Structure of a partially unfolded form of Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase provides insight into its folding pathway

Proteins frequently fold via folding intermediates that correspond to local minima on the conformational energy landscape. Probing the structure of the partially unfolded forms in equilibrium under native conditions can provide insight into the properties of folding intermediates. To elucidate the structures of folding intermediates of Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR), we investigated transient partial unfolding of DHFR under native conditions. We probed the structure of a high‐energy conformation susceptible to proteolysis (cleavable form) using native‐state proteolysis. The free energy for unfolding to the cleavable form is clearly less than that for global unfolding. The dependence of the free energy on urea concentration (m‐value) also confirmed that the cleavable form is a partially unfolded form. By assessing the effect of mutations on the stability of the partially unfolded form, we found that native contacts in a hydrophobic cluster formed by the F‐G and Met‐20 loops on one face of the central β‐sheet are mostly lost in the partially unfolded form. Also, the folded region of the partially unfolded form is likely to have some degree of structural heterogeneity. The structure of the partially unfolded form is fully consistent with spectroscopic properties of the near‐native kinetic intermediate observed in previous folding studies of DHFR. The findings suggest that the last step of the folding of DHFR involves organization in the structure of two large loops, the F‐G and Met‐20 loops, which is coupled with compaction of the rest of the protein.     

Protein Vivisection Reveals Elusive Intermediates in Folding

Although most folding intermediates escape detection, their characterization is crucial to the elucidation of folding mechanisms. Here, we outline a powerful strategy to populate partially unfolded intermediates: A buried aliphatic residue is substituted with a charged residue (e.g., Leu → Glu⁻) to destabilize and unfold a specific region of the protein. We applied this strategy to ubiquitin, reversibly trapping a folding intermediate in which the β5-strand is unfolded. The intermediate refolds to a native-like structure upon charge neutralization under mildly acidic conditions. Characterization of the trapped intermediate using NMR and hydrogen exchange methods identifies a second folding intermediate and reveals the order and free energies of the two major folding events on the native side of the rate-limiting step. This general strategy may be combined with other methods and have broad applications in the study of protein folding and other reactions that require trapping of high-energy states.     

Structure of a rapidly formed intermediate in ribonuclease T1 folding.

Kinetic intermediates in protein folding are short-lived and therefore difficult to detect and to characterize. In the folding of polypeptide chains with incorrect isomers of Xaa-Pro peptide bonds the final rate-limiting transition to the native state is slow, since it is coupled to prolyl isomerization. Incorrect prolyl isomers thus act as effective traps for folding intermediates and allow their properties to be studied more easily. We employed this strategy to investigate the mechanism of slow folding of ribonuclease T1. In our experiments we use a mutant form of this protein with a single cis peptide bond at proline 39. During refolding, protein chains with an incorrect trans proline 39 can rapidly form extensive secondary structure. The CD signal in the amide region is regained within the dead-time of stopped-flow mixing (15 ms), indicating a fast formation of the single alpha-helix of ribonuclease T1. This step is correlated with partial formation of a hydrophobic core, because the fluorescence emission maximum of tryptophan 59 is shifted from 349 nm to 325 nm within less than a second. After about 20 s of refolding an intermediate is present that shows about 40% enzymatic activity compared to the completely refolded protein. In addition, the solvent accessibility of tryptophan 59 is drastically reduced in this intermediate and comparable to that of the native state as determined by acrylamide quenching of the tryptophan fluorescence. Activity and quenching measurements have long dead-times and therefore we do not know whether enzymatic activity and solvent accessibility also change in the time range of milliseconds. At this stage of folding at least part of the beta-sheet structure is already present, since it hosts the active site of the enzyme. The trans to cis isomerization of the tyrosine 38-proline 39 peptide bond in the intermediate and consequently the formation of native protein is very slow (tau = 6,500 s at pH 5.0 and 10 degrees C). It is accompanied by an additional increase in tryptophan fluorescence, by the development of the fine structure of the tryptophan emission spectrum, and by the regain of the full enzymatic activity. This indicates that the packing of the hydrophobic core, which involves both tryptophan 59 and proline 39, is optimized in this step. Apparently, refolding polypeptide chains with an incorrect prolyl isomer can very rapidly form partially folded intermediates with native-like properties.     

