The influence of amino acid substitutions on the conformational energy of cytochrome c.

Conformational energies have been evaluated for each of the staggered side-chain conformations associated with the 261 amino acid substitutions known to occur among 60 eucaryotic species. At least 86% of these substitutions can be sterically accommodated (one at a time) within the structure of horse-heart cytochrome c resulting from conformational energy refinement. Simultaneous incorporation of all pertinent amino acid substitutions found in eight representative species into the refined horse-heart structure is also shown to be sterically possible, with few exceptions. In two cases (Pekin duck cytochrome with 10 substitutions and Samia cynthia cytochrome with 24 substitutions), all substitutions could be readily incorporated, and the total energies associated with their computed structures differed by less than 10 kcal/mol from that of horse-heart cytochrome c. In the cytochromes from rattlesnake (22 substitutions), tuna (18 substitutions), and Neurospora crassa (36 substitutions), tyrosine could not be substituted for phenylalanine at position 46, within the constraints of the calculations. However, when all of the remaining substitutions were incorporated into these three cytochromes, their computed conformational energies differed by less than 30 kcal/mol from that of horse-heart cytochrome c. Between two and four amino acid substitutions cause high energies in the cytochromes from human, baker's yeast, and cotton seed, but all of the remaining substitutions are consistent with a low energy conformation. These results suggest that the structures of homologous proteins may be even more similar than has previously been recognized. Substitutions of all possible amino acid types at the invariant positions (where all eucaryotic cytochromes c bear the same amino acid) have revealed some cases where different amino acids can be accommodated, thus demonstrating that the biological constraints on amino acid substitutions are often different from the purely steric constraints investigated in this work.     

Helix movements and the reconstruction of the haem pocket during the evolution of the cytochrome c family

Analysis of cytochromes c (tuna), c2 (Rhodospirillum rubrum), c550 (Paracoccus denitrificans) and c551 (Pseudomonas aeruginosa) shows that they contain 48 residues identifiable as homologous from superposition of the structures. The other 34 to 64 residues are in loops that vary greatly in sequence, length and conformation, or in alpha-helices that are found in only some of the structures. Of the 48 homologous residues, 17 are in three segments which pack onto the haem faces. In all four structures, these segments have the same conformations, and the same locations relative to the haem. The other 31 residues are in three alpha-helices which are in contact with each other. These form the back and one side of the haem pocket. In cytochrome c551 the positions of the three alpha-helices have shifted and rotated, in comparison with cytochromes c and c2, by up to 5 A and 25 degrees relative to the haem. These shifts, facilitated by mutations at the helix-helix interfaces, are related to the reconstruction of the propionic acid side of the haem pocket described by Almassy & Dickerson (1978). Together these effects produce alternative structures for the haem pocket. This mechanism of adaptation to mutation contrasts with that observed in the globins. In the globins, mutations also produce changes in helix interfaces and shifts of packed helices, but in the globins these shifts are coupled to conserve the structure of the haem pocket.     

The primary structure of cytochrome c from the rust fungus Ustilago sphaerogena

1. The complete amino acid sequence of cytochrome c from the basidiomycete Ustilago sphaerogena was determined from the amino acid compositions and sequences of either tryptic or chymotryptic peptides, and in homology with at least thirty other established sequences of cytochrome c. 2. The primary structure of the molecule bears all of the characteristics of a mammalian-type cytochrome c, showing the typical clustered distribution of hydrophobic and basic residues with a single polypeptide chain of 107 residues. 3. Like all other fungal cytochromes c, it possesses a free N-terminus, and one less residue at the C-terminus than vertebrate cytochromes c. The region of residues 70-80 is strictly conserved, as is histidine at position 18. Position 26 is occupied by an asparagine residue, in contrast to histidine which occurs at this location in most of the known sequences of mammalian-type cytochromes c. 4. In contrast to some other fungal and plant cytochromes c of known primary structures, the Ustilago cytochrome c molecule does not contain trimethyl-lysine. 5. The sequence of Ustilago cytochrome c differs from the sequences of human, horse, chicken, tuna, wheat, and baker's yeast proteins at loci 47, 43, 44, 44 and 38 respectively.     

