Suppression of cytotoxic response to histoincompatible cells. I. Evidence for two types of T lymphocyte-derived suppressors acting at different stages in the induction of a cytotoxic response.

Spleen and thymus cell populations from normal or allograft tolerant mice have been cultured for 5 days with specific alloantigens and examined for their reactivity in three assay systems. No consistent correlation was observed between the production of cytotoxic T cells (CTL) in these cultures and the ability of such cultured cells to inhibit specifically a CML response from fresh normal spleen cells directed to the priming alloantigens. Furthermore, suppressor cells measured in this latter assay were apparently distinct from those able to inhibit the production of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) from bone marrow stem cells in lethally irradiated bone marrow protected mice. Velocity sedimentation experiments confirmed that both the precursor and effector cells for the two suppressor systems were physically separable, and were distinct from CTLp or CTL, respectively. Precursor cells for the two suppressor systems investigated belong to the short-lived cortical thymus cell population.     

The origin of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P): MHC-restricted and alloreactive CTL-P in the spleen during regeneration after a sublethal dose of cyclophosphamide (Cy)

The regenerating spleen 8 days after an injection of a sublethal dose (300 mg/kg) of cyclophosphamide (Cy) had a defective capacity to give rise to cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in response against allogeneic cells, whereas the cytotoxicity against 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl-(TNP) modified syngeneic cells was at the normal level. Alloresponse was first obtained 2 wk after the Cy treatment. The limiting dilution analysis showed this at the clonal level: the frequency of anti-TNP-specific CTL precursors (CTL-P) in the spleen treated with Cy 8 days previously was the same as the frequency in the normal spleen. The defective alloresponse was due to a decreased number of allospecific CTL-P that was later increasing. The regenerative capacity was not abolished by adult thymectomy or treatment of the mice with a bone marrow-seeking isotope, 89Sr, suggesting that these CTL-P are derived from Cy-resistant splenic precursors rather than from the thymus or bone marrow. These precursors have probably been under thymic education: the dominance of H-2k-restricted CTL over H-2d-restricted CTL in the response of (H-2k X H-2d)F1 mice to TNP-self is known to be influenced by the H-2 genotype of the thymus, and this dominance was also demonstrated with anti-TNP CTL derived from these F1 mice pretreated with Cy. The CTL-P in the regenerating spleen (day 8) were not hydrocortisone sensitive, and nylon wool-purified T cells from this stage had a lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) isoenzyme pattern of the mature T cell type (rather than of the thymocyte type). Thus, in these aspects the T cells of the regenerating spleen resembled normal splenic cells. These data suggest that the Cy-resistant spleen population contains cells that can give rise to CTL-P that have a defective specificity repertoire at the beginning of the regeneration, but later mature to a normally alloreactive population.     

Spleen cells from athymic mice are ineffective stimulator cells for cytotoxic responses in microcultures and in vivo

The stimulator cells for the activation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursor cells were studied in vivo and in microculture systems with limiting concentrations of helper factor (interleukin-2). We found in both cases that mixtures of irradiated spleen cells from athymic and euthymic donors of different haplotypes activated CTL responses preferentially against alloantigens which were carried by the euthymic donors. This applied also if athymic and euthymic donors shared parts of the H-2 gene complex. Stimulator cells from athymic and euthymic donors activated, on the other hand, equally strong responses in microcultures which were supplemented with additional helper factor or in conventional macrocultures. This and direct cell mixing experiments showed that the ineffective stimulation by the nude spleen cells in vivo and under conditions of limiting helper factor was not mediated by active suppression. Our experiments are therefore best explained by the assumption that cytotoxic responses under conditions of limiting helper factor require a close proximity between CTL precursor cells and helper T cells. This proximity may be most efficiently provided by the receptors of the CTL precursor cells when helper T cells serve as stimulator cells. Lymph node cells were consistently inferior to spleen cells as stimulator cells, and the nylon wool nonadherent fraction of spleen cells was on the average also inferior to unfractionated spleen cells, indicating that the stimulator T cells belong to a spleen seeking and partly nylon wool adherent T-cell subpopulation or require an additional cell type for optimal stimulation.     