Structural characterization of partially folded intermediates of apomyoglobin H64F

We present a detailed investigation of unfolded and partially folded states of a mutant apomyoglobin (apoMb) where the distal histidine has been replaced by phenylalanine (H64F). Previous studies have shown that substitution of His64, located in the E helix of the native protein, stabilizes the equilibrium molten globule and native states and leads to an increase in folding rate and a change in the folding pathway. Analysis of changes in chemical shift and in backbone flexibility, detected via [1H]-15N heteronuclear nuclear Overhauser effect measurements, indicates that the phenylalanine substitution has only minor effects on the conformational ensemble in the acid- and urea-unfolded states, but has a substantial effect on the structure, dynamics, and stability of the equilibrium molten globule intermediate formed near pH 4. In H64F apomyoglobin, additional regions of the polypeptide chain are recruited into the compact core of the molten globule. Since the phenylalanine substitution has negligible effect on the unfolded ensemble, its influence on folding rate and stability comes entirely from interactions within the compact folded or partly folded states. Replacement of His64 with Phe leads to favorable hydrophobic packing between the helix E region and the molten globule core and leads to stabilization of helix E secondary structure and overall thermodynamic stabilization of the molten globule. The secondary structure of the equilibrium molten globule parallels that of the burst phase kinetic intermediate; both intermediates contain significant helical structure in regions of the polypeptide that comprise the A, B, E, G, and H helices of the fully folded protein.     

Structure of stable protein folding intermediates by equilibrium phi-analysis: the apoflavodoxin thermal intermediate

Protein intermediates in equilibrium with native states may play important roles in protein dynamics but, in cases, can initiate harmful aggregation events. Investigating equilibrium protein intermediates is thus important for understanding protein behaviour (useful or pernicious) but it is hampered by difficulties in gathering structural information. We show here that the phi-analysis techniques developed to investigate transition states of protein folding can be extended to determine low-resolution three-dimensional structures of protein equilibrium intermediates. The analysis proposed is based solely on equilibrium data and is illustrated by determination of the structure of the apoflavodoxin thermal unfolding intermediate. In this conformation, a large part of the protein remains close to natively folded, but a 40 residue region is clearly unfolded. This structure is fully consistent with the NMR data gathered on an apoflavodoxin mutant designed specifically to stabilise the intermediate. The structure shows that the folded region of the intermediate is much larger than the proton slow-exchange core at 25 degrees C. It also reveals that the unfolded region is made of elements whose packing surface is more polar than average. In addition, it constitutes a useful guide to rationally stabilise the native state relative to the intermediate state, a far from trivial task.     

Exploring subdomain cooperativity in T4 lysozyme II: uncovering the C-terminal subdomain as a hidden intermediate in the kinetic folding pathway

Intermediates along a protein's folding pathway can play an important role in its biology. Previous kinetics studies have revealed an early folding intermediate for T4 lysozyme, a small, well-characterized protein composed of an N-terminal and a C-terminal subdomain. Pulse-labeling hydrogen exchange studies suggest that residues from both subdomains contribute to the structure of this intermediate. On the other hand, equilibrium native state hydrogen experiments have revealed a high-energy, partially unfolded form of the protein that has an unstructured N-terminal subdomain and a structured C-terminal subdomain. To resolve this discrepancy between kinetics and equilibrium data, we performed detailed kinetics analyses of the folding and unfolding pathways of T4 lysozyme, as well as several point mutants and large-scale variants. The data support the argument for the presence of two distinct intermediates, one present on each side of the rate-limiting transition state barrier. The effects of circular permutation and site-specific mutations in the wild-type and circular permutant background, as well as a fragment containing just the C-terminal subdomain, support a model for the unfolding intermediate with an unfolded N-terminal and a folded C-terminal subdomain. Our results suggest that the partially unfolded form identified by native state hydrogen exchange resides on the folded side of the rate-limiting transition state and is, therefore, under most conditions, a "hidden" intermediate.     

Mutational analysis of the BPTI folding pathway: II. Effects of aromatic-->leucine substitutions on folding kinetics and thermodynamics.