High-resolution three-dimensional structure of horse heart cytochrome c

The 1.94 A resolution three-dimensional structure of oxidized horse heart cytochrome c has been elucidated and refined to a final R-factor of 0.17. This has allowed for a detailed assessment of the structural features of this protein, including the presence of secondary structure, hydrogen-bonding patterns and heme geometry. A comprehensive analysis of the structural differences between horse heart cytochrome c and those other eukaryotic cytochromes c for which high-resolution structures are available (yeast iso-1, tuna, rice) has also been completed. Significant conformational differences between these proteins occur in three regions and primarily involve residues 22 to 27, 41 to 43 and 56 to 57. The first of these variable regions is part of a surface beta-loop, whilst the latter two are located together adjacent to the heme group. This study also demonstrates that, in horse cytochrome c, the side-chain of Phe82 is positioned in a co-planar fashion next to the heme in a conformation comparable to that found in other cytochromes c. The positioning of this residue does not therefore appear to be oxidation-state-dependent. In total, five water molecules occupy conserved positions in the structures of horse heart, yeast iso-1, tuna and rice cytochromes c. Three of these are on the surface of the protein, serving to stabilize local polypeptide chain conformations. The remaining two are internally located. One of these mediates a charged interaction between the invariant residue Arg38 and a nearby heme propionate. The other is more centrally buried near the heme iron atom and is hydrogen bonded to the conserved residues Asn52, Tyr67 and Thr78. It is shown that this latter water molecule shifts in a consistent manner upon change in oxidation state if cytochrome c structures from various sources are compared. The conservation of this structural feature and its close proximity to the heme iron atom strongly implicate this internal water molecule as having a functional role in the mechanism of action of cytochrome c.     

Local structure of cytochrome c from horse heart in solution. Conformational analysis using data of two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy]

Using the earlier suggested method the calculation of the backbone conformations of horse heart cytochrome c in oxidized (ferricytochrome c) and reduced (ferrocytochrome c) states has been performed by the two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy data. For both protein forms the secondary structure elements have been revealed and the conformations of the irregular polypeptide chain segments have been analysed. The similarity of the secondary structures of ferri- and ferrocytochrome c in solution was established from the comparison of their conformations. Small differences between the conformations of two molecule forms are shown to be localized within the polypeptide chain fragments situated in the spatial structure near the heme crevice. The comparison of the dihedral phi and psi angles in the calculated conformations of horse cytochrome C with the corresponding characteristics of X-ray structures of tuna ferri- and ferrocytochrome c made for the oxidized and reduced protein forms using the quantitative criteria testifies the similarity of their conformations in solution and crystal. In is shown that the conformational changes of the separate amino acid residues which take place as the result of the "solution-to-crystal" transition occur on the surface fragments of protein globule and do not lead to essential alterations of the secondary molecule structure.     

Structure of rice ferricytochrome c at 2.0 A resolution

The crystal structure of ferricytochrome c from rice embryos has been solved by X-ray diffraction to a resolution of 2.0 A, applying a single isomorphous replacement method with anomalous scattering effects. The initial molecular model was built on a graphics display system and was refined by the Hendrickson and Konnert method. The R factor was reduced to 0.25. Rice cytochrome c consists of III amino acid residues. In comparison with animal cytochromes c, the peptide chain extends for eight residues at the N-terminal end, which is characteristic for plant cytochromes c. These additional residues display a collagen-like conformation and an irregular reverse turn, and are located around the C-terminal alpha-helix on the surface or the rear side of the molecule. Two hydrogen bonds between the carbonyl oxygen of the N-terminal acetyl group and O eta of Tyr65, and between the peptide carbonyl oxygen of Pro-1 and O epsilon 1 of Gln89, are involved in holding these eight residues on the molecular surface, where Tyr65 and Gln89 are invariant in plant cytochromes c. Except for the extra eight residues, the main-chain conformations of both rice and tuna cytochromes c are essentially identical, though small local conformational differences are found at residues 24, 25, 56 and 57.     

