Pseudodeficiency of arylsulfatase A: a common genetic polymorphism with possible disease implications

Summary The distribution and frequency of aphidicolin-induced common fragile sites were studied in chromosomes of cultured skin fibroblasts and PHA-stimulated lymphocytes from five normal individuals; 0.2 M aphidicolin was added for the last 26 h of culture. Skin fibroblasts from five fra(X)-positive patients were also studied in the same manner. Fragile sites most frequently found in fibroblasts from normal individuals were 3q26.2, 7q11.23, 16q23, 1p31, 10q11.2, 12q23 and 7q31, whereas those in lymphocytes from the same individuals were 3p14, 16q23, Xp22, 7q32 and 14q24. The distribution of fragile sites in fibroblasts from fra(X)-positive patients was essentially identical with that in normal individuals. The average number of gaps and breaks in 100 metaphases was 36.8 in fibroblasts from normal individuals, 113.8 in those from fra(X)-positive patients, and 279 in lymphocytes from normal individuals. Their rates of chromosome-type breaks and gaps were 7.9%, 29.7% and 54.5%, respectively. Thus, the distribution and frequency of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites were different between skin fibroblasts and lymphocytes, possibly reflecting differences in their DNA replication sequence or gene activity.     

Sister chromatid exchanges are preferentially induced at expressed and nonexpressed common fragile sites

Summary To investigate the relationship between common fragile sites and sister chromatid exchange (SCE), lymphocyte cultures were treated with aphidicolin and bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) and analyzed using a sequential GSCE staining protocol. A total of 1163 SCEs were mapped to their corresponding G-band sites, which were assigned to one of the following four categories: fragile sites expressed; fragile sites nonexpressed; nonfragile sites with breaks; or nonfragile sites with no breaks. The designated common fragile sites were found to be preferred locations for SCE formation, not only when these sites were expressed as visible gaps or breaks, but even when they were nonexpressed in the cell. SCEs were also more likely to occur at nonfragile sites with breaks than at nonfragile with no break sites. Further, SCEs were found to be distributed nonrandomly across fragile sites and nonfragile sites, and among the fragile sites, the high frequency SCE sites were highly correlated with the high frequency breakage sites. These data support the hypothesis of common steps in the mechanism of aphidicolin-induced SCE formation and common fragile site expression.     

Inhibition of topoisomerase I prevents chromosome breakage at common fragile sites

Common fragile sites are loci that preferentially form gaps and breaks on metaphase chromosomes when DNA synthesis is perturbed, particularly after treatment with the DNA polymerase inhibitor, aphidicolin. We and others have identified several cell cycle checkpoint and DNA repair proteins that influence common fragile site stability. However, the initial events underlying fragile site breakage remain poorly understood. We demonstrate here that aphidicolin-induced gaps and breaks at fragile sites are prevented when cells are co-treated with low concentrations of the topoisomerase I inhibitor, camptothecin. This reduction in breakage is accompanied by a reduction in aphidicolin-induced RPA foci, CHK1 and RPA2 phosphorylation, and PCNA monoubiquitination, indicative of reduced levels of single stranded DNA. Furthermore, camptothecin reduces spontaneous fragile site breakage seen in cells lacking ATR, even in the absence of aphidicolin. These data from cultured human cells demonstrate that topoisomerase I activity is required for DNA common fragile site breaks and suggest that polymerase–helicase uncoupling is a key initial event in this process.     

DNA polymerase α inhibition by aphidicolin induces gaps and breaks at common fragile sites in human chromosomes

Summary Aphidicolin, a specific inhibitor of DNA polymerase , is known to induce chromosomal aberrations. At concentrations that did not greatly affect mitotic index, aphidicolin induced a striking number of chromosome gaps and breaks distributed in a highly nonrandom manner in cultured human lymphocytes. Specific chromosome bands, especially 2q31, 3p14, 6q26, 7q32, 16q23, and Xp22 were preferentially damaged in lymphocytes from each of 12 subjects studied. Total and site-specific damage was dose dependent and greatly increased when folic acid was removed from the medium. The sites most sensitive to aphidicolin damage include the hot spots seen under conditions of thymidylate stress and in studies of spontaneous chromosomal damage. The fragile X site, which can also be induced by thymidylate stress, was not induced by aphidicolin in lymphocytes, suggesting a separate mechanism for its induction. Aphidicolin represents a novel tool for detection of hot spots on human chromosomes through the mechanism of DNA polymerase inhibition. The hot spots induced by aphidicolin represent a new class of fragile sites which we term common fragile sites.     

