Re-evaluation of phytohormone-independent division of tobacco protoplast-derived cells

We have used a [³H] thymidine incorporation assay and microscopic observation in order to reassess recently published data dealing with the response of tobacco protoplasts to phytohormones, lipochitooligosaccharides and peptides ( Harling et al . 1997 ; Hayashi et al . 1992 ; Miklashevichs et al . 1996 ; Miklashevichs et al . 1997 ; Röhrig et al . 1995 ; Röhrig et al . 1996 ; van de Sande et al . 1996 ; Walden et al . 1994 ). These proliferation assays reveal that, in contrast to published data, isolated cells of the investigated mutant plant lines axi159 ( Hayashi et al . 1992 ; Walden et al . 1994 ), axi4/1 ( Harling et al . 1997 ) and cyi1 ( Miklashevichs et al . 1997 ), which were generated by activation T-DNA tagging, were unable to grow in the absence of auxin or cytokinin. Furthermore, lipochitooligosaccharides which play a key role in the induction of nodules on roots of legumes were unable to promote auxin- or cytokinin-independent cell division in tobacco protoplasts as claimed by Röhrig et al . (1995 , 1996 ). The finding of van de Sande et al . (1996 ) that ENOD40 confers tolerance of high auxin concentration to wild-type tobacco protoplasts was also reinvestigated. The results of our investigations show that we were unable to reproduce the proliferation data presented in this study, which were obtained by counting tobacco protoplast-derived cells undergoing division. In total, none of the published data on phytohormone-independent division of tobacco cells could be reproduced.     

Rol genes alter hormonal requirements for protoplast growth and modify the expression of an auxin responsive promoter

Summary Growth characteristics of tobacco protoplasts containing rolA linked to its own promoter, or the rolB, or rolC genes of Agrobacterium rhizogenes linked to the Cauliflower Mosaic Virus 35S RNA promoter were compared with those from untransformed plants. RolA protoplasts require auxin and cytokinin for callus formation. Protoplasts overexpressing rolB and C form callus in the absence of exogenously applied auxin and cytokinin, respectively. Long term callus growth requires auxin, but the requirement for cytokinin is not critical. Optimal transient expression of an auxin responsive promoter element occurred at lower external levels of auxin in rolB and rolC protoplasts compared with untransformed protoplasts. Addition of putrescine was required for auxin responsive transient gene expression in rolA protoplasts suggesting that polyamines, or their products affect gene expression in rolA plants.Abbreviations T-DNA transferred DNA - TL-DNA left transferred DNA - NAA naphthalene acetic acid - PEG polyethylene glycol - GUS glucuronidase - CaMV cauliflower mosaic virus     

Activation tagging: a means of isolating genes implicated as playing a role in plant growth and development

Activation T-DNA tagging has been used to generate a variety of tobacco cell lines selected by their ability to grow either in the absence of auxin or cytokinin in the culture media, or under selective levels of an inhibitor of polyamine biosynthesis. The majority of the cell lines studied in detail contain single T-DNA inserts genetically co-segregating with the selected phenotype. While most of the plants regenerated from the mutant cell lines appear phenotypically normal, several display phenotypes which could be inferred to result from disturbances in the content, or the metabolism, of auxins and cytokinins, or polyamines. The tagging vector is designed to allow the isolation of tagged plant genes by plasmid rescue. Confirmation that the genomic sequence responsible for the selected phenotype has indeed isolated is provided by PEG-mediated protoplast DNA uptake of rescued plasmids followed by selection for protoplast growth under the original selective conditions. Several plasmids have been rescued from the mutant lines which confer on transfected protoplasts the ability to grow either in the absence of auxin or cytokinin in the culture media, or under selective levels of an inhibitor of polyamine biosynthesis. This review describes the background to activation tagging and our progress in characterizing the genes that have been tagged in the mutant lines we have generated.     