Comparison of the structures of various eukaryotic ferricytochromes c and ferrocytochromes and their antigenic differences

The nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of various eukaryotic ferricytochromes c and ferrocytochromes c are described. The proteins from the species donkey, cow, dog, rabbit, chicken and pigeon were investigated. The conformations of these proteins detected by NMR were compared to those of horse and tuna cytochromes c and in some cases small differences were found. These differences in structure were shown to correlate with antigenic differences between the various proteins.     

The conformation of eukaryotic cytochrome c around residues 39, 57, 59 and 74.

1H-n.m.r. studies of horse, tuna, Candida krusei and Saccharomyces cerevisiae cytochromes c showed that each of the proteins contains a similar cluster of residues at the bottom of the protein that assists in shielding the haem from the solvent. The relative positions of the residues forming these clusters vary continuously with temperature, and they change with the change in protein redox state. This conformational heterogeneity is discussed with reference to the conformational flexibility of cytochrome c around residues 57, 59 and 74. Spectroscopic measurements of pKa values for Lys-55 (horse and tuna cytochromes c) and His-33 and His-39 (C. krusei and S. cerevisiae cytochromes c) are in excellent agreement with expectations based on chemical-modification studies of horse cytochrome c. [Bosshard & Zürrer (1980) J. Biol. Chem. 255, 6694-6699] and on the X-ray-crystallographic structure of tuna cytochrome c [Takano & Dickerson (1981) J. Mol. Biol. 153, 79-94, 95-115].     

Solution structure of mitochondrial cytochrome c. I. 1H nuclear magnetic resonance of ferricytochrome c

The 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of tuna and horse ferricytochromes c have been investigated and the resonances of all amino acid methyl groups have been assigned to specific absorption lines. The assignment procedure involves principally the comparison of one-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectra from a range of homologous ferricytochromes c and does not require a prior knowledge of the secondary or tertiary protein structure. Of the 49 methyl groups of tuna cytochrome c, the assignment of 33 is made without reference to the X-ray crystal structure. The method should therefore be applicable to other proteins of similar size where X-ray structures are unavailable. The assignments will be used to investigate the structure of cytochrome c in solution.     

Ultraviolet resonance Raman spectra of cytochrome c conformational states

Ultraviolet resonance Raman (UV RR) spectra are reported for ferricytochrome c from tuna and horse heart at pH 1.6, 7, 10, and 13, representing distinct conformational states of the protein (states II, III, IV, and V, respectively). The spectra were obtained with pulsed laser excitation at 200 and 218 nm, via H2 Raman shifting the fourth harmonic output of a pulsed YAG laser. At these deep UV wavelengths, strong enhancement is observed for vibrational modes associated with tryptophan, tyrosine, and phenylalanine side chains and with the amide groups of the polypeptide backbone. The amide I peak frequency is consistent with a dominant contribution from alpha-helical regions, although a broad high-frequency tail reflects a variety of unordered conformations. The peak frequency is 12 cm-1 higher for cytochrome c from tuna than from horse, suggesting a less tightly wound structure, which is consistent with the lower denaturation temperature previously reported for the tuna protein. The amide I peak broadens when native protein (state III) is converted to the low- or high-pH forms (states II and IV), reflecting some disordering of the polypeptide chain, but the peak frequencies are unshifted, establishing that the alpha-helical segments are not completely unfolded in these states. Raising the pH to 13 (state V), however, does produce a frequency upshift, reflecting helix unfolding. The amide II and III frequencies are likewise consistent with a dominant alpha-helix contribution in the native proteins; they gain intensity, and amide III is shifted to a lower frequency, in states II and IV, consistent with partial disordering.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Kinetics of reduction by free flavin semiquinones of the components of the cytochrome c-cytochrome c peroxidase complex and intracomplex electron transfer