The characterization of the common fragile site FRA16D and its involvement in multiple myeloma translocations

Fragile sites appear as breaks, gaps, or decondensations on metaphase chromosomes when cells are grown under specific culture conditions. The breaks are nonrandom, appearing in defined, conserved locations throughout the mammalian genome. Common fragile sites, as their name implies, are present in virtually all individuals. With three common fragile sites cloned, their mechanism of expression and the role, if any, they play in human disease are still unclear. We have assembled a BAC contig of >1 Mb across the second most active common fragile site, FRA16D (16q23.2). We fluorescently labeled these BACs and used them as probes on metaphases from aphidicolin-induced lymphocytes and demonstrated that FRA16D decondensation/breakage occurs over a region of at least 1 Mb. Thus, this is the largest common fragile site cloned to date. Microsatellite markers that map within FRA16D show a very high loss in prostate, breast, and ovarian tumors, indicating that loss within this fragile site may be important in the development or progression of these tumors. In addition, a common t(14q32;16q23) translocation is observed in up to 25% of all multiple myelomas (MM). We localized four of four such cloned t(14;16) MM breakpoints within the FRA16D region. This work further demonstrates that the common fragile sites may play an important role in cancer development.     

Fragile sites induced by FUdR,caffeine, and aphidicolin

Summary The frequencies of common fragile sites (c-fra) induced in peripheral blood lymphocytes by fluorodeoxyuridine (FUdR), aphidicolin, or caffeine, in eight healthy controls were studied. There was a significantly higher frequency of breaks (P<0.05) in the latter two treatments than the former. Also, significant variation in total number of breaks was observed among the eight individuals within the three treatments. The relative frequency of a fragile site in relation to the total number of fragile sites in an individual rather than its expression in total cells was considered important. Use of a frequency of 4% or more of total fragile sites was proposed to eliminate apparent random breaks that were observed. Using these criteria, a total of 31 c-fra were observed in the three treatments. The distribution of the fragile sites was different in FUdR-treated cells as opposed to caffeine- and aphidicolin-treated cells. Sites 3p14 and 16q23 and Xp22 were the three most frequently observed c-fra. The higher frequency of expression of some fragile sites in normal controls, as observed here, suggests that any relationship between fragile sites and neoplastic transformation has to be carefully evaluated. A classification based on frequency in the population, rather than mode of induction, is suggested.     

Expression and distribution of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites in chronic myeloid leukaemia, acute lymphocytic leukaemia and acute myeloid leukaemia

New information is revealed concerning the frequency of expression and distribution of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites in eight leukaemic patients, namely, four chronic myeloid leukaemic patients (CML), three acute lymphocytic leukaemic (ALL) patients, and one acute myeloid leukaemic (AML) patient. The cytogenetic data demonstrate a statistically significant (p less than 10(-6] increase in the frequency of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites in seven of the eight leukaemic patients compared with healthy age-matched and sex-matched controls. The chromosomal band locations of the aphidicolin-induced fragile sites from 400 metaphase spreads of these leukaemic patients reveal a nonrandom distribution in the karyotype. Some aphidicolin-induced fragile sites in these leukaemic patients were located at chromosome bands known to be induced specifically by folic acid, distamycin A, bromodeoxyuridine or azacytidine. The cross-induction of fragile sites in the leukaemic patients may be indicative of shared molecular homology in the sequence composition of nonrandom chromosomal DNA.     