The rates of the individual steps in the disulfide-coupled folding and unfolding of eight BPTI variants, each containing a single aromatic to leucine amino acid replacement, were measured. From this analysis, the contributions of the four phenylalanine and four tyrosine residues to the stabilities of the native protein and the disulfide-bonded folding intermediates were determined. While the substitutions were found to destabilize the native protein by 2 to 7 kcal/mol, they had significantly smaller effects on the intermediates that represent the earlier stages of folding, even when the site of the substitution was located within the ordered regions of the intermediates. These results suggest that stabilizing interactions contribute less to conformational stability in the context of a partially folded intermediate than in a fully folded native protein, perhaps because of decreased cooperativity among the individual interactions. The kinetic analysis also provides new information about the transition states associated with the slowest steps in folding and unfolding, supporting previous suggestions that these transition states are extensively unfolded. Although the substitutions caused large changes in the distribution of folding intermediates and in the rates of some steps in the folding pathway, the kinetically-preferred pathway for all of the variants involved intramolecular disulfide rearrangements, as observed previously for the wild-type protein. These results suggest that the predominance of the rearrangement mechanism reflects conformational constraints present relatively early in the folding pathway.     

Kinetically trapped metastable intermediate of a disulfide‐deficient mutant of the starch‐binding domain of glucoamylase

Refolding of a thermally unfolded disulfide‐deficient mutant of the starch‐binding domain of glucoamylase was investigated using differential scanning calorimetry, isothermal titration calorimetry, CD, and ¹H NMR. When the protein solution was rapidly cooled from a higher temperature, a kinetic intermediate was formed during refolding. The intermediate was unexpectedly stable compared with typical folding intermediates that have short half‐lives. It was shown that this intermediate contained substantial secondary structure and tertiary packing and had the same binding ability with β‐cyclodextrin as the native state, suggesting that the intermediate is highly‐ordered and native‐like on the whole. These characteristics differ from those of partially folded intermediates such as molten globule states. Far‐UV CD spectra showed that the secondary structure was once disrupted during the transition from the intermediate to the native state. These results suggest that the intermediate could be an off‐pathway type, possibly a misfolded state, that has to undergo unfolding on its way to the native state.     

Folding/Unfolding Kinetics of Apomyoglobin

The equilibrium and kinetic folding/unfolding of apomyoglobin (ApoMb) were studied at pH 6.2, 11 °C by recording tryptophan fluorescence. The equilibrium unfolding of ApoMb in the presence of urea was shown to involve accumulation of an intermediate state, which had a higher fluorescence intensity as compared with the native and unfolded states. The folding proceeded through two kinetic phases, a rapid transition from the unfolded to the intermediate state and a slow transition from the intermediate to the native state. The accumulation of the kinetic intermediate state was observed in a wide range of urea concentrations. The intermediate was detected even in the region corresponding to the unfolding limb of the chevron plot. Urea concentration dependence was obtained for the observed folding/unfolding rate. The shape of the dependence was compared with that of two-state proteins characterized by a direct transition from the unfolded to the native state.     

The folding pathway of barnase: the rate-limiting transition state and a hidden intermediate under native conditions

The nature of the rate-limiting transition state at zero denaturant (TS(1)) and whether there are hidden intermediates are the two major unsolved problems in defining the folding pathway of barnase. In earlier studies, it was shown that TS(1) has small phi values throughout the structure of the protein, suggesting that the transition state has either a defined partially folded secondary structure with all side chains significantly exposed or numerous different partially unfolded structures with similar stability. To distinguish the two possibilities, we studied the effect of Gly mutations on the folding rate of barnase to investigate the secondary structure formation in the transition state. Two mutations in the same region of a beta-strand decreased the folding rate by 20- and 50-fold, respectively, suggesting that the secondary structures in this region are dominantly formed in the rate-limiting transition state. We also performed native-state hydrogen exchange experiments on barnase at pD 5.0 and 25 degrees C and identified a partially unfolded state. The structure of the intermediate was investigated using protein engineering and NMR. The results suggest that the intermediate has an omega loop unfolded. This intermediate is more folded than the rate-limiting transition state previously characterized at high denaturant concentrations (TS(2)). Therefore, it exists after TS(2) in folding. Consistent with this conclusion, the intermediate folds with the same rate and denaturant dependence as the wild-type protein, but unfolds faster with less dependence on the denaturant concentration. These and other results in the literature suggest that barnase folds through partially unfolded intermediates that exist after the rate-limiting step. Such folding behavior is similar to those of cytochrome c and Rd-apocyt b(562). Together, we suggest that other small apparently two-state proteins may also fold through hidden intermediates.     

