An integrated quantification method to increase the precision,robustness, and resolution of protein measurement in human plasma samples

Background

Current quantification methods for mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics either do not provide sufficient control of variability or are difficult to implement for routine clinical testing.

Results

We present here an integrated quantification (InteQuan) method that better controls pre-analytical and analytical variability than the popular quantification method using stable isotope-labeled standard peptides (SISQuan). We quantified 16 lung cancer biomarker candidates in human plasma samples in three assessment studies, using immunoaffinity depletion coupled with multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) MS. InteQuan outperformed SISQuan in precision in all three studies and tolerated a two-fold difference in sample loading. The three studies lasted over six months and encountered major changes in experimental settings. Nevertheless, plasma proteins in low ng/ml to low μg/ml concentrations were measured with a median technical coefficient of variation (CV) of 11.9% using InteQuan. The corresponding median CV using SISQuan was 15.3% after linear fitting. Furthermore, InteQuan surpassed SISQuan in measuring biological difference among clinical samples and in distinguishing benign versus cancer plasma samples.

Conclusions

We demonstrated that InteQuan is a simple yet robust quantification method for MS-based quantitative proteomics, especially for applications in biomarker research and in routine clinical testing.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/1559-0275-12-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Enhanced recovery of lyophilized peptides in shotgun proteomics by using an LC‐ESI‐MS compatible surfactant

LC‐ESI/MS/MS‐based shotgun proteomics is currently the most commonly used approach for the identification and quantification of proteins in large‐scale studies of biomarker discovery. In the past several years, the shotgun proteomics technologies have been refined toward further enhancement of proteome coverage. In the complex series of protocols involved in shotgun proteomics, however, loss of proteolytic peptides during the lyophilization step prior to the LC/MS/MS injection has been relatively neglected despite the fact that the dissolution of the hydrophobic peptides in lyophilized samples is difficult in 0.05–0.1% TFA or formic acid, causing substantial loss of precious peptide samples. In order to prevent the loss of peptide samples during this step, we devised a new protocol using Invitrosol (IVS), a commercially available surfactant compatible with ESI‐MS; by dissolving the lyophilized peptides in IVS, we show improved recovery of hydrophobic peptides, leading to enhanced coverage of proteome. Thus, the use of IVS in the recovery step of lyophilized peptides will help the shotgun proteomics analysis by expanding the proteome coverage, which would significantly promote the discovery and development of new diagnostic markers and therapeutic targets.     

Advances in proteomic prostate cancer biomarker discovery

Prostate cancer is the most common non-cutaneous cancer in men in the United States. For reasons largely unknown, the incidence of prostate cancer has increased in the last two decades, in spite or perhaps because of a concomitant increase in serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) screening. While PSA is acknowledged not to be an ideal biomarker for prostate cancer detection, it is however widely used by physicians due to lack of an alternative. Thus, the identification of a biomarker(s) that can complement or replace PSA represents a major goal for prostate cancer research. Screening complex biological specimens such as blood, urine, and tissue to identify protein biomarkers has become increasingly popular over the last decade thanks to advances in proteomic discovery methods. The completion of human genome sequence together with new development in mass spectrometry instrumentation and bioinformatics has been a major driving force in biomarker discovery research. Here we review the current state of proteomic applications as applied to various sample sources including blood, urine, tissue, and “secretome” for the purpose of prostate cancer biomarker discovery. Additionally, we review recent developments in validation of putative markers, efforts at systems biology approach, and current challenges of proteomics in biomarker discovery.     

Advances and challenges in liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry-based proteomics profiling for clinical applications

Recent advances in proteomics technologies provide tremendous opportunities for biomarker-related clinical applications; however, the distinctive characteristics of human biofluids such as the high dynamic range in protein abundances and extreme complexity of the proteomes present tremendous challenges. In this review we summarize recent advances in LC-MS-based proteomics profiling and its applications in clinical proteomics as well as discuss the major challenges associated with implementing these technologies for more effective candidate biomarker discovery. Developments in immunoaffinity depletion and various fractionation approaches in combination with substantial improvements in LC-MS platforms have enabled the plasma proteome to be profiled with considerably greater dynamic range of coverage, allowing many proteins at low ng/ml levels to be confidently identified. Despite these significant advances and efforts, major challenges associated with the dynamic range of measurements and extent of proteome coverage, confidence of peptide/protein identifications, quantitation accuracy, analysis throughput, and the robustness of present instrumentation must be addressed before a proteomics profiling platform suitable for efficient clinical applications can be routinely implemented.     