Replication delay along FRA7H, a common fragile site on human chromosome 7, leads to chromosomal instability

Common fragile sites are specific chromosomal loci that show gaps, breaks, or rearrangements in metaphase chromosomes under conditions that interfere with DNA replication. The mechanism underlying the chromosomal instability at fragile sites was hypothesized to associate with late replication time. Here, we aimed to investigate the replication pattern of the common fragile site FRA7H, encompassing 160 kb on the long arm of human chromosome 7. Using in situ hybridization on interphase nuclei, we revealed that the replication of this region is initiated relatively early, before 30% of S phase is completed. However, a high fraction ( approximately 35%) of S-phase nuclei showed allelic asynchrony, indicating that the replication of FRA7H is accomplished at different times in S phase. This allelic asynchrony is not the result of a specific replication time of each FRA7H allele. Analysis of the replication pattern of adjacent clones along FRA7H by using cell population and two-color fluorescent in situ hybridization analyses showed significant differences in the replication of adjacent clones, under normal growth condition and upon aphidicolin treatment. This pattern significantly differed from that of two nonfragile regions which showed a coordinated replication under both conditions. These results indicate that aphidicolin is enhancing an already existing difference in the replication time along the FRA7H region. Based on our replication analysis of FRA7H and on previous analysis of the common fragile site FRA3B, we suggest that delayed replication is underlying the fragility at aphidicolin-induced common fragile sites.     

Induction of sister chromatid exchanges at common fragile sites.

Experiments were performed to gain further insight into chromosome structure and behavior at common fragile sites by testing the hypothesis that gaps at these sites predispose to intrachromosomal recombination as measured by sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs). Human lymphocytes were concurrently treated with aphidicolin, for determination of fragile site expression, and with 5-bromodeoxy-uridine, for SCE analysis. Aphidicolin induced chromosome gaps nonrandomly, with the great majority of gaps occurring at common fragile sites. On average, 66% of gaps were accompanied by an SCE at the site of the lesion. Analysis of two specific common fragile sites at 3p14 and 16q23 showed the same pattern; that is, on average 70% of gaps at these sites were accompanied by an SCE. These results show that common fragile sites are hot spots not only for chromosomal lesions such as gaps but also for SCE formation.     

Molecular basis for expression of common and rare fragile sites

Fragile sites are specific loci that form gaps, constrictions, and breaks on chromosomes exposed to partial replication stress and are rearranged in tumors. Fragile sites are classified as rare or common, depending on their induction and frequency within the population. The molecular basis of rare fragile sites is associated with expanded repeats capable of adopting unusual non-B DNA structures that can perturb DNA replication. The molecular basis of common fragile sites was unknown. Fragile sites from R-bands are enriched in flexible sequences relative to nonfragile regions from the same chromosomal bands. Here we cloned FRA7E, a common fragile site mapped to a G-band, and revealed a significant difference between its flexibility and that of nonfragile regions mapped to G-bands, similar to the pattern found in R-bands. Thus, in the entire genome, flexible sequences might play a role in the mechanism of fragility. The flexible sequences are composed of interrupted runs of AT-dinucleotides, which have the potential to form secondary structures and hence can affect replication. These sequences show similarity to the AT-rich minisatellite repeats that underlie the fragility of the rare fragile sites FRA16B and FRA10B. We further demonstrate that the normal alleles of FRA16B and FRA10B span the same genomic regions as the common fragile sites FRA16C and FRA10E. Our results suggest that a shared molecular basis, conferred by sequences with a potential to form secondary structures that can perturb replication, may underlie the fragility of rare fragile sites harboring AT-rich minisatellite repeats and aphidicolin-induced common fragile sites.     

Characteristic chromosomal fragility of human embryonic cells exposed in vitro to aphidicolin

The frequency and distribution of aphidicolin (APC)-induced common fragile sites (cfs) were analyzed in human embryonic cells of different origins. Embryonic lung fibroblasts (MRC-5), amniocytes (AMNIO) and embryonic retina cells (HERO790) are as sensitive to the APC-induced clastogenic effect as peripheral lymphocytes, whereas embryonic kidney cells (HEK) seem more resistant to the induction of chromosomal gaps and breaks by the drug. Analysis of the distribution of fragile sites confirmed that the expression of specific APC-induced cfs varies in different cells and that the embryonic cell strains show a greater similarity among themselves than to lymphocytes. In addition, HEK, MRC-5, HERO790 and AMNIO cells show specific APC induction of the cfs at the 1p31.2 chromosomal band, which seems to be a distinctive feature of the embryonic stage of cells.     