Functional clonal deletion and suppression as complementary mechanisms operative in adult hapten-induced cytotoxic T cell tolerance

Immunologic tolerance to the hapten TNP was induced in adult mice through the i.v. injection of reactive TNBS. To probe the cellular basis of the tolerant state, splenic cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) were stimulated in vitro with haptenated, x-irradiated syngeneic spleen cells in the presence or absence of exogenously added growth factors derived from Concanavalin A-stimulated spleen cell conditioned medium (CAS). The cultures were either conventional bulk cultures or limit dilution cloning cultures. For the latter, cytotoxicity was assessed through a semi-automated, radioautographic 111In-release assay. Suppressive potential was assessed by mixing spleen cells from tolerant mice with normal spleen cells before culture. In the absence of CAS, bulk cultures showed profound tolerance, and suppressive capacity was clearly evident. Suppression was dependent on the presence of TNP-self during culture and affected the generation of CTL from CTL-P and not the effector function of CTL. Cyclophosphamide treatment did not prevent tolerance induction. In the presence of CAS, bulk cultures still showed marked tolerance, but mixing experiments now yielded no evidence of suppression. As documented previously, limit dilution cultures of tolerant spleen cells in the presence of CAS showed a functional clonal deletion of hapten-specific CTL-P. In the absence of CAS, limit dilution cultures became dependent on helper T cells as the limiting element. Tolerant populations showed a diminution of activatable helper T lymphocyte precursors (HTL-P), which may have been due to a functional clonal deletion of HTL-P and/or a concomitant activation of suppressor T cells. Adoptive transfer studies showed that cells from tolerant mice did not detectably influence the number of hapten-specific CTL-P in the spleens of host animals. Taken together, the results suggest that both functional clonal deletion of CTL-P and suppression of HTL-P contribute to the tolerant state induced.     

Induction of TNP-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte memory in vivo in the absence of T helper cell activity

The question of whether TH cells are required for the priming of CTL precursors (CTLp) in vivo was studied by using Txbm mice (Thymectomized, irradiated, and stem cell-reconstituted mice). In these mice, TNP-specific CTL could be induced in vitro with TNP-coupled spleen cells only if the cultures were supplemented with an IL 2-containing supernatant (ConAsup). In contrast to normal mice, TNP-specific Lyt-2-TH cells could not be induced by skin painting with trinitrochlorobenzene (TNCB) (as tested by the ability to help CTL formation from thymocyte or normal spleen precursors). These data confirm previous findings that Txbm mice possess CTLp but that their TH compartment is deficient. TNCB skin painting had, however, a clear priming effect on the CTLp population: spleen cells from TNCB-painted mice could give rise to specific CTL with a lower amount of ConAsup than spleen cells from unprimed mice. In addition to this, priming changed the CTLp so that stimulation with lightly coupled cells (0.1 mM trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid [TNBS] instead of 10 mM TNBS) became effective. These changes took place without a significant increase in the frequency of TNP-specific CTL precursors. The data obtained are consistent with the concept that at least with some antigens, CTLp proliferation (clonal expansion), which is probably caused by activated TH cells, is not required for the induction of immunologic memory in vivo.     

In vivo generation of suppressor T cells by thymosin in congenitally athymic nude mice

Treatment of nude mice with thymic factors such as thymosin has been mostly ineffective in generating effector T cells. This study examined the effects of treating nude mice with thymosin fraction 5 on the induction of cells that could participate in and/or regulate cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) generation by normal spleen cells in vitro. Splenic lymphocytes from BALB/c nude mice injected with thymosin fraction 5 every other day for 2 wk were tested for their ability to generate CTL in vitro. Two days after the last subcutaneous injection of thymosin, nude spleens were removed, mixed with normal BALB/c spleen cells, and placed into a mixed lymphocyte tumor culture (MLTC) against allogeneic RBL 5 tumor cells. After a 5-day incubation, cultures were tested for the presence of CTL in a 4-hr 51Cr-release assay. Spleen cells from thymosin-treated nude mice did not generate CTL but suppressed the ability of normal spleen cells to generate CTL in vitro. Characterization of the thymosin-induced nude mouse suppressor cells showed them to be Thy 1 positive, nonadherent, cyclophosphamide-sensitive T cells. These data demonstrate that some T cell maturation occurs in vivo under thymosin influence. However, the activity of these cells is initially limited to a regulatory function. These studies suggest that maturation of functional suppressor T cells occurs before CTL. Further immunologic manipulation appears to be necessary in order to induce CTL effector cells in nude mice.     