Single rol Genes from the Agrobacterium rhizogenes T(L)-DNA Alter Some of the Cellular Responses to Auxin in Nicotiana tabacum

Two kinds of cellular responses to auxin, the hyperpolarization of protoplasts and the division of protoplast-derived cells, were compared in Nicotiana tabacum plants transformed by different T-DNA fragments of Agrobacterium rhizogenes strain A4. Using transmembrane potential difference measurements to characterize hormonal sensitivity of mesophyll protoplasts, we found a 30-fold increase in sensitivity to auxin in protoplasts transformed by the whole Ri A4 T-DNA. Furthermore, the rol genes of the Ri A4 T_L-DNA, together or as single genes, were able to increase the sensitivity to auxin by factors up to 10⁴. The different effects of the single rol genes on the sensitivity of mesophyll protoplasts to auxin, rolB being the most powerful, were consistent with their respective rhizogenic effects on leaf fragments (A Spena, T Schmülling, C Koncz, J Schell [1987] EMBO J 6: 3891-3899). No difference was seen concerning the effects of auxin on division of cells derived from normal or transformed protoplasts. These results suggest that only some cellular responses to auxin could be selectively altered by rol genes. They also show that rol-transformed tobaccos can be a model system to study auxin action in plants.     

Alterations of auxin perception in rolB-transformed tobacco protoplasts. Time course of rolB mRNA expression and increase in auxin sensitivity reveal multiple control by auxin.

Expression and physiological effects of the root-inducing rolB gene of Agrobacterium rhizogenes T-DNA were studied simultaneously in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) mesophyll protoplasts. The kinetic study of the expression of rolB mRNA following exogenous auxin application showed that auxin transiently stimulated rolB expression, with mRNA levels starting to accumulate 6 to 9 h after auxin was supplied and increasing 300-fold after 12 to 18 h. The parallel study of the auxin sensitivity of rolB-transformed protoplasts, as assayed by their electrical response to the hormone, showed that the auxin treatment generated an increase in sensitivity by a factor of up to 100,000, whereas in untransformed protoplasts the same auxin treatment induced an increase in auxin sensitivity that never exceeded 30- to 50-fold. This reflects a strong cooperative effect of auxin and rolB in transformed protoplasts. Surprisingly, the maximal increase in sensitivity was observed several hours before the maximal accumulation of rolB mRNA, suggesting that the dramatic control of auxin sensitivity by auxin in rolB-transformed protoplasts requires only low levels of rolB expression. Antibodies directed against ZmER-abp1, the major auxin-binding protein from maize, differentially altered the auxin sensitivity of the electrical response of rolB-transformed and normal protoplasts. This suggests that alterations of the auxin reception-transduction pathway at the plasma membrane of rolB-transformed protoplasts may account for their increased auxin sensitivity.     

Transformed cell clones as a tool to study T-DNA integration mediated by Agrobacterium tumefaciens

A large number of tobacco SR1 cell clones transformed by the wild-type Agrobacterium C58 have been analysed for the presence of screenable markers such as tumour morphology, opine synthesis and hormone dependence. Distinct phenotypic classes were observed depending upon whether the cell clones were isolated from primary tumours or were obtained via cocultivation of protoplasts. These classes of tobacco SR1-C58 transformants appear to arise from errors in the Ti plasmid (T-DNA) transfer and integration mechanism itself rather than from subsequent T-DNA rearrangements, since 900 subclones, obtained by recloning a wild-type SR1-C58-transformed cell clone, yielded no variation in the phenotypes. A detailed genomic T-DNA analysis showed the presence of characteristic, abnormally short T-DNAs in the teratoma-forming, Acs- class and also in the Nos- class. The abnormal right border in two Nos- clones ends close to a sequence that resembles the normal T-DNA terminus and lies adjacent to the nos promoter, suggesting that this sequence could have functioned as a recognition site directing these particular T-DNA transfers. On the basis of the phenotypic and genomic blotting data it is clear that the short T-DNAs are characteristic of the cocultivation method. Other phenomena causing phenotypic variation, such as the loss of the T-DNA, and the gradual repression of T-DNA gene expression by methylation, are the main causes of aberrations in primary tumours. Moreover, the physical data suggest that early in the transformation cycle of Agrobacterium a replication step of a preselected T-DNA occurs before integration into the plant genome.     

