutants, induced anywhere in the genome, in a first generation, and irrespectively of being lethal themselves or present ina lethal chromosome. Induced mitotic recombination was used again in order to give the chromo-some arm location and recombinational locus. In this way 13 new cell differentiation mutants out of 1504 studied genomes have been detected, meiotically mapped and isolated. They affect the process of cell differentiation of chaetes and/or trichomes in the adult cuticle of the thorax and/or the tergites. A mitotic chromosome map has been constructed using the mitotic recombination data of these new mutants and those of other cell differentiation mutants already available. The applicability of this method for the detection of other cell mutants in other systems is discussed.     

Directed mutagenesis in Candida albicans: one-step gene disruption to isolate ura3 mutants.

A method for introducing specific mutations into the diploid Candida albicans by one-step gene disruption and subsequent UV-induced recombination was developed. The cloned C. albicans URA3 gene was disrupted with the C. albicans ADE2 gene, and the linearized DNA was used for transformation of two ade2 mutants, SGY-129 and A81-Pu. Both an insertional inactivation of the URA3 gene and a disruption which results in a 4.0-kilobase deletion were made. Southern hybridization analyses demonstrated that the URA3 gene was disrupted on one of the chromosomal homologs in 15 of the 18 transformants analyzed. These analyses also revealed restriction site dimorphism of EcoRI at the URA3 locus which provides a unique marker to distinguish between chromosomal homologs. This enabled us to show that either homolog could be disrupted and that disrupted transformants of SGY-129 contained more than two copies of the URA3 locus. The A81-Pu transformants heterozygous for the ura3 mutations were rendered homozygous and Ura- by UV-induced recombination. The homozygosity of a deletion mutant and an insertion mutant was confirmed by Southern hybridization. Both mutants were transformed to Ura+ with plasmids containing the URA3 gene and in addition, were resistant to 5-fluoro-orotic acid, a characteristic of Saccharomyces cerevisiae ura3 mutants as well as of orotidine-5'-phosphate decarboxylase mutants of other organisms.     

Determination of spontaneous loss of heterozygosity mutations in Aprt heterozygous mice.

A mouse model was generated to investigate loss of heterozygosity (LOH) events in somatic cells. The adenine phosphoribosyltransferase ( Aprt ) gene was disrupted in embryonic stem cells using a conventional gene targeting approach and subsequently Aprt hetero-zygous and homozygous mice were derived. Aprt homozygous deficient animals were viable though the mendelian inheritance pattern was skewed. On average these mice died at 6 months of age from severe renal failure. In T-lymphocytes of Aprt heterozygous mice the mean spontaneous mutant frequency at the Aprt locus was 8.7 x 10(-6) while the frequency was 0.8 x 10(-6) at the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase locus. In order to determine whether LOH events contribute to the high spontaneous mutant frequency at the Aprt locus, 140 Aprt mutant T-lymphocyte clones were expanded and analysed by allele-specific PCR. In 97 (69%) of these clones the wild-type allele had been lost. Nine of the mutant clones were characterized in more detail using dual-coloured fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis. Five out of six of the mutant clones which arose from an LOH event, based on the PCR assay, contained a duplication of the targeted allele. Therefore, mitotic recombination or chromosome loss followed by duplication of the remaining homologue appears to be the predominant mechanism for the in vivo generation of Aprt mutant T-lymphocytes.     

The Rec102 Mutant of Yeast Is Defective in Meiotic Recombination and Chromosome Synapsis

A mutation at the REC102 locus was identified in a screen for yeast mutants that produce inviable spores. rec102 spore lethality is rescued by a spo13 mutation, which causes cells to bypass the meiosis I division. The rec102 mutation completely eliminates meiotically induced gene conversion and crossing over but has no effect on mitotic recombination frequencies. Cytological studies indicate that the rec102 mutant makes axial elements (precursors to the synaptonemal complex), but homologous chromosomes fail to synapse. In addition, meiotic chromosome segregation is significantly delayed in rec102 strains. Studies of double and triple mutants indicate that the REC102 protein acts before the RAD52 gene product in the meiotic recombination pathway. The REC102 gene was cloned based on complementation of the mutant defect and the gene was mapped to chromosome XII between CDC25 and STE11.     