Suppression of alloimmune cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) generation by depletion of NK cells and restoration by interferon and/or interleukin 2

By using rabbit antiserum to a glycolipid, ganglio-n-tetraosylceramide (ASGM1), the accessory effect of natural killer (NK) cells on the generation of alloimmune CTL in mice was investigated. When normal C3H/He mice were immunized with C57BL/6 or BALB/c spleen cells, they generated alloimmune CTL with a surface marker phenotype of Thy-1+ Lyt-1-2+ ASGM1-, preceded by early augmentation of cytotoxic activity of NK cells with a Thy-1-Lyt-1-2-ASGM1+ phenotype. Administration of anti-ASGM1 (10 microliters) in mice resulted in a complete depletion of NK activity and ASGM1+ cells in the spleen even 1 day after injection, but no changes in the proportions of T (Thy-1+) cells and their Lyt-1 and Lyt-2 subsets as revealed by an immunofluorescence analyzer (FACS) and phagocytic cells. When these anti-ASGM1-treated mice were immunized with allogeneic cells, they showed neither augmented NK activity nor generation of alloimmune CTL, and spleen cells isolated from these anti-ASGM1-treated mice produced no CTL response to alloimmunization in vitro. Normal spleen cells treated with the antiserum and complement in vitro also showed a complete NK depletion without any deterioration of T cells and their Lyt-1 and Lyt-2 subsets, and when stimulated with allogeneic cells they generated no CTL. Spleen NK (ASGM1+) cells were purified by Percoll-gradient centrifugations followed by complement-dependent killing of T cells with the use of anti-Thy-1 monoclonal antibody, and were further purified by panning methods with anti-ASGM1, giving a preparation consisting of greater than 90% ASGM1+, Ly-5+ cells, and less than 0.5% of Thy-1+, Lyt-1+, and Lyt-2+ cells. These purified ASGM1+ Thy-1- cells alone generated no alloimmune CTL in response to alloantigens, suggesting that ASGM1+ NK cells contained no precursors of alloimmune CTL. When added into NK-depleted spleen cells, they restored the normal alloimmune CTL response of the spleen cells, indicating that ASGM1+ fractions contained cells to provide an accessory function for CTL generation. Lyt-1+ cells purified by panning methods did not restore the CTL response of NK-depleted spleen cells. These results indicate that ASGM1+ NK cells, but not Lyt-1+ helper T cells contaminating ASGM1+ fractions at undetectable levels, are responsible for the accessory function. When these purified ASGM1+ Thy-1- cells were stimulated with allogeneic cells, they produced IL 2 and IFN.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Suppressor T cells regulate the cytolytic T lymphocyte response to syngeneic tumors induced by murine sarcoma virus (MSV) in the mouse.

Studies were designed to analyze the immune activities of spleen cells from mice previously injected with murine sarcoma virus (MSV) and undergoing the processes of MSV tumor growth and rejection. Fractionation of MSV-primed spleen cells according to cell size by velocity sedimentation at unit gravity showed that MSV-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) generated in vivo underwent an apparent transition in size from large to small cells as the tumor regressed. The majority of CTL precursors, however, were invariably recovered among small to medium-sized MSV-immune cells, as revealed to CTL generation in vitro in secondary mixed leukocyte-tumor cell cultures (MLTC). Evidence was obtained for the existence in MSV-immune spleens of two suppressor cell populations capable of inhibiting CTL generation in vitro: one population probably consisted of macrophages and could be removed by treatment with carbonyl iron; the second population was comprised of T cells and inhibited the differentiation of tumor-immune CTL precursors in a selective manner. These results provide a preliminary overview of the mechanisms regulating the generation, differentiation, and activity of tumor-specific CTL in a syngeneic model system.     