Selective stabilization of a partially unfolded protein by a metabolite

When proteins fold in vivo, the intermediates that exist transiently on their folding pathways are exposed to the potential interactions with a plethora of metabolites within the cell. However, these potential interactions are commonly ignored. Here, we report a case in which a ubiquitous metabolite interacts selectively with a nonnative conformation of a protein and facilitates protein folding and unfolding process. From our previous proteomics study, we have discovered that Escherichia coli glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH), which is not known to bind ATP under native conditions, is apparently destabilized in the presence of a physiological concentration of ATP. To decipher the origin of this surprising effect, we investigated the thermodynamics and kinetics of folding and unfolding of GAPDH in the presence of ATP. Equilibrium unfolding of the protein in urea showed that a partially unfolded equilibrium intermediate accumulates in the presence of ATP. This intermediate has a quaternary structure distinct from the native protein. Also, ATP significantly accelerates the unfolding of GAPDH by selectively stabilizing a transition state that is distinct from the native state of the protein. Moreover, ATP also significantly accelerates the folding of GAPDH. These results demonstrate that ATP interacts specifically with a partially unfolded form of GAPDH and affects the kinetics of folding and unfolding of this protein. This unusual effect of ATP on the folding of GAPDH implies that endogenous metabolites may facilitate protein folding in vivo by interacting with partially unfolded intermediates.     

Role of unfolded state heterogeneity and en-route ruggedness in protein folding kinetics

In order to improve our understanding of the physical bases of protein folding, there is a compelling need for better connections between experimental and computational approaches. This work addresses the role of unfolded state conformational heterogeneity and en-route intermediates, as an aid for planning and interpreting protein folding experiments. The expected kinetics were modeled for different types of energy landscapes, including multiple parallel folding routes, preferential paths dominated by one primary folding route, and distributed paths with a wide spectrum of microscopic folding rate constants. In the presence of one or more preferential routes, conformational exchange among unfolded state populations slows down the observed rates for native protein formation. We find this to be a general phenomenon, taking place even when unfolded conformations interconvert much faster than the "escape" rate constants to folding. Dramatic kinetic deceleration is expected in the presence of an increasing number of folding-incompetent unfolded conformations. This argues for the existence of parallel folding paths involving several folding-competent unfolded conformations, during the early stages of protein folding. Deviations from single-exponential behavior are observed for unfolded conformations exchanging at comparable rates or more slowly than folding events. Analysis of the effect of en-route (on-path) intermediate formation and landscape ruggedness on folding kinetics leads to the following unexpected conclusions: (1) intermediates, which often retard native state formation, may in some cases accelerate folding, and (2) rugged landscapes, usually associated with stretched exponentials, display single-exponential behavior in the presence of late high-friction paths.     

Molecular basis of cooperativity in protein folding IV. Core: A general cooperative folding model

The cooperative nature of the protein folding process is independent of the characteristic fold and the specific secondary structure attributes of a globular protein. A general folding/unfolding model should, therefore, be based upon structural features that transcend the peculiarities of α-helices, β-sheets, and other structural motifs found in proteins. The studies presented in this paper suggest that a single structural characteristic common to all globular proteins is essential for cooperative folding. The formation of a partly folded state from the native state results in the exposure to solvent of two distinct regions: (1) the portions of the protein that are unfolded; and (2) the “complementary surfaces,” located in the regions of the protein that remain folded. The cooperative character of the folding/unfolding transition is determined largely by the energetics of exposing complementary surface regions to the solvent. By definition, complementary regions are present only in partly folded states; they are absent from the native and unfolded states. An unfavorable free energy lowers the probability of partly folded states and increases the cooperativity of the transition. In this paper we present a mathematical formulation of this behavior and develop a general cooperative folding/unfolding model, termed the “complementary region” (CORE) model. This model successfully reproduces the main properties of folding/unfolding transitions without limiting the number of partly folded states accessible to the protein, thereby permitting a systematic examination of the structural and solvent conditions under which intermediates become populated. It is shown that the CORE model predicts two-state folding/unfolding behavior, even though the two-state character is not assumed in the model. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Effects of the difference in the unfolded-state ensemble on the folding of Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase

