Specificity of allogeneic and xenogeneic cell recognition in the fetal lamb.

Cells prepared from liver, thymus, and spleen of fetal lambs at different stages if gestation were confronted with allogeneic and xenogeneic cells in MLC. Specific elimination of the responding cells with BUdR and UV light together with a subsequent restimulation was used to study the specificity of the reaction. The response of fetal liver cells was not based on the existence of specifically recognizing cellular subpopulations; the response was concluded to be due either to stimulatory products released by the stimulating cells or to the multipotentiality of the responding cells. Specifically recognizing cells first appeared in the thymus at 58 days postconception and in the spleen at 70 days. In the response of sheep lymphocytes against allogeneic and xenogeneic (mouse, human) cells, a cross-reactivity occurred. Fetal lamb lymphocytes were also capable of recognizing intraspecies differences on the xenogeneic cells. This capacity developed simultaneously with the specific recognition of allogeneic cells. No clear difference was observed in the reactivity of fetal thymus cells and spleen cells when compared to that of adult peripheral blood lymphocytes. These findings indicate that immunologically specific recognition of foreign cells is created in the sheep during the early intrauterine development.     

Cytotoxic and proliferative lymphocyte responses to allogeneic and xenogeneic antigens in vitro.

In vitro lymphoproliferative responses to foreign histocompatibility antigens are phylogenetically restricted. Responses occur most readily to allogeneic or closely related xenogeneic leucocytes, but not to unrelated xenogeneic cells. Specific cytotoxic T cell responses to foreign histocompatibility antigens show the same phylogenetic restriction. This lack of xenoreactivity is not due to a lack of precursor cells for the xenoantigens; guinea-pig lymphocytes, although normally unresponsive to mouse antigens, have a similar precursor frequency for these antigens as do lymphocytes of allogeneic mouse strains. Specific cytotoxic responses of guinea-pig lymphocytes to mouse antigens can be generated if a factor released from con A stimulated guinea-pig spleen cells is added to the culture medium. The factor produced by con A-activated spleen cells (CS) is also phylogenetically restricted in its action; CS must be obtained from animals homologous with the donor of the responding lymphocytes.     

Differential cytotoxicity of activated lymphocytes on allogeneic and xenogeneic target cells. I. Activation by tuberculin and by Staphylococcus filtrate

Normal lymphocytes activated by mitogens such as phytohemagglutinin (PHA), by Staphylococcus filtrate (SF), or lymphocytes from sensitized individuals stimulated by antigen (PPD, etc.) are cytotoxic to tissue culture cells of different origins. In this and the following paper, the results of a detailed quantitative analysis of the specificity of this cytotoxic reaction are presented. Effector cells were human or mouse lymphocytes, activated by PHA, SF, PPD, or serum factors in the culture medium. Cells from established cell lines of human, mouse, hamster, or rabbit origin, or primary human or rat embryonic fibroblasts were used as target cells. Lysis was quantitated by release of ⁵¹Cr from labeled target cells.Purified human blood lymphocytes, activated by PPD, SF, or otherwise, preferentially damaged allogeneic target cells. Lysis of xenogeneic target cells was weak or did not occur. A close correlation was noted between target cell destruction and blastoid transformation of the lymphocytes, but the slope of the regression lines of xenogeneic cytotoxicity was much smaller than that of allogeneic cytotoxicity when plotted as a function of blastoid transformation.Lymph node or spleen cells from CBA mice were stimulated by PPD to transformation and DNA synthesis. CBA lymphocytes also showed an increased degree of blast transformation in medium containing fetal calf serum or certain batches of fresh human serum. Mouse lymphocytes activated in these ways damaged allogeneic L cells but had no effects on xenogeneic Chang cells.These results indicate that lymphocytes activated by various means preferentially damage target cells from their own species. The recognition mechanisms which determine the specificity of the reactions are not known.     

Differential cytotoxicity of activated lymphocytes on allogeneic and xenogeneic target cells. II. Activation by phytohemagglutinin