Functional and phenotypic alterations in T cell subsets during the course of MAIDS, a murine retrovirus-induced immunodeficiency syndrome

The functional and phenotypic characteristics of Ly-4(CD4)+ and Ly-2(CD8)+ T cells were studied after induction of murine AIDS with LP-BM5 murine leukemia virus. Assays of spleen cells for their ability to generate in vitro CTL responses to TNP-modified autologous cells (self + x CTL) and to alloantigens (allo CTL) showed that self + x CTL responses were greatly impaired at 3 to 4 wk postinfection and were undetectable thereafter. Allo CTL responses were normal at 3 to 4 wk, but were reduced at 8 to 9 wk and absent at 14 wk postinfection. This sequential loss of self + x and allo CTL responses was related to a selective defect in Ly-4(CD4)+ Th cell function associated with impaired production of IL-2 and deficient proliferative responses to Con A or to soluble Ag. Changes in the functional characteristics of Ly-4(CD4)+ T cells were unrelated to changes in their frequency in spleen, but did correlate with marked alterations in their distribution among four subsets defined by mAb SM3C11 and SM6C10. Assays of CTL responses generated by mixtures of spleen cells from normal and infected mice suggested that active suppression of Ly-4(CD4)+ Th function may contribute to this defect. Studies of Ly-2(CD8)+ T cells showed that infection with LP-BM5 murine leukemia virus also induced a major phenotypic shift in subpopulations defined by their reactivity with mAb 6C10. However, this phenotypic change did not appear to correlate with major functional defects.     

Ongoing hapten-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity prevents generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes to the same hapten

Cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) specific for trinitrophenyl (TNP)-altered self antigens can be generated in vivo through the simultaneous injection of TNP-modified syngeneic spleen cells and H-2-compatible, minor histocompatibility locus (Mls)-disparate auxiliary spleen cells into the footpads of mice. The latter stimulates host helper cells to produce differentiative and proliferative signals required for the generation of CTL. Advent of this protocol allowed investigation of the initiation of two different cell-mediated immune responses, delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) and the generation of CTL, in the same experimental animal. Mice presensitized for CTL were able to develop DTH as well as normal controls. However, when mice were first sensitized for DTH, they were thereafter incapable of generating CTL. This effect was hapten specific, relatively long lasting, and preventable by treating mice with cyclophosphamide before sensitizing for DTH. Adoptive transfer of lymphoid cells from DTH-immune mice conferred DTH reactivity upon naive recipients but not a suppressed CTL response. Therefore, cells mediating DTH were not responsible for suppression of CTL. The mechanism for suppression has been discussed from the viewpoint of the suppressor-T-cell circuits that are known to be generated when animals are sensitized for DTH and which are susceptible to treatment with cyclophosphamide.     

Mitomycin C-treated or irradiated concanavalin A-activated T cells augment the activation of cytotoxic T cells in vivo

The activation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vivo after immunization of normal or cyclophosphamide-treated mice with allogeneic cells was strongly augmented by the administration of mitomycin C-treated or irradiated concanavalin A-activated spleen cells (Con A-spl). This effect of the Con A-spl was abrogated by treatment with Anti-Thy 1 antibody plus complement, and was therefore presumably mediated by activated "helper" T cells. (The term "helper" cell is only operationally defined in this context and indicates that the augmenting irradiation resistant T cells are obviously not CTL precursor cells). These observations indicated (i) that even the cytotoxic response against allogeneic stimulator cells suffers in vivo from insufficient "helper" T cell activity, and (ii) that the injection of Con A-spl may serve as a simple procedure to apply this "helper" activity in vivo. This procedure was at least as effective as the repeated injection of interleukin 2 (IL-2)-containing cell supernatants with up to four 30-unit doses of IL-2 per mouse. IL-2-containing cell supernatants were found to mediate similar effects only if injected into the footpads but not intravenously. This was in line with the reported observation that IL-2 has an extremely short half-life in vivo. The injection of Con A-spl was also found to augment the proliferative response in the regional lymph nodes.     

Antigen-specific suppression of cytotoxic T cell responses: an idiotype-bearing factor regulates the cytotoxic T cell response to azobenzenearsonate-coupled cells

When A/J mice are injected subcutaneously with azobenzenearsonate- (ABA) coupled spleen cells, their splenocytes contain primed ABA-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors. Animals that are not primed in vivo do not develop vigorous CTL activity when assessed after in vitro culture with ABA-coupled stimulators. Suppressor molecules derived from ligand-induced first-order ABA-specific suppressor T cells were evaluated for their ability to limit cytolytic T cell development. We have shown that an idiotype-bearing, hapten-specific suppressor factor suppresses priming for CTL in an H-2-unrestricted but allotype-restricted manner. The implication of these studies to regulatory networks is discussed.     

