A comparison of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) with the toxin neutralization test in mice as a method for the estimation of tetanus antitoxin in human sera

An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) has been developed for the measurement of tetanus antitoxin in human sera as an alternative to the toxin neutralization test in mice, the currently accepted method of assay. The ELISA was found to be simple and quick to perform and required only small amounts of materials. In addition, the assay was found to give reproducible estimates of antitoxin levels and to measure antitoxin at levels as low as 0.01 IU per ml, a sensitivity similar to that of the neutralization test. Furthermore, a comparison of the results of the ELISA and the neutralization test involving 80 human sera, including sera with both high and low antitoxin levels, showed close agreement in antitoxin levels obtained by the two methods. It was concluded that ELISA was an acceptable alternative to the toxin neutralization test in mice for the measurement of tetanus antitoxin levels in human sera.     

The titration of tetanus antitoxin IV. Studies on the sensitivity and reproducibility of the toxin neutralization test

The quality of tetanus toxin affected the sensitivity of the toxin neutralization (TN) test greatly. By using purified toxin a minimum level of 0.001 IU/ml of tetanus antitoxin could be detected whereas with crude toxin a level of 0.025 IU/ml only could be detected. The TN test described in this report permitted titration of tetanus antitoxin in twofold dilution steps from levels as low as 0.001 IU/ml using 0.6 ml of serum only at the L+/5000 level of purified tetanus toxin. Treatment of the sera with 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME) did not affect the TN titres showing that the TN test detects the neutralizing antibodies (IgG) which are not affected by 2-ME. The TN test was found to be a highly sensitive and reproducible test.     

New equine antitoxins to botulinum neurotoxins serotypes A and B

Hyperimmune monovalent antitoxins to botulinum neurotoxin serotypes A and B have been produced by immunizing horses with newly developed formalin toxoids. After primary immunization, horses developed acceptable prophylactic antibody titers (1-5 IU/mL). Three horses received additional toxoid booster injections to induce hyperimmune antibody titers with antitoxin-A and antitoxin-B titers reaching peaks of approximately 2000 IU/mL and 150-625 IU/mL, respectively. Titers were quantified throughout the process by antigen-capture ELISA and by in-vivo neutralization. ELISA titers and neutralization titers correlated (R2 ～0.62-0.92), however, unique correlations between in-vitro and in-vivo titers were observed for each horse. Monovalent antitoxin pools were made by combining plasma that had been collected twice via plasmaphoresis several months after primary immunization. Neutralizing units were established for each pool relative to the current US and WHO reference standards. Titers were determined at the L(+)/10 and L(+)/40 toxin dose for Toxin types A and B, respectively, and U.S. and international units were assigned to each monovalent antitoxin. Avidity of the new Anti-A pool was equivalent to the WHO Anti-A reference at the L(+), L(+)/10 and L(+)/30 dose. Each monovalent plasma pool failed to cross-neutralize other botulinum neurotoxin serotypes indicating a high degree of specificity of each antitoxin for the toxin serotype used during immunization.     

Titration of tetanus antitoxin by passive hemagglutination. I. Titration of guinea-pig antitoxins at various periods of immunization.

An improved technique for passive hemagglutination (HA) for titration of tetanus antitoxin was described. The use of highly purified tetanus toxoid and of improved diluent increased the specificity and reproducibility of the test. Several hundreds of specimens of guinea-pig serum taken at various stages of immunization were titrated by HA and toxin neutralization (NT) in mice. The ratio of HA to NT titers varied significantly depending on the immunization stage; higher at early stages and lower at later stages. The high HA/NT ratio was not due to the IgM antitoxin, which is very rare in guinea pigs. The variation in discrepancy between HA and NT titers decreased considerably by grouping the serum specimens with respect to the stage of immunization. Thus, it is possible to predict the in vivo titer of a tetanus antitoxin accurately enough for clinical study. The HA test may be useful as an alternative method for titrating tetanus antitoxin in the field trials. Moreover, it can be used for the study of characteristics of antitoxins.     