In the preceding paper it has been shown that human or mouse lymphocytes stimulated by a variety of agents, damaged allogeneic target cells while damage of xenogeneic target cells was weak or absent. In this study, the species specificity of the cytotoxicity of PHA activated lymphocytes has been studied in greater detail. Effector cells were purified lymphocytes either from human peripheral blood, or from spleen or lymph nodes of inbred mice. Target cells were ⁵¹Cr-labeled human Chang liver cells or mouse L cells.PHA stimulated human or mouse lymphocytes were significantly more cytotoxic to allogeneic than to xenogeneic target cells. At low PHA doses at which damage of allogeneic target cells was significant, damage of xenogeneic target cells was very weak or absent. At higher PHA doses, damage of xenogeneic target cells became also significant but always remained at a lower level than that of allogeneic target cells.Prestimulation of human lymphocytes with PHA for 3 days increased their cytotoxic efficiency. Furthermore, damage of human Chang cells by human lymphocytes had a dose-response relationship similar to that valid for stimulation of DNA synthesis. However, damage of mouse L cells by human lymphocytes increased at PHA-doses at which stimulation of DNA-synthesis declined. For mouse lymphocytes, these doseresponse relationships were less clear-cut, probably due to differences in origin and survival of the effector cells. This confirms previous observations that cytotoxicity and DNA-synthesis are different but probably interdependent expressions of lymphocyte activation.     

A partial characterization of suppressor cells in rat fetal liver cells

Rat fetal liver cells (FLC) obtained at 18–20 days gestation suppressed mixed lymphocyte reactions(MLR) of adult lymph node cells. The suppression was not strain specific: both syngeneic and allogeneic FLC were capable of suppressing the MLR. The same suppressor activity was observed with fetal spleen cells but not with fetal thymus cells. Removal of phagocytic cells from FLC failed to inhibit the suppressor activity. The suppressor cells were separated into two different types by BSA density gradient: one is radiosensitive, the other radioresistant. A stronger suppressor activity was observed in radiosensitive cells. The suppressor cells belonged to the fraction agglutinated with peanut agglutinin. The data suggest that the suppressor cells in rat FLC may be a proliferating blastoid-type cell rather than mature lymphocytes or mature macrophages.     

The differentiation of T lymphocytes. Density characterisation of thymic and peripheral T cells responding in syngeneic and allogenic mixed lymphocyte reactions.

Equilibrium density separation on continuous albumin gradients was used to separate and characterise the T cells responding by proliferation to both syngeneic and allogeneic stimulating cells in the one-way mixed leucocyte reactions (MLR). In CBA mouse spleen both light and dense T cells were capable of responding in an allogeneic MLR. No T cells responding to stimulation be syngeneic B lymphocytes could be isolated from adult or 7-day CBA mouse spleen. In adult CBA mouse thymus, cells responding to allogeneic stimuli were enriched in the light density region, along with the low theta subpopulation. Self-reactive cells, responding with proliferation when cultured with syngeneic adult CBA splenic lymphocytes, and found in adult and 4-day CBA mouse thymus, were also enriched in the light density zones. However, in adult thymus syngeneic MLR reactivity was also found in the dense zones, and the density distribution profiles of total syngeneic MLR responding cells revealed a series of peaks extending over the whole density range. It was suggested that these syngeneic MLR responders undergo a complete maturation process, including progressive density increases, within the thymus gland. Such a sterile differentiation pathway could be a censorship process, leading to death of self-reactive cells within the thymus.     

Induction and amplification of T-lymphocyte proliferative responses to periodate and soybean agglutinin by human adult vascular endothelial cells

Human mononuclear phagocyte (M phi) populations were compared to adult human endothelial cells (HEC) for their respective abilities to influence the proliferative responses of purified human T lymphocytes to the mitogenic agents Na-m-periodate (IO-4), soybean agglutinin (SBA), or allogeneic cells. HEC and M phi were both capable of inducing proliferative responses of allogeneic T lymphocytes in mixed-lymphocyte culture. Under low cell density culture conditions, purified T-lymphocyte proliferative responses to IO-4 or SBA could be restored by addition of syngeneic M phi or HEC. At higher cell density culture conditions, proliferation of T cells to IO-4 could be amplified more by HEC than M phi. T-lymphocyte proliferative responses to SBA were amplified by addition of HEC but were suppressed by addition of M phi. These findings indicate that human adult HEC are unique and potent accessory cells for T lymphocytes. Furthermore, these findings demonstrate that accessory cell functions of HEC can be discriminated from those of M phi.     