T-DNA gene 5 of Agrobacterium modulates auxin response by autoregulated synthesis of a growth hormone antagonist in plants.

Oncogenes carried by the transferred DNA (T-DNA) of Agrobacterium Ti plasmids encode the synthesis of plant growth factors, auxin and cytokinin, and induce tumour development in plants. Other T-DNA genes regulate the tumorous growth in ways that are not yet understood. To determine the function of T-DNA gene 5, its coding region was expressed in Escherichia coli. Synthesis of the gene 5 encoded protein (26 kDa) correlated with a 28-fold increase in conversion of tryptophan to indole-3-lactate (ILA), an auxin analogue. Expression of chimeric gene 5 constructs in transgenic tobacco resulted in overproduction of ILA that enhanced shoot formation in undifferentiated tissues and increased the tolerance of germinating seedlings to the inhibitory effect of externally supplied auxin. Promoter analysis of gene 5 in plants revealed that its expression was inducible by auxin and confined to the vascular phloem cells. cis-regulatory elements required for auxin regulation and phloem specific expression of gene 5 were mapped to a 90 bp promoter region that carried DNA sequence motifs common to several auxin induced plant promoters, as well as a binding site for a nuclear factor, Ax-1. ILA was found to inhibit the auxin induction of the gene 5 promoter and to compete with indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) for in vitro binding to purified cellular auxin binding proteins. It is suggested therefore that ILA autoregulates its own synthesis and thereby modulates a number of auxin responses in plants.     

The rolB Gene of Agrobacterium rhizogenes Does Not Increase the Auxin Sensitivity of Tobacco Protoplasts by Modifying the Intracellular Auxin Concentration

Phenotypical alterations observed in rolB-transformed plants have been proposed to result from a rise in intracellular free auxin due to a RolB-catalyzed hydrolysis of auxin conjugates(J.J. Estruch, J. Schell, A. Spena [1991] EMBO J 10: 3125-3128).We have investigated this hypothesis in detail using tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) mesophyll protoplasts isolated from plants transformed with the rolB gene under the control of its own promoter (BBGUS 6 clone) or the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter (CaMVBT 3 clone). Protoplasts expressing rolB showed an increased sensitivity to the auxin-induced hyperpolarization of the plasma membrane when triggered with exogenous auxin. Because this phenotypical trait was homogeneously displayed over the entire population, protoplasts were judged to be a more reliable test system than the tissue fragments used in previous studies to monitor rolB gene effects on cellular auxin levels. Accumulation of free 1-[3H]-naphthaleneacetic acid (NAA) was equivalent in CaMVBT 3, BBGUS 6, and wild-type protoplasts, Naphthyl-[beta]-glucose ester, the major NAA metabolite in protoplasts, reached similar levels in CaMVBT 3 protoplasts, reached similar levels in CaMVBT 3 and normal protoplasts and was hydrolyzed at the same rate in BBGUS 6 and normal protoplasts. Furthermore, NAA accumulation and metabolism in BBGUS 6 protoplasts were independent of the rolB gene expression level. Essentially similar results were obtained with indoleacetic acid. Thus, it was concluded that the rolB-dependent behavior of transgenic tobacco protoplasts is not a consequence of modifying the intracellular auxin concentration but likely results from changes in the auxin perception pathway.     