HLA class I and H ferritin gene polymorphisms in normal subjects and patients with haemochromatosis

Summary The gene for idiopathic haemochromatosis is located on the short arm of chromosome 6 within 1 cM of the HLA-A locus. In this region there are many HLA class I genes, and there may also be a gene for the H subunit of ferritin. Both HLA class I and H ferritin genes are therefore candidates for the abnormal gene in idiopathic haemochromatosis. In 15 unrelated patients the frequency of HLA-A3 was 80% compared with 24% for 600 unrelated individuals from South Wales. The most common haplotype involved is probably HLA-A3, B7. DNA was prepared from leucocytes from 12 of these patients and from 85 normal subjects. After digestion with Taq1, electrophoresis, and Southern blotting, class I sequences were detected by hybridisation to an HLA class I probe (pHLA-A). Of the 34 restriction fragments detected, 22 were polymorphic. Particular fragments correlated with the presence of HLA-A antigens A1, 2, 3, 10, 11, w19, and 28, but there was little correlation with B antigens. Restriction fragment patterns specific for haemochromatosis were not found with TaqI or during less extensive studies with other restriction enzymes. No differences in restriction fragment patterns were found between four patients and four normal subjects apparently homozygous for HLA-A3 and B7. Examination of Southern blotting patterns for genomic DNA from patients and normal subjects with a panel of 12 restriction enzymes and a probe for the H ferritin gene (pDBR-2) revealed no polymorphisms associated with either idiopathic haemochromatosis or particular HLA phenotypes. These studies provide no support for either HLA class I genes or the H ferritin gene as candidates for the haemochromatosis gene.     

Loss of heterozygosity and base substitution at the APRT locus in mismatch-repair-proficient and -deficient colorectal carcinoma cell lines.

We determined the nature of mutations occurring at the autosomal APRT locus in mismatch-repair-proficient and -deficient colorectal carcinoma cell lines. The analysis of mutations that result in APRT deficiency in a mismatch-repair-deficient strain of DLD-1 heterozygous for this locus enabled us to measure the rate of loss of the wild-type gene through deletion, recombination, or gene conversion as well as the rate of point mutation. The overall rate of mutation at the APRT locus in DLD-1 was elevated 100-fold compared with the mismatch-repair-proficient colorectal carcinoma cell line SW620. Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at APRT accounted for only 4 to 9% of mutant strains derived from DLD-1, indicating a rate for these types of events of 4 x 10(-7) to 9 x 10(-7). In SW620 the rate of LOH at APRT was about 10-fold higher. LOH was not found at polymorphic markers within the same chromosome subband as APRT, indicating that only a limited portion of the chromosome was affected by these alterations. Chromosome painting of SWS620 mutants revealed that the loss of APRT occurred together with a substantial portion of the long arm of chromosome 16. Differences in the nature of base substitutions at APRT (e.g., the proportion of mutations resulting from transitions or transversions) in these tumor cell lines were also detected. There was also an important similarity---the presence of a mutant APRT gene with multiple base substitutions that may be the result of some sort of error-prone DNA synthesis.     

In vivo ionizing irradiations produce deletions in the hprt gene of human T-lymphocytes

The hprt T-lymphocyte cloning assay, which detects mutations occurring in vivo in humans, has been used to examine mutants induced in patients receiving radioimmunoglobulin therapy (RIT) for cancer. Samples from 13 patients before treatment (controls) and 15 samples from 12 patients after treatment were studied for both mutant frequencies and molecular changes in the hprt mutant T-cell clones. Patients were studied up to 48 months after treatment. Post-RIT patients showed increased mutant frequencies as compared to pre-treatment values. T-cell receptor (TCR) gene analysis of mutant T-cell clones demonstrated that 84% arose independently, both pre- and post-treatment, which is the same proportion as seen in normal individuals. However, several individuals did show large sets of mutants with the same TCR gene rearrangement patterns. Molecular analysis of mutants demonstrated a greater proportion of mutations with hprt gene changes on Southern blots after RIT treatment than before (40% versus 20%). RIT increases the proportion of mutations with total rather than partial gene deletions or other gross structural changes compared to normal individuals or pre-treatment patients. These studies are defining the spectrum for radiation-induced hprt gene mutations in vivo in human T-lymphocytes.     