Thymectomized, irradiated, and bone marrow-reconstituted chimeras have normal cytolytic T lymphocyte precursors but a defect in lymphokine production

A model system has been developed to study extrathymic T cell differentiation; mice have been thymectomized, lethally irradiated, and reconstituted with bone marrow cells depleted of Thy-1+ cells. After 8 wk, the spleen cells of these athymic, bone marrow-reconstituted chimeras contain Thy-1+ precytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) that are able to respond to antigen only if supernatant from Con A-activated T cells is added to culture. The phenotype of these pre-CTL is similar to that of thymocytes, suggesting that they may be immature T cells. Initial evaluation of the CTL repertoire of these athymic mice demonstrated that the CTL generated to trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic cells are H-2-restricted, and that the CTL generated to alloantigens have many of the cross-reactivities observed in normal mice but not in nude mice. In this report, we demonstrate a helper T cell defect in these thymectomized chimeras. These chimeras lack an Ly-1+ helper cell required for thymocytes to differentiate to CTL. Further studies revealed that when spleen cells from these thymectomized chimeras were stimulated with Con A, they produced normal levels of interleukin 2. However, these splenocytes were defective in the production of another factor needed for CTL differentiation.     

Induction of cytotoxic T cells and their antitumor activity in mice transgenic for carcinoembryonic antigen

In order to develop immunotherapy strategies that are based on eliciting immune responsiveness to the self-antigen, human carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), we examined whether cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity against CEA could be elicited in CEA-transgenic and nontransgenic mice. CEA-transgenic [C57BL/6-TGN(CEAGe)18FJP] and nontransgenic mice were primed with CEA-transfected syngeneic fibroblasts in combination with Corynebacterium parvum. Spleen cells from immunized mice were cultured with irradiated syngeneic MC-38 colon carcinoma cells transfected with CEA (MC-38.CEA) as stimulators prior to the measurement of CTL activity. Primed nontransgenic spleen cells showed augmented CTL activity against MC-38.CEA cells as compared with control parental MC-38 cells, nontransfected or transfected with vector only. Moreover, primed CEA transgenic spleen cells showed augmented CTL activity against MC-38.CEA cells that was similar to that observed in nontransgenic mice. All CTL clones derived from either transgenic or nontransgenic mice showed cross-reactivity with MC-38 cells expressing the CEA-related antigen, nonspecific cross-reacting antigen, but not biliary glycoprotein. CEA-specific CTL clones were not identified. Adoptive transfer of cloned CTL resulted in inhibition of MC-38.CEA but not MC-38.BGP tumor growth. Tumor cures were elicited in mice treated with a combination of cloned CTL and cyclophosphamide. Histopathological examination of CEA-expressing colons from either immunized mice or recipients of cloned CTL did not reveal any autoimmune reactions. These studies demonstrate that CTL recognizing cross-reactive class I epitopes on the CEA molecule can be induced in transgenic mice. The expression of these epitopes on tumor cells creates effective targets for CTL in vivo without inducing adverse reactions in CEA-expressing normal tissues. Since anti-CEA CTL have been generated in humans, CEA-transgenic mice may be a useful model to study vaccines that are based on CTL effector mechanisms. Received: 7 January 2000 / Accepted: 8 March 2000     

Down-regulation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte development by a minor stimulating locus-induced suppressor cascade that involves Lyt-1+ suppressor T cells, IA- macrophages, and their factors