In vitro tests for the measurement of clostridial toxins, toxoids and antisera. II. Titration of Clostridium perfringens toxins and antitoxins in cell culture

The usefulness of cytopathic indicators for the titration of Cl perfringens beta and epsilon toxins has been investigated. Neutralization experiments with monoclonal antibodies have shown that the entities responsible for the lethal and dermonecrotic effects of Cl perfringens beta toxin preparations are identical. However, the cytopathic effects of the same preparations are caused by other entities. Therefore, titrations based upon lethal and dermonecrotic indicators of beta toxin are equally valid but those based on cytopathic effects are not. Similar experiments with Cl perfringens epsilon preparations have shown that their lethal, dermonecrotic and cytopathic activities are all caused by the same entity. It follows that all three activities can be valid indicators for toxin neutralization tests. Cell culture titrations of Cl perfringens epsilon antitoxin performed on rabbit sera at the levels of test prescribed by the European Pharmacopoeia have produced consistent results which agree closely with the dermonecrotic test. This test has, in turn, been shown to reflect the results of the mouse lethal test accurately. Titrations of cattle and sheep sera at lower levels of test have also produced results in close agreement with the in vivo test. It is concluded that cell culture titration offers a valid in vitro alternative to the use of mouse lethal and guinea-pig dermonecrotic indicators for the titration of sera generated in the course of potency tests and field trials of Cl perfringens epsilon vaccines.     

ELISA for the routine determination of antitoxic immunity to tetanus

Serum samples from 727 persons with different vaccination histories were assessed for tetanus antitoxin content in an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and tested for tetanus toxin neutralization activity in mice in order to compare the results obtained by the two methods. Neutralizing antibody activities in sera from individuals previously completely vaccinated correlated well with results obtained by ELISA and the accuracy increased with increasing antitoxin concentration in serum. This correlation was observed in sera from persons vaccinated recently as well as in sera from persons vaccinated many years ago. In sera from persons with an incomplete vaccination history ELISA was found to be an unreliable tool for the prediction of in vivo results. Many of these sera had antitoxin levels by ELISA far above the in vivo values, probably due to the presence of non specific or low avidity antitoxin which is detected in ELISA. The lowest ELISA value reliably predictive of protective antibody activity in serum irrespective of vaccination history was found to be 0.16 IU/ml. It was concluded that ELISA is useful for larger population studies as an initial test, but sera with an antitoxin content below 0.16 IU/ml should also be assessed in a neutralization system.     

An alternative to the toxin neutralization assay in mice for the potency testing of the Clostridium tetani, Clostridium septicum, Clostridium novyi Type B and Clostridium perfringens Type D epsilon components of multivalent sheep vaccines

Potency testing of veterinary vaccines containing clostridial antigens currently requires the vaccination of laboratory rabbits followed by the determination of specific antitoxin concentration in the rabbit sera by toxin neutralization test in mice. ELISAs are described as an alternative method to toxin neutralization for the determination of Clostridium tetani, Clostridium septicum, Clostridium novyi Type B and Clostridium perfringens Type D epsilon antitoxins. The assays were found to be rapid, specific and economical and showed good correlation with the toxin neutralization test.     

Quantitation of commercial equine tetanus antitoxin by competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay

In the USA, the potency of commercially prepared equine tetanus antitoxin is determined by the method outlined in the Code of Federal Regulations, Title 9, Part 113.451. In the current test, commercial equine tetanus antitoxin is tested by a toxin neutralization test in guinea pigs. The in vivo test measures antitoxin content through effectiveness of protection of guinea pigs injected with diluted mixtures of antitoxin and a standard toxin. A competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, designed as an in vitro alternative to the in vivo test, measures antitoxin content based on a competitive reaction between standard or unknown serum and murine monoclonal antibody specific for tetanus toxin. The monoclonal antibody used in the assay delayed death in mouse passive protection studies and reacted with the C fragment of tetanus toxin. No cross-reaction was observed when the antibody was tested with the toxins of Clostridium chauvoei, C. novyi, C. perfringens, or C. sordellii. The in vitro test will measure the antitoxin content of serum samples containing 100-1500 units of antitoxin. Tetanus antitoxin titers obtained by the competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay compared favorably with the toxin neutralization test conducted in guinea pigs. The in vitro assay serves as a feasible alternative to the in vivo test because it can be completed in less time, is reproducible, and eliminates the use of test animals.     