Mouse T lymphocytes proliferative responses specific for human MHC products in mouse anti-human xenogeneic MLR

It has been reported that human T cells recognize the polymorphism of murine Ia antigens in the human anti-mouse xenogeneic mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). In this study, murine T cell recognition of human Class II antigens of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) was analyzed in mouse anti-human xenogeneic MLR responses. The xenoreactive murine T cell proliferative response was blocked by adding anti-HLA-DR monoclonal antibody to the xenogeneic MLR culture. The specificity of xenoreactive murine T cells was examined with regard to the secondary and tertiary xenogeneic MLR system. The xenoreactive murine T cells were restimulated by distinct human stimulator cells that had no shared HLA antigens with the stimulator used in the primary MLR. The data presented here show that the murine xenoreactive T cells recognize the shared determinant(s) of HLA-DR antigen on non-T, non-B stimulator cells. The xenoreactive murine T cell proliferative responses were mediated by Thy-1+, Lyt-1+, and Lyt-2- cells. Furthermore, the xenoreactive T cell responses required Ia+ cells, and Ia antigen on accessory cells plays a crucial role in eliciting the xenoreactive responses against human stimulator cells, while Ia+ accessory cells in the responding cell population are not essential for the elicitation of allogeneic MLR responses, as reported previously.     

The in vitro antibody response to cell surface antigens. I. The xenogeneic response to human leukemia cells.

An in vitro spleen fragment culture system has been developed for the production and analysis of xenogeneic antibody responses to cell surface antigens. Depending on the methods of immunization and in vitro stimulation employed, mouse spleen fragments can produce antibody of both IgG and IgM classes directed against human cell surface antigens for more than 30 days in culture. A saturation binding analysis of the antibody products indicates that their range of specificities was more restricted than that of serum antibody. Approximately 5% of the in vitro antibody products raised against a homogeneous population of human leukemia cells could distinguish between the antigens present on the leukemia cells and those present on normal human lymphocytes. Methods previously employed to influence the range of serum antibodies expressed against complex immunogens, such as suppression of certain responses by passive administration of antibody at the time of immunization, were tested in the in vitro spleen culture system and resulted in successful modulation of the antibody response patterns observed.     

Biological characterization of T and B lymphocytes separated from normal mouse spleen by a physical adherence column method

The capacity of spleen cell populations enriched for T and B lymphocytes by a physical adherence column method to respond in vitro to phytomitogens and allogeneic lymphocytes was determined. Column filtrate cells (T lymphocytes) responded well to phytohaemagglutinin- and mitomycin-C-treated allogeneic spleen cells, but poorly to pokeweed mitogen. Adherent cell populations from the column (B and some T lymphocytes) responded well to pokeweed mitogen, but poorly to phytohaemagglutinin- and mitomycin-C-treated allogeneic cells.Purified peripheral T lymphocytes prepared from normal mouse spleen by the column method reconstituted the depleted in vitro antibody response to the thymic-dependent SRBC antigen of all B lymphocyte sources tested, namely, spleen cells from congenitally athymic mice, neonatally thymectomized mice, and adult thymectomized mice which had been reconstituted with bone marrow, and a lymphocyte population prepared by incubating spleen cells with anti-θ serum and complement. When transferred with sheep erythrocytes to congenitally athymic mice, purified peripheral T cells restored the in vivo IgM and IgG responses of these animals. These results confirm that the column filtrate is a thymus derived subpopulation of cells capable of cell-mediated immunity and cooperation with B lymphocytes in humoral immunity both in vitro and in vivo.     

Determination of glutathione in lymphocytes and possible association of redox state and proliferative capacity of lymphocytes.

The glutathione (GSH) content of mouse T- and B-cells was determined and compared with the GSH content of human peripheral blood lymphocytes and human erythrocytes. Owing to the difficulty of obtaining large numbers of purified lymphocytes, a technique was developed to measure picomolar quantities of GSH. By this technique, mouse T- and B-cells, as well as mouse peripheral-blood lymphocytes, were found to contain approx. 30% of the GSH found in human peripheral-blood lymphocytes. The concanavalin A response of human peripheral-blood lymphocytes and human spleen cells was insensitive to 2-mercaptoethanol as well as to culture in 17% O2, whereas mouse lymphocyte responses were altered by 2-mercaptoethanol and inhibited by 17% O2. The capacity of human peripheral-blood lymphocytes, human erythrocytes, mouse T-cells and mouse B-cells to regenerate GSH stores after chemical oxidation by diamide was tested, and it was found that mouse cells were less capable of regenerating GSH than human erythrocytes or human peripheral-blood lymphocytes. In addition, the latter lymphocytes were less sensitive to oxidation of GSH and to inhibition of proliferation by diamide.     

Cellular immune competence in the human fetus

Thymocytes from eight human fetuses of gestational ages 13–28 weeks were studied in mixed lymphocyte cultures. Seven of the eight thymocyte preparations recognized and responded to foreign histocompatibility loci on normal adult peripheral blood lymphocytes. Thymocytes from human fetuses as young as 13 weeks' gestation appear to be capable of initiating this immunologic response. These fetal cells are to be considered immunologically mature and potentially capable of initiating a graft vs host reaction if transplanted into immunoincompetent recipients.     