Expression and identification of folate-sensitive fragile sites in British Suffolk sheep (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Ovis aries</Emphasis>)

An investigation to understand the dynamics and biological significance of fragile site expression, and identification of 5-fluorodeoxyuridine (FUdR) induced chromosomal gaps/breaks, were carried out in an experimental flock of 45 Suffolk sheep. The statistical comparison revealed, highly significant variation in the frequency of chromosomal fragile site expression between control and FUdR cultures. Mean (± S.D.) values for cells with gaps and breaks, or aberrant cell count (AC), and the number of aberrations (NoA) per animal were 2.02 ± 0.34, 2.42 ± 0.48, 13.26 ± 0.85 and 21.87 ± 1.88 (P < 0.01) in control and FUdR cultures, respectively. The comparison of age revealed nonsignificant variation between control and FUdR cultures. The G-band analysis of fragile site data revealed gaps in 29 autosomal and two X-chromosomal bands in the control cultures, whereas FUdR treated cultures scored 78 unstable bands in autosomes of which 56 were significantly fragile. X-chromosomes expressed breaks and gaps in six G-negative bands and five of them (Xq13, Xq15, Xq17, Xq24 and Xq26) were significantly fragile. The distribution comparison of autosomal fragile sites between sex groups did not reveal any significant variation. Female X-chromosomes were significantly more fragile than the male X-chromosomes. The distribution comparison for age groups (lambs versus adults) revealed significantly higher number of fragile bands in adults. Comparison of published data on reciprocal translocations in sheep with the fragile-site data obtained in this study indicated that the break sites of both phenomena were correlated. Similarities were also found between fragile sites and breakpoints of evolutionary significance in family Bovidae.     

45S rDNA regions are chromosome fragile sites expressed as gaps in vitro on metaphase chromosomes of root-tip meristematic cells in Lolium spp

Background

In humans, chromosome fragile sites are regions that are especially prone to forming non-staining gaps, constrictions or breaks in one or both of the chromatids on metaphase chromosomes either spontaneously or following partial inhibition of DNA synthesis and have been well identified. So far, no plant chromosome fragile sites similar to those in human chromosomes have been reported.

Methods and Results

During the course of cytological mapping of rDNA on ryegrass chromosomes, we found that the number of chromosomes plus chromosome fragments was often more than the expected 14 in most cells for Lolium perenne L. cv. Player by close cytological examination using a routine chromosome preparation procedure. Further fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) using 45S rDNA as a probe indicated that the root-tip cells having more than a 14-chromosome plus chromosome fragment count were a result of chromosome breakage or gap formation in vitro (referred to as chromosome lesions) at 45S rDNA sites, and 86% of the cells exhibited chromosome breaks or gaps and all occurred at the sites of 45S rDNA in Lolium perenne L. cv. Player, as well as in L. multiflorum Lam. cv. Top One. Chromatin depletion or decondensation occurred at various locations within the 45S rDNA regions, suggesting heterogeneity of lesions of 45S rDNA sites with respect to their position within the rDNA region.

Conclusions

The chromosome lesions observed in this study are very similar cytologically to that of fragile sites observed in human chromosomes, and thus we conclude that the high frequency of chromosome lesions in vitro in Lolium species is the result of the expression of 45S rDNA fragile sites. Possible causes for the spontaneous expression of fragile sites and their potential biological significance are discussed.     

The fragile site (16) (q22)

Summary The rare fragile site at 16q22 was experimentally induced in lymphocyte cultures with various AT-specific, non-intercalating DNA-ligands. The optimum conditions for the induction of fra (16)(q22) were determined. The best expression of fra (16)(q22) was found with the aromatic diamidine berenil which is recommended for further studies on this fragile site. The results indicate that fra (16)(q22) is a region with AT-rich, late replicating DNA. The simultaneous treatment of lymphocytes with berenil and aphidicolin (inhibitor of DNA polymerase ) induces both the rare fra (16) (q22) and the common fra (16) (q23) within the same chromosome. A population study on 350 unselected individuals showed that fra (16)(q22) is the most common of all rare autosomal fragile sites in man. The frequency of individuals heterozygous for fra (16)(q22) is 5.1% no homozygosity for fra (16) (q22) was detected. Statistical analysis indicates that the population is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium with respect to the fragile and non-fragile chromosomes 16.     