A novel strategy for development of recombinant antitoxin therapeutics tested in a mouse botulism model

Antitoxins are needed that can be produced economically with improved safety and shelf life compared to conventional antisera-based therapeutics. Here we report a practical strategy for development of simple antitoxin therapeutics with substantial advantages over currently available treatments. The therapeutic strategy employs a single recombinant 'targeting agent' that binds a toxin at two unique sites and a 'clearing Ab' that binds two epitopes present on each targeting agent. Co-administration of the targeting agent and the clearing Ab results in decoration of the toxin with up to four Abs to promote accelerated clearance. The therapeutic strategy was applied to two Botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) serotypes and protected mice from lethality in two different intoxication models with an efficacy equivalent to conventional antitoxin serum. Targeting agents were a single recombinant protein consisting of a heterodimer of two camelid anti-BoNT heavy-chain-only Ab V(H) (VHH) binding domains and two E-tag epitopes. The clearing mAb was an anti-E-tag mAb. By comparing the in vivo efficacy of treatments that employed neutralizing vs. non-neutralizing agents or the presence vs. absence of clearing Ab permitted unprecedented insight into the roles of toxin neutralization and clearance in antitoxin efficacy. Surprisingly, when a post-intoxication treatment model was used, a toxin-neutralizing heterodimer agent fully protected mice from intoxication even in the absence of clearing Ab. Thus a single, easy-to-produce recombinant protein was as efficacious as polyclonal antiserum in a clinically-relevant mouse model of botulism. This strategy should have widespread application in antitoxin development and other therapies in which neutralization and/or accelerated clearance of a serum biomolecule can offer therapeutic benefit.     

The use of the in vitro toxin binding inhibition (ToBI) test for the estimation of the potency of tetanus toxoid

The in vitro toxin binding inhibition (ToBI) test was used to determine antitoxin responses in mice immunized with tetanus toxoid. The ToBI test showed good correlation with the in vivo toxin neutralization (TN) test in titration of sera of mice immunized with various doses of DPT-Polio, DT-Polio and a tetanus reference preparation. Estimates of potency of tetanus toxoid obtained in mice by ToBI test correlated significantly with those obtained in mice by the lethal challenge test. In addition, potency values of the European reference preparation, succeedingly estimated by ToBI test and lethal challenge test in a single group of guinea-pigs, showed good correlation. From the study it is concluded that the ToBI test is a promising alternative to the toxic challenge procedure in the potency assay of tetanus toxoid vaccines. A substantial refinement and reduction in the use of animals can be achieved. Additional savings can be made by combining diphtheria and tetanus potency testing.     

Combined estimation of tetanus and diphtheria antitoxin in human sera by the in vitro Toxin-Binding Inhibition (ToBI) test

The use of the principle of inhibition of toxin binding to an antitoxin coated immunoassay plate as described in a previous paper for tetanus antitoxin titration, was adapted for the estimation of diphtheria antitoxin in human sera. With a few modifications, a Toxin-Binding Inhibition (ToBI) test was developed which could be used for a combined estimation of both tetanus and diphtheria antitoxin levels. The application of streptavidin-biotinylated peroxidase complex when using small serum samples (less than 50 microliters) is discussed. Antitoxin titres (both diphtheria and tetanus) of 0.002 IU ml-1 were detectable by the ToBI test, this being far below the level considered to be protective in man. Sera from 140 adults with different vaccination histories were titrated for both tetanus and diphtheria antitoxin. Good correlations were found between the estimates obtained by the ToBI test and those obtained by the toxin-neutralization (TN) test in mice (tetanus antitoxin) and those obtained in the in vitro neutralization test in VERO cells (diphtheria antitoxin). It is concluded that the ToBI test is a simple and reliable alternative to the functional models currently in use for the estimation of diphtheria and tetanus antitoxin levels. In addition, the ToBI test eliminates the need for laboratory-animal or cell-culture facilities and can be performed with small quantities of serum as required in field trials.     