Advances in quantitative proteomics

Large-scale protein quantification has become a major proteomics application in many areas of biological and medical research. During the past years, different techniques have been developed, including gel-based such as differential in-gel electrophoresis (DIGE) and liquid chromatography-based such as isotope labeling and label-free quantification. These quantitative proteomics tools hold significant promise for biomarker discovery, diagnostic and therapeutic applications. They are also important for research in functional genomics and systems biology towards basic understanding of molecular networks and pathway interactions. In this review, we summarize current technologies in quantitative proteomics and discuss recent applications of the technologies.     

Human body fluid proteome analysis

The focus of this article is to review the recent advances in proteome analysis of human body fluids, including plasma/serum, urine, cerebrospinal fluid, saliva, bronchoalveolar lavage fluid, synovial fluid, nipple aspirate fluid, tear fluid, and amniotic fluid, as well as its applications to human disease biomarker discovery. We aim to summarize the proteomics technologies currently used for global identification and quantification of body fluid proteins, and elaborate the putative biomarkers discovered for a variety of human diseases through human body fluid proteome (HBFP) analysis. Some critical concerns and perspectives in this emerging field are also discussed. With the advances made in proteomics technologies, the impact of HBFP analysis in the search for clinically relevant disease biomarkers would be realized in the future.     

Current progress in protein profiling of complex samples

Accurate cancer biomarkers are needed for early detection, disease classification, prediction of therapeutic response and monitoring treatment. While there appears to be no shortage of candidate biomarker proteins, a major bottleneck in the biomarker pipeline continues to be their verification by enzyme linked immunosorbent assays. Multiple reaction monitoring (MRM), also known as selected reaction monitoring, is a targeted mass spectrometry approach to protein quantitation and is emerging to bridge the gap between biomarker discovery and clinical validation. Highly multiplexed MRM assays are readily configured and enable simultaneous verification of large numbers of candidates facilitating the development of biomarker panels which can increase specificity. This review focuses on recent applications of MRM to the analysis of plasma and serum from cancer patients for biomarker verification. The current status of this approach is discussed along with future directions for targeted mass spectrometry in clinical biomarker validation.     

Discovery of regulatory molecular events and biomarkers using 2D capillary chromatography and mass spectrometry

An important component of proteomic research is the high-throughput discovery of novel proteins and protein–protein interactions that control molecular events that contribute to critical cellular functions and human disease. The interactions of proteins are essential for cellular functions. Identifying perturbation of normal cellular protein interactions is vital for understanding the disease process and intervening to control the disease. A second area of proteomics research is the discovery of proteins that will serve as biomarkers for the early detection, diagnosis and drug treatment response for specific diseases. These studies have been referred to as clinical proteomics. To discover biomarkers, proteomics research employs the quantitative comparison of peptide and protein expression in body fluids and tissues from diseased individuals (case) versus normal individuals (control). Methods that couple 2D capillary liquid chromatography (LC) and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) analysis have greatly facilitated this discovery science. Coupling 2D-LC/MS/MS analysis with automated genome-assisted spectra interpretation allows a direct, high-throughput and high-sensitivity identification of thousands of individual proteins from complex biological samples. The systematic comparison of experimental conditions and controls allows protein function or disease states to be modeled. This review discusses the different purification and quantification strategies that have been developed and used in combination with 2D-LC/MS/MS and computational analysis to examine regulatory protein networks and clinical samples.     

Optimizing Size Exclusion Chromatography for Extracellular Vesicle Enrichment and Proteomic Analysis from Clinically Relevant Samples

The field of extracellular vesicle (EV) research has rapidly expanded in recent years, with particular interest in their potential as circulating biomarkers. Proteomic analysis of EVs from clinical samples is complicated by the low abundance of EV proteins relative to highly abundant circulating proteins such as albumin and apolipoproteins. To overcome this, size exclusion chromatography (SEC) has been proposed as a method to enrich EVs whilst depleting protein contaminants; however, the optimal SEC parameters for EV proteomics have not been thoroughly investigated. Here, quantitative evaluation and optimization of SEC are reported for separating EVs from contaminating proteins. Using a synthetic model system followed by cell line‐derived EVs, it is found that a 10 mL Sepharose 4B column in PBS produces optimal resolution of EVs from background protein. By spiking‐in cancer cell‐derived EVs to healthy plasma, it is shown that some cancer EV‐associated proteins are detectable by nano‐LC‐MS/MS when as little as 1% of the total plasma EV number are derived from a cancer cell line. These results suggest that an optimized SEC and nanoLC‐MS/MS workflow may be sufficiently sensitive for disease EV protein biomarker discovery from patient‐derived clinical samples.     