The kinetics of reduction by free flavin semiquinones of the individual components of 1:1 complexes of yeast ferric and ferryl cytochrome c peroxidase and the cytochromes c of horse, tuna, and yeast (iso-2) have been studied. Complex formation decreases the rate constant for reduction of ferric peroxidase by 44%. On the basis of a computer model of the complex structure [Poulos, T.L., & Finzel, B.C. (1984) Pept. Protein Rev. 4, 115-171], this decrease cannot be accounted for by steric effects and suggests a decrease in the dynamic motions of the peroxidase at the peroxide access channel caused by complexation. The orientations of the three cytochromes within the complex are not equivalent. This is shown by differential decreases in the rate constants for reduction by neutral flavin semiquinones upon complexation, which are in the order tuna much greater than horse greater than yeast iso-2. Further support for differences in orientation is provided by the observation that, with the negatively charged reductant FMNH., the electrostatic environments near the horse and tuna cytochrome c electron-transfer sites within their respective complexes with peroxidase are of opposite sign. For the horse and tuna cytochrome c complexes, we have also observed nonlinear concentration dependencies of the reduction rate constants with FMNH.. This is interpreted in terms of dynamic motion at the protein-protein interface. We have directly measured the physiologically significant intra-complex one electron transfer rate constants from the three ferrous cytochromes c to the peroxide-oxidized species of the peroxidase. At low ionic strength these rate constants are 920, 730, and 150 s-1 for tuna, horse, and yeast cytochromes c, respectively. These results are also consistent with the contention that the orientations of the three cytochromes within the complex with CcP are not the same. The effect on the intracomplex electron-transfer rate constant of the peroxidase amino acid side chain(s) that is (are) oxidized by the reduction of peroxide was determined to be relatively small. Thus, the rate constant for reduction by horse cytochrome c of the peroxidase species in which only the heme iron atom is oxidized was decreased by only 38%, indicating that this oxidized side-chain group is not tightly coupled to the ferryl peroxidase heme iron. Finally, it was found that, in the absence of cytochrome c, neither of the ferryl peroxidase species could be rapidly reduced by flavin semiquinones.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The complete amino acid sequence of Nitrobacter agilis cytochrome c-550

The amino acid sequence of cytochrome c-550 from the chemoautotroph, Nitrobacter agilis, was completed by using solid-phase sequencing and conventional procedures. The cytochrome was composed of 109 amino acid residues and its molecular weight was calculated to be 12375 including haem c. The cytochrome was homologous to eukaryotic cytochromes c and some photosynthetic bacterial cytochromes c2. In particular, its primary structure was very similar to that of Rhodopseudomonas viridis cytochrome c2. Some of its properties were compared with those of other cytochromes c on the basis of the primary structure.     

Probing stability and dynamics of proteins by protease digestion. II: Identification of the initial chymotryptic cleavage sites of homologous cytochromes c

Three homologous cytochromes c from horse, rabbit and tuna were subjected to chymotryptic digestion and their initial cleavage sites were identified. The sites in oxidized cytochromes c are the COOH-terminal sides of Tyr-48, Phe-46 and Tyr-46 for horse, rabbit and tuna cytochromes c, respectively. The results show that the chymotrypsin attacks a single site in each protein; the sites are located at the almost identical position on the polypeptide chain. Through the time-course studies of digestion, it was found that the three cytochromes c have different chymotrypsin-susceptibility at the initial cleavage site in the order of horse less than rabbit less than tuna. Studies on chymotryptic digestion of tuna cytochrome c in the reduced form revealed that the haem-reduction does not alter the initial cleavage site but increases the resistance to the proteolysis at the site. The uniqueness of the initial cleavage site in each cytochrome c species suggests that the protease susceptibility reflects some overall properties of the protein. At the same time, it was clarified that the initial cleavage site is also affected by a neighboring region by the fact that another potential cleavage site is located near the site in question. In order to elucidate the initial cleavage site, several physical properties of tuna cytochrome c molecule deduced from the X-ray 3D structure, accessible surface area, temperature factor, effective hydrophobicity and electrostatic potential, were compared with the experimental results and it was concluded that these properties given by a residue have no direct relationship with the chymotrypsin susceptibility.     