Mechanisms of crown gall formation: T-DNA transfer fromAgrobacterium tumefaciens to plant cells

Agrobacterium tumefaciens harbouring the Ti plasmid incites crown gall tumor on dicotyledonous species. Upon infection of these plants, T-DNA in the Ti plasmid is transferred by unknown mechanisms to plant cells to be integrated into nuclear DNA. WhenAgrobacterium is incubated with protoplasts or seedlings of dicotyledonous plants, circulation of T-DNA and expression ofvir (virulence) genes on the Ti plasmid are induced. The circularization event is efficiently induced by mesophyll protoplasts of tobacco which are highly competent for transformation by the T-DNA, and is also induced by diffusible phenolic compounds excreted from the protoplasts. The circularization and formation of crown gall both require the expression of thevirD locus, one of the induciblevir genes. These results suggest that the circularization of T-DNA reflects one of steps of the T-DNA transfer during formation of crown gall. In contrast to dicotyledonous plants, monocotyledonous plants are thought to be unresponsive to infection byAgrobacterium. We showed that monocotyledonous plants do not excrete diffusible inducers for the expression ofvir genes, while they contain a novel type of a signal substance(s). This inducer is not detected in the exudates of seedlings of monocotyledonous plants, but is found in the extracts from the seedlings, and also those from the seeds, bran and germ of wheat and oats. This finding suggests that T-DNA processing, and possibly its transfer, should take place whenAgrobacterium invades seedlings and seeds of monocotyledonous plants. Recipient of the Botanical Society Award for Young Scientists, 1987.     

Gain of function assays identify non- rol genes from Agrobacterium rhizogenes TL-DNA that alter plant morphogenesis or hormone sensitivity

This study tested the morphogenetic potential of 15 open reading frames of the TL-DNA of Agrobacterium rhizogenes strain HRI. These open reading frames were expressed individually under the control of the 35S RNA promoter in transgenic tobacco plants ( Nicotiana tabacum L.). Expression of three T-DNA loci, ORF3n, ORF8 and ORF13, alters plant morphogenesis or the response of transgenic tissues to plant hormones. ORF3n transgenic plants are characterized by retarded flowering, altered internode elongation, altered leaf shape and, in particular, leaf tip necrosis. ORF3n and ORF8 expression reduces the sensitivity to auxin and cytokinin in combination or auxin alone. Tetracycline-dependent expression of ORF13 overcomes a selection of low levels of expression during plant regeneration and reveals a strong inhibitory effect of the ORF13 gene product on cell division and cell elongation. We conclude that the A. rhizogenes TL-DNA harbors genetic information that is important for pathogenicity apart from the well studied rol genes. We propose that these genes play mainly a negative regulatory role during pathogenesis. Moreover, these loci might be relevant to successful infections in specific host plants.     

Isolation and Characterization of a Cytokinin Up-Regulated Gene from Tobacco Mesophyll Protoplasts

We have isolated a cytokinin up-regulated cDNA clone, H13, froman early stage of cultured tobacco mesophyll protoplasts bya differential display method. The expression of this gene wasspecifically induced by natural and synthetic cytokinins includingN-(2-chloro-4-pyridyl)-N'-phenylurea (4PU30), a diphenylurea-typecytokinin, although the simultaneous presence of auxin was alsorequired. It seems that the preceding treatment of the tobaccomesophyll protoplasts by auxin is necessary for the gene torespond to cytokinin. The addition of a cytokinin antagonist,compound 182, which suppressed the induction of cell divisionin tobacco mesophyll protoplasts, completely abolished the expressionof this gene. Though the predicted gene product of H13 did notsuggest us any sequences of defined functions, two domains ofthe predicted sequence had significant homology to several reportedsequences in the data base. The gene product of H13 is proposedto have a role in regenerating cell wall in cultured protoplasts,since a cDNA clone E6, from cotton fiber cells, which has themost closely related structure to H13, has been isolated fromcells which showed active cellulose synthesis. This suppositionis supported by the evidence that in the absence of cytokinin,cell wall regeneration was significantly suppressed, resultingin failure of the induction of cell division. Thus, the geneproduct of H13 is supposed to have a role in regenerating cellwalls and facilitating the progression of the cell cycle, resultingin the sustained cell division of tobacco mesophyll protoplasts. ¹These authors are equally contributed to this work.     