The unfolded state of a protein is an ensemble of a large number of conformations ranging from fully extended to compact structures. To investigate the effects of the difference in the unfolded-state ensemble on protein folding, we have studied the structure, stability, and folding of "circular" dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) from Escherichia coli in which the N and C-terminal regions are cross-linked by a disulfide bond, and compared the results with those of disulfide-reduced "linear" DHFR. Equilibrium studies by circular dichroism, difference absorption spectra, solution X-ray scattering, and size-exclusion chromatography show that whereas the native structures of both proteins are essentially the same, the unfolded state of circular DHFR adopts more compact conformations than the unfolded state of the linear form, even with the absence of secondary structure. Circular DHFR is more stable than linear DHFR, which may be due to the decrease in the conformational entropy of the unfolded state as a result of circularization. Kinetic refolding measurements by stopped-flow circular dichroism and fluorescence show that under the native conditions both proteins accumulate a burst-phase intermediate having the same structures and both fold by the same complex folding mechanism with the same folding rates. Thus, the effects of the difference in the unfolded state of circular and linear DHFRs on the refolding reaction are not observed after the formation of the intermediate. This suggests that for the proteins with close termini in the native structure, early compaction of a protein molecule to form a specific folding intermediate with the N and C-terminal regions in close proximity is a crucial event in folding. If there is an enhancement in the folding reflecting the reduction in the breadth of the unfolded-state ensemble for circular DHFR, this acceleration must occur in the sub-millisecond time-range.     

The group II chaperonin Mm-Cpn binds and refolds human γD crystallin

Chaperonins assist in the folding of nascent and misfolded proteins, though the mechanism of folding within the lumen of the chaperonin remains poorly understood. The archeal chaperonin from Methanococcus marapaludis, Mm-Cpn, shares the eightfold double barrel structure with other group II chaperonins, including the eukaryotic TRiC/CCT, required for actin and tubulin folding. However, Mm-Cpn is composed of a single species subunit, similar to group I chaperonin GroEL, rather than the eight subunit species needed for TRiC/CCT. Features of the β-sheet fold have been identified as sites of recognition by group II chaperonins. The crystallins, the major components of the vertebrate eye lens, are β-sheet proteins with two homologous Greek key domains. During refolding in vitro a partially folded intermediate is populated, and partitions between productive folding and off-pathway aggregation. We report here that in the presence of physiological concentrations of ATP, Mm-Cpn suppressed the aggregation of HγD-Crys by binding the partially folded intermediate. The complex was sufficiently stable to permit recovery by size exclusion chromatography. In the presence of ATP, Mm-Cpn promoted the refolding of the HγD-Crys intermediates to the native state. The ability of Mm-Cpn to bind and refold a human β-sheet protein suggests that Mm-Cpn may be useful as a simplified model for the substrate recognition mechanism of TRiC/CCT.     

Hydrophobic core variant ubiquitin forms a molten globule conformation at acidic pH

The conformational properties of hydrophobic core variant ubiquitin (Val26 to Ala mutation) in an acidic solution were studied. The intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence emission spectrum, far-UV and near-UV circular dichroic spectra, the fluorescence emission spectrum of 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid in the presence of V26A ubiquitin, and urea-induced unfolding measurements indicate this variant ubiquitin to be in the partially folded molten globule conformation in solution at pH 2. The folding kinetics from molten globule to the native state was nearly identical to those from the unfolded state to the native state. This observation suggests that the equilibrium molten globule state of hydrophobic core variant ubiquitin is an on-pathway folding intermediate.     