Probing stability and dynamics of proteins by protease digestion. I: Comparison of protease susceptibility and thermal stability of cytochromes c

Protease susceptibility of homologous proteins in their native conformations was studied. This work aims to establish a broad and quantitative basis for the utilization of protease digestion to analyze the local stability of native proteins. Using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) the time course of the proteolytic degradation of intact proteins was quantitatively traced. Rapid separation of peptide fragments with HPLC made possible the elucidation of sequential digestion originating from the cleavage at a very few sites which are locally unstable in the protein structure. Using four serine proteases, chymotrypsin, trypsin, elastase and subtilisin BPN', we found some common trends in proteolysis for a group of proteins of the cytochrome c family. By comparing of the proteolysis and thermal denaturation with ten homologous cytochromes c extracted from horse, beef, Candida krusei, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, chicken, tuna, pigeon, rabbit, dog and rat, protease susceptibility was related to locally unfolding states intrinsic to the native conformation.     

Probing Stability and Dynamics of Proteins by Protease Digestion I: Comparison of Protease Susceptibility and Thermal Stability of Cytochromes c

Abstract

Protease susceptibility of homologous proteins in their native conformations was studied. This work aims to establish a broad and quantitative basis for the utilization of protease digestion to analyze the local stability of native proteins. Using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) the time course of the proteolytic degradation of intact proteins was quantitatively traced. Rapid separation of peptide fragments with HPLC made possible the elucidation of sequential digestion originating from the cleavage at a very few sites which are locally unstable in the protein structure. Using four serine proteases, chymotrypsin, trypsin, elastase and subtilisin BPN', we found some common trends in proteolysis for a group of proteins of the cytochrome c family. By comparing of the proteolysis and thermal denaturation with ten homologous cytochromes c extracted from horse, beef, Candida krusei, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, chicken, tuna, pigeon, rabbit, dog and rat, protease susceptibility was related to locally unfolding states intrinsic to the native conformation.     

The amino acid sequence of low-potential cytochrome c550 from the cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa

The low-potential cytochrome c550 has been purified from the cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa and its amino acid sequence has been determined. The protein contains 135 amino acid residues with the Cys-X-X-Cys-His heme binding site at residues 37 to 41. The sequence from residue 28 to 45 shows similarity to cytochrome c553 residues 1 to 18 when the heme binding sites are aligned. Another region of similarity is in the carboxyl-terminal regions of these two proteins. The two aligning regions of cytochrome c553 correspond to helical segments in other related cytochromes. A partial sequence of cytochrome c550 from Aphanizomenon flos-aquae was obtained and showed a 48% identity to the sequence of the M. aeruginosa cytochrome. The single methionine residue in cytochrome c550 of M. aeruginosa occurs at position 119 but there is no methionine in this region in the A. flos-aquae cytochrome, indicating that methionine is not the sixth ligand to the heme iron atom. Histidine 92 is a possible sixth ligand in M. aeruginosa cytochrome c550. The far-uv circular dichroism spectrum indicates that this protein is approximately 17% alpha helix, 42% beta-pleated sheet, and 41% random coil.     

Topographic determinants on cytochrome c. I. The complete antigenic structures of rabbit, mouse, and guanaco cytochromes c in rabbits and mice1.