Down-regulation of the development of CTL has been studied in mice both in vivo and in vitro. To generate CTL to hapten-altered self Ag in vivo, an immunization protocol has been used in which the host's Th cells are stimulated by a minor locus histocompatibility Ag (Mlsd) and its precursor CTL are activated by trinitrophenylated syngeneic spleen cells. Injecting the H-2 compatible Mls-disparate spleen cells along with the TNP-coupled self cells into the hind paws causes TNP-self specific CTL to appear in popliteal lymph nodes within 5 days. We have previously reported that inducing Ts cells by i.v. injecting Mlsd-bearing cells prevents in vivo generation of TNP-self specific CTL after immunization in this way. Here the induced Ts cell as well as the mechanism by which it functions have been further examined. The suppression was seen to extend to allogeneic as well as TNP-self Ag, provided the Mlsd-tolerized animal was reexposed to Mlsd-bearing cells at the time of immunization for CTL. By transferring the Mlsd-induced suppression adoptively we have learned that the splenic suppressor cell bears Thy-1.2 as well as Lyt-1.1 Ag and inhibits the generation of CTL at the afferent limb. In addition, Mlsd-induced PEC of Mlsd-tolerized mice, but not of normal mice, mediated suppression of development of CTL in vivo. The active cells within the tolerized PEC have been identified as T cells and macrophages (M phi). Furthermore, PEC from mice tolerized to Mlsd suppressed generation of CTL directed toward TNP-self targets in vitro. T cells and M phi separated from PEC of Mlsd-tolerized mice achieved suppression best in culture when present together. In addition, Lyt-1+ splenic cells from tolerized but not normal mice cooperated to down-regulate CTL generation in vitro with peritoneal M phi from either tolerized or normal mice. Supernatants of 24- to 72-h cultures of PEC from tolerized mice were suppressive of CTL generation when incorporated at 40 to 50% of culture volume. Supernatants of T cells from tolerized PEC or spleen were suppressive in culture only when M phi from normal mice were also present. To achieve suppression dialyzed supernatants of M phi from tolerized mice could replace the M phi.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Heterogeneity of CD4+ T cells involved in anti-allo-class I H-2 immune responses. Functional discrimination between the major proliferating cells and helper cells assisting cytotoxic T cell responses.

MLR in various combinations with class I H-2 disparity revealed that there are three patterns of MLR in the aspect of responding T subset (CD4 vs CD8) dominance. Irrespective of the CD8 vs CD4 dominance, a single i.v. administration of class I-disparate allogeneic spleen cells resulted in almost complete abrogation of anti-class I proliferative capacity of both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in six combinations. The suppression of proliferative responses was correlated with the striking reduction in the ability to produce IL-2 upon stimulation with the relevant class I alloantigens. In contrast, i.v. presensitized recipient mice exhibiting only marginal MLR/Il-2 production could generate comparable magnitudes of anti-allo class I CTL as well as graft rejection responses to those induced by normal unpresensitized mice. The administration in vivo of anti-CD4 antibody along with the i.v. presensitization not only suppressed the generation of CTL responses by spleen cells but also induced appreciable prolongation of allo-class I-disparate skin grafts under conditions in which neither alone did it. These results demonstrate that 1) the suppression of graft rejection responses is not necessarily reflected on the reduction of MLR; 2) CD8+ CTL precursors responsible for graft rejection can be activated by either allo-class I-reactive CD8+ or CD4+ Th cells; 3) i.v. presensitization induces functional elimination of CD8+ and CD4+ proliferative/IL-2-producing T cells but not of CD8+ CTL precursors and CD4+ Th whose capacity is expressed by assistance of CTL induction but not by their own proliferation. Thus, this study illustrates the heterogeneity of class I alloantigen-reactive CD4+ T cells in the aspect of their capacity to proliferate themselves vs contribute to CTL induction as well as graft rejection.     

The composition of the T cell receptor repertoire in nude mice

Previous results from several laboratories have demonstrated the presence of functional T lymphocytes in congenitally athymic (nude) mice. The present study represents an analysis of the T cell receptor repertoire exhibited by such cells. Clones of H-2Kb-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were generated under primary limiting dilution conditions by using spleen cells from nude mice. These clones were analyzed on a panel of Kb mutant target cells to assess the receptor specificity of each clone. Unlike thymic bearing mice the CTL repertoires of which are exceedingly diverse, it was found that in most cases the vast majority of clones from each individual exhibited the same reactivity pattern. The particular pattern varied from individual to individual. Clones from three animals that exhibited this phenomenon were additionally analyzed by using a monoclonal antibody that can detect the utilization of the gene products of the V beta 8 family. In one animal all clones were V beta 8 positive, whereas in the others, all clones were negative. We conclude that the T cell receptor repertoire in nude mice is extremely limited and represents in vivo expansion of a relatively small number of functional precursors.     