In vitro tests for the measurement of veterinary clostridial toxins, toxoids and antisera. I. Titration of Clostridium septicum toxins and antitoxins in cell culture

The assay of Clostridium septicum antitoxin currently requires the inoculation of test mixtures intravenously into mice or intradermally into guinea-pig skin. An alternative indicator system based on the use of cell cultures is described. Evidence is presented to show that the toxins detected by the in vivo and in vitro indicators are indistinguishable in terms of molecular weight, charge and hydrophobicity and that there is a close agreement between the two methods of titration. Cell culture indicators are more sensitive than their in vivo counterparts, permitting detection of substantially lower titres than is possible using in vivo indicators. It is suggested that cell culture indicators may prove useful for the titration of Cl septicum antitoxin in sera from vaccine field trials and potency tests. Cell culture methods could also be used for the potency testing of antitoxin preparations.     

Problems encountered with the capillary tube immunodiffusion method for detection of botulinal toxin.

By using antitoxin specific for the neurotoxin molecule, the capillary tube immunodiffusion method did not detect low levels of crystalline toxin. Reactions described earlier with crude toxin and less specific antitoxin were probably due to nontoxigenic botulinal antigens.     

Problems encountered with the capillary tube immunodiffusion method for detection of botulinal toxin

By using antitoxin specific for the neurotoxin molecule, the capillary tube immunodiffusion method did not detect low levels of crystalline toxin. Reactions described earlier with crude toxin and less specific antitoxin were probably due to nontoxigenic botulinal antigens.     

The reduction of animal usage by the application of indirect haemagglutination in the potency testing of diphtheria toxoid in combined vaccines

Eight Adsorbed Diphtheria-Tetanus vaccines and 13 Diphtheria-Tetanus-Pertussis vaccines made by four different manufacturers were tested for the potency of the diphtheria components in guinea-pigs by the method of British Pharmacopoeia (1973). Two-hundred-and-ten guinea-pig sera consisting of ten sera related to each vaccine sample thus obtained were titrated for diphtheria antitoxin by indirect haemagglutination (IHA) and the conventional toxin neutralization (TN) tests. Statistical analysis of the results showed a good correlation between the titres obtained with the two tests. The potencies of the diphtheria components of various vaccines calculated from the antitoxin content of the respective guinea-pig sera titrated by the IHA test correlated significantly with the potencies obtained from the antitoxin content titrated by the routinely used TN test. The use of IHA in place of the TN test thus offers as an alternative that permits a reduction in animal usage.     

The titration of tetanus antitoxin III. A comparative evaluation of indirect haemagglutination and toxin neutralization titres of human sera

The tetanus antitoxin titres of 174 serum samples from healthy adults were determined by a standardization indirect haemagglutination test (IHA) and the conventional toxin neutralization (TN) test. The serum samples were titrated by the IHA test using glutaraldehyde-fixed and toxoid sensitized sheep erythrocytes before and after the treatment of the sera with 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME). The IHA method has been found to be very sensitive and specific for the estimation of tetanus antitoxin in human sera. The IHA titres before the treatment of the sera with 2-ME were generally about four times higher than the TN titres and the correlation coefficient between these titres was 0.94. The IHA titres after the treatment of the sera with 2-ME were in good agreement with the TN titres and there was no statistically significant differences between the titres by the two methods. The tetanus antitoxin titres of 50% of the sera were below the minimum protective titres of tetanus antitoxin (0.01 IU/ml). In 19.5% of the sera the antitoxin level (IU/ml) ranged from 0.01 to 0.1, in 20.1% from 0.1 to 1.0 and in 10.4% from 1.0 to 10.0.     