Protein misfolding: optional barriers, misfolded intermediates, and pathway heterogeneity

To investigate the character and role of misfolded intermediates in protein folding, a recombinant cytochrome c without the normally blocking histidine to heme misligation was studied. Folding remains heterogeneous as in the wild-type protein. Half of the population folds relatively rapidly to the native state in a two-state manner. The other half collapses (fluorescence quenching) and forms a full complement of helix (CD) with the same rate and denaturant dependence as the fast folding fraction but then is blocked and reaches the native structure (695nm absorbance) much more slowly. The factors that transiently block folding are not intrinsic to the folding process but depend on ambient conditions, including protein aggregation (f(concentration)), N terminus to heme misligation (f(pH)), and proline mis-isomerization (f(U state equilibration time)). The misfolded intermediate populated by the slowly folding fraction was characterized by hydrogen exchange pulse labeling. It is very advanced with all of the native-like elements fairly stably formed but not the final Met80-S to heme iron ligation, similar to a previously studied molten globule form induced by low pH. To complete final native state acquisition, some small back unfolding is required (error repair) but the misfolded intermediate does not revisit the U state before proceeding to N. These properties show that the intermediate is a normal on-pathway form that contains, in addition, adventitious misfolding errors that transiently block its forward progress. Related observations for other proteins (partially misfolded intermediates, pathway heterogeneity) might be similarly explained in terms of the optional insertion of error-dependent barriers into a classical folding pathway.     

Detection of a hidden folding intermediate of the third domain of PDZ

The folding pathway of the third domain of PDZ from the synaptic protein PSD-95 was characterized using kinetic and equilibrium methods by monitoring the fluorescence signal from a Trp residue that is incorporated at a near-surface position. Kinetic folding of this domain showed multiple exponential phases, whereas unfolding showed a single exponential phase. The slow kinetic phases were attributed to isomerization of proline residues, since there are five proline residues in this domain. We found that the logarithms of the rate constants for the fast phase of folding and unfolding are linearly dependent on the concentrations of denaturant. The unfolding free energy derived from these rate constants at zero denaturant was close to the value measured using the equilibrium method, suggesting the absence of detectable sub-millisecond folding intermediates. However, native-state hydrogen exchange experiments detected a partially unfolded intermediate under native conditions. It was further confirmed by a protein engineering study. These data suggest that a hidden intermediate exists after the rate-limiting step in the folding of the third domain of PDZ.     

Kinetic folding and unfolding of staphylococcal nuclease and its six mutants studied by stopped-flow circular dichroism

Kinetics of refolding and unfolding of staphylococcal nuclease and its six mutants, each carrying single or double amino acid substitutions, are studied by stopped-flow circular dichroism measurements. A transient kinetic intermediate formed within 10 ms after refolding starts possesses a substantial part of the N-domain core β-structure, whereas helices are formed at the later stages. The structure of the kinetic intermediate is less organized than the structure that is known to be formed by a nuclease 1-136 fragment. Only the refolding kinetics are affected by the mutations in all the mutants except two in which the mutations have changed the native structure. From this result and also from the locations of the mutation sites, the major N-terminal domain of the nuclease in the transition state of folding has a structure nearly identical to the native one. On the other hand, the minor C-terminal domain has previously been shown to be still disorganized in the transition state. The effects of the amino acid substitutions on the stability of the native and the transition states are in good agreement with the changes in the hydration free energy, expected for the corresponding amino acid replacements in the unfolded polypeptide. Since side chains of all the mutated residues are not accessible to solvent in the native structure, the result suggests that it is the unfolded state that is mainly affected by the mutations. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The high-resolution NMR structure of the early folding intermediate of the Thermus thermophilus ribonuclease H

Elucidation of the high-resolution structures of folding intermediates is a necessary but difficult step toward the ultimate understanding of the mechanism of protein folding. Here, using hydrogen-exchange-directed protein engineering, we populated the folding intermediate of the Thermus thermophilus ribonuclease H, which forms before the rate-limiting transition state, by removing the unfolded regions of the intermediate, including an α-helix and two β-strands (51 folded residues). Using multidimensional NMR, we solved the structure of this intermediate mimic to an atomic resolution (backbone rmsd, 0.51 Å). It has a native-like backbone topology and shows some local deviations from the native structure, revealing that the structure of the folded region of an early folding intermediate can be as well defined as the native structure. The topological parameters calculated from the structures of the intermediate mimic and the native state predict that the intermediate should fold on a millisecond time scale or less and form much faster than the native state. Other factors that may lead to the slow folding of the native state and the accumulation of the intermediate before the rate-limiting transition state are also discussed.