The cytolytic T lymphocyte response to trinitrophenyl-modified syngeneic cells. I. Evidence for antigen-specific helper T cells.

Mice were primed subcutaneously with trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified syngeneic spleen cells. Seven days later, spleen cells from these in vivo primed mice, or spleen cells from naive mice, were co-cultured with TNP-modified syngeneic cells. Spleen cells from the in vivo primed mice demonstrated augmented cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity. The spleens of these in vivo primed mice contained a population of radioresistant, antigen-specific, helper T cells. Specifically, spleen cells from these mice, after x-irradiation, were able to augment the in vitro CTL response of normal spleen cells to TNP-modified syngeneic cells.     

Priming for a cytotoxic response to minor histocompatibility antigens: antigen specificity and failure to demonstrate a carrier effect.

Spleen cells from normal mice do not give a detectable in vitro cytotoxic T cell (CTL) response to minor H antigens. Spleen cells from animals primed in vivo with minor H antigens give a strong CTL response when boosted in culture with the appropriate stimulating cells. Here I have studied the requirements for priming a CTL response to minor H antigens. It is shown that priming is just as antigen specific as is cytolytic effector function. That is, priming cells have to carry the same minor antigens as the challenge cells. Inducing a graft-vs-host reaction in vivo does not nonspecifically allow spleen cells to respond to minor H antigens in vitro. Using minor H congenic mice (congenic for H-Y and/or H-7) I have also tried, and failed, to demonstrate a carrier effect in priming. Female mice primed to H-Y were challenged in culture with cells bearing H-Y and H-7 antigens in the hope that a helper response to H-Y would augment a CTL response to H-7. This did not happen, however. Such primed and boosted cells gave a strong secondary CTL response to H-Y but none to H-7. It is concluded that in order to prime for a detectable in vitro response to minor antigens it is necessary to expose the CTL precursors to antigen in vivo. This either expands the size of the pool of precursors by cell division or changes them in some qualitative way.     

Cyclophosphamide and abrogation of tumor-induced suppressor T cell activity

Summary Previously we have demonstrated that the in vitro generation of P815-specific anti-tumor cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) was suppressed by splenic suppressor T cells from late tumor-bearing hosts (TBH). Suppression is not caused by in vitro growth of P815 from splenic metastases, since suppression was also seen with spleen cells from late TBH mice bearing a hypoxanthine/aminopterin/thymidine-sensitive subline (PHS-5) of P815 in the presence of HAT. Cyclophosphamide has been shown to inhibit theinduction of suppressor cells selectively in a number of immune responses, but evidence that it can inhibit active tumor-induced suppressor T cells is limited. We have found that suppressor T cells already induced by P815 in syngeneic late TBH are sensitive to low doses of cyclophosphamide (50 mg/kg) given 1 day before spleen harvest, but the in vitro CTL response of late TBH spleen cells could not be restored by pretreating the mice with cyclophosphamide, even when exogenous interleukin-2 was added to the cultures. Although 50 mg/kg cyclophosphamide did not inhibit the CTL response of spleen cells from mice immunized with P815 +Corynebacterium parvum, the same dose of cyclophosphamide eliminated the CTL response of spleen cells from early TBH. Interleukin-2 (IL-2) did not overcome this effect of cyclophosphamide, suggesting a direct effect on CTL. Ultra-low-dose cyclophosphamide (10 mg/kg) did not adversely effect early TBH CTL but was still able to eliminate suppressor T cell activity from late TBH. Nevertheless, late TBH CTL remained unresponsive after pretreatment of mice with ultra-low-dose cyclophosphamide, even when exogenous IL-2 was added in vitro. CTL precursor frequency analyses demonstrated that cyclophosphamide pretreatment had little or no effect on the numbers of CTL precursors from early TBH. Late TBH CTL precursor cells were not detectable in these studies, with or without suppressor T cell inhibition by cyclophosphamide pretreatment. Thus, it appears that most CTL precursor cells may be lost or irretrievably inactivated in the spleens of late TBH mice.This work was supported by grants CA42443, CA48075 and T32-CA09210 from the National Cancer Institute, Department of Health and Human Services, and an American Cancer Society Clinical Oncology Career Development Award (H. D. Bear)