Activation of glyoxalase I during the cell division cycle and its homology with auxin regulated genes

In several plant systems increase in glyoxalase I activity has been correlated with cell proliferation. Cell cycle studies of tobacco protoplasts indicate a rise in glyoxalase I activity prior to G₂/M phase. Further, synthetic auxin, NAA, induced glyoxalase I activity and cell division significantly. This induction was specific in response to auxin only. Cytokinins alone do not induce cell division or increase enzyme activity. Analysis of glyoxalase I cDNA sequence from soybean shows significant homology with auxin inducible genes particularly Nt107 and limited but strong similarity with identified plant mitotic cyclins, implicating glyoxalase I in possible relationship with certain cell division regulating factors.     

Perception of the auxin signal at the plasma membrane of tobacco mesophyll protoplasts

Auxin-induced variations of transmembrane potential difference have been shown to be a useful tool for analyzing hormone sensitivity in tobacco protoplasts. Using this technique, we demonstrated that protoplasts derived from wild-type, an auxin-resistant mutant and Agrobacterium-rhizogenes transformed plants differed widely in the sensitivity of their electrical response to naphthalene acetic acid. We have used different antibodies, raised to auxin binding proteins (ABP) from maize coleoptiles, or to the axr1 gene product (ABP1), to test whether changes in auxin sensitivity can be correlated with the presence of tobacco proteins immunologically related to this ABP. Titrations indicated that 0.4 nM anti-ABP IgG inhibited 50% of the auxin-specific response of wild-type protoplasts, whereas 0.04 nM or 4 nM anti-ABP IgG were necessary to inhibit the response of mutant and transformed protoplasts, respectively, to the same extent. On wild-type protoplasts, blocking part of the immunoreactive sites with anti-ABP antibodies resulted in a decrease in auxin sensitivity of the electrical response (0.4 nM anti-ABP IgG inducing a 10–fold decrease), whereas addition of maize ABP increased this auxin sensitivity (1 pM ABP1 raised the sensitivity more than 1000–fold). The results obtained suggest that the auxin sensitivity detected by our assay system correlates with the amount of tobacco proteins immunologically related to the axr¹ gene product from maize. A hypothesis accounting for the presence of these proteins at the external surface of tobacco protoplasts and for the effects of hetero-logous maize ABP on auxin sensitivity is proposed.     

MEI1, an Arabidopsis gene required for male meiosis: isolation and characterization

 The T-DNA tagged mutant gene of Arabidopsis thaliana, mei1, produces after meiosis an abnormal tetrad, consisting of five to eight microspores of varying sizes and DNA contents. Plant DNA flanking the inserted T-DNA was isolated by inverse PCR. An approximately 16-kb DNA fragment spanning the T-DNA insertion site was isolated by screening a wild-type genomic library, using the plant flanking DNA as a probe. Using RT-PCR and RNA isolated from very young flower buds, a cDNA fragment was obtained. Nucleotide sequence comparison of the cDNA and the genomic sequence in this region indicated a gene which contained two introns. The 5′ and 3′ splice sites of neither intron comply with the :GU...AG: rule. In the mutant, the T-DNA had inserted into one of the introns. The deduced sequence of the MEI1 wild-type gene, which contains 89 amino acids, shows possible similarity with the human acrosin-trypsin inhibitor, HUSI-II, and is about the same size. Two wild-type DNA fragments, both extending over the T-DNA insertion site, were introduced into mutant plants by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation and plants were selected for both hygromycin and kanamycin resistance. Several independent male-fertile transformants were obtained with one of the DNA fragments. The fragment showing complementation of the mutant phenotype indicated that the sequence with similarity to the acrosin-trypsin inhibitor is MEI1. Within the 16-kb genomic fragment two other genes were identified; one showed no overall similarity to any protein sequence in the database and the other had almost complete identity with an Arabidopsis-transcribed sequence tag with similarity to ACC oxidase. Double mutants between mei1 and qrt1 were made, permitting better characterization of the mei1 phenotype because the individual microspores continued to be held together after callose dissolution. Received: 21 April 1998 / Revision accepted: 11 June 1998