Spontaneous adherence and rosette formation of lymphocytes to Leydig cells: an in vitro technique

A spontaneous rosette phenomenon occurs in vitro when suspensions of mouse testicular cells are mixed with suspensions of lymphocytes. The core cell of these rosettes are the Leydig cells, and the coronas are formed by lymphocytes. No other testicular cell, either seminal or Sertoli, participates in lymphocyte binding.Autogeneic, syngeneic, allogeneic, and xenogeneic lymphocytes from thymus, spleen, and peripheral blood similarly react with mouse Leydig cells. Lymphocytes from spleens of athymic nude mice and from chicken bursa also give Leydig rosettes. It is suggested that mouse Leydig cells carry membrane receptors spontaneously recognized by lymphocytes.     

Alloantigen-induced T helper activity. I. Minimal genetic differences necessary to induce a positive allogeneic effect.

Addition of histoincompatible lymphocytes can influence the course of ongoing immune responses. Such allogeneic effects may either augment or diminish immune responses. We describe here the minimal genetic differences necessary to generate positive allogeneic effects (allohelp) in a humoral immune response. The antibody response to sheep erythrocytes of T cell-depleted mouse spleen cells was reconstituted by addition of syngeneic or allogeneic nylon wool column-passaged spleen T cells. T cells were pretreated with mitomycin C before culture to prevent development of allo-suppression and cytotoxic lymphocytes. Positive allogeneic effects were operationally defined as superior helper effects (to generate greater antibody forming cell responses) with T cells allogeneic rather than syngeneic to the responding B cells. Thus, addition of allogeneic T cells resulted in many more antibody forming cells than did equal numbers of syngeneic T cells, and fewer allogeneic than syngeneic T cells were necessary to generate comparable responses. With congenic, recombinant, and mutant mouse lines, genetic differences in the H-2 complex and those associated with Mls were each sufficient to provide positive allogeneic effects. With intra-H-2 recombinants, differences at either I or D were sufficient. A disparity at H-2K alone, as provided by the H-2 mutant B6.C-H-2ba against the parental line C57BL/6By, also induced helper effects. The significance of these results is discussed.     

Inhibition of normal mouse lymphocyte mitogen responses by xenogeneic or allogeneic antibodies to the MuLV glycoprotein gp71.

Xenogeneic and allogeneic antisera to the major envelope glycoprotein (gp71) of murine leukemia viruses (NyLV) inhibited the mitogenic response of normal mouse splenic lymphocytes to phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and lipopolysaccharide (LPS). This inhibition was specific for gp71 as demonstrated by the inability of xenogeneic antisera to other viral glycoproteins or structural proteins to inhibit and by the ability of purified antigens to block specifically the inhibitory effect. The ability of antisera to gp71 to inhibit LPS responses, however, is highly dependent on the strain and age of mouse spleen cells used and appears correlated with the expression of endogenous viruses. Moreover, the preferential inhibition of LPS responses suggests that this expression may be predominately B cell specific. The results suggest that the inhibitory effect is mediated via antibody binding to lymphocytes and that expression of viral envelope antigens on the cell surface which bind immunoglobulins can block or interfere with the binding or uptake of mitogens. A variety of natural mouse immune sera and "tumor" sera, having antibodies directed against gp71, can similarly inhibit mitogen responses; and this inhibition can be specifically blocked with MuLV or gp71.     

IL 1 requirement for B cell activation revealed by use of adult serum

Fetal calf serum is an essential component of the culture medium developed by Mishell and Dutton for the immunization of murine spleen cells in vitro. Serum from adult donors (mouse, human, rabbit) does not support antibody synthesis in this system. This "deficiency" of adult serum can be overcome with IL 1. Adult serum in the presence of IL 1 is as effective in stimulating a B cell response against xenogeneic red cells as fetal calf serum. We attribute the capacity of fetal calf serum to support an immune response in the absence of exogenous IL 1 to serum factors that cause macrophages to release IL 1 endogenously. Our findings strengthen the notion that IL 1 plays an essential role in the process of B cell activation and suggests that the use of fetal calf serum should be avoided in studies concerned with the function of interleukin 1.     