Transfer of cloned human class I major histocompatibility complex genes into HLA mutant human lymphoblastoid cells.

Three new kinds of recombinant DNA constructs were used to transfer cloned human class I HLA genes (A2 and B8) into unique HLA mutant lymphoblastoid cells: pHeBo(x): a class I gene, "x," in plasmid vector pHeBo, which contains a hygromycin resistance gene and Epstein-Barr virus oriP element that sustains extrachromosomal replication; pHPT(x): gene x in a vector with a hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) gene; pHPTe(x): gene x in a vector with the HPRT gene and oriP element. Cell surface class I antigen expression was strong in transferents made with class I-deficient lymphoblastoid cell line mutants .144 (A-null), .53 (B-null), and .184 (A-null, B-null). Transferents expressing HLA-A2 were recognized specifically by HLA-A2-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes. When introduced on either of the vectors with the Epstein-Barr virus oriP element, the class I gene replicated extrachromosomally and was lost at rates of 0.2 to 0.3 per cell division. When introduced with vector pHPT (lacking Epstein-Barr virus oriP), the B8 gene was inserted at different chromosomal locations. Introduction of the HLA-B8 gene failed to restore antigen expression by HLA-B-null mutant .174, providing evidence that, unlike mutants exemplified by .53, .144, and .184, some HLA antigen loss mutants are deficient in a trans-acting function needed for class I antigen expression. Of more general interest, the results obtained with HLA class I genes in vectors that replicate extrachromosomally suggest ways of relating genic expression to chromatin structure and function and of attempting to clone functional human centromeres.     

Molecular analysis of spontaneous mutations at the gpt locus in Chinese hamster ovary (AS52) cells

AS52 cells are Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells that carry a single functional copy of the bacterial gpt gene and allow the isolation of 6-thioguanine-resistant (6TGr)mutants arising from mutation at the chromosally integrated gpt locus. The gpt locus in AS52 cells is extremely stable, giving rise to 6TGr mutants at frequencies comparable to the endogenous CHO hprt locus. In this study, we describe the spectrum of spontaneous mutations observed in AS52 cells by Southern blot and DNA sequence analyses. Using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and the Thermus aquaticus (Taq) polymerase, we have enzymatically amplified 6TGr mutant gpt sequences in vitro. The PCR product was then sequenced without further cloning manipulations to directly identify gpt structural gene mutations. Deletions predominant among the 62 spontaneous 6TGr-AS52 mutant clones analyzed in this study. Of these, 79% (49/62) of the mutations were identified as deletions either by Southern blotting, PCR amplification or DNA sequence analysis. Among these deletions is a predominant 3-base deletion that was observed in 31% (19/62) of the mutants. These data provide a basis for future comparisons of induced point mutational spectra derived in the AS52 cell line, and demonstrate the utility of PCR in the generation of DNA sequence spectra derived from chromosomally integrated mammalian loci.     

In vivo ionizing irradiations produce deletions in the hprt gene of human T-lymphocytes

The hprt T-lymphocyte cloning assay, which detects mutations occurring in vivo in humans, has been used to examine mutants induced in patients receiving radioimmunoglobulin therapy (RIT) for cancer. Samples from 13 patients before treatment (controls) and 15 samples from 12 patients after treatment were studied for both mutant frequencies and molecular changes in the hprt mutant T-cell clones. Patients were studied up to 48 months after treatment. Post-RIT patients showed increased mutant frequencies as compared to pre-treatment values. T-cell receptor (TCR) gene analysis of mutant T-cell clones demonstrated that 84% arose independently, both pre- and post-treatment, which is the same proportion as seen in normal individuals. However, several individuals did show large sets of mutants with the same TCR gene rearrangement patterns. Molecular analysis of mutants demonstrated a greater proportion of mutations with hprt gene changes on Southern blots after RIT treatment than before (40% versus 20%). RIT increases the proportion of mutations with total rather than partial gene deletions or other gross structural changes compared to normal individuals or pre-treatment patients. These studies are defining the spectrum for radiation-induced hprt gene mutations in vivo in human T-lymphocytes.