Intact protein profiling in breast cancer biomarker discovery: Protein identification issue and the solutions based on 3D protein separation,bottom‐up and top‐down mass spectrometry

Proteomics profiling of intact proteins based on MALDI‐TOF MS and derived platforms has been used in cancer biomarker discovery studies. This approach suffers from a number of limitations such as low resolution, low sensitivity, and that no knowledge is available on the identity of the respective proteins in the discovery mode. Nevertheless, it remains the most high‐throughput, untargeted mode of clinical proteomics studies to date. Here we compare key protein separation and MS techniques available for protein biomarker identification in this type of studies and define reasons of uncertainty in protein peak identity. As a result of critical data analysis, we consider 3D protein separation and identification workflows as optimal procedures. Subsequently, we present a new protocol based on 3D LC‐MS/MS with top‐down at high resolution that enabled the identification of HNRNP A2/B1 intact peptide as correlating with the estrogen receptor expression in breast cancer tissues. Additional development of this general concept toward next generation, top‐down based protein profiling at high resolution is discussed.     

Urinary proteomics: towards biomarker discovery, diagnostics and prognostics

During recent years, the proteomics field has moved onward to clinical applications, particularly for biomarker discovery, diagnostics and prognostics of human diseases. The urine is one of the ideal clinical samples for such applications because it is readily available in almost all patients, and its collection is very simple and non-invasive. Urinary proteomics thus becomes one of the most interesting subdisciplines in the clinical proteomics area. This article highlights and updates recent progress in the urinary proteomics field for clinical applications.     

Highly multiplexed targeted proteomics using precise control of peptide retention time

Large-scale proteomics applications using SRM analysis on triple quadrupole mass spectrometers present new challenges to LC-MS/MS experimental design. Despite the automation of building large-scale LC-SRM methods, the increased numbers of targeted peptides can compromise the balance between sensitivity and selectivity. To facilitate large target numbers, time-scheduled SRM transition acquisition is performed. Previously published results have demonstrated incorporation of a well-characterized set of synthetic peptides enabled chromatographic characterization of the elution profile for most endogenous peptides. We have extended this application of peptide trainer kits to not only build SRM methods but to facilitate real-time elution profile characterization that enables automated adjustment of the scheduled detection windows. Incorporation of dynamic retention time adjustments better facilitate targeted assays lasting several days without the need for constant supervision. This paper provides an overview of how the dynamic retention correction approach identifies and corrects for commonly observed LC variations. This adjustment dramatically improves robustness in targeted discovery experiments as well as routine quantification experiments.     

The Plasma Proteome: High Abundance versus Low Abundance

The field of proteomics is rapidly turning towards targeted mass spectrometry (MS) methods to quantify putative markers or known proteins of biological interest. Historically, the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) has been used for targeted protein analysis, but, unfortunately, it is limited by the excessive time required for antibody preparation, as well as concerns over selectivity. Despite the ability of proteomics to deliver increasingly quantitative measurements, owing to limited sensitivity, the leads generated are in the microgram per milliliter range. This stands in stark contrast to ELISA, which is capable of quantifying proteins at low picogram per milliliter levels. To bridge this gap, targeted liquid chromatography (LC) tandem MS (MS/MS) analysis of tryptic peptide surrogates using selected reaction monitoring detection has emerged as a viable option for rapid quantification of target proteins. The precision of this approach has been enhanced by the use of stable isotope-labeled peptide internal standards to compensate for variation in recovery and the influence of differential matrix effects. Unfortunately, the complexity of proteinaceous matrices, such as plasma, limits the usefulness of this approach to quantification in the mid-nanogram per milliliter range (medium-abundance proteins). This article reviews the current status of LC/MS/MS using selected reaction monitoring for protein quantification, and specifically considers the use of a single antibody to achieve superior enrichment of either the protein target or the released tryptic peptide. Examples of immunoaffinity-assisted LC/MS/MS are reviewed that demonstrate quantitative analysis of low-abundance proteins (subnanogram per milliliter range). A strategy based on this technology is proposed for the expedited evaluation of novel protein biomarkers, which relies on the synergy created from the complementary nature of MS and ELISA.     