Cellular immunity in the mouse. I. In vitro lymphocyte reactivity

The mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) and antigen-mediated proliferative response represent important correlates to the in vivo phenomena of allograft rejection and delayed hypersensitivity. This study defines an in vitro model to measure mouse lymphocyte responsiveness to allogeneic cells, antigen (tuberculoprotein), and nonspecific mitogens. Results describe optimal cells concentration, time and conditions of culture. Optimal conditions include the use of high cell concentration, flat-bottomed vials, RPMI-1640 medium, and fresh human serum. Peripheral blood lymphocytes demonstrated greater proliferation than lymph node lymphocytes, which in turn demonstrated greater activity than splenic lymphocytes. Significant proliferation occurred in serum-free media, dialyzed against fresh serum and supplemented with hydrocortisone and carrier protein. The MLC response in the mouse appears dependent on multiple subpopulations of cells and on soluble substances produced by them.     

Fractionation of lymphocyte subpopulations which regulate mixed lymphocyte reactions.

Four days after injection of allogeneic lymphocytes BALB/c splenic T cells suppress proliferation of syngeneic cells in mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). Conversely, lymph node cells from the same mice amplify MLR responses. To further characterize these functional subpopulations, alloantigen-primed lymphocyte suspensions from both organs were fractionated by velocity sedimentation at unit-gravity. After fractionation MLR suppressor cells from spleens localized exclusively in rapidlly sedimenting fractions of large cells. MLR suppressor activity of cells from these fractions, as well as that of unfractionated spleen cell suspensions, was abolished by treatment with anti-Thy-1.2 serum and complement. Spleen cell fractions of similar sedimentation velocity also secreted a soluble MLR suppressor into culture supernatants. Although inhibitory of MLR, spleen cells of rapid sedimentation velocity did not suppress responses to T cell mitogens. In marked contrast with the effects of spleen cells, large 4-day-alloantigen-primed lymph node cells had no suppressive activity in MLR. MLR amplifier cells of uncertain derivation were found in fractions of medium sedimentation velocity from both spleens and lymph nodes. Fractionation of alloantigen-primed lymph node cell suspensions did reveal, however, a subpopulation of small cells with MLR suppressor acitivty which was unaffected by treatment with anti-Thy-1 serum and complement. The data thus indicate that large alloantigen-activated lymphocytes are not intrinsically suppressive nor are cells which suppress MLR necessarily large. We consequently conclude that regulation of MLR responses by alloantigen-primed lymphocytes involves a complex interaction between distinct functional subpopulations of cells which are separable both by physical and biologic properties.     

The suppressive effect of a supernate from concanavalin A-activated human lymphocytes: effects of concanavalin A-activated lymphocytes and their supernates on cytotoxic and mixed lymphocyte reactions.

The effects of Concanavalin A-treated human peripheral blood lymphocytes and their supernatants were evaluated on the MLC reaction and on the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes assessed by cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). Experiments were performed with both allogeneic and xenogenic sensitization. It was found that Con A-activated cells suppressed the MLC and CML reactions in allogeneic and xenogeneic systems. On the other hand, the SIRS-like supernate was able to suppress the MLC reaction and blastogenesis, but had no suppressive effect on the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes. We found no difference in the magnitude of suppression, whether or not Con A-activated lymphocytes were syngeneic to the responder cells. This finding suggests that there is no requirement for allogeneic restriction in the interaction between suppressor and suppressed cells, and demonstrates a soluble human suppressor substance capable of suppressing some cell-mediated reactions.     

Intracellular localization of anti-tumor immune RNA.

Syngeneic spleen cells from normal, non-immune Fischer 344/N rats and allogeneic spleen cells from normal Wistar-Furth rats became cytotoxic, in vitro, to chemically induced Fischer rat sarcoma (MC3-R) target cells following incubation with xenogeneic Immune RNA (I-RNA) extracted from spleens of guinea pigs immunized with MC3-R tumor cells. I-RNA extracted from intact spleen cells or from the cytoplasmic fraction of spleen cells were equally active. RNA extracted from isolated spleen cell nuclei was inactive, as were all RNA fractions from spleen cells of nonspecifically immunized guinea pigs. Syngeneic I-RNA extracted from intact spleen cells or the cytoplasmic fraction of cells from spleens of Fischer rats bearing growing MC3-R transplants mediated cytotoxic reactions against MC3-R target cells when incubated with normal Fischer rat spleen cells. RNA from the nuclei of spleen cells of rats bearing MC3-R tumors was considerably less active. All RNA fractions from spleen cells of normal non-immune Fischer rats were inactive. The immunologically active component of xenogeneic and Syngeneic I-RNA, therefore, were found to be localized in the cytoplasm of specifically sensitized lymphoid cells.