Development and preclinical evaluation of a new F(ab′)2 antitoxin against botulinum neurotoxin serotype A

Concern about the malicious applications of botulinum neurotoxin has highlighted the need for a new generation of safe and highly potent antitoxins. In this study, we developed and evaluated the preclinical pharmacology and safety of a new F(ab′)₂ antitoxin against botulinum neurotoxin serotype A (BoNT/A). As an alternative to formalin-inactivated toxoid, the recombinant Hc domain of botulinum neurotoxin serotype A (rAHc) was used to immunize horses, and the IgGs from the hyperimmune sera were digested to obtain F(ab′)₂ antitoxin. The protective effect of the new F(ab′)₂ antitoxin against BoNT/A was determined both in vitro and in vivo. The results showed that the F(ab′)₂ antitoxin could prevent botulism in mice challenged with BoNT/A and effectively delayed progression of paralysis from botulism in the therapeutic setting. The preclinical safety of the new F(ab′)₂ antitoxin was also evaluated, and it showed neither harmful effects on vital functions nor adverse effects such as acute toxicity, or immunological reactions in mice and dogs. Thus, our results provide valuable experimental data for this new antitoxin as a potential candidate for treatment of botulism caused by BoNT/A, and our findings support the safety of the new F(ab′)₂ antitoxin for clinical use. Our study further demonstrates the proof of concept for development of a similar strategy for obtaining potent antitoxin against other BoNT serotypes.     

Use of the toxin-binding inhibition test for estimation of tetanus antitoxin in serum

The usefulness of the toxin binding inhibition test (ToBI) for the titration of tetanus antibody in human sera was assessed. Sera from 80 healthy people with different vaccination histories that had been previously tested by the in vivo toxin neutralization (TN) test were retested by the ToBI test. The lowest tetanus antibody titre which could be detected by using 0.1 Lf/ml tetanus toxin was 0.01 IU/ml. Comparison between the estimates obtained by the ToBI test and those obtained by the TN test (r = 0.93 and r = 0.7 for titration low titre sera) showed good correlation. No overestimation of antibody content was seen in titrating low titre sera by the ToBI test. It is concluded that the ToBI-test is a reliable alternative to toxin neutralization test in mice.     

A comparison of the indirect haemagglutination test with the toxin neutralization test for the estimation of diphtheria antitoxin in mouse sera

Serum samples from 42 groups of mice immunized for different immunization periods with various doses of Adsorbed Diphtheria-Tetanus Vaccine, Adsorbed Diphtheria-Tetanus and Pertussis Vaccine and a standard diphtheria toxoid were assayed for their diphtheria antitoxin content by indirect haemagglutination (IHA) and by toxin neutralization (TN) tests. A very good correlation of 0.91 was obtained between the results of the two methods. There was no statistically significant difference between the IHA and the TN titres obtained. Adsorption with sheep red cells and treatment of the sera with 2-mercaptoethanol had no effect on the IHA titres. The minimum level of antitoxin detectable by the IHA test was 0.00039 IU ml-1. IHA proved to be a sensitive, specific and reproducible method which can be used reliably for the assay of diphtheria antitoxin in mouse sera.     

应用Vero细胞检定法和家兔皮内中和法检测吸附白喉类毒素的效价

Ｖｅｒｏ细胞法测定ＤＴＰ疫苗中白喉类毒素的效价与家兔皮内中和法（简称ＮＴ法）所得结果两法之间有一种平行关系,并且有很好的相关性,ｒ＝０．９３。但Ｖｅｒｏ细胞法测得平均值低于ＮＴ法,二者之间的平均比率为０．２８７,Ｓ＝０．０８９。本试验结果与１９９５部颁规程ＮＴ法０．２５ＩＵ／ｍｌ相比,确定了Ｖｅｒｏ细胞法以０．０７ＩＵ／ｍｌ作为检定吸附ＤＴＰ效价的最低要求。