Rabbit, mouse, and guanaco cytochromes c differ from each other by only two amino acid residues. The identification is described of all of the antigenic determinants of mouse and guanaco cytochrome c that elicit an antibody response in rabbits, and those of the rabbit and guanaco proteins that elicity antibodies in the mouse. All except one of these sites center around single amino acid residue differences between the antigen and the host cytochrome c. The corresponding antibody popylations bind only to the areas of the protein in which the substitutions occur. Such antigenic determinants manifested in rabbits by quanaco and mouse cytochromes c are centered around residues 62 and 89, and residues 44 and 89, respectively. Similarly, the mouse recognizes sites containing residues 44 and 62 in guanaco cytochrome c, and residues 44 and 89 in rabbit cytochrome c. In none of these instances has a change in sequence failed to produce an antibody response. Each of these determinants appears to elicit and bind to its antibody, independently of other determinants present on the protein. In addition, two different autoantigenic responses have been detected. The antibodies produced against the determinant formed by glutamyl residue 62 of the guanaco protein in both rabbits and mice, the cytochromes c of which carry an aspartyl residue in that position, also bind to the aspartyl-containing region but with lower affinity. However, mouse and rabbit cytochrome c also elicit antibodies to the area of residue 62 in rabbits and mice, respectively, and these antibodies still bind more strongly to the glutamyl-than to the aspartyl-containing determinant. This last response occurs only when there are residue substitutions elsewhere in the molecule, because mice and rabbits fail to respond to their own cytochrome c. Antibodies produced in mice against the change from alanyl to valyl residue 44 by rabbit and guanaco cytochromes c also bind to the alanyl-containing determinant, except less tightly than to the valyl region. Conversely, antibodies raised in rabbits against the change from valyl to alanyl residue 44 only bind to this region when it carries an alanine. It is suggested that antigenic determinants that arise as a result of amino acid residue substitutions between the immunizing and the corresponding host protein, without a change in the spatial arrangement of the polypeptide backbone, be termed topographic determinants.     

Redox-linked conformational changes of a multiheme cytochrome from Geobacter sulfurreducens

Multiheme c-type cytochromes from members of the Desulfovibrionacea and Geobactereacea families play crucial roles in the bioenergetics of these microorganisms. Thermodynamic studies using NMR and visible spectroscopic techniques on tetraheme cytochromes c(3) isolated from Desulfovibrio spp. and more recently on a triheme cytochrome from Geobacter sulfurreducens showed that the properties of each redox centre are modulated by the neighbouring redox centres enabling these proteins to perform energy transduction and thus contributing to cellular energy conservation. Electron/proton transfer coupling relies on redox-linked conformational changes that were addressed for some multiheme cytochromes from the comparison of protein structure of fully reduced and fully oxidised forms. In this work, we identify for the first time in a multiheme cytochrome the simultaneous presence of two different conformations in solution. This was achieved by probing the different oxidation stages of a triheme cytochrome isolated from G. sulfurreducens using 2D-NMR techniques. The results presented here will be the foundations to evaluate the modulation of the redox centres properties by conformational changes that occur during the reoxidation of a multiheme protein.     

A comparison of the physical and chemical properties of four cytochromes c from Azotobacter vinelandii

1. A modified method for the separation and purification of four cytochromes c from Azotobacter vinelandii is described. Two new cytochromes c have been purified and are designated cytochromes c(551) and c(555). 2. Additional evidence is presented to establish the dihaem nature of cytochrome c(4). Ultracentrifugation data indicated similar molecular weights for the native and the denatured protein. Cleavage with CNBr yielded seven peptides; the amino acid compositions of the purified peptides were determined. Only one haem peptide was recovered. 3. Cytochromes c(551) and c(555) were characterized as acidic proteins of molecular weights about 12000. The spectral properties, isoelectric points, ;maps' of peptides from CNBr cleavage and amino acid compositions were determined for these two proteins. 4. The spectral properties, isoelectric points, molecular weights, CNBr peptide ;maps', amino acid compositions, relative oxidation-reduction potentials and e.p.r. (electron-paramagnetic-resonance) spectra of the four cytochromes c were compared. Cytochrome c(4) and cytochrome c(551) appear to be distinct proteins. The distinction between cytochromes c(5) and c(555) was not as clear, and our data are inadequate to establish firmly that they are distinct proteins. 5. The dihaem nature of cytochrome c(4) is evident in its e.p.r. spectrum. The e.p.r. spectra are similar to the spectra of mammalian cytochromes c.