The cancer cell secretome: A good source for discovering biomarkers?

Cancer is a leading cause of death. Early detection is usually associated with better clinical outcomes. Recent advances in genomics and proteomics raised hopes that new biomarkers for diagnosis, prognosis or monitoring therapeutic response will soon be discovered. Proteins secreted by cancer cells, referred also as “the cancer cell secretome”, is a promising source for biomarker discovery. In this review we will summarize recent advances in cancer cell secretome analysis, focusing on the five most fatal cancers (lung, breast, prostate, colorectal, and pancreatic). For each cancer type we will describe the proteomic approaches utilized for the identification of novel biomarkers. Despite progress, identification of markers that are superior to those currently used has proven to be a difficult task and very few, if any, newly discovered biomarker has entered the clinic the last 10 years.     

Targeted Proteomics for Studying Pathogenic Bacteria

Mass spectrometry‐based proteomics has been extensively used to map bacterial proteomes, which has led to a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying bacterial infection and bacteria–host interactions. Quantitative proteomics using selected or parallel reaction monitoring is considered one of the most sensitive and specific quantitative MS‐based approaches and has significantly advanced proteome studies of pathogenic bacteria. Here, recent applications of targeted proteomics for bacteria identification, biomarker discovery, and the characterization of bacterial virulence and antimicrobial resistance are reviewed among others. Results of such studies are expected to further contribute to improve the fight against the most common human pathogenic bacteria.     

Recent findings from the human proteome project: opening the mass spectrometry toolbox to advance cancer diagnosis,surveillance and treatment

The Human Proteome Project stands to eclipse the Human Genome Project in terms of scope, content and interpretation. Its outputs, in conjunction with recent developments across the proteomics community, provide new tools for cancer research with the potential of providing clinically relevant insights into the disease. These collectively may guide the development of future diagnosis, surveillance and treatment strategies. Having established a robust organizational framework within the international community, the Human Proteome Organization and the proteomics community at large have made significant advances in biomarker discovery, detection, molecular imaging and in exploring tumor heterogeneity. Here, the authors discuss some developments in cancer proteomics and how they can be implemented to reduce the global burden of the disease.     

Discovery of regulatory molecular events and biomarkers using 2D capillary chromatography and mass spectrometry

An important component of proteomic research is the high-throughput discovery of novel proteins and protein-protein interactions that control molecular events that contribute to critical cellular functions and human disease. The interactions of proteins are essential for cellular functions. Identifying perturbation of normal cellular protein interactions is vital for understanding the disease process and intervening to control the disease. A second area of proteomics research is the discovery of proteins that will serve as biomarkers for the early detection, diagnosis and drug treatment response for specific diseases. These studies have been referred to as clinical proteomics. To discover biomarkers, proteomics research employs the quantitative comparison of peptide and protein expression in body fluids and tissues from diseased individuals (case) versus normal individuals (control). Methods that couple 2D capillary liquid chromatography (LC) and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) analysis have greatly facilitated this discovery science. Coupling 2D-LC/MS/MS analysis with automated genome-assisted spectra interpretation allows a direct, high-throughput and high-sensitivity identification of thousands of individual proteins from complex biological samples. The systematic comparison of experimental conditions and controls allows protein function or disease states to be modeled. This review discusses the different purification and quantification strategies that have been developed and used in combination with 2D-LC/MS/MS and computational analysis to examine regulatory protein networks and clinical samples.     

Targeted proteomics on its way to discovery

For a long time, targeted and discovery proteomics covered different corners of the detection spectrum, with targeted proteomics focused on small target sets. This changed with the recent advances in highly multiplexed analysis. While discovery proteomics still pushes higher numbers of identified and quantified proteins, the advances in targeted proteomics rose to cover large parts of less complex proteomes or proteomes with low protein detection counts due to dynamic range restrictions, like the blood proteome. These new developments will impact, especially on the field of biomarker discovery and the possibility of using targeted proteomics for diagnostic purposes.