Population cytogenetics of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites

Summary Chromosome fragile sites are inducible by aphidicolin in cultured human lymphocytes. To assess the frequency and distribution of these common fragile sites in the general population, a cytogenetic survey was performed on 126 subjects, 59 males and 67 females, whose age ranged from 1 day to 72 years. Common fragile sites, induced by aphidicolin, were widespread and showed a remarkably different sensitivity among individuals; age influenced the overall frequency of fragile sites. Moreover, both age and sex seemed to modulate the expression of specific fragile sites. In our population, the most common fragile sites were: 3p14, 16q23, Xp22, 6q26, 1p31, 4q31, 1p22, 7q22, 2q33, 3q27, 2q31, 7q32, 14q24, 10q22, 5q31, 2q37, 6p21.     

DAPI-inducible common fragile sites

DAPI, a compound specific for the AT bases of DNA, causes gaps and breaks in three human chromosome sites, at the 1q41-1q42 interface, 2q31, and 7p22. It also induces undercondensation of a chromosome site at the 13q21-13q22 interface. The first three sites have the characteristics of "common fragile sites" and are present as gaps and breaks on the chromosomes of seven individuals.     

A TRF1-controlled common fragile site containing interstitial telomeric sequences

Mouse telomeres have been suggested to resemble common fragile sites (CFS), showing disrupted TTAGGG fluorescent in situ hybridization signals after aphidicolin treatment. This “fragile” telomere phenotype is induced by deletion of TRF1, a shelterin protein that binds telomeric DNA and promotes efficient replication of the telomeric ds[TTAGGG]n tracts. Here we show that the chromosome-internal TTAGGG repeats present at human chromosome 2q14 form an aphidicolin-induced CFS. TRF1 binds to and stabilizes CFS 2q14 but does not affect other CFS, establishing 2q14 as the first CFS controlled by a sequence-specific DNA binding protein. The data show that telomeric DNA is inherently fragile regardless of its genomic position and imply that CFS can be caused by a specific DNA sequence.     

Cell type-dependent difference in the distribution and frequency of excess thymidine-induced common fragile sites: T lymphocytes and skin fibroblasts

Summary Common fragile sites were induced by excess thymidine in phytohemagglutin-stimulated T lymphocytes from 4 normal individuals, and skin fibroblasts from 4 normal and 5 fra(X) positive individuals. The results indicate that the frequency and distribution of excess thymidine-induced fragile sites are different between these two types of cells. The sites at 1p13 and 2p11.2, induced in both types of cells, have not previously been described, and are thus considered to be excess thymidine-specific fragile sites. These findings extend and support our previous studies on cell type-dependent difference in aphidicolin-induced common fragile sites.     

Mechanisms of Genomic Instabilities Underlying Two Common Fragile-Site-Associated Loci, PARK2 and DMD, in Germ Cell and Cancer Cell Lines

Common fragile sites (CFSs) are specific chromosome regions that exhibit an increased frequency of breaks when cells are exposed to a DNA-replication inhibitor such as aphidicolin. PARK2 and DMD, the causative genes for autosomal-recessive juvenile Parkinsonism and Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy, respectively, are two very large genes that are located within aphidicolin-induced CFSs. Gross rearrangements within these two genes are frequently observed as the causative mutations for these diseases, and similar alterations within the large fragile sites that surround these genes are frequently observed in cancer cells. To elucidate the molecular mechanisms underlying this fragility, we performed a custom-designed high-density comparative genomic hybridization analysis to determine the junction sequences of approximately 500 breakpoints in germ cell lines and cancer cell lines involving PARK2 or DMD. The sequence signatures where these breakpoints occur share some similar features both in germ cell lines and in cancer cell lines. Detailed analyses of these structures revealed that microhomologies are predominantly involved in rearrangement processes. Furthermore, breakpoint-clustering regions coincide with the latest-replicating region and with large nuclear-lamina-associated domains and are flanked by the highest-flexibility peaks and R/G band boundaries, suggesting that factors affecting replication timing collectively contribute to the vulnerability for rearrangement in both germ cell and somatic cell lines.